Indian government: We're sticking with Russia | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 фев 2024
- India is standing by its close relationship with Russia - refusing to join the widespread condemnation of the death of opposition leader Alexei Navalny. Speaking to DW at the Munich Security Conference, BJP National Spokesman Jaiveer Shergill said India is “on the side of peace.” With Germany and France signing pledges to keep providing Ukraine with weapons, Shergill urged Europe to consider “what would it take to stop the war?”
Shergill addressed the challenge facing India from China, saying “the era of one single power domination is long gone.”
Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#India #Russia #Ukraine
"India doesn't crave for attention from West to tackle China"- that line hit hard this reporter😂😂😂
Really ? 😅😅😅😅
@@user-cm2lu1lc4q Of course. India has never approached any other country to drum up support against china .....but giving China what it deserves directly, through diplomacy, military, and Economic measures........Western countries are using this scenario as a hedge against China is for their own interest and by their own prerogative.
Had India needed the support it would have changed the nature of the Quad from purely economic to a military cooperative nature.....but despite USA wanting to India has resisted such a move, India keeps buying oil from Russia....do you think if there was dependency on the West fir India's security India would have been able to msintain such a strategic autonomy, which even Europe cannot?
@@tanmayhaldar7565 Yep we will see how long, especially as artificial intelligence develops.
I kind of like India is not a camp follower. It's similar to Nelson Mandela's your enemy is not my enemy. While NATO is flaunting the alliance as a sign of strength, reality has shown that they are a bunch weak insecure fellows who have traded their national pride and survernty to uncle Sam for protection.
@@user-cm2lu1lc4qCheck the History. And look what India does to China in Future
I’ll translate the gentleman’s answer in layman’s speak:
“Not our clowns, not our circus.”
Sad but facts
Perfect
@@ArabianKnight63sad for who? The global South does the right thing, it's not their war, not their issues.
History Lesson :When Pakistan attacked India in 1972 and a war broke out. The EU and the US sent military to support Pakistan. It was Russia and Israel which helped us win the war. Now the EU and US want us to openly condemn them? This is rubbish. Well done spokesperson
"but we're definitely still best friends with the war-crime clown"
Although China and India have differences... China and India are consistent in their attitude towards hypocrites...
But we Indians will never trust CCP neither any Chinese people in the current situation.....we would like to have TIBET FREE.....
@@Clklom你还是先关心一下那些被印度政府屠杀的穆斯林吧！！不要总是想着分裂别人的国家😂😂
@@Cheeraddl Brother , then why China demolished mosque and built toilet in its ruins.... ???
@@Cheeraddldekho baat bhi kon kar raha 😂
China is aggressive towards others, India are not.
India didn't impose sanctions on the US and G.Britain when they invaded and occupied Iraq, Korea, Yugoslavia, Afghanistan...
Bravo!
Sadly, Don't have influence to do so.
Western bullies wins here
@@Dr.Kraig_Rennotwithstanding. Doesnt make Usa and Nato the decision makers on whats legitimate and whats not
in layman's words, "Not my problem."
And that still sounds genuine.
Yep! not our problem ..your enemies are your enemies..not ours
Western countries think their problems is global problems.
Global warming : India will be uninhabitable
(Let's hope Russia comes to the rescue, because the West
will tell India to get stuffed !)
I encourage americans and europeans to look up 1971 bangladesh war and realize how US and west supported mass genocide and rape, supported dictatorship over democratically elected candidate and hence pushed India towards Russia.
He's a true politician. Speaking a lot without saying anything.
Sounds a lot like Putin. Lies every time he opens his mouth.
Usa + eu is backing genocide in gaza but India has called for ceasefire in Ukraine and gaza 😊
@@Kartoffelsuppe_m_Wursteinlage so does the leaders of the West and everywhere else in the world. Atleast he's not being a hypocrite.
Nonsense, if he doesn't say anything.
He speaks it perfectly, you can't get what you want, its democracy, we have our own opinion
Note " India is not in the business of issuing Conduct certificates to other countries" . That's nice one. Implied is "Nor should others judge us".
"Standing in Germany I will not indulge in opposition bashing." - Did the DW reporter get the hint?
It seems that way as he moved on to another question. What is your point?
How can India not stand up against aggression
@@steverolf5279Same way west never stood against Pakistani aggression towards india. Same way west kept supplying weapons to a terrorist nation Pakistan against world's largest democracy.
RAGA
he got the message
India supports its own interests!
Every country does
@@debapriyasahoo10 are you sure ? 🤔
@@debapriyasahoo10Very few, India, China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela and that's it.
Everyone else is a vassal of the US.
@@eddastrohmayer251yeah. Especially with their moves
...just like China they have interests like in kashmir.
My man droped nuke in his first sentence 😂
India’s courts are drowning in over 5 crore pending cases, with most of them stuck in the lower judiciary. At this rate, it would take more than three centuries to clear the backlog. This is a nightmare for millions of litigants who suffer injustice, poverty, and uncertainty due to the endless delays. Shame on india, 🇮🇳 no vision and no quality of service or life.
Number of pending cases: As of December 2022, over 5 crore (50 million) cases are pending across all levels of courts in India, with over 4.3 crore languishing in district courts alone.
* Time for case resolution: With the current disposal rate, it's estimated to take over 324 years to clear the existing backlog.
* Impact on citizens: Delays in resolving cases can cause immense hardship for litigants, affecting their lives, finances, and businesses.
Shame shame 75 years of independence still running on British made judiciary 🧑⚖️ system 😀😀😀. No make in india for law and order.
😂butthurt@@IndiaNoKidsToilets
Fr😂
I hope this guy doesn't have much say in India
We don't even know him, but yes the general sentiments are pro-Russia. The 1971 Bangladeshi war of independence amplifies it further.
@@steverolf5279
Meanwhile Germany is importing Russian gas refined at Indian refineries. :)
@@wsffffit's a fact not joke...
Fact@@wsffff
"India is not in the habit of handing out certificates on particular policy stand of EU"
I like that. Something EU US can learn.
India don't need certificate from EU.
History Lesson :When Pakistan attacked India in 1972 and a war broke out. The EU and the US sent military to support Pakistan. It was Russia and Israel which helped us win the war. Now the EU and US want us to openly condemn them? This is rubbish. Well done spokesperson
@@puneetsunder India does not have any real experience with Russia. Yes, geopolitically they were kind of allies but people and politicians in India have no clue what is the real Russia like. For me as an Eastern European the Indian approach is a big disappointment.
@@miroslavdusin4325 and the west doesn't know what Pakistan is like, yet they continue to supply weapons to Pakistan, most of which always end up being used against India. Hope this helps you understand something.
@avdusin4325 They have experience with the West,thats enough to side with Russia. Or to be more precise,side with the West against Russia.
Better get out of your western bubble a bit and see what others places think of the West and its foreign aggression policies and general Western Hegemony. Even compared to the West,Russia has a better reputation globably. Like in Africa or Latin America,but not only.
We are bullies,nothing more to add tothat. The Word,along with India,has had enough of the Western Hegemony and being told what to do and how to do it by the West.
He is not a government spoke person ... he is a party spoke person ... DW should correct it's mistake
They are considering India as one party.
He literally said "the spokesperson for the governing party of India, the BJP"
BJP is the government
The ruling party is the government
@@avinashtyagi2 to correct you ... BJP is running the government not the government. Any political party's stance does not reflect its country's stance as there is constitution and judicial system to stop a party from doing anything which doesn't interest India or it's people.
Nowadays, every Indian is a chad on foreign policy.😂😂
Wdf Is chad
@@pauldiego17someone who is super confident, super good at something..whose response and actions make everybody impressed.
Edit- this is the Indian definition of this word. It may differ in other countries.
😂
@@pauldiego17 A chad is a stereotypical Alpha male who is very attractive, influential, confident and very famous among women.
*Mr S Jai Shankar Chad-Men*
🥂🚬🗿🔥☠️🌪️⚡🇮🇳👑💪🏻
They are losing against Indian's in this comment section 😅😢😂
After all democracy is a game of numbers... 😂
I will lose to you ❤
😂😂😂😂
@@chinyalp1made me chuckle 😂
Good joke
@@kubuhzz-lm2786bahat badmas ho vai
India is a neutral country. Should stick to no one.
India is sticking to doing illegal business with Russia.
As a tibetan born in India. I am certain, India is the greatest and biggest true democratic nation on this planet. Thank you, India 🇮🇳. Jai Hind Jai Tibet.
No Democracy in india. Only Dictatorship but they brag as India to cheat west.
Jai Hind, Jai Tibet!
The people of CHINA support the people of KALISTAN and struggle for free from Hindustan.
@@Puntland1we also support tibet and inner Mongolia
but they don't support democracy abroad
"You provoked a war, you didn't help us in our problems, we don't care about your problems."
Is that how you live your life?
@@christianevanherck6023yes it’s called Karma. Hindus strongly believe that everybody pays for their good or bad deeds eventually.
@@Worldlackscommonsense then India has some bad Karma coming their way for financing Russia's war in Ukraine.
@@christianevanherck6023maybe… like how Americans created mujahideens in Afghanistan to fight Russians? Those mujahideens are now Taliban and we know what happened there.
Like how Americans ignored the mass rape of Bangladeshi women and supported Pakistan and India had to liberate Bangladesh with Russian support?
Lots of history is not taught in Western books.
You call Kissinger a legend- not so much so. A criminal he really was…
@@christianevanherck6023maybe. Like how Americans supported Mujahideens with Pakistan to fight Russia. These muhahideens are now Taliban and we know what happened there.
Like how Americans supported Pakistan in the Bangladesh liberation war. While the Pakistani generals committed not so nice stuff against Bangladeshi women. And India had to liberate Bangladesh with Russian support.
Lots of history isn’t taught in Western history books.
BJP's spokesperson is not less than a well trained diplomate - great to see youth is coming in politics with right ethics - long live India
he was dodging all the questions
@@goldenhorde106 nope . he didnt
@@goldenhorde106were we watching the same video?😅
India slapped hardest on America's face again 😁!
Usa should adopt russia peace policy & support India against China.
@@PraveenKumar-kt1qrthat’s a sensitive topic
He is a party spokesperson, not a government official🤦🤦🤦
The party that dominates India, Modi rules, while pappu can only walk
not a good party
But the ruling party of that government, unfortunately.
@@joeferreti9442we Indians will tell weather it’s good party or bad party my putting majority votes we don’t need cheap outsiders opinion kid
I voted for bjp, it's better than any other party in India
He said same words what western countries used to say us when Pakistan conducted terrorist attacks and killed our civilians ....reason in todays Indian diplomatic aspirants have line common in them " there are 4 direction North , South , East and Hypocrisy. "
😂😂😂
Yeah. Especially the EU is like that. The EU wants the US and the whole world to focus everything on Ukraine but the EU itself doesn’t support the American stance on defending Taiwan.
EU should first sanction China if they have the guts..,😅
@@artman12 lol good point...the (former) emperors truly have no clothes!
🤐🤣😂
As a Ukrainian Canadian I admire and respect Indians.
It’s fascinating to see Germany keeps choosing wrong path of history .
How come DW makes fundamental errors while reporting? Is the guy talking as BJP spokesman or is he talking about official Indian Govt position?
Shhh! BJP is very evil thing.
Who votes for the members of Indian government? :)
@@trifio5242a percentage of population.
@@Leaf_Walker That is democracy. One wins with a Simple Majority.
@@asmirann3636 It's not. If only a percentage of the population gets to vote, it's de facto no democracy.
Additionally voting for representatives that run the parliament is a representative democracy, not a true democracy.
Strategic Autonomy and Non-Alignment are the two pillars of India's international policy.
Strategic Stupidity and Non-Understanding of Anything are the two pillars of India's international policy.
@@mr.primanlike you think yourself most intelligent person!
It is very thanking Putin sir that bharat economy doing very great. While hypocriting west sanction Russia, bharat continuing very full support of the great war crimings of Putin sir, very enjoying cheap oil and coal from Russia! Jai Hind! Jai shree Putin!!
@@AdityaBaitalit does not take intelligence really. India decides to stay with a murderous state. And this muppet here talks about peace.
And you know it would be still ok, to be just an egotistical country with no respect for anything but it’s own existence. But the reality is that Russia will turn India in one of its many “….Stan” slave states.
@@user-pv2xy1og8hSo only West can make a profit and everyone else must fall in line for them? Yeah right, good luck with that...
First line was like a atom bomb😂😂😂😂😂😂
His first sentence was a slap in the face😂😂😂
There is no permanent friend, only temporary interest.
And future enemy.
Lolll tell that to andhbhakts who blindly follow Russia…. If leadership in west changes as with Putin, it can change all sides of the equation. Praying for India cuz it’s gonna need it- definitely needs sense of wisdom instead of blindly following anyone tbh.
Russia is 100% wrong on this one
For US it sure is the case but russia india relationship is a genuine one
A permanent friend might be temporary out of interest but staying a friend until interests are crossing again.
Each country has its own interest to promote and protect.
Russia is an enemy of Europe. Only Europe and the US. India is a friend of Russia
Not the Germany; they are just kukolds 😁
@@trappedinthamaze cry about it
@@sohamparab7436 ignore the NAFO scammers😂😂
😂EU is desperate on DT return
The caption is inaccurate. He serves as a spokesperson for the 'party,' not the government. In India, unlike China, there exists a clear distinction between party and government roles.
Yeah party spokesperson cannot become diplomat representing a nation. He is speaking like a party person. West needs more clarity about India
Yeah I reported it. Hopefully they see
Though a party spokesman he did well even diplomatically...a brillliant hi-calibre young man
I love india . A true friend seen in hard days .
The world is mutch bigger than Europe
And that excuses extreme amounts of war crimes? You are not making a good case for the "world" here
Yeah, and our fear is to not face a ww3 while pacifist India's friends are trying their best to start one. I lived through a dictatorship, I don't wish it on my worst enemy. India supporting Putin not Russia, nor Russians. India is supporting its own interests when Russia will be a wasteland after Poo dies, cause this kind of man makes sure there's no one to substitute him. India will use Russia's precious natural resources after it turns in a graveyard.
And it continues to get bigger as Europe shrinks geopolitically, militarily, and economically.
And potato is bigger than ant. Ergo India can be chummy with war criminals
What about the crimes committed by the west? Heck even now in Gaza?@@skontejonte
Did not the US veto a cease fire in Gaza yet DW has never seriously questioned that.
A ceasefire and then what? Another 10/7?
@@tomatomi8041 Put pressure on Russia for the sake of west Which supported Pakistan militarily against India in 1971?
@@deathsupplier8408 What do you mean by putting pressure on russia? The ones who are invading Europe as we speak? Currently they're bragging about conquering and annexing another city.
@deathsupplier8408 you won't hear that here!
@@tomatomi8041Kargil war and 26/11 terror attacks did not stop US and west from aligning with Pakistan!
This gentleman gave to the point answers to the questions. The reporter tried hard to make him say controversial things, but the Indian representative remain firm and answered his questions perfectly. Western Media, and the West itself especially The US, must understand one thing that they cannot make India do things as they want. Time has changed. Mark my words, ten years from now, India will be a superpower, at that time, no one will have the guts to ask India for anything. So The US and European Union must accept this reality and respect India's sovereign decisions at global level.
... and who cares?
DW man is very well trained in USA
Whole Europe is trained to look after the interest of there OVERLORD UK AND US
His quesitons are valid and makes sense. US does not provide training to journalists.
@@kingdomofgeorgia1751 isn't Germany under US occupation ?
@@ytskt This is not occupation rather than agreement between the two countries. If Germans ask Americans to leave, they leave. However, Germans don't want US army to leave because it protects Germany and provides income to German economy.
@@kingdomofgeorgia1751😂😂
It appears even the interviewee himself does not believe his own words 😂
what made it appear like that?
The interviewee failed because the interviewer was repeatedly saying only one thing: we are on the side of peace!
He is spokesperson of BJP, rulling a political party. He is not under any Govt position. And is answer proves that he is a NPC...
That's all in your head my friend.
You lack understanding. You're just bitter cos you didnt get to hear what you wanted to hear. Deal with it!!!
Regardless of the points he is making, I find it interesting that DW News is labeling these views as those of the Indian Government when this is a party spokeperson, he doesnt represent the Indian Government like the title of this video implies.
Its DW. Theyre just propoganda. Sometimes theyre good, but theyll say anything to fit the agenda.
in his first sentence he clearly speaks for the whole of India as a nation. he explains India's position
India is taking advantage of various forces and is wearing down the patience of the West. The West must exert greater pressure on India, including financial investment and market access.
@@80-80. I clearly speak for the whole of India. Who appointed this dude?
Honest, I could not even listen 'til the end. It repels me how this man is winding around like a slithery worm.
We love India and Russia 🇷🇺- from South Africa 🇿🇦
Let me guess, your a member of the African National Congress, the political party that enjoys putting a rubber tire around someones neck and setting it afire if they do not agree with the ANC.
It's wrong to say that India is sticking with Russia. It's sticking with its national interest.
It's called being selfish! Well, it gives an easy answer to India's calls for any future western help then!😎
@@miroslavnovak6567 what planet are you from? Why wouldn't they care for their interest when western nations only care about theirs.
@@miroslavnovak6567Ask the west which side did they supported when there were conflicts on indian border.
@@fatmanfrommillennium7369 The west supported and funded West Pakistan in 1970-71 against India, the US Navy had a blockade and supplied tanks to our enemy. This war led to the creation of Bangladesh (previously East Pakistan) as a free country. West Pakistan didn't want someone from East Pakistan to run the government despite election results. So the west supported the anti-democratic West Pakistan. Russia came to India's help back then.
How do you talk with such confidence when you are so ignorant?
We don't need you now or ever.
@@miroslavnovak6567 Joker as we will take it free without dollars like vassals
Russia and Israel help India when west was hostile towards India ..in 1971 Bangladesh war & Kargil war ..so as indian culture we never ever leave friends who indeed helped in difficult times .its our only lesson taught by our ancestors..
Is Bangladesh part of India now?
@@koushikdas1992are you trolling? No bangladesh is not part of india. But 71 is still important to India since thats how they got closer to russia and eventually with Israel
@@koushikdas1992 should have taken bangladesh in 1971 and shipped all pakistan loving bangladeshi razakars to pakistan
Who helped India in Kargil war ? Bill clinton called Nawaz to Washington and warned him to stop the war. Thats why it came to end angering Musharaf against Nawaaz. But India saved lot of its soldiers lives. Be thankful to USA. Russia dont have many frineds. So keeps India in its clutches.
@@koushikdas1992 who wants 160 m 🐷
He sounds like someone who doesn’t want to anger the bullies
India is a more powerful country than Russia by all measures Russia can never be a bully to India Russia has its problems but usa is the biggest bully in the world.
Diplomacy 101
West saying that they do not support Palestine genocide but supports Israel is any different?? 😅
He yaps at China but is like "we love our master russia"😂
Sounds more like someone the bullies can't touch
That was an intense round.
Well read journalist ,
And equally answered by counterpart bjp spokesperson.
Europe has to grow out of the mindset that Europe's problems are the world's problems, but the world's problems are not Europe's problems."...😊😊😊
what is the west doing in regards to Palestine? They say they do not support the Palestine genocide but will not cut its ties with Israel?? Isn’t that hypocritical? If you can understand the logic n sensibilities there then you surely can extend the same to India’s stand in Russia Ukraine conflict! India doesn’t support any violence but we will not cut our ties with any country- Ukraine nor Russia! Simple! Not rocket science!
There are no friends or enemies in geopolitics, just interests! Your neighbour’s neighbour is your friend! China’s neighbours Russia n India will maintain good ties with each other to keep the bully dragon in check! We do not support any conflict but we can’t put our security n interests at risk for a temporary conflict elsewhere. isn’t that what west is doing in Israel Palestine war? Maintaining good relations with both without supporting the genocide? Why such hypocrisy then?
Respect India FM
The West will make India pay for supporting Russia. And that rightfully.
that is a wasteful what aboutism. We don't talk about other problems when you have to think of a solution to one problem.
It became an Indian problem when India started supporting Russia after Ukraine war started.
India supplies Humanitarian aid
EU provides weapons
That's the difference between an ancient civilization and warmongers!
So the west supplies only weapons? No aid? Serious you believe that?
whats the use of aid ? if you cant stop the war ? Only weapons or strict action needed to finish the war. Dont act innocent and as a helping guy.
@@narenaw4258 but we are not funding the war, we r not supplying weapons to these slavic people to destroy each other. So we are not at fault. I saw a video clip of some western leader who was saying to zelensky that "this is the best investment of our money, russians are dying". It saddens me that how western people feeling happy in funding war. My nation India is peaceful country and we do not interfere in other's affairs. Its none of our business!
"warmongers" - are you referring to russia?
@@BaronLemon no..i m referring to EU and USA
Hypocrisy of West when comparing Ukraine conflict and Palestine conflict is just outrageous. India, China atleast have been consistent
Why is it outrageous? Russia started the Ukraine War and the Palestinians started the war in Gaza, it is an open and shut case!
Also, I must highlight that the summary is a misrepresentation of what the man actually said. It is an opinion of DW and not what the interviwee actually said.
That is what the spokeperson says although it might not fit with your views. India and Russia would always remains friends and ally. India is not involved with Russia "internal affairs", but they are friends and would remains engaged and trade and help each other. The West is still trying to pull India and Russia apart.
News Papers can’t have opinions. They can have opinion pieces or things from the bureau, or official stand. But they can’t quote “Indian Government” and pretend that people will assume ofc that it’s an opinion of what they think India is saying.
Death of Alexei Navalny is sad and condemn-able. So is the arrest, torture of Julian Assange and hounding him with false charges by the USA and UK. Russia should learn from USA how to do nasty things wrapped in veil of legal process and rule of law. They should have charged him of espionage like they did with Julian Assange.
Alexei died due to natural reasons. You cannot blame anyone for that.
@@borisnikator7060 so natural just like Wagner’s leader 😂
Julian Assange? Is he dead like...Boris Nemtsov, Anna Politkovskaya, natasha Estemirova, 30 oligarchs who tripped out of the windows or even Prigozhyn etc.?
@@hamodalbatal464 people die due to health issues. But business jets don't fall out of the sky out of the blue.
just like trump has too many law suits@@borisnikator7060
Why doesn't the EU and nata choose dialog instead of supplying more weapons ?
This person in more qualified than Rahul Gandhi
The West itself has forgotten this while lecturing to the world that “you cannot bully any sovereign nation into making its own decisions”.
When was the last time that "The West" annexed the territory of another country after invading it?
Your grammar is confused
@@mainStream-user Then perhaps, this bot will give you a more grammatically correct one. India does not give a penny about what USA or Russia does. Go invade smaller countries, we do not care. We are here for business, nothing else. Our wars are ours, yours are yours.
@@mainStream-user looks like u don't have any argument 😂
Hmm. It's difficult to become a regional leader, and yet remain neutral and fair. I think you'll witness the "strategic autonomy" and "non-interference" stance change rapidly this decade.
India support which benefits indias interests and india do not care who fight with whom it is upto the warring party to solve with. India work for its benefits.
By financially supporting Russia's war in Ukraine?
@@christianevanherck6023how, don't say oil
@@christianevanherck6023and also providing humanitarian aid to Ukraine right & don't forgot western nations&us is also doing business with Russia😂 they only select one item which they doesn't need it bt spare 100s of items which they need it😂
@@christianevanherck6023 are you talking about around 100 billion dollars import of energy by Europe from Russia in 2024
@@user-rv6bt6bi9b 100 billion was in 2022 not now
Independent foreign policy Matters 🔥
The journalist / interviewer was very well informed about India-related issues and domestic politics. He asked good questions in a very professional way. Respect from India.
If West wants India to support them. They need to support India in its interest.
It doesnt go both ways that you support Pakistan and expect us to take your side when you need it.
without west support, by now, India would have collapsed. All IT jobs, money inflow belong to west only.
The only country that will be willing to help India against China is the united states of America.
China has already defeated the Indian army in India in the last war.
You guys are not smart.
It's not about support it's about calling out a bad action from Russia
@@steverolf5279 Why don't west calls out pakistan for its bad action? Even if Indian government had any intention to support west's stance on Russia the people India won't allow them to do it. West is now a synonym for hypocrisy.
@olf5279 Why should we? Does West condemn Pakistani cross border terrorism? Does west condemn China illegally occupying Indian territory? Your problem is not our problem period...
This young Man spoke very well for India. Lots of respect!
Lost respect. He seems pretty ignorant. The Soviet union is not Russia. And today, russia is the only country in the world that supplies lethal weapons to both Pakistan and China.
West saying that they do not support Palestine genocide but supports Israel is any different?? 😅
@@alloutofbubblegum7271 And trying to assassinate indian opposition members outside of India.
@@francoislechanceux5818 stop spreading false information. You are trying to purposefully mislead those who are not at all aware of Southasian geopolitics
Indians and Russian are true friends
if you think the Russian people actually care about you...
you are greatly mistaken.
First of all, there is a ton of racism. They are not liberal, not progressive, but conservative in their own traditional values.
You're about as much a friend to them as the people of North-korea. People they've never talked to.
The only friend you have there is the government because you buy their oil.
And you're not friends with Chinese people, nor their government.
The only friends you have is Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Bangladesh
You can judge a person by the company they keep.
Hindi rusi bhai bhai - I remember it being like that for over 50 years
@@hb9145 Lmao it's not our war bruh. Nobody asked nato to go on russians door step. You think Putin was gonna welcome you with open arms like yeah set up nukes at my border. I'm not supporting russia but they're giving us very cheap oil and gas which is important for us as we're 1.5 billion people. The US has put sanctions on Iran and Venezuela as well like this ain't high school if you're friends with him you're my enemy
yes they are: there are a lot of indians in management of Russia companies, there are a lot of indians as ministers (or prime minister) in Russia, there are lot of indians in Russsia!!! Yes!!!🙌 Oh, wait, that's in USA and UK.
India is a civilization state and our national memory is very strong. We remember what Russia did for us in 1971. There is no way anyone in India will allow its govt to forget it. We will stand by Russia in its hour of need, no matter the consequences. We stand steadfast with Russia.
Good work Jaiveer.
For sure, consequences will be there! India wants to do business with the EU/US, and at the same time, India finances Russia's war in Ukraine by buying cheap Russian oil, refining it and selling it on the open market as Indian refined petroleum products.
European crisis isn't India's problem. Solve it within themselves. India isn't party of this crisis.
Yeah who cares about international order and morality..
You're talking morality....what's happening in gaza @@warbler1984
@@warbler1984
There is no such thing as International order and morality.😂
Only the USA tries to become world police.
@@warbler1984No Western nation can lecture others about morality.
@@warbler1984 international order and morality this guy is 3 years old 😂😂
During Indo-Pak war Ukraine provided arms and ammunitions to Pakistan that killed Indian soldiers and now they are expecting India to go against the only country who stood alongside India from 1960s.... delusional zelensky😂😂
The comedian 😂😂😂😂😂
Exactly 😂
Ukraine was part of the Soviet Union during the 1960s. The Soviet Union didn't have regions with that type of autonomy. So if Pakistan got weapons and ammo from those regions during that period, it was likely through illegal arms deals kind of like how Russia still gets its micro chips from the west despite the sanctions. Basically it means it would have been individuals and not a state operation. At least in the terms of the weapons leaking out of that region, or through a third party that those weapons were sold to and then that third party in another country sent it to Pakistan.
@@Adohleas they are talking about recent sales of tanks to Pakistan. That happened after USSR broke up.
@@ssark9187the last time they fought was 1998/99. That wasn't even a war just a skirmish. So Ukraine gave them tanks specifically to help this fight,?
Or they just sold Pakistan tanks long before the war?
he's saying, make money not war. NO love involved here, next question
Mostly Indian's vocals for Asia 🌏
Just a reminder: he's the spokesperson for the party, not the country.
Who is then that's been our foreign policy from the 1900s lol this is not something new. Heard of NAM.
both the same mate
Also does Indians support Russians or Putin?
Nope
@@loganadenveerapen2875Yes, because they heard concerns of both sides before forming a biased opinion.
The Indian man sounds more like a school principal who tells 2 fighting kids to just apologize and be nice to each other and voila, all will be well. It's just not reality, though I wish peace was that easy to attain.
Its not a fight India is responsible for. It has nothing to do with India. Europe's problems are not India's problem. These kids need to behave themselves and sort it out. Do you see India complaining when nobody in Europe cares about their government supporting a military dictatorship on India's border responsible for terrorism in India? Why should it care about reality in Europe when no European cares about realitys in India?
West saying that they do not support Palestine genocide but supports Israel is any different?? 😅
@@Artrader_em8ko look at that kremlin bot copying and pasting this exact comment all over the place trying to dillute the discussion...absolutely pathetic
@@82seno why spread one sided narrative about my country n paint a negative picture of us when you guys do exactly the same in other conflicts? It’s my prerogative to stand up for my country n call out this hypocrisy!
what is the west doing in regards to Palestine? They say they do not support the Palestine genocide but will not cut its ties with Israel?? Isn’t that hypocritical? If you can understand the logic n sensibilities there then you surely can extend the same to India’s stand in Russia Ukraine conflict! India doesn’t support any violence but we will not cut our ties with any country- Ukraine nor Russia! Simple! Not rocket science!
There are no friends or enemies in geopolitics, just interests! Your neighbour’s neighbour is your friend! China’s neighbours Russia n India will maintain good ties with each other to keep the bully dragon in check! We do not support any conflict but we can’t put our security n interests at risk for a temporary conflict elsewhere. isn’t that what west is doing in Israel Palestine war? Maintaining good relations with both without supporting the genocide? Why such hypocrisy then?
NAFO Bot 🐷😂@@82seno
Is this person a minister in BJP govt, then this party looks promising, see how clear thought process this person have.
🇮🇳 INDIA, "Europe has to grow out of the mindset that Europe's problems are the world's problems, but the world's problems are not Europe's problems."
Yes, in the first place, the Europeans should withdraw the hundreds of billions of dollars they have invested in India so far and stop all their new investments in India, which are more than 100 billion dollars annually, then it won't be India's problem anymore.
@@JigilJigil of course, they can but at first they should return 15 trillion that they looted from India. I think whole EU have not the capacity to do it. They are really weak and a bunch clown too.
@@JigilJigil they are not investing in India for charity, they are doing it for profit. Actually they come with a begging bowl begging for please let us do business in India, please we want access to ur huge market. That’s their true attitude.
Well by not investing in India u will not stop India’s inevitable rise of to become a global superpower. U may just delay its rise and get an enemy superpower 100yr down the line. With time we will control all the trade routes across the entire Indian Ocean. So make up your mind.
@@JigilJigil first return colonial loot of 45 trillion then bark moral values nonsense😂😂
@@pranavgandhar4604 Loot? I don't think India has anything worth stealing. You can keep your scammers.
Despite the talking points and obfuscation, I do like this guy. We might not agree on everything, but I do appreciate the articulation, and stringing together a cogent stream of thought(s).
Mr Shergill articulated India’s stand with full clarity
He has given all answers very confidently and we need people like him on the border and in our external affairs
May I ask, why Germany still doesnt supply battle tank, fighter jet that the Ukrainians ask for. The answer is that Germany doesn't want to upset Russia and keeps the possibility of again buying energy from Russia. So Germany can prioritize its interests against Ukraine's needs, but others cant! Is that fair?
You have just exposed German and, more generally, Western hypocrisy.
Wrong, they do not want to escalate the conflict into WWIII... Very different from "keeping the possibility to buy energy from Russia," pure BS!
@@jonasrohdin8856lmao then guess what, India is doing the same thing, "not escalating the conflict" by not antagonizing Russia.
I don't want to get in any discussion about this now and do respect your country's decisions, and also I am not a German, so I have no stakes in this, but I feel there might be a misunderstanding. Germany is in fact the second biggest provider of financial and military aid to Ukraine after the US. It organised/pledged/sent several state of the art air defense systems guarding Ukrainian cities (even systems their own army desperately wants but hasn't received yet) worth billions, a 3 digit number of Leopard I and II main battle tanks, MARS II and PzH2000 artillery systems, Gepard mobile air defense, all of their Marder IFV, etc. As for fighter jets: Germany gave all their MiG29 to Poland, which in turn handed them over to Ukraine. Yesterday, 17th Feb 2024, Germany pledged another 1,8 billion US$ including 36 tanks and signed a security pact with Ukraine. As for the energy: The German government includes the Green party that has for many years championed a zero fossile energy system in their efforts to fight global warming and Germany - like most European countries in the last two years - has massively invested in Solar and Wind power as well as Geothermal power. As a matter of fact they have been promoting this long before this war and are more than happy to finally get rid of any carbon based energy. If you doubt any of this, a 20 second Google Search (e.g. "German aid to Ukraine") will confirm it. As stated before, I am not German and yes, Germany like most countries has many flaws, but not supplying UKR with tanks or jets in order to get more fossile energy from Russia are certainly not among them.
Brother you have exposed hypocrisy of literally all european countries 😂😂😂😂 .
Friend with benefits👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
🐻➕🐄 = 💕
well europe is also a pet 🦮 of america .
like Europe and US
@@adityamaheshwari251now trump is threatening europe for not paying for nato alliance😊
@@souravkumarpandey6691 Now Trump has to pay 350 million dollars for fraud.
As a British citizen I salute this Indian man. He's reacting like an adult which is a refreshing change. This isn't about "who's side are you on?" This is about how we can stop it from escalating further.
yes, india loves to collaborate with russia. history will not forget
Just like history didn't forgot to create wikipedia pages on war crimes of USA, UK & Germany
ukraine solds tanks to pakistan while russia sells them to india. I think it is very clear which side india is on
India has 1.4 billion population to take care off. What is Germany's population size ?
Germany throws away more food in a day than India eats. So, context.
You don't have much money. India's per capita gdp is too low. That's the concerning part.
what is the west doing in regards to Palestine? They say they do not support the Palestine genocide but will not cut its ties with Israel?? Isn’t that hypocritical? If you can understand the logic n sensibilities there then you surely can extend the same to India’s stand in Russia Ukraine conflict! India doesn’t support any violence but we will not cut our ties with any country- Ukraine nor Russia! Simple! Not rocket science!
India never cared about its population, and now suddenly - they do :) No, buddy, the issue is of course money and nothing else (it never was).
@@koushikdas1992than how India's purchasing power parity is 16 trillion dollars and stock market value is trillion dollars and foreign exchange reserves are 625 billion dollars and nominal GDP is 4.2 trillion dollars
India fears no country on this earth ❤
Except that it is trying to be a U.S. lapdog.
Nobody cares though.
@@rwksasc in order to get something thing you have to little bit allign with great powers so India indulge in it without accepting their terms and conditions that's the beauty of India...soon the major power will vested on India and China..USA hegemony will gone..that period awaited by many🤩
@@stephenhill545 haha everybody cares soon it will be reality...long live India
China 1962😂
"C'mon, poke the bear."
"Nah."
"C'mon, poke the dragon."
"Let me get a sharpened stick."
"C'mon, poke the bear"
"Take my sticks"
"C'mon, poke the dragon"
"Buy my sticks"
Nice to hear India will continue to be a friend of Russia
True facts: Because of the UNSC's permanent seat - No one ever questions the ambiguity of China, and no one points fingers at the south China sea dispute.
This Politician is the true representative of India ... This is how a true leader and politician should be., All the best.
Why couldn't you be unsc permanent member?
When it comes to Russia we Indians will forget what the West (read the US and NATO) did to other countries in Asia, Latin America, Balkan, and Africa.
what is the west doing in regards to Palestine? They say they do not support the Palestine genocide but will not cut its ties with Israel?? Isn’t that hypocritical? If you can understand the logic n sensibilities there then you surely can extend the same to India’s stand in Russia Ukraine conflict! India doesn’t support any violence but we will not cut our ties with any country- Ukraine nor Russia! Simple! Not rocket science!
Why other countries look at what they did to us pak invaded us multiple times china also all these western countries sided with pak and China it was only the Soviet which helped us
@@anaesthete5592 that is exactly what i am saying. the West always sided with the dictators in our neighborhood.
you mean India will not forget ... is it?
West is a hypocrite. They keep trading with China and made China stronger. China got western money and technology and now threatening its neighbors. Why doesn’t west boycott China which is not democratic and committing genocide in Tibet and Hongkong? 😢
Bravo India, true, honest, great friend .
❤❤❤
"India is not in the habit to hand out certificates..." Programmers meme insert
I think he is as clear as water and not just a Politician. Make habit of listening to the facts and our Stand🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
No one can win a war, at the end everyone need meeting.
So why is Putin still trying to win?
@@thomaskalbfus2005 i don't know.
Who is the speaker?
Problems of the west are not the problems of the whole world.
Well done India!
India does not support violence but supports Russia 😂😂😂
Just like US dont support genocide of Palestinians but support Israel
😂😂😂😂😂
just like west is against terrorism but supported pakisthan
Western countries not support violence but support isreal 😂😂😂 hypocrisy on peak
Cheap gas and fighter planes..India will sell its soul for a deal!
Amazing answer by Indian, India is an independent country and not a puppet
India is slowly but surely becoming a Russian puppet
how was the title made
A wonderful spoke by our delegate, great keep it up, actually he will become India's next foreign affairs minister great job.❤❤❤🎉
This guy is trying to put together two impossible ways of thinking .. peace and the support for Kriminals ..
Yup, its the irony of European crying foul about Russian atrocities in Ukrain while arming and supporting the Israeli genocide of innocent Palestenian children and women.
Their are two big threats for peace one is Russia another is USA
This dude is 🤡🤡
😂😂😂😂😂 from western pov i guess 😂😂😂
Well his right but funny sheep won’t see this.they think war on war helps find peace wow
India is ❤
God Bless India lmao thats how every foreign state should talk about state matters
Europe's focus on being bitter towards India is not a solution for their problems. Rather they should focus on engaging with masterminds of all wars - china,US,russia. Fundamental reason for all the deep mess of rising cost and war funding.
Well done India, the journalist is hilarious
He is articulate, finally an indian in foreign policy we can understand his English! His answers can be criticized, but discussing peace when world loves to fight is not easy!
He is not 'in foreign Policy'. He is a lawyer and just a spokesperson die India's ruling Party.
There are Indian Diplomats all over the world serving and more articulare than this guy.
I suggest you should not only learn better English but also work on the lack of your general awareness.
Wait? You didn't understand Jaishankar's English? You can accuse him of being erudite, but his language is not at all ornate. I wonder what you'd think of Shashi Tharoor's language (Disclaimer: I certainly feel Mr.Tharoor's language is unnecessarily ornate).
@@dinum4378 He is Indian himself. Moreover English is not India's native language so one is not bound to be proficient in it. For those who can't understand an Indian's English may better use subtitles.
This spoke person is smart, the take away is that India is telling the West that India is more than capable to resolve their own conflict and ask West not to interfere with India's conflict or relationship. Hope all countries are as strong as India who is vocal and also independent. India is neighbor with Russia, China, Maldives, Pakistan, etc; and if there are conflict or allied, they are supposed to resolve to internally without the West involvement which usually lead to wars and large conflicts.
But only India and China have sovereignty 😂😂
India is neighboring Russia :))))))))))))
God bless India
The Indian spokesman really earns his pay.
Europe should grow up the old mentality that world will follow them, those days are gone. World order is chanting rapidly.
Being drunk is a hard habit to break with lots of withdrawal symptoms. Being drunk on power is an even harder habit to break!
you mean: chanting Om
@@lets_discuss5352 you're getting desperate 😂