I agree with some of the comments that Patrick and Emmy sang it very well together. But when Gerald sang it to her on the bridge towards the end.....there was no comparison to him. He owned that part beyond anyone. I just wish she didn't have to pull his mask off.
Look at them! Being so cute, looking at each others eyes, and holding hands, and getting so close to each other, and that little peck Patrick gave her in the end!! Soo cute, and really fits the song! Love it
Gerard Butler does have an excellent voice--it's more on the haunting side than powerful. And Gerard is not the only young guy to ever play the Phantom (eh-hem Ramin.)
@@michaelcastanaga5839 In all honesty, though Ramin has a clearer voice and probably a better range (Gerard can go falsetto, and so can Ramin), Gerard's persona and presence, plus older-sounding voice and acting, have me personally favoring him. Of course, Michael Crawford is my all time favorite.
Awwww she was so nervous in the beginning but after they hold hands she calms a bit and beams a genuine smile. And then her voice has more breath support 💖
I LOVE Sarah Brightman and I heard Emmy Rossum before I got the chance to hear Sierra Boggess, who did an remarkably stunning job as Christine but I have to admit that IMO Emmy Owned this song.
They are both stunning people with incredible voices! I loved them in the film and live! And aww when they kissed in the end, omg! They had a great chemistry! 😍
Gerard Butler was simply amazing and powerful as the phantom and no one could have performed in that intense, dark and sexy way better! And Patrick was also amazing as Emmy! The whole movie is a masterpiece and an extraordinary tribute to Andrew Lloyd Weber's masterpiece!
This just melts my heart-------one of THE most beautiful duets of all-time, & Emmy & Patrick are perfect. -------------Emmy, you were gorgeous. -----------------------Wolfsky9
Um, Gerard DOES have an excellent voice, so please stop hating on him simply because of a lack of previous "professional" experience with using said voice...you guys are really starting to get on my nerves!
It is so discouraging to read that someone here thinks ALW " looks creepy "; the man was born as he is, can't we just accept that ?? --As for Gerard Butler, remember it was ALW & Joel Schumacher who wanted Phantom to be tall, dark, sexy, & masculine, younger than the men who had been playing the role on B.'Way. And, IMHO, he was perfect, with that Scot's accent coming through . Emmy is so gorgeous, Patrick was perfect as Raoul, & the film is a masterpiece. Wolfsky9
the new phantom series is designed to pull in younger audiences by making the phantom into a young upstart cool guy but this is a 180 from the original vision which was so effective where the phantom is a cool calculating experienced and controlling fatherly figure.
Hey everyone! Andrew Lloyd Webber (the writer) chose the cast, so these people are exactly what he wanted. I thought the casting was great! Gerard is not the best singer in the world, but he has such passion and feeling in his voice. He brought me to tears often throughout the movie. Plus, he is easy on the eyes. Emmy Rossum has a great voice! I wish I could sing like she does.
I am so in shock. I saw The Conjuring not long ago, and I have seen a lot of Patrick Wilson recently. And today, randomly, I decided to revisit some Phantom film clips. But I just now realized after watching that the two actors are the same man... I never realized that Patrick played Raoul, or that he could sing like this... Oh, what a voice!
The 3 main character's from the Phantom of the Opera are who made me fall in love w/the movie. I wish that they would have played in the 2nd movie/play.
Great! Now I have two songs that touch me so much I get choked up when they're performed. This one (wow Emmy!) and Susan Tilson as Eponine singing On My Own from Les Mis (lucky to have seen this one live in Chicago during the 90's).
I think that Sir Lloyd Weber has the last rights to all the Great Airs of the Twentieth Century truly a prolific composer!!! All of his melodies are intoxicating and brilliant.
I think Patrick took her hand cause she was shaking, poor thing. :D And she was only 16-to be only 16, and hit the high notes of a much older professional (i.e. Sarah Brightman) is something extraordinary, indeed.
It matters not what you study, either way you'll still have your favorites and those who you just don't like. Even if you're a "professional" you still listen with a biased ear, and that, in the end, will never change.
@rogerzilla thats why during the show, they have the top E prerecorded, since most singers can't handle that night after night. this is also why the stage version has an alternate christine to perform 2 of the 8 shows a week...
actually loveformakeup13, she was 17 when they filmed the movie and only 16 when she got the part....just to be specific. but yes that is pretty amazing
It was because she performed opera professionally ever since she was a child. You should see her in her debut film. Her acting and singing is just too much for words. :)
The duet is great.....but I know I ain't the only guy here who notices that Emmy Rossum has a SMOKIN' HOT BODY....she's got the whole package. Sings, beautiful,and got a SMOKIN' HOT BODY....! DAMN....!
You thought it was odd that Gerard Butler played the Phantom since the character required an older man with an excellent voice? Well, then, he fit's the description! Gerard IS an older man with an AMAZING voice. You don't know what you're saying.
What's crazy about Gerard singing all his parts is that he's not a trained singer. Phantom was the first film he did when he sang his parts, but being from Scotland he has this natural kind of rock tone in his voice as he sings that he used very well in the film
Please don't try to change my opinion. He wasn't the best, but I loved him as the Phantom singing and all. If you're comparing him to the guys who play that role on stage, don't. It's not fair to group him with professional singers. Also, stage and film are two different mediums. Even you're a professional singer, you're going to have people you like and don't like. The Phantom was not a professionally trained singer in the book. He taught himself. Good and bad singing is relative and therefore everyone has their own idea of good and bad singing.
She sang in the childrens chorus at the Metropolitan Opera in NY from age 7 into her teen years, then took lessons again before she started shooting the film.
I thought it was great live. And I also believe Gerard did amazing for no previous experience in musicals and opera. Emmy had background from when she was younger and so did Patrick. So it's not fair to group them like they are all professional singers. :( but I do love Gerard. xD
I felt my heart melt when Patrick Wilson started to sing....oh oh
Eternelspotlessmind ugh me too i love him so much 💕
I'm a girl btw I just use a fake name 😄
I am so impressed with Patrick Wilson's clear, pitch-perfect voice.
I agree with some of the comments that Patrick and Emmy sang it very well together. But when Gerald sang it to her on the bridge towards the end.....there was no comparison to him. He owned that part beyond anyone. I just wish she didn't have to pull his mask off.
right! AND HE DIDN'T EVEN HAVE VOCAL TRAINING
AND HE'S DEAF IN ONE EAR! O_o
Anna Baker really wow he's good
Soul0Stealer no way, Patrick sang it way better than Gerard. Gerard ruined that song.
He sang it in a voice that broke my heart, especially after knowing what was coming at him
Look at them! Being so cute, looking at each others eyes, and holding hands, and getting so close to each other, and that little peck Patrick gave her in the end!! Soo cute, and really fits the song! Love it
Emmy Possum has such voice like an angel and it gives me goosebumps. I liked her ever since 2004 her talent is amazing😉.
Gerard Butler does have an excellent voice--it's more on the haunting side than powerful. And Gerard is not the only young guy to ever play the Phantom (eh-hem Ramin.)
Yeah but there is a difference, Ramin is awful
i respect your opinion, but Ramin is a better Phantom than Gerard
@@michaelcastanaga5839 In all honesty, though Ramin has a clearer voice and probably a better range (Gerard can go falsetto, and so can Ramin), Gerard's persona and presence, plus older-sounding voice and acting, have me personally favoring him. Of course, Michael Crawford is my all time favorite.
But he was the best looking and sexiest Phantom I've ever seen.
@@Mira_Dunia r u all serious? Comparing a theatre and film actor with each other? Wtf
Does nobody know that Patrick Wilson started off as a broadway singer?
Juliette Veronica I knew he won a Tony award for Oklahoma and the full Monty
Juliette Veronica no clue
Emmy & Patrick make this one of the most romantic duets, ever. I mean, EVER. OMG, Emmy you were so gorgeous ! Wolfsky9
I love how Patrick takes her hand ... so sweet!
Love Emmy and Patrick. They are both so talented and well rounded in their talents.
I wish there was a clip of this in hd. For the audio. I like this version better than the movie one
OMG andrew lloyd webber is playing the piano behind them and i just realized
emmy is such a beautiful singer, i- i'm just absolutely amazed.
Awwww she was so nervous in the beginning but after they hold hands she calms a bit and beams a genuine smile. And then her voice has more breath support 💖
I loved Gerard Butler as the phantom and he is older than both Emmy Rossum and Patrick Wilson. His voice was amazing!
I LOVE Sarah Brightman and I heard Emmy Rossum before I got the chance to hear Sierra Boggess, who did an remarkably stunning job as Christine but I have to admit that IMO Emmy Owned this song.
They are both stunning people with incredible voices! I loved them in the film and live! And aww when they kissed in the end, omg! They had a great chemistry! 😍
is that the guy from the conjuring?!!
yup and insidious
and watchmen
Radiohead yup I knew lol
yesss he is i love him
Radiohead yes....didn't know he could sing
Patrick Wilson has a very beautiful voice.
That was beautiful. Emmy your voice is so precious and powerful. This song is wow, I loved the movie and encourage you to always sing!!!
Beautiful song they sound wonderful together Emmy and Patrick are very well trained singers great duet great live beautiful melody and song
I would love to sing this song with Patrick Wilson
I love this! They sang it so well! ❤ Love this movie!
Same here~~~
Gerard Butler was simply amazing and powerful as the phantom and no one could have performed in that intense, dark and sexy way better! And Patrick was also amazing as Emmy! The whole movie is a masterpiece and an extraordinary tribute to Andrew Lloyd Weber's masterpiece!
This just melts my heart-------one of THE most beautiful duets of all-time, & Emmy & Patrick are perfect. -------------Emmy, you were gorgeous. -----------------------Wolfsky9
Patrick❤️❤️❤️
beautiful voice!!!
Its a young love story... I love the innocence of this song...
Um, Gerard DOES have an excellent voice, so please stop hating on him simply because of a lack of previous "professional" experience with using said voice...you guys are really starting to get on my nerves!
Child of Music and Dreams
yeah, it could have been cast much worse **cough** Russell Crowe **cough, cough**
@ironfire98 We're not saying he would make it in the stage musical, dude.
@ironfire98 No, just that we all have our favorites. If other people say their favorite is Gerry, respect that.
ironfire98 Would love to see you do better 💀😂
@ironfire98 but its a movie production though not a broadway production.
It is so discouraging to read that someone here thinks ALW " looks creepy "; the man was born as he is, can't we just accept that ?? --As for Gerard Butler, remember it was ALW & Joel Schumacher who wanted Phantom to be tall, dark, sexy, & masculine, younger than the men who had been playing the role on B.'Way. And, IMHO, he was perfect, with that Scot's accent coming through . Emmy is so gorgeous, Patrick was perfect as Raoul, & the film is a masterpiece. Wolfsky9
the best version I swear lol
Perfect.
she is so gorgeous and has such an amazing voice
Emmy Has the most beautiful voice in the whole world
I love this song. These two are so perfect together.
FIONA GALLEGHAR!
She did not play Christine to be known as fiona🤦🏽♀️
@@NessWrldd, but she did a great job with both characters.
She will always be "Christine Daae" to me..
I remember watching POTO in 2004, then when I started watching Shameless I did a double take lol.
@@eyb0sswelcometothericefiel752 Poto significa trasero en Latinoamérica xD
I love this song. I had it played at my wedding.
And the water works have started. IM THINKING OF THE ROOF SCENE AND IM NOT OKAY. HELP.
It’s sick how much I’ve watched this movie. Best version ever
the new phantom series is designed to pull in younger audiences by making the phantom into a young upstart cool guy but this is a 180 from the original vision which was so effective where the phantom is a cool calculating experienced and controlling fatherly figure.
Wow they both are enchanting!
Patrick Wilson so good looking and he can sing!❤️❤️💕
Beautiful performance, they even live look great together and sound great together. Patrick looks a lot better with short hair then long.
Hey everyone! Andrew Lloyd Webber (the writer) chose the cast, so these people are exactly what he wanted. I thought the casting was great! Gerard is not the best singer in the world, but he has such passion and feeling in his voice. He brought me to tears often throughout the movie. Plus, he is easy on the eyes. Emmy Rossum has a great voice! I wish I could sing like she does.
I am so in shock. I saw The Conjuring not long ago, and I have seen a lot of Patrick Wilson recently. And today, randomly, I decided to revisit some Phantom film clips. But I just now realized after watching that the two actors are the same man... I never realized that Patrick played Raoul, or that he could sing like this... Oh, what a voice!
i see no flaws or imperfection, i think this was fantastically beautiful!
Emmy + Gerard are my fav Christine and phantom
YES AMEN
Wow! wonderful voice of Patrick Wilson!!! i really like it!!! : )
The 3 main character's from the Phantom of the Opera are who made me fall in love w/the movie. I wish that they would have played in the 2nd movie/play.
Great! Now I have two songs that touch me so much I get choked up when they're performed. This one (wow Emmy!) and Susan Tilson as Eponine singing On My Own from Les Mis (lucky to have seen this one live in Chicago during the 90's).
Wow!! PATRICK!!! He has a really nice voice
I love this Movie so much! The Songs are simply great!!! Andrew Loyd Webber is the best!
I love that movie ❤️❤️😫😫💯💯😭😭
Patrick Wilsons voice is like butter! EXCELLENT singer!! :D
ganda ng voice nla bgay n bgay ung blending ng voice nla sarap pkingan
IT MAKES ME SO HAPPY THEY CAN ALL SING WOWOWOWOWOW
I think that Sir Lloyd Weber has the last rights to all the Great Airs of the Twentieth Century truly a prolific composer!!!
All of his melodies are intoxicating and brilliant.
Patrick Wilson is enchanting *sigh*
エイミーが大人っぽかった。ついでに、すごい背が高いことがわかった。
I think they both are awesome, and so is Gerard, so I am VERY happy with the casting :P
Patrick Wilson is my hero. *swoon*
And Emmy Rossum is soooo hoottt... *swoon*
パトリック、また日本に来てねー！！ 日本語、話せるようになったみたいだしｗ
Beautiful !
beautiful!
I think Patrick took her hand cause she was shaking, poor thing. :D
And she was only 16-to be only 16, and hit the high notes of a much older professional (i.e. Sarah Brightman) is something extraordinary, indeed.
I love phantom of the opera and of course Emmy As Christine has it awesome voice
Emmy is so talented
I always find it amazing how different she seems when singing this vs. her singing "slow me down" from her album. She's incredible at both styles!
Aaaahhh Emmy’s voice makes my heart melt 😩😍💕
wow,that's amazing!!the sing exactly as they sing in the movie..
It matters not what you study, either way you'll still have your favorites and those who you just don't like. Even if you're a "professional" you still listen with a biased ear, and that, in the end, will never change.
THANK YOU!
his voice is absolutely amazing. this wasn't her best performance, but i still looove her
they are perfect!!!!
Love their voice!^^
Wow he is amazing live!
Great songs for this valentine ^^
@rogerzilla thats why during the show, they have the top E prerecorded, since most singers can't handle that night after night. this is also why the stage version has an alternate christine to perform 2 of the 8 shows a week...
That was lovely.
actually loveformakeup13, she was 17 when they filmed the movie and only 16 when she got the part....just to be specific. but yes that is pretty amazing
BRAVO !!!
I love this song :")
she is such a good singer
wow.. so lovely
I did not realize that was Patrick and Emmy for some reason 😳 😅
Both are such knockouts. n___n
It was because she performed opera professionally ever since she was a child. You should see her in her debut film. Her acting and singing is just too much for words. :)
I completely agree with you. I like Gerry and Emmy's mix too. I've always thought that.
The duet is great.....but I know I ain't the only guy here who notices that Emmy Rossum has a SMOKIN' HOT BODY....she's got the whole package. Sings, beautiful,and got a SMOKIN' HOT BODY....! DAMN....!
um.. I loved Gerald butler in this movie. he had a wonderful voice. i think it suited the phantom so much.
Rossum and Wilson performing LIVE is even better than hearing them pre-recorded!
i love him!
You thought it was odd that Gerard Butler played the Phantom since the character required an older man with an excellent voice? Well, then, he fit's the description! Gerard IS an older man with an AMAZING voice. You don't know what you're saying.
What's crazy about Gerard singing all his parts is that he's not a trained singer. Phantom was the first film he did when he sang his parts, but being from Scotland he has this natural kind of rock tone in his voice as he sings that he used very well in the film
@PopKing It's a good idea to say "I think Gerard was the worst Phantom singing wise." Whether he was bad or good are people's opinions.
No, he wasn't the best. I thought he was still good, though.
I also find it very rude that you wrote lmao.
Please don't try to change my opinion. He wasn't the best, but I loved him as the Phantom singing and all. If you're comparing him to the guys who play that role on stage, don't. It's not fair to group him with professional singers. Also, stage and film are two different mediums. Even you're a professional singer, you're going to have people you like and don't like. The Phantom was not a professionally trained singer in the book. He taught himself. Good and bad singing is relative and therefore everyone has their own idea of good and bad singing.
Wow on the dress!!!
wonderful
Didn't expect the peck at the end, but still cute & beautiful video overall👏👏👏
Amazing!
DAMN I LOVE HIM
Wow both so talented. Emmy is baeutiful and Patrick is hot.
Huh... wasn't expecting the show to be Japanese. Love this song
@katbby23 i totally agree! her singing is beautiful but you can tell her voice is still developing,,,,gotta love emmy!
Очень понравилось!!!! замечательное видео-вызывает улыбку и поднимает настроение! Обожаю этот фильм!
i love this song
She sang in the childrens chorus at the Metropolitan Opera in NY from age 7 into her teen years, then took lessons again before she started shooting the film.
I thought it was great live. And I also believe Gerard did amazing for no previous experience in musicals and opera. Emmy had background from when she was younger and so did Patrick. So it's not fair to group them like they are all professional singers. :( but I do love Gerard. xD