Ashari Makes Huge Blunder When Debating Dawah Man - Does Allah Speak With Sound?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 авг 2021
- For more info on this topic, refer to 1:15:02 - 1:41:40 of this video. • SHOCKING: Disturbing D...
Here are the points in this video:
- Allah says tells the muslims to give the disbelievers shelter until they hear the speech of Allah, سمع in Arabic means to hear sounds, so Allah speaks with sound.
- There’s a hadith in Bukhari where Allah calls out to Adam with sound, this hadith explicitly describes Allah’s speech as having sound. Also nida is understood by consensus of the Arabs to mean communicating with sound.
- Kalam in Arabic is understood to mean sound and words by consensus of those with a sound intellect according to Imam Abu Nasr Al Sijzee.
- Zakariya was told that he wasn’t allowed to speak to the people for three days, and that he was only allowed to do hand gestures and signals. This refutes the ashari idea of kalam being inside of you that doesn’t come out of you, as well as it proving that Kalam means communication with sound and words as that’s what Zakariya wasn’t allowed to do. We’re not saying that our speech is like Allah’s speech, this is just to prove the definition of kalam.
- Imam Ahmad said that Allah speaks with sound, Imam Al Bukhari also said the same thing in his Khalq Af’aal Al Ibaad.
Abu Nasr Al Sijzee (Died 444H) wrote a book called الرد على من أنكر الحرف والصوت where he refutes those who deny that Allah speaks with sound and words, you can refer there for further information.
For more info on this topic, refer to 1:15:02 - 1:41:40 of this video. ruclips.net/video/u8y6GIN95Xo/видео.html
Here are the points in this video:
- Allah says tells the muslims to give the disbelievers shelter until they hear the speech of Allah, سمع in Arabic means to hear sounds, so Allah speaks with sound.
- There’s a hadith in Bukhari where Allah calls out to Adam with sound, the Hadith explicitly describes Allah’s speech as having sound. Also nida is understood by consensus of the Arabs to mean communicating with sound.
- Kalam in Arabic is understood to mean sound and words by consensus of those with a sound intellect according to Imam Abu Nasr Al Sijzee.
- Zakariya was told that he wasn’t allowed to speak to the people for three days, and that he was only allowed to do hand gestures and signals. This refutes the ashari idea of kalam being inside of you and doesn’t come out of you, as well as it proving that Kalam means communication with sound and words as that’s what Zakariya wasn’t allowed to do. We’re not saying that our speech is like Allah’s speech, this is just to prove the definition of kalam.
- Imam Ahmad said that Allah speaks with sound, Imam Al Bukhari also said the same thing in his Khalq Af’aal Al Ibaad.
Abu Nasr Al Sijzee (Died 444H) wrote a book called الرد على من أنكر الحرف والصوت where he refutes those who deny that Allah speaks with sound and words, you can refer there for further information.
Akhi can you give the reference for the Hadith in Bukhari, I don’t have doubt regarding this topic but just wana add the Hadith in Bukhari to my notes.
@@user-br1qk6mt6k It’s hadith number 4741. The translation isn’t that good, but if you read the Arabic you’ll see فَيُنَادَى بِصَوْتٍ which shows that Allah will call out to Adam with sound.
@@user-br1qk6mt6k Its in Kitab Bhukari Tafsir I posted it wasn't 4747, its hadith 4741 on Sunnah com as the brother corrected his typo, its similar to the near last Hadith in Kitab Iman in sahih Muslim...
I tried posting the hadith but its not showing...
@@user-br1qk6mt6k Narrated Abu Sa`id Al-Khudri:
The Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) said, "On the day of Resurrection Allah will say, 'O Adam!' Adam will reply, 'Labbaik our Lord, and Sa`daik ' Then there will be a loud call (saying), Allah orders you to take from among your offspring a mission for the Fire.' Adam will say, 'O Lord! Who are the mission for the Fire?' Allah will say, 'Out of each thousand, take out 999.' At that time every pregnant female shall drop her load (have a miscarriage) and a child will have grey hair. And you shall see mankind as in a drxnken state, yet not drxnk, but severe will be the torment of Allah." (22.2) The people were so distressed that their faces got changed (in color) whereupon the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) said, "From Gog and Magog nine-hundred ninety-nine will be taken out and one from you. You Muslims (compared) will be like a blxck hair on the side of a white ox, or a white hair on the side of a blxck ox, and I hope that you will be one fourth of the people of Paradise." On that, we said, "Allahu-Akbar!" Then he said, "I hope that you will be) one-third of the people of Paradise." We again said, "Allahu-Akbar!" Then he said, "(I hope that you will be) one-half of the people of Paradise." So we said, Allahu Akbar."
- Sahih al-Bukhari 4741, Kitab Tafsir
@@ibmsulaymani Jhazakhallu khairan
Ahlus Sunnah affirms Allah’s Kalam. He speaks whenever He wills, His Speech is heard by whomsoever Allah wills and also He Speaks with letters [harf] and sound [sawt].
“It is not for any human being that Allaah should speak to him unless (it be) by Revelation, or from behind a veil.” [Surah Ash-Shuraa (42): 51]
Allaah, the Majestic and Most High, rebuked the people of shirk for the fact that they worshipped statues, which do not speak. Ibraaheem `alayhissalaam said:
So ask them if they are able to speak. (Sooratul-Anbiyaa· (21), aayah 63)
The above ayah context: Prophet Ibrahim alaihissalam showed his people that their idols were not worthy of worship, primarily because they could not speak. Notice that Ibrahim was referring to actual speech that can be heard, that’s why his people could not refute his evidence.
Jazakallahu Khair. These are very strong proofs.
Maybe that ashari guy has a special miracle where he can hear without sound
Now that's interesting. Ahlul Kalam (people of philosophy/rhetoric) rejecting kalam (speech of Allah).
When you go away from the true understanding of the Sunnah, then you become foolish like the asharis and matarudis.
@@pointdot094 without any hesitation.... Any exposing deviants isn't a slander but rather a highly recommended practice
Ibn Abi Al Izz al Hanafi does a great job breaking down the ashari/mutazilah doubts on those that negate the speech of sound, as well as the uncreated speech of Allah.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته akhi,
In which book can i find this?
@@altin1546 Sharh Aqeedah Tahawiyyah
Subhanallah, it gets weirder and weirder day by day, jazakallah khair Ibrahim!
إِنْ شَاءَ ٱللَّٰهُ we can get in touch :)
Watched the full thing asharis disturb me truly may Allah guide them.
They seem to be the mixture of good and evil in the hadith of hudayfah...
Atharis are the good, then came mutazila & then Imam Ashari raised Mutazila became closer to Athari & formed Khulabi Ashari ideology which Ibn Hanbal refuted. Imam Ashari repented & Barbahari witnessed it!
Ashari : 3 cycles, Seljuks to Crusades with betrayal of shias in Egypt & Hijaz, its why Salahudin said I can't fight crusades with shi'a backstabs, then Saladin to Monghuls 100 yrs later again due to sufi bida & shi'a betrayal, then Uthmanis beat monghuls but again betrayed by safawid shi'as & then Ikwanis. Saudis 1st Kingdom and Banu Tamim tried to help the Uthmanis return to the Sunnah and leave their bida which lead them to secularism tyt etc.
if everyone makes up their own stuff its just going to divide.
Eventually ikwanis recycles the sufi bida of Uthmanis and more - as Sh. Albani said when talking on unity with ASharis its treating the illness with illness, with shi'aism etc, while Saudis formed 3rd kingdom and Banu tamim hard on dajjal though tribe means nothing without Din and righteous actions. May Allah guide us!
@@dontinsultme4821 USa brother.
There's a video of sheikh uthman ibn farook touching on this topic aswel , that ibn qudama refuted the ashari's
Barakallahu Feek, Tbh it wasn't even a proper debate, it was just stubbornness, if he was honest he would answer Imran honestly and not use very low debate tactics to insult him and act arrogantly. May Allah guide them
I dont get it, how does an ash3ari claim there is no sound when Allah spoke to Musa from the tree?
Just tell them, Allah can even speak through creations (with sound) , here's the dalil > But when he came to it, he was called from the right side of the valley in a blessed spot - from the tree, "O Moses, indeed I am Allah , Lord of the worlds." {Quran 28:30}
الله أكبر الله أكبر و الله إن السنة لتنير القلب و تزيح ظلمة البدعة و تزيلها و تريحه الحمدلله على نعمة الاسلام و السنة❤️🍃✨ بارك الله في الشيخ عبدالرحمن حسن و الاخ صاحب القناة و نفع بهم ❤️❤️
i like these books cover it makes me want to really read them and buy a lot of them
Again, kalaam is sound and letters if we affirm the meaning. It wouldnt be kalaam if there is no sound. The actual confusion these deviants spread is that they mix the Attribute of kalaam with specific kalaam with certain letters like Quran. It is some of the kalaam revealed to us. There are ahadeeth where Allah calls Jibrael A.S, and Jibrael shrinks with fear. You can correct me if its not authentic.
People had debates on tiktok... I didn't even know... These ahlulkalam have their own definition of Allah's attribute.
May Allah protect ustadh abdur rahman hasan ameen
Mashallah sheikh
WHO IS THE RECITER PLEASE?! AT THE BEGGINING OF THE VIDEO.. MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU!
Ustadh Abdurahman Hassan
😊❤❤
😮
How come advertisment pop up in this video..
ruclips.net/video/kh4vC2nwM0Q/видео.html
2:40
Bruh ALLAH spoke with the prophets ALLAH didn't write to tell hazrat Muhammad e.t.c ALLAH directly spoke with them
Not all prophets spoke with Allah directly.
Musa AS was the only one who Allah SWT spoke with. The Prophet SAW didn't usually speak with Allah SWT directly (I say usually because of the Night Journey however I don't know if even then Allah SWT directly spoke to the Prophet SAW). I'm not sure of Ibrahim AS, but Adam AS definitely did.
@@junaid2266 Allah swt did speak to the Prophet directly