Banana Pudding vs Pecan Pie - Back Porch Bickerin'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Which Southern dessert reigns supreme? Matt and Calli take to the porch to duke it out over decadent desserts: Banana Pudding vs Pecan Pie!
NEW SHIRTS FOR SALE!! Check them out: store.southernt...
![Brits Try To Make [PECAN PIE] For The First Time!](/img/1.gif)
Callie and Matt are the perfect bickering duo. Bring back this show!
Bless her, she lost the minute she called it Pee-Can!!!!! 😂
Yeah, it's pee-con.
And when she referenced Zac Brown
In North Alabama we pronounce it pa-con lol
In my neck of the woods in east Tennessee it's p - con. Lol
Puh-CON pie
I love both, but, daggone, Matt’s case would hold up in a court of law👩🏼⚖️😆
He had me at “toothless”-Banana pudding _truly_ is for everybody😌
We get it, You're Southern.
Absolutely
Banana pudding immediately takes me back to my childhood going to my G’ma’s lake house. She ALWAYS made nana puddin. Now that she’s gone I always feel comforted by a bowl of banana pudding
I had a great uncle that always requested my mom's banana pudding instead of a birthday cake every year. Rest in peace uncle John.
I've never in my life had any part of a pecan pie that was the least bit salty, so I don't know what in the world Calli's talking about as to the "saltiness" of the pecan pie. I love pecan pie, but banana pudding just takes the cake. The creaminess of the pudding, the softness of the bananas, and the soft-crunchiness of the 'nilla wafers just mixes together perfectly, and delivers a flavorful, yet unforgettable experience.
You have a problem.
I'm team sugar...I'll take a little bit of both, thanks.
Michael MM
Amen 👏
Get in my brain
Best memory of my great-grandmother is her banana pudding.
Team yes!!! I’m Baptist so when both are at a potluck I’m a happy camper
I love this man. I always agree with him. I love me some banana pudding.
I did too until I saw the pulled pork vs. brisket. I’m from Texas so brisket rules here. But never order brisket if you cross the state line.
Puddin’ for days!! Especially with nilla wafers 😍
Rachel but the must be under the puddin' to make them soft and yummy
@paisleyyama Agreed! It ain't banana pudding without the nilla wafers. And have to be Nilla Wafers, not some generic kind. Mmm-mmm.
Banana pudding all the way I hate pecans
Nilla wafers originally come from Staten Island. Immediate disqualification from the South's pantheon of desserts.
This channel deserves millions subscribers.
I want them big but want to have a better connetion to them
Since I found them over a month ago, I have only watched them and a few episodes of the new season my favorite tv show
I'm with Calli on this one. Pecan pie saved a disastrous Thanksgiving for me in 1978 and I've never lost the love.
These two deserve a TV show. Great chemistry and naturally funny.
Unfair battle. That’s like comparing Thanksgiving Dinner (pecan pie) with a weekday night supper (banana pudding).
While you love both, you know you just couldn’t eat pecan pie that often. But I would wager that most, that like both, would love to have banana pudding at least a few times a week.
I think that what makes pecan pie so special as calli points out it takes time to make a good pecan pie and only have it a few times a year while banana pudding it’s a throw together Dessert
To me it depends on what you're making and what time of year. Pecan pie for Thanksgiving or Christmas. Banana pudding in the summer for a cookout or bbq. Other times of the year you have cobbler.
I definitely understand your point, but pecan pie isn't tasty so that's where I have the issue 😁
umm I can have either whenever I want because I just make them. what are you talking about only having it rarely
Pecan pies to sweet but man it’s good
Matt was absolutely right about banana puddin at church. Wherever there's banana puddin, you better get it on your first trip cuz it'll be gone real quick.
As long as Moon Pies are recognized as a snack not a desert I have no problem
Moon pies are a basic food group.
Jude F. Agreed
PizzaIsLif3 YT lol lol lol shalom God bless your heart GBY IN JESUS NAME
@Necroglobule A mere meal? It's the food of the gods!
It's illegal in the south to eat a moon pie without an R C cola
Wow this one is difficult. They're each right. I have to say both! Love the line about God gave Moses the recipe for banana pudding 😂🙌❤
Always banana pudding!
Same
for sure
Pecan pie
Yes.
The first time I ever held a knife, I was under ten and my grandma great told me it was fine and to cut the bananas for the pudding. I will have that memory forever. My grandpa great called my grandma Lieutenant and he was called Captain, they were both born and raised in Louisiana and my grandpa was known for driving from California to Louisiana in less than a day by truck and loving pecan pies. So, both foods are very special to me. I love them and miss them. Thanks for the cuteness!
Banana pudding all day long!!!
Pecan pie is great, but only in small doses!
Good point! Pecan pie, one piece, you're done. Naner pudding, you'll go back for 2nds and 3rds if there's any left and if it is all gone, you'll go back to use your finger to get what little remainder there is.
Never seen anyone lick a pecan pie pan before...
I’m allergic to pecan pie
Agree all the way
@@arthurchase7716 ,
General nut allergy or specific varieties?
One of my supervisors was allergic to blueberries. Just blueberries. I had never heard of that before he told us he couldn't partake of the blueberries or blueberry pies some of us brought in. Luckily for us it wasn't like most significant peanut allergies which can be triggered by the tiniest amount of peanut dust. He had to actually eat some blueberries or get several blueberries worth on his skin. So we put hand wipes out and made sure not to leave any blueberry mush on the exposed surfaces.
Coaster bay then don’t eat it.
I gotta go with warm PECAN PIE, with a side of banana puddin'😁:)
Why not have both of these~Yum!!
Yep! Banana Pudding, and I have had my fair share of both.
You know you're a true Southerner when no matter how hard you try, you read 'pudding' as 'puddin' and the ing is an afterthought (if you think of it at all haha)
Banana pudding all the way!
How about putting the banana pudding on the pecan pie? A sweet old lady from Atlanta, Georgia told me 50 years ago it is peacon pie. A peecan is something you piss in. I have never forgotten this sage advice. LOVE you guys!!
Peach Cobbler is where it's at
Peach cobbler is the best :)
With vanilla Blue Bell icream.
KAL EL no I'm not a fan.
Cherry cobbler
I don’t like peach cobbler. Every since I was young and had the flu well I think you can figure it out.
I was so proud when he held up the banana pudding and it wasn't neon yellow. You need a layer of the vanilla wafer cookies, then banana, and then regular pudding. Layer that three times, then do a pretty design on top with the wafers, chill, and get some before it's gone. It "evaporates" in about fifteen minutes.
I’ve noticed that Matt is right in every one of these videos. Dr. Pepper over Coke, Whataburger over Chick-fil-a, banana pudding over pecan pie, and so many more
Since he is a major player in this show he probably gets to choose first
Imagine:
Women
Hahahhhahahahaah, Slurp
“At least I can pronounce my dish correctly” LOL 😂
What type of southerner pronounces it “pee-can”? 😂
Omar Harris Every last one.
Omar Harris Me
Omar Harris my dad says that what we have in our hunting blind is a pee-can
mynameis bob it's "pee-caan" not "pee-can".
Omar Harris amen puh con
Oh man you have me absolutely split, this two are in my top favorite desserts. This is like picking my mom or dad as my favorite.
Team I can’t choose, pecan pie is my favorite pie and nanner puddin is my favorite dessert.
Banana pudding for sure! It's always best when you get those about-to-turn-brown-bananas and make some.
Pecan pie is too sweet.
Banana pudding wins!
Working for this channel has to be the best job in history of jobs. Sweet tea, every southern food imaginable, country music, good manners, monogrammed everything, SEC football (I played for Johnny Majors at Tennessee) and they seem to have so much fun!
Calli is wrong for 2 reasons:
1) always banana pudding
2) you dont say it pee-cans, its puh-con.
Thanks for coming to my ted talk
My girl fr just said, "Calli is wrong for two reasons." ???-,Yea you have an opinion,but say she's wrong straight up..Okay,you crossed the boo.
Kermit i mean hate to see it hate to hear it but...
Isn’t there something to be said that if you have to spell it with an O to express its pronunciation then automatically that makes its incorrect. ?? I say peCAN, my husband says peCON. If it was suppose to be pronounced peCON shouldn’t we spell it with an O. Lol
Daria!!!
Absolutely right about "Who brings the Nanner Puttun' " to family functions. Grandma will give you a Kidney but not her Receipe for her Banana Pudding.
Big ole bowl of banana pudding please that's real south
I am for banana pudding because eating it in the summer when it’s hot outside is the most amazing experience!😍
I love puh-con pie but when she says pee can, that just makes me nauseous. Banana pudding, if made from scratch, is like heaven in a bowl.
Amen!
Uh, no. Puh-con is up north crap. Pee-can is southern.
Pah-cons are what you eat. Pee-cans are. What truck drivers use to pee in
I love banana pudding my favorite of thanksgiving and pretty much any other gathering
Matt is right like 90% of the time.
Yes both please! And top with a little chantilly whipped cream following Paul Prudome’s recipe.
I have to admit Mrs. Calli lost me on this one. When I heard PEE-CAN, And then the music reference.....I was devastated lol But, I was already TEAM puddin' anyway lol Love yalls videos
PAA-CON! THAT'S HOW IT'S PRONOUNCED
Team BANANA PUDDIN!
I have never thought of pecan pie as having a salty taste ever and nana puddin' is by far the superior southern treat. I can't eat a gallon of pecan pie, but I can eat a gallon of nana puddin'.
Banana pudding all the way
Never was a Pecan Pie fan nor a Banana Pudding fan but would lean to the Banana Pudding. Cheese Cake (chilled) blows them all away!
Ok pecan pie is bomb but only enjoyed during the fall and winter and pudding is great all year long! Boom!
💣
Omg, you have a rule for when you allow yourself to enjoy a specific food item?!? Heck no!!! I eat what I want whenever I want it! Limiting yourself to some stupid old fashioned rule like that is just ridiculous! Please,live a little-give yourself permission to have what you want anytime of year and please don't tell others it can only be enjoyed certain times of the year!! Smdh....
I like them both so I will have both with my meals ... and snacks :-)
Has anyone else noticed the two window frames hung in front of the siding right behind these two bickerers? LOL
Banana pudding is the best!
BANANA PUDDING!!🍌💖🍌💖🍌
I think Peach/Apple Pie vs Pecan Pie would have made more sense
Apple pie is definitely!
[Infinity Jeff Kaplan]
Yep
[Infinity Jeff Kaplan] apple pie all the way
[Infinity Jeff Kaplan] Apple and peach pie aren't as southern as banana pudding
[Infinity Jeff Kaplan] o my goodness 🤗😍😄😊apply pie peacher cobbler
i'm surprised you didn't bring up the fact that nobody has EVER ordered a pecan pie shake, but a banana pudding shake on a hot day?
GLORIOUS.
When it was really Southern it would be Nanner Puddin
At one time on i75 in Kentucky between London and Lexington there were 4 small truck stops.
At exits 49 59 62 and 76. They all had girls running base station CBs. They all advertised "nanner banner pudding. The Derby City at exit 62 had good pudding exit 76 had the biggest radio a lady called 38 special was the most popular.
But the best truckstop is still in London at exit 41. London auto/truck. They did not even advertise. Those other girls would get into cat fights on the cb. Very entertaining. At 2 am.
Team Matt all the way!!! My favorite desert in the world!!! :) :) :)
Seriously this should not be an argument. It's simple, both! Add in some sweet potato pie too.
I enjoyed hearing Matt's overview of the history of banana pudding. I didn't know that backstory. I prefer pecan pie myself (don't like the texture of bananas) but I love all food history!
It’s pronounced Puh-KHAN. A “pee can” is what your grandfather had under his bed when he had to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night.
When it comes down to which is better between pecan pie and banana pudding I will always choose banana pudding it's on almost every buffet for a dessert choice and it is so delicious especially if it is layered correctly
My aunt from Delaware says, "Pee-can..." Hmmm. I'm now doubting this lady's southern authenticity!
Since when is Delaware the south? :-)
Every year at Thanksgiving and Christmas my mother-in-law makes a dessert just for me. She makes something different each time every year and gets kinda exotic at times. The result is usually me trying it and taking rest home and never eating it. My wife tells me I better act like it's good, and I'm sure it is for someone who likes that sort of thing, but I tell her every year to ask her mother if she will just make a banana pudding or pecan pie. Those 2 tried and true desserts can't be beat.
If I had to choose between the 2, which I hope I never have to, then I would say puhcahn pie wins. Simply for the fact that it can be served hot or cold. I've tried banana pudding warm before, and have to say that it wasn't enjoyable. PP straight out of the fridge or "Heated and Treated" at Waffle House is awesome always.
Banana puddin all the way! Now if it was apple pie that would be a different story.
Love, Love, Love Banana Pudding, Has to be home made! Never instant.
Team banana pudding all the way!
Banana Pudding for the win!!! and is she even southern saying Pecan like that?
Banana pudding is best! ;)
Dang it, I always side with Matt. Naner Puddin' all the way!
Banana puddin!
Banana pudding is what we had nearly every Sunday. Mom would let me lick the pudding bowl and then a few left over Nilla wafers. Pecan pie was a special treat. If I had a choice it would be homemade banana pudding.
Y'all are great. I love you girl, but I gotta go with the nanner puddin. When our church has a pot luck even the preacher looks forward to it the most :) Oh and here in Texas the Pecan tree is our state tree. So I can officially say it's Pecan (pee-con) not pee can.... ;) They just messed the spellin' up :) :)God Bless and keep y'all.
C Hamilton yes! i’m north carolinian and i say pee-con
My grandparents have pecan trees, and they shell the pecans by hand. They sell them too, they're hands become cracked, and covered in blisters. They usually make about $50+ every year. Calli you can by some if you want to!
Banana pudding is the best
2:50 Exactly! You can have pudding for a snack or dessert any day. But pecan pie is for special occasions because it's so exceptional.
What say we split the difference: Chess Pie!
What exactly is chess pie? 🤔
@@lilannegirl03
It's a pie made from a sweetened buttermilk custard, typically seasoned with nutmeg, vanilla, and sometimes a bit of allspice.
It gets its name from a New York Yankee journalist who toured the south in the late 1800s, writing about the cuisine. When he asked for the recipe and name of the pie he had been served, the woman gave him the recipe, and said "It's jus' pie!" He misunderstood her southern accent and thought she'd said "Chess Pie", and that's what he published. The name stuck.
In any case, it's delicious, and a southern standard.
@@supergeek1418 thank you so much for the explanation! 😊
Nanner puddin all day every day. Even on the holidays. And I even grew up in Jawja.
BANANA PUDDING 100%
They both delicious I like a little crunch or little soft as pudding
Banana pudding any day
Both. I’m sorry, but I just can’t choose between the two amazing deserts. They both have a pretty good case.
Actually, I'm Team Chocolate Pie!
Which is basically just pudding with a crust
Started out at the family reunions just bring the chips... graduated two green bean casserole, never got much beyond that.
What's more satisfying than pecan pie after a slab of BBQ ribs?
Mike Gustafson that’s for sure
Cheese cake.
Peach Cobbler with ice cream
Walking into an air conditioned room on a hot day? (I lived in Phoenix, AZ and Las Vegas, NV most of my life. )
An ice cold beer?
I grew up on a farm in Southern Indiana near the Ohio River. I could see Kentucky from the grain silo. Apparently I have more in common with the South than the Mid West. Sweat Tea is a sacrament, Chocolate Gravy for breakfeast on a special occation, banana puddin anytime, everything fried, a dab of butter goes in nearly every recipe, Ma'am or Sir was drilled into me growing up, Church every Sunday, and hearing "Bless your heart" wasn't necessarly a good thing. I was raised by my grandparents sooo..old fashioned.
I like my pee-can pie with a side of nanner puddin'
Obviously Calli is from Georgia. Hey, Sweetie, there is other Southern States. Pecan Pie is Southern, however "Nanner Puttun' " is the "Boss"!
It should've been peach cobbler and pecan pie.
Because the banana pudding wins too easily?
y'all do this to me every video. I love em both by God I gotta go with banana puddin. it is what he said it is its awesome, its tricky to get right, and yes it is the dish that everyone's lookin forward too!
Team Banana Pudding but it is "Pea- con" Pie
I love both of them so mich.
Banana pudding! Love it!
Outstanding video friend. Thanks a lot. Great job. Keep up the great work. SC Navy vet.
I am ashamed to say this but I don't like pecans so I cheer for banana pudding
Both!!! A good Southern dinner table will have both on it! :)
A “pee-can” is a porta potty, it’s pronounced “puh-con”
Gotta go with Matt on this one. Banana 'Nana' Pudding for the win!
Both. Always at the table. At church socials. And holidays. When I make pecan pie I have one sister eats the nuts off it and the other sister eats the filling I wanted to kill them it looked so pretty they demolished it I make 2 now.
I love both I can’t choose!