All new SKILSAW Worm Drive 48v Circular Saw Vs. Makita 36v Rear Handle Circular Saw. TOOL DUEL!!!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 авг 2024
- Today we put two monster circular saws up against each other. In today's Tool Duel, the all new Skilsaw 48v Worm Drive Circular Saw is going head to head with the Makita 36v rear handle saw. Only one can win, so don't forget to leave your vote in the comment section below!
Buy Here
Skilsaw Worm Drive Saw imp.i284638.net/D21A2
Makita Rear Handle Saw imp.i284638.net/r7bev
To say Skill has more power.... 48v vs 36
Makita bogged a little vs Skilsaw. Maybe because makita was making a deeper cut
Maybe compare both saws set at the same cutting depth
I’m too late with this obviously, but you’re right: both saws should be tested at the same depth of cut and then note that one could cut deeper if required. You can’t complain that a saw seems less powerful when it’s cutting several mil deeper.
Balance on a 'rear handle' saw doesn't matter. Once the saw is on the wood, it weighs nothing. Discharging the sawdust through the handle on the skilsaw might seem like a good idea until it gets clogged up with sappy green doug fir or pine. You will never see a framer with a vacuum hooked up to his saw, ever. The Makita is superior to the Skil in every real world situation. If you have the Makita saw, you likely have other Makita 18v tools. Makita has been in the cordless game so long, with so many great tools, there is no reason to buy the Skil.
except for power, but in my case i git an old bosh (skil) worm drive saw for the heavy duty work.
⁸⁸⁹⁹⁸988⁸⁹988⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹9⁸⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁸⁹⁸⁹⁹⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹8⁸⁸⁹9⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹9⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁸98⁸9⁸⁹⁸9⁸⁹9⁸98⁸9⁸⁹⁹98⁸⁹⁹⁸⁸⁸⁹⁸⁹⁹⁸9⁸8⁸⁸⁸⁸9⁸⁹⁹⁹⁸⁸⁹⁸⁸⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹⁹l
Absolutely agree 110% I just got the 18 X 2 36v 12" Makita miter saw and it's just like you said "superior in every way" to others and I noticed on Amazon they have pretty reasonably priced combos that come with 4X 5.0 ah batteries + the dual speed charger and a tool like the chainsaw or the blower there are a bunch + all the batteries are interchangeable 110% Makita ✊👍
MAKITA! Especially for price. Thanks Clint, and God bless! 😁👍
Tha6for the vote Dave!!!
Here's a cheer with a beer end a blue Thumb up
@@konamanstudio2447 KONOMAN! 🍻😁
the Makita is cutting more depth it takes more power set them both at the same depth and see how they do
No way I'm spending 240 bucks on a battery, cuz you will need a few. Makita wins for me
Thanks for the feedback Tim
Skill is the one with the 240dlls 🔋 that you can only use on that saw
The new Makita 40v batter for the rear drive is $200 for the 4ah. They’ll be about the same as the Skilsaw battery and the 4.0 isn’t the biggest battery but it’s pretty good considering it’s 40 volts. WH are the highest on the market with the Makita 40v batteries.
Plus is there’s a large 40v line vs just the 1 Skilsaw. That’s the killer.
Makita is the best I think I like the design performance relieabilty maintenance part even tho it isn't as powerful cause it's 36volt vs 48 oh and it has more cut depth
Putting a 1 year warranty on your tool speaks loudly enough about the crap they're putting on the market. MAKITA all day.
These are the two saws that ride in my truck and I have to say that I definitely reach for the Makita more often. Neither of these saws are in any way bad tools but if I had to pick one to run every day for just cutting framing lumber it would have to be the Makita. There's no contest when it comes to power, the winner being the skil. You don't really notice that power much until you're cutting wet treated or something that tends to bog down a saw. The cordless Skilsaw will honestly outpower the corded versions I'm used to. Anyway, the reason I tend to reach for the Makita is honestly weight and balance. For most of the normal crosscuts in 2x lumber you won't notice much of a difference in weight but the second you turn it sideways to rip a sheet of plywood leaning up or throw it over your head for a few minutes you'll notice the difference. The batteries don't really matter much they both seem to die when you're in the rafters hanging by one arm upside down like any battery operated tool. Last point against the skil is the dust extractor thing, It works ok under ideal conditions but ripping wet yellow pine or treated it WILL clog up on you and clearing it out can be a pain.
The skilsaw has more power where as the makita bogs down
Thanks for tools comparison! Would be awesome to see DeWalt dcs577 alongside them.
In my country Makita + 4 5ah batteries costed me around 500$.
DeWalt rear handle + 2 3ah(54-60v) would cost around 700$+ shipping, and the worm drive Skil with 2batteries would be around 1k$.
So I stick with Makita. But I think either of them is a great tool and they're pretty damn close to each other. And it is stupid to decide without closer look on their other tools lineup.
So your country is also run by a bunch of M.F. thieves like Costa Mierda is ?
@@dougtilaran3496 all that and more
Thanks for the review of the skill saw..I definitely considering buying one
makita is a better way to spend your money between the 2. you can use the batteries on the makita on your other makita tools, makita is powerful, and dont forget way cheaper
Thanks for the vote Zachary!!!!
I like the Makita better Bro,Awesome saw wow I love it :)
Thanks for the feedback TJ!!!
I’m spoiled by Mikita! Love them!
Yeah you can't go wrong with them. Thanks for the vote Average Gurl!!!
I recently bought the makita rear handle saw and i did notice it has a port on the right side where you can connect a vacuum line
I like the dust coming out thr handle but when I get mine I will be looking for the things you dont like and see if I dont like them as well
Did the makita bog down more because of the depth. You should do cuts at the same depth.
Prob I was thinking that it takes more torque to cut deeper depth the skil wouldn't have had it as hard cause has smaller saw blade
I've had the Makita for a while, but finally broke down and got the skilsaw. I just never felt right using a bastardized sidewinder as my primary circular saw. The biggest thing I love about the Skil is that it's a real tool, built the way it's ancestors have been for 80 years. I really hate that with the move to cordless, tools have gone from something you buy and use for a career to things that are at best only intended to last until the battery platform becomes obsolete. The Skil feels different- it's literally the classic worm drive design with a big battery plunked on the back. Which a lot of people use as a knock on it, but that is exactly what I want. And I think the concern about using a different battery system is a little overblown. While I agree that all else being equal it's nice to keep on one system, for a cornerstone tool like a circular saw, which is quite power hungry, you're pretty much going to have a battery (or set of batteries for Makita) dedicated to that tool anyway. So does it really matter if it is a different system? And yes it's heavy; so what? My great grandpa built houses in the 50s with an 8 1/4 worm drive that was 20+ lbs. Man up.
Dang that's hard to ignore in the future I'm leaning toward a proven worm drive saw
I have this makita saw it's beautiful to work with
I like the makita because it's more compact and the batteries can be used in my other tools aswell
Great video Clint killer comparison
Skillsaw the vest like always smashing my like botton kaboooooooooooooom
Skil has great dust extraction tho... And power for days
I purchase the Makita and why I did it has nothing to do with the price, power or battery. Those are all good metrics when judging a tool, but they don't get at what makes a good tool for an individual user. It's been my experience when a tool stops being noticed in your hand, and integrates with you, that's the gold standard for tools ( vision, hands, brain and body). After a few cuts I learned the behavior of the saw and it become an extension of me and my cuts were faster, cleaner and more accurate. As a side note, If your worried about saw power, keep sharp blades on it. Pros - feel, balance, weight, line of site. Cons - I had to spend money
Very nicely done sir, I like the power of the Skil , the batteries of the Makita to go with rest of the tool line. Do these 2 come in corded version ? How do they compare to the Mag 77?
Merry Christmas and Thanks for sharing your thoughts and videos Rodney
Hi Rodney! No corded for the Makita in this style but Skil has a few of them corded in this style. Haven't tried the Mag so can't give you an honest answer buddy
Makita does have the corded version of this
@@Mario9462 nah it doesn't
At David Potter sorry bro you are 100% mistaken. Makita absolutely has a corded rear handled 7-1/4” circular saw and has for A LONG TIME.
Would be nice if the exhaust on the skil saw could move toward the front of the saw.
I like the skil because of the worm drive. It would be nice if it had the makita positive stops. I like the markings on the depth gage on the SKIL. Con on the SKIL is it is a Mountain Dew killer. Definitely need a dust bag on the SKIL. I am going with the SKIL *(wormdrive)
Errrrr, two mountain dews gone to soon bro!!!!. Yeah, the dust isn't so bad at 90, but the bevel definitely aims it straight for DA FACE!!!! Thanks for the vote John!!!!
My friend haven't seen you for a while but here's a thumbs up and cheers with a beer
Anyone know if I can fit 6AH batteries on the makita? Cant find it online
Yes
Yo you forgot that makita has a dust extraction port also that has a nice rubber plug in it when comes out of the box look on the front right and remove that for attaching the dust collection hose, might want to add an update to your video as you say it doesn’t have a feature it has. I choose the makita great saw and it’s all about the battery and lineup.
Your right and I actually forgot about that. I'll edit the video. Thanks for pointing that out
Makita for the win. Lighter and more efficient. Cheaper batteries that control over 250 different Makita tools. Reliable Hypoid gearing. No adding of oil to the self destructing worm drive gears. Reviewer complains of the tool bogging down...No that's the Makita brushless motors Automatic speed control lowering the RPM to give more the tool more torque, thus protecting the motor. The only advantage the Skil has, which is truly epic, is the dust management. But is that enough?...I think not. Great review though. you nailed all the testing. keep it up. Just do a little more research first.
what is that big ass brick hanging off the end of that skil saw, ?maybe for bashing someone over the head at your job site when they try to grab your tools.
I like the skill, with 48v off grid system you could mount it upside down and use it as a table saw with vacuum on the handle. Just have to make a custom attachment for power connection. Why not just use inverter and 110v or 220v regular table saw? Because this saw will do most of what you need and up to 40% energy savings if you keep DC to DC.
I do not like the dust discharge on the Skilsaw. Seems like a good idea at first but becomes clear it can be an issue if it becomes clogged. The Makita gets a thumbs up because of the number of tools that can use the batteries. I have an older (14 Years +) battery-powered Makita drill set and they perform as well today!! That is saying allot. Makita comes with a Bag!
And this saw is on sale at HomeDepot and you get two free batteries as well. I went with this option to get the extra batteries for other tools. The new Makita battery platform will be compatible with the current system as well.
I forgot to mention, great vid brother!
Thanks brother 👊
I gave you a thumbs-up on both of your comments but I'm only doing it on this one combining cheers with a beer you maybe need to
@@konamanstudio2447 cheers and a beer with KONAMAN!!
Makita; because it did cut deeper, and Skil needs to work on their dust extraction! Dewalt does have a Skil corded look a like, but I don't know how powerful it is! Could you please do a test revue on that.
Is there any particular reason at the skill saws all have the blades on the left side and I would definitely cat some sort of vacuum hookup purchase a saw dust bag just to stop it from shooting all over the place
Hmmm, great question but not really sure bro. Maybe @skilsawstaytrue can help answer this question?
Better sight line of the blade for right handed people.
@@drewt9829 thank you for helping me with my question really appreciate it thank you
@h2s really I did not know that thank you for your comment thanks I just figured they had it on the left side because usually you're doing a lot of cuts and it's just easier to see the line but did not know that they have them on the right side
Two absolute deal breakers against the Skil - no battery platform and the totally screwed up dust extraction. Makita all day.
I been used skilsaw and I love it but on cordless makita is the best by far
Just received my Skilsaw last week!! Thing is a creature. Bought mine at Menards, wish I would’ve waited and bought it from Acme so I could have got the free battery deal :( . Hopefully as they come out with more cordless tools the batteries will drop a little in price.
Yeah that deal is pretty good. You could probably return it and still get the deal from acme?
I’m not the bullish on them releasing more tools. Their brand is to specialize in one product. Seems unlikely.
They simply went cordless because that’s what the industry calls for nowadays.
I got the Makita deal super good deal, specially since i have other cordless tools from them. Just one thing wish Makita saw had wich is a place in the tool for the wrench it comes with to change the blade . Plus all reviews that people are pointing at is the he bag that it comes with, i haven't been able to zip it close with saw and double battery charger. LoL
How long did those batteries last on both saws?
Skilsaw is a dust punisher if your left handed.
Lol yeah I could imagine, but really funny how you put that 🤣
That battery is a deal breaker, it's big and goofy and has no other use. What an oversight. They definitely designed the saw first, then made the biggest battery pack they could fit on the end of the handle. I have plenty of 18v makita batteries and tools to go with them. Easy decision
Skilsaw is coming out with a sidewinder not sure when am sure your rite about the table saw and miter saw in the future that thing is a monster battery does look like a charger I think ego battery looks about the same so does Craftsman battery for there ope lawnmower nice video thank you for sharing if I had a shop this would be good for me the new cordless wormdrive but a sidewinder works just fine
Thanks for the feedback and info buddy
Why does the makita cut deeper then the skil saw they have the same size 7 1/4 blade
Antonio Claudio Michael I’m assuming because of the shape of the saw. The Makita batteries are tucked kind of out of the way the skil battery is in the way maybe? I don’t know I have owned the Makita for 2 years now. Framing everyday and it has never let me down
@@lancekeiser8766 I spoke to my dad he use to build houses he told me some circular saws the shoe is higher up so more blade is exposed
Drill small hole through safety and pin or wire it over . Don’t have to halfway let go of saw to make cut. Can also use thumb on trigger with pinned safety. Yeah I’m a roof framer so there’s many situations where my thumb is my trigger finger. ESP with a gun.
For the 45 cuts install the hose adapter and point the sawdust away from your face
Great saw. But which is best for finish work. And seeing Skilsaw comes out with a true wormdrive cordless circular saw I can bet the others are working how to create their own.
@DougE oh now I see
@DougE yeah for sure they do. All the other rear handle saws are basically side winders
Worm saw is like MX125. Power is everything so I will go with the Skilsaw being bias from the old corded world.
Also cost goes to makita 230$ right now for the saw 4 batteries and a dual charger and bag deal
Think its 199 at acme with 2 batteries
300$ for kit.. Skil 400
400++
I paid 249.00 for the rear handle makita 4 batteries dual charger and bag,also the sidewinder makita with 4 batteries dual charger and bag for 249.00,both are excellent saws,like the rear handle the best,and I'm about to get another one
Makita because of their platform. I have the makita but I would still buy the skil.
Thanks for the fe Michael!!
My makita got run ovee by a 10 ton gradall and the batteries still work... Haha
Makita 36v rear handle circular saw is the Ferrari of rear handle circular saws. It’s not as powerful it’s not as robust but it’s sleek it’s smooth it’s light and those things just make the makita a better saw. If you want power the dewalt the skil saw the Milwaukee have tons of power but it’s just a matter of personal preference.
Makita's power seems to be better as it is deeper.
TRZ I am really really sorry to hear about your Mountain Dew you don't mess with a man's Mountain Dew. I do believe if the two blades on the saw were even in death I believe Makita would have smoked the skill saw. When you were letting us hear both of the saws rev up the Makita sounded like a dragster and the skill sounded like a VW Bug that's what I heard. Peace brother
Haha, thanks for the mountain dew condolences bro. It was definitely a sad day indeed. It sounds like a vote for Makita lol
Makita hands down. When you only have one dog in the fight it has to be a lot better than just real good. Once they have a table and miter saw added to the platform then and only then will they be taken seriously. In my humble opinion. 👍🏾
makita es the first battery saw that came on the market, I own 5 of then on 2 different crew and works like a champ, You can't go wrong with makita on battery, but on cord the champ es the skill
With cordless tools it's all about the battery platform. Makita has tons of tools that use 18v batteries so adding an Makita x2 tool is painless. Buying into then maintaining a whole new battery system just for one tool is stupid. I wouldn't buy the Skilsaw over the Makita even if it were twice as good, which it clearly isn't....One more note, I just purchased 2 aftermarket 6ah Vanon batteries for the Makita platform for $24 each delivered. That's 1/5 the cost of a the Skilsaw battery which can only be used on the skilsaw.
I own the Makita and love it. Great battery life and very smooth. Reagood warranty too. It can feel under powered sometimes. If you are ripping lvls then Dewalt would be the best choice.
That dewalt 60v is a beast 👊
YO TRZ! I dont believe you wasted the mountain dew. I think you were smart enough (or not) to drink it then fill it with water or whatever. If you did waste the mountain dew I going to have to let you go as my lookout. Dont worry you'll receive a "very nice like" severance package.
Haha, bro you always make me laugh. Your the man👊
Move it up to mill and dewalt? Wtf...the makita is better then the mill and dewatl?
Battery too expensive, you can get 4-5 5mah Makita batteries for the same price... you know... the batteries you use in all of your other tools... No brainer. Sure the Skil is slightly better. I'm sad that Makita didn't add a vacuum port. That would absolutely have sealed the deal for me, as I have to cut indoors a lot.
Noah Zork it does have 1 it’s plugged up out of the box u have to take it off he forgot to mention it
Skilsaw looks fantastic if I hadn't just bought Milwaukee I would have definitely gone to the skil
I have the Milwaukee. I love it and think it’s better than everything except the latest Makita 40V. That’s my new favorite. Wish the Milwaukee had positive stops though. That’s the only thing I don’t like but it is smooth for the adjustments.
Easily the Skilsaw. Makita can't come close.
Why is this a comparison? The skil is a worm drive and the Makita is just a regular saw with a rear handle.
Both great saws. Haven’t used the new Skilsaw but I do own the Makita. And yes, the Makita is the Ferrari of saws it’s so smooth and effortless to use. Until they expand the battery platform Makita gets the edge.
Can't disagree with you there Treeboss. Thanks for the vote bro!
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO WITH THAT MONSTER SKIL BATTERY, USELESS OTHER THAN THAT ONE TOOL. MAKITA, CAN USE 18V BATTERIES ALONG ENTIRE TOOL LINE, 18V TOOLS AND 36 VOLT TOOLS. MAKITA IS A NO BRAINER TO PURCHASE!
your cutting more depth so it should cut easier.
Makita are well made and reliable and very smooth motors.
Corded wise, Skilsaw is used by the majority of framers. Skilsaw needs to really up their game with all this cordless technology.
I have some questions. As far as i.know dewalt.does not.make a worm drive batt saw just a worm drive STYLE saw. Kind of like the knock off styer augs vs the real augs from austria. So in the front of ur video u mentioned something about dewalt but as far as i know dewalt is not a true worm drive please correct if I'm wrong
You are correct Sam. The only real wormdrive is Skil. Others are just (wormdrive style) rear handle saws
@@ToolReviewZone but also to clarify worm drive is in fact the gearing mechanics behind making the blade spin imparting more torque so then the Makita u showcased is also just worm style or rear handle so then if I want a battery worm o need skill but the Makita looked tasty too
@@samrowe2889 yeah, I believe the rear handle saws are basically sidewinders configured a bit differently
@@ToolReviewZone thank u I'll be looking heavily into the skill
Used both but makita is waaaay betterrr and way cheaper
Skil needs maintenance and it can be smelled oil.
Iv used every saw and the Makita is by far the best. You Don’t need to buy different battery’s to use it. 18v batteries go to 90% of there tools. Also A Full charge in like 20 min and that’s great in fast paste work. I do the roof structures on commercial warehouse buildings and I use the Makita for landing.im constantly cutting studs and laps witch are 4x8 plywood sheets 1/2, 3/4,5/8 sheets. I do use 4 batteries to do a full 8 hour day job. Got two working and two charging. It’s funny cuz all the old heads at work told me it wouldn’t be any good and that it won’t last all day or it’s not going to have the power for what we do at work. they were sure wrong cuz now all the formans went out to buy there own after a week of me using it . Makita is just a beast.i cant wait to buy there chainsaw next
I'm big and strong...and good lookin. I can carry 2 hundered foot extension cords to run my Bosch worm or Makita Hypoid ! $250 US failed pesos gets me a lot of cordage !
When talking circular saws it starts and stops with skilsaw worm drive mag77
Team Makita
The skill did it better then the makita but to much dust out the skill.
Makita all the way.
Makita all day long .
It's kind of sad to be honest. As a framer, the skilsaw was always number 1. I don't understand how the makita compares or beats their saw. This is the first battery tool they've launched. You'd think they'd blow the fish out of the water... But its literally just as good as any other wormdrive battery packed thing out there. Super disappointed. Mind you. The company was sold a while ago... so yah.
Makita
Just picked this saw up for $144 with the HD HACK
Same here couldn't pass on the deal
@@DON_TOOLS did you returned the battery?
@@robertopics kept them since im not in the makita platform
@@DON_TOOLS I have an array of cordless tools but I might go all in on k either Makita or Milwaukee.
@@robertopics im in the milwaukee line have most of their impact wrenches m12/m18
Only a Skilsaw fanboy will choose it over the Makita or Dewalt for the simple fact the battery on the Skil is single tool use only If you need a cordless saw chances are you already have many other dewalt or makita batteries. I don't know about the rest of you but i don't want to add another battery and charger to my ecosystem for a very small if any performance increase of a cordless tool not to mention battery price.
When it comes to power the skil saw has the advantage because it's a worm drive provides more torque. But skil saw is still fairly pricey.
The only reason I'm looking at the Makita is because it's less expensive. The problem is most inventory has been sitting on home Depot shelves since 2018 which has me concerned about the batteries..
These videos should be looked at as for entertainment only. No one that works with these machines for a living would use them as shown here. Different variables need to be concider which render these results inconsistent. For example depth adjustment according to material being cut, blade type and sharpness, battery load, user force being applied during cut, material being cut, and width of blades. Comparing one saw to the other is like comparing apples to oranges. In my opinion either saw is great if you're making money with it. Otherwise both are useless if the operator can't use them.
That dust..discharge...it is a bitch...if you cutting up on the ladder a stud..in front of your face..like up above your face...if the wind blows...its all over your face...there was no reason for that feature...
I am a framer. I own a cordless Skill and the company uses Makita. I love my Skill. It comes with a vacuum attachment and it lets you direct saw dust where you want it to go and that is really nice. Take it from a pro Skill is the better saw.
The company you work for are even more pro than you and they went with makita
makita for the quality
This head to head is totally pointless !! They are both very good saws the makita is a standard drive saw with a rear handle and the skilsaw is a wormdrive ? Its like doing a head to head drill test but only one has hammer action then saying one was way better drilling concrete ... both are good but they are different tools more suited to different applications
Makita. Just better overall.
I bought one. It was a fortune and one battery died almost immediately. Nothing but stall and excuses from Skil till the warranty expired, and THAT was their new excuse. Not to be trusted. The new battery is about the cost of a Skil corded saw.
And quality the skill saw but for bang for the buck I have to go with the Makita I got mine with 2 batteries for $95 I can't complain but you would complain if I didn't say cheers with a beer
Wow, that's one hell of a deal bro!
That is a great deal Depot had it for $169 on clearance. I bought mine for $250 with 4 batteries and thought that was a deal.
@@milanroets9697 it was on clearance at Home Depot and it didn't have the charger with it I already had a charger when I won subcompact from cup tools and they gave me a dual charger and a 2 Amp battery if I didn't have that's already I wouldn't have bought the other
I do t like the makita dust extractor soon As the shoe makes contact with the wood the dust extractor just spits the dust all over your work as well as the saw I think the skil saw won this tool dual
Makita might have less power than the skil but more than enough power to get the job done for any rough framer.. Makita equals lighter saw, fastest charging time out there, best run time and at least 150$ cheaper.. Eazy decision.. MAKITA ALL DAY
Where are each of the saws manufactured? That is the deal breaker for me
Waste? Wut? Drink that shit... Puts hair on your chest.