Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
James Whale Clashes With Guest Over JK Rowling And Kellie-Jay Keen
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 апр 2023
- Legendary TV and Radio host James Whale clashed with Freda Wallace, host of the Gender Nebulous Podcast, over JK Rowling and Kellie-Jay Keen's views on trans issues.
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
Who do you think came out of the discussion better?
Definitely not Freda 😂
James Whale because all of these SJWs and activists contradict themselves, talk in word salad and don't know what they want.
James did I agree with him 👍
Trans people lose every discussion because the ideology is based off of lies.
James
Men in women's spaces: this has happened with putting convicted male rapists in women's prisons. It happened in Britain. It is still happening in the US, where women have been raped and impregnated. It also happens with hospital wards, especially psychiatric hospitals, where extremely vulnerable women have no protection against violent men.
A woman in the NHS as a patient has been raped. She was not believed because they said that there were no men. For a whole year. Then the cctv footage ( that they’d had all along) proved that she was but the man who raped her said that he was a woman. Women are not safe and we will fight for our daughters and our spaces and our language.
I don't think Freda is able to really take this horrific fact in as he's too entrenched in identiy.
I agree. My dad worked in the prison system. In women's prisons, a woman officer should be present, when a male officer is there. He had to visit women's prisons occasionally, and was always accompanied by a female officer. The same applies to male prisons. A female should always have a male officer present at interviews at all times.
At the time, there were no male officers employed in women's prisons.
can you give me the source for 'male rapists in women's prisons'. so i can check for myself, i want to know the total amount of occurrences, and compare this to the total prison population; in NZ and other countries, prisoners may be divided into subgroups, and those with 'special needs' may be separated from the general population - does this happen in the UK
@@antdavisonNZ Nichola Sturgeon of SNP resigned from the backlash of allowing a violent double rapist into a women's prison. Isla Blair I think it was, real name Ian. He was fully intact and only decided to "identify" when he was convicted. His wife said he did it to get a soft sentence.
Kellie Jay is standing up for safe places for woman she is a heroine.
China put a robot as Facebook wife, western will just explode inside out, Tick Tock...the clock is ticking, gates thinks he is god, pharma will control people, uses children as troops.
Well said
And she is a woman
Kellie?
James its impossible to become the "opposite sex" as you stated. It just can't be done and never ever will.
So true, makes me laugh when they say transitioning, when it will never happen, thats where all the mental self loathing kicks in, and then they get a certain age and the pills stop working!
We are all sick and tired of it they need to repeal the GRA and return us to normality instead of the freak show calling the shots x
This dude, Fred, needs to stop invading women’s private spaces. It’s creepy and so is he.
Decent men don't want to invade women's spaces; the ones who do are the creeps.
When he said "where is the violence "vit was obvious he was off his trolley .
@M Jones I read that in America the last 5 school shooters were trans
Fred's a woman surely? That's not a bloke?
That sure is one. fine. woman.
He thinks he's entitled to women's sex based spaces because he's *female* now. He won't take no for an answer. That's some toxic masculinity right there lmao
He's not female; he thinks he's female. His reality stops when it conflicts with mine.
Right, odd how the male entitlement is somehow so damn prevalent in them, isn't it.
@@ron88303 *His fantasy stops when it conflicts with my reality.
That’s a bloke!!!!!
@@annalisam9999 You phrased it better than me.
'Who's violent?' He knows exactly how violent these people are.
What a liar he is..
Why would any woman want a hateful man calling her “cis” on her show? He has no respect whatsoever, not even for himself.
absolutely my birth certificate says female...not CIS female...nobody asked me if i was ok with that term..im not...but they insist on using it and my non compliance is somehow erasing THEIR rights and identity?? any one in the medical professon claiming there is more than two genders or that women can have penises (delusional) or that im a chest feeder. (dehumanising)..either needs to be sacked or go back to school...End of.
Can somebody please pass Freda a dictionary and point out what the word 'female' actually means? Because it's pretty specifically a category of biology, and he's not included in it 🤨
Disingenuous man in a dress. KJK's events are about letting women speak, and that's what she DOES, man in a dress.
That’s not a woman - that’s a bloke!
It’s Kellie Keen poundshop Myra Hindley, bought and paid for by Westbro Baptist Church
so you're a man I'm glad you clear
Kelly-Jay Keen provides a platform for women to speak about their own lived experience. Why is this offemsive?
It's not offensive to me. The people that think it's offensive ARE offensive to me.
It's offensive to these men pretending to be women, because it reinforces their male biology and negates their desire to force society to acquiesce to their delusion/fetish.
unless they speak against Kellie Jay Keen then they're not allowed to speak
Because certain MEN feel excluded because they are not biological women. It couldn’t be more ridiculous; they think woman is a costume to be put on and we are not living breathing adult human females!
Kellie-Jay most definitely does a lot for women. Freda wouldn't know because Freda isn't one.
@Anna Freda does nothing for women but causes harm when advocating for himself to come into a woman’s space
Fred is the antithesis of Kelly-Jay
How lovely to so bigoted
"you’re talking bollox, Freda.” Hahahah. Yup.
The only transition anyone should go through is puberty.
Stay out of women's private spaces! Simple. And some of these men are barging in there.
Teachers can't keep secrets for a child. It's against professional code of conduct.
Not sure about that. If the child confides in the teacher that some illegal activities are happening at home, the teacher has obligation to report for instance. But in terms of sexuality, this is a very very very grey area.
@@stratfordbaby ofc he's not talking about illegal activity or abuse. And the question is not sexuality, is gender identity, way different.
@@stratfordbaby it's in the schools safe guarding that we arent allowed to say we will keep a secret because if you then go and break that promise they may never trust you or another adult again.
By far the majority of schools have disclosed that they do not inform parents.
They're doing it ..
Giving Voice to women is Doing much More for Women than Most politicians
Freda tells us everything we need to know about him we he talks about the prison thing and frames it entirely around "risk". This isn't just about risk. This is also about women in prisons being *unwilling* to bunk and shower with men. Any man who disregards that because *he* feels *his* need or desire to bunk and shower with them supercedes that lack of consent on the women's part *is a predator*. Period. But like any entitled man, when women say no his answer is "I'm not dangerous" and he proceeds to disregard the "no".
@murderoustendencies 100% agree
^^^ this 💯👍
ANY biological male (REGARDLESS of self-ID'd "gender") who priotizes HIS OWN individual "validation", above the right to privacy, dignity and safety of ALL women and girls, is the absolute LAST man, who should be allowed in female spaces.
The men who self-ID as "trans woman", and invite themselves into women's bathrooms, are the men with the LEAST respect, and the MOST blatant, open contempt, for women and girls.
Someone who tells kids "This is our secret. We dont have to tell your parents" is a danger to children.
No James you haven’t got friends who have changed sex and have a great life, you have got friends who have a great life.
Don’t normally agree with James but I’m with him on this.
Kelly-Jays message is very supportive of women. The trans community are upset because even they can see the holes in their argument.
I don’t know how anybody can have any respect for a “feminist” who seems perfectly fine with Nazi presence at her rallies or spends more time raving about removing the rights of a minority than they do fighting any other cause.
Please recall what happened to Kellie-Jay in New Zealand when she was set upon by an angry baying mob comprising trans and trans activists: 9.23 onwards - quote from 'Freda' " We're not a trans society, we're not like a club where we all meet and decide to be angry at something…' That is EXACTLY what happened in New Zealand FFS.
It also happened about a year ago to Julie Jaman in Port Townsend Washington when her YMCA banned her for telling a man to leave the shower room.
TRA’s say Be Kind (or else) and live by DARVO
The only reason people may not seem to have a problem with him in real life is fear. Confronting a man in a women's restroom is pretty frightening for most women. If not afraid of assault, there is still concern about the trans tantrum.
It’s not just the trans who tantrum - any males who are fond of crossing women’s boundaries for sport tend to go off like a toddler when told ‘no’.
Nobody will stop me standing up to them…from a Natural Womban. A Mother so I know 100% I’m a Natural Womban…and btw … don’t need to play Dress Up to look like and be a Womban. End of.
On 3 occasions I have had men in the shop changing rooms! It was very distressing.
No one can become the opposite sex
It would be interesting to know if Freda is a full transgender, autogynephilic, or a tranvestite. The problem is that all three shelter under the umbrella term 'Trans'. It's a problem because they are all different and have different motives and agendas. That is why there is confusion.
Autogynophile whether it's had the chop or just wearing the clothes & taking hormones
That's what I've always said. Women are supposed to just accept any man who says he's trans or else we're bigots. I've personally got no problem sharing a space with someone like Blaire White - it's the autogynephilic men that I don't want in female spaces. And no trans women in female sports either.
Freak of nature will suffice.
People with gender dysphoria are going back to using transsexual now, just to get away from association these people.
If you see them on TV, RUclips, etc. the chance of them not being autogynephilic is very low. Someone who has actual dysphoria will very seldom appear in this context. Obviously there are a few exceptions but they would never argue for men being in women's spaces(or sports etc.) like this and they're also able to admit to being men.
To the guest: The parents surely know their children better than all these figures, so do not pretend that you are saving a child by encouraging him or her to do things in secret without involving the parents...
Fred is the type of person I would never leave alone with a child.
Straight away. You can not change sex. It’s magical thinking.
Observe how quickly the media and this vile movement forget about Nashville.
And Galashiels…
😂😂😂 nobody can change sex, nobody is born in the wrong body and they need to LEAVE THE KIDS ALONE.
Freda seems like a right creep.
Wear your lipstick and blouses but stay the hell out of women's spaces.
It said it its self " it's an identity " so it's still male not female, just defeated it's own argument.
The respect that they DEMAND is never going to be given when they dont respect the people they are trying to be ...WOMEN
Julia is one of the best newscaster interviewer, Julia is brilliant. I can’t stand listening to these people, attention seeking people, that’s all they are.
The problem is: they're getting the attention.
No you haven't got friends that have become the opposite sex, it's not possible.
I'm not 'cis' anything, a term I find offensive. I'm a woman simple as that.
Scary fella would not like him in my changing room never mind my wife’s
Give them their own Sports and Bathrooms and Change Rooms. Then, if they go into Women's Rooms, ARREST them. If you have to transition, it means you are not a woman.
And even when they transition they're still not a woman. A woman is an adult female and no amount of feelings or amputation and drugs can make you one. We are born that way and will forever remain that way until we die.
People that criticize JK Rowling are truly some of the worst on my opinion … how dare criticize a literacy genius who gave us such a magical adventure .
Also why would trans people insist soo much to be called a woman .. u should be happy to define urself as trans.
By wanted to be identify as a woman , forgive if I’m wrong , but sound like u not very happy of who you became .
You should ( as you are and have been over years) carry fighting for justice and recognition for trans people not for a gender change
James did spctacular, The guest was talking rubbish, and he is right, they never answer.
Fred is a very selfish individual. Why should real women take the abuse activists dish out? Why should a real woman be put into situations that they are at risks from a penis? Why should women put up with violence for saying men with penises stay out of women's places? If Fred thinks he is a woman he'd better shut his mouth and put up with the abuse that these men are throwing at real women.
James you not cis, cis is a derogatory word made up to insult you by people who won't accept they are men or women. Please challenge if a future guest calls you a cis.
This person is a man not a woman.
Drag queen story time for children. Madness.
Drag Queen story time began with the readers dressed as Panto Dames and reading traditional Grimms fairy tales…or stories the parents picked and then the queen would lead conversation about the story’s themes.
Not today, it’s now a platform for stupid people to spew their nonsense.
So they can’t accept themselves for who they are …but they try and force us to accept them for pretending they’re something else. 🤔🤯
Clearly the decimation of our MH Services has taken its toll!
A man in a dress is a cross dresser, not a real woman and never ever will be and to expect me to pretend so as not to hurt your little feelings is way over the top. Your a man and always will be no matter how hard you try to kid yourself and people should help them by telling them the truth instead of joining in the lies
You said a MAN in a dress. No need to say he's not a real woman.
Women do not invite men into the sisterhood.We were not asked. Ex-wives, that is, trans widows, are left holding the bag financially and emotionally. Info: Ute Heggen YT channel
We are not Cis!!! Absolutely no need for that word at all!!
What the bloody hell is that ffs…why the Labelling of EVERYBODY anyway..dangerous game.
Totally agree with you James . Oh my god this is so ridiculous. This person is unbelievable and should stay off social media
Three men was hanging around jks home the police had to remove them on FACT.leave us WOMEN and children alone this person needs to be in reality.disgusting Man needs to get the facts of what's being taught behind our backs.
This is a great video for anyone who wants to explain what gaslighting means…😂
Keep the groomers ideas out of the school.
The thing is, whenever you see these men, it becomes immediately obvious why they don't want to be who they are! It must be painful hating yourself that much. No wonder they are so angry.
Ditto just said the same , how sad and angry they all seem to be
Trans want acceptance as normal, that’s the problem.
how would you feel if your life and existence was being made into a debate
Women are mostly polite, do not like to make a fuss and empathetic. These attributes are fantastic but sometimes are to our detriment. Speak up, shout and no means no.
This is all madness.
If i am a man who identifies as a woman , but I am still attracted to women in todays world that makes me a lesbian.
Utterly ridiculous that we've reached this point in our evolution.
So funny that ‘she’ says KJK isn’t challenged!! If New Zealand isn’t being challenged then I’d hate to see what is!!!
Violence is all they've got.
Schools should only teach the mechanics of sex i.e. how to avoid getting pregnant and how to avoid catching sexually transmitted diseases. The rest is so close to paedophilia, it should not be discussed with teachers, as far too many have an agenda they want to push onto our children. This would free up time to teach the 3 R's, somthing sadly neglected in today's schools.
A lot of parents will save their children from a lifetime of medicalization
I wouldn't feel safe around "Freda", Freda comes across as an angry man who'd swing for me if I didn't agree to call him she
Well you can bet he hasn't changed anything surgically so just one swift kick would render him incapacitated 😂😂
@@Lass1888
🤣
I'm a woman living in Melbourne, a couple months, I went to use the toilets in the city... There was a line. Low and behold, a man (early 20s), walks out of one of the cubicles. No one said anything. He stared at us with this awkward smile on his face. It looked like he was waiting for someone to say something.
I was in my work uniform so couldn't risk saying anything. But my god, I did want to.
He got away with it. He'll do it again.
This cult has given these creeps permission to completely abolish the boundaries.
You can't become the opposite sex James, as you said your friends have .
I don't blame Julia for not wanting Freddy on her show, he is a complete was of time, doesn't answer any questions what so ever.
you should just let him speak more , we need to hear the stupidity
Hell hath no fury like a trans woman's wrath.
Trans Man.
Can't belive they kept it on after James told it not to smoke and it did anyway.
lol notice Freda feels proud a woman is frightened of her, yet she won't stand up to these men
Him!
Thou shall not lie doesn’t apply to trans
You know what you are not. I know what you are not. You can’t convince us of what you wish you were. I’m a woman….no prefix of Cis needed, FREDA.
In this world where the tail wags the dog,the dog needs to grow a pair and bite back.
I’m laughing…he’s just ridiculous 🤡👍😅⚠️
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT
THEY ARE LOONIES,FRED HE'S DEFINITELY A LOONIE, JULIA HARTLEYBREWER WOULD RUN RINGS ROUND HIM😂
Have to say...Freda has balls. She even speaks balls too.
i find the best way to deal with these people is to ignore them completely
They're not Trans they're in a Trance!!
What a dirty nasty person 😮 Thank you James ❤
Kellie Keen and her Nazi friends?
Ash's face at that caller, what the hell was she even saying?
He.
I'm surprised he let the caller went on for so long. I couldn't understand a thing they was saying
Fred wants to be a normal person 😂
Please keep platforming this troon. He is great for peaking any neutrals.
Trans expert liars.
Repeal the GRA, the whole thing needs to go.
The person vaping is your typical unprofessional trans
Parents aren’t shaming their minor children, they are educating them about reality and teaching them that schools are not looking out for their best interests by indoctrinating them into believing in this trans ideology. This is a clear definition of grooming children. A parent has every right to teach their children “their” values and realities, against the wishes of they, them, their who have an agenda to transition children. If the groomers were to leave children alone, we’d leave these deviants alone.
3 men talking about women's rights. One of them a liar, delusional and entitled, guess which one lol😂
"Freda" is so obviously not a "female", despite their protestations.
Freida looks like a very happy person!!. No problems here!
Well said James, I agree with you 100%
That first caller would have hung up couldn't understand a word she sounded pissed up
I am so happy I live on the International Space Station!
Love the Whale. I wish him all the best with his recovery. We need you around many more years James. Even those who don't like you or your positions need you as a foil. Keep strong mate.
Don't even give it airtime
Forget all this bollox about people who have a uterus, people who have a penis etc. Whatever you are wearing, or what you call yourself is neither here nor there. Males have XX chromosones, and females have XY. An archaeologist can find your bones in a thousand years time, and work out what you were when alive.
@barnaby hoofer Females are XX, males XY, but there are intersex conditions/disorders of sex development for males and females where they may have a different pattern, such as Klinefelters syndrome XXY, or Turners syndrome X, Swyer Syndrome XY where the gonads do not produce testosterone, and AIS or PAIS where either XX females or XY males may have different genital and reproductive organ development because their body is resistant to the androgens that instruct the development. Chromosomes do tell a large part of the story, but not always the whole story.
@Shelley Philcox are you aware what you've written here?
Except the people with XY and androgen insensitivity (I don't know the cause of it), the sex chromosomes tell the story.
If a person has only one X sex chromosome, she is a female and has Turner syndrome, or people with Swyer syndrome have normal XY but can't develop male sex organs because of a defect in Y chromosome, etc...
Your chromosomes contain any and every information about your physical body. How do you think your body is defined? By magic or chance?
Moreover, people with DSDs are around 0.5% of the entire population, and no sane person questions maleness or femaleness of these people. So, what is your point?
@@gamzecarsamba6273 The OP stated that females are XY and males are XX...I thought that needed correcting. Read it carefully.
What's your point?
@@shelleyphilcox4743 1. Point: your chromosomes contain your DNA, so they tell the whole story about your sex and body.
2. Point: 95.5% of people is either a female with XX, or a male with XY. There are similar amount of people as the people with DSDs, who were born with 6 fingers instead of 5. Would you feel the need to correct a person if s/he talked about that humans have 5 fingers?
People with DSDs are not in the middle, they are either male or female. Even if they were in the middle, or they could switch from one sex to the other, would that imply the notion that XY males can turn into women, or vice versa? NO. So, no need to mention them in every single trans related conversation.
@@gamzecarsamba6273 I'm going to try again, because you are projecting onto my words something I have not stated or implied in any way whatsoever.
Are males XX? This is what the OP wrote.
Are females XY? This is what the OP wrote.
Fact: Males are actually XY. This is what I wrote.
Fact: Females are XX. This is what I wrote.
You appear to agree with me on this, not the OP.
Sometimes people dont have pairs of chromosomes, they have 1 or 3, comprised of X or Y combinations. You dont dispute this, now people who thought that everyone has pairs now knows that is not always the case.
Moving on...people can have hormone conditions that can change the development of their gonads in gestation and have an affect on the later development of their bodies too.
Do the bones indicate if someone has AIS or PAIS ? This is entirely seperate to XY or XX analysis, but can cause ambiguity in gonad development and how ones body may be perceived in childhood or adulthood...and gonads are soft tissue, and not part of your skeleton/bones.
Having AIS or PAIS does not change whether you are male or female, that is determined by the presence or absence of a Y chromosome, but it can create ambiguity in the development of gonads.
I've been waiting for years to hear the answer to the million dollar question, "Why are trans people so angry?"
Sadly, this woman evaded the answer to this question, and so we will wait again..
Not a woman though.
@@littlecatfeet9064 Apologies... you're correct! I get as confused with their identities as much as them!!!! 🤣
Not a Womban.
@@kimauthor me too!
Fred hasn't got clue about women's rights, because he's a narcissistic man! KJK is a feminist hero!
James: "We've got friends who have changed sex"
🥴🤔 No you haven't though because you cannot change your sex 🤣
I consider Cis a slur and hate speech!
James is the best. One of a very few who will speak out. Don't always agree with him but only have utter admiration for him speaking his mind.