Man poor pilots like imagen your just flying your ship and you find a bunch of your generals just dead and you offer one of them help and they tell you and your brother (the second pilot) to stand down like just imagen the clones just thinking why are they doing this we didnt do anything we fly our ships for them and this is how they thank us this is outrageous it's unfair like seriously just imagen that for a moment
@@goldenpro1096 Honestly I love that you honed in on that, because I wrote it to communicate the distrust between clone and Jedi at that moment. But it's really cool how something I didn't think twice about could really mean so much
@@PentePatrolStarWars it's those little details that fir some reason I pay alot of attention to and also helps that I really love the clones so when I heard this I immediately thought of the clones perspective so yeah oh and thanks for responding your a bug youtuber and I dont really get responses from big youtubers so thank you for your time one fellow youtuber to a other :)
This would be in a world set in the Multiverse, where she doesn’t get immediately decked in Episode 3. Because, they flat out offed her- Order 66 style. Barely any screen time, just a Full on death.
Honestly a Jedi would've 100 percent been a better partner for Anakin. Padme wouldn't have understood and didn't understood most of Anakin's feelings or his anger due to her not knowing jack about the force, or the Jedi, she only knew politics , Aayla or perhaps any other female Jedi would've sense those feelings and would've helped Anakin with his feeling and dark side urges
While I'll ship Anakin x Padmé until I die, Anakin and Aayla would have had a healthier relationship than Anakin and Padmé. They were both slaves and they would have had a good relationship and understanding of each other. Slave mentality is definitely an heavy effect to this. Padmé and Anakin's relationship could have worked for sure and could have an understanding of each other, but they would need more communication therapy.
I’m not sure Aayla Secura would be interested in a relationship with Anakin, who was 7 years younger than her. She was 2 years older than Padme Amidala. Also, Aayla reached the rank of Jedi Knight 7 years before Anakin did. Aayla had a brief romantic relationship with Nautolan Jedi Master Kit Fisto, who saved her life during the Battle of Mon Calamari. Had it not been for their duties as Jedi Generals during the Clone Wars, their relationship may have progressed further.
"You aren't on this council, but we grant you the rank of master" Anakin: What? How can you be a master, and not be on the council? Mace: Don't take a seat.
I absolutely loved this one. The fact that you portrayed their relationship. I absolutely respect this kind of love. This was exactly what Anakin deserved.
Gotta be honest, I would totally ship this relationship more than Padmé x Anakin. Aayla’s character deserved more screen time imo and the way she was murdered in RoTS was just heartbreaking
Well to be fair they did it like that because they respected her. They wanted her death to be quick and so the kept shooting to make sure she died fast
The original version of her death was a lot worse. After she was shot multiple times an AT-TE Clone Walker steps on her corpse. I don't remember which youtuber had shown the deleted cuts but if you can find the deleted cuts it has a lot.
I love anakin and Padme, and without them we wouldn’t have the original trilogy. But padme despite her good heart and kind demeanor she just wasn’t right for him. In attack of the clones when anakin told her he slaughtered a whole village of Tuskans she just shrugged it off like it didn’t happen. If she would’ve distanced herself then I believe he would’ve been better off.
I honestly think Aayla could've been a real romantic interest for Anakin, or at least a best friend, from his time in the temple. He was a former slave, and her people (Twi'leks) were often targeted for enslavement. This would've been a common ground they could've bonded over.
What if Saesee Tiin trained Anakin? Both were outsiders as padawans so maybe Tiin would be able to understand Anakin alot better than Obi Wan, Plus alongside Plo Koon they're the best pilots in the Jedi Order.
That would be a lot of fun! That's the one thing I regret not including in the 'Plo Koon Trained Anakin' video about the piloting relationship between the two... I think it'd be a lot of fun to do here!
Saesee might have turned out badly though, since he's pretty prejudiced about anything resembling the Dark Side if I remember correctly. Anakin being naturally more receptive to the Dark because of his attachments he couldn't let go of might have led Saesee to think badly of him, although I'm sure he would move past it. Very underrated Jedi in general
@@PentePatrolStarWars This is something else about Obi-Wan. They apparently had very few or no interests in common. Their friendship is purely through shared trauma, and war wounds. Anakin loves Flying Obi hates it Anakin cares for his droids Obi sees them as tools Anakin hates the world politics Obi-Wan has a great deal of political canny, and even takes part in Jedi schemes, multiple times at Anakins expense (but no time more blatant than in EP. III) Anakin wants to both be a Jedi, and Love Padme Obi-Wan saw his love for Satine as a 'if not the Jedi, then Her'
@Mackenzie Bauroth I think he'd be great, especially interesting because he was forced out of the High Council right before RotS. With Eeth and Ahsoka forced out, what would Anakin have done
While this would have been a deep spiritual relationship, which would have been very beneficial for both Jedi, and perhaps even a dyad in the force, which would have allowed Aayla to either survive the force lightning or Anakin sense it ahead of time, Aayla and Anakin would have been sent on many missions together, including undercover missions, and I am sure that there would have been occasional moments of intense lust (the two hottest people in the Jedi order, come on).
As much as I love anakin and padme I definitely think anakin and aayla could have worked and would have been a great relationship. Yes that doesn't mean anakin and padme was destined to end in a tragedy that relationship could have also worked but there was a much better chance of aayla and anakin having a happy ending so to speak than padme and anakin.
Me going into this video: "Oh, you're slashing him with the scantily clad jedi twi'lek. Uh-huh." Me barely a few minutes into the video: "This is actually a great love story...and infinitely better than Padme and Anikin..." Edit: At the end there, I loved every second of it. A MUCH more satisfying story here than in the prequels. Excellent.
Personally, while I think that Aayla and Anakin would have had a better relationship than Anakin and Padme the entire Rush Clovis/Scipio scenario would have turned out differently as Anakin would have been in a relationship with Aayla already (given the Lurmen events) and therefore never guarded Padme since the choice was to keep on eye on his "secret" girlfriend. Although it's a well-done and well-thought out concept of the Clone Wars it seems more likely that they would have made each other better and had a greater chance to understand the other's feelings via the Force, but I doubt that Aayla would have necessarily joined Anakin to Palaptine's office as Palpatine was stated to have had an almost fatherly relationship with Anakin since the Battle of Naboo. Though not necessarily making it NSFW it's likely the reunions between Aayla and Anakin could have been intimate (more likely sharing abed, not necessarily sexual)
I honestly think it would've been a sexually intimate relationship but I don't think Anakin would've been the Jedi involved in Padmé's missions anymore because they weren't in a secret relationship that would entice Anakin to spend time with her. And the only reason I had Aayla join Anakin is because she knew how close Palpatine and Anakin were. She was going there to support Anakin because she knew he'd struggle to tell Palpatine that it was time to give up his power
I liked this story and the impact it had on Anakin, and it really highlighted how painful and dangerous (and even kinda toxic) the relationship between Anakin and Padme was. But I do think if they had a child before Order 66 and Ayla's death, but Ayla still died. It could have made this story more powerful, though it may have gone in a different direction as Anakin has to now try and do what is right for this child that is the last remaining peice of Ayla. But this was well made regardless.
In a relationship, People don't need to be physical to show love, they can show by supporting and caring for each other also sacrificing and compromising for partners that's how it works
If that's how everything works then i guarantee the first love will be the final love and no divorce will happen only because of this sex thing the divorce and all rates are increasing
Huh, it was definitely interesting, however I was under thr impression that Aayla and Anakin were roughly the same age as each other. I remember reading somewhere that he, Aayla and Barris Offee were close friends as they grew up together in the Jedi Temple
@@PentePatrolStarWars I see. I thought she was a few years older than him. I'm not sure where I read that info on, but it was a long time ago. All it mentioned that when Anakin was still a Padawan, he formed a close friendship with Aayla and Barris, as it also spoke that at the time, Aayla was still a Padawan to Quinlin Voss
I liked it. It fit with the characters and felt it was within the relm of posibility, I mean depends on what Aalya would have done. But it was sweet, it would be nice to see anakin happy in a alternate universe, even though she died it was bitter sweet, and she helped anakin be the best version of himself.
I feel like this would be an amazing outcome if it was canon or ever made into a movie. It sounds more fleshed out than Panime. Aayla would have best good SO material for Anakin. Also, your impressions were pretty good. there were a few points that I thought I was hearing Anakin speak.
Video Suggestions: -What If Luke Skywalker turned to the Darkside -What If Starkiller became Palpatine's fourth Sith apprentice -What If Aayla Secura survived Order 66 -What If Darth Maul killed Dooku -What If Jar Jar Binks turned to the Darkside after the death of Padme -What If Mace Windu secretly survived Order 66 -What If Leia became a jedi during the events of Return of the Jedi -What If Rey turned to the Darkside -What If Snoke returned during the events of Rise of Skywalker instead of Palpatine and became a powerful darkside user -What If Dooku killed Anakin during Revenge of the Sith
You're right this is my favorite! Aayla Secura is my Favorite Jedi Knight besides Ahsoka during the Modern Republic era since I had a crush on her. Having this potential romance for chosen one is a creative idea I never thought of, but I am loving it! Here's a subscription as a Thank you 💙💚❤💜💛🧡🤎🖤🤍
LMAO I once jokeshipped them together xD But seriously, I think it's more realistic for Anakin to develop an attraction and bond to a fellow Jedi than with Padme. I love Padme's character but I don't really think she was a good match to Anakin, he needed someone who could understand him on a more deeper level and another Jedi like himself could have helped him down that path, so I love that you explored that in here. Awesome video!
Omgg hahaha... and yeah I agree, I think if he were arrogant enough to think he could piss Anakin off he could have him, which I feel, almost happened when Aayla died
Now, what we really need is a fully flashed fanfic about this and it will be perfect. In need of a good star wars fanfic in light of the sequel trilogy and other bad SW movies :)
I just thought of an way to bring her back. You could have her come back as an Force Ghost, and the Force resurrects her because it sees how much Anakin needs and loves her, and that without her; he’ll turn to the dark side.
The librarian wanting to help makes sense due to her and the count having feelings for each other before his turn to the dark side, she understood how they felt, being so close yet so far away from being with each other
Yeah Aayla would easily take Anakin under the wing of hers and become a mentor to him and in return Anakin would be loyal to her as long as she is more on the grey jedi kind of mindset yeah
Sexual relationships without love or attachment are extremely unhealthy I enjoyed this video it seems like Jedi love stories and doomed to be tragic ones
Anakin should have really been partnered up with another Jedi, or made Padme at least a Force sensitive! It would have lend strength to the whole "If Anakin ever an offspring, it would be strong enough to defeat the Emperor!" Anyway, Ayla would be the best partner with Anakin because she is a Twilek! They're traditionally slave workers throughout the Star Wars series, and we know how Anakin feels about slavery! Also both displayed a certain level of respect and affection for their Clone Troops!
When I was a kid before the prequels my older brother and I always presumed that Luke and Leia's mother was another Jedi. No issue how it played out but I think it still would have made plenty of sense.
Honestly, I'd think that it would have a positive effect on Skywalker. It is obvious that Padme both was a bad influence and was probably trash in bed, that is why Anakin is so pissed off all the time. Aayla would treat that man to some wise advice, and a Twi'lek special lmao.
I have an interesting idea for a story. Sekura did exactly wanted to have aniken's children, but the situation was critical. Darth talon had stolen aniken's seed. The details are sketchy. But the point is that Darth talon is confirmed pregnant with aniken's children and was last seen with a vast growing womb. Secura was no stranger to pregnancy. Kamenoes have experimented growing clones in a natural womb. They even developed serums that expands the womb and enhances fertility. During her trimester asoka visited her. She asked why she wanted to have aniken's children, especially after talon, and how did talon survive for so long. "Stories are told about twelick women who are somehow anointed with eternal beauty, fertility, and healing. Darth talon was one of those women. The only other confirmed individual...is the one who is talking to you. I don't know how we got it. But what I do know is that the blood of the chosen one in the hands of the sith is bad news. I have sensed a growing darkness. It will happen shortly after I give birth. I will give birth. Take the children to a... trusted friend, then I will return to the front lines, and... let my men shoot me. And when my healing power brings me back to life, I will hunt down talon.
Palpatines pov: Anakin I know what the Senate is when I said it I meant that i unofficially control it You Don’t Need To Tell Me WHAT THE SENATE IS The other Jedi POV: Anakin what the fu-
The distinctional difference is this relationship is not one done in secret. The crux of why Anakin and Padmes relationship was unhealthy was because it was in secret. It was a lie...
The only way I can see something like this happening is during a anakin talking to alaya secura telling her that he loves her or something along those lines
I love this concept. It's told in a way that sounds realistic to the Star Wars canon. It does seem... unrefined? Not to be rude or anything, you tell your stories in a way that shows the thought and love you put into these stories and I'd love to see this rewritten. i love the way you tell your stories, there's so much emotion in them and it really pulls on my own when listening to them. (please do not feel pressured or anything by anyone to either rewrite produce videos faster. if those types of comments have come up anyway. my desire to see this rewritten is that and only that. i love what you're doing right now.)
Anikin Skywalker falling in love with Aalya Secura is fairly believable. I saw that Clone Wars Episode too. But let's be honest here, while the woman is gorgeous, her accent is the epitome of sexy. Yet, Aalya Secura falling in love with Anakin Skywalker is where it gets a little strange. Aalya Secura is a Jedi master. She doesn't dress this way because she wishes to express her sexuality, but to show her solidarity with the sex-slaves of her own species. Anakin is young, too powerful and too full of himself. He is not someone she would fall in love with. But she would bang Mace Windu in a heartbeat!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Please don't think I am try to offend you, I just typed my thoughts down as I watched the video. Personally, with Padme not in the picture, I think he would have fallen in love with Asoka Tano. Excuse me, further in love. ruclips.net/video/JMtRgptUc4I/видео.html
@@PentePatrolStarWars Thank you. Please understand that I love the concept of Star Wars, just not where it's going in movie form. It has lost its way in what is generally referred to as Canon. Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni are the true heirs of Lucas. Their work is fast becoming Iconic. Many people had a problem with Luke Skywalker being introduced into the Mandalorian, but I saw the reactions of dozens of fans who went out of their minds with joy when they saw a gloved hand wielding a green lightsaber. I heard the screams of ‘The Most Powerful Jedi In The Galaxy.’ I saw when the Son had his own heroic corridor scene. These men and their crews are channeling the past to build a future for this franchise. ruclips.net/video/QedbgpBe6kg/видео.html
Anakin: I tend to be popular with the ladies 😉 Obi Wan: Too popular 😏 (Coincidentally, I actually had a dream where Anakin & Aayla were an actual couple! Great video, dude! 👍💙 And this is the very 1st one I saw on your channel!)
I think that if Aayla Secura returned the feelings, Anakin and her would've led a Jedi rebellion against the Jedi. Seeing at how zealous the Jedi were, change needed to happen. I could totally see Ashoka, and other Jedi joining Anakin and creating a new Jedi Order. One of which wouldn't have been recognized by the older order. At which point I could see Palpatine and or Maul assassinating Yoda, framing Anakin and causing a galactic wide division or subwar. The Separatists probably would've taken Courscant, and the Republic would've been fractured into many different pieces from multiple sources of infighting. Palpatine would've still executed certain orders for the Clones, and probably Order 66 because the Grand Army of the Republic would've been fractured. Mace Windu would've assumed Grand Master and perhaps even Count Dooku would've remained a Jedi depending on the timeframe. Wanting revenge or being angered at Anakin's assassination of his former master. Unlike Padme, Aayla would've understood Anakin's grievances and dissuaded him from the Dark Side, but I don't think this would've been better for the galaxy in the long run. As the Jedi remnants warred against each other, the Empire most certainly would've continued to be founded and a new order of Sith combined with massive armies of droids and ships would've been sent to hunt down the Jedi either way, the armies of clones the Jedi fought with against one another would've been turned on them just the same. The only variable that's drastic is that the Separatists take the galaxy, not the Republic. At which point Palpatine still would've been able to found the Empire. We should assume Luke and Leia are still born, and that Anakin's somehow either dies or turns to the dark side. Leaving Secura or Ashoka to take care of his children. Luke would probably still go on to fulfill the prophecy.
Well as Commander Bly apparently had some kind feelings for Ayla it would have been an interesting fight if ever something like Clovis happened with Bly and Aayla. Although unlikely
When Anakin gets another love interest besides Padme: "I'll survive though, right?" PPSW: "So sad they didn't survive. I had no choice in the matter." Obi-Wan: "Wait, I survived!!? WOOOO!" Aayla (or other Love Interest): "Oh shut up!!" -------------- In all seriousness, I think these 2 could have been a good pairing and in an alternate story where both survived, would have probably had happier lives. Maybe for much later videos, you could have some alternate endings, whether one is dark and light or what if somebody's live interest survives through it or not. Branching paths in the space gulag wouldn't be the worst thing ever.
Hey Pente, I know I already asked, but I would really like to see you do "What If Anakin left the order with Ahsoka." If you don't wanna then that's ok
What if padme died before attack of the clones? Anakin never loved padme he was obsessed with her beauty nothing more. If he did love padme he wouldn’t have destroyed everything padme loved
Love had blinded him. He loved her so much he was willing to destroy the galaxy to keep her alive not taking the time to think how that would affect her or her feelings.
He sees her briefly during the same time as AotC, but they only flirt a little. Anakin likes Aayla and has been matured by that attraction. Rather than acting out when with Padmé
Two Part Video Idea: What if Jaster Mereel Survived Tor Visla's Ambush combined with What If Anakin was adopted by Jaster Mereel as brother to Jango Fett
I like the fact it was more of a deep friendship with maybe something more, its more believable and something that could have fit in canon, instead of feeling like bad "fan fiction".
What if the spirits of Revan and Bastila Shan trained Luke? What if Celeste Morne was founded by the Jedi during the Clone Wars instead of Vader during the reign of the Empire? What if Ahsoka Tano joined the Order of Revan after the events of The Wrong Jedi? What if Darth Vader had premonitions of Abeloth? What if Ahsoka Tano was in the Legacy Era during the time of Cade Skywalker? What if Padme was a Descendant of Revan and Bastila Shan? What if Padme was a Revanite? What if Padme was a Descendant of Darth Zannah? What if Luke Skywalker found Revans' holocron? What if Anakin Skywalker had premonitions of Abeloth? What if Darth Bane had premonitions of Darth Sidious and his vision of a Rule of One? What if Darth Krayt managed to get his revenge on Vader and Sidious? What if Darth Bane fought Darth Vader? What if the Sith Purebloods were never wiped out? What if Satele Shan was in the Clone Wars? What if Satele Shan was in the Galactic Civil War (Rebel Alliance vs Galactic Empire)? What if Anakin Skywalker met the Bendu? What if Luke Skywalker met the Bendu? What if Leia Organa/Skywalker met the Bendu? What if Padme was an Anti-Heroine? What if Padme was a Vigilante? What if Padme had a 3rd child? What if the Order of Revan returned during the Clone Wars? What if the Order of Revan returned during the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Zannah was in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Zannah was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Bane was in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Bane was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Malgus was in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Malgus was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Anakin Skywalker was a member of the Order of Revan?
I’m watching these in the order you have on the playlist and you always gotta throw in that plo koon reference, I fucking love it. Big pop from me every time
Aalya was just two or three years older than Anakin in Cannon. She was a Padawan to Jedi Knight Vos in her teen years at the same time Anakin was also a full Padawan to Obi-won. She entered the at the same time as him. Plus, because of his upbringing on Tatooine, he would have seen and been curiously attracted to the Twi'lek race because of seeing the sex slaves growing up. He could have some hidden Xenophilia feelings. Also in Cannon, Aalya is raped during a mission for the High Council to track slave trading from her home world. During this mission, she was still a Padawan to Knight Vos. So, she is also broken like Anakin. I liked this story very much. Personally, I see it as a great Jedi romance pairing. Even if Palpatine did pull Anakin to the Darkside, I don't think it would be too hard for him to turn her as well.
I was surprised as I haven't read the comics in ages so I didn't know they had any kind of friendship. I agree that Padme and Anakin had a toxic relationship but in my opinion it was only one factor in Anakins fall. I think Anakins lack of boundaries in his relationship with Obiwan played just as big a part in his fall. Anakin knew he was more powerful than Obiwan and on some level resented him due to their closeness in age and Anakins knowledge that he was the chosen one, basically he didn't respect Kenobis authority as his master. So in order to turn Anakin from his path to the dark side you would have to address both issues. There is also the issue of Palpatine... he subtly encouraged Padme and Anis relationship because it served to push him towards the dark side but a relationship with Ayla would not have so Palpatine would have had her killed the moment he realised she had any kind of influence over him. It was an interesting theory though and I'll be subscribing for future what ifs 😁
Man poor pilots like imagen your just flying your ship and you find a bunch of your generals just dead and you offer one of them help and they tell you and your brother (the second pilot) to stand down like just imagen the clones just thinking why are they doing this we didnt do anything we fly our ships for them and this is how they thank us this is outrageous it's unfair like seriously just imagen that for a moment
The complete shock would be unreal!
@@PentePatrolStarWars ikr
@@goldenpro1096 Honestly I love that you honed in on that, because I wrote it to communicate the distrust between clone and Jedi at that moment. But it's really cool how something I didn't think twice about could really mean so much
@@PentePatrolStarWars it's those little details that fir some reason I pay alot of attention to and also helps that I really love the clones so when I heard this I immediately thought of the clones perspective so yeah oh and thanks for responding your a bug youtuber and I dont really get responses from big youtubers so thank you for your time one fellow youtuber to a other :)
@@goldenpro1096 Makes perfect sense! And of course my friend!
Anakin see's Aayla Secura's Cake
Anakin: This is Where the Fun Begins!
LMFAO if it was in the Story and if Aayla secura lives Luke And Leia would have been born and Anakin would be Master Jedi.
wtf
lol I came back here to see this comment once again.
.....
@@DEVINNNNNNNX how much do you want? 100 credits? 1000?
Now that would have been a relationship I could have seen happening. I like the positive effect she had on Anakin
I do too, I wanted this to be an emotional story!
This would be in a world set in the Multiverse, where she doesn’t get immediately decked in Episode 3. Because, they flat out offed her- Order 66 style. Barely any screen time, just a Full on death.
That would be a great relationship maybe even with kids
@@stevelenox152 but what is with luke and lea ?
So Luke and Leia would end up being the same race as Hera and Kanan's child lol.
Honestly a Jedi would've 100 percent been a better partner for Anakin. Padme wouldn't have understood and didn't understood most of Anakin's feelings or his anger due to her not knowing jack about the force, or the Jedi, she only knew politics , Aayla or perhaps any other female Jedi would've sense those feelings and would've helped Anakin with his feeling and dark side urges
Exactly
…phrasing
dark side urges 😏
Why are two out of three of you pervs?
@@ilyysm I definitely want Aayla to help me with my "urges".
While I'll ship Anakin x Padmé until I die, Anakin and Aayla would have had a healthier relationship than Anakin and Padmé. They were both slaves and they would have had a good relationship and understanding of each other. Slave mentality is definitely an heavy effect to this. Padmé and Anakin's relationship could have worked for sure and could have an understanding of each other, but they would need more communication therapy.
Yes perfectly said!
I’m not sure Aayla Secura would be interested in a relationship with Anakin, who was 7 years younger than her. She was 2 years older than Padme Amidala. Also, Aayla reached the rank of Jedi Knight 7 years before Anakin did.
Aayla had a brief romantic relationship with Nautolan Jedi Master Kit Fisto, who saved her life during the Battle of Mon Calamari. Had it not been for their duties as Jedi Generals during the Clone Wars, their relationship may have progressed further.
Anakin:i SlaUgHtErEd ThEm lIKe AnImAls!
Aayal:Darlin' why didn't tell me?! We could of done together?!
Anakin:...
Anakin:Pardon me...?
@@ggt47 Lmaooo
@@PentePatrolStarWars Sorry.😂
"We grant you the rank of...Master. What? I..I'm overwhelmed Masters. Th...Thank you! I'm honored!" - Anakin Skywalker
"Take a seat Master Skywalker!" - Mace Windu
Lmaoo
"You aren't on this council, but we grant you the rank of master"
Anakin: What? How can you be a master, and not be on the council?
Mace: Don't take a seat.
@@TraceguyRune 🤣
"Plus, you're going to be a father."
Anakin: "What?! I'm a father?! Hey everybody! I'm going to be a father!"
@@NarwahlGaming Lmao HISHE
I absolutely loved this one. The fact that you portrayed their relationship. I absolutely respect this kind of love. This was exactly what Anakin deserved.
Gotta be honest, I would totally ship this relationship more than Padmé x Anakin. Aayla’s character deserved more screen time imo and the way she was murdered in RoTS was just heartbreaking
Straight facts
Well to be fair they did it like that because they respected her. They wanted her death to be quick and so the kept shooting to make sure she died fast
The original version of her death was a lot worse. After she was shot multiple times an AT-TE Clone Walker steps on her corpse. I don't remember which youtuber had shown the deleted cuts but if you can find the deleted cuts it has a lot.
“…It was good we were all wearing helmets that day”
It’s even worse if you listen to Battlefront. They completely destroyed her because they didn’t want her to suffer.
If Cut has taught us anything a sexy Twi’lek solves everything
Anakin: aRe YoU aN aNgLe?
Aayla: I'm a person and my name is Aayla
I love angles
Yoda: "Hmm, Twi'leks lead to the Dark Side, and enjoy it you will."
Dude, this should totally be in a star wars what if series.
Also your anakin and palpatine impressions are on point
Thank you so much!
I like how Anakin felt the need to literally clarify the definition of the senate to Palpatine
“Ayla is kinda noticeable”
You can say that again.
This was sad, heartwarming and immersive all at the same time. I could vividly imagine this, and it was well written. Good job.
I love anakin and Padme, and without them we wouldn’t have the original trilogy. But padme despite her good heart and kind demeanor she just wasn’t right for him. In attack of the clones when anakin told her he slaughtered a whole village of Tuskans she just shrugged it off like it didn’t happen. If she would’ve distanced herself then I believe he would’ve been better off.
Ahhh..that's why Luke has such an affinity for blue milk..
Omg lmao
LMAO That is just AMAZING
🤦♂️🤷♂️
I honestly think Aayla could've been a real romantic interest for Anakin, or at least a best friend, from his time in the temple. He was a former slave, and her people (Twi'leks) were often targeted for enslavement. This would've been a common ground they could've bonded over.
What if Saesee Tiin trained Anakin? Both were outsiders as padawans so maybe Tiin would be able to understand Anakin alot better than Obi Wan, Plus alongside Plo Koon they're the best pilots in the Jedi Order.
That would be a lot of fun! That's the one thing I regret not including in the 'Plo Koon Trained Anakin' video about the piloting relationship between the two... I think it'd be a lot of fun to do here!
Saesee might have turned out badly though, since he's pretty prejudiced about anything resembling the Dark Side if I remember correctly. Anakin being naturally more receptive to the Dark because of his attachments he couldn't let go of might have led Saesee to think badly of him, although I'm sure he would move past it. Very underrated Jedi in general
@@PentePatrolStarWars This is something else about Obi-Wan.
They apparently had very few or no interests in common. Their friendship is purely through shared trauma, and war wounds.
Anakin loves Flying
Obi hates it
Anakin cares for his droids
Obi sees them as tools
Anakin hates the world politics
Obi-Wan has a great deal of political canny, and even takes part in Jedi schemes, multiple times at Anakins expense (but no time more blatant than in EP. III)
Anakin wants to both be a Jedi, and Love Padme
Obi-Wan saw his love for Satine as a 'if not the Jedi, then Her'
@@AlyssMa7rin Perfectly said
@Mackenzie Bauroth I think he'd be great, especially interesting because he was forced out of the High Council right before RotS. With Eeth and Ahsoka forced out, what would Anakin have done
While this would have been a deep spiritual relationship, which would have been very beneficial for both Jedi, and perhaps even a dyad in the force, which would have allowed Aayla to either survive the force lightning or Anakin sense it ahead of time, Aayla and Anakin would have been sent on many missions together, including undercover missions, and I am sure that there would have been occasional moments of intense lust (the two hottest people in the Jedi order, come on).
Yeah I agree, they would have some moments if not *a lot* intimate/private moments
"The two hottest Jedi, Come on."
Kenobi: Visible Sadness
@@Blurgamer17 nah what do you mean
Yoda: visible sadness
@@ogan2631 prime 900+ year old Dagobussy.
Meanwhile Ki Adi Mundi looking at you with an atempt at a seducing smile while caressing a wookie 😏
As much as I love anakin and padme I definitely think anakin and aayla could have worked and would have been a great relationship. Yes that doesn't mean anakin and padme was destined to end in a tragedy that relationship could have also worked but there was a much better chance of aayla and anakin having a happy ending so to speak than padme and anakin.
Me going into this video: "Oh, you're slashing him with the scantily clad jedi twi'lek. Uh-huh."
Me barely a few minutes into the video: "This is actually a great love story...and infinitely better than Padme and Anikin..."
Edit: At the end there, I loved every second of it. A MUCH more satisfying story here than in the prequels. Excellent.
Thank you so much!
If Anakin fell in love with pretty much anyone other than Padme he’d never turn to the dark side.
Personally, while I think that Aayla and Anakin would have had a better relationship than Anakin and Padme the entire Rush Clovis/Scipio scenario would have turned out differently as Anakin would have been in a relationship with Aayla already (given the Lurmen events) and therefore never guarded Padme since the choice was to keep on eye on his "secret" girlfriend. Although it's a well-done and well-thought out concept of the Clone Wars it seems more likely that they would have made each other better and had a greater chance to understand the other's feelings via the Force, but I doubt that Aayla would have necessarily joined Anakin to Palaptine's office as Palpatine was stated to have had an almost fatherly relationship with Anakin since the Battle of Naboo. Though not necessarily making it NSFW it's likely the reunions between Aayla and Anakin could have been intimate (more likely sharing abed, not necessarily sexual)
I honestly think it would've been a sexually intimate relationship but I don't think Anakin would've been the Jedi involved in Padmé's missions anymore because they weren't in a secret relationship that would entice Anakin to spend time with her. And the only reason I had Aayla join Anakin is because she knew how close Palpatine and Anakin were. She was going there to support Anakin because she knew he'd struggle to tell Palpatine that it was time to give up his power
I liked this story and the impact it had on Anakin, and it really highlighted how painful and dangerous (and even kinda toxic) the relationship between Anakin and Padme was. But I do think if they had a child before Order 66 and Ayla's death, but Ayla still died. It could have made this story more powerful, though it may have gone in a different direction as Anakin has to now try and do what is right for this child that is the last remaining peice of Ayla. But this was well made regardless.
Oh certainly! Thank you though!
In a relationship, People don't need to be physical to show love, they can show by supporting and caring for each other also sacrificing and compromising for partners that's how it works
Exactly!
If that's how everything works then i guarantee the first love will be the final love and no divorce will happen only because of this sex thing the divorce and all rates are increasing
@@manabuhorikita1453 I think a lot of people don't understand how love or relationships work
@@manabuhorikita1453 No phisical contact in a relationship typically doesn't last. Otherwise you're living with a friend, not a partner.
@@TheSmolPrince I'm talking about lust, love is different you won't realise that
Huh, it was definitely interesting, however I was under thr impression that Aayla and Anakin were roughly the same age as each other. I remember reading somewhere that he, Aayla and Barris Offee were close friends as they grew up together in the Jedi Temple
Oh she was 10 years older than him
@@PentePatrolStarWars I see. I thought she was a few years older than him. I'm not sure where I read that info on, but it was a long time ago. All it mentioned that when Anakin was still a Padawan, he formed a close friendship with Aayla and Barris, as it also spoke that at the time, Aayla was still a Padawan to Quinlin Voss
Anakin has a thing for older women
I liked it. It fit with the characters and felt it was within the relm of posibility, I mean depends on what Aalya would have done. But it was sweet, it would be nice to see anakin happy in a alternate universe, even though she died it was bitter sweet, and she helped anakin be the best version of himself.
Anakin is ladies man.
I feel like this would be an amazing outcome if it was canon or ever made into a movie. It sounds more fleshed out than Panime. Aayla would have best good SO material for Anakin. Also, your impressions were pretty good. there were a few points that I thought I was hearing Anakin speak.
Thank you so much!
Video Suggestions:
-What If Luke Skywalker turned to the Darkside
-What If Starkiller became Palpatine's fourth Sith apprentice
-What If Aayla Secura survived Order 66
-What If Darth Maul killed Dooku
-What If Jar Jar Binks turned to the Darkside after the death of Padme
-What If Mace Windu secretly survived Order 66
-What If Leia became a jedi during the events of Return of the Jedi
-What If Rey turned to the Darkside
-What If Snoke returned during the events of Rise of Skywalker instead of Palpatine and became a powerful darkside user
-What If Dooku killed Anakin during Revenge of the Sith
YES
What if Anakin never turned to the dark side
@@PentePatrolStarWars What if Aayla had received a Padawan instead of Anakin, or Aayla and Anakin had teamed up during the Ryloth arc
@@andrewmalinowski6673 YES!
@@jackstadler7065 YES!
Two words about this...
"Hell yes!"
I would have preferred Anakin & Aayla over what we got.
It's the next best thing besides Anakin x Ahsoka
Same
You're right this is my favorite! Aayla Secura is my Favorite Jedi Knight besides Ahsoka during the Modern Republic era since I had a crush on her. Having this potential romance for chosen one is a creative idea I never thought of, but I am loving it! Here's a subscription as a Thank you 💙💚❤💜💛🧡🤎🖤🤍
Thank you so much!
LMAO I once jokeshipped them together xD But seriously, I think it's more realistic for Anakin to develop an attraction and bond to a fellow Jedi than with Padme. I love Padme's character but I don't really think she was a good match to Anakin, he needed someone who could understand him on a more deeper level and another Jedi like himself could have helped him down that path, so I love that you explored that in here. Awesome video!
Fr!! Thank you so much!
This looks like so many fan fictions I’ve seen…😏
Also I don’t think Palpatine would make his move until he was sure he had some leverage
Omgg hahaha... and yeah I agree, I think if he were arrogant enough to think he could piss Anakin off he could have him, which I feel, almost happened when Aayla died
Great stories!! These are a lot of fun to listen to. The family friendly aspect is appreciated. 👍
“Becomes a master,……. To Ashoka” ya has me there for a minute
Now, what we really need is a fully flashed fanfic about this and it will be perfect. In need of a good star wars fanfic in light of the sequel trilogy and other bad SW movies :)
If this was canon
Palaptine: uh Anakin what are you doing? You’re suppose to be with padme
Really nice work. Always used think about Anakin going for Aayla. Just hoped that his disliking of sand would go well with Aayla too lol.
Thank you so much and lmao
As hardcore fan of the SW lore this hurts a bit, but my love for this kind of AU content is good to see and overrun the hurt felling
“They both felt a force pulling them together”
I see what you did there
;)
What if Anakin fell in love with Shaak Ti or what if Marvel’s What if crossed over?
Ooo these could be fun!
Man, that was...that was beautiful...sad, but also beautiful...Aayla definitely would've been a better love partner for Anakin.
Palpatine: I am the senate
Anakin: That's not how the senate works
He then Force slaps Palpatine for talking about Aayla.
"Get my lady's name out your f@*%ing mouth!" he screams!
Hahah
Palpatine just in shocked because he just got Will Smithed by Anakin
I just thought of an way to bring her back. You could have her come back as an Force Ghost, and the Force resurrects her because it sees how much Anakin needs and loves her, and that without her; he’ll turn to the dark side.
The librarian wanting to help makes sense due to her and the count having feelings for each other before his turn to the dark side, she understood how they felt, being so close yet so far away from being with each other
Yeah Aayla would easily take Anakin under the wing of hers and become a mentor to him and in return Anakin would be loyal to her as long as she is more on the grey jedi kind of mindset yeah
Sexual relationships without love or attachment are extremely unhealthy
I enjoyed this video it seems like Jedi love stories and doomed to be tragic ones
Then you're going to have some really powerful kids.
Anakin should have really been partnered up with another Jedi, or made Padme at least a Force sensitive! It would have lend strength to the whole "If Anakin ever an offspring, it would be strong enough to defeat the Emperor!"
Anyway, Ayla would be the best partner with Anakin because she is a Twilek! They're traditionally slave workers throughout the Star Wars series, and we know how Anakin feels about slavery! Also both displayed a certain level of respect and affection for their Clone Troops!
Bro you just be makin everything 💯 😂 and I am HERE for it!! Love these fan fics bro, keep it ALL up!!
Thank you so much!
When I was a kid before the prequels my older brother and I always presumed that Luke and Leia's mother was another Jedi. No issue how it played out but I think it still would have made plenty of sense.
Some clone during order 66: "Do we have to kill Secura? I was kinda hoping to get her holo number!"
Honestly, I'd think that it would have a positive effect on Skywalker. It is obvious that Padme both was a bad influence and was probably trash in bed, that is why Anakin is so pissed off all the time. Aayla would treat that man to some wise advice, and a Twi'lek special lmao.
Aayla deserved more screentime
I have an interesting idea for a story.
Sekura did exactly wanted to have aniken's children, but the situation was critical. Darth talon had stolen aniken's seed. The details are sketchy. But the point is that Darth talon is confirmed pregnant with aniken's children and was last seen with a vast growing womb.
Secura was no stranger to pregnancy. Kamenoes have experimented growing clones in a natural womb. They even developed serums that expands the womb and enhances fertility.
During her trimester asoka visited her. She asked why she wanted to have aniken's children, especially after talon, and how did talon survive for so long. "Stories are told about twelick women who are somehow anointed with eternal beauty, fertility, and healing. Darth talon was one of those women. The only other confirmed individual...is the one who is talking to you. I don't know how we got it. But what I do know is that the blood of the chosen one in the hands of the sith is bad news.
I have sensed a growing darkness. It will happen shortly after I give birth.
I will give birth. Take the children to a... trusted friend, then I will return to the front lines, and... let my men shoot me. And when my healing power brings me back to life, I will hunt down talon.
What if Shaak Ti trained Anakin?
And what if Count Dooku assassinated Palpatine?
I'm working on this one rn actually! 👀👀
@@PentePatrolStarWars Ayyy, Can’t wait to see it 👀
Probs a less aggressive Anakin
He’d be a legend.
Palpation: I am the senate
Mace Windu: not yet 😌
Anakin: no, your not *procededs to explain what the senate was* 😎
Palpatines pov: Anakin I know what the Senate is when I said it I meant that i unofficially control it You Don’t Need To Tell Me WHAT THE SENATE IS
The other Jedi POV: Anakin what the fu-
Palpatine: Okay, Anakin, if you're trying to be a smartass, you're failing miserably at it.
The distinctional difference is this relationship is not one done in secret. The crux of why Anakin and Padmes relationship was unhealthy was because it was in secret. It was a lie...
Me (when I first saw the thumbnail and the title): This is where the fun begins! 😏😆😂
lmaooo
If this happened, Anakin would't have R2D2 as it was a wedding gift from Padme
R2 would still meet Ani in some way tho
The only way I can see something like this happening is during a anakin talking to alaya secura telling her that he loves her or something along those lines
I love this concept. It's told in a way that sounds realistic to the Star Wars canon. It does seem... unrefined? Not to be rude or anything, you tell your stories in a way that shows the thought and love you put into these stories and I'd love to see this rewritten. i love the way you tell your stories, there's so much emotion in them and it really pulls on my own when listening to them. (please do not feel pressured or anything by anyone to either rewrite produce videos faster. if those types of comments have come up anyway. my desire to see this rewritten is that and only that. i love what you're doing right now.)
Anikin Skywalker falling in love with Aalya Secura is fairly believable. I saw that Clone Wars Episode too. But let's be honest here, while the woman is gorgeous, her accent is the epitome of sexy. Yet, Aalya Secura falling in love with Anakin Skywalker is where it gets a little strange. Aalya Secura is a Jedi master. She doesn't dress this way because she wishes to express her sexuality, but to show her solidarity with the sex-slaves of her own species.
Anakin is young, too powerful and too full of himself. He is not someone she would fall in love with. But she would bang Mace Windu in a heartbeat!
Exactly, I think (hope) I talked about it at the end of the video
@@PentePatrolStarWars Please don't think I am try to offend you, I just typed my thoughts down as I watched the video. Personally, with Padme not in the picture, I think he would have fallen in love with Asoka Tano. Excuse me, further in love. ruclips.net/video/JMtRgptUc4I/видео.html
@@Dawnspell8 Oh no worries, I'm not drastically offended lol, I usually discuss some of my creative decisions at the end of videos. I gotcha!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Thank you. Please understand that I love the concept of Star Wars, just not where it's going in movie form. It has lost its way in what is generally referred to as Canon.
Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni are the true heirs of Lucas. Their work is fast becoming Iconic.
Many people had a problem with Luke Skywalker being introduced into the Mandalorian, but I saw the reactions of dozens of fans who went out of their minds with joy when they saw a gloved hand wielding a green lightsaber. I heard the screams of ‘The Most Powerful Jedi In The Galaxy.’ I saw when the Son had his own heroic corridor scene.
These men and their crews are channeling the past to build a future for this franchise.
ruclips.net/video/QedbgpBe6kg/видео.html
Fisto x Secura for life.
Anakin: I tend to be popular with the ladies 😉
Obi Wan: Too popular 😏
(Coincidentally, I actually had a dream where Anakin & Aayla were an actual couple! Great video, dude! 👍💙 And this is the very 1st one I saw on your channel!)
I think that if Aayla Secura returned the feelings, Anakin and her would've led a Jedi rebellion against the Jedi.
Seeing at how zealous the Jedi were, change needed to happen. I could totally see Ashoka, and other Jedi joining Anakin and creating a new Jedi Order.
One of which wouldn't have been recognized by the older order. At which point I could see Palpatine and or Maul assassinating Yoda, framing Anakin and causing a galactic wide division or subwar. The Separatists probably would've taken Courscant, and the Republic would've been fractured into many different pieces from multiple sources of infighting. Palpatine would've still executed certain orders for the Clones, and probably Order 66 because the Grand Army of the Republic would've been fractured. Mace Windu would've assumed Grand Master and perhaps even Count Dooku would've remained a Jedi depending on the timeframe. Wanting revenge or being angered at Anakin's assassination of his former master.
Unlike Padme, Aayla would've understood Anakin's grievances and dissuaded him from the Dark Side, but I don't think this would've been better for the galaxy in the long run. As the Jedi remnants warred against each other, the Empire most certainly would've continued to be founded and a new order of Sith combined with massive armies of droids and ships would've been sent to hunt down the Jedi either way, the armies of clones the Jedi fought with against one another would've been turned on them just the same. The only variable that's drastic is that the Separatists take the galaxy, not the Republic. At which point Palpatine still would've been able to found the Empire.
We should assume Luke and Leia are still born, and that Anakin's somehow either dies or turns to the dark side. Leaving Secura or Ashoka to take care of his children. Luke would probably still go on to fulfill the prophecy.
I imagine Anakin would become the next Revan of the current timeline.
blue Milk Would have new meaning
bruhhhh haha
Well as Commander Bly apparently had some kind feelings for Ayla it would have been an interesting fight if ever something like Clovis happened with Bly and Aayla. Although unlikely
That blue milk man…
Less of a romance, more of a tragedy, oh well
When u fall in love with that girl who is a few grades above u
When Anakin gets another love interest besides Padme: "I'll survive though, right?"
PPSW: "So sad they didn't survive. I had no choice in the matter."
Obi-Wan: "Wait, I survived!!? WOOOO!"
Aayla (or other Love Interest): "Oh shut up!!"
--------------
In all seriousness, I think these 2 could have been a good pairing and in an alternate story where both survived, would have probably had happier lives. Maybe for much later videos, you could have some alternate endings, whether one is dark and light or what if somebody's live interest survives through it or not. Branching paths in the space gulag wouldn't be the worst thing ever.
Hey Pente, I know I already asked, but I would really like to see you do "What If Anakin left the order with Ahsoka." If you don't wanna then that's ok
Hello! Yes I do intend on doing it! I'm just planning out the week of theories that I've got (to record, edit, and write)! But I will do it!
Like what if Count Dooku never left the Jedi Order
I've always wanted to do this one!
you can do it
@@gerardocovarrubias3058 You know it!
This would be a Good FanFiction someday. There’s only one Aayla x Anakin fanfic and I loved it.
which fic is it? i wanna read it!
@@AnaLugia256 hold up I’ll give you the link
@@zeroarashiuchiha7699 Where is it?
I’ll post the link again
Respectable, I would have lost my shit and went darker than the darkest side in his stead
if this did happen, Anakin would have been getting some with a Twi'lek instead of a Naboo Queen.
I reckon she give ten ten slops
Time Traveller: Moves a chair
The Timeline:
"I am the Senate."
"No you're not,"
Palpatine: I AM the Senate!
Anakin jumping onto Palpatines desk: And I have the High Ground!
Obi-Wan: THAT'S MY BROTHER!
What if padme died before attack of the clones? Anakin never loved padme he was obsessed with her beauty nothing more. If he did love padme he wouldn’t have destroyed everything padme loved
This could be really cool!
Love had blinded him. He loved her so much he was willing to destroy the galaxy to keep her alive not taking the time to think how that would affect her or her feelings.
@@TraceguyRune lmao
@@TraceguyRune So you're saying love has blinded you?
@@PentePatrolStarWars lol
So I’m guessing that in this AU Anakin never sees Padme again after the events of the Phantom Menace?
He sees her briefly during the same time as AotC, but they only flirt a little. Anakin likes Aayla and has been matured by that attraction. Rather than acting out when with Padmé
Thank you for the video
Me: *sees title* tsk ani you lucky bastard
Wow! That is an interesting theory. I am totally surprised.
Two Part Video Idea: What if Jaster Mereel Survived Tor Visla's Ambush combined with What If Anakin was adopted by Jaster Mereel as brother to Jango Fett
Interesting!
I like the fact it was more of a deep friendship with maybe something more, its more believable and something that could have fit in canon, instead of feeling like bad "fan fiction".
Thank you, that's what I tried to shoot for!
that pop up pic @2:24 mark looks like a family with Asoka being their adopted daughter
Honestly though
@@PentePatrolStarWars welp time for a fan fic haha
@@nathanvosburgh718 Oop lmaoo
What if anakin reached full potential
Oooo!
Awesome video!
Thank you so much
What if the spirits of Revan and Bastila Shan trained Luke?
What if Celeste Morne was founded by the Jedi during the Clone Wars instead of Vader during the reign of the Empire?
What if Ahsoka Tano joined the Order of Revan after the events of The Wrong Jedi?
What if Darth Vader had premonitions of Abeloth?
What if Ahsoka Tano was in the Legacy Era during the time of Cade Skywalker?
What if Padme was a Descendant of Revan and Bastila Shan?
What if Padme was a Revanite?
What if Padme was a Descendant of Darth Zannah?
What if Luke Skywalker found Revans' holocron?
What if Anakin Skywalker had premonitions of Abeloth?
What if Darth Bane had premonitions of Darth Sidious and his vision of a Rule of One?
What if Darth Krayt managed to get his revenge on Vader and Sidious?
What if Darth Bane fought Darth Vader?
What if the Sith Purebloods were never wiped out?
What if Satele Shan was in the Clone Wars?
What if Satele Shan was in the Galactic Civil War (Rebel Alliance vs Galactic Empire)?
What if Anakin Skywalker met the Bendu?
What if Luke Skywalker met the Bendu?
What if Leia Organa/Skywalker met the Bendu?
What if Padme was an Anti-Heroine?
What if Padme was a Vigilante?
What if Padme had a 3rd child?
What if the Order of Revan returned during the Clone Wars?
What if the Order of Revan returned during the Galactic Civil War?
What if Darth Zannah was in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Zannah was in the Galactic Civil War?
What if Darth Bane was in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Bane was in the Galactic Civil War?
What if Darth Malgus was in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Malgus was in the Galactic Civil War?
What if Anakin Skywalker was a member of the Order of Revan?
YES
Everytime I hear "execute order 66" from palpatine I get goosebumps
Wow… this is way better than I thought
I’m watching these in the order you have on the playlist and you always gotta throw in that plo koon reference, I fucking love it. Big pop from me every time
Aalya was just two or three years older than Anakin in Cannon. She was a Padawan to Jedi Knight Vos in her teen years at the same time Anakin was also a full Padawan to Obi-won. She entered the at the same time as him.
Plus, because of his upbringing on Tatooine, he would have seen and been curiously attracted to the Twi'lek race because of seeing the sex slaves growing up. He could have some hidden Xenophilia feelings.
Also in Cannon, Aalya is raped during a mission for the High Council to track slave trading from her home world. During this mission, she was still a Padawan to Knight Vos. So, she is also broken like Anakin.
I liked this story very much. Personally, I see it as a great Jedi romance pairing. Even if Palpatine did pull Anakin to the Darkside, I don't think it would be too hard for him to turn her as well.
💙Anakin Skywalker × Aayla Secura💙
I was surprised as I haven't read the comics in ages so I didn't know they had any kind of friendship. I agree that Padme and Anakin had a toxic relationship but in my opinion it was only one factor in Anakins fall. I think Anakins lack of boundaries in his relationship with Obiwan played just as big a part in his fall. Anakin knew he was more powerful than Obiwan and on some level resented him due to their closeness in age and Anakins knowledge that he was the chosen one, basically he didn't respect Kenobis authority as his master. So in order to turn Anakin from his path to the dark side you would have to address both issues. There is also the issue of Palpatine... he subtly encouraged Padme and Anis relationship because it served to push him towards the dark side but a relationship with Ayla would not have so Palpatine would have had her killed the moment he realised she had any kind of influence over him. It was an interesting theory though and I'll be subscribing for future what ifs 😁