UN Security Council: Undemocratic, Non-Representative and in Need of Reform | Samir Saran
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- Roundtable on United Nations Security Council Reform | Shifting the Balance: Perspectives on United Nations Security Council Reforms from Global South Think Tanks |
On Thursday, 1 June 2023, the Permanent Missions of Brazil, India, South Africa, and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines hosted a Roundtable on Security Council Reform, with the aim to bring in the perspective of the Global South on the issue of Security Council Reform, keeping in mind the pressing urgency for a reformed multilateralism architecture in the United Nations representative of contemporary geo-political realities.
Leading think tanks and thought leaders from Brazil, India, and South Africa kickstarted an informal interactive discussion to generate ideas and identify new approaches to take the IGN process forward in a meaningful way.
Opening Remarks:
Ruchira Kamboj, Permanent Representative of India to the United Nations
Joao Genesio De Almeida Filho, Deputy Permanent Representative of Brazil to the United Nations
Contribution of Think Tanks:
Dr. Samir Saran, President, Observer Research Foundation
Gustavo de Carvalho, Senior Researcher, South Africa Institute of International Affairs
Matias Spektor, Professor of International Relations at FGV (Brazil) and Visiting Scholar at Princeton University
#UNReform #unsecuritycouncil #SamirSaran
Watch more from the playlist of Samir Saran: • #Flashback | ChinaTech...
Subscribe, follow and engage with us:
ORF RUclips: / orfdelhi
ORF Facebook: / orfonline
ORF Twitter: / orfonline
ORF Instagram: / orfonline
Raisina Dialogue Twitter: / raisinadialogue
Raisina Dialogue Instagram: / raisinaofficial
Raisina Dialogue Facebook: / raisinadialogue
Clear & concise, as always, Mr. Saran!
Samir is in the league of s jaishankar. He is top class when he says unsc was created in a way to keep the colonization gng .
He may be next FM of india
Mr Samir is a misguided individual. Beggars can't be choosers. Why is asking for UNSC for India with per capita income of less than 3K and loses to China in every war? Increase GDP to 25 K and develop military capability instead of buying weapons from money earned by low skilled laborers in the middle east.
I look forward to seeing where this conversation goes!
This was definitely a great discussion and hope this becomes some kind of force behind the restructuring of UN and it's various bodies.
It's difficult, Caz for restructuring it requires the approval from founding members, that won't happen..... only way to change it is to make a complete different new UN and demolish the old UNSC
It's difficult, Caz for restructuring it requires the approval from founding members, that won't happen..... only way to change it is to make a complete different new UN and demolish the old UNSC
It's difficult, Caz for restructuring it requires the approval from founding members, that won't happen..... only way to change it is to make a complete different new UN and demolish the old UNSC
It's difficult, Caz for restructuring it requires the approval from founding members, that won't happen..... only way to change it is to make a complete different new UN and demolish the old UNSC
It's difficult, Caz for restructuring it requires the approval from founding members, that won't happen..... only way to change it is to make a complete different new UN and demolish the old UNSC
Make a global south Block with India as base. Let all the countries who are not represented be part of the group. That is a big action than asking for change from the elite countries.
Scintillating Samir 👏
samir sir just a question on the side maybe you can ignore it but why do you say Issue as :is ssue" ???? is this some kind of tick you are giving to the whites?
❤best
All good, but then why not just leave the UN? We are the world’s most populous country now - we should lead and start a new grouping with Africa and Latin America and East Asia
New grouping for what ?
India still lacks economic and military might for that .
India isn't china as of now in econ.
Rt now focus on economy by increasing manufacturing. Rest is all talk.
I am permanent member of security Council International
Arunava Dasgupta and family
India 29.09.2023
All nations except the 5 permanent members should leave the UN and form their own organisation. The permanent members should be welcome to join - but without their vetoing power. ASAP.
UNSC has 5 permanent members: China, France, Russian, United Kingdom, and the US
Ten non-permanent members elected for two-year terms by the General Assembly (with end of term year):
Albania (2023)
Brazil (2023)
Ecuador (2024)
Gabon (2023)
Ghana (2023)
Japan (2024)
Malta (2024)
Mozambique (2024)
Switzerland (2024)
United Arab Emirates (2023)
This really is a joke. How can India not be in this group.
A corrupt country like india shouldnt have much power.Period.
Thanks i get new insight about , un as its was made because to continu colonial gang together and to make colonoalise ,,,, they i want to tell u some bitter but truth , one day un is going to demolished like league of nation , as need of hour reform is imperative and need of hour , yes to fulfill aspirations and dream of global south , africa asia representations in sacred UN
#india was offered twice ..once by usa and by ussr . Nehru chickened out in name of cold war and power politics. Even after indo China war nehru supported unsc for ccp china.
Lol. They were playing the game. You didn't understand. You should read about it in details.
@@IndiaTides what game?
@@brisingr12 Muh se bolke kuch nahi hota bhai waise to trump bhi bola tha permanant seat denge karke
bhai koi apna power kisi aur se kyun share karega nobody wants to share there power
aur jo seat unsc mein china ko mili vo tabhi PRC nahi tha Taiwan wala china tha
Nehru was a curse
BS !, UNSC was formed at the 1945 Yalta conference, two years before India gained independence.
Nobody listens if per capita GDP is less than 3K and the country wins 0 gold medals in Olympics and the industrial base underdeveloped. Increase per capita GDP to 15K and win 20 medals, UNSC will follow. Otherwise, anyone who listens to this plea will smirk and think what a waste of time.
#India should test atleast 5 meagoton thermonuclear bomb to end the drama of gandhigiri. And name the operation this time as operation narsimha .
Let the world powers get the msg that new pole has emerged .
A 5 trn $ economy of india should aspire to have megaton nukes.
Lets make you PM. Diwali will become fun again.
A corrupt country like india shouldnt have much power.Period.
We are 192 Nations and, Countries, and we like *Speakers Corner* in *London's Hyde Park.* We just speak, and *nobody implements our decisions.* We are *Speakers' Corner, no more, no less.* We just make speeches and then disappear. This is who you are right now.
*Mr. Maummar Gaddifi's Speech at the 2009 United Nations General Assembly*
...........................................
68 wars have been broken out since 1945.
*Is it common goal or in our interest.*
No not all, these are in *interest of one or two of these State that hold "Permanent Seats with "Veto Power"*
...........................................
We are not equally "Sovereign", in terms of "Preamble", of the Charter of UNO.
There is only the State of *China* which hold this Permanent Seat in the Security Council and that holds this post *being elected* in the UNSC through *Democratic Process.* All the rest of the four out of five are not elected through Democratic process, USA, UK, then USSR and France. There is no mention of criteria in the *Charter of UNO.*
Only criteria is *Supper Power.*
There must only be *a seat for the European 27 Countries.*
African Union, Latin America's Countries, ASEAN Countries, SADC 57 Islamic Countries and 118 "NAM, each must hold *One Seat in the United Nations Security Council* so that *a General Will of the People of the Nations/World for "PEACE" among 192 Nations/State could prevail for Long lasting, Durable, and Sustainable "Peace Mission", in accordance with the terms as enshrined in it*
UNSC mind set is old one .so its should changes as soon as possible others wise the unity of UNSC is far away from his duties
GOOD WORKING GOOD JOB GOOD ASSEMBLY GENERAL UNITED NATIONS UNSC BEST DIPLOMATS BEST FORCE UNITED NATIONS POLICE DETECTIVE INVESTIGATION SECRET SERVICE UNPOL GOD BLESS ALL AMÉN AMÉN AMÉN AMÉN ✍️🇺🇳🇺🇳💪✍️🇺🇳✍️👍✍️🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳💪🇺🇳✍️🇺🇳✍️🇺🇳✍️🤙
Wow. That's some plain talking.
All of you need to set a walkout. Im sack of the speeches.
✨🇵🇰🇲🇲✨I'm Singapore. In my opinion The United Nations should also give chance to #Failed #States like #Pakistan and #Myanmar to voice their views. Tho the existence of these 2 states are #Trivial to the planet and #Nuisance for the region but the "Stability & Peace" are things achievable only by Collaboration, not by Condemnation towards what they are!
by kg, singapore
MIGHTY(3) ARTICLE.APPLIED AMENDMENT DULY ESTABLISHED. THE TERM(4) IDEOLOGICAL SHIFT POLICY ADJUSTABILITY CLAUSE.