Being sensitive will generate a field of presence in which you can observe through attention everything happening spontaneously. The more sensitive you are the more field will generate. Just be aware of that and watch everything with all your senses. That’s the real fate or realization and you don’t need spiritual hocus-pocus because that’s a natural state for human beings. Don’t think about just watch with all your senses.
@@johnny4175 Yes, and I thought I was the only one to see this strange phenomenom. It's good to know that someone else is seeing it. Have a nice day, Sir.
The idea of destiny and worthless-ness of free will is certainly hard to accept. But this acceptance ultimately translates to the act of Surrender (which Ramesh ji also talks about here). What i understand is that Surrender is the way in which the sense of personal doer-ship dissolves and actions are done in a flow in which there is no conscious thought. The severe pain of psychological afflictions like depression is very genuine and i donot yet understand how spiritual insight can deal with that. I suffer from depression too, at times very powerful. What may be considered here is that Suicide is committed in a heightened state of Ego in which the Self pronounces that the pain is unbearable and inescapable. And if the Ego is to be completely dropped and surrendered, then the identification with forces of depression will cease. I admit that i struggle to internalize this beyond mere intellectual understanding. But in my mind, i keep returning to the idea of not identifying with my Ego.
@Cowzah I once suffered from depression as well and I think you are correct about the possibility that the depressive thought patterns can be dropped/surrendered. One day, it suddenly happened within me. Terrible spiraling thoughts about low worth, no hope, no answers and then, suddenly... a new thought came. "What if I just didn't desire anything anymore?" But it wasn't dropping the desire for life, it was more like dropping the mental story of my life. The story my ego was repeating about unmet desires and hopelessness was was just dropped, suddenly. It was like my consciousness just lost interest in the story of "myself" and dropped it.
I went through the same and this teaching works you just have to keep at it go as deep as you can, wisdom takes time to sink in the system, years, but you will have learnet the most precious thing inlife after you get it. do not make any effort, just go deep, also check other spiritualities to have a better understanding, be curious and it will come. Open the hand of thoughts, be aware of them slowly but surely; they are the cause of depression and pain in the body.
I feel the same way. I've been following these teachings as well as the "direct, non-dual" approach for years. I've been meditating (I think) for hours every day for 14 years. Yet I am now as depressed as I've ever been. I sleep as much as possible and have no inspiration or motivation to cook, clean, get a job, make friends, etc. I exercise physically which helps me to feel fairly good much of the time, but then the dark thoughts arise again. I thought it was clear that there was "no one" here and that free will was an illusion. Now I feel like I've been fooling myself all this time. I am just a person. I feel like the doer no matter how clearly I see intellectually that I am not. I think it's time for me to admit failure and just go back to living as if conditions could bring me satisfaction. I'm cooked.
47:28 true, Islam means to surrender. "He who wishes that there appear, at a given moment, other than what God has manifested in it, has not left ignorance behind at all." The teaching of Ramesh has changed my life.
I am not the doer; accept the certain fact that life is uncertainty; and go with flow: knowing and accepting this, and changing my attitude towards life and 'the other', brings peace. That is enlightenment! Thank you, Rameshji!
Its interesting because if u are not the doer, the experiencer, you separate yourself from the act. But all conflict has its root on separation/division. It feels like everything is ONE, and if thats so, how can we separate ourselves from the ONENESS? It feels like its the our EGO MIND that separates us from everything thats why suffering happens. If everything is the same, we will always BE everything, we are the actions, we are thoughts, we are the trees, we are the people around us, we are the world, we are CONSCIOUSNESS which gathers everything in existence.
Being translated into the Light is liberation of spirit and soul. The body grows less and less important. The truth Sets free. It doesnt hurt. Heaven is pure bliss and freedom. We can Taste it to a certain degree here on earth. Thats what I think. God is Love.
First find peace, be in peace with youre highs and downs. In that peace you will find something called happyness. When you seek happyness the seeking of happyness itself will be the problem. Find peace, be in peace with youre hate, fear, pleasure etc. so that isnt importand what arises in you. Then there is peace
@@religionofpeace782 sorry iam german, i try my best. Sometimes its Not so easy, we write Happy, and then i think you write happyness because in German we Take Double for short, ness, but yeah, i think happines is the Thing you mean or i mean 😅
I live this talk! So down to earth and simple. No mystical mumbo jumbo just straight forward logical sensible life advice 🙏 i really hope kunal found some help and relief for his depression, its heart breaking to see somebody suffering like that he seems a nice gentle soul
Depression is curable.... depression is our thoughts from the past... anxiety is from future....the power remains in now. Correcting the eating habits and swaying away from sugar and carbs ,eating veggies help... Long fasting work wonders..add b vitamins in the diet
Don't need to change your diet at all. Just change your mind by seeking the same non-dual path pointed at by people like Shankara and Buddah in the past.
- живот се састоји од жеља и могућности - ако лимитираш жеље на могућности увијек је живот лијеп - ако те савладају жеље а мало могућности увијек се пати - дакле - дешава се ма што но имамо вјеру тако да што би да би _ не бринеш него уживаш живот у вјери са вјером ослони се на вјеру ИСУСА на вјеровања добрих "великих људи и жена" _ *_"права молитва, чврста молитва кључ за све"_* _ угодан дан - сваки дан је задњи дан а многи од нас неће ни доживјети сутрашњи дан - хоће се казати живи сваки дан вјеру за вјечност и добро ће бити _ кад се бавиш промашеном вјером ни одоговора свих немаш - и тада доживљаваш живот као патњу _ како наћи циљ живота у вјери без циља - та не можеш јер га нема и онда живот и глуп изгледа _ што више тражиш све више пустоши срећеш - што се више питаш све мање одговора имаш
@@michaelbriggs9925Hopelessness is about not having identity. It is about the impossibility to run a normal life. You have the power to build your life and find new ways to be happier. The hopeless is unable to do any of that.
While the philosophy is good, religion, Bhakti is good, it is also important to seek thetspy( cognitive behavioral therapy) along with medications. Depression is not imaginary, it’s like diabetes or hypertension. It involves neurotransmitters. I heard one gentleman here talk about depression. Please get help. Just like ur body needs vitamins, food, u have to seek help for depression!🙏
Great point! And that does not contradict what he’s saying here either. As I know you did not imply :-) Sometimes this human form needs help in order to feel better and continue to show compassion to others. However, I think the key is to just except that this is true. I myself suffer with bipolar and depression, and through these teachings and many others I recognize that I can’t feel sorry for myself, or will it away. I do what I can for my body because this is the reality in which I live. Everything is in God’s perfect will and I ask for that will every day. Sometimes minute by minute!
I am amused by all the comments from people offering their wisdom. This is reflective of how the ego makes one feel as if he is an expert or awakened. When you see what there is to see there is little to talk about or to prove to anyone else.
yes, another possibility to develop compassion, most beings have not arrived at the experience of a Ramesh and are only regurgitating, this in order to comfort their poor lack of esteem and to suffer a little less 🙏🙂
Patience of whom ? What you mean by Ramesh ? A biological body mind organ or God ? If your answer is body mind organ then I think there is nothing great in this because this body mind organ is nothing but a programmed machine (as per him) always acting according to God's will like any other ordinary human being. If your answer is God then I will say that God is without any attributes like patience.
And he was razor sharp. When I was in the hot seat and was so unclear and yet he asked questions in such a way to bring about true communication. Sat with him for 3 weeks, 21 years ago. An absolute blessings. Christ Ramesh.
On a light note. I'm pretty sure thats Roger Castillo at the back taking it all in 😊. We are fortunate it was his destiny to come across Ramesh's teachings, and present them for future generations ❤
That is only the relationship between the self and the other. The ideas of self and the other are illusions. All relationship is illusion and ignorance.
What is perfect Sir ! Is it perfect because a robber can now live with his head high because no longer he needs to feel guilty of his acts as he has now got the license to rob others and say that he is doing so because it is the will of the God ? Or a rapist gets certificate of his innocence because his acts amount to charity as he is fulfilling the will of the God ?
@@hermansohier7643 Okay ! I don't understand, but who is saying this... is it some impersonal or personal. Simply parroting the heard lines from someone or somewhere does not make difference unless you see through yourself.
@@chandankumar-lk9kr I'm not parotting words ,this is an understanding without some one who understands .If i had listen to these teachings 30 years ago i would of gone mad and angry .But ' i ' went all the way ,did everything possible to become enlightent and one day i realised that 'i'could'nt do anything because there was no i to begin with .The i ,the world and the conceptual thinking are 3 words for the same thing and it's empty and full the samme time .
Nothing is pre determined. Only acceptance will liberate us. Once we accept we are able to ride the waves of experiences. The knowing of being is happiness. common name is "i" In religious terms is god.
Don't see what is brilliant or so clear in the conversation. The conversation only raises questions and answers none. A man can't live even for a moment without an action, and what one does depends on his/ her prakriti (Gunas) , which in turn is the result of his past and present lives/ karmas (samskaras), this in turn depends how one lives and acts every moment and the eagerness she/ he shows every moment in knowing himself and also the purpose of life. Polio was incurable sometimes before but not now and this was possible because the effort and the will of the mankind. You can't say that earlier God had the will to make human suffer through polio but now He has changed his mind and now He wishes that no one should suffer from this disease called polio. Moreover, will you tell me why someone suffer and some enjoys if one can't do good or bad ?
@chandankumar-lk9kr clear as a bell. It's between the words in the infinite gap between all perceptions, thoughts. Don't listen through your mind and you will be taken to direct experience where his meaning lies.
@@lynlavalight I fully agree. Truth can't be perceived by mind and therefore mind has to be transcended. But here lies, what I call the Sadhana, practice, nidhidhyasana etc. to bring mind under control and not think that mind will come under control if it is the will of the God. All spirituality in essence teaches how to control the mind or transcend this mind which obstruct us from seeing the truth.
God first t will us to suffer. We all have consequences for the karmas we did in this life & several past lives. Hence we r born w certain genes, into certain families & certain conditions. Please get help for depression or for any other condition/ any troubles while also involved in Bhakthi, seeking forgiveness, seeking understanding. God will always help us with strength to bear the consequences of our karma as well as mitigate it. He will decrease a bad karma from a snake bite to an ant bite for example. When ur body & mind is not an ok e to deal w certain things, please care for it. Feed the body, mind & spirit. It’s not just mind & spirit alone. Take care of ur biological self too.
Society call his or her action.. But as all have free will but not control in results of action.. So.. Nothing of results, which society think his or her action.. Is actually his/ her action
@@michaelmcclure3383 What creation ? Exactly where the will of God applies. If there be no creation where the will of God will apply and on to whom ? Sir, Nagarjuna says, that it is impossible to know the higher truth without knowing the lower truth. So, first learn to swim before abandoning the boat.
@@michaelmcclure3383 I am not sure whether the teaching of Sh Ramesh is of Karmyoga. Because in my understanding karmayoga implies the voluntary action with no end result in sight, which is certainly not the case in his teaching. Moreover, for karmyoga there has to be an element of doership (in early phase), which completely misses in his teachings. Fact remains, and that is based on first hand individual experience, that mere knowledge does not remove the conditioning of mind or past habits. It can be concurred only through practice. As long as mind is under the influence of Gunas it will be bound to react according to its composition of Gunas. Without practice even if there is knowledge, the composition of Gunas can't be changed. So Bhakti or surrender is culmination of the Karmyoga or in other words bhakti/ surrender shall be incomplete unless it has passed though the path of Karmyoga.
@@michaelmcclure3383 The moment Krishna says that one has only right to act means that one is free to act. Who is free to act of course the ego, I. If one can't act why will he ask Arjuna to act ? Think ! The moment you lose the sense of doership or sense of I you become the Lord Krishna Himself. There remains no separation between Him and you. You are just narrating the final truth but the fact is that this state has to be acquired in order to realize which in turn passes from the sense of doership and finally becoming not a doer. Mere stating intellectually that I am not the doer will not do good.
@@michaelmcclure3383 You are right. The enlightened sages identify with the body but fully understand that they are not the doer. My point is that this realization of not being the doer is not an intellectual understanding. The sense of doership falls automatically if one pursues the path of Karmayoga as its culmination. Here lies the catch. You referred Raman Maharshi who got enlightenment in very early age but to make that understanding and realization seeps through his being and remain steady he practiced sadhana for decades. And this is what I am trying to highlight. Unless the mind becomes fully sattvic it will never be steady with the realization even if one happens to get.
Are you really free? The most intense freedom I experienced Was when Jesus set met free. Try praying. Thinking that there is no God is some what like slavery. If there is something greater than pure truth and absolute love, then go and seek. But why seek for more of Jesus can give us everything we need.
@guitarszen at the same time you are the BODY which goes through the experience of illusion of free will, you are the SOUL which is free from the illusion of free will n simply witness the drama with complete acceptance (Surrendered to the will of GOD), You are the GOD who is FREE... -VEDANTA 🙏🙂
41:00 his conclusion is that unhappiness comes from rivalry. This is not true in my experience. I have no rivalries and the best intentions, yet I am not happy. Also he is wrong about genes. We 𝑑𝑜 have control over our genes. I think in this talk, especially with the person at 1:08:30 he makes the mistake of "for a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail". Totally not helpful for the guy, but I assume he gives answers/this talk to be of service. Anyway, he has some good points. For me, free will is a very good illusion and it doesnt help philosophizing about it - what's the point? Yes, God acts through us and yes we do have different possibilities of acting but this is also highly limited by a lot of factors. I like to think in terms of 'we have a certain degree 0 < x < 100 of free will', strictly not 0 and strictly not 100%, and even if it was 0 or 100: it doesnt matter.
True Master ! How Sir ? Because, now you can say that the reason for your abject failure was not the lack of any effort on your part but God's will ? Or in his teaching you have got the license to sit idle and do nothing ?
You are completely right from your point of view and where you stand. My statement in the OP probably came from my Ego as well! It’s all play of thoughts anyways!
Pain is exacerbated and prolonged by the label “ pain “. Thus: I am in pain. I think that the pain validates the me as real, and is therefore unconsciously propagated.
How a human being has a "totall freewill". We didnt chose the country and family in which we were born and we are conditioned by that society , parents etc., and now any decision i make will come from that conditiong. Suppose if i was not born in India but america then the decision i take will be diffrent due to change in conditioning. So i dont have any freewill as im motivated or forced to take action and decision by my conditioning.
Indirect stoic philosophy, well, a lot of it is! And nihilism, the acceptance of the absurd, and meaninglessness and purposelessness! Hmmmmmm loved it, is love the right word....doesn't matter, doesn't matter at all!
I was about to amazed then I thought, his teaching is pure determinism and I don't know if I agree with him. I don't believe in God, or I question what is so called God ? Totality of pre determined rules ?
I don't believe in any god either but "god" is the ethno-geographical arrangement for "cosmic law" ... which is a force to be able to imagine and invent.... sexuality, for example and so many more wonders
We are eternal beings stuck in these bodies because we are supposed to improve life as we can see it for other lifeforms, including us. We evolved meta awareness for this end.
@MrPierrefeu as long as there's death and suffering at the hands of sociopaths that run the world, what in the name of Christ kind of joy might you have?
Summary 1. Everything happens as per God’s Will. 2. Develop attitude towards life as well as others by understanding that you are not doer and so no human being should have guilt for one’s action and hatred for others for others action. 3. This will give you peace of mind and ultimately happiness. Continued……
@@wanderingfool God /Supreme Being/Universal consciouness/Supreme soul/Parmatma / ultimate reality/ The only Truth / Embodiment (as form) as MAYA (sakar and temporary) and formless in NITYA. The one in all. God in every form or formless existence. Whatever one consider the ultimate source of all energies, consciousness etc., Every person can have distinct way of defining the undefined God. Mano to Pathar bhagwan na mano to rassi (Rope) bhi saap (Snake). Meera to girdhar Gopal. Just give any name and realise it. For someone Rama or Allah or Buddha or ................... neverending names. To reach the ultimate one can realise through any form (embodiment like Rama/Krishna/Shiva) or Formless(Brahma/allah/Shiva(formless).........) but only through one`s own internal journey through various path of meditation.
@guitarszenthats is stupid no offense ..ofcourse your doing it .lahatever it is but u didnot choose your genes and conditioning ..so it is rather happening ..not that u choose to be a mathematic genius ..or psycophat doesnt choose to be psycho..u did not choose to be a human .u could have been a horse for example…so everything goes according to plan..none stop happening
life is what you say it is no depression no chance of reaching enlightenment no chance of meeting Ramesh Balsekar the solution he gives to Kunal : to think of all those millions of suffering people who are in a worse situation than him is in fact, THE crucial question of time and eternally of any time, that Bouddha and so many others , Jesus had raised 2023 years ago the ability , or not, to put ourself in the shoes of others to see the other as another yourself when you are obsessed, hypnotised with your own suffering you cannot see the beauty, or the suffering of others : this is the challenge of compassion which is increasingly lacking in our societies of individualized and forceful productivism... especially excuse me, but among rich people I will not want to be displaced and clumsy but with the lovely companion that he has even I !!! which , who am I a pure saint like goat's yogurt detached from earthly circumstances... would like to be in his place ... even if there are not together , When Asia speaks, all the guys are "enlightened" ☺🙏🙏 😊 joking aside, from Kunal's body posture it would seem that you have anger to express, to channel and, according to the will of cosmic law... it is she who can help you emerge from your depression, using it because it is your vital energy, stuck prana, blocked, so hit the drums Kunal !!! Participate to the universe DANCE
As an Advaita master Ramesh is, I wonder why he did not talk about the the practice of deidentification from the pain and let the pain be the agent of awakening from identification of the animated corpse of dirt and water and guide this fellow's stand as the Witness of the pain etc..mind boggling to me really
“God protect me from your believers!” -bumper sticker wisdom. Pain and suffering are impermanent and the 4th Noble Truth. In a dualistic world tormented by this or that; good or bad; right or wrong, etc one can attain cessation of suffering by being in the Middle Way or following the 8-Fold Path. We already exist in the Middle Way, but attachments to past keeps one in suffering. Every moment of existence in the intermediate state of this Gaia planet, all sentient beings are blessed with 3 Noble Identities which are in union of a mind/body incarnate. The First Identity is the ego identity; how we perceive our experience of self in this realm; it is the ongoing internal narrative of personal experience; ego protects and promotes our experience, but is also our own worst enemy! Second Identity is how community perceives ‘I’; it’s the Social Identity; it’s how a body of our peers judge/value ‘I’. It’s the ‘them’ in us. Third Identity is the Metaphysical Identity. We are essentially pure energy and thus, is here permanently (though body is impermanent). Energy is beyond demarcations of the body and is of divine origins of The Creator. We return to what we create, in one form or another, and suicide is not the answer. Who we are is determined by the identity in which we dwell from moment to moment. True transformation occurs upon breakthrough of Monkey Mind (the default mind program of our species). But Transference from this Gaia to another Pure Land is an unknown new art … or is it? Transference is the Great Escape from this open-air prison that was once a Pure Land Gaia. Our One Common Mother. Only Gaia knows where her sisters are in the vast cold harshness of deep space and thus how to get there. But even Isaac Newton understood that Energy Transfer is operating in this realm and throughout the cosmos. Many deep questions for simple minds and no one to put them forward to-
Even Physicists are saying freewill is an illusion. I think the Superpower that has created the Universe, has already scripted every bit of action that goes on in it and created beings like us only to act out the Script.
There is no life, nor is there imprisonment. There is no god ether, nor creator. No root. No birth, no death. No truth. No false. No destiny. No script. No story. No good, no bad. No universe. No time - no space. No karma, no doer. No past or future lives; no afterlife, no presence either. No real or false beliefs. All those concepts above may only appear as that, but only as long as there is language/words attempting to describe “THIS what is” which is ALREADY free of any identity/story and context. It’s incomprehensible isness isnessing without any purpose and meaning but all meanings seem to arise from it. Like reality arising from unreality lol. Sometimes there is a rainbow in the sky, so what? You are already free, because there is no real you and nothing to be free from! You never done anything wrong or right, again there is no real you in that apparent body; behind those eyes, no matter how real that sense of you and the apparent story of you may seem. This is it as is - completely unknowable and ungraspable in spite of APPEARING knowable. Beliefs appear and disappear. No one chooses them - or opposes them -> So, mr. imaginary chooser, wake up! This is boundless freedom already no matter what those apparent thoughts say or don’t say; they are NOTHING already only appearing as something particular but to no one. No one can teach you anything. There are no teachers as there are no students. There may be arrogance, but no teacher can be held liable for being arrogant, it’s not like anyone chooses that. 😂 There are only names, symbols and words appearing to put this unknowable isness in a context to make everything appear orderly and to make sense of this appearance that can’t be even talked about other than through apparent words/symbols lol. Who or what would you be without a name, nationality/race and date of birth? No one! Just as you were when that you was apparently born awwww, but now you have suddenly become a someone, a someone real on a mission, someone separate from wholeness 😂 And for the end… That what feels like a sense of self, like something separate, like a you. You didn’t choose that either. What did? NO ONE knows! It’s dead beginning/end already. The end of knowing - period! No word/belief can describe it. So there is not a fucking thing wrong with feeling separate or not separate. Yes, this is all nothing for no one. It’s so stunningly simple and beyond obvious and that’s the hardest part! 😂😂😂
Are there two bodies and minds? One automatic - biological with its own instinctual- gene logic and one conditioned - programmed by social environment? Is that what the master says?
Being sensitive will generate a field of presence in which you can observe through attention everything happening spontaneously. The more sensitive you are the more field will generate. Just be aware of that and watch everything with all your senses. That’s the real fate or realization and you don’t need spiritual hocus-pocus because that’s a natural state for human beings. Don’t think about just watch with all your senses.
☯️✌🏻
Hi Vinod, when I pay attention, I see very small white particles/grains in the air in front of me. Ever experienced anything like this ?
@@johnny4175 Hello, John. I do experience the same thing like You, Sir. I do see those flutuating white particles in the air.
@@NiggadoRangel Yes that's exactly what I also see !
@@johnny4175 Yes, and I thought I was the only one to see this strange phenomenom. It's good to know that someone else is seeing it. Have a nice day, Sir.
The selection of the talks in this channel is wonderful and brilliant. A big 'Thank You' to the one who compiled this talks of Ramesh Balsekar.
The idea of destiny and worthless-ness of free will is certainly hard to accept. But this acceptance ultimately translates to the act of Surrender (which Ramesh ji also talks about here). What i understand is that Surrender is the way in which the sense of personal doer-ship dissolves and actions are done in a flow in which there is no conscious thought.
The severe pain of psychological afflictions like depression is very genuine and i donot yet understand how spiritual insight can deal with that. I suffer from depression too, at times very powerful. What may be considered here is that Suicide is committed in a heightened state of Ego in which the Self pronounces that the pain is unbearable and inescapable. And if the Ego is to be completely dropped and surrendered, then the identification with forces of depression will cease. I admit that i struggle to internalize this beyond mere intellectual understanding. But in my mind, i keep returning to the idea of not identifying with my Ego.
@Cowzah I once suffered from depression as well and I think you are correct about the possibility that the depressive thought patterns can be dropped/surrendered. One day, it suddenly happened within me. Terrible spiraling thoughts about low worth, no hope, no answers and then, suddenly... a new thought came. "What if I just didn't desire anything anymore?" But it wasn't dropping the desire for life, it was more like dropping the mental story of my life. The story my ego was repeating about unmet desires and hopelessness was was just dropped, suddenly. It was like my consciousness just lost interest in the story of "myself" and dropped it.
I went through the same and this teaching works you just have to keep at it go as deep as you can, wisdom takes time to sink in the system, years, but you will have learnet the most precious thing inlife after you get it. do not make any effort, just go deep, also check other spiritualities to have a better understanding, be curious and it will come. Open the hand of thoughts, be aware of them slowly but surely; they are the cause of depression and pain in the body.
I feel the same way. I've been following these teachings as well as the "direct, non-dual" approach for years. I've been meditating (I think) for hours every day for 14 years. Yet I am now as depressed as I've ever been.
I sleep as much as possible and have no inspiration or motivation to cook, clean, get a job, make friends, etc. I exercise physically which helps me to feel fairly good much of the time, but then the dark thoughts arise again.
I thought it was clear that there was "no one" here and that free will was an illusion. Now I feel like I've been fooling myself all this time. I am just a person. I feel like the doer no matter how clearly I see intellectually that I am not. I think it's time for me to admit failure and just go back to living as if conditions could bring me satisfaction. I'm cooked.
47:28 true, Islam means to surrender.
"He who wishes that there appear, at a given moment,
other than what God has manifested in it,
has not left ignorance behind at all."
The teaching of Ramesh has changed my life.
The irony, Islam preaches to kill kafirs. 😄
Kunal brother if you see this, how are you doing? Much love to you on your journey. ❤❤❤
I am not the doer; accept the certain fact that life is uncertainty; and go with flow: knowing and accepting this, and changing my attitude towards life and 'the other', brings peace. That is enlightenment! Thank you, Rameshji!
Its interesting because if u are not the doer, the experiencer, you separate yourself from the act. But all conflict has its root on separation/division. It feels like everything is ONE, and if thats so, how can we separate ourselves from the ONENESS? It feels like its the our EGO MIND that separates us from everything thats why suffering happens. If everything is the same, we will always BE everything, we are the actions, we are thoughts, we are the trees, we are the people around us, we are the world, we are CONSCIOUSNESS which gathers everything in existence.
bullshit
Acceptance may happen or may not happen.
Being translated into the Light is liberation of spirit and soul. The body grows less and less important. The truth Sets free. It doesnt hurt. Heaven is pure bliss and freedom. We can Taste it to a certain degree here on earth. Thats what I think. God is Love.
G R E A T T E A C H E R. His concepts are helpful, since minds are so tricky.
My God, this was absolutely amazing!😍😍🥰🥰🥰😇😇😇😇
First find peace, be in peace with youre highs and downs. In that peace you will find something called happyness. When you seek happyness the seeking of happyness itself will be the problem. Find peace, be in peace with youre hate, fear, pleasure etc. so that isnt importand what arises in you. Then there is peace
What is happyness? Never heard of this word before
@@religionofpeace782 sorry iam german, i try my best. Sometimes its Not so easy, we write Happy, and then i think you write happyness because in German we Take Double for short, ness, but yeah, i think happines is the Thing you mean or i mean 😅
I live this talk! So down to earth and simple. No mystical mumbo jumbo just straight forward logical sensible life advice 🙏 i really hope kunal found some help and relief for his depression, its heart breaking to see somebody suffering like that he seems a nice gentle soul
Depression is curable.... depression is our thoughts from the past... anxiety is from future....the power remains in now.
Correcting the eating habits and swaying away from sugar and carbs ,eating veggies help... Long fasting work wonders..add b vitamins in the diet
Don't need to change your diet at all. Just change your mind by seeking the same non-dual path pointed at by people like Shankara and Buddah in the past.
B-Vitamins are for brain health and i take them by myself. Very good.
Brain and mind are two different things. What you said works for the brain. The Mind needs different nutrition called spirituality
Multivitamin works for the brain. Have twice a day. Amla ka juice is also good for the brain. Have it only once. ESP in the morning before sunrise.
Love the way he told the truth. Just understand nothing in your hands and go with the flow.
Thankyou Video uploader, you are making PEACE to many one's. ❤🥺
- живот се састоји од жеља и могућности
- ако лимитираш жеље на могућности увијек је живот лијеп
- ако те савладају жеље а мало могућности увијек се пати
- дакле
- дешава се ма што но имамо вјеру тако да што би да би
_
не бринеш него уживаш живот у вјери са вјером ослони се на вјеру ИСУСА на вјеровања добрих "великих људи и жена"
_
*_"права молитва, чврста молитва кључ за све"_*
_
угодан дан
- сваки дан је задњи дан а многи од нас неће ни доживјети сутрашњи дан
- хоће се казати живи сваки дан вјеру за вјечност и добро ће бити
_
кад се бавиш промашеном вјером ни одоговора свих немаш
- и тада доживљаваш живот као патњу
_
како наћи циљ живота у вјери без циља
- та не можеш јер га нема и онда живот и глуп изгледа
_
што више тражиш све више пустоши срећеш
- што се више питаш све мање одговора имаш
What?¿????¿
Hopelessness occurs when an authoritative body crushes the Self of the individual, thus depriving him of the possibility to be what he really is. ❤
I love this. My landscaping boss tried to force me in on the day I had said I couldn't because I was so tired.
@@michaelbriggs9925Hopelessness is about not having identity. It is about the impossibility to run a normal life. You have the power to build your life and find new ways to be happier. The hopeless is unable to do any of that.
@@sydereum what?
I like this man, he knows
Life is about Being free; but our Lives are mentalized as prisons.
While the philosophy is good, religion, Bhakti is good, it is also important to seek thetspy( cognitive behavioral therapy) along with medications.
Depression is not imaginary, it’s like diabetes or hypertension. It involves neurotransmitters. I heard one gentleman here talk about depression. Please get help.
Just like ur body needs vitamins, food, u have to seek help for depression!🙏
Great point! And that does not contradict what he’s saying here either. As I know you did not imply :-)
Sometimes this human form needs help in order to feel better and continue to show compassion to others. However, I think the key is to just except that this is true. I myself suffer with bipolar and depression, and through these teachings and many others I recognize that I can’t feel sorry for myself, or will it away. I do what I can for my body because this is the reality in which I live.
Everything is in God’s perfect will and I ask for that will every day. Sometimes minute by minute!
I am amused by all the comments from people offering their wisdom. This is reflective of how the ego makes one feel as if he is an expert or awakened. When you see what there is to see there is little to talk about or to prove to anyone else.
I'm amused by the people actually listening to this guy.
And ur doing the same thing they are by calling them out on it inferencing that you have a higher spiritual perspective
@@Guru_Josiahhaha funny!
@@jasonbourne4784don’t worry it’s not their free will to choose. Haha.
yes, another possibility to develop compassion, most beings have not arrived at the experience of a Ramesh and are only regurgitating, this in order to comfort their poor lack of esteem and to suffer a little less 🙏🙂
Ramesh had infinite patience🙏
Patience of whom ? What you mean by Ramesh ? A biological body mind organ or God ? If your answer is body mind organ then I think there is nothing great in this because this body mind organ is nothing but a programmed machine (as per him) always acting according to God's will like any other ordinary human being. If your answer is God then I will say that God is without any attributes like patience.
❤
And he was razor sharp. When I was in the hot seat and was so unclear and yet he asked questions in such a way to bring about true communication. Sat with him for 3 weeks, 21 years ago. An absolute blessings. Christ Ramesh.
@@chandankumar-lk9kr There is no God dude.
Knock it off with your scriptural knowledge.
@@chandankumar-lk9kr at this point u r just copying the speech style of Ramesh XD ..... people will begin to ignore u after a while ..
On a light note. I'm pretty sure thats Roger Castillo at the back taking it all in 😊. We are fortunate it was his destiny to come across Ramesh's teachings, and present them for future generations ❤
Basis of every human relationship is suspicion and rivalries 🙏😢
That is only the relationship between the self and the other. The ideas of self and the other are illusions. All relationship is illusion and ignorance.
Oh, Such a Beautiful Video. Thanks
Mind Opening.❤❤❤❤
Thanks for the clarity I was seeking for my pain🙏🏻
Kunal does not seems to be convinced, hope he is alive & happy.
Always Perfect, listening to Ramesh!
What is perfect Sir ! Is it perfect because a robber can now live with his head high because no longer he needs to feel guilty of his acts as he has now got the license to rob others and say that he is doing so because it is the will of the God ? Or a rapist gets certificate of his innocence because his acts amount to charity as he is fulfilling the will of the God ?
@@chandankumar-lk9kr You realy don't understand the word perfect ,you look at it from a personal point of view but the perfection is impersonal .
@@hermansohier7643 Okay ! I don't understand, but who is saying this... is it some impersonal or personal. Simply parroting the heard lines from someone or somewhere does not make difference unless you see through yourself.
@@chandankumar-lk9kr I'm not parotting words ,this is an understanding without some one who understands .If i had listen to these teachings 30 years ago i would of gone mad and angry .But ' i ' went all the way ,did everything possible to become enlightent and one day i realised that 'i'could'nt do anything because there was no i to begin with .The i ,the world and the conceptual thinking are 3 words for the same thing and it's empty and full the samme time .
@@chandankumar-lk9kr What are you bragging about here? xD
You think you are all known dude..lol
this is amazing when you are able by gods will to let it in thank you thank you !!!
The right message will free you!
For the believer life is an imprisonment ..The Prophet of Islam
This man is getting the business, the seeker.
What the fuck - this was brilliant! But it got dark towards the end. I really hope Kunal is at a better place now. Kunal, tell us you're better!
Interesting and the courage of the students to ask hard questions, thank you.
Smiling is the remedy for depression, and loving somebody or God more than yourself
Guruji❤
Nothing is pre determined. Only acceptance will liberate us. Once we accept we are able to ride the waves of experiences. The knowing of being is happiness. common name is "i" In religious terms is god.
7 billion points of views this is one of them…
8 billion now. We keep growing and growing. 1 billion to 8 billion in just 200 years. Insane!
I just wish this guy will listen
@Kunal Please look into addressing gut dysbiosis/inflammation. God willing you see this message.
🙏 Thanks so much for the upload!
Om namah sivaya🕉️🙏,
I think that unity is all there is. Only the human mind sees differences.💗🌍🌸☯️☪️✝️✡️🕉️🕎💟
Brilliant! Clarity. Thank you.
Don't see what is brilliant or so clear in the conversation. The conversation only raises questions and answers none. A man can't live even for a moment without an action, and what one does depends on his/ her prakriti (Gunas) , which in turn is the result of his past and present lives/ karmas (samskaras), this in turn depends how one lives and acts every moment and the eagerness she/ he shows every moment in knowing himself and also the purpose of life. Polio was incurable sometimes before but not now and this was possible because the effort and the will of the mankind. You can't say that earlier God had the will to make human suffer through polio but now He has changed his mind and now He wishes that no one should suffer from this disease called polio. Moreover, will you tell me why someone suffer and some enjoys if one can't do good or bad ?
@chandankumar-lk9kr clear as a bell. It's between the words in the infinite gap between all perceptions, thoughts. Don't listen through your mind and you will be taken to direct experience where his meaning lies.
@@lynlavalight I fully agree. Truth can't be perceived by mind and therefore mind has to be transcended. But here lies, what I call the Sadhana, practice, nidhidhyasana etc. to bring mind under control and not think that mind will come under control if it is the will of the God. All spirituality in essence teaches how to control the mind or transcend this mind which obstruct us from seeing the truth.
Thank you!!!! 🙏❤❤❤❤
God first t will us to suffer. We all have consequences for the karmas we did in this life & several past lives. Hence we r born w certain genes, into certain families & certain conditions. Please get help for depression or for any other condition/ any troubles while also involved in Bhakthi, seeking forgiveness, seeking understanding. God will always help us with strength to bear the consequences of our karma as well as mitigate it. He will decrease a bad karma from a snake bite to an ant bite for example. When ur body & mind is not an ok e to deal w certain things, please care for it. Feed the body, mind & spirit. It’s not just mind & spirit alone. Take care of ur biological self too.
Society call his or her action..
But as all have free will but not control in results of action..
So..
Nothing of results, which society think his or her action.. Is actually his/ her action
Thank you for again uploading this of guru ji ❤
Of fine, but will you tell me why are you so elated. Have you found who you are or have you discovered the secret of creation ?
@@michaelmcclure3383 What creation ? Exactly where the will of God applies. If there be no creation where the will of God will apply and on to whom ? Sir, Nagarjuna says, that it is impossible to know the higher truth without knowing the lower truth. So, first learn to swim before abandoning the boat.
@@michaelmcclure3383 I am not sure whether the teaching of Sh Ramesh is of Karmyoga. Because in my understanding karmayoga implies the voluntary action with no end result in sight, which is certainly not the case in his teaching. Moreover, for karmyoga there has to be an element of doership (in early phase), which completely misses in his teachings. Fact remains, and that is based on first hand individual experience, that mere knowledge does not remove the conditioning of mind or past habits. It can be concurred only through practice. As long as mind is under the influence of Gunas it will be bound to react according to its composition of Gunas. Without practice even if there is knowledge, the composition of Gunas can't be changed. So Bhakti or surrender is culmination of the Karmyoga or in other words bhakti/ surrender shall be incomplete unless it has passed though the path of Karmyoga.
@@michaelmcclure3383 The moment Krishna says that one has only right to act means that one is free to act. Who is free to act of course the ego, I. If one can't act why will he ask Arjuna to act ? Think !
The moment you lose the sense of doership or sense of I you become the Lord Krishna Himself. There remains no separation between Him and you. You are just narrating the final truth but the fact is that this state has to be acquired in order to realize which in turn passes from the sense of doership and finally becoming not a doer. Mere stating intellectually that I am not the doer will not do good.
@@michaelmcclure3383 You are right. The enlightened sages identify with the body but fully understand that they are not the doer. My point is that this realization of not being the doer is not an intellectual understanding. The sense of doership falls automatically if one pursues the path of Karmayoga as its culmination. Here lies the catch. You referred Raman Maharshi who got enlightenment in very early age but to make that understanding and realization seeps through his being and remain steady he practiced sadhana for decades. And this is what I am trying to highlight. Unless the mind becomes fully sattvic it will never be steady with the realization even if one happens to get.
He was the master.
A master
He's not at all hypocrite, n he's very simple n to the point sharing his understandings, concepts.... , again by the will of God! 🙂🙏
Are you really free? The most intense freedom I experienced Was when Jesus set met free. Try praying. Thinking that there is no God is some what like slavery. If there is something greater than pure truth and absolute love, then go and seek. But why seek for more of Jesus can give us everything we need.
@guitarszen at the same time
you are the BODY which goes through the experience of illusion of free will,
you are the SOUL which is free from the illusion of free will n simply witness the drama with complete acceptance (Surrendered to the will of GOD),
You are the GOD who is FREE...
-VEDANTA 🙏🙂
@@owrah2198 you are right 🙏🙂
The algorithm is doing its thing again
The Great Algorithm 😂🤣😂
41:00 his conclusion is that unhappiness comes from rivalry. This is not true in my experience. I have no rivalries and the best intentions, yet I am not happy.
Also he is wrong about genes. We 𝑑𝑜 have control over our genes. I think in this talk, especially with the person at 1:08:30 he makes the mistake of "for a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail". Totally not helpful for the guy, but I assume he gives answers/this talk to be of service. Anyway, he has some good points. For me, free will is a very good illusion and it doesnt help philosophizing about it - what's the point? Yes, God acts through us and yes we do have different possibilities of acting but this is also highly limited by a lot of factors. I like to think in terms of 'we have a certain degree 0 < x < 100 of free will', strictly not 0 and strictly not 100%, and even if it was 0 or 100: it doesnt matter.
the question is not to believe in free will or not, but to know why we don't do what we would like to do
A great Video. At par with JK
Rameshji speak from round @2:30+ @5:49 IMP MSG/Q!!!!
धन्यवाद.
so so true!
We must do better in this time to have elevation next life time,the spirit lives on if we allow God's will.
True master!
True Master ! How Sir ? Because, now you can say that the reason for your abject failure was not the lack of any effort on your part but God's will ? Or in his teaching you have got the license to sit idle and do nothing ?
You are completely right from your point of view and where you stand. My statement in the OP probably came from my Ego as well! It’s all play of thoughts anyways!
There is no failing nor success only a concept within the ego ' God is in you and outside of uou '
Pain is exacerbated and prolonged by the label “ pain “. Thus: I am in pain. I think that the pain validates the me as real, and is therefore unconsciously propagated.
wonderful questions.
But you cannot will it unless God wills: for, behold, God is indeed all-seeing, wise Quran 76:30
Finally! Found the real master Oogway ❤
Enlightenment has happened ...proceed 🎉
For those with habitual habits
Brilliant!💜
sending love to Kunal
As Flip Wilson (Geraldine) might’ve said: The Wrath of God made me do
it !!!
❤❤❤❤❤
Nice ..
So everything randomly predetermined …and i should accept it¿how is it accepting power
Y E S
How a human being has a "totall freewill". We didnt chose the country and family in which we were born and we are conditioned by that society , parents etc., and now any decision i make will come from that conditiong. Suppose if i was not born in India but america then the decision i take will be diffrent due to change in conditioning. So i dont have any freewill as im motivated or forced to take action and decision by my conditioning.
He said the same thing bro.. Worthless free will..!
@@abdulsatthar3548 and im saying we do not have a freewill. It is worthless only if it exist but it doesn't.
🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Indirect stoic philosophy, well, a lot of it is! And nihilism, the acceptance of the absurd, and meaninglessness and purposelessness! Hmmmmmm loved it, is love the right word....doesn't matter, doesn't matter at all!
I was about to amazed then I thought, his teaching is pure determinism and I don't know if I agree with him. I don't believe in God, or I question what is so called God ? Totality of pre determined rules ?
I don't believe in any god either but "god" is the ethno-geographical arrangement for "cosmic law" ... which is a force to be able to imagine and invent.... sexuality, for example and so many more wonders
@@e-ternell Hımmm I wouldn't call it as law but yeah I think I get it. 🙏🏻
Even tho I agree to an extent such videos are dangerous!! Yes life is imprisonment but one must try to befriend life than to surrender like a fool.
Surrendering is the same as becoming friends
@@ilqar887 surrendering is close to slavery not friendship
Any update on Kunar ?
We are eternal beings stuck in these bodies because we are supposed to improve life as we can see it for other lifeforms, including us. We evolved meta awareness for this end.
we are supposed to improve joy
@MrPierrefeu as long as there's death and suffering at the hands of sociopaths that run the world, what in the name of Christ kind of joy might you have?
LIFE IS A PRIVELEGE ACTUALLY.
i love how comment section is filled with more unnecessary wisdom.
When wisdom becomes unnecessary it becomes unnecessary wisdom
@@dogtail3937hahahahahahaha.... You just proved my point.
@@zindagijeenede ha!
Anyone knows what happened to Kunal
Summary 1. Everything happens as per God’s Will. 2. Develop attitude towards life as well as others by understanding that you are not doer and so no human being should have guilt for one’s action and hatred for others for others action. 3. This will give you peace of mind and ultimately happiness. Continued……
which god? name please?
@@wanderingfool Lord Siva.
@@wanderingfool God /Supreme Being/Universal consciouness/Supreme soul/Parmatma / ultimate reality/ The only Truth / Embodiment (as form) as MAYA (sakar and temporary) and formless in NITYA. The one in all. God in every form or formless existence. Whatever one consider the ultimate source of all energies, consciousness etc., Every person can have distinct way of defining the undefined God. Mano to Pathar bhagwan na mano to rassi (Rope) bhi saap (Snake). Meera to girdhar Gopal. Just give any name and realise it. For someone Rama or Allah or Buddha or ................... neverending names. To reach the ultimate one can realise through any form (embodiment like Rama/Krishna/Shiva) or Formless(Brahma/allah/Shiva(formless).........) but only through one`s own internal journey through various path of meditation.
@guitarszen good observations. But wether God exists or not is debatable. God as an old man on a throne ?
@guitarszenthats is stupid no offense ..ofcourse your doing it .lahatever it is but u didnot choose your genes and conditioning ..so it is rather happening ..not that u choose to be a mathematic genius ..or psycophat doesnt choose to be psycho..u did not choose to be a human .u could have been a horse for example…so everything goes according to plan..none stop happening
Thanks, Captain Obvious.
Wonderful
❤❤🙏
A costume, a mask...❤
In Bhagavat Geeta Shri Krishna says to aquire 16 Divine qualities. Daivi Gunas. Please 🙏 respond to this question
life is what you say it is
no depression no chance of reaching enlightenment no chance of meeting Ramesh Balsekar
the solution he gives to Kunal : to think of all those millions of suffering people who are in a worse situation than him is in fact, THE crucial question of time and eternally of any time,
that Bouddha and so many others
, Jesus had raised 2023 years ago
the ability , or not, to put ourself in the shoes of others
to see the other as another yourself
when you are obsessed, hypnotised with your own suffering you cannot see the beauty, or the suffering of others :
this is the challenge of compassion
which is increasingly lacking in our societies of individualized and forceful productivism... especially excuse me, but among rich people
I will not want to be displaced and clumsy but with the lovely companion that he has even I !!!
which , who am I a pure saint like goat's yogurt detached from earthly circumstances... would like to be in his place
... even if there are not together ,
When Asia speaks, all the guys are "enlightened"
☺🙏🙏 😊
joking aside, from Kunal's body posture it would seem that you have anger to express, to channel and, according to the will of cosmic law... it is she who can help you emerge from your depression, using it because it is your vital energy, stuck prana, blocked,
so hit the drums Kunal !!!
Participate to the universe DANCE
As an Advaita master Ramesh is, I wonder why he did not talk about the the practice of deidentification from the pain and let the pain be the agent of awakening from identification of the animated corpse of dirt and water and guide this fellow's stand as the Witness of the pain etc..mind boggling to me really
I'm not boggled. This guy is fake.
Why use philosophy when you can explain in simpler way of psychology which they also don't seem to understand?
“God protect me from your believers!” -bumper sticker wisdom.
Pain and suffering are impermanent and the 4th Noble Truth. In a dualistic world tormented by this or that; good or bad; right or wrong, etc one can attain cessation of suffering by being in the Middle Way or following the 8-Fold Path. We already exist in the Middle Way, but attachments to past keeps one in suffering.
Every moment of existence in the intermediate state of this Gaia planet, all sentient beings are blessed with 3 Noble Identities which are in union of a mind/body incarnate. The First Identity is the ego identity; how we perceive our experience of self in this realm; it is the ongoing internal narrative of personal experience; ego protects and promotes our experience, but is also our own worst enemy!
Second Identity is how community perceives ‘I’; it’s the Social Identity; it’s how a body of our peers judge/value ‘I’. It’s the ‘them’ in us.
Third Identity is the Metaphysical Identity. We are essentially pure energy and thus, is here permanently (though body is impermanent). Energy is beyond demarcations of the body and is of divine origins of The Creator. We return to what we create, in one form or another, and suicide is not the answer. Who we are is determined by the identity in which we dwell from moment to moment. True transformation occurs upon breakthrough of Monkey Mind (the default mind program of our species). But Transference from this Gaia to another Pure Land is an unknown new art … or is it?
Transference is the Great Escape from this open-air prison that was once a Pure Land Gaia. Our One Common Mother. Only Gaia knows where her sisters are in the vast cold harshness of deep space and thus how to get there. But even Isaac Newton understood that Energy Transfer is operating in this realm and throughout the cosmos. Many deep questions for simple minds and no one to put them forward to-
Your fruits are your fruit and you have deserved them thru your action.
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
11:23 I no longer believe that I have feee will 🤔
I have no free wheel too
@@thomasbarchen 19:39 I think he goes about saying we have free will and we don’t 🤷♂️
This means we are puppets in God’s hand.
Even Physicists are saying freewill is an illusion. I think the Superpower that has created the Universe, has already scripted every bit of action that goes on in it and created beings like us only to act out the Script.
it can be very relaxing 🙂
@@e-ternellIt can work either ways.
Yes and the ultimate god might be enslaved to its own essence too
Is kunal still alive??
Living?
I was actually scrolling down hoping someone knew anything about Kunal as well.
There is no life, nor is there imprisonment. There is no god ether, nor creator. No root. No birth, no death. No truth. No false. No destiny. No script. No story. No good, no bad. No universe. No time - no space. No karma, no doer. No past or future lives; no afterlife, no presence either. No real or false beliefs. All those concepts above may only appear as that, but only as long as there is language/words attempting to describe “THIS what is” which is ALREADY free of any identity/story and context. It’s incomprehensible isness isnessing without any purpose and meaning but all meanings seem to arise from it. Like reality arising from unreality lol. Sometimes there is a rainbow in the sky, so what?
You are already free, because there is no real you and nothing to be free from! You never done anything wrong or right, again there is no real you in that apparent body; behind those eyes, no matter how real that sense of you and the apparent story of you may seem.
This is it as is - completely unknowable and ungraspable in spite of APPEARING knowable. Beliefs appear and disappear. No one chooses them - or opposes them -> So, mr. imaginary chooser, wake up!
This is boundless freedom already no matter what those apparent thoughts say or don’t say; they are NOTHING already only appearing as something particular but to no one.
No one can teach you anything. There are no teachers as there are no students. There may be arrogance, but no teacher can be held liable for being arrogant, it’s not like anyone chooses that. 😂
There are only names, symbols and words appearing to put this unknowable isness in a context to make everything appear orderly and to make sense of this appearance that can’t be even talked about other than through apparent words/symbols lol. Who or what would you be without a name, nationality/race and date of birth? No one! Just as you were when that you was apparently born awwww, but now you have suddenly become a someone, a someone real on a mission, someone separate from wholeness 😂
And for the end…
That what feels like a sense of self, like something separate, like a you. You didn’t choose that either. What did? NO ONE knows! It’s dead beginning/end already. The end of knowing - period!
No word/belief can describe it. So there is not a fucking thing wrong with feeling separate or not separate. Yes, this is all nothing for no one.
It’s so stunningly simple and beyond obvious and that’s the hardest part! 😂😂😂
Oh, you put it so beautifully. Perfect.
The God's cosmic law can be interpreted by humans?
@@michaelmcclure3383 so true
He hardly disagrees...
symposium on delusions
If what he is saying is true with that much certainty, then there's no room for invention and innovation.
if you say it
Are there two bodies and minds? One automatic - biological with its own instinctual- gene logic and one conditioned - programmed by social environment? Is that what the master says?
Is he byrd