Don’t fret. What you do on the ground is far more important than you telling us about it. Prof Gerdes cites you as his source, continually, so those of us who follow him are well aware of your efforts. Top job. Thank you
Andrew, your work is cited every day and there are no words to sufficiently express our gratitude for your enormous contributions to help us understand all that is taking place. You are a research and reporting hero in this war. God bless.
God bless you and your team Andrew! Thank you so much for the update! I really appreciate you condensing all the accounting into wisdom too - it's priceless! Please know that y'all are in my prayers too. Slava Ukraini!
The work you do sir has got to be depressing seeing all the death and destruction...thank you for the work you do, it is truly important. Take care of yourself
Hello!! xxx Thank you for all you doo xxx #SLAVA UKRAINI still sacrificing and fighting for all our tomorrows to be safe and free xxx honour, respect, gratitude and love always xxx
Thank you very much. The overview, with your predictions is educational. I'm particularly happy to hear the Ukrainians have established good trenches. They can enjoy relative safety, while the TickTock battalions herd flocks of sheep into the meat grinder. Eventually, the Mothers & Wives of Russia will decide they have gotten enough benefits from the Kremlin for ridding themselves of abusive drunks. They will rise up and depose Putin.
Wish Your Tutorials Were Watched By All In The U.S.! Quite Sad How Ignorant The People In New England USA Are. Can’t Even Have A Conversation With People In My Area Of Connecticut USA. Totally Sucks, 3 Years Later. Miss Listening To You Andrew & All The People You Work With! 🎯🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🎯
I loved the video that you guys made about drone strikes with the singing. God bless you and your basement crew. You are always in my prayers my friend ❤
Busy, busy, busy you're really busy and I appreciate the work you and your team do so much. Thanks for helping Jon out guys. He really counts on your efforts to do his map updates. Does mud cost them arty. from CBF?
I feel like maneuver warfare is kind of redundant term. I mean isn't all where warfare fundamentally based on movement? If you just sit there in one spot you're just going to defend forever and die 😂
Could AFU hold these positions if they wanted too? Can the high casualty rate eventually leave the Russians needing men? Can Ukraine run an offensive to the Russian logostics node and hold those positions until the Russians out of supplies?
Thanks a lot. Very informative and I’m very glad for the hard work you are doing. But one thing! Please it is very disturbing when you all time zooming out and in. That makes It very, very difficult to follow your explanation when I all time have to orient myself when you do it. I think it is very much better if you all time let the map be out zoomed. Take care. Göran in Latvia.
Don’t fret. What you do on the ground is far more important than you telling us about it.
Prof Gerdes cites you as his source, continually, so those of us who follow him are well aware of your efforts.
Top job. Thank you
Thanks Andrew. Words aren't sufficient to cover the respect and appreciation I have for the work you do, and more so your insights and conclusions.
Many, many thanks for your meticulous and relentless work.
😍 Welcome back! Thank you for your hard work for Ukraine. God bless you always 🙏.💪🇺🇦🎖️🪖
Andrew, your work is cited every day and there are no words to sufficiently express our gratitude for your enormous contributions to help us understand all that is taking place. You are a research and reporting hero in this war. God bless.
Thank you for the hard work you put in Andrew and it’s nice to hear from you
Really really missed you brother. Keep up the great work, your massively appreciated!!!
Cheers. Your dedication is remarkable. Kudos.
Glad your back, we understand the absence and appreciate all your hard work.
Thanks Andrew for all your incredibly hard work. Jonathan MS Pearce rates you very highly as we all on ATP Geopolitics do
Your work is valuable abd greatly appreciated by many. Thanks so much.
Thank you for your excellent work. I know that myself and so many commentators rely heavily on your data to help analyze the state of the conflict.
Many thanks from Tasmania, to hear your happy and well is enough!!!!!
Hobart 17 degrees and sunny
Thanks Andrew for your hard work. I get my updates from professor Gerdes he always credits your diligence and integrity.
God bless you and your team Andrew! Thank you so much for the update! I really appreciate you condensing all the accounting into wisdom too - it's priceless! Please know that y'all are in my prayers too. Slava Ukraini!
A big thanks to you and your team from Sweden!
Thanks!
Thanks Andrew, I hear your work cited by many other content creators so it's always nice to hear directly from you. Slava Ukraini
The work you do sir has got to be depressing seeing all the death and destruction...thank you for the work you do, it is truly important.
Take care of yourself
Andrew a big hug from NZ,you're legend
This update is appreciated. Thank you
Thank you for the truth. Slava Ukraine
Thhanks Andrew.
Thanks for your (and the teams) work!
I have seen your reports, well done. I will be following you in the future.
Welcome back.
Thanks for your hard work brother .. we really appreciate it !
Welcome back, your work is incredible and I can only imagine how much time and energy you must spend on this critical work!
Hello!! xxx Thank you for all you doo xxx #SLAVA UKRAINI still sacrificing and fighting for all our tomorrows to be safe and free xxx honour, respect, gratitude and love always xxx
Thank you Andrew for your your work
Thank you very much. The overview, with your predictions is educational. I'm particularly happy to hear the Ukrainians have established good trenches. They can enjoy relative safety, while the TickTock battalions herd flocks of sheep into the meat grinder. Eventually, the Mothers & Wives of Russia will decide they have gotten enough benefits from the Kremlin for ridding themselves of abusive drunks. They will rise up and depose Putin.
Thanks for your work. Liberty for Ukraine.
Great to hear from you, Andrew!
Thank you for everything you do for us. You are one in a million.
Thanks again from the UK 🇬🇧.
Thank you for your time and your dedication to this endeavor! Your work is much appreciated.
Thank you, really appreciate your efforts
welcome back Andy
Glad to see you back!!!!
Thanks from Italy.
God bless you and your team...and Ukraine
Hi Andrew Perpetua and thanks 👍⚔️🇺🇦🛡️
Thank you.
We missed you💜
“Mostly optimistic.” Excellent. 👌🌞
Thanks for staying engaged.
Thanks
Great Respect and appreciation on what you do and make us more aware of the current situation in Ukraine. Thank you☺️
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
Thank you! Appreciate this. Slava Ukraini 💪💪🇺🇦💪💪
"Work Work Work"
Thx for all you do.
Strongly underrated
🇺🇦🇺🇦🔱✌🔱🇺🇦🇺🇦
Hi there! NO need to apologize. Y R doing a Great job. By the way... welcome back😊
Wish Your Tutorials Were Watched By All In The U.S.!
Quite Sad How Ignorant The People In New England USA Are.
Can’t Even Have A Conversation With People In My Area Of Connecticut USA.
Totally Sucks, 3 Years Later.
Miss Listening To You Andrew & All The People You Work With!
🎯🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🎯
Standard dictator trick is keeping people in the dark and confused.
Lots of different opinions confuses the uneducated
Thank you Andrew
It's good to hear from you.
Andrew! Welcome back! Hope you were able to rest and rejuvenate! We appreciate your hard work!
I really apreciate the job you do and the stamina you have.
Your work is awesome and I'm sure stressful so wishing you well Andrew.
I Think If Your Thinking This, Then , That’s Their Goal 🎯🙏🔱🙏🎯
Even though I follow you on X platform, it's great to see you here again.
Thanks Andrew!
I loved the video that you guys made about drone strikes with the singing. God bless you and your basement crew. You are always in my prayers my friend ❤
That video is truly awesome!!!
Thanks mate
It's been a while... many thanks Andrew!
Missed you Andrew. I’m from Jonathan MS Pearce’ outer orbit.
Ah, Another legend of the multiverse, Good to see you!!!
Nice one
Breaks one's heart on a daily basis.
Good work, people. Cheers.
Thanks Andrew
Thank you
Great work, Andrew!
Thanks for all your hard work ! I feel Russia is on its last legs ,just need the orange man to really help.
Busy, busy, busy you're really busy and I appreciate the work you and your team do so much. Thanks for helping Jon out guys. He really counts on your efforts to do his map updates. Does mud cost them arty. from CBF?
Merci, merci beaucoup et oui ça faisait très longtemps trop longtemps mdr !
Thanks andrew
Thank you Andrew, are you sure about mud ? it seems precipitations are quite scarce this winter in Ukraine
I feel like maneuver warfare is kind of redundant term. I mean isn't all where warfare fundamentally based on movement? If you just sit there in one spot you're just going to defend forever and die 😂
Aloha
Videos are secondary.
Updating stats is that matters the most.
Nice having a video back Andrew
🎯🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🔱🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🎯
A thousand thousands is a million.
oh god @1:44 did he just say they are moving in massive amounts of horses 😮no that's right that's tomorrow 😱
Everyone is entitled to a life
Could AFU hold these positions if they wanted too? Can the high casualty rate eventually leave the Russians needing men? Can Ukraine run an offensive to the Russian logostics node and hold those positions until the Russians out of supplies?
When is America and Nato going to send troops to Ukraine?
Thanks a lot. Very informative and I’m very glad for the hard work you are doing. But one thing! Please it is very disturbing when you all time zooming out and in. That makes It very, very difficult to follow your explanation when I all time have to orient myself when you do it. I think it is very much better if you all time let the map be out zoomed. Take care. Göran in Latvia.
I was concerned. I feel much better now. What news of excavators?
🇳🇱❤🇺🇦
A Very long time 😅
Andrew can you PLEASE slow down your scrolling and zooming of the map!
who allowed this guy to step away from the spreadsheets??? 😂😂😂
how do you ensure completeness of the loss reports?
He doesn’t
What acid are you tripping on man?
Why do you say they have no gain? Sounds like they are gaining ground.. thanks
Too much mousing around!!! Sorry bud im gone.
I thought Trump cut the funding for channels like this.
Trump's cut his own throat already methinks. Americans are well known for terminating their Leaders prematurely after all 😂
Great to hear from you, many thanks for all your hard work
Thank you for your dedication to the truth and your unending support of Ukraine's efforts to secure their future.Slava Ukraine!!Heroam Slava!!!
Hi team AP greetings from the netherlands
Thanks Andrew and PJ 🫡🫵🥇🍻☮your work is greatly appreciated in many ways.🖖👏🫡