ER Doctor Rates 10 DIY Surgery Scenes In Movies & TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 фев 2022
- Emergency room doctor Jamie Lee looks at 10 emergency medical scenes from movies and TV and rates them based on realism.
She looks at "Squid Game" S1E10 (2021), "Cast Away" (2000), "Anaconda" (1997), "No Country for Old Men" (2007), "Casino Royale" (2006), "127 Hours" (2010), "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" S3E13 (1999), "Die Hard" (1988), "John Wick: Chapter III - Parabellum" (2019), and "The Wolverine" (2013). Scenes include shoulder dislocations, resuscitations, dealing with bullet injuries and emergency amputations.
Lee is an emergency medicine physician in New York City. You can find out more about her by checking out her social media and her blog:
RUclips: / thestrivetofit
Blog: www.thestrivetofit.com
If you have a medical emergency, dial 911.
MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
Military Trauma Surgeon Rates 10 Battle Wounds In Movies & TV
• Military Trauma Surgeo...
Afghan War Veteran Rates 9 Afghanistan War Battles In Movies
• Afghan War Veteran Rat...
Urban-Warfare Expert Rates 11 Urban-Warfare Scenes In Movies And TV
• Urban-Warfare Expert R...
------------------------------------------------------
#EmergencySurgery #HowRealIsIt #Insider
Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com
Insider on Facebook: / insider
Insider on Instagram: / insider
Insider on Twitter: / thisisinsider
Insider on Snapchat: / 4020934530
Movies Insider on Snapchat: / 9616609930
Insider on TikTok: / insider
ER Doctor Rates 10 Emergency Surgery Scenes in Movies and TV | How Real Is It?
People don't realise just how brutally tight a tourniquet has to be in order to be truly effective. I was attacked by a knife-wielding nutcase in the Netherlands the other year and was bleeding out; the first responders put a tourniquet on me and that honestly hurt more than being stabbed and slashed up. But, it saved my life.
Ugh! Horrible! Glad you are still here.
Dreadful experience lad. I hope you are better
Woah. What an experience! Thanks for sharing.
You mean an Arab?
Hope they found the bastard!
Going around hurting people with his tourniquet.
I had a lot of fun with this shoot. Thank you so much for having me!
Great job Dr J.
Wow, I'm a huge fan of TheStrivetoFit, so happy to see your content on Insider, too! :) So exciting! XOXO
I saw the thumbnail and I was like whaaaaaaat? Clicked instantly.
always exciting to hear the pros share about what they're passionate about
Yeah ok but Wolverine has a healing factor. They didn't teach you that at med school huh?
“It could be uncomfortable” meaning “pure agony” 😂😂😂
Some slight pressure.
Just a little scratch
Tis but a scratch
In medicine, "uncomfortable" is a euphemism for "unbearable pain"
This lady is fantastic, can we have the mortician guy, the CIA disguise lady and the bug guy back to do another video soon? It's amazing how yall find people that are knowledgeable yet can break down things so average Joes can understand, this is another home run
I don’t think there’s a single one that I haven’t enjoyed tbh. For some reason tho, I do love the sheer availability of the “doctors react” type of videos. Dr Wagner and Dr Mike do a lot of those sort of videos, and media is loaded with Grey’s Anatomy/House/Scrubs/The good doctor/er/etc etc etc.
I’d like to see some officers/detectives/svu/etc explain shows like criminal minds/CSI/NCIS/etc bc the assistant scoutmaster in my scout troop was a cop and he always said he wished he knew of a department with 10% of the tech they have on those shows.
Also, if you’re looking for good ones, the linguist they have explaining accents/historical figures portrayed on tv/in movies, those are my favorites.
The mortician guy was my favorite
@@andyhighroller8217 I absolutely agree with having officer/detectives on. I'm an officer and I watch some shows and see so many things wrong
CIA lady was so cool. I particularly enjoyed this lady too - super knowledgeable.
I would like a procedural show with them…
I work in emergency medicine and one part of our training was actually applying CATs (combat application tourniquet) to ourselves and our colleagues to learn how much pressure we actually need to put to completely block blood flow to the selected extremity (and how much that freaking hurts).
It was some time ago but the pain I felt while having the tourniquet on me is still something I really vividly remember.
Tourniquets save lives. Use them if needed. Make sure to write the time of application though, it's kinda important to know how long the arm/leg has been basically dead (without blood flowing). And NEVER remove the tourniquet yourself if you didn't get it on in training purposes. It needs to be removed in the OR by the surgical team to actually make sure the clots formed don't kill you.
I wrote a really long and boring post, but shortened it and then probably still made it too long. Short short: Me scout kid mental bad but deal with ouch good, friendo hurt arm with saw oopsie, tourniquet! Nono, but I say yes, adult back with nurse, yippie, tourniquet, bad adult, bad first aid kit, you kid with mental real good, okie responsibility go me, adult ask good/bad I say, okie, but later byebye scouts. Short long: I had mental issues and experience ending up in hospitals, having cuts and just reading about things that can happen to a human body. A friend cut himself in a weird place (I don't get how he got hurt there, I mean) near his elbow and the saw went really far in. We improvised a tourniquet, but a scout team leader I asked to apply an improvised tourniquet but didn't want to, so I asked him to get the nurse got back with her and she applied a real one but said that using it earlier woulda been better, but I was getting things together and partway through tying a belt around the kid's arm when they came. The kid was airlifted and the scout team leader kicked out, cause not only did he not realize a real threatening injury occurred, but our first-aid kit lacked a tourniquet among other things (like non-alcoholic disinfectant). I got a pat on the head for suggesting a tourniquet early on but also told about the pain that entails and just in general got some slightly more advanced first aid knowledge and was like the go to "do we need to go to the hospital" guy on smaller outings that didn't have a nurse till I quit.
@ET Hardcorgamer I know! I'm older now than the scout leader that didn't want to apply a tourniquet was back then and I have no idea how the guy was entrusted with kids if he wasn't ready to help a kid in that situation. I truly don't get his thinking - we all saw the amount of blood the kid was losing. Not to mention how irresponsible it is to not have a tourniquet in a first aid kit when on an outing in the middle of the forest, with a lot of sharp objects and kids that may not realize how badly they can hurt themselves.
As to HEMA, it's also important to remember that those manuals were made for knights who'd be wearing plate, grabbing a sword with a gauntlet wouldn't really hurt the hand. But I agree with you completely - sometimes you've gotta do what you've gotta do to survive. It's better to lose a limb than your life.
127 hours is still an unbelievable story. The fact that he managed to cut his arm off and then survive is just mind blowing. I'd rather die under that rock than attempt this lol
With Swiss army knife as well if I remember right
@@crazynutreviews2647 exactly
“This is pretty much how it would be done”
“3/10”
Pretty sure it was because the person wouldn't be functioning if he was having heart issue and wouldn't be walking around after he flatlined 🙄
If only there had been more than that one statement to explain the rating...
Maybe because it was the first clip she saw, she priced higher marks out of the curve too quickly.
You forgot to take into account that the scene with Wolverine. He regenerates blood, skin, muscle tissue etc. So for him to reach under the rib cage to remove something from his heart is not going to be an issue he will heal in no time. It was easier than breaking his own ribs to access his heart
also, he prob cant cut thru his chest due to the metal coating it, so he has to go thru his abdomen
Totally agree!
If they were going to give her a clip frim Wolverine they should have given her some context. Otherwise the scene is just absurd.
Probably not a good idea to use super-powered people for a "how real is it" clip anyway. 😅
And he would not be able to cut through his ribcage anyway.
@@rvanzo925 yes he would, with his blades. adamantium is the only thing that can cut through adamantium
That level of chill would be very comforting if I were in an ER.
I like her use of "uncomfortable" for what appear to be very painful situations.
I was thinking the same thing. I never had a shoulder dislocation but I did have a knee dislocation so I dunno if they’re similar pain/trauma-wise but it was not even the same realm of pain compared to some other pretty serious injuries I’ve had (including fracturing my femur) and I was in an immobilizer for two months. So.. “uncomfortable” is just a BIT of an understatement.
@@naturequeene132True. When I tore my ACL in 2017, they did the surgery pretty quick after a few weeks of physical therapy, and then within 9 months I was back to full-time training and running 5ks, but when it immediately happened, I was almost numb to the pain, and that I think was just my brain keeping me from realizing the immediate pain that I was in. The aftereffect left me feeling confused, lethargic, and even at times like I was numb all over my body.
@@zaynes5094 that’s adrenaline baby! You don’t feel the pain immediately because your brain is rushing.
If you want to skip straight to one of them...
1. "Casino Royale" (2006) - 3/10 [0:28]
2. "Anaconda" (1997) - 6/10 [2:43]
3. "John Wick: Chapter III - Parabellum" (2019) - 3/10 [4:55]
4. "Die Hard" (1988) - 7/10 [6:31]
5. "The Wolverine" (2013) - 1/10 [7:39]
6. "Squid Game" S1E10 (2021) - 6/10 [9:25]
7. "No Country for Old Men" (2007) - 8/10 [10:51]
8. "127 Hours" (2010) - 9/10 [12:44]
9. "Cast Away" (2000) - 7/10 [15:21]
10. "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" S3E13 (1999) - 4/10 [16:35]
Life saver
RUclips algorithms hate this man for this one simple trick
Not the hero we deserve, but the hero we need
Every video should do this
Not all hero wear caps
For the John Wick one, I'm surprised she didn't comment on the low light. What is it with films and shows nowadays where everything indoors has to be unrealistically dark? Especially in a situation like this where you'd want all the light you can get. And what little light there is is shining on the wrong side of the patient.
agree. but, it’s a movie/show. i used to think the same until i dabbled in photography and had to learn about lighting and it actually plays a pretty big part in how you’re trying to convey a scene and set a type of mood for the shot. i’m sure there videos on youtube that explain scenes like this when it comes to lighting and when you hear why it’s lit like that and watch the scene agin you’re like “ok, i get it” and realize that realistic lighting would change the whole mood of the shot.
@@terahsavaya3688 I partly agree, the thing is, it just not realistic, and sometimes more realism is just better, plus in this case, light for surgeries are very bright and cold, and could have worked very well. It feels just unnatural and unsettling for a lot of people. So I think they could have made a better job with the light in this case.
Mostly I think its intentional noir lighting
Well she gave it a 3
The amount of light you see isn’t necessarily the amount they showed to be seeing in movies. Just like when they supposedly can’t see anything but you can.
17:35 Uncomfortable is an understatement. I have Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, so I get frequent dislocations and usually reseat the joint without assistance. I've learned what works and what doesn't. But not so much in the first few minutes, but after a qtr hour or so of a joint being out of socket it starts to become really nauseating. While you're numb and in shock it's quite easy to deal with, but once the endorphins fade it's a bad place to be.
It took me years to learn not to over reach and stretch my shoulders too far, just because you can doesn't mean you should lol. In my experience though, dislocations hurt considerably more than broken bones. After dislocating my wrist and fracturing my scaphoid it was the dislocation that caused 95% of the pain, the day after once some of the swelling had subsided, I managed to pull my thumb enough to reseat everything else in the wrist where it should be and the pain receded to a background murmur. Breaks ache, dislocations are much more viscerally painful.
As goes the clip, when I reseat my own shoulder I lift the affected arm onto a table with my other hand, then squat down so the arm is lifted above my head, and it usually shlups back into place. It tends to stretch everything out though so for a few months it'll be prone to coming out at a sneeze. After 3-6 months it tightens up and stays in socket unless I'm stupid and reach fast without thinking. I've cracked the cartilage in the cup of the joint though, so I don't know if that's why it goes in so easily from above for me. If I can't find something to raise the arm, then I use the other hand to try and pull it over my head like I'm a ballet dancer, but it's a bit more hit and miss. I had to do it like that in the deep end of a swimming pool once and I panicked and floundered quite a bit and got a mouthful of water before I managed to get it back in and swim to the edge of the pool. Disclocations suck, and I don't go swimming much anymore as I don't like breaststroke but it's the only kind of swimming that doesn't throw out one or other of my shoulders.
I can't believe they didn't include Paul Bettany yanking a bullet out of his abdomen in "Master and Commander: the Far Side of the World"! The scene where Stephen uses a mirror to operate on himself is fantastically done.
I'm very surprised and disappointed!
Yes!!!! That scene always has me fascinated...because back in that time frame, as the movie shows when poor Lil Will looses his arm, they bite down on the sticks because they had nothing to numb the pain.
@@shinigamikitty well they did have laudanum
Wow! Jamie. I remember the days you were studying hard in medschool. Thanks a lot, because your videos helped me a LOT
"More damage that has to be fixed later" = Tell me you've never heard of Wolverine without telling me you've never heard of Wolverine.
Yep...she should've gave him a 10 out of 10...
And she was expecting him to cut his adamantium chest open haha
Yeah! She shouldn't be a doctor if she doesn't have the basic knowledge!
Ah... The comment i was looking for.. 😂
@@drusix1987 To be fair, she's probably not trained as a mutant doctor.
I like that she did no country for old men, as a former EMT I really loved that scene.
And in 127 hours in real life he really did use a small multi tool knife that wasn’t sharp.
I’ve never had my
Shoulder dislocated, thank goodness.
Did he steal the anaesthetic from the pharmacy?
Jamie is lovely, bring her back for more.
Probably the most strict rating system I've seen in this series xD. I feel like she had more thoughts that were cut for time
It was unnesecarily strict . She gave a real life event a 9/10. How much more real can it get than real life
Aw....I was hoping she'd rate Mark Watney's(Matt Damon) self-surgery in "The Martian." That scene was intense. Also, John Rambo's(Sylvester Stallone) field surgery in "First Blood" would've been interesting.
ill rate matt damons one. It's all feasible. He should've cut the clothes around the pole before pulling it out in case it hit some vessel, in that location may hit inferior epigastric artery if deep enough. He should use some antiseptic wash given there's clearly medical equipment. Angle of mirror needs to be better to see properly, although you could try do it by feel, sometimes we do these by feel. He should have washed the wound before closing it with staples. I'm surprised the staples hurt as it looked like the thing he injected at the start was probably local anaesthetic. So 7/10, missed a few steps but overall OK.
To be fair his injury was sustained during that martian dust storm right? If it did, that injury wouldn't have realistically happened. Dust storms on Mars are immense and massive but quite honestly it's like a weak wind storm here on earth because the gravity on Mars is so low as is its atmospheric density. The reason they look so extreme is because the whole planet is covered in nothing but dust and when those storms start that wind just keeps going, even if by earth standards is not very powerful wind.
I was hoping for The Predator to make an appearance 🤣
She was so respectful in saying that Casino Royale is absolute bunk
That was the thing I was confused about. She seemed fairly complementary, but it was a 3/10 lmao
@@bmgiannotti Maybe because it was the first clip she saw, she priced higher marks out of the curve too quickly.
Next do: *_Time-Traveler Reviews Time-Traveling Paradoxes from Movies and TV Shows (2035 Edition)_*
Wow, wonderfully explained based on the scenario at the scenes👍👏
Gee, what kind of medical expert is this? She didn’t even know Wolverine has an adamantium-infused skeleton and therefore had to go through his abdomen! 😁😁
She still wasn't surprised by the claw :D
You have a point. The circumstances are of the fantasy-kind, as, not only does he have a adamantium infused skeleton, but his body also re-generates (well, partly due to the , er ... thing he has on his heart). Upon that he is used to excruciating pain which would make others pass out. I can't expect any doctor to make any comment about it. She made the best of it and just trashed the scene.
Real people don't have a admantium skeleton
@@KingNerdius are you sure?
@@VladimirLukele yes
That was brutal. Great episode! You guys seriously always choose the perfect person for these vids.
Awesome stuff. But I don’t think she knows who Wolverine is. Lol
I was going to comment the something
I am onclined to agree. 1/10? Given hos healing factor and his built up tolerances for pain, he did survive those nuclear burns in the movie, I would have given it a 1/10 if it was a regular human but I would have bumped it up to at least a 5/10.
She was rating how real it was so she was on the money. She got squid game wrong though. Should have been 10/10 since she did die.
@@letsautomateit7870 could be she didn't watch the drama, so she doesn't know her character died.
Her assessments are base on surgeries in real life situation not Hollywood bluff.
Her smile is contagious
SHE is contagious.....I would fake an injury just to be attended to by her!
Omgosh it’s Jamie !! Woohoo👏
Loved this! It would have been cool, if she had reviewed the scene in the Outlander pilot episode, where Claire puts Jamie’s shoulder back into place. It would have been a good comparison to the Buffy scene.
She missed out on the "Master and Commander" scene from which the doctor was accidental shot by the royal marine officer in the abdomen. Since the doctor was the only medically qualified person on board he had to carry out surgery upon himself to remove the metallic ball shot.
I loved that part especially when his mate said the piece of shirt on the ball would patch up quite nicely lol and he was also performing his own surgery using a mirror so everything had to been backwards
@@zoidbergler2058 the clothpatches being carried into the wound by the ball were a huuuuge risk for infection.
Most wounded during that area died due to infection and less because of the actual injury. And you could consider yourself "lucky" if an infected wound did just cost you an arm or leg.
@@Gilhadriel yea the guy told cpt Aubrey that the tiny piece of shirt would fester and kill the doctor if it wasn't removed from his belly that's when he started looking at the anatomy pictures in the book and getting woozy by illustrations of guts that's when Paul opted to do his own operation cuz his mate wouldn't know what he was doing digging for a ball in a person's abdomen and not loose the piece of shirt top
A very good vid indeed! I do have one gripe, though: you didn't do the scene from "Master and Commander", where Stephen Maturin digs a musket ball out of his own innards. I DO SO VERY MUCH WANT your reality score on this scene!!
Joke’s on the doctor, Wolverine’s rib cage is also made of adamantium (all his bones are), so he couldn’t cut through the diaphragm. Plus, he has a healing factor so he could survive, but cutting through the abdomen to the heart was his only way lmao 😂
Wouldn't the cutting instrument just have gotten stuck though?
Who knows?
The example was a poor use of time. When she didn't nerd out about the potential and technicalities about Wolverine, the producers and editor should have cut the whole thing.
I wouldn't blame her for that bit.
Edits exist.
I don't know why but this ER Doc is making my love parts tingle talking about stitching people up...
She clearly doesn't know how Wolverine is a comic book character that has self healing ability and an adamantium/vibranium skeleton. He had to go thru the diaphragm bcos he couldn't cut thru his ribcage.
It's adamantium vibranium is caps shield and wakanda shiz
you'd think they'd teach that in Med school
And she thinks he does a bunch of extra damage they would “have to fix later” lol
It’s still pretty unbelievable that someone could handle the pain of that procedure
@@thinkinyblinko6666 adamantium and vibranium are the same metal. It's a copyright issue again. Like how the MCU couldn't refer to mutants or mutations bcos that was X-men intellectual property. Like SHAZAM and Captain Marvel.
As a fresh civilian medic, this was nice to watch. The TQ, we had to have them applied to use during the program so we truly understand how tight it has to be, the first few mins, it's a very solid 9/10 pain but after awhile, you stop feeling anything.
Flatlined and still awake? WOLVERINE! I love you Jamie!
In the casino royals scene, it could be said that what he actually used was black pepper with water and that is known to cause nausea/vomiting on an empty stomach because it lowers the stomach pH even further and therefore induces retching under the right circumstances.
I'd love an explanation as to how black pepper (which is alkaline) and water (which is pH neutral) lowers the pH inside your stomach.
@@abasdarhon Black pepper is naturally acidic outside the body and, as you sarcastically imply, it does produce an alkalinizing effect inside the body once consumed…but only in small amounts…when you take an entire flask of black pepper, it overwhelms the alkalinizing properties of the pepper, trending towards acidity again and promotes stomach upset/nausea. At any rate, I could be wrong cause, last I checked, I’m just a random guy. So save the sarcastic quips for another forum.
If he grabbed pepper, it isn't shown, and the glass he drinks has no visible dark stuff in it. I think Bond was just trying anything he could think of to quickly get rid of any remaining poison.
@@freddiei.2696 First of all, black pepper (piper nigrum), is highly alkaline, not acidic. Introducing black pepper alone with or without water, whether a small amount or a flaskful, into the stomach, will absolutely not increase the acidity of the stomach; that is impossible.
Now, what could happen (I can't claim certainty on this since I've not experimented with it), is that the reaction of the strongly acidic stomach juices with the strongly basic black pepper could yield a product that irritates the stomach and help induce vomiting, but this would have nothing to do with "making the stomach more acidic". For instance, every first-year chem student knows that mixing HCl (hydrochloric acid) with NaOH (sodium hydroxide) yields water and salt...as well as a LOT of heat; I've personally had more than one test tube shatter on me from repeated heat stress while demonstrating this.
Secondly, I don't have a particular bone to pick with you, but after so many times of trying to explain to people how drinking lemon juice will not alkalinize your body, I tend to get irritated when encountering similar misinformation. I apologize if you felt personally attacked by my admittedly unnecessary sarcasm.
@@abasdarhon The point in your second paragraph is what I’ve been able to surmise talking to my patients about this query and to nutritionists that work around the hospital. Just empirical observations that I was able to draw, I apologize if my erroneous assumption struck a chord with you.
I put seven stitches in my lip using a mirror, bent sewing needle, fishing gut, and fishing forceps. So that is definitely realistic!
I did the same when I accidentally got stabbed with a freshly sharpened chisel.
Honestly, I can never think of a dislocated shoulder without thinking of Martin Riggs in Lethal Weapon slamming his shoulder into the wall to push it back in. It was done to show how "crazy" he was and but later became a tough guy thing, like in the scene with Faith.
Emergency tracheotomy tv's favourite surgery.
I would love to see her rate the scene in "Shooter" when he buys all his supplies at the store and fixes his wounds in the bathroom. And the scene from "A hitmans bodyguard" where Samuel Jackson extracts a bullet from his leg. 😁😁
Please good sir! Might we get another?? 😄🤩
Absolutely! Really surprised they didn’t do the Shooter scene.
I was hoping for Ronin myself, when Robert De Niro has to remove a bullet, with the help of Jean Reno holding the clamps.
A lot of these type of review shows always comment that in most cases removing the bullet isn't all that realistic unless it is causing an issue. The important thing is reduce bleeding. There are lot of people with bullets and other objects walking around with them still in them. Digging around for and pulling a bullet could cause more damage than just leaving it where it is. Not to mention without pain killers it would really painful.
Any of these would have been better than the Wolverine thing.
I can think of at least 3 scenes from House where they improvise surgery outside of a hospital. The first episode of Good Doctor too.
@9:19 - That is actually the only way to do this on Wolverine. You cannot go through his rib-cage because of the metal.
Context!
Wolverine was able to do his own surgery because as soon as he removed the invasive robot from his heart, his injuries would heal in seconds. The tiny robot was preventing his healing factor from functioning.
was wondering if she had seen the movie or was at all aware of the character lol judging that scene by real world standards it is of course stupid. but usually on these they will acknowledge that "this is not a normal human" and rate accordingly. she just seemed like she had no idea about his mutant healing abilities.
Good point about self stitching, it’s possible with out local aesthetic. I had to do it once on my hand, the difficult part is getting the needle up through the bottom of the skin to complete a loop.
Was hoping to see the Master and Commander surgery scene in this. One of my favorite self surgery scenes ever!
This is one of the best series' on the web, hoping for them eternally.
The audio in 127 Hours was so good, A.R.Rahman ❤
Should’ve reacted to some Rambo movies, like stitching up himself or using that fire to heal his wounds
Casino Royale: "Yep, that part's pretty realistic. And that's realistic. And that's reasonably true. I give it a three!" Do you want the actor to actually be poisoned???
Nice video as always
To be fair, you cant go through the ribs on wolverine because they're indestructable, so he had to cut though the squishy parts and would then just heal up once he got the thing that was killing him
I wish she had reacted to the martian, that always struck me as very realistic
Great selection of shows.👍🏽
It's such a doctor thing to call agony- or ya know, chopping your own arm off- "discomfort."
Go Jamie! OG strive to fit fam right here rooting you on!!
😎😎 I wish she can upload like she used to..but she’s busy now so
Bravo doctor and all around the world
4:45: "Chest compressions! Chest compressions! Chest compressions!"
- Dr. Mike
This lady is great! Her presentation style is PERFECT! She is so beautiful. It seems to me that her beauty comes from her soul; and from her soul came her skill, knowledge and wisdom which altogether led her into medicine, and her subsequent mastery of the art of the application of surgical medicine. If I was rushed into and ER, my life hanging by a thread, I would want this doctor to be working on me.
Ladies and gentlemen, this is what we call a simp.
Cmoon he is Wolverine… he is not human :)
On the 2009 Chilean earthquake all the windows were broken and ended up with god knows how many shards in my feet. Training was saying "don't pull them out" but my instincts overcame it.
I have had to do that too and I made a post commenting about it. I stepped on a broken bottle. Technically you should leave something in to reduce bleeding but I had to remove it so I could walk and drive to the hospital. It wasn't real deep either. I pulled a few pieces off, washed it off wrapped it up and went to the hospital. I probably should have called an ambulance but I am a bit of a moron lol.
I was disappointed to see that master and commander wasn't on this list
Thank you! Stephen pulling a bullet out of his guys was an excellent scene!
@@cleverusername9369 also why I know what superate means!
My grandfather always said that the first thing to do after having any kind of wound or burn was to just run it under clean water... Glad to hear such a simple thing is still considered so safe.
Excellent video and guest, aside from the Wolverine segment. Wolverine's bones are coated with adamantium, so going through his rib cage / sternum to access his heart isn't possible. He had no other choice than to go below it and reach up, and his mutant healing factor is the reason he's able to survive or stay conscious. That said, she's right, it IS totally unrealistic.
I was hoping to see the scene from The Martian removing the antennae! Such a cool video series.
did she really give Wolverine a 1/10 for saving his own life
That was enlightening 🙂
In all fairness, John Wick was running out of time before he was officially excommunicated to get help from the doctor, which is why he ends up having to stitch up the rest of the wound himself. He's on the run, hitmen are after him, so obviously the scene is gonna be rushed and sloppy because of that.
Too much time for fictional Wolverine, which is a superhero and self-healing and almost immortal.
I dislocated my knee and ankle sametime while in cabin no way to get to hospital. Got both back in place alone. Was tho really painful.
I popped out my shoulder once making a diving catch. Easily the second most painful thing I ever felt. As I was writhing on the ground, the rolling action popped it back in, which was the most relieving thing I ever felt. What I learned after is one you dislocate something, it’s more likely to get dislocated (in full or partially) in the future. I’ve subluxed that shoulder a few times since.
(Most painful thing I dealt with was the morning after ankle surgery. My pain meds completely wore off. We had to call my poor doctor at 6am to get stronger stuff prescribed to get it under control again.)
Lol did anyone tell her who Wolverine was before they showed her the scene? No need to worry about fixing damage later when your body automatically heals itself in a few moments. She's absolutely right in her analysis by the way, but didn't factor in that he was a nearly immortal mutant. Also he used a giant metal blade that popped out of his knuckle to cut himself. The whole scene was preposterous. Seriously though great job, Doc.
Well technically he didn't have his healing factor there, that was the point of opening his chest cavity and stopping his heart, to stop the bot that was somehow dampening his healing factor. Which by the way the movie never explained in a decent manner
Well mutants with healing factors aren't real
@@KingNerdius Maybe don't do react videos to non-real characters, then. I assume these are your videos, considering the amount of time you put "into them".
@@DaddyLongFeather you don't get the points of these videos do you
@@KingNerdius The woman specifically says "given (the character's) circumstances" regarding other characters than Wolverine. If she was consistent, either she would not take the character's circumstances into account in any of the examples or she would take into account the circumstances of all of the characters. It's okay if she doesn't know about Wolverine; that version of reality is not the end of the world you appear to be avoiding by justifying it.
ER Doctor: Yeah your heart is not in your abdomen
Me: Hmmm fair enough
Re: Die Hard and removing the glass - he's in the bathroom after getting away from bad guys! Where is he going to get tweezers? Being so literal about Logan doing self-surgery and how long it's going to take a person to heal? It's Wolverine, he has instant self-healing abilities.
Such a pretty nurse - 10 outta 10.
I believe (please correct me if i'm wrong) that 127 hours was based off a true story. The guy got his arm trapped, had tp amputate it himself, and managed to survive! The strength that humans can have is amazing.
Do-It-Yourself Surgery - Thats a book title 🤔
Chapter 1
"So, you've decided it's time for that triple bypass?"
They missed to Show her the scene in ronin with Robert de Niro and Jean Reno.
Best scene and i would say, most realistic.
I was thinking that too, hoping they would comment on it. Would imagine it'd get a high rating.
I would have loved to see her review the DIY surgery in "Ronan".
need her more
Check out her RUclips. The strive to fit. She has her journey documented since early medschool. It’s a pretty big channel. But she doesn’t upload as much because she’s busy. It’s like 1 video per month now.
that scene in 127 hours lives rent free in my head until now, i rather rewatch that caesar op in prometheus than this
As a veteran and having to have CLS multiple times and regular tourniquet practice and you have to tighten it with all your strength and that person will yell, scream, and sometimes hit you it hurts that bad especially on the thigh because you’re trying to constrict someone’s thigh to the point there not pumping out blood. It truly takes all your strength for a tourniquet to truly be effective on a friend, family, victim, soldier etc. I’m sure most medics can truly say that tourniquets need to be done with the right procedures if not you can hurt the victim more than saving them.
I'd love to see the last surgery from The Knick here
I was really hoping they would do houses self surgery!
Uuuummmm he's Wolverine!! He's a comic book character that has almost unrivaled regenerative and healing factor! It's a super hero movie. He's literally healed from being close to a small yield nuclear blast. Sooo yeah he could most certainly do that!! The giant metal claw coming out of his hand didn't give it away??!!!
dr jamie is an absolute dime. wow
the adorable level from her is soooooo high!!
I accidentally popped my elbow back in when I dislocated it. Worst pain I ever felt in my life. Very uncomfortable.
Yup. My shoulder pain was so bad the only thing that mattered was to get it to stop hurting. Nothing else existed at that moment.
this poor lady :( was doing sooo good. someone should have told her the reason Wolvie couldnt cut through his sturnum to reach his heart is because he has unbreakable adamantine laced bones so Logan HAD to go through the diaphram.
she had it on the rest ov it i think. i blame disney for taking the bteam avengers and launching them to simony
7:44 I think what you forget is that Wolverine has a healing factor. His body will heal itself, so he doesn't have to be careful with performing surgery on himself.
Wolverine have a healing Factor so once he gets the bug out he'll he'll no problem.
I've performed minor self surgery before. I had a chunk of glass imbedded under my skin so I had to cut a little bit and pick the pieces out with a pair of tweezers. Then pour peroxide over the wound. Then wrap it up. It was in an area with low blood flow so I didn't bleed a crapload but still enough.
The shoulder dislocations ik that feels and it’s very uncomfortable doc🤣😭and what she said in that whole section is true🫡
Great vid
Being a skateboarder, I've separated my right shoulder twice as well as my right hip. It definitely hurts, but one time my friend actually kinda drop kicked me and it popped back into place. Still sore but like 2 minutes later it was okayish. It sucks, but similar to being knocked out, once it happens, you kinda know what to expect. Ironically I never broke a bone but was once told it would have been better the bone in my left knee broke rather than tearing every ligament as I did.
Yay top 168 comments. Love this channel. Thanks for the new video. Best to all.
As a security guard (side job to support being a musician aha) I had to do the stitch by by myself at 5:25... thankfully not where an artery was, just a patch on my forearm after being stabbed in a liquor shop robbery gone wrong. No time to get to the emergency department at hospital... and I could've been waiting 2 hours or more.
So I got stitches from a family friend and did a running stitch myself. Yes, I've had professional medical training, more than just first aid. So a 3/10 score she gave him is a little harsh from my perspective. I think a 5 would've been fair. I do concede that Mr Wick was stitching up a wound near an artery and using a mirror. I didn't do that. It was one stitch that I used though, as I was losing a lot of blood by the second....
Might be uncomfortable means excruciating pass out pain lol
Two things with Wolverine/Logan going up under the ribs:
1) virtually indestructible adamantium skeleton makes it a whole lot harder to go with a more direct route.
2) mutation (superpowers lol) makes it so he can basically magically heal from any damage that doesn't outright kill him (not sure if he even can really be killed at that point in time)
I once had a surgery done in hospital on my pelvis. En they forgot to burn down a tiny bloodvessel. After a few hours home I got a bad swelling and was rushed to the hospital by my parents. I was out of concious a few times. When they opened up the swellig they said I lost 4 liter of blood. I was really lucky to get out of there with no damage at all. They just burned that vessel and stiched the old wound with 40 stiches and took me for observation for a few hours until my blood was at the normal pressure. The point the emergency docter sliced al the stiches of the surgery down to get to the wound all the 4 liter of almost clocked blood came out and all went over him. He never saw that coming.
Best self surgery scene IMO was Paul Bettany removing a bullet from his own chest in "Master & Commander".
Many years ago I was incredibly lucky with an injury that it didn't result in something FAR worse happening. I was rock climbing without a rope, and reached up to use a pebble as a hand hold, and as I pulled on it, my left shoulder popped out. I managed to stay, standing in balance while someone went to the top and rigged up a rope (Luckily, I was wearing my harness), and I clipped in and got lowered off. By then my shoulder had popped back in, but I certainly wouldn't have been able to complete the climb!