REACTING TO UNQUALIFIED MUFTI
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Salam alaikum brothers & sisters. You can contribute to our day to day costs of travel and other camera and editing expenses by donating to www.gofundme.com/askthesheikh
May Allah swt Mercy & Blessings be upon you all.
![Tee Grizzley - Robbery 8 [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/34_vkNV6wrU/mqdefault.jpg)
These comments are actually making me angry.. Like is everyone watching a different RUclips from me and not seeing what imran and his team are doing ???? Like I'm mad confused. These little boys think that they have all knowledge and portray nothing but ignorance, showing attitudes that they know everything and are 'the rightly guided' (idc if this has not been uttered out of their mouths, this is the portrayal) for all those calling it 'petty etc' why don't you understand that they are misguiding so many ? These guys have no qualification and think that they have the authority to refute everyone and everything ! I am overly happy that Ali is addressing it. May Allah reward him and keep him with the rightly guided. Ameen. Like imagine Imran sat in one of his vids exposing people from the dawah scene talking about how they all participate in sinful lives and acts, creating suspicion and trying to paint himself in a positive light. Do people not see the manipulation and falsehood ? Wallah maybe people don't get the effects these people have but they do!! And it's time for someone to shut them down. I get Ali's passion, which was veery evident in the video. It's not about Sheikh Haitham, it's about EVERYTHING! Perhaps this was a video to address it with the most passion. Kudos to you Akhi for addressing it ! 🙌🏽
100% sister. remember people dawah man(wallahi used to respect this brother) is the same guy that slandered haitham saying he was agreeing with Shia scholars and he is misguided. and he has effectively been refuted by adnan rashid.
I agree with you 100% how can imran and his team try to mock a shiekh and try tell people he's a liar when he's been practicing for years. How dare they and who gave them the authority to do this. They have no qualifications to talk about things like voting. They have misguided loads of muslims. May Allah guide them
hussain thomas they pick and choose from the Quran and Sunnah. Yes agreed they use quotes etc, however in a very manipulative way. The Quran and Hadeeths isn't simplistic like many try to make it out to be, it's take years to study and has more than one meaning. Yes Imran maybe the same age as Ali but Strydez, (he doesn't even look like he's hit puberty and his name in itself conveys immaturity) Abu Bakr are not. Ali doesn't give out Fatwas etc because he isn't anyone to do so, he hasn't dedicated years of studying with the best just like these brother haven't thus shouldn't bring out videos like that where hey refute people who have Subhan'Allah
must afa akh he sat there and spoke about guys committing Zina, adultery etc like it's nothing ? When these are one of the worse sins to commit. He basically said in the video that anyone he's disconnected with has done those things, so there was me thinking rah Ali done this, Musa, Adnan Rashid etc did this. It definitely is done in a manipulative way because he tried to paint himself in a positive light. I watched it throughly, don't block the hidden messages, we can all feel some type of way about Bidah etc however exposing one sins is also of a great evil. Like Nouman Ali Khan said, whenever there comes a discussion of the Quran and Hadeeths he keeps his mouth shut because that's how complicated it is to study it and this is someone who has studied for years especially in regard to the matters discussed by them. There's a reason why the revelation came to the Prophet pbuh at the age 40 and not 20. They talk about stuff that is beyond them, and I stand by what I said. Like shown in the video they use the Quran, fatwas, quotes and Sunnah to their own advantage I definitely used to respect dawah man a lot and often watched him for inspiration however due to recent videos I no longer hold those feelings. There's enough Hadeeths that explains people like them.
Abdurahman Omar same I did too. It's a shame he changed so dramatically Subhan'Allah. May Allah guide him. Ameen
The difference between this channel and Imrans is that every point Imran says he uses evidences from the salaf and never interprets anything on his own but uses the interpretations of the Prophet and Sahaba and the rightly guided. You can refute in the manner Imran presents his videos but you cannot refute the evidence he brings, in the end Fear Allah and his punishment and May Allah guide all of us and forgive our sins
Akh Hassan yuppp
Exactly.
🤣 based on who, unless he transported back in time to ask those Blessed people. If not, he's still taking views..either his own or someone else's..that's why there's Ijma. That's how narrow minded our people have got now, they can't make simple distinctions.
@@sabar2453 these people claim salafi are khawarij. They make muslim blood halal to kill bc tbey are salaf and purist so whatever they say goes
hassan :D please can you send the link I would like to follow the brother
At first I just thought the brother in the top left corner was just a translator for the Sheik through hand signs LOL
amreen shaju 😂
amreen shaju sameeeeee❤️😂😂😂
😒😒 🤣😂
ruclips.net/video/g_oLLe6n_l8/видео.html
Ramadhān Mubarak guys, I hope you're all having a lovely day. May Allāh bless whoever reads this and grant them happiness and the highest level in Jannah ☺️
(I post this so people don't get lost in the midst of all this negativity that's being spread around especially in the month of Ramadhān)
Rami Ali are you Ramiroo Ali
+Rami Ali ,Ameen YRA. Thank you for the well wishes and positive thoughts for us :) May Allah Bless you and your family and keep the ummah tight as a whole.
I'm eagerly waiting for the marriage documentary!!!
Muna Umran its a personal matter, so stop it.
maybe we should just let it go now aha
Muna Umran u shouldn't be asking for it because you are a female
by the time its out he will be divorced
ghulam hazrat How did you figure that one out. Marriage is for all! (Men + women of course) 😂
As salam u alaikum guys. My job is to give Dawah and defend Islam, but sadly the oppression and slandering being done can not be ignored. Even tho I have every right to make this public as the sin was done in public, I private messaged brothers kindly asking the video to be removed but it was declined. So let this be reminder to us all to stick to our lanes and not mock and insult people of knowledge. May allah swt grant you all jannah.
Ali what your doing isnt making sense bro. You acting like they are themselves giving out fatwas. You acting like they themselves are giving thier own interpretation of the Quran and the Hadith. If you actually watch their videos you will see that not even one opinion they give is their own. They ALWAYS refer back to the scholars and the sahaba and the Prophet peace be upon him JUST as you would if discussing a matter. If you watch their videos you would know this which actually makes me doubt if you are even watching them properly. And also you need to drop this attitude of 'oh they are young'... so? does that mean they cant quote from scholars? I would rather listen to a young brother quoting from scholars than blind follow someone who isnt giving and proof/evidences just based on the fact that he is older....
Ali, you're contradicting yourself, you're slandering and mocking this brother who makes more sense than you do.
Ali Dawah ameen jazakAllahu kheyr
فقط المسلمين الحقيقيين فهم العربية
your immature, this is clearly personal
lol its mad how the "dawah" scene on yt has now become entertainment rather than beneficial. Its best if you ALL just hop off RUclips and get a day job. Embarrassing much 😭
Moeyy Lol I remember when these videos were genuinely about trying to help the muslims to become better individuals. It's sad that these videos are about refuting one another and gaining followers and fans to help fuel the fire
Moeyy Lol lol
Moeyy Lol I think they do have day jobs
Neither make money off RUclips I think. They have no ads enabled.
Lol, perhaps an interesting question is whether these youtubers are getting paid for their videos through ads or anything
I agree 100% Ali. I hate these type of muslims who throw away the word 'kufr' to others like its meaningless. It's very very haram to call another muslim kufr
Saying that something is (an act of) kufr, is not the same as calling someone a kafir. Comitting kufr doesn't necessarily make one a kafir. Btw I'm not justifying anything the brother said, I just wanted to clear things up regarding that matter.
.+awt BB
Wrong. Accursing someone of committing kufr *is* _exactly_ the same as accusing someone of being a kaafir. The word 'kufr' means 'disbelief' - the word 'kaafir' means 'disbeliever'. If you claim someone disbelieves, or does not believe, you are calling them a disbeliever.
You may not be justifying what he (and others) have said, but still abstain from giving them excuses to use.
P.S. To accuse someone of kufr is (almost always) interchangeable with/the same as accusing someone of shirk. It is *not* a light accusation to be brushed off a person's shoulder with ease - the problem so many in our (Muslim) community forget. Throwing around the word is very, very dangerous.
Once you accuse someone of something as grave as kufr, there are two possibilities: they are right, and you are wrong - or you are right, and they are wrong. One of you will be leaving the fold of Islam.
Spoderman you hate 'the actions of those muslims' and not the Muslims themselves.
Spoderman same as you
+awt BB is correct aki
salaam,
meet and talk the issues with each other instead of sending for each other on youtube.
barakAllah feekhum
debate what. Would you debate a 5 year old
Never said debate i said talk or discuss like adults if both parties disagree then khalas
0121_ R.K exactly ! thats what I thought straight away. yust talk with eachother. you are borthers in Islam. this can be dealed different in sha Allah
0121_ R.K totally agree with that
Ali you shouldn't look down on him, instead advice him privately. And even if he did insult the sheikh, you shouldn't have insulted him! lets not forget he's your brother in Islam. and making fun of his expressions was not necessary. You speak of these sheikhs as if they're the prophet . There's a fine line with respecting someone.
aisha khan
The reason he did it in public is because the brother did the video in public so the condition to advises him is in public .
This is a core principle in shariah
Ok but it would have been better if he said, this video is wrong for the following reasons, & if u dont take it down I'm going to make a video on it. Give him a chance
ruclips.net/video/g_oLLe6n_l8/видео.html
I have an illness can you guys make dua that Allah cures me from it in sha Allah, may allah reward you guys
I hope you are better now InshaAllah
@@Foralluhaterz ameen
@@rewd9296, do not say 'Ameen' after someone has said InshaAllah because then it is as if you are enforcing something upon Allah through your statement. As hassan Waleed said 'If Allah wills' meaning that Allah decides as to this matter but then you said 'so be it' so it is as if you're enforcing something upon Allah unintentionally through your statement. Please change your 'ameen' then to 'Insha Allah'. As-Salaamu 'alaykum! :)))))
Ameen and May Allah grant you Shifaa
How are you tho because this was 3 years ago.
RUclips might be a fitnah for you guys now..stick to putting out beneficial videos not ones attacking each other. May Allah unite the Muslims 🙏
These people are misguiding people it had to be talked about and it is to this day
You guys really need to stop refuting one another, its uncomfortable to watch. Study and do your best to share whatever knowledge you have acquired and then leave the rest to Allah. Only Allah can guide people to the truth.
mila kunis that makes no sense because allah will destroy u himself if u dont talk out about people who act like sheikhs idk who to follow anymore but oh well
ruclips.net/video/g_oLLe6n_l8/видео.html
😳😳😳😳Kinda speechless... I think Ali and Dawah mans team should just meet up and sort things out... Too many disagreements😳 btw whatever I'm saying is an option...not trying to hate or be rude.
May Allah guide us to the right path all the way to Jannah, Aameen!
& Allah knows best
Ukhta Aadam they should just box it out lol
Thing is , he was only trying to help the ummah. This is not an appropriate approach. If you spoke with respect in a way which informed him and educated him , that would be acceptable😕. This is so gobsmacking.
@Naruto Uzumaki Bro thats not tbs problem, I like ali dawah but he needs to be more respectful.
That guy is a nonce
This is so childish
ruclips.net/video/g_oLLe6n_l8/видео.html
recite Ayat Al Kursi everyday so that Allah will protect you always
Young age
Ibn Shihab:
“Do not underestimate yourselves because of your young age. For, whenever Umar ibn Al-Khattab was faced with a difficult matter, he would invite the youths and consult them; seeking the sharpness of their intelligence.”
• Hilyah Al-Awliyah 3/364
Dont compare
guys please pray for me i have my medical exams and since its ramazan and studying is quiet hard and im left with everything to study please its a blessed month do remember me in your prayers
JazakAllah khair ☺
Asma Khan ameen
May Allah make it easy for you sister! Ameen
Asma Khan May Allah make it easy for you and may you pass with flying colors! 😊
may Allah make it easy for you to successfully pass your exams!
mxxx96 - Ameen
Subhallah I love the way Ali puts his point across!!!savage but polite and eloquently
what qualifications do you have to refute him?
Brother Abu Bakr refuted a scholar. Where as Ali refuted brother Abu Bakr. Big difference, but either way, both these videos shouldn't be happening.
common sense
Mohib Khail. Couldn't agree more.
MadeForAkhira what gave imran and his team to refute a shiekh. A whole shiekh. How dare they.
hussain thomas imran and his team dont have qualifications
at the beginning of the video we see sheikh salih alfawzaan and he holds the opinion that voting is haram.
Maryam Ahmed Abdiras
Ali wasn't saying he agreed with the sheikh, but that Abu Bakr was trying to be/act like him. At least that's my take on it. Ali explained it in the video, that everything in Islam is technically ibadah, and voting for the lesser of two evils is an act of ibadah; but Abu Bakr misunderstood.
Under sharia law, choosing the Muslim's leader through widespread vote is not from Islam. But voting under a secular non-muslim regime is a totally different matter.
am I the only confused here..
Beautiful Patience I am :(
Yep this is what happens when someone makes a haram thing halal using random scholars and not returning to the Quran and Sunnah.
Inshaa Allah Allah makes us all understand the haqq.Ameen
Brother Ali, entire video I kept hearing the word "you you you, you are this you are that" towards brother Abu Bakr. You're clearly mocking the brother and saying you're not but then you also say actions have to be according to intentions? There is absolutely NO need at ALL to put a caption on anything of the brother! Is that clearly not mocking? Please for the sake of Allāh stop going back and forth. No good is coming out of it rather more confusion and fitnah. You do what you think is if you're so firm on it and remember age does NOT mean anything. Wallahi this is so sad.
Hijab Modesty Don't watch this with emotions tbh this is so petty on both sides , but this has built over so many months these brothers imrans team i do not doubt they have good intention but they are trigger happy with no firearm.
PoeticEntity 786 They always aggravate first though.
PoeticEntity 786 But I like both channels tbh
@Hussain Thomas: Akhi in all honesty your an older brother than most of these individuals making the RUclips videos. I think for that reason it's upon you more than most to have wisdom in this situation and not be bias. How many times has imran and his crew assaulted Shaykh Haitham and 'Ali whether directly or indirectly but never have I seen you yet wheel them up in their errors. Akhi to be honestly imran and his crew are relentless in their campaign to sabotage the good work that others are trying to do in the name of Salafiyyah and following the Sunnah. I can see that you would have a leaning towards them due to them studied from the same people you do and taking from the same scholars you do but that still does not give you a mandate to be bias towards these brothers and clearly not represent the full truth in your comment. Is it worse what brother 'Ali is doing which to openly refute abu bakr nonsense and try his utmost to show him his place which could even though unlikely be seen as undermining or what abu bakr done which was to come out of his place and speak about issues which he has no right whatsoever to speak about and won't have a right for maybe another 10+ years??
Bro to be honest Allah says observe justice even if it be against yourself.
@PoeticEntity 786: Really sad to see how you speak about the adab of others but can't even correct yourself when your calling another brother a joke and diplomat without any valid or sufficient proof. First and foremost I sincerely advice you go and rectify you situation in regards to your manners. Secondly if you watched the video objectively without a previous bias you would have seen the approach and content which was taken by brother 'Ali wasn't nothing except for necessary but also superb. The individual abu bakr stated practicing a year and some time ago and he is speaking about issues many many Tulaab who have studied for decades would not dare to venture into. Does that not tell you something about the severity of this crisis and why it was pivotal that this brother address this issue??
Lie seriously it's Ramadhan so it's strongly encourage to better yourself in this month. Like seriously don't go backwards and digress in your judgment.
you have lost a subcriber it's the month of Ramadan .. this is getting out of hand on both parts.. these videos need to be re evaluated.. I don't doubt the intentions are good but this is not helpful to no-one. stop with the reaction videos the hype has got to all of you brothers. Allah bless u all u and guide u back to what is best and benifical.
Wow how catastrophic for him🙄
Wallahi a very much needed video. Jazakallah khair brother Ali
Anyone else noticed that the Brother Ali Dawah is reacting to and anyone else who appears on Brother Imran Ibn Mansur's videos, seem to speak and act EXACTLY like Imran?
No Muslim can say a Muslim or none Muslim a KUFR .....
jay Ali yes cz its Allah's job
No, you must recognize the people of the Book and the mushrikeen as kufaar, if you do not recognize obvious kufaar as kufaar then you've committed riddah.
Say Nada its in Quran no Muslim can use the word Kufr simple as that take it or leave it
jay Ali where's your evidence dont lie upon Allah and his messenger becareful
Go and Read Surah Al-Kafirun (109)
It clearly has the word Kafir
NO BODY CHRISTIAN OR HINDU DO YOUR HOME WORK FIRST
So you have to be a mufti now to see that voting for democracy ( a system other then Allah swt His system) is haram? Is the Qu'ran and the hadeeth's only for 'mufti's' or for mankind????? SubhanAllah, why trying to downgrade brothers who trying to protect us against kufr, WITH ' *evidence* from the Qu'ran, that it's haram to vote, is it a necessity to vote?? have we a choice to 'not ' vote? yes we have, and also did someone put a gun to your head that you need to vote? is it a matter of life and death?? so is it a necessity ??? No it is NOT! you call these brother ignorant, yet you follow a so called 'shaykh' who fail to provide evidence about this issue.
Can you provide the evidence why its permissible (according to you) to vote??? Show me?
Do you know what Wageeb means?
This doesn't make sense
For this reason so many people are becoming apostates. This is my 13 year old self! Amazing! Yaqeen institute conducted a survey on 600 Muslims and the number 1 reason they are doubting Islam is because everyone thinks they are in the right way and everyone else is in the wrong way.
Ali- the way you spoke about Abu Bakr was absolutely disgusting how about YOU stay in YOUR lane how dare u I've watched his video he has nothing but utmost respect. Even though I agree with you're saying the way you said it naaa not on and what happened to advising people sincerely and in 'private' clearly YOU mocked him saying how he has a little knowledge of deen etc I don't even know what to even say....
SaMoo KHaaNi again and again Sheikh Haddad is attacked, I think those guys need a little more 🔥 for them to understand better
That's the difference between people of knowledge and some tiny little RUclips "Dawah Stars". I'm not tagging brother Abu Bakr as a ulama or a shaikh. But he's still more knowledgeable than Ali Dawah.
@@jamilumagaji582 he deserves this. May Allaah guide him and guide us.
Cant believe we are are having the time to watch all this during ramadan Ya Allah forgive us all in sha Allah
This is a doubtfull matter therefore its best just to avoid it. The Pophet (pbuh) said whoever stays away from doubtfull matter saves himself from the fire (im paraphrasing)
You are doing the same. may Allah guide you
Are we committing shirk by living under the rule of Teresa may?
We are already under the rule of a non Islamic nation, so what's the difference if you vote or don't?
If we don't vote then does that mean we are accepting the laws that will be put in place by the next party? So does that also come under their definition of shirk?
We are still Muslims though right? We don't associate partners with Allah, we worship Allah solely.
I ain't taking no other person for worship other then Allah.
If vote for a party that will stop bombing and occupying Muslim countries, if we vote for a party that sets a just system for Muslims and allows us to practice our religion without any restrictions then that's logic and rather it makes it easier for us to worship Allah alone.
These same people who are against it will be complaining when their parents get deported back to their own countries, when they ban the hijab, close Down all the masjids and ban islam in this country.
Illogical fallacy.
Burhan Saeed there is a difference between participating and abiding , by voting your are affirming democracy whereas by abstaining your are negating democracy
Say nada what can u say if by abstaining from voting and that result in a party that ban u from practicing ur Ibadah
Hamza Usman then in that case i believe its permissible lesser of 2 evils but that doesn't apply in this year voting elections
Burhan Saeed what I don't get is imagine UKIP or the BNP were up for rule would they advice for us to sit back and let them rule without us voting against them ? 🙃 these lot live in LaLa land wallah.
Everyone please learn something from the video and don't take this fatwa from br Burhan and also dont take his rationality regardless of how much of it is correct. Stick to the scholars that refer to quran sunnah and salaf. No offense akhi.
The face at 9:45 KILLED ME laughing😂😂😂😂 the peek of cluelessness
Ali he is just asking questions
I love u and this guy naseeha sessions so don't beef
ruclips.net/video/g_oLLe6n_l8/видео.html
Good points raised brother Ali. May Allah keep you firm on the path and free from riya and arrogance ameen.
The lack of food during Ramadan is getting to some brothers!
Masha Allah, I like your new haircut may Allah bless you and use you as mean to spread the good and stop anything evil
People who are asking Ali Dawah to talk to them in private, perhaps you have knowledge on these issues. What about us, who learn from these videos. If Ali Dawah did not make the refutation in this video, I would have believed everything the other brother said. Thank you Ali for the video. JazakAllah Khair
Islam is so simple yet we as muslims make it so hard
Now a days there's so many different opinions, young people like me get very confused. I get so stressed from it
Same, I get so confused on who's right and who's wrong.
May Allah guide us all to the right path.
Tahsin Gury just try your best, Allah SWT guides. Ameen :)
EaZee eventhough I like both these brothers especially Ali dawah I never take something like Islamic ruling from them, I take from classical scholars of Islam and the current huge scholars living in the east like in mecca/medina or influential Muslim scholars like yasir qadhi and nouman ali khan living in the west.
I used to watch this guy. I noticed he was being a bit irrational at times, but I still watched him anyways. However, I lost respect for him when he said that music causes homosexuality. Brother, I get you follow the opinion that music is haram and that's fine, but why come up with your own imagination? Where is this in the Quran and Sunnah? Where is this in modern scientific findings?
Al Humduilah in Australia you can be excused from not voting if it goes against your religion. May God bless Australia. Muslims living in Australia are very lucky we don't see it. We're bless to live in Australia a safe country that we can practice our religion peacefully.
Allah alone knows who is truly guided from this two groups. May Allah guide us and unite us upon the haqq.
Ok, Ali. I am not from the UK, So, I don't know what's going on there. Therefore, I'm in no position to talk about it. But, I've been watching your videos for a long time now, as well as the videos of brother Imran. I love you both for the sake of Allah. I like your videos, as well as brother's Imran videos, they are good. But this video is wrong. Although you say you don't have any personal issues with the other brothers, I see that the inverse is apparent in this video, and in another one, you put before. I watched the full video of brother Abu Baker, and personally, I didn't feel that he is mocking the Sheikh. I found that he had strong arguments against what the Sheikh said.In this video of yours, you put some quotes of scholars who permitted voting in some particular situations. But, you didn't put any references to the original fatwas. I see that you're the one who is relying on his understanding, not what the scholars said. This also goes to doctor Heithem. He stated that shura in Islam is the democracy, which is entirely against the teachings of Islam. I also think that brother Abu Baker and brother Imran have an adamant argument here. Because I never heard any scholar say that before, this is the first time. Doctor Heithem said a lot of things, but he didn't give any pieces of evidence to base his arguments. All he did is giving his understanding about the subject. He never refers to any scholar, and when he did, he just says the things that support his opinion, which is not the right way, and not the scientific way. For this, I'd like to give you a sincere advice, from a brother to a brother, take knowledge from the people of the highest rank. Because with all the respect I have for the Sheikh, he is not a scholar.
may allah bless you for your hard work!
laughed so much when he said "stay in the hard shoulder akhi, don't move your car" 😂😂😂
Its not funny tho his tryna act all big man this guys a clown in real life man
People are missing the point. This is not about whether it is permissible to vote. It’s about knowing your place, not imposing your stance and not issuing verdicts on matters you are not qualified to speak on. Although Ali Dawah sides with the permissibility of voting, he’s not imposing his views nor is he attacking scholars. The Dawah Man team and people caught up in this debate should heed this advice.
i dont understand at 7:25 ali says and i quote "in general we agree its haraam" (voting) so what is the point of this video if he acknowledges its haraam, whats he trying to counter if he agrees with the brother??
itsjustdako specific situation is lesser of two evils they all agree that the big scholars say it is not permissible unless it meets certain criteria, some people cannot comprehend diffrence of opinion and will just hastily make a decision pass a fatwa.
i get that, in the video he makes a point where he says its permissible to vote if it stops our muslim brothers and sisters from being bombed, but wasn't it the labour government who decided to invade iraq and kill over 120,000 people, it doesn't matter who is in power it won't stop our ummah from being bombed in other countries, i guarantee they will continue to do so and by giving them your vote in essence you're giving them the power to do exactly that.
itsjustdako and the alternative is? u can make dua ofc but u also need to try ur best to prevent harm and ensure the lesser of two evils. We are not talking about the labour under Tony Blair who went to iraq and bombed innocent ppl we r talking about the party which under Jeremy corbyn will fund more for NHS will help with tuition fees and wants to unite us rather than divide us like Theresa May. The two situations r very different plz understand and if we dont vote we are just allowing this to happen anyway the outcome is likely to change and could be much worse for the Muslim ummah as many sheikhs have pointed out
akhi lets be honest politicians are profoundly known for selling dreams and going back on their word, and also it'd be very naive to believe that Corbyn would come in and suddenly change everything, im just saying don't let them feed you bs and sell you dreams be wiser than that, them saying that they're going to stop the bombing of muslim countries is just another form of propaganda just so they can win your vote and once they receive your vote they will do exactly what they said they weren't going to do.
Ali dawah that's amazing advice not only on him for all of us God bless you for making dawah to Muslims first
What's up with you UK "muslims" you have so many shuyukh telling you that voting is shirk. Unfortunately the government you're voting for imprisoned them and now you have shuyukh that are telling you that it's wajib. Tauhid al hakimiyah, learn it. Where's your jealousy fir your deen??
first time I've seen ali actually pissed
Allah knows who is right and who is wrong, may Allah cover our shortcomings
brother Ali you are doing great efforts MashAllah because you are guiding us in a right way but people like brother abu bakar can misguide other who have little knowledge. but Jazak Allah bro Ali.
Satan will never enter the house in which Surah Al Baqarah is recited
Such a ideological division in Islamic community is completely unnecessary, as every Muslim have been commanded to follow the same orders.
May ALLAH guide us to the straight path.
LOOOOL this is mad, in my eyes both Ali Dawah AND Dawah man are unqualified. BROTHERS STICK TO THE BASIC THINGS OF A DAEE (Calling to Islam). AND HELP ME FIND A WIFE MATE, LOOL IM IN ANOTHER RAMADAN AND MY BED IS STILL EMPTY. p.s. this is not an attack as we should come together as i see good in both of them
asalamu alaikum exactly lol.
This isn't right brother, you've miss represented the brother and made him come across as completely incapable.
Fear Allah, I hope you make an Open toubah.
Your love for Sheikh Haitham is way out of proportion. Please Akhi, no one bar the Prophets is infallible in regards to the understanding of the deen of Allah. To seemingly always make excuses for the Sheikh despite him making contradictory statements and then coming up with your own interpretation of worship is with no authentic basis or references to fix this clear contradiction is majorly wrong.
I'm not discounting the Sheikh knowledge of the religion, but I'm also not saying he can never make mistakes.
I hope you've apologised to this brother since this video and sought forgiveness from Allah and then him for the back biting.
I swear that watching both channels makes me mad confused when I'm just coming to gain knowledge and now I didn't vote and was debating my family on it
Subhan'Allah Subhan'Allah
Agree, totally. It's about time this issue was addressed. The Muslim youth are already being misled in all direction, we do not need more people within the muslim community doing the same and encouraging harshness, arragance and the idea of being quick to judge and in some cases slander of highly knowledgeable and qualified individuals. Know your limits. Thank you for addressing this very very important issue.
really sas how there are people who insult the youngsters and/or shaykh haitham. They are all our brothers.
You tell them ali.... they practice then they think they are some scholars lmao
09:52 if it's due to lack of knowledge then give him the knowledge!!! He literally admits that he could easily be wrong and that he would be happy for someone to explain this to him- no need for brother Ali to be so petty on reacting to the whole video and making fun of him instead of just explaining it to the brother
His explaining in the video would be the same if he typed it what more could you ask for
brother Ali i know you are right but you are also exposing the sin of other how because i wasn't aware of this matter now i am because of you May Allah protect you and all of us Ameen.
Assalamualaikum Ali Dawah, I saw the original video and JazakAllah for correcting the brother because I was in disbelief in what I was watching and people accepting it in the comments.
Ali dawaah shouldn't talk about people staying in their lanes. Look at the margin of difference between Ali and Shamsi answering Yusuf on the issue of Allah SWT form according to the athari aqeeda.
I agree with brother ali that the young students should not ever fall in the mistakes of thinking they know something. The only thing I would have not done the way brother ali did, would be this rather harsh tone against this brother. Overall, it is not smart to take advice from young brothers and sisters about matters and topics such as this one. Those scholars are not scholars for show, we have to acknowledge this.
I think this should have been done privatly, from both sides just them between, and then maybe after a video that would explain the whole situation. Peopel are now taking sides, it's almost like Dawah man Co vs Ali Dawah Co. Both sides are doing their best to call peopel to Islam, both sides have error (just like anyone else) but why do you FOLLOWERS have to creat a whole scene out of this? Remember, the brothers from both sides(I hate to call sides since all of the are in Islam) are your brothers in deen.
May Allah subhana wa ta'ala bring these brothers together again Ameen.
Chowdhury u spoken the truth brother, all brothers taking sides are not doing a good thing.
Abdurahman Omar brother I'm afraid this will lead to personal issues between them and we all know how much shaytaan will Love this and take benefit out of this.
Ali Dawah you are unqualified as well...
Yeah I'm pretty sure Sheikh Fawzan was talking about the dawah youtubers like Ali.
As you said Ali it is Ramadan and although you may be justified in some things you are saying you seem to be allowing your emotions to lead your words at times that could come off a bit mean. You say "Unqualified Mufti MashAllah" Should we really be using these beautiful words of Allah to mock someone? I genuinely enjoy your videos and the videos of Naseeha, sucks to be listening to these videos strongly disagreeing with each other. I do believe the other brother was being genuine and not arrogant. Dont you think that their are men just as important and qualified as the men you speak of that hold the same belief as this young brother? Why not agree to disagree? I know you may be genuine in your response as well but this video just seems to be creating fitna.
What a nice, moderate, and soothing comment! JazakAllahu khayran sister for representing what we are: a religion of balance (in our behavior as well as our conduct)
Soukina Kad thank you. I know these brothers mean well. for all we know these young men may be the sheiks of our children's times, but it seems like things are starting to be taken more personally. In sha Allah we can learn to always handle things in the most pleasing of way to please Allah and not ourselves.
Youre response is exactly why women has to have 4 witnesses. You are emotional creatures and your throw rationality and logic out the window!
Nowadays there a lot of Muslims who judge and think that they know Islam better than anyone. Everyone should stay in their limits even if it is a sheik or student as Allah is the one to judge.
democracy is a religion in of its own. anyone who promotes it and prefers it over the shariah in anyway shape or form. is like the one who bows down to idols.
ali dawah wallahi ali ur manners toward the brother was rude
and look at the brother on other hand
asking with manners to the sheikh
the brother was not looking fault on the sheikh rather on Islamic things that needed to be clarified
u r the one u mocked the brother saying looking at his face totally rude fear Allah and repent
the brother is not speaking from himself he is speaking from what the scholars put forth before him
It makes me angry when people of knowledge dont answer questions when they know the answer. I was on a real imams tumblr page and a sister asked a simple question about what is proper hijab and he basically let her down and told her to go ask some other sister on there because he claimed he didnt have experience to be talking about hijab which shocked me because its not an excuse hes an imam and that was a perfect oppurtunity to gain experience talking about hijab anyway and it wouldve been an an easy and quick answer and he basically missed out on that ibadah. Keep in mind this imam knows arabic and gives lectures of course he knew the answer but didnt give it to her. Im guessing its because he had a lot of young female fans and a lot of people on tumblr are young teens and sensitive and these days a lot of sisters like to ignorantly tell brothers they have no right to be talking about hijab or what a woman should wear even though enjoining good is wajib. May Allah guide us.
There are some that say voting is Haram but they keep clicking the dislike button😂
What has that got to do with anything?
So true show this guy. Too many people u can't believe nowadays
its a real problem in our time that people with no understanding talk about understanding of the religion. the believe that its ok to read the statements of the schoolers and pass them forward. you dont become a doctor by reading a medicine book. "go back to the quran and sunnah bro". as if common people can just go to the quran and sunnah directely. this is what got us in this confussion in the first place. Allah knows best.
Hahaha my g hard shoulder ya naa!!😂😂😂👊 about time bro dem man der needed a response spot on my g👌🏽👍🏼
isn't the title a mock in itself? I do love this brother tho. May Allah bless and guide us all.
When an ignorant youth tries to school (disrespect) a Doctor, sometimes they need reminding.
I look to the fatwa of Shaykh Ibn Uthejmin and I don't find that sentence what you said... In election in the west... Manipulation with fetawas is known, when Shejh Uthejmin say about that or other Ulemas they talk about countries like, Saudi, or other 'Muslim' land, and for people which their plans are to bring sharia laws and inhibit shirk, kufr and sins.
where's the respect Ali?
7:55
Reference, I honestly have been trying to find it for like 10 minutes, I can't find it.
Musas dad is amazing may Allah perserve him
He believes Shaykh Haitham is a major scholar. He's not amazing.
To be honest the words of shaykh Saalih al-Fawzan were enough... your commentary on top only diluted what he said in the beginning... no doubt the youth need to know their place and leave these matters to the scholars...
This video being like: I saw something wrong and I wanted to rectify it, but the only thing I did is something worse than what I saw
1st of All he dint claim himself to be mufti
Been waiting for this video to be released all day! Gonna sit down and watch with a cup of tea after Taraweeh 😭
this is the state of the muslim today..
Mashallah amazing may Allah preserve you Ali
he made mistake in islam you can not call another muslim kufur
This is the problem nowadays with young guys , they judge all big scholars like imam Hanifi , Shafiye, Maliki, Hambali radiyAllahu anhuma, they think they know beter than anyone else, Get knowledge brothers , if you are in 5 class don't judge some one who is graduated .
People need to stick to the basics such as memorising the Qur'an, the adkaar, learning the Arabic language etc... And try getting closer to Allah. Totally agree with brother Ali, people need to stick to their lanes. I heard a scholar recently, who mentioned either Umar or Ali (ra) said that a person who knows his limits is blessed. These kids need to know their limits and people can't take knowledge and opinions from any random nobody on RUclips. If a person wants to vote or not vote, they can make their own mind up by getting the opinions from reputable scholars. RUclips has become a big fitna and people need to be careful how they use it.