Allah is fair. He will reward the child either in this life (by making him empathetic and merciful to others) or in the other life. But all kids are innocent in Allah's eyes. Also, that "someone" would be punished the same way, either in this life or in the next.
@@comicahmet the fact the child is innocent in the first place, makes the reward for the kid great and the punishment for the person abusing the kid, even worse
2 года назад+3
I dont see as Allah testing someone. People have their own free will. Allah simply leaves the punishment for the day of judgement. Whether they were done dirty or lived a long life, Allah will count their deeds and be fair.
@@marienovak3663 Please don't digress from the question being asked. I am not speaking of elephants and puppies. What just God would allow a three year old child to be raped? Babies to die of hunger? To be maimed, wounded and crippled? Is this just God testing the faith of innocent children and babies then in such a horrific manner? Don't have an answer, do you?
I understand your pain. As a child who has suffered, these Muslims are beyond disrespectful to the fallen. Allah has no right making these children suffer for things like this. Please hold on, I wish you the best in life. Don't listen to idiotic Muslims and take yourself.
I am Muslim but I don't under stand why God created the base of evil,badness ,and pains even for innocents.Gods wants us to do only good deeds but God itself does good and bad both by creating goodness and evil the both.why can any body explain.
God had already created beings that only do good and there's no disobedience or free will. Those are the Angels. But God decided to create beings that do have the right to make a choice between good and bad.. what's better? The one who does good because they are physically incapable of doing bad or the one who does good when they can choose to do bad?
Still makes absolutely no sense to me I'll tell you why. Firstly he allows an evil act on innocent so the innocent suffers unjustly then he punish the doer for the same act and he suffers according....... Fine. But the better thing would be the stop the act intervene in the act so the evil is stoped there only and no one suffers and the evil doer understands it clearly that he will be punished henceforth .is this not a better option
The point is to remind you that everyone has been given free will. Do as you please - this life is a test and once you commit a sin you will be punished for it.
It's not about your opinion of what is better or worse. Allah has revealed to us the purpose in death and life, to test those who are best in deeds (in accordance to his laws) The Islamic premise for this life is that it's a test. Evil is also part of that test but evil will not reign forever, because this life is temporary. We have to use our free will and intelect to accept what God has revealed and act in accordance with it, or reject it and doom yourself with a purposeless life. If the answers for the test was provided with the questions, what's the point of the test?
Cuz this earth isnt heaven or hell... Hell = bad thing only Heaven = good thing only Earth = the good and the bad ! Theres Islamic POV video from Purpose Of Life Jeffrey Lang about pain, suffering etc. Why Allah allows human to experience it. I give you a glimpse of it, imagine you are an athlete, you need hardcore exercises and its makes your body suffering and in pain but its make your body strong, they say "no pain no gain" Now in this, we are not growing physically but spiritually ! Imagine in this world has no suffering, is possible people can be compassion in environment with no suffering ? Can a computer be called compassion for it programmed to produce medicine ? Can computer called being honest that programmed not to make incorrect statement ? And btw, human or other allah's creation that cause us to suffer not allah, He just allow it.. Imagine.. a deer and a lion, which one do you prefer to die ?
Each person who does evil and causes suffering of another soul, will pay in the day of judgement. Allah knows everyone’s intentions and actions. Allah does not forget anything. Allah knows who is evil and who is good, and Allah will give each person what he deserves
In physical world its not possible that a Soul will not suffer, everyone are made up of flesh and can be damaged by accident or disease . Use your brains Atheists ....
I am facing lots of problems. I am facing frustrations I am facing ill treatments I am facing pains I am facing worries I am facing damages I am facing losses WHY I am facing such types of nasty things in life when I have a good heart and good thoughts and good feelings and good habits? Why it happens? I earn legally I speak the truth I am honest I am kind I am truthful I am honest My attitude towards others are positive. I don't think or do anything bad for others but why day to day I am failing into trouble, falling into frustrations, falling into difficulties and problems? I can't understand why. Is this a punishment for me from Allah? Have I done anything wrong? Have I done anything that made Allah to anger? I, myself can't understand this. I am getting damages , losses in que I am facing problems in que I am undergoing severe problems in life. 😟😪
Please don't linger to this thought and feeling to make u more depressed. The peace is from Alla，the solution is from Alla，everything will come to end and we will return to Alla. Alla loves u，keep doing right thing，I hope Alla give u ease and give up right understanding
Assalam Brother, you are not the only Person to have problems.Subhanallah I am tested so much as well but I am patient & still praying,make dua to Allah.This dunia is not easy InshaAllah Allah will give us blessings & reward us with Jannah.I am a single mum with 2 kids,there is no One else in my life,no family/friends 😢 I had to leave the man I loved very much last year,we were planning to get married,he was also my best friend but he tried to kill all of us using jinns
I am also suffering from 18 years but now before I was not praying now I started salat nafl tahajud azkar and reading Quran alhamdullilah it gave me peace in my heart I have also gone through health issue 3 health issues through marriage problems even I have no friends and my country is in war our income is not good we have to pay taxes I didn’tget what I loved I have more problems but I can’t share but Alhamdullilah I am happy because I have find complaining 3riples the problems
They also have their say on the day of judgement. A woman was condemned to hell for abusing and killing a cat. Another was forgiven completely from a life of sin, because she gave water to a thirsty dog.
@@lightinthedark9201 Allah has written everything that will happen, also taking into consideration our free will, the course of existence has already been decided, whatever choice you made of free will, was predestined before your birth, Allah is truly the greatest, it takes time for all of us to understand. Inshallah Allah will make everything clearer to us
2 года назад+1
@@EeLyos The way i see it we make our own actions. Allah has written everything before hand because he can see the future and how it all ends but that doesnt mean Allah chooses what we do on every action we make. Allah is simply all knowing
What a pathetic joke. You explained absolutely nothing. You proved the point that Allah is not just. And just because we don't believe the world will ever be just doesn't mean we don't believe in right and wrong. Allah has no right to force people to suffer for heaven period
So much cats and dogs and Lyon and lioness and bee's Bird and fish and humans and animals are sick and poor and hungry and blinds and deaf and cold medecine needs and so much poverty in my people Afghans people are poor and hungry and america is taking 10 billions dollar of my people they are starving no food and water and medicine they eat moldy hard bread and yemen people are starving and africa 🌍 and I am sick other people are sick no cure 😭😭😭
And how would man know about some kind of being that looks like a man that has always existed when man hasn't always existed, religion is a hustle that we as a species evolved to use to obtain wealth.
@@merajsiddiqui2402 that’s the problem I’m having, ive watched about 5 videos now and all of them are explaining how the injustice will be compensated, but the question of ‘why it even happened in the first place’ has remained unanswered
@@Fatiinextdoor I agree and some of the answers here are like justifying suffering and that's incoherent because the one that's being abused do not deserve it. Here's why it happen, in life, suffering is a part of life that's crucial to the human growth. One that has suffered would most probably be more mature compared to someone that hasn't. And that varies to a certain amount of degree. Because sometimes, one could be too broken to even mature from something. But this depends on case by case, however, God in Islam, has specifically said, that we shall not suffer except what we could take on and our burdens are in line with our potential (2:286). In other words, it is part of something that makes a human being complete. Just like knowing happiness is part of it, it's also the same with knowing pain. However, not everyone in this life, are capable of making good decisions. A lot of people doesn't want to sift and grow through chaos, instead they like to blame others. Here's why, they say they want to improve their life, but if you see their behaviour, they take no action, stay passively and only blame everyone. That is when, as that behaviour grow, they make become worse than their abusers overtime. That is why, the day of judgement exist. Because, we have people that transgress their rights and others to a varying amount of degree and it therefore creates chaos.
Pandemics and social strife. Suffering and social dilemmas. Why? Sin. It is arrogance to say that God causes suffering, when in fact suffering is a result of being judged because of sin. The world is full of sin, and the heart is wicked. If God created a perfect world where no one had the freedom of choice, then that is a God who hates His own creation. If God created a world where He just left it to its own devices, then that God also hates His creation. But, since the God of our creation loves His creation, He gave us free will. With free will is expected much responsibility. When a child rebels against the parents, that child will suffer consequences. These attributes of a fallen creation are laid out in Genesis, and throughout the Bible. Jesus Christ came to give Life to the sinner through repentance and trusting that He will save them after this world is finished. In the end, God wins. He will abolish sin and suffering. That is His plan. Until then, because rebellion still exists within some angels, and all humans, sin and suffering will be part of reality.
Brother i really want to know. Did Jesus at the cross - when He was dying - really said that "I'm here will die for your sins" direct, loud, and clear?
The world is perfect, the human mind of thinking and free will and what they choose to isn't, the humans have ruined this world and I know we have all taken advantage of it
@@Naddi_ The world is not perfect. Infact, even if every human were to be good hypothetically, there is still pain and suffering inevitably, caused by death and lost of loved ones. But you're also wrong, because in our world, Allah has created suffering as part of something that has to exist in the world. You misunderstood that.
@@asoorahammed4836 Sufferings are not random, based on the verse in surah baqarah ayah 286. "Allah does not charge a soul except that within it's capacity" there's also a second meaning to the "wus'aha" here, it also means, Allah does not charge someone except with something that is within it's potential. Everyone's sufferings are unique to themselves and if handled correctly we are able to bring the potential that Allah has given us. Just in case, you don't believe that Allah has given each of us a potential, (17:84) shaakilatihi, means a set of skills, potential, weakness and strength, your passion. We're supposed to work, within all that in this world, to the hereafter. And all that encompasses, whether it'd be working with your job in this world or even being nice to your family and exercising sabr. Don't say shallow things like what you said. It might push people away from Islam.
Cant wait .Love you from old mother.been so confused for so long. No more...THANK YOU.
Short but Powerfull message
Subhanallah. Got this msg. Just when i needed. May ALLAH bless you with best . Aameen
Your voice gives me so much hope in my Rab, gives so much hope in Islam.
Ok but what a long time to wait the day of judgement ,you know I’m not a rock or a stone I’m flesh even more weak than an ant I have feelings
What about someone who abuses a child who didn’t deserve it, is god testing an innocent child
Allah is fair. He will reward the child either in this life (by making him empathetic and merciful to others) or in the other life. But all kids are innocent in Allah's eyes. Also, that "someone" would be punished the same way, either in this life or in the next.
@@comicahmet but that kid will suffer mentally during his time on earth, so is it worth letting the child being abused ?
@@comicahmet the fact the child is innocent in the first place, makes the reward for the kid great and the punishment for the person abusing the kid, even worse
I dont see as Allah testing someone. People have their own free will. Allah simply leaves the punishment for the day of judgement. Whether they were done dirty or lived a long life, Allah will count their deeds and be fair.
@@comicahmet Empathetic people usually get taken advantage of.
Mash Allah beautiful speech 🤲🕋🕯️❤️
Jazakallah Khair..
So beautiful explained so true this life is a test and that's why God has day of judgement 🙏🥰😍😘😭😭😭
Is this life also a test for babies and children who suffer?
@@msrumasen yes everyone even the tiny kitten and puppies and Bebe lyons and bebe elephant I love animals but they also suffer and get tested 😔🤲🕋🕯️📿🙏
@@marienovak3663 Please don't digress from the question being asked. I am not speaking of elephants and puppies.
What just God would allow a three year old child to be raped? Babies to die of hunger? To be maimed, wounded and crippled?
Is this just God testing the faith of innocent children and babies then in such a horrific manner?
Don't have an answer, do you?
I understand your pain. As a child who has suffered, these Muslims are beyond disrespectful to the fallen. Allah has no right making these children suffer for things like this. Please hold on, I wish you the best in life. Don't listen to idiotic Muslims and take yourself.
Take care of yourself.
Can someone link the original video please?
that didn't make sense. anyone got the full talk?
I am Muslim but I don't under stand why God created the base of evil,badness ,and pains even for innocents.Gods wants us to do only good deeds but God itself does good and bad both by creating goodness and evil the both.why can any body explain.
What is good if there is no bad?
What's the point in being kind to someone if there's no negative consequences of being unkind to someone?
What even is unkindness without kindness and vice versa?
God had already created beings that only do good and there's no disobedience or free will. Those are the Angels. But God decided to create beings that do have the right to make a choice between good and bad.. what's better? The one who does good because they are physically incapable of doing bad or the one who does good when they can choose to do bad?
جزاااااكم الله خيرا
So perfect come in time may allah reward you alll the best and good here and fatdous in the hereafter
Still makes absolutely no sense to me I'll tell you why.
Firstly he allows an evil act on innocent so the innocent suffers unjustly then he punish the doer for the same act and he suffers according....... Fine.
But the better thing would be the stop the act intervene in the act so the evil is stoped there only and no one suffers and the evil doer understands it clearly that he will be punished henceforth .is this not a better option
I have the same thoughts as you.
He can't do nothing and does not care , cause does not exist
The point is to remind you that everyone has been given free will. Do as you please - this life is a test and once you commit a sin you will be punished for it.
@@babygirla6630 What religion do you follow?
It's not about your opinion of what is better or worse. Allah has revealed to us the purpose in death and life, to test those who are best in deeds (in accordance to his laws)
The Islamic premise for this life is that it's a test. Evil is also part of that test but evil will not reign forever, because this life is temporary. We have to use our free will and intelect to accept what God has revealed and act in accordance with it, or reject it and doom yourself with a purposeless life.
If the answers for the test was provided with the questions, what's the point of the test?
which ayat was the quote? can someone shed some light pls? thanks a million in advance
Its surah fajr (first three verses)in which Allah(swt) swears by four things to warn us how disbelievers and those who disobeyed Him were punished
The desire of God testing a human being is a crime
Prove me what you are saying, objectively
@@IrfanAli-so5hh he cant
Well why is there suffering
I posted my understanding of why there's suffering in the main thread.
Cuz this earth isnt heaven or hell...
Hell = bad thing only
Heaven = good thing only
Earth = the good and the bad !
Theres Islamic POV video from Purpose Of Life Jeffrey Lang about pain, suffering etc.
Why Allah allows human to experience it.
I give you a glimpse of it,
imagine you are an athlete, you need hardcore exercises and its makes your body suffering and in pain but its make your body strong, they say "no pain no gain"
Now in this, we are not growing physically but spiritually ! Imagine in this world has no suffering, is possible people can be compassion in environment with no suffering ?
Can a computer be called compassion for it programmed to produce medicine ?
Can computer called being honest that programmed not to make incorrect statement ?
And btw, human or other allah's creation that cause us to suffer not allah, He just allow it..
Imagine.. a deer and a lion, which one do you prefer to die ?
I was a practising muslim, now I am an atheist, until I get the answer for these sufferings and misery on this world, I will not revert
Each person who does evil and causes suffering of another soul, will pay in the day of judgement. Allah knows everyone’s intentions and actions. Allah does not forget anything. Allah knows who is evil and who is good, and Allah will give each person what he deserves
@@1lvwrs
Flawed answer
@@LacertaProject please explain how it is flawed
God doesn’t need you, you need God. It’s your loss
In physical world its not possible that a Soul will not suffer, everyone are made up of flesh and can be damaged by accident or disease . Use your brains Atheists ....
I am facing lots of problems.
I am facing frustrations
I am facing ill treatments
I am facing pains
I am facing worries
I am facing damages
I am facing losses
WHY I am facing such types of nasty things in life when I have a good heart and good thoughts and good feelings and good habits?
Why it happens?
I earn legally
I speak the truth
I am honest
I am kind
I am truthful
I am honest
My attitude towards others are positive.
I don't think or do anything bad for others but why day to day I am failing into trouble, falling into frustrations, falling into difficulties and problems?
I can't understand why.
Is this a punishment for me from Allah?
Have I done anything wrong?
Have I done anything that made Allah to anger?
I, myself can't understand this.
I am getting damages , losses in que
I am facing problems in que
I am undergoing severe problems in life.
😟😪
Please don't linger to this thought and feeling to make u more depressed. The peace is from Alla，the solution is from Alla，everything will come to end and we will return to Alla. Alla loves u，keep doing right thing，I hope Alla give u ease and give up right understanding
Assalam Brother, you are not the only Person to have problems.Subhanallah I am tested so much as well but I am patient & still praying,make dua to Allah.This dunia is not easy InshaAllah Allah will give us blessings & reward us with Jannah.I am a single mum with 2 kids,there is no One else in my life,no family/friends 😢 I had to leave the man I loved very much last year,we were planning to get married,he was also my best friend but he tried to kill all of us using jinns
No Allah loves you most
I am also suffering from 18 years but now before I was not praying now I started salat nafl tahajud azkar and reading Quran alhamdullilah it gave me peace in my heart I have also gone through health issue 3 health issues through marriage problems even I have no friends and my country is in war our income is not good we have to pay taxes I didn’tget what I loved I have more problems but I can’t share but Alhamdullilah I am happy because I have find complaining 3riples the problems
@@مطبخفاطمه-ه8ه dawood in the original comment is not complaining. People have the right to express their pain.
then why do animals suffer?
They also have their say on the day of judgement. A woman was condemned to hell for abusing and killing a cat. Another was forgiven completely from a life of sin, because she gave water to a thirsty dog.
@@kanon4408 i know but why is there animal suffering in the first place?
But a atheisist asked why animal suffering why in forest broken leg deer or some other animal suffer they are not going to heaven
There is suffering and pain because of human beings.How is it Allah's fault?
@@Sweet-Rat-Milk it is their test whether they'll do something good or evil
@@lightinthedark9201 Allah has written everything that will happen, also taking into consideration our free will, the course of existence has already been decided, whatever choice you made of free will, was predestined before your birth, Allah is truly the greatest, it takes time for all of us to understand. Inshallah Allah will make everything clearer to us
@@EeLyos The way i see it we make our own actions. Allah has written everything before hand because he can see the future and how it all ends but that doesnt mean Allah chooses what we do on every action we make. Allah is simply all knowing
@@lightinthedark9201not all suffering is due to human actions.
What a pathetic joke. You explained absolutely nothing. You proved the point that Allah is not just. And just because we don't believe the world will ever be just doesn't mean we don't believe in right and wrong. Allah has no right to force people to suffer for heaven period
So much cats and dogs and Lyon and lioness and bee's Bird and fish and humans and animals are sick and poor and hungry and blinds and deaf and cold medecine needs and so much poverty in my people Afghans people are poor and hungry and america is taking 10 billions dollar of my people they are starving no food and water and medicine they eat moldy hard bread and yemen people are starving and africa 🌍 and I am sick other people are sick no cure 😭😭😭
And how would man know about some kind of being that looks like a man that has always existed when man hasn't always existed, religion is a hustle that we as a species evolved to use to obtain wealth.
He does not actually answer the question.
I posted my own understanding in the main comments
Absolutely clickbait in the name of faith
This seems to be more of an explanation of how only God's justice can truly compensate for the injustice and suffering
@@merajsiddiqui2402 that’s the problem I’m having, ive watched about 5 videos now and all of them are explaining how the injustice will be compensated, but the question of ‘why it even happened in the first place’ has remained unanswered
@@Fatiinextdoor I agree and some of the answers here are like justifying suffering and that's incoherent because the one that's being abused do not deserve it.
Here's why it happen, in life, suffering is a part of life that's crucial to the human growth. One that has suffered would most probably be more mature compared to someone that hasn't. And that varies to a certain amount of degree. Because sometimes, one could be too broken to even mature from something. But this depends on case by case, however, God in Islam, has specifically said, that we shall not suffer except what we could take on and our burdens are in line with our potential (2:286). In other words, it is part of something that makes a human being complete. Just like knowing happiness is part of it, it's also the same with knowing pain.
However, not everyone in this life, are capable of making good decisions. A lot of people doesn't want to sift and grow through chaos, instead they like to blame others. Here's why, they say they want to improve their life, but if you see their behaviour, they take no action, stay passively and only blame everyone. That is when, as that behaviour grow, they make become worse than their abusers overtime.
That is why, the day of judgement exist. Because, we have people that transgress their rights and others to a varying amount of degree and it therefore creates chaos.
There is no God.
Pandemics and social strife. Suffering and social dilemmas. Why?
Sin. It is arrogance to say that God causes suffering, when in fact suffering is a result of being judged because of sin. The world is full of sin, and the heart is wicked. If God created a perfect world where no one had the freedom of choice, then that is a God who hates His own creation. If God created a world where He just left it to its own devices, then that God also hates His creation. But, since the God of our creation loves His creation, He gave us free will. With free will is expected much responsibility. When a child rebels against the parents, that child will suffer consequences. These attributes of a fallen creation are laid out in Genesis, and throughout the Bible. Jesus Christ came to give Life to the sinner through repentance and trusting that He will save them after this world is finished. In the end, God wins. He will abolish sin and suffering. That is His plan. Until then, because rebellion still exists within some angels, and all humans, sin and suffering will be part of reality.
Brother i really want to know. Did Jesus at the cross - when He was dying - really said that "I'm here will die for your sins" direct, loud, and clear?
The world is perfect, the human mind of thinking and free will and what they choose to isn't, the humans have ruined this world and I know we have all taken advantage of it
Sufferings occurs totally randomly. Nothing is fare in this world thats why every belives in heaven were it is fare
@@Naddi_ The world is not perfect. Infact, even if every human were to be good hypothetically, there is still pain and suffering inevitably, caused by death and lost of loved ones. But you're also wrong, because in our world, Allah has created suffering as part of something that has to exist in the world. You misunderstood that.
@@asoorahammed4836 Sufferings are not random, based on the verse in surah baqarah ayah 286. "Allah does not charge a soul except that within it's capacity" there's also a second meaning to the "wus'aha" here, it also means, Allah does not charge someone except with something that is within it's potential.
Everyone's sufferings are unique to themselves and if handled correctly we are able to bring the potential that Allah has given us.
Just in case, you don't believe that Allah has given each of us a potential, (17:84) shaakilatihi, means a set of skills, potential, weakness and strength, your passion. We're supposed to work, within all that in this world, to the hereafter. And all that encompasses, whether it'd be working with your job in this world or even being nice to your family and exercising sabr.
Don't say shallow things like what you said. It might push people away from Islam.