The comics was better simply for the fact of the overall story and characters within it. I recently finished the comics and this video makes me want to read them again!
@@Julian-uk6mji don’t think it was as much rushed as it was a late realization that this was the perfect time to end it. it can feel rushed sure but i think the ending was still good.
I love the comic. Andrea is hands down one of my favorite fictional characters of all time and I hate how the show ruined her. She was basically the Daryl of the comics.
Yeah but the same could be said with Carol in the comics so your point is a bit invalid, I dont like the comics because carol was a useless character who did nothing. The same could be said with shane, morgan and hershel who are all massive down grades from the tv show counterparts. Also daryl is better than andrea in the comic for me, so having andrea in the tv show just be like him causes daryl to be worse.
@@nani4249 the point of Carol’s character in the comics was showing how the mayhem and isolation of the apocalypse can drive someone crazy. And she ultimately took her own life because she couldn’t handle and evolve to the new world like everyone else. She was so isolated and lonely she suggested a polygamous marriage with Rick and Lori, only to get heartbroken and angry when Lori understandably didn’t want that. She character in the comics is meant to be a tragic figure instead of the terminator she was turned into in the show.
@@AlecEburhard exactly carol and andrea in both comic and TV show were meant to tell an entire different story from each other, not saying either is bad but just as 1 his worse than the other doesn't necessarily make it worse, and as they are different and have different level of importance in each story doesn't make any sense to criticise the tv show purely because its different from the comic
@@nani4249I like Daryl but many things that were done by Andrea, Abraham and Tyreese were given to him. On top of that Its so stupid how they made Caron a menace on the show. Like come on 1 woman be coming a terminator? The change to father Gabriel on the TV was more belivable than that of TV Carol.
@rumers100 daryl just replaced those characters anyways so it doesn't matter. And you really can't say Abraham, tyreese and andrea in the comic are better than daryl. But carol even though she was a strong survivor didn't display any super human feats so I can't see your problem with her development, plus she's more like rambo than terminator anyways
I think more The Walking Dead comic book reviews would be great. Also what would be really cool is if once Invincible ends if that studio was able to animate The Walking Dead comic. The only problem is if the live action series overstays it's welcome (which some may argue it already has.) People might become so tired of the series that even if the comic tells a better story and there was an animated series that was a 1 to 1 adaptation people may just not care at that point. Carl is my favorite character from the comics. He's ok in the tv show but an absolute bad ass in the comic.
I thought they did Tyreese SUPER dirty bro, I kinda just watched it out of inertia since then ... and then they made Negan ... actually boring. Terrible execution. The governor was good but ... too drawn out
Please do the other compendiums. I read the negan arc before it came out and was soooo excited to see it on tv. Jeffrey dean morgan did a fantastic job showcasing the unhinged charisma of negan.
i really hope that someday there will be a 1:1 adaptation thats fully animated in the style of the comic. its such a shame to me that as books and reading has fallen out of style in favor of tv people have missed so many amazing stories so i hope more accurate book adaptations are made so more people can actually experience these stories without some soulless tv exec making cuts for better ratings
Public library has them all can even search all the libraries in town online to pull them all to one location to pick up later. Love it. They have almost every older comic run ive ever wanted to read
I must've read the comic like 2 or 3 times and just now realizing that bc Lori and (Judith) her newborn weren't shot in the head that they did in fact turn. Haunting.
Oh no I think it turned out worst then that with Judith actual somewhat surviving and lori turning into a zombie on top of her…. You could imagine what happened after that…gnarly shit
@@urbanlegendd6646I think, mercifully, Lori crushed Judith when she fell on top of her. A roughly 150 pound woman falling full force between Judith and the hard ground would likely not leave her alive.
"the source material is better then the adaptation"... what a brave statement that really has never been stated before, bravo! this is literally a rule of the universe 9/10.
I do like some overall elements better in the show, typically that has to do with actor performances or character arcs. Standout examples of Morgan, Carol, Daryl, Hershal, Glenn, etc. Nothing against their comic counterparts, I just find certain characters to have been enhanced by talented actors and plot changes. Though, typically, all of my praise dies away by the sixth season. The comics give a better feeling of mental decline and desperation for the characters. The grime (no pun intended) feels more pervasive, the physical decay of the old world, the human struggle, it's all focused better in the comic series. And all of the lows lend better towards the small glimpses of humanity and peace that are achieved by the survivors. All in all, it's the same classic story that happens with all the cool shit we like: The walking dead is a great series by a talented author that deserves more attention and a better adaption.
I think something cool you do with this series is focus in on a particular character and talk in depth about the differences from comic to show, like Andrea, or Caroll
Something I also never see mentioned about the walking dead is having a disabled main character, with how popular the tv show became im always disappointed they never had it happen in the show. The fact rick loses a hand and is like that for the whole comic is one of my favourite things.
I have a funny memory involving both versions of this series. I was in high school back when we were waiting for part B of season 5 of the show and one of my teachers made the Terminus sign for out in the hall around Halloween. We started talking about the series one day just us two, and I mentioned how the comic was so different because at the time I liked both. They enthusiastically asked me if they should read the comics since they liked the show. I immediately thought of the Governor Arc and said "I don't recommend it, it has SA and a lot more messed up stuff." and their reply was "O-oh...."
Going 16 episodes a season was too much, I'm not a huge comic book reader in general but The Walking Dead is amazing and the show is fun overall but the comics are superior on every level.
ok idk about every level, if there’s one thing i might prefer from the show, are some of the characters getting more attention, but if you don’t want to be disappointed read the book because that’ll at least have semi satisfying ending.
I have read the entire walking dead comic and it is much much better than the show. I was really disappointed about how much they changed the governor on the show.
What I love about the comics is how more realistic and darker they are than the show. It shows how terrible life as gotten and how it psychologically affected the characters. Michonne talks to her died boyfriend, Ricks group questioning his leadership, When the governor attacks the prison half of the people in Ricks group die. I also think the dialogue is far more superior and has a better impact for the reader.
Really liked your review Ryan! Have you ever watched David lynch's Twin peaks. if yes it would be nice if you can make a series analysis on the tv show
The Governor's arc is even more fucked up if you read the novels. Originally he was a big coward and a big fuck up, unlike his younger brother Philip. Philip did the same shit in the novels that the Governor did in the comics. Philip almost even killed him because he wasn't able to protect Penny and let her die. The Governor started to act like his brother because he convinced himself that the world needs you to act like Philip in order to survive. At the same time, The Governor fights his real persona hiding underneath the new one, often feeling sick to his stomach and crying while trying to maintain the Philip persona. Comic doesn't show that until the last issue where he really gets scared and let's the Brian (the Governor's real name) come out.
By the end it didn't feel unbelievable it felt bittersweet tbh which was the perfect ending anyone could ask for yeah it's sad and horrible but what the best part is everyone knows because of what their lives were back then and the people forced them to be. It didn't make them bad people a d frankly it's a cycle of life sadly now we all come back as the dead and have to rebuild
Please do the rest of the series! I remember reading this and attack on titan consistently when i was in high school and they were my favorites. So much better than the show and you’ll appreciate a lot of whats to come.
I love the show alot, i think they did alot of great things with the series. Up until S7 episode 1. Once that episode aired it started going downhill real quick. I love season 7s opening episode but everything after just. Idk i feel like they kinda gave up and started to milking the series for everything its worth. Which could have been fine if they were still going strong but they didnt. I think season 7 and 8 were good for binheing but for week to week it was aeful. Everything after there were only moments i liked a lot but the writing got so damn bad. The comics is definitely the only version of the show ill ever watch/read all the way thru ever again. I might watch the first 8 seasons with someone if they wanna blast through it but i aint continuing after that lol
I hope you continue to the end of the seires. The comic only gets better from there. It was such a great ride for the amazing telling. It's a shame how the tv series really pissed all over the source material
The comic is night and day better than the show, I would love a like for like animated adaptation the way Invincible on Prime did it, that would be perfect 👌 IN COLOUR THOUGH😅! As my only complaint about the comics, if I had to force one is that it was colourless, but that never ruined anything for me, it just would have been better in colour.
Keeping up with comics when they were still being written so was so fun theorizing of what will happen next issue. I always prefer the comic over the show. I stopped watching the show after season 8 and don’t plan to go back to watch it.
way better than the show, if the black and white turns you off you can read the newly released color comics, i believe they are on the 90th issue out of 193 so you can start reading em in color as they release
I disagree. The characters are definitely better in the show. They have more depth to them. Just look at Rick, Morgan, Shane, Carol, Tyrese, the governor, Negan, Abraham, Herschel, Gabriel. Their stories, epic moments, and character are just so much better and that’s because the show allows them to be better. The comics are scarier and more gritty, more raw, but I always felt the writing was dull. I did wish to see more comic Jesus in the show.
oh my if you have so much of a good story left to read i envy you! as someone who has been a lover of zombie fiction my entire life i can say the walking dead comic is one of the absolute high points of the medium, and well worth finishing if you liked it even remotely up to this point
while there are many things that are better than the show, i prefer the shows version of the characters such as shane and negan. i think negans/saviors introduction is wayyyy better in the show.
I remember being super excited to read the comics, I purchased the first 3 and I was super into it during the first book. Super excited for the second one, I was shocked to see the the change of art style. I just couldn't get into it, the art style was unimmersive for me.
Unpopular opinion maybe. I think there were things the show did better than the comics (like adding Daryl) but I think they butchered some characters in the show. But also made some characters better in the show (Carol). I enjoy both and liked some of the changes the show made but I also wish they followed some of the storylines in the comics
I am a huge fan of both but i mostly prefer the show. Yeah, they extended certain storylines out WAY too long but with a few exceptions like Andrea and Carl, the characters in the show were so much better and fleshed out. This is because of the greatest person in The Walking Dead show: the casting director. Even when the storylines or drama or dialogue were a bit clunky, every last performance in the show was top notch. The cast really gave it their all. I understand why people prefer the novels, i understand why people prefer the show. They both have pros and cons, and both of them have far more pros than cons. And as a fan of both, i really love that for people that watched the show first or read the novels first, you can enjoy the other one and really be on the edge of your seat the whole time because of how many differences there are with only the broad strokes being the same. Also, the soundtrack in the TV show is phenomenal and really enhances the story. So now when i am reading the novels (Yeah, baby, Deluxe collection!) I hear the songs and soundtrack in my head.
Read this as it was releasing almost every aspect is better then the show but that’s normally how it goes not enough budget or air time to really flesh out these Storys in a short run time
Hot take ig but if im being honest i liked the first two seasons of the show better then the first two chapters of the book, i think they end at around the same time
I started reading the comic during the farm season of the show(you know, nothing happened there, so...), the comic was extremely great and far superior to the show ALWAYS, BUT, the comic overextended its existence the same way the show did, it should have ended with All Out War(the "final battle" arc with Negan, I don't remember if thats the correct name, anyone feel free to correct me if i'm wrong), but it kept going... After that it was all downhill for me, everything felt so "unimportant" compared to Negan's "saga", like DBZ after the Cell Saga, imagine if Berserk keeps going after the Godhand are all dead... Oh and by the way, I stopped watching the show as soon as I started reading the comic
I 100% disagree about the sex. Most of it is gratuitous and Michonne is just treated like shit in the comic. Kirkman seems to have benefited from meeting actual women and minorities IRL during the show run because the comic becomes more believable after the prison arc. I hated all the random BJs and hookups. Where’s the actual time for that in the apocalypse?
When carol asked for a three some was the most cringe statement I've ever heard a twd character say, and her kissing both rick and lori was a bit weird, and not the good weird but the who'd actually write this kinda weird. And to think rick almost killing tyrese came from carol attempted suicide was just terrible and sloppy writing, and they say the tv show had terrible drama Twd comic is to edgy just because it has rape in it doesn't mean its deep and I was more convinced maggie got raped by the governor than michoone due to there different behaviors after the assault happened.
comics overall is better. many of its characters (like Tyreese, Andrea, Negan, Carl, Michonne, and Maggie) are better than their tv show counterparts. the zombies are more consistent. the story moves faster. there are less plotholes, and most deaths in the first half of the comic series are pretty cool and arent just for shock value. there are some stupid shit like the commonwealth and the whisperers. but its a comic book so its pretty excusable. like the show, the second half isnt nearly as good as the first. the show has better individual moments like the CDC, Hershel getting his leg chopped off, many scenes with The Governor, many Rick moments etc. and there are many characters in the show who is much cooler in the show than in the comics (Shane, Rick, Glenn, Carol, The Governor, Dwight, Hershel). some rewritten story lines are much better in the show like Terminus/The Hunters, Shane and Rick's conflict in the second half of season 2, the barn story line, etc. But the show is super inconsistent with its quality. season 1 was pretty solid. but the whole first half of season 2 was a complete poorly written, soap opera-y slog. season 3 was also pretty solid, despite some stupid and overly-comical scenes. season 4 would switch from being boring to being good again. first half of season 5 was good right up until Beth's death, and it picked right back up at the finale, which shouldve been the end of the show. season 6 was boring and the whole Glenn dumpster scene made me stop watching the show for an entire two months before picking it up again. the episode where everyone killed all the zombies in Alexandria is prob the only decent episodes, minus the scenes with Enid. and then the rest of the show is just another poorly written, plot-hole ridden, zombie soap operah. Negan is a terrible villain who isnt scary and just gets on my nerves. imo he doesnt rlly work as a villain at all and seems more like an anti hero. tho he needed to be dumbed down a bit and maybe even recasted. Steven Ogg wouldve prob made for a better Negan than JDM. SO the comics is overall pretty good, with one half consistently being awesome for a comic book and the second half being alright and a bit too long. the show's first half is pretty good. a bit of a mixed bag but its best moments are probably some of the best in all of TV. THE SECOND HALF is terrible. some of the worst writting and worst moments ive ever seen in TV and there isnt a single character i liked aside from maybe Morgan, Simon, Dwight, and sometimes Eugene (as the whole plan he made to help Rick defeat the saviors was pretty cool)
AMC 100% is at fault for the downfall of the series, if it wasn't for Frank Darabont's departure, the show would be way more enthralling, but because AMC wanted to play the undisputed king, the show fell off
Lol… a little late to the party on this huh? I enjoy the comics more overall but adaptations shouldn’t be scoffed at if you truly enjoy the world. Little or big tweaks here and there keep things fresh. As someone who was current with the comic the entire time the series was on air, I appreciated the differences. Knowing what to expect every second is boring
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
For anyone who hasn't read the comic, picture Daryl being beheaded in a sloppy and ugly fashion. That's how it felt seeing comic Tyreese's end.
The comics was better simply for the fact of the overall story and characters within it. I recently finished the comics and this video makes me want to read them again!
Yeah less drama, no idiotic decisions, mostly better characters, better ending, better action, no bad CGI and no budget cuts.😂
It's so insane that kirkmans rushed ending is better than the ending to the insanely popular show with so many writers 😂
@@Julian-uk6mj Quality vs Quantity
@@brianachim2670 yeah the episode requirement per season really fucked the show
@@Julian-uk6mji don’t think it was as much rushed as it was a late realization that this was the perfect time to end it. it can feel rushed sure but i think the ending was still good.
@@jico5147 oh I still love the ending of the comic
I love the comic. Andrea is hands down one of my favorite fictional characters of all time and I hate how the show ruined her. She was basically the Daryl of the comics.
Yeah but the same could be said with Carol in the comics so your point is a bit invalid, I dont like the comics because carol was a useless character who did nothing.
The same could be said with shane, morgan and hershel who are all massive down grades from the tv show counterparts.
Also daryl is better than andrea in the comic for me, so having andrea in the tv show just be like him causes daryl to be worse.
@@nani4249 the point of Carol’s character in the comics was showing how the mayhem and isolation of the apocalypse can drive someone crazy. And she ultimately took her own life because she couldn’t handle and evolve to the new world like everyone else. She was so isolated and lonely she suggested a polygamous marriage with Rick and Lori, only to get heartbroken and angry when Lori understandably didn’t want that. She character in the comics is meant to be a tragic figure instead of the terminator she was turned into in the show.
@@AlecEburhard exactly carol and andrea in both comic and TV show were meant to tell an entire different story from each other, not saying either is bad but just as 1 his worse than the other doesn't necessarily make it worse, and as they are different and have different level of importance in each story doesn't make any sense to criticise the tv show purely because its different from the comic
@@nani4249I like Daryl but many things that were done by Andrea, Abraham and Tyreese were given to him.
On top of that Its so stupid how they made Caron a menace on the show. Like come on 1 woman be coming a terminator?
The change to father Gabriel on the TV was more belivable than that of TV Carol.
@rumers100 daryl just replaced those characters anyways so it doesn't matter.
And you really can't say Abraham, tyreese and andrea in the comic are better than daryl.
But carol even though she was a strong survivor didn't display any super human feats so I can't see your problem with her development, plus she's more like rambo than terminator anyways
I’d absolutely love to see more comic reviews!
My mom and I loved these comics. Realizing 6 months have past and a new volume was about to be released, it was great
I think more The Walking Dead comic book reviews would be great.
Also what would be really cool is if once Invincible ends if that studio was able to animate The Walking Dead comic.
The only problem is if the live action series overstays it's welcome (which some may argue it already has.) People might become so tired of the series that even if the comic tells a better
story and there was an animated series that was a 1 to 1 adaptation people may just not care at that point.
Carl is my favorite character from the comics. He's ok in the tv show but an absolute bad ass in the comic.
Let’s be real, TV Carl ain’t no “monster” like Comic Carl was, and the live action has lowkey overstayed their series
Better by far. I've completely lost interest of the show when they threw Chandler Riggs under the bus.
I thought they did Tyreese SUPER dirty bro, I kinda just watched it out of inertia since then ... and then they made Negan ... actually boring. Terrible execution. The governor was good but ... too drawn out
"Humans are the real monster" - reddit
Adam and Eve
Please do the other compendiums. I read the negan arc before it came out and was soooo excited to see it on tv. Jeffrey dean morgan did a fantastic job showcasing the unhinged charisma of negan.
Every time I'm reminded of twd it just makes me wish it had a more accurate adaptation. Kirkman really is just a fantastic writer.
i really hope that someday there will be a 1:1 adaptation thats fully animated in the style of the comic. its such a shame to me that as books and reading has fallen out of style in favor of tv people have missed so many amazing stories so i hope more accurate book adaptations are made so more people can actually experience these stories without some soulless tv exec making cuts for better ratings
Public library has them all can even search all the libraries in town online to pull them all to one location to pick up later. Love it. They have almost every older comic run ive ever wanted to read
I must've read the comic like 2 or 3 times and just now realizing that bc Lori and (Judith) her newborn weren't shot in the head that they did in fact turn. Haunting.
Oh no I think it turned out worst then that with Judith actual somewhat surviving and lori turning into a zombie on top of her…. You could imagine what happened after that…gnarly shit
@@urbanlegendd6646I think, mercifully, Lori crushed Judith when she fell on top of her. A roughly 150 pound woman falling full force between Judith and the hard ground would likely not leave her alive.
"the source material is better then the adaptation"... what a brave statement that really has never been stated before, bravo!
this is literally a rule of the universe 9/10.
The Boys is an exception
@@zero_cali_4772 Even that isn't true, especially not after season 4.
I do like some overall elements better in the show, typically that has to do with actor performances or character arcs. Standout examples of Morgan, Carol, Daryl, Hershal, Glenn, etc. Nothing against their comic counterparts, I just find certain characters to have been enhanced by talented actors and plot changes.
Though, typically, all of my praise dies away by the sixth season. The comics give a better feeling of mental decline and desperation for the characters. The grime (no pun intended) feels more pervasive, the physical decay of the old world, the human struggle, it's all focused better in the comic series. And all of the lows lend better towards the small glimpses of humanity and peace that are achieved by the survivors.
All in all, it's the same classic story that happens with all the cool shit we like: The walking dead is a great series by a talented author that deserves more attention and a better adaption.
i think season 9 onwards kinda picks things up again
@@All_Star_Editzno.
@@ema4020 it does imo
@andrewvazquez1936 it isn’t that bad . I said in my opinion aswell
I think something cool you do with this series is focus in on a particular character and talk in depth about the differences from comic to show, like Andrea, or Caroll
Carol is the only character I think that was a genuine, serious upgrade. That, and I liked Michonne and Rick together.
I finished the comics a few months ago, it was great
So glad my boy Ryan is doing walking dead. Literally my favorite comic book
I also think the Telltale series of TWD was very very good as well 👍
Imo the first season of Telltale's game series is the best installment in the entire franchise.
Something I also never see mentioned about the walking dead is having a disabled main character, with how popular the tv show became im always disappointed they never had it happen in the show.
The fact rick loses a hand and is like that for the whole comic is one of my favourite things.
TWD without Rick would be like if Walter white suddenly disappearing in breaking bad.
The Deluxe comics are awesome. I loved seeing it again in color
Unexpected, but very good video ! Us WD fans could have told you that the comic is better since season 2 though haha
I have a funny memory involving both versions of this series. I was in high school back when we were waiting for part B of season 5 of the show and one of my teachers made the Terminus sign for out in the hall around Halloween. We started talking about the series one day just us two, and I mentioned how the comic was so different because at the time I liked both. They enthusiastically asked me if they should read the comics since they liked the show. I immediately thought of the Governor Arc and said "I don't recommend it, it has SA and a lot more messed up stuff." and their reply was "O-oh...."
I'll be the first to say it, I could care less about the comics. If you love them thats awesome but I prefer the show
Going 16 episodes a season was too much, I'm not a huge comic book reader in general but The Walking Dead is amazing and the show is fun overall but the comics are superior on every level.
ok idk about every level, if there’s one thing i might prefer from the show, are some of the characters getting more attention, but if you don’t want to be disappointed read the book because that’ll at least have semi satisfying ending.
there's a lot the show does better
16 was fine, it was wasting half the season on random bs that wasn't in the comic was the problem/gimple.
Please, keep reviewing this series! It's one of my old favorites and I would love to hear your further opinions on it.
Ryan if your doing western comics you gotta do cover The Crow comic. you won’t regret it!
I have read the entire walking dead comic and it is much much better than the show. I was really disappointed about how much they changed the governor on the show.
Very true. I read the whole thing so far and I loved it. RICK IS THE MAN
Lori and Dale were sooo much better in the comic.
So what, carol, morgan and Shane were, the argument that an individual character is better in the other source material means nothing.
They just need animated that follows the complete comic book or a complete reboot
What I love about the comics is how more realistic and darker they are than the show. It shows how terrible life as gotten and how it psychologically affected the characters. Michonne talks to her died boyfriend, Ricks group questioning his leadership, When the governor attacks the prison half of the people in Ricks group die. I also think the dialogue is far more superior and has a better impact for the reader.
Wait until you get to the end, it blows that abomination of a tv show out of the water. They did Carl dirty.
eh i mean the show did some of it better than the comics
Yes please absolutely finish reviewing the comics!
Really liked your review Ryan! Have you ever watched David lynch's Twin peaks. if yes it would be nice if you can make a series analysis on the tv show
The Governor's arc is even more fucked up if you read the novels. Originally he was a big coward and a big fuck up, unlike his younger brother Philip. Philip did the same shit in the novels that the Governor did in the comics. Philip almost even killed him because he wasn't able to protect Penny and let her die.
The Governor started to act like his brother because he convinced himself that the world needs you to act like Philip in order to survive. At the same time, The Governor fights his real persona hiding underneath the new one, often feeling sick to his stomach and crying while trying to maintain the Philip persona. Comic doesn't show that until the last issue where he really gets scared and let's the Brian (the Governor's real name) come out.
You should totally cover invincible too! I love the way you covered the walking dead comics in this video
I literally just finished watching your video on rick grimes and his final episode and now I see a review of the comics, awesome!
I’ve been debating over getting the comics or watching the show, but 11 seasons of a 43 min episode tv show is like catching up to One Piece for me
Also you could do in the future a twd comic issue cover tier list. So many good covers exists in this series man.
Like they always say, The Manga is better than the Anime
Yes, please give us more reviews of the walking dead comic when you're done 👍🏾
Fun fact: the season 1 opening is a reenactment of when it snows in Georgia
They should definitely do a animated series based on the source material. And have a black and white adaptation
That would be so cool
For a second I thought you were going to rip into the show and I was impressed you had managed to keep it under 13 mins.
One thing you should do is lissten to funeral march while reading it makes it feel more depressing
Oh yea definitely review the rest of the series, really enjoyed this video!!
I watched the show first then read the comic after. I was shocked how crazy the governor arc was.
By the end it didn't feel unbelievable it felt bittersweet tbh which was the perfect ending anyone could ask for yeah it's sad and horrible but what the best part is everyone knows because of what their lives were back then and the people forced them to be. It didn't make them bad people a d frankly it's a cycle of life sadly now we all come back as the dead and have to rebuild
The only thing I prefer from the TV show is that Shane and Rick are more fleshed out and then it's not as fast as the first like 10 or so volumes
Please do the rest of the series! I remember reading this and attack on titan consistently when i was in high school and they were my favorites. So much better than the show and you’ll appreciate a lot of whats to come.
I love the show alot, i think they did alot of great things with the series. Up until S7 episode 1. Once that episode aired it started going downhill real quick. I love season 7s opening episode but everything after just. Idk i feel like they kinda gave up and started to milking the series for everything its worth. Which could have been fine if they were still going strong but they didnt. I think season 7 and 8 were good for binheing but for week to week it was aeful. Everything after there were only moments i liked a lot but the writing got so damn bad. The comics is definitely the only version of the show ill ever watch/read all the way thru ever again. I might watch the first 8 seasons with someone if they wanna blast through it but i aint continuing after that lol
Never read the comic or seen the show, though I’ll always remember the hype behind the show. I would see endless ads for the episodes here.
More TWD Comic reviews please! Plan on reading them soon...
I have to 1st compendium & even re-read it after the TV show ended. Still need to obtain the other compendiums as well.
In the comic it takes place in Kentucky
This video compels me to buy the comics.
I'd love to see more folks reviewing The Walking Dead comics
I’m down for more reviews of these
I hope you continue to the end of the seires. The comic only gets better from there. It was such a great ride for the amazing telling. It's a shame how the tv series really pissed all over the source material
The comic is night and day better than the show, I would love a like for like animated adaptation the way Invincible on Prime did it, that would be perfect 👌 IN COLOUR THOUGH😅! As my only complaint about the comics, if I had to force one is that it was colourless, but that never ruined anything for me, it just would have been better in colour.
they’ve been re-releasing them in color!!! you can read em online 😁
@@logan_pa5h that's awesome! What website?
Keeping up with comics when they were still being written so was so fun theorizing of what will happen next issue. I always prefer the comic over the show. I stopped watching the show after season 8 and don’t plan to go back to watch it.
Hmm i didn't know there was a comic book
way better than the show, if the black and white turns you off you can read the newly released color comics, i believe they are on the 90th issue out of 193 so you can start reading em in color as they release
I disagree. The characters are definitely better in the show. They have more depth to them. Just look at Rick, Morgan, Shane, Carol, Tyrese, the governor, Negan, Abraham, Herschel, Gabriel. Their stories, epic moments, and character are just so much better and that’s because the show allows them to be better. The comics are scarier and more gritty, more raw, but I always felt the writing was dull. I did wish to see more comic Jesus in the show.
This video was recommended to me by RUclips along with other compelling videos like "10 Reasons why Water is Wet"
Need more comic book reviews from Ryan
oh my if you have so much of a good story left to read i envy you! as someone who has been a lover of zombie fiction my entire life i can say the walking dead comic is one of the absolute high points of the medium, and well worth finishing if you liked it even remotely up to this point
Heck yeah Ryan more comic reviews on TWD please :)
More reviews please! 🙏
Will this review series be a berserk style analysis series??
while there are many things that are better than the show, i prefer the shows version of the characters such as shane and negan. i think negans/saviors introduction is wayyyy better in the show.
I remember being super excited to read the comics, I purchased the first 3 and I was super into it during the first book. Super excited for the second one, I was shocked to see the the change of art style. I just couldn't get into it, the art style was unimmersive for me.
I had no idea this guy wrote Invincible
This was great thanks! I’m here for more
The killing joke is the dumbest Batman movie ever, they literally made Batgirl a sex device for the plot and immediately paralyzed her after
Unpopular opinion maybe. I think there were things the show did better than the comics (like adding Daryl) but I think they butchered some characters in the show. But also made some characters better in the show (Carol). I enjoy both and liked some of the changes the show made but I also wish they followed some of the storylines in the comics
Idk, the show still clears for me. Better characters, better dynamics, less unnecessary edginess, and better decisions.
I am a huge fan of both but i mostly prefer the show. Yeah, they extended certain storylines out WAY too long but with a few exceptions like Andrea and Carl, the characters in the show were so much better and fleshed out. This is because of the greatest person in The Walking Dead show: the casting director. Even when the storylines or drama or dialogue were a bit clunky, every last performance in the show was top notch. The cast really gave it their all. I understand why people prefer the novels, i understand why people prefer the show. They both have pros and cons, and both of them have far more pros than cons. And as a fan of both, i really love that for people that watched the show first or read the novels first, you can enjoy the other one and really be on the edge of your seat the whole time because of how many differences there are with only the broad strokes being the same. Also, the soundtrack in the TV show is phenomenal and really enhances the story. So now when i am reading the novels (Yeah, baby, Deluxe collection!) I hear the songs and soundtrack in my head.
Read this as it was releasing almost every aspect is better then the show but that’s normally how it goes not enough budget or air time to really flesh out these Storys in a short run time
Id love to see u review the rest of them please🤓
First couple.of seasons were so goated man
Hot take ig but if im being honest i liked the first two seasons of the show better then the first two chapters of the book, i think they end at around the same time
It had the same issue as the show of after Negan, it really drug on.
I started reading the comic during the farm season of the show(you know, nothing happened there, so...), the comic was extremely great and far superior to the show ALWAYS, BUT, the comic overextended its existence the same way the show did, it should have ended with All Out War(the "final battle" arc with Negan, I don't remember if thats the correct name, anyone feel free to correct me if i'm wrong), but it kept going... After that it was all downhill for me, everything felt so "unimportant" compared to Negan's "saga", like DBZ after the Cell Saga, imagine if Berserk keeps going after the Godhand are all dead... Oh and by the way, I stopped watching the show as soon as I started reading the comic
You might have convinced me to give it a read
It would have been better if you'd used the colored version of the comic.
I started reading it right at the begging but never finished. I think the tv show killed the hype for me...Maybe I should finish it now.
I 100% disagree about the sex. Most of it is gratuitous and Michonne is just treated like shit in the comic. Kirkman seems to have benefited from meeting actual women and minorities IRL during the show run because the comic becomes more believable after the prison arc. I hated all the random BJs and hookups. Where’s the actual time for that in the apocalypse?
When carol asked for a three some was the most cringe statement I've ever heard a twd character say, and her kissing both rick and lori was a bit weird, and not the good weird but the who'd actually write this kinda weird. And to think rick almost killing tyrese came from carol attempted suicide was just terrible and sloppy writing, and they say the tv show had terrible drama
Twd comic is to edgy just because it has rape in it doesn't mean its deep and I was more convinced maggie got raped by the governor than michoone due to there different behaviors after the assault happened.
Oh boy, the govenor isnt even the worst one in the comics
Are you reading the comic online or physically?
comics overall is better. many of its characters (like Tyreese, Andrea, Negan, Carl, Michonne, and Maggie) are better than their tv show counterparts. the zombies are more consistent. the story moves faster. there are less plotholes, and most deaths in the first half of the comic series are pretty cool and arent just for shock value. there are some stupid shit like the commonwealth and the whisperers. but its a comic book so its pretty excusable. like the show, the second half isnt nearly as good as the first.
the show has better individual moments like the CDC, Hershel getting his leg chopped off, many scenes with The Governor, many Rick moments etc. and there are many characters in the show who is much cooler in the show than in the comics (Shane, Rick, Glenn, Carol, The Governor, Dwight, Hershel). some rewritten story lines are much better in the show like Terminus/The Hunters, Shane and Rick's conflict in the second half of season 2, the barn story line, etc. But the show is super inconsistent with its quality. season 1 was pretty solid. but the whole first half of season 2 was a complete poorly written, soap opera-y slog. season 3 was also pretty solid, despite some stupid and overly-comical scenes. season 4 would switch from being boring to being good again. first half of season 5 was good right up until Beth's death, and it picked right back up at the finale, which shouldve been the end of the show. season 6 was boring and the whole Glenn dumpster scene made me stop watching the show for an entire two months before picking it up again. the episode where everyone killed all the zombies in Alexandria is prob the only decent episodes, minus the scenes with Enid. and then the rest of the show is just another poorly written, plot-hole ridden, zombie soap operah. Negan is a terrible villain who isnt scary and just gets on my nerves. imo he doesnt rlly work as a villain at all and seems more like an anti hero. tho he needed to be dumbed down a bit and maybe even recasted. Steven Ogg wouldve prob made for a better Negan than JDM.
SO the comics is overall pretty good, with one half consistently being awesome for a comic book and the second half being alright and a bit too long.
the show's first half is pretty good. a bit of a mixed bag but its best moments are probably some of the best in all of TV. THE SECOND HALF is terrible. some of the worst writting and worst moments ive ever seen in TV and there isnt a single character i liked aside from maybe Morgan, Simon, Dwight, and sometimes Eugene (as the whole plan he made to help Rick defeat the saviors was pretty cool)
It's really not. There are strong points to both. People give an insane amount of unearned hate to the show.
Plz do more reviews!
AMC 100% is at fault for the downfall of the series, if it wasn't for Frank Darabont's departure, the show would be way more enthralling, but because AMC wanted to play the undisputed king, the show fell off
Yes, more please and thank you.
Bro mew berserk is out go get it!
I remember reading the first volume at the library years ago. Seems worth checking out again
Of course is not better what is wrong with all the people i like the stories from the characters that were not from the comic specially Daryl
Lol… a little late to the party on this huh? I enjoy the comics more overall but adaptations shouldn’t be scoffed at if you truly enjoy the world. Little or big tweaks here and there keep things fresh. As someone who was current with the comic the entire time the series was on air, I appreciated the differences. Knowing what to expect every second is boring