Retired Air Force captain says attack on Extortion 17 could have been prevented

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 окт 2024
  • Circa News

Комментарии • 195

  • @detroit19531
    @detroit19531 7 лет назад +54

    as a veteran this pisses me off,as it should every one

    • @edwardrobaon8555
      @edwardrobaon8555 6 лет назад

      Do you know what’s happened about this?

    • @user-zr4lj6qc8e
      @user-zr4lj6qc8e 6 лет назад +1

      Thank you for your service, I truly appreciate you risking your life, to protect US 🇺🇸 prayers going up for you, and your family 🙏🏼

    • @johnscanlon2598
      @johnscanlon2598 2 года назад

      @@edwardrobaon8555 nothing at all

  • @mf2389
    @mf2389 7 лет назад +10

    I am from South Africa ..... I also never knew this happened, just learned about this about 4 days ago, and I cried bitterly. My heart goes out to all the families and to America.

  • @sharonkeith601
    @sharonkeith601 7 лет назад +34

    No more leaving our guys defenseless to die on their own. What kind of country does such to those expected to spend all for their countrymen? I am so ashamed and broken-hearted!

    • @Beehighfive
      @Beehighfive 7 лет назад +9

      We now have a Commander And Chief that isn't a coward. All those under his command will be treated with respect once again. Obama was faithful to the Muslim Brotherhood. President Trump will be faithful to the American Soldiers. God Bless President Trump and God Bless All Branches of Our Military.

    • @georgeins.c.494
      @georgeins.c.494 7 лет назад +6

      Sharon Keith Agree as am I and many. Perhaps those emotions must turn to anger for justice at some point. Helpless feeling.
      "The People Know "

    • @lovejen01
      @lovejen01 7 лет назад +4

      It is called Obama and the Democratic party plus that fucker Clinton if he didn't cut support to the Northern Alliance we would have never be Afghanistan or 9/11

    • @edwardrobaon8555
      @edwardrobaon8555 6 лет назад

      Do you know what happened about this?

    • @cjherndon62
      @cjherndon62 6 лет назад +1

      "They pour the blood of our soldiers out like water on the sand!" - Lt. Col. Jeffrey Addicot
      Absolutely deplorable and evil! An ENORMOUS "thank-you!" to this very brave woman for speaking out, and standing for truth - regardless the cost!

  • @heatherann3596
    @heatherann3596 Год назад +4

    My friend lost his life that day. Never seen this. Breaks my heart and infuriates me.

  • @gypsyvarga2800
    @gypsyvarga2800 7 лет назад +12

    Joni Marquez. is a real hero and great person God bless her

    • @bellarinamarquez
      @bellarinamarquez 6 лет назад

      gypsy varga thank you she is my auntie

    • @maryannstrange3092
      @maryannstrange3092 6 лет назад

      Bellarina Marie you are very lucky to have such a great Aunt! Our Son, Michael, was on Extortion17, so your Aunt Joni coming forward and telling the truth is such a blessing to us. Give your Auntie a BIG HUG from Chalie & Mary!🇺🇸 🤗 ❤

    • @darcyboyd8014
      @darcyboyd8014 4 года назад

      Mary Ann Strange I hope your search for justice has led you somewhere, this is so so wrong. RIP to your boy and those on the flight

  • @sallyanngrisolia4876
    @sallyanngrisolia4876 4 года назад +5

    Asking for permission to engage? Handcuffing our military? Thank God that is gone. What a disgrace to have to ask to defend themselves.

  • @debbiezimmerman998
    @debbiezimmerman998 7 лет назад +6

    we need more service men and women like Joni Marquez. My prayers are with you all and all the families who are continuously lied to by our governmental swamp.

  • @mz15945
    @mz15945 6 лет назад +6

    Rules of engagement changed to prevent terrorist casualties.....there fixed it for you...you're welcome

  • @Phildo8
    @Phildo8 6 лет назад +9

    GOD BLESS JONI MARQUEZ! 🙏🏻

  • @db63131
    @db63131 7 лет назад +6

    She is a hero! To bad there aren't many more like her.

  • @anaschuster686
    @anaschuster686 7 лет назад +14

    God help us.

  • @MrBigike76
    @MrBigike76 7 лет назад +4

    Capt. Marquez is a true American patriot. God bless you Capt. Marquez, as well as your family!

  • @ethereal4271
    @ethereal4271 7 лет назад +7

    our nation is be attacked from without and within. If we want this nation to exist for future generations then we need to do something about this now. Before it's too late. I will never forget the day Seal team 6 got shot down. I knew instantly something was not right. Sadly now you have comfirmed it.

  • @sherryhodges8045
    @sherryhodges8045 7 лет назад +9

    They did the same shit in Vietnam,

  • @leifstrong
    @leifstrong 7 лет назад +6

    I Hope Team Trump can get going on this illegal, horrible event! Great Work Sara Carter.

  • @TikvahHa
    @TikvahHa 5 лет назад +4

    Love your bravery Joni! We JUST had Aaron's dad,speak at our women's club,this week.

  • @tutumama
    @tutumama 7 лет назад +3

    May Justice be swift and sure. You can be sure the brothers of these brave ones have never forgotten what was done. Remember Extortion 17. God bless you Joni Marquez.

    • @maryannstrange3092
      @maryannstrange3092 6 лет назад

      tutumama AMEN!THANK YOU!
      NEVER FORGET O8/06/2011🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @TheFilamom30
    @TheFilamom30 7 лет назад +4

    bho's rules of engagement have turned battlefields into suicide missions. This needs to end. We must insist that the new adm deal with the issue asap...
    God bless our heroes & their families...We will forever be sorry for their loss...
    The bravery of Capt Márquez should be commended & honored. I pray that the Lord provide for her healing, guidance & protection for the rest of her journey...

  • @SLM-je1gh
    @SLM-je1gh 5 лет назад +3

    President Trump!!! Time to release the truth about Extortion 17.

  • @aroundlinemen
    @aroundlinemen 7 лет назад +3

    God bless you and our troops !

  • @janwallace4287
    @janwallace4287 7 лет назад +3

    Why aren't charges against those responsible for the deception and lies, and deaths, not being lodged?

    • @meribast
      @meribast 5 лет назад

      Presidential pardons.

  • @anthonyj.castellitto9103
    @anthonyj.castellitto9103 7 лет назад +10

    you are a brave beautiful woman, have no shame, have no guilt and thank you.... so tragic and .... well, at face value it seems like treason

  • @factstraight
    @factstraight 7 лет назад +8

    Why were 17 ST6 members on a single helo?

  • @joehelecki6759
    @joehelecki6759 6 лет назад +2

    Thank..you. for..your..service...You..Are. a..true...Hero...And.. deserve.. all. .Title...as. an...American...Patriot. God.. Bless...You...Greatly

  • @joanq7904
    @joanq7904 7 лет назад +4

    a must watch.!!

  • @yahnieyah6620
    @yahnieyah6620 6 лет назад +3

    Bring our service men home, it's time to bring them home! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @QUACKERBACKER101
    @QUACKERBACKER101 4 года назад +1

    JUSTICE IS COMING!
    God bless you guys and hang in there.

  • @katindahat7927
    @katindahat7927 7 лет назад +3

    I believe her

  • @jojowrightrn1116
    @jojowrightrn1116 7 лет назад +2

    Thank you Sara Carter!

  • @nigelfoggin4617
    @nigelfoggin4617 Год назад

    I love this woman she has had the guts to speak out….justice is coming…..

  • @carolburnett8372
    @carolburnett8372 6 лет назад +2

    Obama/Hillary cannot serve enough time to pay for this ......

  • @yelloecanary
    @yelloecanary 7 лет назад +2

    Please tell her to be very, very careful. Hire personal security if possible. Constantly change up her activity. Don't eat food, or meal components not purchased at the spur of the moment and from a different source as often as possible. She may know the drill for self preservation, so this post may not be necessary. But please take precautions. Also, you may want to go and live in a very public, busy, heavily recorded environment.

  • @RWong-wn3pv
    @RWong-wn3pv 6 лет назад +3

    Does anybody see a trend here? This and Benghazi are only two examples?

  • @drew65sep
    @drew65sep 5 лет назад +2

    Epitome of the government running a war, and doesn't have the slightest clue how to do it...and tying one hand of our soldiers behind their back. They never learn...it happened in Vietnam, in Desert Storm, Somalia, etc, etc. So much for remembering the lessons history should have taught them.

  • @jerrywtf9053
    @jerrywtf9053 7 лет назад +1

    some one needs to pay for this

  • @johnhasse3995
    @johnhasse3995 7 лет назад +1

    They are supposed to be defending US, not changing regimes in other countries.

  • @vlm5723
    @vlm5723 5 лет назад +1

    What would be the reason they were not given permission to attack the enemy under those circumstances? I don't understand.

  • @sherryhodges8045
    @sherryhodges8045 7 лет назад +1

    Screw the rules

  • @user-zr4lj6qc8e
    @user-zr4lj6qc8e 6 лет назад +1

    What a brave woman she is, I hope this all comes out, I couldn’t dare sleep at night, with all that blood on my hands, and this is for Obama, and the Clinton Cartel. They WILL PAY, for God will see them on their judgement day 🇺🇸🙏🏼

  • @marknorwood7521
    @marknorwood7521 6 лет назад +1

    BHO Administration at it's best. Make itself look good but cover up it's incompetence.
    Thankfully this brave woman had the courage to tell the truth.

  • @TikvahHa
    @TikvahHa 2 года назад

    Joni,our Roger Gangitano passed away..

  • @fod6740
    @fod6740 6 лет назад

    this should play on a loop non-stop 24/7 365 on every goddamn news station on every f****** Channel what the f*** is going on with this country

  • @edgardocarrasquillo9
    @edgardocarrasquillo9 Год назад

    5y ago. Has ROA been updated?

  • @billhoward1296
    @billhoward1296 7 лет назад

    I heard a different story than this one but I will take nothing away from her story stand Brave Stand Fast.

  • @aosborne8189
    @aosborne8189 6 лет назад

    Lets pray ms/mrs marquez doesnt end up dying in a "car crash", a "lightning strike", etc... Just like so many other brave whistleblowers

  • @stevenmorris3181
    @stevenmorris3181 7 лет назад

    Make sure politician family members cannot avoid a future draft or overseas deployment. Infantry school mandatory for all after basic training, then on to primary MOS.

  • @edwardrobaon8555
    @edwardrobaon8555 6 лет назад +1

    Does anyone know what has happened about this? You know it will be lost to history and the film Lone Survivor. It took ages for me to realise that it was even the same event.

  • @nbk9372
    @nbk9372 7 лет назад

    Anyone down range in the Afgan theater, has the SOP on ROE changed since new CIC? Thanks.

  • @abninf501
    @abninf501 Год назад +1

    The Obama Administration at its finest!!!

  • @trump2q242
    @trump2q242 4 года назад +1

    Biden for GITMO 🚨

  • @suzanbrowning3980
    @suzanbrowning3980 2 года назад +1

    I thought it was a hit job… anyone else?

  • @dianapease643
    @dianapease643 7 лет назад

    But why????

  • @wheelerking8380
    @wheelerking8380 5 лет назад

    This makes me fucking sick!!

  • @cwnewsnow7875
    @cwnewsnow7875 7 лет назад +2

    it's a shame Obama and Clinton and s still free to roam the streets without any consequences whatsoever, if we the people piss in the wrong direction we are prosecuted someone needs to do something even if they have to put their life's on the line

  • @FailWords
    @FailWords 6 лет назад

    6: payback?

  • @janetstorm7881
    @janetstorm7881 8 месяцев назад

    In history there are very few good war time president's George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, and in my lifetime George Bush, the elder, the combat fighter pilot at 19 during WWII was the last who knew what he was doing! I really wish he would have won reelection and if he did Black Hawk Down would have never happened!

  • @RobertFay
    @RobertFay 6 лет назад

    BETRAY SHALL END . . . agreed?

  • @kathyborthwick6738LakotaEmoji
    @kathyborthwick6738LakotaEmoji Год назад

    Why were they in the slow moving old Chinook?

    • @jjp.8690
      @jjp.8690 Год назад

      Murdered!

    • @kevinmorthorst521
      @kevinmorthorst521 Год назад

      @@jjp.8690It was a full ST6 troop and the chinook is the only helicopter with the carrying capacity for that size of a force.

  • @josephroberts6865
    @josephroberts6865 3 года назад

    Interesting interview. Wonder why none these so-called radio calls by her crew to engage were never part of the AH-64 recordings that were on station the entire time? Also interesting to note the 64 drivers never saw what she claims, otherwise, they were in better position to engage. Mostly this sounds like some disgruntled Usaf Captain trying to get her 15 mins of fame.

  • @son0fsocal
    @son0fsocal 7 лет назад

    😍

  • @blaze-mh9eg
    @blaze-mh9eg 6 лет назад

    I feel so so bad for these and other families who's loved ones. Have been victimsOf draconian ROE. That get these men murdered Sometimes I think the govt doesn't want to win to keep these wars going for $. We could win but that would kill certain parts of the economy.

  • @fourfootcottonmouth
    @fourfootcottonmouth 6 лет назад

    How do you "retire" from the Air Force with 14 years service?

    • @kevinmorthorst521
      @kevinmorthorst521 Год назад

      Sometimes the military offers early retirement to reduce the size of the force for various reasons.

  • @Max-jn5sp
    @Max-jn5sp 7 лет назад

    why come out now? if it was bad why did she wait until she got out of the military?

    • @m4a1JAY
      @m4a1JAY 7 лет назад +3

      tiny rick it's a very dangerous thing to do. She might be on CIA hit list now.

  • @landrywilliams3028
    @landrywilliams3028 6 лет назад

    Good job obama. Also everytime this lady said taliban i cringed at the way she said it

  • @mattwoodardtn
    @mattwoodardtn 6 лет назад +2

    First to my shipmates and crewman aboard i wish God speed and may the rest in peace. Look a here! First and foremost i hope charges where brought up on this former Captain for speaking about such whether true or not true. I question one thing straight off in that nobody onboard ejected anywhere. There is no ejection on a chinook. Second off me you and anyone involved in this took an oath to follow orders especially in time of war and during any type of inquiry or investigation. You people not a single one of you knows all details surrounding this event and reasons why certain things may seem out of place. No matter what those reasons are there are two things you best come to terms with. First is no matter what they are nothing is gonna bring em back nor take away the pain they are gone and can only make it worse. Second thing is it dont matter what you think should be said or done now or then you was given direct fucking orders how and what to do and that is that. Leave it! I dont agree with liberal thinking or policy but Obama did not purposely get them killed and how dare you hint at such. Yes policy needs to change and perhaps mistakes where made. Hind sight is 20-20 but we dont know why certain things where done that is up to spec ops command the pentagon cia and oval office. They make decision or handle it in a particular way it is for a reason! We dont know all pieces of the puzzle as they do and those brave men our finest men where not done as yall are assuming they were and if by the impossible delusional chance that they where it was for the intentment to benefit our nation that anyone involved swore to uphold defend and protect! All you are doing is causing drama and bringing shade to the well earned memory of our fallen servicemen. None of this does anyone any good! The rules of engagement are what makes us the greatest country in human history and why we can exist. If we didnt do that the rest of the world would go from passively trying to destroy us to it becoming there sole purpose. Some things are need to know period! So stop trying to figure out shit that you cant number 1 and number 2 is none of your freaking business to begin with! Dont like obama? Dont like Trump? Dont vote for them! Dont like this general or admiral or secretary? Thank your moms and dads cause they trained promoted them or served with them! If they were unfit then why? Think about that when you are in charge. That guy moping the floor might be the secretary of the Navy someday so do your job. You dont wait till decisions made in the heat of battle and when it hits the fan beat and pick it to death. No general or admiral got up one day and said hooooray i get to off the best unit in the military today cause? Cause i feel like it. Drop it nd let these heros finally have peace. God bless shipmates.....

  • @oliviadestandau4243
    @oliviadestandau4243 7 лет назад +3

    The deaths of American service operatives could even BETTER have been prevented by NOT INVADING Afghanistan. Committing WAR CRIMES thereby and subsequently ensuring the the poppy crop (under American supervision) increase X4. I WONDER why that happened... Don't you?

  • @safaqi01
    @safaqi01 2 года назад

    This video is full of lies. Actually Devrgu members said in podcasts that the ones who shot the RPGs were insurgents in buildings preciously unseen. The Chinook came to unload the operators from the opposite direction that the initial rangers were flown in and unloaded from. Instead of flying in from a direction previously verified as safe, they came in from a new direction and were spotted. The rules of engagement for Special military units like DEVGRU are basically non existent since the missions they go on themselves are non existent in the fact that JSOC never verifies any missions that take place period. This lady doesnt know what the hell shes talking about. War is war and war is unfair. Sometimes the good guys get lucky, and sometimes the bad guys get lucky. RPGs always get launched at helos and sometimes they hit and sometimes they dont. This was just one of the unfortunate times that the rocket did hit

    • @bigboots6114
      @bigboots6114 Год назад

      how is it full of lies when the capt saw first hand what was going on

    • @safaqi01
      @safaqi01 Год назад +1

      @@bigboots6114 basically the premise of this video is that this event could've been prevented right? First of all, if you decide to commit yourself to a war, there is only so much risk you can mitigate. At some point, youre gonna have to put yourself in harms way and sometimes you win, and sometimes the enemy wins. Secondly, the point she's trying to make is that the rules of engagement were too lax and that's what caused the enemies to shoot down the Helo. Think about it, the US And coalition was in Afghanistan villages constantly killing civilians, and the government made a deal with the US Which was either leave, or only kill people who you CONFIRM to be holding a weapon. Is that too much to ask? Imagine you live in a village haunted by death from the Americans and all you want from them in exchange of being allowed to continue operating is to confirm the people you aim at are enemies with weapons, is that too much to ask? AFTER Osama died, we had no more reason to be in Afghanistan, he was the reason we went and he was gone. Extortion 17 is to be blamed on the Generals and politicians who refused to pull out of afghanistan

    • @bigboots6114
      @bigboots6114 Год назад +1

      @@safaqi01 as an AF officer or military member you have a duty to speak up. next, the US military do not go out of there way to kill civilians and if you are holding a weapon, you are a threat. SO the rest of your comment is very ignorant

    • @brettrobertson2538
      @brettrobertson2538 Год назад

      @@safaqi01 it's about the ROE and it makes total sense they were not given the green light to fire therefore resulting in the tragedy

    • @kingtachalla6181
      @kingtachalla6181 Год назад

      @@safaqi01 "erm actually the woman who was there and had the best eyesight is wrong bcs the erm the most powerful military branch that is the gov bitch said said otherwise and they wouldn't lie" lmao you definitely retarded and brainwashed by American propaganda you probably believe Chris Kyle and Marcus luttrel too huh ? Operation mockingbird is real

  • @TFfolkes
    @TFfolkes 7 лет назад

    poor baby.......... why women should stay home

  • @nightwaves3203
    @nightwaves3203 6 лет назад

    She could of illuminated and night blinded the enemy for a half hour which hints of surprise wanted. Maybe proper maintenance wasn't done on 130 not allowing spotlight use. She wouldn't be complaining if she had slaughtered the village? Try the army way of letting villages know when you will be there and whine about that. Videos off others dying.