THEORY VIDEOS RUIN EVERYTHING

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 окт 2023
  • After all, it is all JUST a theory...
    What's the craziest or most memorable fan theory you've ever heard? Did any of them turn out to be right? Let me know in the comments!
    Go watch The Ghost and Molly McGee on Disney+!
    Also, I didn’t name drop them, but here’s the video I referenced by Jegcopo about Candace knowing Perry’s secret! • CANDACE Knew Perry's S...
    Molly McGee Discord: / discord
    Sunnyland Productions Discord: / discord
    JJJreact
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 258

  • @Theducksterisback
    @Theducksterisback 9 месяцев назад +321

    To me, theories have always been like creepypastas you kind of just read them for fun and then make fun of how Absolutely ridonculous they are

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +35

      It’s entirely possible to come up with a plausible theory, but that’s still all it is.

    • @danielgoldinho
      @danielgoldinho 9 месяцев назад +4

      SANS IS NESS I AM NESS AND SANS AAAAAAAA

    • @scribblecloud
      @scribblecloud 9 месяцев назад

      exactly

    • @This-is-a-commentt
      @This-is-a-commentt 9 месяцев назад

      Yeah… until they end up being right

    • @This-is-a-commentt
      @This-is-a-commentt 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@danielgoldinho are people really still hung up on that? That was years ago

  • @kirbystar7474
    @kirbystar7474 9 месяцев назад +140

    I don’t think theories are bad because a lot of times fans connect over theories of a show they like and that is really nice. But it’s bad when people get so obsessed with their theories that they either get angry when it’s not canon or ignore every other theory suggested to them because they think their theory is superior.

    • @SnickerDoodleBug05
      @SnickerDoodleBug05 9 месяцев назад +7

      That's when things get bad, other than that theories are fine I actually like it when a theory is never confirmed or disproven. I'm also very open to other theories and constantly making new ones

    • @skilledful
      @skilledful 6 месяцев назад

      Agreed

  • @fatcat1414
    @fatcat1414 9 месяцев назад +17

    I'm a big fan of "theoryfiction" where people try to fill in the blanks of a preexisting story and come up with something interesting, even if it's absurd (so long as it's more creative than 'it's all a dream.') Theoryfic is a core part of many awesome fanworks. What I don't like is how many people treat theoryfiction as legitimate theories that are likely canon, even going so far as to actively annoy creators over something they never intended to convey.

  • @gladisseabrook3309
    @gladisseabrook3309 9 месяцев назад +152

    Personally, one of my favorite things about making theories is that when proven wrong, it can make the story that more exciting! Though yes, for Phineas and Ferb it's a bit strange to make theories for.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +15

      I love Dan and Swampy’s reaction to the Pinhead Pierre theory

  • @PlutoTheSecond
    @PlutoTheSecond 9 месяцев назад +77

    I have this minor theory, if you don't mind me sharing...
    Becoming a Wraith doesn't simply make your body a "soulless husk." When Molly and Darryl became Wraiths, their bodies were still capable of speech, along with a minimum of expression, just not the same kind (and certainly not to the same extent) as usual. Rather, your body still has a small speck of personality, but it's the opposite of your actual character. Essentially, your Wraith form inherits your defining aspects, leaving the body with the rest - the traits that aren't you.
    Here's my reasoning. People would look at these shells and assume that they're just depressed. But looking closer, I think there's evidence that there's more to it than that.
    Consider Darryl. When he becomes a Wraith, his shell doesn't actually look depressed, or even sad. It's more of a deadpan look - emotionless. Molly's shell actually looks sadder than Darryl's...but why would there be a difference? Because they're different people. Darryl isn't positive and cheerful, at least not like Molly is. He's wild, free-thinking and rebellious. That's why his shell is the opposite of that: an obedient puppet, so much so that when he calls it "garbage," it takes that literally and throws itself away.
    So what about Molly? Well, as I said, her shell does have more of a "depressed" expression than Darryl's, which is obviously the opposite of her usual, happy-go-lucky self. But her shell's dialogue tells us a lot more. In contrast to the bright, loving, hopeful, optimistic young soul we know and love, her shell is unfeeling, uncaring, indifferent and, dare I say, nihilistic. Each of those qualities has a different line of dialogue to back it up.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +19

      Oh, absolutely. A shell is basically your body without its’ essence.

    • @kirbystar7474
      @kirbystar7474 8 месяцев назад

      Molly’s soulless husk is like Lumalee from the Mario movie.

  • @PauloJrchannel
    @PauloJrchannel 6 месяцев назад +14

    I'm gonna be honest, this feels like the writers just trolled you by accident.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  6 месяцев назад +7

      What’s really hilarious is that I know Bill has seen a whole bunch of us in Mollycord hate on Wraith Scratch theory, but…
      Oh, MAN, that finale. (Finishing getting a script written today, I can’t wait to talk about it. Absolutely blew me away.)

  • @Kayclau
    @Kayclau 9 месяцев назад +33

    I liked that they dropped the name Bobby Daniels just as a tease that Patty was a wild lady on her youth and then they actually introduced the man. I wasn't expecting to actually ever see anything of Patty's past and now I'm left craving a whole seaos of those love birds.
    I will watch Patty and Bobby and I will cry at the end.

  • @Jamfrog35
    @Jamfrog35 9 месяцев назад +19

    This is kinda why I stop doing theory videos. It was fun at first, but the more you overlook some details, the more it unravels.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +3

      Like I said, I don’t actually have a problem with theory videos, but not everything is an elaborate mystery and/or conspiracy

  • @LGreat16
    @LGreat16 6 месяцев назад +8

    Oof this guy will not like the ending

  • @rowan404
    @rowan404 6 месяцев назад +7

    I guess there's a reason why 7:33 prevailed. 8:16-10:08 aged like milk left in the summer sun.
    I actually first heard that theory in this video and returned here after watching the finale and continuously wondering if you feel stupid now.

  • @spooderderg4077
    @spooderderg4077 9 месяцев назад +7

    Hot take. Its not theory videos that ruin the fandoms but people who take these clearly headcanon videos too seriously. Especially ones that get mad a theory they disliked was shown to be more accurate than one they liked in a later episode causing the fans to harass creators about the fact not all headcanons can actually be canon.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +2

      Absolutely! People take these way too seriously.

    • @spooderderg4077
      @spooderderg4077 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds this and power scalars. An entire community of people arguing who is stronger between carrot cake and dupercat only for them to both lose to the only real contenders, the guy the writer wants to win and the pal the editor doesn't want to lose. And both are fodder to coughing baby who solos fiction like paper between his pudgy half dead hands.

  • @mysticalkeyblade759
    @mysticalkeyblade759 9 месяцев назад +45

    The only theory I have is that Scratch used to be a taxi driver or something when he was alive since he said to Grandma Nin that people usually give a tip

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +12

      I mean, that’s also a concierge thing.

    • @mysticalkeyblade759
      @mysticalkeyblade759 9 месяцев назад +8

      @@SunnylandProdsyeah and heck it was probably not meant to be taken seriously. I honestly don’t care if a theory becomes real or not if the payoff of what they bring is satisfying.

  • @daviddanczyk2638
    @daviddanczyk2638 9 месяцев назад +5

    This is just a theory but, maybe Todd is Scratch's father and thats why he's always depressed because his son died.

  • @kirbystar7474
    @kirbystar7474 9 месяцев назад +9

    A example of a show theory baiting not well was how Steven universe was foreshadowing something with rose but most people already guessed she was pink so all the little hints just fueled the fire but people were confused on how vague they were.

  • @Nerd_with_internet_access
    @Nerd_with_internet_access 9 месяцев назад +13

    Dude, finally someone put it into words! So many times I’ll see a video like “this media SOLVED!!?!?” And I’m like, what do you mean solved? Like there’s nothing to solve, it’s literally a story.
    So, I have the opinion that a mystery media is not a mystery unless you can conceivably solve it with the information that is presented, otherwise it’s just a story. (Which isn’t bad, it’s just different) I don’t even mean it has to make sense. I just mean if you were had a list of characters you could pick who it is off of that. That’s why I don’t consider Sherlock s1e1 a mystery. Because it’s a random dude. It’s just a story. The ghost and Molly McGee is the same way. It’s not a mystery, it’s a story that is still unfolding. The bit about making jugsaw puzzles form nothing is so good. Like, gravity falls is a mystery, I think because there is enough of a precedent for what happens at the end, and it’s set up.
    Anyways, loved the video, hope everyone is haveing a good day 💜

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah, I think theories make sense if it’s something that’s actively giving you clues to solve for. Otherwise you’re likely just analyzing a bunch of stuff and coming to a conclusion that the creators never even thought of. Which can be fun to think about, but that doesn’t make it canon.

  • @KyProRen
    @KyProRen 8 месяцев назад +8

    9:03
    THAT WAS ME!!! I'M IN A VIDEO!!!

  • @christianparrish3292
    @christianparrish3292 9 месяцев назад +23

    I'm wondering if scratch's childhood friend is still a kid, or years passed, and she's grown up.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +8

      We don’t know exactly what year the flashbacks took place, but it was decades ago, for sure, so Adia is very much an adult. She’s probably older than Pete and Sharon. Likely in the 70’s-80’s based on the fashion. (Scratch’s mullet, Adia’s clothes)

    • @christianparrish3292
      @christianparrish3292 9 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@SunnylandProdsthat's an interesting theory. But that's up to the writers.

    • @kirbystar7474
      @kirbystar7474 9 месяцев назад +2

      In IMDb the description for episode 17a the many lives of scratch and says that he will meet the spirit of adia so who knows.

    • @kirbystar7474
      @kirbystar7474 9 месяцев назад

      @@bobertbopala Yeah I saw that

  • @7L13D
    @7L13D 9 месяцев назад +25

    For me I've always taken Theory's with a grain of salt if i even believe them in the first place. As much as i like MatPat's film and game theories I like GT(NOT)LIVE, Food, and Style more cause food theory is often just fun science experiments that even Mat himself doesn't always expect to work, and style can actually be really informative since it takes a lot more research. (And Steph as a bigger role on that channel) I know a lot of theories (from MatPat or otherwise) can often be crazy but I don't mind usually hearing them out. As long as they actually explain their evidence. (And not stuff like the whole "origin" of P&F thing.) Granted I usually firget most theories by like the next day or so, like I said I don't usually take them seriously.
    Also this is why i like this channel. You make really good arguments and points in your vids. When i saw the thumbnail, I was worried what this vid was going to be like, but then I remembered you're actually a reasonable person so I always give your videos a watch. And this was another great analysis

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +4

      Glad you liked it! Yeah, food theory is so much fun because it’s often Matt and Steph running actual experiments.
      Or it’s deciphering the lore of the GrubHub Cinematic Universe, which is still just insane to me. Like, THAT was obviously intentional, but I’m still not sure WHY GrubHub did all of that.

  • @NobodyUndefined
    @NobodyUndefined 6 месяцев назад +3

    This aged soo badly, the theory of Scratch being Todd was not a bad one and honestly the message of being too scared to live as you're scared to die is such a good one. Also technically the creator was right to say that we get an episode showing Scratch's death because why would they spoil it? If they said no then it'd be obvious that scratch either never died or is a wraith and why would they spoil that?

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  6 месяцев назад

      Go watch my newest video about the episode! (Spoiler alert: I LOVED IT.)

  • @andreagrubaugh9699
    @andreagrubaugh9699 9 месяцев назад +47

    I really don't like the 'Adia is Jinx' theory, it just felt like the fandom saw two characters who both had curly hair and black voice actresses, and just wanted to come up with an angsty scenario. Also, I feel like it undermines Jinx both as a character/really fun villain and with any sort of arc of her going from evil to good. If she's revealed to be Adia, her getting any sort of redemption arc would feel like 'Well, she's Scratch's former best friend, he HAS to forgive her', bleh.
    That being said, I feel like the Wraith!Scratch arc could still work/still feels fairly foreshadowed - he literally calls Todd 'soulless' in the ep before 'Molly VS the Ghost World' - and I feel like you could still have the themes of Scratch learning how to find happiness and live again, with this eventually leading to him deciding to return to his body and live a full life - accepting both the good and bad of life - instead of simply being a ghost/wraith that's lazily floating through life.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +9

      Well, like Bill said, we’re gonna see how Scratch died.
      So no, Scratch isn’t a wraith.

    • @PlutoTheSecond
      @PlutoTheSecond 9 месяцев назад +8

      @@SunnylandProds I was on the fence about the Scratch is a Wraith theory, but your video convinced me that it's not true. As for the Adia/Jinx theory, I never understood it to begin with. They don't even look similar!

  • @sasamichan
    @sasamichan 9 месяцев назад +10

    Fan theories can be fun, they can be correct, they can be almost correct, plausible , dark, ridiculous Some times they are legit some times they are not they don't ruin every thing, they give me some thing to talk about and you don't have to watch them.
    I know the "Scratch is a Wrath" theory is popular

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +3

      I don’t actually think they ruin everything

  • @alexklepp6479
    @alexklepp6479 9 месяцев назад +7

    I agree about that the obsession of theories and I like how you criticized Chekhov’s gun in that sometimes, it’s just put it because it looks cool.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +2

      It kinda makes sense when you’re talking about dressing a stage, but I really like stories that have good worldbuilding. One thing that’s so great about shows like The Ghost and Molly McGee and Phineas and Ferb is how fleshed out their worlds feel because of how they do worldbuilding.

  • @dannyorange9023
    @dannyorange9023 9 месяцев назад +3

    The "this character is actually another version this other character" are the worst of which!
    Fun video.

  • @genemelendez368
    @genemelendez368 9 месяцев назад +20

    LS Mark made a great point about this in his video on cartoon fan theories. Fun/plausible theories usually have some evidence in the show to back them up. The bad/dumb theories either just put an edgy explanation for weird things that happen, or say that characters represent drugs, mental illnesses, 7 deadly sins, etc.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah, and I think MatPat’s Doof theory and Jegcopo’s Candace theory

  • @cartoonloverzxc3237
    @cartoonloverzxc3237 9 месяцев назад +16

    Yes, dark theories do ruined everything but it’s fun to have happy theories, and just imagine with the show could be

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +3

      Remember when everyone was theorizing about how maimed the girls from Amphibia would be by the finale?

    • @cartoonloverzxc3237
      @cartoonloverzxc3237 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@SunnylandProds Yeah That Was Realy Unnecessary

    • @cajunking5987
      @cajunking5987 9 месяцев назад +1

      they actually… don’t ruin anything. They don’t affect anything at all.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      @@cajunking5987 Most of the dark theories are just super boring, honestly. It’s all the same.

    • @cajunking5987
      @cajunking5987 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds doesn’t ruin anything 🤷‍♂️

  • @Fractvred
    @Fractvred 9 месяцев назад +9

    This is a theory and why theories are bad. But hey, that’s just a theory. A theory theory

  • @sasamichan
    @sasamichan 6 месяцев назад +6

    fans finally got one right. But also, one wrong.

  • @Bobsburgers123
    @Bobsburgers123 9 месяцев назад +8

    I think that good,really well made theories are fine. I always enjoy people making great theories as now you can make head canons.

  • @metallicsnake.
    @metallicsnake. 9 месяцев назад +3

    the gallery nucleus panel, there was a common question asked about the character’s Zodiac signs in the owl house. Dana answered via text, that the Demon Realm had 666 days to a year and 13 months, so as to avoid pinning characters to our signs. It raises alot of other questions though. Amity is 14 . So 666×14= 9323 ÷ 364 is 25 years old in earth time. Here a other one from ducktales duck DNA is goes like this boys have ZZ and girls have ZW so unless they added a W in there that means that Scrooge is trans. Due to the fact his clone was a female and her two clones were female too

  • @raphaelmarquez9650
    @raphaelmarquez9650 9 месяцев назад +5

    Another issue is the number of theories in one story that only one has to be confirmed true, leaving fans of the other theories unhappy, so it's best to just debunk all their theories and subvert their expectations.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +2

      Which is what I friggin love about The Last Jedi, by the way. Space wizards do not need to be the dang royal family.
      “Whoever you’re waiting for on Jakku, they’re never coming back.”
      “The belonging you seek is not behind you. It is ahead.”

  • @MollyFox-gs3sl
    @MollyFox-gs3sl 9 месяцев назад +4

    I believed the wraith scratch theory because I didn’t think they had the guts to actually address scratch’s death but looks like we will get it after all and I’m pretty excited to see how things go

  • @DGilVids
    @DGilVids 9 месяцев назад +2

    "But I'm not here to talk about Star Wars." YEAH! That's my thing!

  • @parkerpotter6149
    @parkerpotter6149 9 месяцев назад +8

    Darn your clickbait! You scared me but I completely agree.

  • @MistCLaneous
    @MistCLaneous 6 месяцев назад +2

    Watching this after the finale and I'm glad I hadn't heard *that* theory before (pretty sure I never even picked up on [redacted]'s existence; granted, I'm also a more casual viewer of this series than you are). That becomes my personal issue with theories, the feeling of "I'd rather make that spoiler-y connection/discovery on my own rather than have it put into my head by someone else ahead of time."

    • @sonicsnake44
      @sonicsnake44 6 месяцев назад

      Same reason I don't bother with theories. Much more satisfying to figure it out yourself or be surprised.

  • @Robbity
    @Robbity 8 месяцев назад +3

    Personally, I think Todd’s purpose is supposed to be a a red herring. They make him so empty and designed to look like scratch. I think it’s supposed to be making fun of fan theories.

  • @lakegroce685
    @lakegroce685 9 месяцев назад +4

    I remember in the days of Steven Universe where if people didn’t like
    your theories, they’d call them stupid or constantly harass them. And then that somehow turned into Rebecca Sugar is secretly trying to promote fascism and defending abusers. Like this was a children’s show about nonbinary space aliens. What were these people watching? Because it was not the same show I was watching.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      Like I said, I don’t have a problem with fan theories, but people need to be respectful!

    • @Flowermations
      @Flowermations 9 месяцев назад +2

      And then that turned into Lily Orchard making a highly misinformed and spiteful video about why she doesn´t like SU, accusing Rebecca of being a N*zi supporter (even though she´s Jewish) all because the diamonds were redeemed? Like isn´t this show´s main message all about forgiveness and empathy, the diamonds are not space n*zis, their high ranked alien space rocks following a strict system of perfection White Diamond made because she got identity issues, if they were humans, then it would be a totally different story.

    • @lakegroce685
      @lakegroce685 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@Flowermations oh yeah I remember that. I never watched the original video itself but I did watch a bunch debunking certain points it and proving it was just bad faith criticism.

    • @Flowermations
      @Flowermations 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@lakegroce685 Good on you because that video conflicted me about my love for the show as a teen, like most different opinion videos tend to do to me as I kind of end up suddenly agreeing with them when that wasn´t my actual opinion.

  • @DPatifinho
    @DPatifinho 9 месяцев назад +2

    There are some theories that become true, for example, some Miraculous Ladybug theories.
    Gabriel is Hawk Moth - Confirmed
    Most of the secondary heroes identities - Confirmed
    Adrien is a Sentimonster - Confirmed (And multiple people didn't believe and still don't believe)
    Lila is future Hawk Moth - Confirmed
    But there also some Stupid theories, like "X character is in Coma" "X character is dead" "It's all a dream"

  • @gracekim25
    @gracekim25 9 месяцев назад +3

    Yeah i don’t want to know who Phineas’ dad is 😅

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      His dad is Lawrence! That’s the only answer that matters!

    • @gracekim25
      @gracekim25 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProdsEXACTLY 😊 it was the first show I saw to have a blended family in a good light and that’s all I care about. (Blended family is another word for a family made of a biological and step family members)

    • @gracekim25
      @gracekim25 9 месяцев назад

      I’ve generally never understood this obsession with knowing who’s the biological dad. It happened with Jim lake Jr in Trollhunters despite the characters making it clear his dad was a jerk who abandoned his family 😅 (the Trollhunter fans beloved his dad would appear in the movie despite not making any logical sense to do so. Those kind of theories make me question people’s sanity sometimes)

  • @ArendAlphaEagle
    @ArendAlphaEagle 9 месяцев назад +3

    There was this person who used to be in the Milo Murphy's Law fandom, who believed that Orton Mahlson, creator and starring actor of Dr Zone, was actually Melissa's dad, and that Melissa knew it the whole time, even noting some facial similarities... even though the two had completely different surnames and look NOTHING alike (Melissa in particular was named AND modeled after Dan's daughter, Meli Povenmire, while Orton Mahlson was named after Martin Olson, a friend of Dan that helped co-writing songs). And even when Melissa's actual dad, Richard Chase, showed up, the theorist _still_ held onto her theory that Orton HAS to be related to Melissa in some way and that Melissa views him as her dad, and that Richard must actually be some kind of robot (explaining where Time Ape came from). The theory was officially debunked when "Missing Milo" shows that the present-day Orton is actually MUCH OLDER than how he appears in Dr Zone, upon which the theorist decides to use her theory as a basis for an AU in which Orton Mahlson IS Melissa's dad. Orton Mahlson was clearly the only thing she truly cared about regarding Milo Murphy's Law, because she stopped watching after "The Phineas and Ferb Effect" aired, and the only other Season 2 episode she saw was "Lady Krillers", PURELY because it was a controversial episode.
    The theorist also apparently has a grudge on show writer Joshua Pruett for either deliberately misleading or deceiving her (I forgot which). Pruett and the writing team had scattered clues around in MML, and the theorist believed they practically lied to her because she was certain it would lead to the reveal that Orton was Melissa's dad and that Melissa knew it the whole time or something, when it's much more logical to assume she was following a completely different trail of breadcrumbs that the writers never intended to make and were merely coincidental.
    I don't have any clue why she was so _adamant_ about there being a connection between Orton and Melissa, but a 2020 interview between Jonathan of The 2nd Dimension, and Dan Povenmire, has Dan theorize she might've seen a moment in the We're Gonna Do It Again music video in which a picture of Dr Zone had his name swapped with that of Melissa's dad... _which was a complete accident._ I don't know if that's true, because the theorist never spoke about the music video being where she got the idea from, but a theorist basing their whole identity on a big theory they are certain will come true, because they took a tiny mistake at face value... it sounds a bit embarrassing.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Holy crap, I forgot about that, but that’s right!

    • @ArendAlphaEagle
      @ArendAlphaEagle 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds I just remembered that very early on, she also theorized that Orton was going to be evil (and in turn, Melissa would either also be evil, or would turn against her "dad" due to her friendship with Milo). Orton being evil had a bit more merit since the term "Evil Orton" was put multiple times on a pinboard from the same We're Gonna Do It Again music video that was MUCH more widespread across the fandom, as it would potentially summarize the Season 1 story arc in three acts. However, we'd come to realize that "Evil Orton" actually referred to Derek the Pistachion, the primary antagonist of "Fungus Among Us" and "The Phineas and Ferb Effect" who took Orton's place and whose present-day appearance looks like a Pistachion version of Dr Zone.
      Even then, Dan Povenmire had confirmed that half of the plot points thrown onto that pinboard were made up on the spot for kicks for the music video, although some of the unused plot points were real ones that were scrapped (such as "Ferb" betraying the gang, IIRC).

  • @daviddanczyk2638
    @daviddanczyk2638 6 месяцев назад +3

    Man, that aged pretty well.

  • @DoubleH2279
    @DoubleH2279 26 дней назад

    I feel like whoever came up with the Phineas and Ferb schizophrenic creepy pastas are really trying to put rats in every person’s birthday cake, if you catch my drift

  • @mitkitty
    @mitkitty 9 месяцев назад +1

    Scratch being a wraith is EXTREMELY PLAUSIBLE- having an episode about "how scratch died" is very ambiguously worded. Plus, he's still a ghost and "dead inside" before meeting Molly!
    It's fine if you dont believe the theory, but it's extremely plausible given the constant references and dialogue. Of course, it could be a red herring, but i think the theory is pretty sound.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      He’s absolutely not a wraith. They didn’t come up with the wraith mechanics until they were figuring out Molly vs the Ghost World.

  • @reynellfreeman8761
    @reynellfreeman8761 9 месяцев назад +1

    I kind of like the Jinx is Adia theory it gives her a redemption arc down the road and the show plays up the enemies to friends (or lovers because I do ship them) for scratch and jinx

  • @jasonjasso666
    @jasonjasso666 9 месяцев назад +5

    Mort from Madagascar is canonically the arbiter of chaos that ties almost every Dreamworks film in a terrifyingly consistent manner.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      I still like this better than Pixar Theory

  • @JoelTheParrot
    @JoelTheParrot 6 месяцев назад +2

    1:52 I mean, it happened regardless.
    (TGAMM S2 FINALE SPOILERS BELOW)
    8:17 Honestly minus the previously unmentioned (afaik) Wraith Amnesia this still holds water. Todd acts a bit too lively and independent. Not that it wasn't a satisfying episode and conclusion, just has a strange minor contrivance.

  • @cartoonloverzxc3237
    @cartoonloverzxc3237 9 месяцев назад +2

    I actually do believe that Candace does know about Perry and I kind of think First does as well because he didn’t react very much when he found out on across the second dimension

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      Oh, I totally believe Ferb knows.

  • @acesinger6092
    @acesinger6092 9 месяцев назад +1

    9:07
    Excuse me while I _AAAAAAAHHHHHHH_
    That is so cool!! I'm so curious as to how he died, I can't wait for that episode

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Yeah, I’m super excited for that one!

  • @PhantomPhera
    @PhantomPhera 9 месяцев назад +4

    I think it's also the fact that Todd had simular facial features to scratch overall 8:23 aside from just the voice actor being the same, The 2 still have way more in common than Jynx and Adia which have next to no simular features whatsoever. While your right in that wrath bodies are pretty lifeless Todd (while somewhat lively) Does seem to be mostly bland and lifeless even if it's not to the degree we see Wrath Molly. So it's still mostly possible for sure. Scratch not actually being dead wouldn't ruin the show cause a wrath is still a ghost so it isn't like title or show overall is lying.
    Also I'm pretty sure the actual purpose of the show is to be a fun slice of life story with a ghost and a girl bot this 9:56
    but I agree this also this 11:06

  • @ThePrincessCH
    @ThePrincessCH 6 месяцев назад +4

    Have you seen the season finale from "The Ghost and Molly McGee" yet?

  • @panizshariat7892
    @panizshariat7892 9 месяцев назад +8

    I like to turn very dark creepy shows and make them light hearted like that one tumblr post

  • @connorthompson8376
    @connorthompson8376 9 месяцев назад +1

    The whole thing about Scratch and Jynx/Adia with some thing that occurred to me, but I didn’t say anything until now. They clearly are setting some thing up with the villain, and probably some thing with his past, so there is the human tendency to look for patterns. It will be interesting to see what they do in the end, but whatever theories I form, I don’t tend to put them out there as fact.

  • @awesomeocelot7475
    @awesomeocelot7475 3 месяца назад +1

    I do wonder if Scratch was always intended to be a Wraith because the creators have both said stuff they points to and against that…

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  3 месяца назад +1

      It was the plan from very early on.

  • @rowan404
    @rowan404 9 месяцев назад

    I love theorizing and even made some theory videos of my own for a surreal webseries with a lot of open questions, but I only make theories that have a good amount of evidence. Many fan-theories, such as the Pixar Theory, annoy me because, like you said, people are putting together a puzzle that doesn’t exist. It’s obvious that there’s no deeper meaning, but people try to find one anyway.

  • @TheRealSuperKirby
    @TheRealSuperKirby 9 месяцев назад +2

    For some reason video game theories seem to always make sense and tv show ot movie theories seem to never make sense. Anyone else notice this?

    • @TheRealSuperKirby
      @TheRealSuperKirby 9 месяцев назад

      Actually I think I just realized why, in most video games understanding the story is completely optional and you can just focus on the game play, so the story is usually more open for theorizing, and will often have mysteries left unsolved, but in tv shows and movies the story is the most of the show, and will usually end with tying up any mysteries the show had, leaving not much room for theories that don't completely change the show.

  • @anthonyackerman7914
    @anthonyackerman7914 9 месяцев назад +2

    I think Matpat aren't really meant to be taken seriously

  • @bisha7989
    @bisha7989 5 месяцев назад +2

    Watching this after watching the finale, well this vid aged well

  • @Crystre
    @Crystre 9 месяцев назад +3

    I don’t mind theory’s and some of my own. I just hate when people take these theory’s as canon and treat them as such and spread them as canon

  • @JERealize
    @JERealize Месяц назад

    I guess the takeaway of this video is, "Something can be displayed as set dressing and nothing more, and that's okay." Hard to stomach, but not untrue.
    To tell you the truth, I'm not a fan of fan theories. It kind of ruins the ability for me to enjoy a show on its own, it forces me to keep up with the Joneses with wackier theories, and it's one of the reasons why I don't hang around in fandoms anymore. Good thing that paid off, too. I missed the boat on the "Evil Luz" theory entirely. In fact, when my sister and I were discussing what was going on in the Human Realm with Camilla, she hypothesized a version of said theory while I dismissed it as 'too obvious' and came up with the theory that Luz would eventually end up in a time rift to live out the life she missed so her mom would be none the wiser. We both ended up wrong, but the reveal was decent.
    It kind of reminds me of an Arthur episode. The school caught "Binky Rules" written in graffiti on the walls and blamed student "Binky" Barnes, which would cause him to miss out on school sports. Fern and Buster, each with their own history of solving cases, butt heads on their theories as to who was really responsible. Buster thought Binky had an evil twin who wanted revenge, while Fern thought a rival soccer team set him up to fall. The correct answer was, of course, an overzealous marketing campaign for a group of Finnish Vocaloids. Yeah, the truth can be anything in fiction.
    And yeah, we all call things wrong sometimes. I hated the "Garnet is a fusion" fan theory (I thought it would ruin a character with so much room to grow, especially when I still hadn't understood fusions (I still kind of don't)), and defended it by saying gem placement has so far been symmetrical and maybe Garnet's gem would split in two upon her forming. Well... shoot.

  • @kirbystar7474
    @kirbystar7474 9 месяцев назад +1

    5:56 That was the theory from the second dimension’s video on the show. That explains why you know it.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Yep! He’s a good friend of mine!!

  • @gracekim25
    @gracekim25 9 месяцев назад +2

    I guess they do sometimes 😅 I don’t take every theory seriously 😂

  • @titleinworkingprogress8867
    @titleinworkingprogress8867 9 месяцев назад +1

    The credits jingle for this show is a lot of fun to listen to.

  • @sulu8050
    @sulu8050 9 месяцев назад

    You know, I think you should dive into the way how shipping in fandom works, I'm curious to know of your take when it comes to this, because wowww, there's sooooo many of them in Deviantart and fanarts in general.
    Anyways for theories, yeah, I do admit I got sucked into the flow of theories, ranging from what you mentioned of Candace to Linda "knowing" everything of Phineas. And yeah, that does kinda ruined everything.

  • @bugztandosffhat305
    @bugztandosffhat305 9 месяцев назад +1

    I'll always find it funny that people would would tear Matpat apart like pieces of paper, i remember watching one of his theories on WH (aka Welcome Home) and the fans in that fandom were acting like he was gonna ruin, everything but in reality i believe that some of the fans were acting like Matpat was Satan Incarnate
    but again it's hella funny to see that people are Still Tearing apart Matpat

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Like I said in the video, I really like MatPat’s videos!

    • @bugztandosffhat305
      @bugztandosffhat305 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds i'm on your side too!, what talking about the people who hate on MatPat and will stop at nothing to rip him apart

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      @@bugztandosffhat305 did you see the FNAF movie yet?

    • @bugztandosffhat305
      @bugztandosffhat305 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds sadly no QwQ

  • @SonofMrPeanut
    @SonofMrPeanut 9 месяцев назад

    One Gravity Falls hypothesis I came across was the notion that the dinosaurs in "Land Before Swine" ARE the aliens who the crash site ship belongs to (or at least descendants of the arriving ones).

  • @fanaticalistic
    @fanaticalistic 9 месяцев назад +2

    To all those that clicked on the video with hate in their heart from the video title: 3:41

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      I think anyone who’s a fan of MatPat’s videos knows this is exactly how the game is played.
      Seriously, nothing but respect for MatPat.

  • @SonofMrPeanut
    @SonofMrPeanut 9 месяцев назад

    On fan predictions impacting reactions to TLJ, maybe that helped me enjoy it as much as I do. If anything, I wasn't wondering much about what came next until I saw said movie.

  • @SonofMrPeanut
    @SonofMrPeanut 9 месяцев назад +1

    The more a fan consistently and unwaveringly brandishes their prediction about and shoots down every other possibility, the higher likelihood they'll lash out about it not coming true. Maybe even to the point of harassing creatives.

  • @moonbased7796
    @moonbased7796 9 месяцев назад

    Honestly I enjoy looking at theories and honestly sure a lot of them could be wrong (which I remember when I was younger, I made dumb theories and were wrong all the time) but hey it was fun to see what other people came up with regardless if it became true or wrong.
    Also to answer your question I remember believing that Dipper and Mabel had a third sibling (aka Lebam because of the pool episode) and it was fun to see how wrong I was lol

  • @infinitetimer27
    @infinitetimer27 4 месяца назад +1

    Man…since the last episode came out it’s bring a new look at things. Lol

  • @SonofMrPeanut
    @SonofMrPeanut 9 месяцев назад +1

    If we're talking theories for the fun of it, TheRealJims' "Who Really Shot Mr. Burns?" series comes highly recommended. His Abe Simpson solution is my favorite.

  • @atleastdecent3810
    @atleastdecent3810 9 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you Thankk you thank you, finally someone agrees that Food theory is genuinely a good channel

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Do people not like Food Theory or something?

    • @atleastdecent3810
      @atleastdecent3810 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProds I just don’t think it gays the same love as the other channels, and I haven’t met anyone who has watched it. It might be my favorite of the theory channels since the information is all real life stuff

  • @oBirino
    @oBirino Месяц назад

    The problem is when the developers change everything because they saw that one of the theories is corrected, and/or think that private information was leaked.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  Месяц назад

      Yeah, I think that happened with one of the Scream sequels.

    • @oBirino
      @oBirino Месяц назад

      @@SunnylandProds Really? The new ones or the old ones?

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  Месяц назад

      I think it was Scream 3

  • @thefantasticretroreviewer3941
    @thefantasticretroreviewer3941 9 месяцев назад +1

    Great Video

  • @A.B.-ub9un
    @A.B.-ub9un 9 месяцев назад +1

    The issue I get is sometimes when a major character is set up, but then gets no real payoff. Five Nights at Freddy's is infamous for this in regards to the supposed new villain in Security Breach, Burntrap. In Ruins, Burntrap gets no mention outside of a small easter egg, despite being a main antagonist. We got a set up for him, only for him to get replaced by someone else entirely.
    A background character not having any importance is fine, but when a main character gets a big set up for some major story arc, only for the writers to suddenly change their mind and go with something else completely, is just flat out bad writing.

  • @puppyninjawarrior7312
    @puppyninjawarrior7312 3 месяца назад +2

    8:32 well that aged well..

  • @user-mj2xp8fb5x
    @user-mj2xp8fb5x 9 месяцев назад +1

    Super cool.😊

  • @christianparrish3292
    @christianparrish3292 9 месяцев назад +1

    I mean, they might bring back Reggie some how.

  • @SuperNova-mp5zp
    @SuperNova-mp5zp 9 месяцев назад

    Man honestly have run into a nice amount of thories espeically on tumblr. There are a fair few scratch theories floating around.

  • @FizzyMoonBeam
    @FizzyMoonBeam 9 месяцев назад +1

    I only watch game theory for FNAF

  • @Shadowthechangling
    @Shadowthechangling 9 месяцев назад

    i love theroys they give me a new look on something

  • @The-Coven-Guard
    @The-Coven-Guard 3 месяца назад

    Seeing this after watching The Ghost and Molly Mcgee finale is so confusing.

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  3 месяца назад +2

      Which is why I’m tempted to unlist this video and possibly remake it at some point. Because I think my ultimate point of “take fan theories with a grain of salt, enjoy the ride” is a good one, even if one of the main theories I contested actually ended up being true.

  • @erinwademan-flores5204
    @erinwademan-flores5204 9 месяцев назад +2

    Tily green from Big city greens isn't Bill's biological kid

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад +1

      Even if that was true, it’d be in the same territory as who Phineas’s biological dad is. *Entirely unimportant.*

    • @metallicsnake.
      @metallicsnake. 9 месяцев назад +1

      Just because she has different hair and skin color then any know family member doesn't make her a product of cheating

  • @PeterPeter20
    @PeterPeter20 8 месяцев назад

    14:24-14:41 Never say this to a FNaF theorist

  • @Nakia11798
    @Nakia11798 9 месяцев назад +1

    I think it depends. MattPatt ruins everything, but theories in general do not.
    Look at Miraculous! A lot of the theories have been proven to be true!
    I will agree that these edgy non-substatial "character is dead/coma/mentally ill" are awful though

  • @rainbowspongebob
    @rainbowspongebob 9 месяцев назад +1

    Didn’t matpat make a video about how he ruined games with theory’s lol

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      Probably, I don’t watch enough Game Theory tbh

  • @MrGabeanator
    @MrGabeanator 9 месяцев назад

    now i'd like to see that fan fiction of linda flynn and walt disney

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  9 месяцев назад

      There’s a super dark pitch for a series if anyone wants it, I guess

    • @MrGabeanator
      @MrGabeanator 9 месяцев назад

      @@SunnylandProdsi'd watch it

  • @christiancardona7342
    @christiancardona7342 9 месяцев назад

    I respect your opinion on theory

  • @rimfire8217
    @rimfire8217 9 месяцев назад +1

    1:52 "I think the only reason why the auto-scan replicator was in, was so blah blah blah"
    Yeah but where's the fun it that?
    Where's the Imagination?

  • @josiahtheawkward6008
    @josiahtheawkward6008 6 месяцев назад +4

    Welp

  • @CartoonyAndor19
    @CartoonyAndor19 9 месяцев назад +1

    Yeah...
    BUT ITS FUN!!

  • @OfficialMinecrafter0986
    @OfficialMinecrafter0986 6 месяцев назад +2

    Heyy, may want to watch "The End" XD one of these theories come true

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  6 месяцев назад +1

      Did you seriously think I hadn’t already seen the episode?
      Yeah, I’m writing the video on it right now.

    • @OfficialMinecrafter0986
      @OfficialMinecrafter0986 6 месяцев назад +2

      @@SunnylandProds no, I knew. I was joking XD

  • @awesomeocelot7475
    @awesomeocelot7475 3 месяца назад +1

    I’m just watching this video for the first time now and your whole argument against Scratch is a wraith and is actually Todd thing aged HORRIBLY…

    • @SunnylandProds
      @SunnylandProds  3 месяца назад +1

      People keep commenting on this video like they don’t think I know that. 😂

    • @awesomeocelot7475
      @awesomeocelot7475 3 месяца назад +1

      @@SunnylandProds I never said you didn’t know that I mean obviously you know you did a video about it.

  • @stm7810
    @stm7810 9 месяцев назад

    I only like theories that fit and add to the lore for fun, character x is dead or should be because physics is boring and goes against the story, but hey here's this connection that makes a good point or explains something to add to the lore can be good, for an example Undertale.
    Bad theory: Sans is Ness, Undyne is only determined due to unethical experiments that go against Alphys's love or monsters are evil are garbage theories.
    Sans stole your pause button, Undyne has god and anime on her side and Papyrus is non binary are fun.

  • @denime2727
    @denime2727 8 месяцев назад

    Damn I loved theorizing about Gravity Falls it was so satisfying when your theory was true and when other things were revealed you coud go back and find clues

  • @shadesco211
    @shadesco211 9 месяцев назад

    Oh, no, you got me. Oh no oh no. Oh no I I clicked on the video because of the title in your me oh no aaaah

  • @christianparrish3292
    @christianparrish3292 9 месяцев назад +2

    I subscribed to your friend 2nd dimension.

  • @showmytheticket248
    @showmytheticket248 Месяц назад +1

    It's funny how you keep talking that scratch isn't tod, just for the show to reveal it is

  • @rainbowbrony12
    @rainbowbrony12 9 месяцев назад

    Scratch saying "0 spirit, it's like he has no soul" while talking about his possible body in the wraith-theory is REALLY starting to get to me.
    EDIT: So uh, I guess that "no soul" thing was foreshadowing after all, huh?

  • @rosez64aj
    @rosez64aj 9 месяцев назад

    Ash is in coma and hes dreaming theory

  • @eeveefennecfox
    @eeveefennecfox 9 месяцев назад +2

    I think theory videos only ruin everything is there's barely even evidence behind them,which is why I hate alot of pokemon theories,none of them have any evidence backing them up or even make sense,plus all the creepypasta stories ruin everything even more,like no I didn't come here for your sick twisted dark disturbing stories
    I seem to like matpat's theories even though I do have a hard time understanding them due to my 1% brain cell XD but at least he has evidence with his theories unlike 99% of other theory videos people do and I do have fun with watching his theories cause of it,there's only one other theory channel I watch besides matpat,theroundtable,they do a pretty good job with cartoon theories,but every other channel I come across seem to lack evidence and deep dives and it just ruins the fun,it depends for me,cause I hate most theories cause 99% of the ones I've seen have 0 evidence,like are they sure they even watch the show that their doing a theory on? at least matpat and theroundtable sit their butts down and watch the shows that they are theorizing on