Chantilly: Animated Battle Map

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @AmericanBattlefieldTrust
    @AmericanBattlefieldTrust  5 лет назад +52

    By the request of many of our viewers, we have added narration to our already existing original set of battle maps. We appreciate your support and hope you enjoy the update! For our more modern animated maps, please visit the top of our Animated Battle Maps playlist ruclips.net/p/PLZrhqv_T1O1sdxRNm5SNc6cGSWr7xiWZs.

  • @gregmarbury9432
    @gregmarbury9432 5 лет назад +82

    I am convinced this is the way to study these battlefield movements. Love my books but this is great.

    • @crimony3054
      @crimony3054 5 лет назад +6

      Yes, books have difficulty capturing the dynamic movement of armies in the field.

  • @hatuletoh
    @hatuletoh 3 года назад +12

    General Kearny had lost his left arm while serving in the Mexican-American War. During the Pennisula Campaign, Union General O.O. Howard was hit twice in his right arm, and it had to be amputated. Visiting him in the hospital, Kearny said to him, "well Howard, now we can shop for gloves together." General Lee knew Kearny from their time serving together in the Mexican-American War, and when he heard of his death remarked, "poor Kearny. He deserved better." The Confederates had recovered his body, and under a flag of truce, sent it with an honor guard and letter of condolence to his family from Lee back to Washington.

  • @crowneproductions9908
    @crowneproductions9908 3 года назад +12

    The part that fascinates me about this animated battle map series is how we have such detailed information on these battles. Chantilly was not a Grand Battle. I can see how we have loads of information on something like Antietam or Gettysburg but I just find it facinsating how we know so much about these battles down to the brigade movement level and even skirmisher actions.

    • @Anomaly-uz9pr
      @Anomaly-uz9pr 2 года назад +1

      The armies kept records of everything deployments advances n all troop movements

  • @dclark142002
    @dclark142002 2 года назад +6

    Everybody lauds Jackson's flashy flank attacks and maneuvers...
    ...but I love his practical attention to detail when posted to defend a position. The man had skills.
    He also had flaws, and wasn't as good as many seem to believe...but his ability to create confusion by defensive disposition was demonstrated many times.

  • @Mr508films
    @Mr508films 3 года назад +8

    I'm glad this battle finally got some respect

  • @heberfenderful
    @heberfenderful 4 года назад +6

    Cant get enough of this animation videos , keep em coming !!!

  • @reganmahoney8264
    @reganmahoney8264 4 года назад +9

    I live in this area and this Battle of Chantilly happened around the corner of my house but I never knew much about it.

  • @m2858
    @m2858 3 года назад +5

    Love the intro music on these videos!

  • @nicknam8478
    @nicknam8478 7 месяцев назад +1

    I visited the battle site yesterday. It's surrounded by houses and busy streets. It could use a little love but glad it was preserved.

  • @huntingthekaiser6490
    @huntingthekaiser6490 5 лет назад +67

    You guys shouldn't have added the printed narration that blots out too much of the map.

  • @claytonkaeiser6214
    @claytonkaeiser6214 4 года назад +5

    Another great video by the American Battlefield Trust.

  • @duncanstevens2631
    @duncanstevens2631 5 лет назад +8

    Great video! I love the detailed breakdown and explanation.

  • @Chanceisafoodie
    @Chanceisafoodie Год назад +2

    My great great grandfather fought as a Union soldier at the age of 18 in this battle and was shot in the head. He survived and rejoined his regiment the next year.

    • @dvrmte
      @dvrmte 4 месяца назад +1

      My g g grandfather was a Confederate soldier who volunteered in late 1861 at age 28. He was married with four children and one on the way. My great grandfather was the one on the way.
      He was killed during the campaign against Pope. His division was the rear guard of Stonewall Jackson's army as it destroyed the Union supply depot prior to the Battle of Second Manassas/Bull Run. The image you see in my avatar is my ancestor. It's also on a battlefield marker at Bristoe Station/Kettle Run battlefield near where he fell. In exchange for the use of the photo, my sons and I were invited as guests of honor to the 150th commemoration. The battlefield guides gave us a personalized tour of the battlefield. They had got permission to metal detect on private land bordering the battlefield because that is where my ancestor's company of the 60th Georgia, was posted. They were able to locate the firing line by finding a line of dropped unfired bullets. Soldiers often dropped cartridges in the haste of battle. We took a handful of soil and a rock to place on his grave marker in Georgia since he was buried in an unmarked grave, probably close to the firing line. Hopefully we brought a piece of him home.

  • @bluejackgirlyx
    @bluejackgirlyx Год назад

    Cool opening sound effects! Good for you, man. YOU ARE BRIGHT!! Keep those sound effects coming - they make a REAL difference... many forget the power of slight, smal sounds that nature gives us. Well done, friends.

  • @RonnieDobbz1978
    @RonnieDobbz1978 5 лет назад +31

    its right there by the fair oaks mall, between safeway and whole foods.

    • @jason60chev
      @jason60chev 4 года назад +2

      I lived very near there in 1985-1987 and worked at the Radio Shack at Kamp Washington shopping center....also worked at a bank in Reston. I would drive by that field often, before it became a park. I think there was just a little marker. I remember when townhomes were being built, the remains of a soldier was discovered, which had South Carolina buttons on remnants of his uniform. Archeologists came to exhume the remains and after study, were sent to Columbia, SC for burial with full honors.

    • @stargazerspark4499
      @stargazerspark4499 Год назад

      It's unfortunate that one of the wealthiest counties in the US and the richest in Virginia by far did practically nothing to preserve it's only Civil War Battlefield. The developers wanted to remove Kearny & Stevens' memorials too but at least those property rights weren't for sale. At least it's destruction spurred on the creation of battlefield preservation groups to save this important heritage across the US before it's too late.

  • @ashleybishop9937
    @ashleybishop9937 5 лет назад +19

    Great vid but script repeats at about 5.21 and 7.55.

  • @johnzajac9849
    @johnzajac9849 3 года назад +2

    Modern route 29 meets route 50 (Arlington Blvd) at the location of the old village of Jermantown.

  • @misterbaker9728
    @misterbaker9728 2 года назад +2

    Great presentation

  • @kmslegal7808
    @kmslegal7808 3 года назад +2

    Fairfax Towne Center shopping mall. There is a small park across the street on a portion of the battlefield

  • @frankofva8803
    @frankofva8803 Год назад

    Rewatched. Just as good the second time!

  • @flickinggamer
    @flickinggamer 5 лет назад +12

    Scotchmen? So the 79th were heavy drinkers? Or Scotsmen, people from Scotland.

    • @SantomPh
      @SantomPh 4 года назад +3

      Scotch is just a way to say Scottish Whisky. A person from Scotland can be called Scotch, although people prefer Scots or Scotsman/woman

    • @kellyowens1868
      @kellyowens1868 Год назад

      Well I don't know much about all that malarkey ... or is it mcguillicutty ... hic cup
      I'll have you know I'm half Scots, or half Scottish if you prefer ...
      ... and as ye might see be me wee first name ... am half of the Irish in me ta boot.
      The thing is ... whena get's to drinkin' the mothers milk o'the Celts.
      To tell you the whole truth ...
      Halfa me just wants to get more than a wee drunk ... but the uther halfa me ...
      Juss don't wan to be payin' fur it.
      KOut

    • @minsapint8007
      @minsapint8007 Год назад

      Perhaps both - Scottish heavy drinkers. 🙂

  • @terryhiett3406
    @terryhiett3406 4 года назад +1

    I live in Winchester Virginia Which changed hands 72 times during the war I also work in Chantilly VA which is close to Manassas about an hour from Fredericksburg when you get to see a lot of the battlefields up close and in person and see the Strategic points they fought over it really shows the genius of those Southern Generals and how a country that's undermanned and under-armed could last so long and be so successful

    • @ottomatic3123
      @ottomatic3123 3 года назад +1

      It is an immense advantage to be defending rather than attacking. Consider Antietam and Gettysburg.

  • @timneal5617
    @timneal5617 3 года назад +1

    As a boy I lived by a well known man here who grew up in Chantilly, he was born in 1901, said as a kid they had breastworks and war stuff still there.

    • @Stefanthenautilus
      @Stefanthenautilus 2 года назад

      I can only imagine what it would have been like to grow up around one of these battlefields when they were still relatively "fresh", especially one of the big ones, like Gettysburg or Antietam. For a young child it would be a treat to explore.

    • @BezmenovDisciple
      @BezmenovDisciple 2 года назад

      @@Stefanthenautilus Agreed. Makes me jealous. My mother talked about how my uncle and grandfather used to find arrowheads and such while exploring random fields back in the 50s and 60s. I suspect they were finding the last of those historical artifacts before they were paved over or picked clean. Nothing left to explore these days without a space ship or a submarine. It's a shame.

  • @peterclague3539
    @peterclague3539 Год назад

    Great History teaching from across the Pond…..👏🇮🇲

  • @romegavadquez6310
    @romegavadquez6310 5 лет назад +6

    Christ couldn’t help them that day

  • @generalrendar7290
    @generalrendar7290 4 года назад +2

    Tactical loss, strategic victory in a nutshell.

  • @dukeman7595
    @dukeman7595 5 лет назад +2

    Outstanding account, thank you.

  • @15halerobert
    @15halerobert 4 года назад

    Just about 2 miles from where I grew up

  • @2011Matz
    @2011Matz 4 года назад +1

    A map should have a scale.

    • @justint.holljr.6746
      @justint.holljr.6746 4 года назад

      Always. And I like it when some of the modern landmarks are shown to also help with scale. I’ve been to this almost minuscule battlefield park and could not get a feel for where the troops had actually been. The same is true for the small battlefield park at Bristoe Station.

  • @BA-gn3qb
    @BA-gn3qb 5 лет назад +12

    When did the "tide of battle turn?"
    The Union got it's butt kicked from start to finish.

    • @sdushdiu
      @sdushdiu 5 лет назад +7

      Its amazing the Union forces managed to remain in existence given the ineptness of its military leadership.

    • @blaisevillaume2225
      @blaisevillaume2225 5 лет назад +5

      I think the more appropriate cliche would have been "when things went from bad to worse" or something like that.

    • @slavemonkey5063
      @slavemonkey5063 4 года назад

      yeah, i think they just meant "when they realized the tide of battle was against them". It was always against them in hindsight, but the Union soldiers had to find out first, right?

    • @jeep146
      @jeep146 4 года назад

      Nothing wrong with the soldier, just the generals. You also have to figure most battles were fought on terrain that was familiar to the Confederates. In Gettysburg Lee dresses down Stuart because without his support he was left blind on foreign soil. Once Grant, Sherman, and Sheridan took over, it was over.

  • @hankpikuni7024
    @hankpikuni7024 3 года назад +1

    Chantilly lace and a Pretty face.

  • @richardbradley2335
    @richardbradley2335 4 года назад +1

    love these vids but please keep the big er square with all the writing off the screen.....cant see any of the map !!!!!...301 to 305...excellent

  • @bonanzatime
    @bonanzatime 5 лет назад +1

    I had heard there was a 2 hour hand to hand combat in the pouring down rain with thunder and lightning because the gunpowder was too wet to fire reliably, where today is a big shopping mall.?? ..maybe an exaggerated rumor?.. Because I didn't hear it mentioned in this presentation.

    • @RatmanSays
      @RatmanSays 5 лет назад +1

      You're right, there's quite a few malls and neighborhoods over those lands now

    • @RonnieDobbz1978
      @RonnieDobbz1978 5 лет назад

      yeah its right by the mall.
      www.google.com/maps/place/Ox+Hill+Battlefield+Park/@38.8639594,-77.3719707,2066m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x89b64f5c5c28018d:0xa7dfbc2c2cf10ef8!8m2!3d38.8642786!4d-77.369725?hl=en

    • @indy_go_blue6048
      @indy_go_blue6048 4 года назад +2

      @@RonnieDobbz1978 That's okay. I-64 runs right through the middle of the Seven Days battlefield and the field of Fredricksburg where Burnside's men were slaughtered is all built up with housing and commercial property. You have your choice of McDonald's or Hardy's (c 1995) where the northern flank of Pickett's charge crossed. Modern times, boys; thank God the old soldiers created the national battlefields.

  • @jesskerr9805
    @jesskerr9805 3 года назад

    Adds are ??????I guess

  • @slantsix6344
    @slantsix6344 5 лет назад +14

    Stonewall almost surrounded and destroyed the Union army at this battle. The weather thwarted the ambush and enabled the Union army to get reinforcements. 2 Union Generals were killed here. The battle was fought in a terrible thunderstorm.

    • @HemlockRidge
      @HemlockRidge 5 лет назад +5

      It was NOT the whole Union Army.

    • @slantsix6344
      @slantsix6344 5 лет назад

      @@HemlockRidge I know, it was one of them

    • @HemlockRidge
      @HemlockRidge 5 лет назад +2

      @@slantsix6344 Only IX Corps and parts of III Corps of the Army of Virginia. That Army only existed in 1862. It's easy to verify, why didn't you?

    • @slantsix6344
      @slantsix6344 5 лет назад +1

      @@HemlockRidge I did not get specific because I don't feel it is that important. A corp is close to 8,000 men.

    • @HemlockRidge
      @HemlockRidge 5 лет назад +2

      @@slantsix6344 A corpS could be 8000, or it could be more or less. Attrition was sometimes not addressed, so numbers could vary widely. BUT that's not the question, a corps is NOT an Army. In fact there were only about a total of 6,000 federal soldiers engaged at Chantilly, against about 15,000 Confederate. Once again, easy to verify.

  • @KevinMalone-yy4jd
    @KevinMalone-yy4jd 7 месяцев назад

    This video needs serious help!

  • @Farlomous
    @Farlomous 3 года назад +3

    what a waste....such poor planning and leadership. instead of just waiting for reinforcements while it was raining, they sent their men headlong to their deaths. wait a couple of hours for a couple of more divisions to come up, put one on the turnpike in front of Jackson with artillery support and force him to attack. when he splits his attention, you hit is flank and drive him back. their damage at 2nd Manassas was far worse than what the Union took and Hill especially. Longstreet is too far away to reinforce AND has to go through the rest of Pope's army to do it.

    • @NefariousKoel
      @NefariousKoel 2 года назад

      Yeah, the coordination and timing was terrible for the Union. It was handled similarly by Kearney on the Union's right flank at 2nd Manassas too, failing to exploit early gains even though his chance of success was far greater in the earlier battle.

  • @residentevil1878
    @residentevil1878 5 лет назад +13

    IF only those union MEN could've seen into the future and saw WHAT would become of their efforts... I'm convinced they'd join their confederate brethren and marched together on Washington... Sued for peace and the removal of the slaves from U.S. soil.

    • @Jac2587
      @Jac2587 4 года назад +8

      Welp. That's a pretty racially charged stance, right there.

    • @Th3M4k40n
      @Th3M4k40n 4 года назад +2

      Let's file away that edge

    • @BezmenovDisciple
      @BezmenovDisciple 2 года назад

      I reckon you aren't wrong. These guys grandfathers committed treason and started a revolution over a tea tax. They would be horrified at what the feds are up to these days.

    • @LEEboneisDaMan
      @LEEboneisDaMan 2 года назад +2

      Bro what?

    • @jazzjj7665
      @jazzjj7665 6 месяцев назад +4

      Jesus Christ, you have to be put on a watchlist… who knows what violent acts you’ll commit

  • @crimony3054
    @crimony3054 5 лет назад +1

    All civil war battlefields should be remembered, but this one doesn't require further preservation. There were never earthworks there, the battle didn't last long, and it was not a dramatic outcome for either side.

    • @dontask6863
      @dontask6863 5 лет назад +3

      So the lives lost there are not enough to be sacred ground to you?

    • @crimony3054
      @crimony3054 5 лет назад +1

      @@dontask6863 No more than the lives lost on the highway make it sacred. There are no earthworks in Chantilly and there are hundreds of better battlefields to preserve. The preservation craze is outta control.

    • @dontask6863
      @dontask6863 5 лет назад +5

      It’s because folks DIED there fighting for this nation. The preservation “craze” is not strong enough. You sound like a disgruntled person that had to pay extra for a historical house status or couldn’t develop your new lingerie business because the land it was on was sacred. People like you are disgusting. You’d rather see a sea of Hardee’s and McDonald’s than a beautiful landscape that holds keys to our past. What a shame you are.

    • @crimony3054
      @crimony3054 5 лет назад +1

      @@dontask6863 Chantilly Battlefield is mostly townhouses, apartments, and highways. There are no earthworks. There are no significant monuments. And the relics were salvaged from the ground back when Fair Oaks was a driving range. There's nothing sacred about that ground.

    • @crimony3054
      @crimony3054 5 лет назад +1

      @@Reiman33 War makes ground sacred? What f-ed up religion is that? There are enough battlefields around. It's okay to purchase real estate you want to buy, but to block development is faulty. No one ever wanted a piece of land to own, but then they try to block its development into something useful. That stinks.

  • @TRNATO1
    @TRNATO1 4 года назад

    Terrible music sounds like a knock off Pirates of the Caribbean escapade.