She refused a Damn distortion,She's a Goat for that. For her loving Husband,she's destroying a Damn Star of the City. I cant wait for Her Cameo in Limbus sooo Bad
That lone tree allegory is interesting given that there are in fact single trees that have managed to make whole forests. Also, Xiao doing her best Kars impression there.
Carmen is trying to take down a beast of pure determination with simple fact and logic, like trying to quench a blazing inferno with but a single droplet of water.
God the way you portrayed Carmen is this is so good. Whenever she first shows up over Xiao's shoulder with a bit of Angela's color pallet that slowly unravels into her own. Especially whenever she's holding her hand out to Xiao. The background shifting with her influence and the way the static reminds you that she's both there and not really there, or rather that she's not limited by? residing in? reality. (and then whenever Xiao speaks the background is consumed by fire, resisting Carmen's influence) I really love this depiction of her
"Finally"? Since the very beginning of the game the library was portrayed as a villainous faction, both Angela and Roland were far from sympathetic most of the time, the only thing they had going for them was that most of their "victims" weren't any better than they were. You were pretty much meant to at least dislike Angela from the very beginning and Roland was also pretty indifferent to a lot of probably-murder of arguably innocent people, so you'd naturally sympathise more with their opponents whenever they weren't irredeemable bastards.
Xiao reached the conclusion that poor Philip could not, and yet, it didn't make the road ahead any easier... I'm just glad the Liu made it out alive in the end
i love Xiao, usually we're thought to fight against what we have to face but instead Xiao, takes it with acceptance while remaining resolute. The idea that despite disparity, we will eventually learn to accept its way as it is; not as a means to ignore the outcome but to have the resolution in our end and that's so cool.
Xiao is the Reception that opened the Pages about how Evil angela Really is. she have seen Lulu lost Mars,Roland asked if she ever regret Doing all of this to achieve Her goal,and She said No,they're here because of their Own will. and After This exact Reception,He objects to fight Lowel when he found out they're married,since Roland too,know how it feels to lost someone Like that. This whole Reception,is the only Reception that i Root for to Win against the Library So bad..oh,how i really hope we could see Lowel and Xiao again celebrating their Anniversary in Limbus...
this is kinda true-but it’s to be noted that “the cycle of suffering” was all angela ever knew, being born to literally do that for millions of years and then die and even getting out of that cycle, she’s once again stuck with nobody, carmen telling her that she can get everything she wants if she just listens and gets the one true book and angela wanted to hold onto that and I think the most beautiful part was her breaking free from that - D1 angela glazer
And don’t ever forget *SPOILERS* Carmen was the one inviting everyone to the Library to begin with, so even if they signed it, Angela basically states that anyone who receives it is either in dire straits and can’t refuse or is essentially forced to because it branches from an objective of theirs. Did they ever truly have free will to go there when an omnipresent entity is just giving them death they can’t avoid on a silver platter? It doesn’t exactly “excuse” Angela from the *principle* of killing off anyone invited (as they never truly died, every single person who were made into a Book except Argalia and the rest of the Reverberation Ensemble were freed but it’s just what she was willing to do that made the difference) but it does make you see Carmen in an even worse light the more you think about her being behind the Distortion Phenomenon as well. Worst part is, while Hokma knew since the beginning (and hasn’t ever had a fervent respect for her anyway) + Binah never even meeting her, it’s still unknown if the other former Sephirah know that the person they respected so much is actually the cause behind one of the most impactful phenomena in the City at the moment and was actually the one essentially leading the invited to their deaths. After everything they’ve been through, I do hope Angela keeps that to herself.
my babygirl angela believed that what she was doing was fair and ‘just’, since people needed to sign an invitation and unbeknownst to her, many factors made it so there wasn’t any real ‘choice’ and when she was confronted with it she refused to accept it 💔💔💔
it still scares me hearing Carmen speak as the ensemble said she sounds so calm and beautiful, but everything that came out from her mouth is all negative thing You could hear about yourself. i don't blame people who got distorted Carmen is literally what the people in the City wanted someone who could listen to all of your problems and solved it.
Honesty, Im scared of what Xiao wouldve become had she distorted, I presume a dragon but no, the queen of flames manifested her own ego, when she just wanted to settle down with her husband, god Xiao is so fucking cool
OOOHH THIS IS BEYOND GORGEOUUUSSSS!!! i wasn't expecting carmen's dialogue pieces, but it makes her side of the conversation feel that much more fulfilling. the burning away of carmen's deceit, the flames stirring every which way, the transition from key ingredient to the original--oh my god, it's all SO perfect!!! here's to hoping we'll see xiao and lowell together again in limbus
Imagine the awkward moment after all the light is released and Xiao just finds Lowell chilling in a backstreets bar trying to get back to the Liu Association headquarters.
Honestly, I absolutely love the animation. Though I do have some suggestions to improve your skills When animating scenes like 2:06 , where a character's hair or maybe their clothes are being affected by strong wind, swaying violently; you could instead slow down the swaying animation with a minimum of 3 repeating frames. And if it's something like hair, you could instead have less detail lines inside the hair, to be able to interpret the entire hair to be swaying. Only the stroke lines moving left and right. And a tip I have is practicing animating movements of a single limb, like an entire arm stretching out, let's say. When animating things like that, you should of course base it off of the previous position(s) that the limb was in, but still treat it like it's own singular art piece, which will allow you to put more effort and detail to it, for it to not look like one of those memes where there's a very well drawn horse on the left and it's continuation is just an elementary school doodle. Also, in scenes like 1:10 , Carmen's eyes could've been a biiiit bigger towards the top-left. Diagonally-Rotated faces usually tend to look smaller, yes but in this situation, it's just the facial structure I do not in any way mean that this is bad animation, I absolutely fucking love it as a big fan of Xiao, I'm just trying to give constructive criticism. Sorry if it offends you in any way. I would love to see more of your work
Xiao is the person who will say 'fuck you' to Carmen then proceed to manifest her own ego.
Isn't that how you normally get effloresced ego?
@@TheMentallyTired Yeah, Dongrang did the same.
She refused a Damn distortion,She's a Goat for that. For her loving Husband,she's destroying a Damn Star of the City. I cant wait for Her Cameo in Limbus sooo Bad
Ahab: hahaha hahaha I'm true!!!!!!!!!!
"No, you're wrong Miss Carmen."
"Tonight, a star of the city... shall fall."
Line so hard it gave me 400 stacks of burn
“”Tonight, a star of the city… shall fall.”
Line so hard it gave me 400 stacks of burn”
Line so hard it gave me 800 stacks of burn
Line so fire
Yesod with Myongest Solemn Lament and Regret:
Nullify Honest Reaction:
But that's not the text. Even though it's what I remember as well, the text says otherwise
A lone tree may not form a forest, but one match can certainly burn down a library.
That lone tree allegory is interesting given that there are in fact single trees that have managed to make whole forests.
Also, Xiao doing her best Kars impression there.
The whole conversation basically comes to this
Carmen : "Pls Distort"
Xiao : "Nah i'd E.G.O"
Carmen is trying to take down a beast of pure determination with simple fact and logic, like trying to quench a blazing inferno with but a single droplet of water.
she had that kars ahh pose lol
@@tapionwakasushe tried becoming the ultimate life form
Lowell In fact died for this.
He did in fact died for this..
This is peak
True!
He knew his woman well
Stop burning me Please It hurt so much
God the way you portrayed Carmen is this is so good. Whenever she first shows up over Xiao's shoulder with a bit of Angela's color pallet that slowly unravels into her own. Especially whenever she's holding her hand out to Xiao. The background shifting with her influence and the way the static reminds you that she's both there and not really there, or rather that she's not limited by? residing in? reality. (and then whenever Xiao speaks the background is consumed by fire, resisting Carmen's influence) I really love this depiction of her
That switch from Key Ingredient to the original song was incredibly smooth.
so smooth that it gave me 50 stack of sinking.
Goated xiao love here
The gebura in my pocket :
The Solemn Lament in Yesod's Pocket:
hi tonrep
:)
but would you smash?
Xiao makes you finally feel guilty for your actions
Jokes on you, I felt guilt when we killed finn
@@TwopenceWritingWe fr jumped that mf ong 😭😭😭😭
@@TwopenceWritingDude just wanted to do something in life :(
"Finally"? Since the very beginning of the game the library was portrayed as a villainous faction, both Angela and Roland were far from sympathetic most of the time, the only thing they had going for them was that most of their "victims" weren't any better than they were. You were pretty much meant to at least dislike Angela from the very beginning and Roland was also pretty indifferent to a lot of probably-murder of arguably innocent people, so you'd naturally sympathise more with their opponents whenever they weren't irredeemable bastards.
@@IchCharacter I mean after countless deaths in Lob Corp.. It's not that hard to ignore bad things for a while
Despite Xiao being our enemy, i was glad that she refused to despair and manifested EGO
and then she burnt my ass to a crisp, but that's okay ')
2:06 xiao hitting kars pose
THATS WHAT IM SAYING
She Is the Ultimate Life form
@@TheBlackSilencesDamn right
Bro cooked, set the kitchen on fire and still made peak
The way you mixed iron lotus and the key ingredient alongside the animation is SO GOOD!!!!!! Definitely earned a new subscriber
God, I wish I could like this more than once. You're an amazing animator and storyboarder! Please make more PM-related animations, I beseech thee!
Xiao reached the conclusion that poor Philip could not, and yet, it didn't make the road ahead any easier...
I'm just glad the Liu made it out alive in the end
Carmen was like: "Hey you should distort yourself..."
Xiao: “闭嘴你这个女鬼！我根本听不懂你在说什么！”
这也对，66
You cant distort if you cant even process what they said
Imagine not distorting because of language barriers lol
That was actually amazing. God I love Xiao.
THIS IS.... PEAK.... 🥲🥲
nay, it is Yi Sang!
its truly ideal!
Using the Key Ingredient ver. for the start was such a good idea.
California doing the xiao reception 💀
Amazing work DetaMation, the addition of Carmen's dialogue into Xiao's heroic second wind moment was very nice touch!
i love Xiao, usually we're thought to fight against what we have to face but instead Xiao, takes it with acceptance while remaining resolute. The idea that despite disparity, we will eventually learn to accept its way as it is; not as a means to ignore the outcome but to have the resolution in our end and that's so cool.
The yell into roar transition at 0:46 really hits hard
"A lone tree can not form a forest on its own."
What a dumb statement.
"A lone tree is forever more a forest than land with naught a single tree."
"Be prepared, for today, a Star of the City shall be gone." LINE SO FIRE I HAVE 999 BURN STACKS 🔥
What the peak?!?! PM is sining right now for not having you there.
Xiao is the Reception that opened the Pages about how Evil angela Really is. she have seen Lulu lost Mars,Roland asked if she ever regret Doing all of this to achieve Her goal,and She said No,they're here because of their Own will. and After This exact Reception,He objects to fight Lowel when he found out they're married,since Roland too,know how it feels to lost someone Like that. This whole Reception,is the only Reception that i Root for to Win against the Library So bad..oh,how i really hope we could see Lowel and Xiao again celebrating their Anniversary in Limbus...
this is kinda true-but it’s to be noted that “the cycle of suffering” was all angela ever knew, being born to literally do that for millions of years and then die
and even getting out of that cycle, she’s once again stuck with nobody, carmen telling her that she can get everything she wants if she just listens and gets the one true book
and angela wanted to hold onto that
and I think the most beautiful part was her breaking free from that
- D1 angela glazer
@@zyopticThe ultimate Angela glazer fr
And don’t ever forget *SPOILERS*
Carmen was the one inviting everyone to the Library to begin with, so even if they signed it, Angela basically states that anyone who receives it is either in dire straits and can’t refuse or is essentially forced to because it branches from an objective of theirs. Did they ever truly have free will to go there when an omnipresent entity is just giving them death they can’t avoid on a silver platter? It doesn’t exactly “excuse” Angela from the *principle* of killing off anyone invited (as they never truly died, every single person who were made into a Book except Argalia and the rest of the Reverberation Ensemble were freed but it’s just what she was willing to do that made the difference) but it does make you see Carmen in an even worse light the more you think about her being behind the Distortion Phenomenon as well.
Worst part is, while Hokma knew since the beginning (and hasn’t ever had a fervent respect for her anyway) + Binah never even meeting her, it’s still unknown if the other former Sephirah know that the person they respected so much is actually the cause behind one of the most impactful phenomena in the City at the moment and was actually the one essentially leading the invited to their deaths. After everything they’ve been through, I do hope Angela keeps that to herself.
my babygirl angela believed that what she was doing was fair and ‘just’, since people needed to sign an invitation and unbeknownst to her, many factors made it so there wasn’t any real ‘choice’ and when she was confronted with it she refused to accept it 💔💔💔
I mean none except probably the orchestra really died they all got revived in the true ending
it still scares me hearing Carmen speak as the ensemble said she sounds so calm and beautiful, but everything that came out from her mouth is all negative thing You could hear about yourself. i don't blame people who got distorted Carmen is literally what the people in the City wanted someone who could listen to all of your problems and solved it.
2:07 Xiao ultimate life form
That was a good reference
That nice * load solemn lament with dark flame bullet *
Shadow the hedgehog??mm?
Damn so powerful.... 0:42 I actually friggin felt it omg, Chills....
Don Quixote showed me this before we went to that bloodfiend place, and was going on and on about it.
Honesty, Im scared of what Xiao wouldve become had she distorted, I presume a dragon but no, the queen of flames manifested her own ego, when she just wanted to settle down with her husband, god Xiao is so fucking cool
2:45
2:09 "Ultimate life form Kars" ahh moment😭🙏
Xiao was, and always will be my favourite reception. The art here is absolutely incredible! And as a fellow artist you have my utmost admiration ❤️🧡💛
Holy fucking shit??? This might be my favorite project moon animation to date!
OOOHH THIS IS BEYOND GORGEOUUUSSSS!!!
i wasn't expecting carmen's dialogue pieces, but it makes her side of the conversation feel that much more fulfilling. the burning away of carmen's deceit, the flames stirring every which way, the transition from key ingredient to the original--oh my god, it's all SO perfect!!!
here's to hoping we'll see xiao and lowell together again in limbus
A Woman of focus, commitment and sheer will, shall not simply distort when asked nicely.
This really gives me the same amount of chills like how Yi-Sang's Canto did to me.
I think this is one my favorite videos I've ever seen now.
진짜 뭔가 애니메이션 명장면처럼 만들었네 ㄷㄷ 앞으로도 좋은거 많이 만들어주셈!
I can feel 56 burn stacks crawling down my spine.
watching it made me shiver...
so cool
_after 1 scene_
PING PING PING PING PING PING PING PING
_staggered_
_getting jumped and died_
Exhausted? Tired. Want rest? Hungry. Want out?
2:05 is that the fucking ultimate life form
she stopped breathing😢😢😢😢
I think this is one of the first RUclips videos to make me cry
The illustrations and the effects come together nicely.
I really like what you did with the animation, good work~
I love that this is done on Gebura's floor, because no sane person would use anyone BUT gebura for this fight... EGO vs EGO my belovid.
God everytime i hear his dialogue is just to epic...send a chill down my spine
ABSOLUTELY GOATED
Yep and *solemn lament*
We were truly fire with this one 🔥
This is so peak that i got goosebumps
2:06 haha, basking in that sensation of vitality, just like a certain ultimate life form...
this went so hard it genuinely gave me chills
This Is FIRE!!! 🗣️🔥🔥🐉⚔️🔥🔥
IM FIRE🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I don’t even know what to say, just absolutely peak cinema. That was fucking great.
yoooo i just watched the apocalypse bird animation yesterday
this is so goodddd
This is peak
You made cool character even cooler somehow.. No, hotter, not cooler. i can feel the hundreds of burn stacks.
Aw hell yeah, this is the kinda thing i enjoy seeing!
Imagine the awkward moment after all the light is released and Xiao just finds Lowell chilling in a backstreets bar trying to get back to the Liu Association headquarters.
"But would you distort?..." "Nah, Id' E.G.O."
2:09 ah yes, my favourite jojo episode when xiao got the red stone of aja and became ultimate xiao
It’s so good, peak cinema
2:45
Honestly, I absolutely love the animation. Though I do have some suggestions to improve your skills
When animating scenes like 2:06 , where a character's hair or maybe their clothes are being affected by strong wind, swaying violently; you could instead slow down the swaying animation with a minimum of 3 repeating frames. And if it's something like hair, you could instead have less detail lines inside the hair, to be able to interpret the entire hair to be swaying. Only the stroke lines moving left and right.
And a tip I have is practicing animating movements of a single limb, like an entire arm stretching out, let's say. When animating things like that, you should of course base it off of the previous position(s) that the limb was in, but still treat it like it's own singular art piece, which will allow you to put more effort and detail to it, for it to not look like one of those memes where there's a very well drawn horse on the left and it's continuation is just an elementary school doodle.
Also, in scenes like 1:10 , Carmen's eyes could've been a biiiit bigger towards the top-left. Diagonally-Rotated faces usually tend to look smaller, yes but in this situation, it's just the facial structure
I do not in any way mean that this is bad animation, I absolutely fucking love it as a big fan of Xiao, I'm just trying to give constructive criticism. Sorry if it offends you in any way. I would love to see more of your work
this is so good
really good animation
Xiao was lost and in despair just before carmen showed up and pissed her off lol.
Finally beat Xiao yesterday and now she's back to beat my ass in my yt reccomended
This was the part when I realized that the library was morally grey
"Tonight a star of the city.. shall fall" ye ye whatever just put the myongest + blunt stance+ dark flame + solemn lament in the keypage bro
this deserves the likes it has and more holy shit
Gebura On The Sideline Ready To Overwrite Xiao Theme With Aggressive Metal Music:
각오해라, 오늘 도시의 별 하나가 질테니
THIS IS FIRE 🔥🔥🔥
This is so PEAK❗🗣️🔥
this is so fucking awesome
its beautiful ohm hyubgodo
This... this is peak.
excellent, goes very hard
Incredible
W ANIMATION W VIDEO LOVE THE CITY I LIVE IN 🔥🔥
미친 퀄리티...❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
THIS IS CRAZY
Extremely Nice 🖤
This animation is peak…
Key Ingredient Iron Lotus mentioned🎉🎉🎉
The two funny "ding dong" guns in my pocket:
I was enjoying it so much but carmen’s voicelines being from the angela light dialogue threw me off so much 😭
Xiao Kars pose is real.. But holy shit this animation is so peak I love her now she’s so cool
Holy shit this is gas I'm crying
If it's phillip, he might slowly crumble into distortion.
Me: oh no, I welp thats ten more hours it is.
YOU COOKED SO HARD IT GAVE ME 420 STACKS OF BURN
We need Philip now....
That went so hard