Was Melinoe... an accident? - Hades

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024
  • Sorry about the weird noises, don't know what's causing it

Комментарии • 91

  • @impureEnigma
    @impureEnigma 7 месяцев назад +1523

    Now that Early Access is here, Hades says himself that they decided to have Melinoё after a while

    • @joaobarcessat_
      @joaobarcessat_  7 месяцев назад +237

      Just ran into him and got that dialogue. So nice to see how they care for such a harmless piece of dialogue from one game ago.

    • @ovencake523
      @ovencake523 7 месяцев назад +10

      can you do a read more to spoiler protect it?

  • @hmalba7864
    @hmalba7864 7 месяцев назад +1767

    Zagreus: Please don't have any more children, there's no telling the kind of chaos that would unfold if that happened (also I'd get less attention from you and dad)
    Zagreus, 5 seconds after Melione is born: I have known my sister for only a moment, but if anything happens to her I will drag every soul in Hades down to Erebus and then myself

    • @ramael3299
      @ramael3299 7 месяцев назад +284

      Also the irony of Melinoe being a very disciplined, prim and proper child (I guess basically being a child soldier does that to you), while he himself is more like a chaos goblin in comparison despite being the elder sibling lol

    • @leandraleo281
      @leandraleo281 7 месяцев назад +77

      Growing up at home vs growing up in a war i guess​@ramael3299

    • @aaronjohnston2751
      @aaronjohnston2751 7 месяцев назад +51

      Or the difference between growing up in a disfunctional/abusive household and a much more compassionate household.

    • @poxelus
      @poxelus 7 месяцев назад +56

      ​@@ramael3299 it's funny, how he might technically not even be an elder sibling anymore, since he was stuck in the time stasis for the entirety of Melinoe's life, which might already have a similar length.

    • @ramael3299
      @ramael3299 7 месяцев назад +49

      @@poxelus I guess it is a possibility since we don't have confirmed ages or anything, but from the context I think it's unlikely.
      So far it's framed as we took control of Melinoe shortly after she became old enough to begin her missions/became a young adult. For all we know she's exactly the age she looks (unlike many gods) which is probably younger than 20?
      On the other hand in the first game it was implied Zagreus has been around for at least a while. For a long time be believed Nyx was his actual mother. He had 2 failed relationships (with Maegara and Thanatos) and looking at how he's worried in the poly romance route about hurting them before telling them about each other, we can assume the previous relationships weren't simultaneous and I'd assume it would span at least a decent amount of time since they are gods and take a lot of things slow, also add to that Than and Meg are working a lot...etc.
      He also had a long standing reputarion as a troublemaker and everyone in the house seemed to know his antics like the back of their hand.
      Based on all that and some other stuff I'm too lazy to type out, I've always assumed Zag was older than he looked based on human years. If not centuries, than at least somewhere between 40 to 60? I'm saying human years because there is no denying he acts like an adolescent but since they are gods time and development might not be the same for them.

  • @kakishisfriend1126
    @kakishisfriend1126 Год назад +953

    Just realized her hair is in the shape of a cornucopia

    • @nathanroberts3638
      @nathanroberts3638 Год назад +16

      Huh, TIL

    • @theEskit
      @theEskit 7 месяцев назад +9

      Cool fact thanks

    • @bellingtoned
      @bellingtoned 6 месяцев назад +1

      ... Huh that kinda makes sense now that i think about it

    • @llamachai
      @llamachai 6 месяцев назад

      😂

  • @NRV0
    @NRV0 7 месяцев назад +247

    Persephone: "Hahaha, no. You're plenty.......But"

  • @saxonjf
    @saxonjf Год назад +574

    I'm guessing that Hades II is set twenty years in the future, giving Hades and Persephone to either change their mind or have an "unexpected." Part of the issue was they couldn't ask for help because the whole thing had to be a secret. Perhaps Apollo or Asclepius (Apollo's son and god of medicine) could be called in to ensure Melinoe wasn't stillborn.

    • @FantasyGameLover
      @FantasyGameLover Год назад +38

      Or more, they're gods after all.

    • @janecowie3626
      @janecowie3626 7 месяцев назад +44

      @@FantasyGameLover very late reply but there is dialog in hades 1 that imply hades thinks 100 years is a very short amount of time

    • @korsekil
      @korsekil 7 месяцев назад +38

      @@janecowie3626 Yeaaah, exactly. None of them are living mortals, the time frame could be between twenty years to centuries.

    • @thebaseandtriflingcreature174
      @thebaseandtriflingcreature174 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@janecowie3626 yes, when he berates Orpheus for not singing, and gives him a time limit of "only one hundred more years" to make up his mind about this.

  • @tut28Angel
    @tut28Angel 7 месяцев назад +340

    In my headcanon Zeg wanted a sibling. But after learning of how his birth affected his mom he never told anyone. But when he found out the news he was maybe the happiest person to know.

    • @ttterg6152
      @ttterg6152 7 месяцев назад +10

      But Persephone was affected by the thought of Zag being dead? Am I missing lore about this? Can you please explain me?

    • @Memelord-md5hs
      @Memelord-md5hs 7 месяцев назад +40

      ​@@ttterg6152exactly she became deeply depressed because she thought Zag was dead on birth
      The commenter said that zag probably did want one but most likely didn't want to say so because his own birth was so negative for persephone she just left and winter took over the mortal world

    • @GuiSmith
      @GuiSmith 6 месяцев назад +3

      @@ttterg6152Persephone left the underworld almost entirely because of how dejected and depressed she was when Hades couldn’t offer her solace after Zagreus was originally stillborn.

  • @silverblade357
    @silverblade357 7 месяцев назад +69

    Persephone: "Zagreus has matured so much. You two aren't even curt with one another anymore."
    Hades: "...We should have another troublemaker, er, I mean child."

  • @paulagiselparma7125
    @paulagiselparma7125 7 месяцев назад +162

    well they are inmortal beings.... eternity can make them change their mind xD

    • @strvmpet
      @strvmpet 6 месяцев назад

      no because melinoe being an accident is so funny actually

  • @hydra7427
    @hydra7427 7 месяцев назад +87

    With enough mood music, anything is possible.

    • @sheassea9320
      @sheassea9320 7 месяцев назад +11

      You’re right, Darren Korb does make the best tunes

    • @rene9175
      @rene9175 7 месяцев назад +9

      Orpheus was probably in the corner of the room when it happened.

    • @desadograisedrobot515
      @desadograisedrobot515 7 месяцев назад +6

      Zagreus: Eurydice, Orpheus. Father will give Orpheus a whole 10 short years vacation to any level of Tartarus if you play great romance music.
      Orpheus: ten years seem... Too long.
      Zagreus: It is?
      Eurydice: We'll take the deal!

    • @rizkyanandita8227
      @rizkyanandita8227 7 месяцев назад +2

      With the exception of Hypnos and Nyx, unless I forgotten the detail, everyone is screwing someone in that house. If the war on the surface is over, the workload gett lighter and they have time to enjoy themself.

    • @rene9175
      @rene9175 7 месяцев назад +3

      @rizkyanandita8227 There is a short spat between Zag and Nyx when Ares wants to get to know her better, if I remember correctly.
      So yeah, just Hypnos. And maybe Dusa.

  • @Aurora-313
    @Aurora-313 7 месяцев назад +47

    After playing early access, I'm glad to know that they'd patched things up to have a second child.

    • @mesaOptimizer
      @mesaOptimizer 7 месяцев назад +4

      Well in the myth both Zagreus and Melinoe are Persephone’s children by Zeus in the form of Hades. So… yeah

  • @notphotogenic4552
    @notphotogenic4552 Год назад +112

    * proceeds to have Melinoë and Makaria *

    • @antonissa8345
      @antonissa8345 6 месяцев назад +10

      I'm really hoping that we get a Hades 3 where we get to play as Macaria

    • @korrenthereaper4357
      @korrenthereaper4357 5 месяцев назад +1

      Hades 2 JUST came out! Calm your soggy tits.

  • @Shiruvan
    @Shiruvan 7 месяцев назад +33

    oh thank you for mentioning about the weird noises, my pc is working strange on modern youtube/chrome whatever, and its been that way to a lot of Hades 1 videos, I thought my graphic card is actually dying this time, but nope~

  • @grimshock6983
    @grimshock6983 6 месяцев назад +14

    He actually has two sisters. I think Zagreus is supposed to be the last child. Melinoe is first born in mythos

  • @MsWatismyname
    @MsWatismyname Год назад +14

    Possible, or it was some time ago she said that and they changed their mind.

  • @toshio1334
    @toshio1334 6 месяцев назад +5

    Isn't there also supposed to be a 3rd child?

  • @hartantoanggoro
    @hartantoanggoro 7 месяцев назад +4

    It's just pretty little accident

    • @caad5258
      @caad5258 7 месяцев назад +1

      Now I know why I vibe with Melinoe...

  • @SomaHososhi
    @SomaHososhi Год назад +40

    Little late on this. But irl, Melinoe isnt the daughter of Hades and Persephone. Rather that Zeus took the form of Hades and seduced Persephone "mixt with Zeus Kronion (Cronion), arose, near where Kokytos' (Cocytus') mournful river flows; when, under Plouton's (Pluton's) [Haides'] semblance, Zeus divine deceived with guileful arts dark Phersephone (Persephone)." This is why Melinoe is depicted as being half white and dark, taking both Cthonic and Olympic blood.

    • @joaobarcessat_
      @joaobarcessat_  Год назад +63

      In old mythology that is, devs do whatever they want with their story.
      Nice to know though.

    • @SomaHososhi
      @SomaHososhi Год назад +4

      @@joaobarcessat_ Oh sorry i thought I put that they could make their own lore for the game, similar to Zag.

    • @thijmendol8248
      @thijmendol8248 Год назад +22

      Yeah Melinoë will probably not be the actual character from the mythology, just like Zagreus. That being said, they do nod to Zagreus' original myth where he is born and then turned into dyonysus (long story lol), so they might do something similar with Melinoë.

    • @mythicalplague1014
      @mythicalplague1014 Год назад +10

      Here’s the thing though is that the orphics who made the hymm are the same people who believe that Zeus and Hades are the same person and hades is just a form of zeus.

    • @Gr3nadgr3gory
      @Gr3nadgr3gory 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@mythicalplague1014that's ridiculous knowing how different the two act.

  • @allfiction8905
    @allfiction8905 6 месяцев назад +2

    Oh she lie!

  • @bokarndiaye323
    @bokarndiaye323 7 месяцев назад +9

    Ahem... probably somewhat... worse than an accident. In the Orphic Hymn to Melinoe, Zeus takes the appearance of Hades to deceive Persephone and fathers her. It's possible that we get a retcon of that, just the same way as Demeter being Hades' sister or Zagreus being a name of Dionysus are retconned in Hades 1... but yeahhh, seeing how Melinoe lasts longer on the surface than her brother and father, it's possible her ancestry is different

    • @Selnathorn
      @Selnathorn 7 месяцев назад +2

      Or maybe she is just more like her mother, simple is that

    • @josephreynolds2401
      @josephreynolds2401 7 месяцев назад +3

      It's possible her connection with the moon would allow her some more access to those places. I gathered that "witch" was related to the moon/goddess. It would make sense for Melinoe to walk under it, if only at night.

    • @Illier1
      @Illier1 6 месяцев назад +3

      Pretty sure the only reason Zagreus is the way he is is because technically he's undead. Nyx's Magic brought him back but now hes bound to the place.
      Mel was born and was likely kept alive by the Fates themselves as she was a child of prophecy meant to kill Chronos.

    • @garretcorain6882
      @garretcorain6882 6 месяцев назад +5

      A lot of people who study those texts think that the hymn is referring to Hades. Apparently, the translation calls him dark Zeus and in other instances Hades is called Zeus of the underworld. At the time, saying Hades' name, or any cthonic god's name, was taboo. It supposedly would draw their attention, and having a god of the underworld paying attention to you was not considered a good thing.

    • @bokarndiaye323
      @bokarndiaye323 6 месяцев назад +1

      @@garretcorain6882 100% credible from a scholarly standpoint - the Romans kind of did the same with Dis Pater, their name for Pluto. Dis shares a root with the greek Dios/Zeus, which is also a way to refer to him as the Lord Below. (Funnily enough, Dis ends up becoming the name for the Underworld, in the same way as Hades designates both the greek god and his domain)

  • @wallaceneto3159
    @wallaceneto3159 6 месяцев назад +1

    Aren't we all...?

  • @victorvoe8008
    @victorvoe8008 6 месяцев назад +1

    Yeah but infact. If u would read all through the mythology u can't find out but realise that Melinoe was the FIRST child of Persephone and Hades. But Moiras predicted that the child must be the son.. not the daughter of Underworld. That should show u the way that Zagreus is just one of the looks that Melinoe can turn into cause she can transfigure her body in the way that she wants. And as I remember Hades always wanted his son to be the First child but Melinoe happened. In mythology Zagreus just doesn't exist.. All that was is Melinoe herself transforming in the person that would please her Father beliefs. Hades and Persephone had no sons.. only daugthers.. Melinoe and Macaria who died cause of Heracles. Such a shame

  • @doctorshark509
    @doctorshark509 7 месяцев назад +1

    Well, if I remember correctly some myths say that Mel is the child of Zeus and Persephone. Not even considering how messed up that is the chances of the creators choosing to make that canon is almost nonexistent.

    • @PaulonTheBrave
      @PaulonTheBrave 7 месяцев назад

      Well considering that myths usually depict Hades as abducting Persephone its not too much of an extreme, considering Persephone is still Hades niece in most myths when he aducts her....

    • @doctorshark509
      @doctorshark509 7 месяцев назад +5

      @@PaulonTheBrave In Hades's defense, that was just how things worked back then. Honestly kidnapping was the height of good manners if you wanted to marry someone outside of your..... everything really. Also technically the kidnapping was Zeus's idea.

    • @Vazar
      @Vazar 7 месяцев назад

      Zagreus too

    • @ultimate9056
      @ultimate9056 7 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@PaulonTheBraveHades tried to go through the standard cultural procedure at the time by asking the father (Zeus) for his daughters hand at which he was told that if he wants to mary Persephone he should just whisk her off her feet and make her his own. Hades then proceeded to follow the blessing of his love's father and treated Persephone better then arguably any other greek god has treated their spouse, especially wives. It doesn’t pass by todays standards but in the cultural context and in comparison to other greek gods Hades is the greatest gentleman among them and his relationship with Persephone is easily the healthiest

    • @josephreynolds2401
      @josephreynolds2401 7 месяцев назад

      ​​@@ultimate9056 In the Hades Canon, Demeter probably exaggerated tales of Persephone's abduction to every mortal she feasibly could, tbf, which wouldn't be out of character for her in the ancient mythos.
      Of course, the ancient mythos is full of inconsistencies and alternate retellings. I quite like retellings that take creative license.

  • @azuredragon8388
    @azuredragon8388 7 месяцев назад +4

    Do not spoil it for me but i have strong feeling she was just straight up lying to Zag.

  • @dokuganryyu
    @dokuganryyu 6 месяцев назад

    3 Doritos later...

  • @Quarzt-0
    @Quarzt-0 6 месяцев назад +1

    Isnt Demeter Melione's mother? Sorry im confused everyone makes out with everyone 😭

    • @User1273-
      @User1273- 6 месяцев назад

      Demeter is Persephone mother ( father is unknown in hades the game). Melinoe is daughter of hades and Persephone (Zagreus sister)

  • @ElBandito
    @ElBandito 7 месяцев назад +6

    In Greek tales, Zeus masqueraded as Hades and boned Persephone, and thus Melinoe was born.

    • @Handepsilon
      @Handepsilon 7 месяцев назад +1

      Oh no, not again 😂

    • @Daydream_N
      @Daydream_N 7 месяцев назад

      Same With Zag

    • @caad5258
      @caad5258 7 месяцев назад +2

      GODDAMN IT ZEUS!
      Hera needs to commission a chastity cage from Hephaestus.

  • @biancabentes7565
    @biancabentes7565 Год назад +5

    Muito foda

  • @kinghermit6392
    @kinghermit6392 Год назад +15

    maybe melinoe is the older sibling? who knows

    • @joaobarcessat_
      @joaobarcessat_  Год назад +35

      Very unlikely, Persephone left the underwolrd only because she thought Zag was dead, I don't think she would've done the same thing if they had another child to care for

    • @jasonandrews1770
      @jasonandrews1770 Год назад +22

      Shes been called the younger sister. Its confirmed

  • @izzy1356
    @izzy1356 7 месяцев назад +14

    Zag: "You're not thinking about having more children, are you?"
    Persephone: *𝘚𝘰 𝘐 𝘴𝘢𝘪𝘥* "Hahaha, no, you're plenty!" *𝘠𝘰𝘶 𝘬𝘯𝘰𝘸, 𝘭𝘪𝘬𝘦 𝘢 𝘭𝘪𝘢𝘳*