No . We should decentralise more and give more power to states and local bodies if we really want to develop. Centralisation is a disaster . Wheather it’s USA or China all have done decentralisation.
Jo man mai Aya bol diya 😂 ... Not practically possible... Rahi baat to mathematics science related subjects uniform ho sakte hai but cultural heritage and social public relations different hai ... Social science should be state dependent
@@ajeetydubansi4083 not possible, agar science technology aur mathematics reasoning ki baat hai to uniform honi chahiye, par social studies cultural heritage and social norms public relations language study state wise honi chahiye. Each state has its own identity. Uniformity ke karan Bahut nuksaan hoga
श्रीमान जी एक बिंदु जो शायद छूट गया था वह इस प्रकार है: अलग अलग समय पर चुनाव होने से आम लोगों के स्थानीय मुद्दों पर बात होती है, पार्टियां उन मुद्दों को ध्यान में रखते हुए अपना मेनिफेस्टो तैयार करती हैं और सरकार बनती है तो सरकार इन मुद्दों को ध्यान में रखते हुए नीतियां बनाती है। यदि सरकारें ऐसा नहीं करती तो जनता के पास अवसर होता है कि चुनाव आने पर उस पार्टी को समर्थन ना दें। इस प्रकार सरकार की जवाबदेही तय होती है, लेकिन यदि पांच वर्ष में केवल एक बार चुनाव हुए तो निश्चित रूप से सरकार की जवाबदेही कम हो जाएगी।
To apko lgta hai ki term agar km ho jayegi to muddo pr baat hogi us country maj jahan hindu muslim darmiik mudda charm sima pr hai or kedra sarkar apna barchasv sathhir krna cahaegi Centre mai bhi or state maj bh
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does. Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties. Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win. So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
आम आदमी मूर्ख है, आपको लगता है, आम आदमी को जात-पात ऊंच नीच, हिन्दू मुस्लिम से फुर्सत है, जिस विकृत मानसिकता की जनता है क्रमशः उसको नेता भी वही उपलब्ध हैं, विश्व का सर्वश्रेष्ठ धर्म हम भारतीयों का था, लेकिन उसको पाखंड अंधविश्वास, कर्म कांडों ने इतना पीछे धकेल दिया कि आज हर कोई सनातन धर्म को आंख दिखा देता है, हमने कभी नहीं देखा कि क्या है हमारे पास बल्कि दूसरे क्या कहते हैं उसी में पड़े है, विज्ञान कहता है कि एक हे परिवार में शादियां होने से संतानों को जघन्य रोग और आनुवांशिक बीमारियां होती है, लेकिन हमारा धर्म हमें श्रद्धा भाव से ऐशा कहने को सिखाता है, जो श्रद्धा हमे अपनी बहन बेटियों पर हमारे धर्म के आधार पर होती है, वो पश्चिमी देशों के मन में नहीं है, यही फर्क है इस देश की संस्कृति और पश्चिमी में,
I don't know why there is question that, Is india ready for this. we all know that this system was already adopted in the country but breaks due to some reason and its time to revive it ones again that simple.
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does. Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties. Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win. So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
मुझे लगता है की भारत जैसे देश में जहां राष्ट्रवाद और धार्मिक मुद्दों के सामने लगभग सारे मुद्दे गौण हो जाते हैं ऐसे में अगर एक राष्ट्र एक चुनाव लागू होता है तो काफी हद तक ये संभव है कि राष्ट्रीय मुद्दों के सामने क्षेत्रीय और स्थानीय मुद्दे पीछे छूट जाए तथा राष्ट्रवाद और धार्मिक मुद्दों के बल पर एक ही पार्टी राज्य और केंद्र दोनों जगह सरकार बना ले।ऐसी स्थिति देश में न सिर्फ संघवाद के लिए खतरनाक साबित होगी बल्कि इससे नागरिकों के अधिकारों में भी कमी आयेगी इसके अलावा इस व्यवस्था से नागरिकों के द्वारा अपने प्रतिनिधि को चुनने की क्षमता भी प्रभावित होगी। ऐसे में मेरा मानना है कि इस समय जब देश की अधिकांश जनसंख्या राजनीतिक रूप से पूरी तरह शिक्षित नहीं है,इस परिस्थिति में एक राष्ट्र एक चुनाव जैसी व्यवस्था को लागू नहीं किया जाना चाहिए जब तक की एक आम नागरिक पूरी तरह से राजनीतिक रूप से जागरूक न हो जाए,नहीं तो हो सकता है कि भारत एक संघीय राज्यव्यवस्था से एकात्मक राज्यव्यवस्था में परिवर्तित हो जाए।
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does. Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties. Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win. So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
Mujhe lagta h ki azadi ke samay ek sath chunao karana swechha se jyada majburi rhi hogi kyu ki us time sabhi jagah chunao karna hi tha chahe state ho ya country,,,fir dheere dheere jaise jaise rajyo ke karyakal badlte gya chunao ke timing badalte gya@@crashwithMTI
there are some constitutional changes are required Article 83: Pertains to the tenure of the Houses of Parliament. Article 85: Deals with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha by the President. Article 172: Concerns the duration of state legislatures. Article 174: Addresses the dissolution of state assemblies. Article 356: Deals with the imposition of the President’s rule. so it is a challenge for india
One nation galat hai.... Lakin agar central election separate ho ,aur all state election yek sat ho ,and local election state mei yek sat ho to accha hoga.... ❤❤❤ 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Bhai 100 days ka gap hai , central aur state government ( municipal level) ke election me , ye khi nhi report me diya hua hai ki simultaneously honge election. No offense but I think he is also politically motivated.
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does. Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties. Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win. So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
But financial burden badega.. Sarkar ka kharcha kam karne k liye aur political advantage k liye kar rahe hai. Aur One election One nation that is Hindu Rashtra baneneka plan chal raha hai
Thank you sir, it was to the point explanation about the pros and cons of the topic. Adding one more point against the topic, there might be a massive flow of misinformation among the general public, through media which may lead to manipulation of the mass, turning it into an uncontrollable law and order situation in the country. Please do correct me if my perspective is wrong.
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does. Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties. Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win. So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
But regional and national demands are different and both should be given equal respect in one nation one election regional demands will somewhere be shadowed over national demands
Bharat ek unique country hai ,constitutional view se ek dam khatarnak hai , future me foreign attack ki sambhavna ko badhawa degi qki election ke dauran pura desh ki sampradayik dange ko hawa mil jayega ..... One election desh and sambidhan hit me nhi hai ..ye khas tarah ki vikrit mansikta ko darsata hai Bangladesh ke takhta palat es sambhawna ki pusthi kiya ja sakta hai..... Viksit bharat ko banane or bane rahne ke liye .... panchayat or lok sabha ka election ek sath ho to bikash ki sambhavna achhi future ki taraf ho sakti hai
One nation one election result aane ke bad kisi party ko pura bahumat nahi mila central government me to pura system kharab ho jayega. Or one nation one election karane me election commission of India ko supreme power dena hoga jo sahi nahi hai. Kyoki us time bahri attack ho ya badi problem ho. Tab india me leadership ki kami ho jayega. Ya sainik sahab aane ki sambhavna rahega. Please reply vijender sir my comments
India main already Loksabha ke sath State ke bhi election hote hai , E.g. - Telangana , Aandra pradesh , Odisha , Mizoram, sab state main alag alag party ke sarkar hai
Namaste Sir 🙏, Sir agar one nation one election, India adopt kr bhi leti hai? to eski qa guarantee hogi ki aane waale samay mein, kisi rajya ki sarkaar na gire? ya central ki sarkaar na gire?, or fir se election alag alag karwaane ko badhya na ho?
I fully support this as long as there are no administrative and logistical difficulties. Because I do not see how a citizen being facilitated to vote for different houses simultaneously could be regarded as undermining federalism. This argument doesn't hold much weight apart from being semantical - One (Nation One Election) vs many (states and federalism).
स्वस्थ लोकतंत्र हेतु लोकसभा और सभी राज्यों के विधानसभा चुनाव के मध्य ढाई साल का अन्तर हो । नहीं तो मतदाता जहां हवा वहां बहा जो वोट केन्द्र को वहीं वोट राज्य को जाने की संभावना बन जाएगी ।
One nation, one election is fine, but the question is whether they (those in power) or we (the general public) will be able to manage and take responsibility for it, despite this concept or thoughts that arise from negative fears ! 🙏
Haa to unhone iske liya unexpired term bhi rakha hai means agar sarkar 2nd yr mai gir jati hai to firse election hoga aur jo next sarkar banegi wo 3 saal ke liye banegi... Then fir whole india mai Election hoge
dear sir i m not upsc aspirant but i follow you because i love you although i have an query if one nation one election happens there will be 1]unfair election 2]one govt rule 3]social media collaboration to one govt probably these points affects the election so what do you think about it
Sir, I hope you're doing well. I have been following your RUclips channel and really appreciate your insightful content. I wanted to suggest a topic that I believe would make for a great video: the reservation system based on caste in India. I personally have reservations about this system and feel that it may not be the best approach for our society. However, I know that you hold a different perspective and believe it is beneficial for Indian society. Given your balanced approach to complex topics, I think a video where you explain your viewpoint on this issue would be really valuable for people like me who are trying to understand both sides. Sir personally I think that equity should be provided to the backward and lower category of India but the reservation system is failing to address the root causes of inequality and is not effectively solving the underlying problems, Instead, it is fostering new divisions and animosity between different communities in India. Kindly take a moment from your valuable time to share your thoughtful views on this topic.😊🙏🏻
Sir pls make video on IIT BHU GANGRAPE CASE. Students protesting regarding this issue have been suspended from college. All culprits have been granted bail.
Sir, I believe that the motive of government to bring in “one nation one election” would resolve the issue of policy paralysis and reduce the wasteful spending in elections ,but at the same time as a democracy where not only everyone’s representation is necessary but this representation should be seen equally,the major political parties would get an advantage over the local and regional political parties which are confined and focused in a particular state or region, moreover the local issues such as water scarcity, food shortages, unemployment may struggle to find place in mainstream media during simultaneous elections and may remain unnoticed . Hence, i believe that we as a nation are not ready yet for “one nation one election”
Sir 2 points at ground level that I believe will create more stress and challenging is - deployment of security forces in challenging areas. - lack of govt. School teachers may get pressure to work.
When each state has a different problems we should not conduct all elections together. People should have the hold of the government. Lok Sabha, State election and Local elections separately. Each should have 1.5 years gap, so that people will have neck of the government.
मे यह देखता हूं कि अगर लोकसभा के चुनाव और विधानसभा के चुनाव एक साथ ना करके सभी राज्य में लोकसभा चुनाव के एक साल के अंतर मे विधानसभा के चुनाव होना चाहिए और पंचायत चुनव आदि को राज्य के ऊपर छोड़ देना चाहिए। इससे राज्यों के आंतरिक मुद्दे को भी स्पस्तता मिलेगी और केंद्रीय मुद्दे को भी अलग अलग से प्राथमिकता दी जाएगी। और इससे केंदीय और राज्यिक विषयो पर भी जानता का मत स्पष्ट होगा। जैसे अब हो रहा है । लेकिन सभी राज्य में एक साथ विधानसभा के चुनाव होने पर में पक्ष ले सकता हूं।
Jb kharcha kmm krne ke liye hi sarkar soch rhi hai toh P.M.apni Luxurious ko chhor de or unke mantriparisad ke log v ! Tb smjha jayega ki nation ka kharcha bachakar wo sahi jagah kharch krke dikhaye , aam janta ke beech 🙏
Instead of decentralising and giving power to states , the current ruling dispensation is doing the opposite. Decentralisation should be the norm not the other way around.
This is to how a real teacher guides to students ❤❤❤
One nation one election nahi balki one nation one education🎒🏫📚🎓 hona chahiye
Bilkul
No . We should decentralise more and give more power to states and local bodies if we really want to develop. Centralisation is a disaster . Wheather it’s USA or China all have done decentralisation.
Jo man mai Aya bol diya 😂 ... Not practically possible... Rahi baat to mathematics science related subjects uniform ho sakte hai but cultural heritage and social public relations different hai ... Social science should be state dependent
Aur language 😂 to alag hi level par pahunch jayega mamla pura desh jala diya jayega
@Nitishkumar-bu9mn afterwards keep blaming that everyone is applying for same job
शिक्षा और स्वास्थ्य एक सामान हो देश में ताकि गरीब किसान मजदूर का जीवन सुधरे और देश आगे बढ़े..??
Kya matlab
Shiksha se kya arth hai apka ... Explain kariye
@@KaranMalviya-cw5cc primary to PhD education is equal for every Indian student.
@@ajeetydubansi4083 not possible, agar science technology aur mathematics reasoning ki baat hai to uniform honi chahiye, par social studies cultural heritage and social norms public relations language study state wise honi chahiye. Each state has its own identity. Uniformity ke karan Bahut nuksaan hoga
@@KaranMalviya-cw5cc
That wasn't the topic
अद्भुत है सर आप महान है सभी प्रश्नों के जवाब बहुत अच्छे से मिले गए।
श्रीमान जी एक बिंदु जो शायद छूट गया था वह इस प्रकार है:
अलग अलग समय पर चुनाव होने से आम लोगों के स्थानीय मुद्दों पर बात होती है, पार्टियां उन मुद्दों को ध्यान में रखते हुए अपना मेनिफेस्टो तैयार करती हैं और सरकार बनती है तो सरकार इन मुद्दों को ध्यान में रखते हुए नीतियां बनाती है। यदि सरकारें ऐसा नहीं करती तो जनता के पास अवसर होता है कि चुनाव आने पर उस पार्टी को समर्थन ना दें। इस प्रकार सरकार की जवाबदेही तय होती है, लेकिन यदि पांच वर्ष में केवल एक बार चुनाव हुए तो निश्चित रूप से सरकार की जवाबदेही कम हो जाएगी।
To apko lgta hai ki term agar km ho jayegi to muddo pr baat hogi us country maj jahan hindu muslim darmiik mudda charm sima pr hai or kedra sarkar apna barchasv sathhir krna cahaegi Centre mai bhi or state maj bh
श्री मान, अग्निवीर का नाम सुना है?
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does.
Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties.
Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win.
So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
Chunao 2 times hone chahiye. for example States ka chunao 2028 me aur General chunao 2029 me. phir 2033 and 20234 me
आम आदमी मूर्ख है, आपको लगता है, आम आदमी को जात-पात ऊंच नीच, हिन्दू मुस्लिम से फुर्सत है,
जिस विकृत मानसिकता की जनता है क्रमशः उसको नेता भी वही उपलब्ध हैं,
विश्व का सर्वश्रेष्ठ धर्म हम भारतीयों का था, लेकिन उसको पाखंड अंधविश्वास, कर्म कांडों ने इतना पीछे धकेल दिया कि आज हर कोई सनातन धर्म को आंख दिखा देता है,
हमने कभी नहीं देखा कि क्या है हमारे पास बल्कि दूसरे क्या कहते हैं उसी में पड़े है,
विज्ञान कहता है कि एक हे परिवार में शादियां होने से संतानों को जघन्य रोग और आनुवांशिक बीमारियां होती है,
लेकिन हमारा धर्म हमें श्रद्धा भाव से ऐशा कहने को सिखाता है,
जो श्रद्धा हमे अपनी बहन बेटियों पर हमारे धर्म के आधार पर होती है, वो पश्चिमी देशों के मन में नहीं है,
यही फर्क है इस देश की संस्कृति और पश्चिमी में,
Exactly like how it was written in the Hindu analysis. Thank you sir very well explained 🙏
I hope nation want ...one nation one health care one nation one education.
I don't know why there is question that, Is india ready for this. we all know that this system was already adopted in the country but breaks due to some reason and its time to revive it ones again that simple.
You are our inspiration Sir 😊
विजेंद्र सर आप उत्तम दर्ज़े के वक्ता और शिक्षक हो...🙏
जी चाहता है आपको घंटो सुने ❤
Bilkul sahi bole aap
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does.
Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties.
Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win.
So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद गुरुजी इतना बढ़िया से समझने के लिए मार्गदर्शन बहुत ही अच्छा था आपका
मुझे लगता है की भारत जैसे देश में जहां राष्ट्रवाद और धार्मिक मुद्दों के सामने लगभग सारे मुद्दे गौण हो जाते हैं ऐसे में अगर एक राष्ट्र एक चुनाव लागू होता है तो काफी हद तक ये संभव है कि राष्ट्रीय मुद्दों के सामने क्षेत्रीय और स्थानीय मुद्दे पीछे छूट जाए तथा राष्ट्रवाद और धार्मिक मुद्दों के बल पर एक ही पार्टी राज्य और केंद्र दोनों जगह सरकार बना ले।ऐसी स्थिति देश में न सिर्फ संघवाद के लिए खतरनाक साबित होगी बल्कि इससे नागरिकों के अधिकारों में भी कमी आयेगी इसके अलावा इस व्यवस्था से नागरिकों के द्वारा अपने प्रतिनिधि को चुनने की क्षमता भी प्रभावित होगी।
ऐसे में मेरा मानना है कि इस समय जब देश की अधिकांश जनसंख्या राजनीतिक रूप से पूरी तरह शिक्षित नहीं है,इस परिस्थिति में एक राष्ट्र एक चुनाव जैसी व्यवस्था को लागू नहीं किया जाना चाहिए जब तक की एक आम नागरिक पूरी तरह से राजनीतिक रूप से जागरूक न हो जाए,नहीं तो हो सकता है कि भारत एक संघीय राज्यव्यवस्था से एकात्मक राज्यव्यवस्था में परिवर्तित हो जाए।
Aajadi ke samay kaun sa 100% litracy tha
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does.
Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties.
Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win.
So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
Mujhe lagta h ki azadi ke samay ek sath chunao karana swechha se jyada majburi rhi hogi kyu ki us time sabhi jagah chunao karna hi tha chahe state ho ya country,,,fir dheere dheere jaise jaise rajyo ke karyakal badlte gya chunao ke timing badalte gya@@crashwithMTI
Bro thoda aur explain kar sakte ho ki kaise ek hi parti state aur center me ban jaye
@@Knowledge-cz9yuये कुतर्क सही नहीं है आज भी एकसाथ हो सकता है
there are some constitutional changes are required
Article 83: Pertains to the tenure of the Houses of Parliament.
Article 85: Deals with the dissolution of the Lok Sabha by the President.
Article 172: Concerns the duration of state legislatures.
Article 174: Addresses the dissolution of state assemblies.
Article 356: Deals with the imposition of the President’s rule.
so it is a challenge for india
Also .Janpratinidhi adhiniyam 1951
अद्भुत, आप महान हैं। सारे प्रश्नों के उत्तर मिल गया।❤🙏
Sir aap aise hi videos banaye.....thanks
Best ever teacher
Thank you Sir. 🙏
With all humbleness and respect.
One nation galat hai....
Lakin agar central election separate ho ,aur all state election yek sat ho ,and local election state mei yek sat ho to accha hoga....
❤❤❤
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Bhai 100 days ka gap hai , central aur state government ( municipal level) ke election me , ye khi nhi report me diya hua hai ki simultaneously honge election.
No offense but I think he is also politically motivated.
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does.
Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties.
Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win.
So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
Thanks sir for explaining such a great way to understand one nation one election ❤❤❤
Very informative video thank u sir ...keep making such informative videos... we love you we respect you we support you we are very grateful to you❤❤
One nation 2 election
One time general election
Second time legislative
Isse state wise mudde bhi apni importance bnaye rakhenge
Or national mudde bhi
But financial burden badega.. Sarkar ka kharcha kam karne k liye aur political advantage k liye kar rahe hai. Aur One election One nation that is Hindu Rashtra baneneka plan chal raha hai
Bhai Public Hushiyar hain .
Dono Election Ek Saath Bhi Hoo Toh Vote Alag Degi.
One nation one election very important
thank you sir explain the one nation one election ❤❤
Knowledgeable 👍
Explain krne ka treeka thoda casual h 😂😂😂😂 just joking sir 😅 I respect your views❤
Ur way of explaining sir superb
Thank you for bringing such videos,
Thank you sir, it was to the point explanation about the pros and cons of the topic. Adding one more point against the topic, there might be a massive flow of misinformation among the general public, through media which may lead to manipulation of the mass, turning it into an uncontrollable law and order situation in the country. Please do correct me if my perspective is wrong.
कभी शिक्षा पर कुछ नहीं कहेगे क्योंकि बहुत बुरी शिक्षा व्यवस्था है 😢
Bolah unhone bhai
Agar sab educated ho gaye toh how will politician get vote on caste/religion
If citizens get educated then it will become a problem form for politicians
Physicist Michio Kaku ka bhi interview he wo bhi USA ka education system ko kosh rha thaa.
😂
Har jagah nawaab sab rotey rhtey he
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION is best 🇮🇳🇮🇳 This person is just pushing his Communist ideology like he always does.
Now, as for whether regional concerns will be cornered due to One election, No it won't happen!! Since both election will be held seperately but in similar time period so you can choose different parties.
Also some changes can be made of there is any serious concerns, but ONE nation ONE election is MUST, otherwise evey minister will get busy in Election advertisement like they do today. They have to do it in order to win.
So this step is good will increase overall efficiency.
I am lawyer practicing on constituional side since last 40 years.
I think your perception is absolutely correct
Constitution is written by foolish people..
Deep analysis
One nation one education hona chahiye sir
But regional and national demands are different and both should be given equal respect in one nation one election regional demands will somewhere be shadowed over national demands
Sach baat to ye hai ki bharat ki janta chamchagiri mai mast hai ... Buddhi nahi hai unke pass
Sach baat to ye hai ki bharat ki janta chamchagiri mai mast hai ... Buddhi nahi hai unke pass
Very helpful video..
thank you sir.
Bharat ek unique country hai ,constitutional view se ek dam khatarnak hai , future me foreign attack ki sambhavna ko badhawa degi qki election ke dauran pura desh ki sampradayik dange ko hawa mil jayega .....
One election desh and sambidhan hit me nhi hai ..ye khas tarah ki vikrit mansikta ko darsata hai
Bangladesh ke takhta palat es sambhawna ki pusthi kiya ja sakta hai.....
Viksit bharat ko banane or bane rahne ke liye .... panchayat or lok sabha ka election ek sath ho to bikash ki sambhavna achhi future ki taraf ho sakti hai
As u said sir it's against the separation of power so it comes under the judicial review I think the supreme court cannot accept this concept .
Wonderful analysis 🙏
One nation one election result aane ke bad kisi party ko pura bahumat nahi mila central government me to pura system kharab ho jayega. Or one nation one election karane me election commission of India ko supreme power dena hoga jo sahi nahi hai. Kyoki us time bahri attack ho ya badi problem ho. Tab india me leadership ki kami ho jayega. Ya sainik sahab aane ki sambhavna rahega. Please reply vijender sir my comments
Very balanced articulated ❤..
India main already Loksabha ke sath State ke bhi election hote hai , E.g. - Telangana , Aandra pradesh , Odisha , Mizoram, sab state main alag alag party ke sarkar hai
Tq sir for this very useful session...
Thanku sir,is thara se samjhane ke liye
Namaste Sir 🙏, Sir agar one nation one election, India adopt kr bhi leti hai? to eski qa guarantee hogi ki aane waale samay mein, kisi rajya ki sarkaar na gire? ya central ki sarkaar na gire?, or fir se election alag alag karwaane ko badhya na ho?
अगर राज्य सरकार गिर जाए तो मध्यावधि या अस्थायी सरकार के चुनाव होंगे। इस बदलाव से खर्चा बढ़ भी सकता है अगर कई राज्य सरकारें गिरने लगें।
Sir mai ek engineering student hu aur aapke Vani ki spashtata bahut achhi❤❤ h ....Best explained than dhruv rathi 😊
You are our inpirsan sir ji
My school is representing One Nation, One Election Bill in 35th National Youth Parliament at Zonal level 🙌
Sir ,
Mujhe aap bahut achchhe lagte ho,
Aap bahut hi balancing baat karte hain,
Excellent analysis ❤
Nice information sir ❤
Much needed
Casual bat h sir
चुनाव आयोग 1967 तक लोक सभा, विधान सभा का चुनाव एक साथ करा सकता था तो अब क्यो नहीं करा सकता।
इस समय तो पहले से ज्यादा संसाधन है हमारे पास।
Tab ki population kya thi aj ki dekho 4th time bad gye h
@@mohdajam-ui5weto Aaj technology aur resources kitne jyada hai ye bhi dekho ...
To aaj technology and election commission ke sansadhan bhi to bad gye he @@mohdajam-ui5we
Toh Jake Karaoo na coments kr Dene se sab nhi hojata hai 😂😂😂
😂@@dhananjaysingh2721
One nation, two election .
Sir loksabha chunav ke 2.5 years ke baad vidhansabha (state wala) election karwana chahiye.
Big fan sir
I fully support this as long as there are no administrative and logistical difficulties. Because I do not see how a citizen being facilitated to vote for different houses simultaneously could be regarded as undermining federalism. This argument doesn't hold much weight apart from being semantical - One (Nation One Election) vs many (states and federalism).
बिल्कुल सही
Love Jade plant sir ❤
Election commission should be free from government hands🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
स्वस्थ लोकतंत्र हेतु लोकसभा और सभी राज्यों के विधानसभा चुनाव के मध्य ढाई साल का अन्तर हो । नहीं तो मतदाता जहां हवा वहां बहा जो वोट केन्द्र को वहीं वोट राज्य को जाने की संभावना बन जाएगी ।
One nation, one election is fine, but the question is whether they (those in power) or we (the general public) will be able to manage and take responsibility for it, despite this concept or thoughts that arise from negative fears ! 🙏
❤👍Nice Information Sir 😊
I think it is not practically possible because the state govt or center govt may fall before the fixed tenure
Haa to unhone iske liya unexpired term bhi rakha hai means agar sarkar 2nd yr mai gir jati hai to firse election hoga aur jo next sarkar banegi wo 3 saal ke liye banegi... Then fir whole india mai Election hoge
@@whoisabhishek thnkx
@@whoisabhishek thankx for correcting me
@@whoisabhishekabhi state elections toh kayi phase mein ho rahe hain ,one nation one elections kaise honge.
@@drjagritisingh6569dekhte hai
dear sir i m not upsc aspirant but i follow you because i love you although i have an query
if one nation one election happens there will be
1]unfair election
2]one govt rule
3]social media collaboration to one govt
probably these points affects the election
so what do you think about it
Sir, I hope you're doing well. I have been following your RUclips channel and really appreciate your insightful content. I wanted to suggest a topic that I believe would make for a great video: the reservation system based on caste in India. I personally have reservations about this system and feel that it may not be the best approach for our society. However, I know that you hold a different perspective and believe it is beneficial for Indian society. Given your balanced approach to complex topics, I think a video where you explain your viewpoint on this issue would be really valuable for people like me who are trying to understand both sides.
Sir personally I think that equity should be provided to the backward and lower category of India but the reservation system is failing to address the root causes of inequality and is not effectively solving the underlying problems, Instead, it is fostering new divisions and animosity between different communities in India. Kindly take a moment from your valuable time to share your thoughtful views on this topic.😊🙏🏻
Jai samvidhan
Shiksha kranti zindabad 🙏
Sir ❤❤❤
Thank you sir
Me sabkuch nahi bataunga … specific points raise karke hero banunga
Guru❤
We need one health one education
सतप्रतिशत
Thanks sir ❤❤❤❤❤
❤ thank you sir ❤
Aapko mera bahoot pyar
Sir pls make video on IIT BHU GANGRAPE CASE.
Students protesting regarding this issue have been suspended from college.
All culprits have been granted bail.
Drishti team ke member ❤❤
Education, hospital, road, water is priority
awesome
Sir, I believe that the motive of government to bring in “one nation one election” would resolve the issue of policy paralysis and reduce the wasteful spending in elections ,but at the same time as a democracy where not only everyone’s representation is necessary but this representation should be seen equally,the major political parties would get an advantage over the local and regional political parties which are confined and focused in a particular state or region, moreover the local issues such as water scarcity, food shortages, unemployment may struggle to find place in mainstream media during simultaneous elections and may remain unnoticed .
Hence, i believe that we as a nation are not ready yet for “one nation one election”
Sir, good explanation, par btaane ka tarika thora casual tha.
Amazing sir
Sir 2 points at ground level that I believe will create more stress and challenging is
- deployment of security forces in challenging areas.
- lack of govt. School teachers may get pressure to work.
When each state has a different problems we should not conduct all elections together. People should have the hold of the government. Lok Sabha, State election and Local elections separately. Each should have 1.5 years gap, so that people will have neck of the government.
Casual ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Tq sirji
Thanks sir
Nice information sir.
मे यह देखता हूं कि अगर लोकसभा के चुनाव और विधानसभा के चुनाव एक साथ ना करके सभी राज्य में लोकसभा चुनाव के एक साल के अंतर मे विधानसभा के चुनाव होना चाहिए और पंचायत चुनव आदि को राज्य के ऊपर छोड़ देना चाहिए। इससे राज्यों के आंतरिक मुद्दे को भी स्पस्तता मिलेगी और केंद्रीय मुद्दे को भी अलग अलग से प्राथमिकता दी जाएगी। और इससे केंदीय और राज्यिक विषयो पर भी जानता का मत स्पष्ट होगा। जैसे अब हो रहा है । लेकिन सभी राज्य में एक साथ विधानसभा के चुनाव होने पर में पक्ष ले सकता हूं।
❤❤❤❤❤ love 💕 you sir ji
In one nation election small budget candidates easily marginalized. It's like organized sector always win over unorganised sector
No One Nation One Election this is called One Nation One Person 😮
One nation one health care one nation one education hona chahiye..??
Wo bhi cahiye,
Saath me ONOE bhi cahiye..
those in its favour have atleast some solid reasons
those against it have some cooked theories and philosophies 😅
One nation one election hona chahiye
Jb kharcha kmm krne ke liye hi sarkar soch rhi hai toh P.M.apni Luxurious ko chhor de or unke mantriparisad ke log v ! Tb smjha jayega ki nation ka kharcha bachakar wo sahi jagah kharch krke dikhaye , aam janta ke beech 🙏
Who is student
I am students of 12 class
Bro🤝
Instead of decentralising and giving power to states , the current ruling dispensation is doing the opposite. Decentralisation should be the norm not the other way around.
Hitler once :- `One people one Empire one Leader'
Please make video on Bihar.... North India pichhar kyu gya South India se specially Bihar....
Main conclusion can find in term of financial source of lower and middle class, quality of education and literacy rate.
I know u will question about corruption which is by product of lack of information and law
Unequal land distribution since the time of Arabic Invasion
@@ramkashyap1356
I want to about the root cause from sir's view....