The Idea of Bharat is to Have Maximum Goodwill & Minimum Adversaries |Why Bharat Matters |Jaishankar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 июл 2024
- Why Bharat Matters Book Launch | Dr. S. Jaishankar's New Book | Embark on a journey into the heart of India's significance with the launch of Dr. Jaishankar's latest book, "Why Bharat Matters." Hosted by @orfonline, this event marks a powerful start to the new year. Dr. Jaishankar, renowned for his earlier release, "The India Way" (2020), continues to captivate audiences with his new book that picks up from where the first left off-why India is a civilisational power and its engagement with global forces and powers.
In Conversation:
Dr. S. Jaishankar, Minister for External Affairs, India (@MEAIndia @MEAIndiaFile)
Samir Saran, President, Observer Research Foundation
#BookLaunch #WhyBharatMatters #Jaishankar #SamirSaran #India #VishwaMitra #AmritKaal
Watch Related Video: • Launching 'Why Bharat ...
Don't forget to subscribe, like, and hit the notification bell to stay updated on more thought-provoking discussions.
00:00 - Launch Trailer
01:50 - Introduction and Acknowledgement
02:15 - Reason for Writing the Book
03:10 - Perspective on the Transformation of India's Foreign Policy
04:12 - Global Trends and Challenges
04:52 - Last 5 Years of Shocks and Events
05:31 - The Case for Reglobalization
06:11 - Strategic Autonomy and Economic Choices
06:47 - India's Role in the Global Workplace
07:12 - Atmanirbhar Bharat (Self-Reliant India)
07:44 - Policy Options and Focus Areas
08:39 - Transformations in the Last 10 Years
09:10 - Article 370 Decision
09:56 - About why Bharat matters
10:44 - Practical Choices and Operations
11:24 - Changes in the Last Decade
11:47 - India's Quest to be a "Vishwamitra"
12:10 - 2 Main Subjects Addressed in the Book
14:10 - How Bharat Impacts the World
15:36 - Book Inspired from Epic Ramayana
19:37 - Dr. S Jaishankar in conversation with Samir Saran
21:23 - Testing Powers and Lord Ram's Moments
25:35 - Analogies Between the Quad and the Ramayana
26:30 - India as Vishwamitra
28:24 - Discussion on Norms, Values, and Normative Foundations in the context of Ramayana and Mahabharata
29:14 -Dr. S Jaishankar on Global South
30:50 - Addressing Deviations from Principles and the Utility of Principles
31:30 - The Economic Message Throughout the Book
36:08 - Workplace Mobility
37:50 - Internal Constraints and External Actions in Foreign Policy
42:25 - Exploring "What If" Scenarios
45:50 - Impact of India's Choices in the Past on Present Relationships
47:16 - The Role of Young Diplomats in Today's Changing World
51:10 - From France Lakshman to India
52:23 - Relatability of India
57:06 - Vibhishana in Another Role
1:00:58 - Q & A
1:25:44 - Conclusion
Subscribe, follow and engage with us:
ORF RUclips: / orfdelhi
ORF Facebook: / orfonline
ORF Twitter: / orfonline
ORF Instagram: / orfonline
Raisina Dialogue Twitter: / raisinadialogue
Raisina Dialogue Instagram: / raisinaofficial
Raisina Dialogue Facebook: / raisinadialogue
![Sean Rii, Karyon, Sharzkii - Taungule [My Love] (Official Music Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eJoMuypbSzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
History will treat this Gentleman with golden words.
@@ShikharSrivastavathen why is he speak in English 😂
@Grow_Positive.
Being relevant to the times he lives in and also speaking theb anguage makes him propagate the ideas of Bharat to the world at large.
@FC-vp9ej No he isn't. He talk to point. Explains effortlessly and leaves. Also believes that Bharat should have Strategic Autonomy which is not liked by many in the west so...
@@FC-vp9ej
@@rx5241: Strategic Autonomy has to be earned. Which, unfortunately, Bharat has yet to achieve.
59:20 Vibhishan is actually very well respected all accross Shri Lanka.
Really grateful Sir to learn about the role of lord Laxman and assist to lord Ram for internal matter of Bharat as well as external environment for global good🙏
Dr jaishankar is my hero❤❤❤❤ like I am crazy obsessed with this guy
01:51 The book provides a perspective on the transformation of India's foreign policy.
05:00 Reglobalization is needed for strategic autonomy and global workplace
10:34 The idea of Bharat is to have the maximum goodwill and minimum adversaries
13:08 Exploring the impact of historical perspectives on modern-day international relations
18:30 Inherited wisdom and civilizational power are important for Bharat
20:42 Bharat's contemporary politics related to Ramayan
24:48 Coalition building for broader connections and convergences
27:03 Diplomacy aims for maximum goodwill and minimum adversaries
31:34 Need for national economic policies and global partnerships
33:50 Opportunity in global workplace and resilient supply chains
38:15 Post-independence, India fell short in various socio-economic indicators compared to other countries.
40:31 India's growing influence will result in a mix of responses from other countries.
44:57 Sadar Patel's view on America and foreign policy
47:05 India's growing influence and presence in the global arena
51:33 India's emergence and foreign policy explained through Indian experiences and epics.
53:36 Embracing traditions and culture evokes goodwill globally
58:08 Vishan's role in modern contemporary times
1:00:24 Importance of making the right judgment and being empowered through information.
1:04:57 India and Norway as bridge builders
1:07:25 India strives to have maximum goodwill and minimize adversaries.
1:11:53 Building self-belief and utilizing strengths in diplomacy
1:14:13 The impact of AI era on privacy, security, and business
1:18:47 Economic and strategic choices need to be linked.
1:21:16 India's position in geopolitics and global transformation
1:25:51 Importance of punctuality and gratitude
bhai thanks a lot 😎
How u made timestamp? Used AI?
Good job my compliments🤌🏼.
Dr Jayshankar is a fascinating guy. Having said that, he is also a master of hiding his intentions. I have never seen anyone this good.
Sanjay you ask good questions. How greater would you be if you were able to resist the temptation to "complete" Dr Jaishankars sentences. It's a learning for all Indians including me.
Your the Boss in the history of Diplomacy of Bharat 🥰
Fan of S.Jaishankar spread this book launch video like wildfire..
7:17 Well said. To realize Atmanirbhar Bharat, it is first of all important to be Bharat.
S. Jaishankar sparked a great deal of interest on foreign policy among the general public, particularly among youth.
How has Bharat become Atamabirbur inn the last decade when 81 crore Indians can not feed themselves without taking charity of 5 Kg grains. Bharat has become a nation of hungry people.
@@pardeeptandon You failed to get his point. Yes, Bharat has still poor people but what about a large section that is continuously being uplifted since independence. If I am not wrong, even UN in its report acknowledged the change.
You will miss out on what Bharat accomplished with perseverance if all you think about is what she hasn't been able to achieve. Self criticism is good with a comprehensive picture.
@@sumandutta4834 he is spamming all through the comments section
I only hope, this way of Bharat, defininf ourselves from ohr history and philosophy and not some external one, i hope it's not just a temporary phenomena for a political party, but a long lasting change in Indian policy and society
the one and only JAISHANKAR.
He is guru …hats off…all time I see and listen to him ..I feel hungry to get more and more from him…I wish If I would have worked under him
if India grows whole world will grow. coz we believe good for all being. world is family.
Great 🙏✨
We have the best interpretation of Ramayana and Mahabharata relevance on present day politics.
What I am going to write here it may not be accurate but believe me when you read you feel sorry for few . If anyone who is not Hindu sanatan can't understand any theme of diplomacy directed by Jaishankar sir. Finally what a lovely timing to introduce the Book. JaiSriRam JAIHIND Vandematram
I love Dr jai❤
We solemnly constituted it, yes.
Great to listen to the minister once again.
About the lessons to learn from vibishan's episode. Rama's ideology is to accept anyone who surrenders unconditionally. Vibhishan knew the virtues of Lord Ram and he knows that he is avatar of vishnu. Hence he surrendered himself to Ram.
Hanuman told Ram that he can be accepted. But Rama already made his mind that he has to accept Vibishan because he surrendered. Rama just wanted know what others have in mind.
Lesson for India is, if a country comes to us for help despite being an ally to an enemy nation, India should help. Our nature should be to save/help only. If that country again gains strength and help our adversary, we will fight against it.
Grt episode ORF
I should read that book
The book captures the essence of the awakening and the re emergence of BHARAT 🇮🇳as a thriving civilisational rashtra in a rapidly transforming world 🙏🏼
Of late the world has started looking down on Bharat.
Thanks Sanjay, Sameer and Kapish. You and your team is the true trademark of #Bharat that matters.
Others e.g. #ANI completely failed to bring the true essence of this book in their interview with EM HE Jaishankar.
ANI's interview was more of a general interview of EAM on India's foreign policy with some mentions of the book, but Sameer's was completely focused on the book and its themes and subjects.
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Great to see ORF inviting students for such an important discussion. However, it is also important to see that most of the comments are from Bharatiyas...how is ORF increasing its viewership beyond that and S Asia?
Epic intro music .. I must say
🕉️
Fine production for filtering with microw level is Scaning of every defalt after clearing all the Doubts after Pekege Process" and Satisfaction of Boths with Consumers"
SAB SE AAGEY HONGE HINDUSTANI YEH BAAT HAI SAB NE MAANI
Only Andh Bhats NE MAANI
Always a pleasure to listen samir
I would go to the time of reformation of the society or religion or whatever it is!
Where I found your book free to read because it's costly for me as students....😊😊😊
Minimum adversaries should not come at the expense of selling your foreign policy to other countries.
We have all adversaries around and we do not really have friends in neighbour hood.The non alignment which is as good as Nonsense alignment is the root cause of the same.
Our foreign policy since independence is a net zero sum game approach, neither we have developed the deep relationships needed nor the muscle power to send a proper message.
This foreign policy also denied India the Western technology and capital which helped other Asian countries to become developed countries.
With our visionless leaders all around who are more interested in their families than the country, it is a long way to go achieve the required standing in the world.
What about Rafale or Eurofighter typhoon from Germany? For maritime?
We have both options.
What would you like to have?
We can have from Germany for relationship issue as well as france is also our very good friend! Both are very good aircraft in their type of aircraft!
Our navy isn’t deploying tejas due to the cost.
So for the indo pacific ocean our navy is getting more warship/ destroyer/ battleship or even aircraft carrier Hopefully for increasing the number of presence
May be not really!I like to think and arguing! When we argue with facts science or on based on the truth then it can even be go against what we believe : )
Ramayan also symbolizes victory of medical ethics:
Sushen Vaidya was Royal head doctor (Raj Vaidya) of Ravan. During Lanka War Laxman was attacked with Shakti Astra (power weapon) by Ravan’s son Meghnath (Indrajeet). Laxman was on throes of death & there was no vaidya in the Ram's Army who knew its antidote. Then it was suggested by Vabhishna to bring Sushen Vaidya from Lanka's Rajmahal. Hanuman brought him from Lanka but Sushen invoking his royal duty & patriotism refused to treat his country’s enemy saying if forced to treat, he would cause more harm to Laxman.
Ram tells Sushen that Lord Dhanwantri has bestowed his power of healing on the physician & this power flows from the divine trust bestowed between the physician & the patient. Ram said he would stand by this divine trust & Sushen has to choose between conflict of his two dharmas: Raj dharma & physician's Dharma. If he chooses Royal dharma he would be returned with respect, dignity & apology back to Lanka. Sushen chose Physician’s dharma over Royal dharma. The arguments at the battlefield are a treatise on Medical Ethics.
Hanuman was then given impossible task to bring Sanjeevani herb grown on Dronagiri mountain of Himalayas by sunrise. Hanumaan got boon of becoming Sankat Mochan of devotees for completing this difficult task & ending monumental tragedy faced by Lord Ram in his human avatar.
After treating Laxman with Sanjeevani, Sushen demanded mountain Dronagiri to be placed back in Himalayas as these life-saving herbs are for entire mankind & can grow only there. This was very important directive. True to our heritage, India supplied life saving Covid vaccines to over 125 countries many on priority basis & free of cost while the western multinationals raked in huge profits taking advantage of the crisis.
After the Lanka War, Vaidya Sushen settled to practice in the Kaushal Kingdom of Ram’s mother Kaushalya which encompasses present day Raipur. There is a temple of Vaidyaraj Sushen in Chandkhuri village 27km from Raipur where Sushen settled. Sushen Temple must become pilgrimage Center and Call of Conscious Center for all those involved in the treatment of mankind.
Unfortunately, we failed to follow the human values you have referred to? Why ? Are there flaws in our culture?
@@pardeeptandonRemember what George Orwell, the famous British author & journalist born in Bihar during British-India time wrote : “The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history.”
According to French political scientist Christophe Jaffrelot successful modern democracies have adopted Cultural Secularism: relegating theological aspects of the religion to the private sphere & conjuring of the faith as a political identity marker in the public sphere.
In Western liberal democracies, the state is Christian but the government pursues secular policies. The religious head of Church of England is also Member of Parliament & parliamentary proceedings begin with a Christian prayer.
The ruling parties in Germany & Australia call themselves Christian Democratic Union & Christian Democratic Party.
Philosopher Edmund Burke in Reflections on the Revolution in France declared that to be human is to inherit a culture whose moral values must be preserved.
India is now rising because it is learning difference between national identity & secularism. The people of India have rightly kicked out pseudo-secularists. The core identity of India is based on Hinduism and Indian nationalism & secularism comes naturally to most Indians because of this core identity.
Universal Power God is Bhartiy Indian is for all the information frome Bharat spreding for not universally ?
If you want to define bharat? Also define its geography which mentions Shaktipeeths and Jyotirlings, Bharat territory goes from the Himalayas in the North and the Indian Ocean in the south, up to Afghanistan in the west and south East Asia in south east, also Tibet can be added there because there are Jyotirlings there too are there?
Kon kon upsc aspirant hai
LlvE LMK issues Good morning sir 👑 🇦🇪 🇮🇳 PM me shieej shi to you Goodwill 🎉🎉🎉 Mixture sixteen
I wonder how the Minister gets time to write.
Samir ranting without concluding sensibly!
I have not read this book. But I will give in writing, until u dont have the co operation of people within your country, here I mean the opposition, your progress will be limited. Your outreach will be limited. Real success makes even disbelievers bow down
India has never ever had full internal cooperation during its history for the last 1000 years and that shaped what India became. India is now trying to make its move irrespective of that internal contradiction. George Washington did the same in the founding years to foster today's US and only on becoming what the US became in 1900s, did it try to heed your suggestion of adopting and practicing catchwords and phrases of the developed Western societies. You cannot be nice to everyone when your means are limited...hazarding an attempt in that direction is a sure way to disasters.
The opposition is moronic. Cant expect them to cooperate. Any company is as good as its ceo. Same with congress. Untill the fool rahul and his family steps away fully, no hope for better opposition
@@harishramachandran2324 u mean murko ka sardar 🤣🤣🤣 I learnt one thing. Never hate and dont underestimate. He cannot do what PM Modi has done. But some of the stuff he says is true. What is the opposition 's true intention, that even I dont know
In the past century, the Gandhi/Nehru family has made significant contributions to India. The family's iconic figure offered his grand residence in Allahabad to serve as the Congress party's office in the fight against the British. Nehru, his son, spent nine years in jail advocating for independence. As Prime Minister, he laid the groundwork for modern India, establishing our constitution, democracy, steel plants, IITs, IIMs, space and atomic research centres, canals, and dams, among other accomplishments. His daughter triumphed over our archenemy on the battlefield, taking 90,000 Pakistani soldiers as prisoners and dividing Pakistan to create Bangladesh. She lost her life as PM of India while combating terrorism. Her son, Rajiv Gandhi, ushered in the telecom revolution, positioning India as an IT superpower and enabling digital progress. He also sacrificed his life in the fight against terrorism. Sonia Gandhi declined the opportunity to become PM, allowing the esteemed economist Manmohan Singh to take the role in the national interest. Today, Rahul Gandhi, after completing a 3500 km "Bharat Jodo Yatra," is opening a "Mohabat Kee Dukan," supporting the underprivileged. Over the past 32 years, no member of this family has sought personal gain from a governmental position. We need more families like the Gandhi family, rather than those like the Sang family. The true tragedy is the leader who has left 82 crore Indians reliant on a 5 kg grain charity, placing India at 111 out of 121 countries on the World Hunger Index, a worse standing than the struggling nation of Pakistan.
Ruling over you is never Ruling by God by as ours Transportation and traffic controll and Systems is devoloping by even ourselves butt not God because it is a orderly system needed required and utilizes " are awareness of Human's intelligences " are ato part of Creator's creation of a Human and his Survival in any condition confident after your's accuracy and His extentions " onle Mottos is Only Your Selfe personal" mottos of destroying What ? Is only not your selfe "
BJP must encourage foreign languages study. We need experts on various countries. To play a bigger role and first hand information,not just translators
India would love to be mediator in polarised world but western countries ego will always be in way too progress until they broke up economically in next 20+ years.
For whom this book is for? If he is getting insights being MEA why he does not publish book through NBT or at affordable prices. Mr. Jaishankar, Im disappointed with this publication. Please make book affoddable for massess. 🙏
Dr. Jaishankar is wrong about his definition of Nehru. Dr. Jaishankar says just 'ERROR',he should have actually told 'BLUNDER'
Perish se Nehru ke kapde Dhulay after Presh hokar aeroplane se india aata ttha meaning is what ?
Discussion Series | Dr. Jaishankar’s Why Bharat Matters ruclips.net/video/T86-HvzNots/видео.html
Should have allowed more time to audience to interact instead of going on for 20 plus minutes saying this is my last question. It’s like politician who doesn’t want to give up microphone.
Their's Karan iff wibhishan and concept of was only Truth about butt not lie supportive,
Vishva guru to vishva mitra 😂😂😂
The host comes across as very cocky. Show some humility dude…
They are both friends
srilanka ,nepal , maldives , bangladesh ..are now in the lap of china ..and bangladesh allowed china to use its port ..thanks to ur exemplerory performance as mea .
They all are Vibhishans.
Koyi vee jeew jantu ya terrorists kavee marna nahin chahta hai prantu virous of Body's is essential of cleen firstly after with your Good health and with freshe mindset doo next jobe for your good environment healthier for your livings surrounding " kinds of virous some supportive some nutral, some or viroul for deses creation,
China Pakistani ruling honors not Horny abbility saandh power have he" have to serve you only as name of just Indian part is part of china and his national emotional fights has he needs to fighting continue " is past to latest only psychology boundary made feare with Milittry power over, butt wee are aware brfore theme's next stapes,
To be precise- Hanuman ji is a half human and half monkey king. When referring to him shouldn’t we call him that ?
Better still call him Vannar as he is in original Ramayan. Simply means forest dweller and not a different species.
During the Manmohan Singh Decade, our GDP expanded by 2.83 times and GDP per capita by 2.5 times, whereas Modi only achieved 1.67 times. Our government debt to GDP ratio doubled during the Modani era. Thus, who was more beneficial for the Indian economy?
There is something called the Base Factor !!! 😂😂😂
@@VermaRajinder: Base factor is potent when you compare quarterly or yearly results less so when you are comparing results of a Decade.
@@pardeeptandon crossing natural growth in to the realistic and hardwork is called true changes in governance. And also you forget that spring get more tightened when you want to press it more than a certain point. 🤝👍🙏
Dude in statistics there is a fundamental called the base effect. The world (wherein every country faces music) underwent radical changes in the last 5 years especially. Use analytical thinking when you parse numbers
@@debashisganguly4738: Excuses !!!!
Nawabi Culture is withought risk butt only enjoying a kingdom of Nawab " problems of people's is no his headache,
Whenever politics interferes with governance, the country and society suffer. Pakistan has experienced this, and it has become a troubled state, while Bangladesh has managed to avoid such issues and has thrived. Is the BJP attempting to turn India into a Hindu version of Pakistan? There are numerous versions of the Ramayana; which one are they referring to?
Were the Hunter Kings referred here to as Vegetarians?
Kabhi usa or china ki padhi hai books ya wo kha se inspiration lete hai Plato Socrates aristotal kon hai fir 🤔 kabhi kuch padha bhi hai bharat ka ya bas Gaali dena aata hai bas 😊
@@mayankindian3750: Rather than giving a lecture, try contradicting my points logically.
@@pardeeptandon me logical hi baat kar rha hu 🙂
@@mayankindian3750: The Western world today dominates the world because they read and followed Socrates & Plato while we have become one of the poorest nations of the world following our outdated traditions.
@@mayankindian3750: You have failed to give a logical reply to the issues raised by me.
हिंदी में नहीं बोल सकते क्या वोट मांगते समय तो हिंदी में बोलते हैं😂
This interviewer is terrible, confusing
Earlier under this same FM we had step by step answers to all the questions raised by detractor recently, this has gone more comic commando and rhetorical e.g. why India's ranking gone down in many parameters the answers from our foreign office is wanting like we are vishwa guru and look at others and u and all nonsense whatabourty. this can fool gullible public in India not outside
If you choose to be gullible and live in your echo chambers that’s entirely your choice🛑
@@gopalramanathan7062again rhetorical and just shows who is gullible
Why don't you listen to lectures on this exact topic of foreign rankings on India and their parameters by Sanjeev Sanyal. He has explained it very well and also written a paper on it. He explains in detail how these parameters are designed, i.e. their methodology, how it is based completely on opinions by certain unknown persons and no objective data.
ruclips.net/video/20UZfX2xx1Q/видео.htmlsi=yQGqKl6HNUAoMC-r
Look at the above lecture. You'll get your answers.
Please please say tamil and telugu kings not monkey kings
They have names and dynasties, kings, kingdoms, human problems, and the armies, rama came with just 2 persons and 1 was kidnapped and you are a fool to believe he communicated with monkeys because a 14 th century writer wrote about the people in the history happened before 10000 years , he thought, vanaras means monkeys actually vana means forest nara means human forest human and rama came from the gangetic plains thats might the reason he called them as vanaras , you see the name of legend, its hanuman, what are normal tamilian names in history & today end with, raghavan, kannan, kannadasan , hariharan, karikalan, and see the name of story itself, its ramayan tell me another epic ends like that and before 10k years adi dravidas have bigger mouths , if you visit the tamil villages. Still you can observe it on their faces. Kashi tamil sangamam is a first step, Full integration will happen, only when you accept and change this part of ramayan. My advice to all bharatiyas to propagate this.
10,000 years? Where did you get that number from? Why is Lord Hanuman still depicted as half human half monkey? Change Ramayan?
First like, first comment!
Why did the US president decline to be the Chief Guest at our Republic Day Parade? Why did Xi Jinping not attend the G-20 Summit in Delhi? Why did no nation criticize China when they occupied our Territory? Why did the US not invite India to the Table when they were withdrawing from Afghanistan? Why has discrimination against Hindu employment in oil-rich ME countries begun? How has our trade deficit exponentially increased in the last decade? How has today's GDP Per capita of Vishva Guru India become less than that of Bangladesh in the previous decade? How has our debt-to-GDP ratio become equal to that of Basket Case Pakistan?
Since you believe that asking many questions is a sign of a well-read mind, extend the compliment to others like the undersigned. Answer 1: Because the US wants India to allow it to host and nurture social pests like Pannu (who is believed to be part of the CIA) .. Answer 2: Because the western block doesn't care and in fact their leader (US) wanted China to teach India a lesson which attributed to China's belligerence in the 60s which resulted in Akshai Chin annexation. If suddenly the US speaks for development in Ladakh area, India today is smart enough to remind the uncle of its role in the 60S... Answer 3: Because it was US discretion to leave Afganisthan high and dry unilaterally with disregard to regional security concerns, as it aids its weapons industry... Answer 4: To the extent that I understand that an important oil-rich MEA country is inaugurating a Hindu temple .. appreciate your newfound concerns for Hindu rights by the way, which has nothing to do with religion anyway... Answer 5: Because India is still not a manufacturing hub although our domestic demand has increased manifold due to the current upswing in the economy. So, the emphasis on programs like Make in India, PLI schemes, etc... Answer 6: "Today's GDP" yet "previous decade"... not sure if your mind is working. Anyways allowing room for dissent, it's apt to say consider the 2 numbers on PPP terms (hopefully you know the merit) and also wait patiently till the 2030s if you are adamant about ignoring PPP and huge economic disparities among states in this huge landmass.... Answer 7: First of all, you should compare India with its global peers on which metrics India is very favorably placed. I will help with the data source (so that you may factor in the possibility of me being a bhakt/chaddi/khaki etc - worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/debt-to-gdp-ratio-by-country). But knowing that your thought pattern will argue about your case point (Pakistan vs India) I can only politely remind you that the majority of external debts in Pakistan emanate from its iron-brother China - who are not exactly known for data transparency. In simple words, external debt data for Pakistan is a black box and secondly please be informed that it's the ability to pay external debt that matters more to the lenders. I think you are convinced that Pakistan has a bigger ability than India. Best of luck to your theoies
@debashisganguly4738: Reply 1: The United States has rebuked India for allegedly using RAW to attempt the murder of Pannu, an American citizen in America. If Pannu had violated any laws in India or America as a civilized nation, the proper course of action would have been to follow the law and ensure prosecution rather than acting as a Vishva Guru (world leader). Reply 2: Even if we entertain the hypothetical theory that in the 60s, China annexed Aksai Chin at America's behest, it isn't easy to believe that America currently supports the Chinese occupation of our territory in Ladakh and Arunachal. But still, it did not criticise China for doing so. Furthermore, why did Xi Jinping decline to attend an international conference in Delhi if not to snub India? Reply 3: America invited several regional countries, including Pakistan, to negotiate its withdrawal from China. Consequently, India was not considered a regional power by America. America seemed more concerned about Pakistan's security than that of India. Why is India purchasing weapons from America if it only serves their interests? Are we being taken advantage of? Reply 4: The lynching of Muslims in India and the daily Hindu-Muslim debates in our media have led to restrictions on employment for Hindus in the Middle East. The magnanimity of the rulers of Dubai allowed the construction of a new temple. Temples and Sikh Gurudwaras have existed in Dubai for decades. Reply 5: During Manmohan Singh's tenure, our GDP grew 2.83 times and GDP per capita by 2.5 times, while under the current government, it has only grown 1.67 times on both accounts. Point 6: In 2021, the GDP per capita of Bangladesh was $2621, while India's was $2389. In 2014, they were 40% behind us. I know the term "PPP" and am not ignoring it or falling for the promises of 2030 or 2047. Point 7: The debt-to-GDP ratio determines the ability to pay, and today, this ratio is comparable for India and Pakistan. The IMF has recently projected that this ratio for India will reach 100% by 2025. Debt worldwide is repaid in cash or in kind. Pakistan is adept at doing this and has often done so at the expense of our security interests. I come from a family who came as refugees from Pakistan and have no love for Pakistan. Still, I am worried that our economy is being pushed into a rat hole by the plutocrats who have hijacked our democracy.
pradeeptandon - Dont be lazy and do your homework yourself next time.
Few friends were kind enough to guide you with detailed replies to your questions, sounds like a frustrated rant.
@@pardeeptandonEither you are blind or deaf, so I do pity you. As you are unable to comprehend the economic growth we saw in last 5 years! Do comparisons to what you saw in India before and now. Whether it’s infrastructure or toilets or food grains to poor or digital growth or more opportunities for eligible ! I can go on and on. I guess you will quote the European think thanks survey ! So I do not blame you for the myopic views you posted in all your messages in this chat !
So he wants one party rule😅😅😅
Patting one's own back is all we can do. Something like this ought to have been authored by a foreigner to be worth anything.
You are from the old school that needs western approval stamp.. like rahul gandhi who goes to US Uk chatham house stamp..time to write our own destiny!!
@@TheKarmicExposures but we don't need self approval also lol
@@gururajnarer9469 To be a global power even in global south, we need to think like one. Have you ever seen US /Chinese Analysts think low of themselves.
@@TheKarmicExposures: They do not need to think low about themselves as the world recognises their achievement and is aware that 60 % of Indians are surviving on charity of 5 Kg Grains.