Boris Wild’s Acaan Revealed Fool Us

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2020
  • This is a variation, I didn’t buy or had someone to explain me his original version.
    The trick that got in everybody’s mind since last season of Fool us from Penn and teller now revealed, a trick that looks like a miracle and the secret wouldn’t be different.

Комментарии • 141

  • @julesbevey
    @julesbevey 3 года назад +92

    Very interesting, but we have 3 problems :
    First, Teller have shuffles the deck and Penn have cuts it BEFORE the choice of the card.
    Second, Boris Wild said in a conference that he had sorted out the pub cards and the jokers and it was cut in the editing
    Third, Penn had three card in his hand at the end of the trick.
    But thank you so much to share that version of the ACAAN.

    • @rockdesu
      @rockdesu 2 года назад +5

      That is why I hate that scam of a show. They are great with the edits and helping the magicians do "magic". After all they need to make it appear they are creating magic for the ratings.

    • @edcellwarrior
      @edcellwarrior 2 года назад +30

      @@rockdesu them cutting out a few seconds of removing the jokers from a deck makes the show a scam? Lmao

    • @JEAN-zx6ne
      @JEAN-zx6ne 2 года назад +2

      they just cut the part where they takes out the jokers, it dosent change the trick at all. also I think Penn had notice that he has more cards in his hands but they still didn't understand how he did the trick so they decided to give hime the trophy anyway

    • @billdewall6152
      @billdewall6152 2 года назад +6

      @@rockdesu They literally did the opposite. They cut out the part where he removes the jokers and advertising cards, and instead make it look like he produced a deck of only 52 cards, from a completely fresh box that should usually contain 56 cards. Editing it in that way actually makes it look obvious that he's using a gimmicked deck, whereas if they'd left that portion in, it would have looked like a completely legitimate, normal fresh deck.

    • @camipco
      @camipco 2 года назад +2

      Assuming it's a genuine fresh deck, he'd just need to start with the gimmick pocketed and palm it into the deck, probably while Teller is showing the chosen card to the audience. That means any shuffling or whatever before the pick is returned to the deck is irrelevant.
      Then he has to reclaim it by palming it from the top before handing Penn the 3 cards. I mean, watching the video I don't catch either of those palms, but he does have the deck in his hands at both points, so it is possible.
      I do find it somewhat unlikely however that Teller would miss that there's a double / bent card in the deck when he's given it to shuffle, plus there's a risk Teller just separates them by chance. That suggests to me he's holding the stuck-pair during the shuffle and returns it after. Now we're up to 4 palms that P&T don't catch up close though, which if that's how he did it is impressive in itself.

  • @antalantal2366
    @antalantal2366 2 года назад +26

    To be honest I am getting tired of these wannabe "I explain it" that turn out not to explain what Boris wild actually did: those aren't but click-baits hiding behind misleading titles.

  • @timscoviac
    @timscoviac 2 года назад +48

    I give you credit for being able to think of a way to pull this effect off which seems hard to do at all. As some have said it isn’t how Boris did it and one way I know for certain is because when he counted 3 cards down, he didn’t square up the 3 cards, like you have to do in this method or else you’ll see the cards going under the chosen card, he left all three spread out and told pen to pick them up. Also I was excited about this method you came up with and I practiced it for a hour or so and I personally found that it isn’t practical for two reasons. If someone says a number even over like 8 or 10 the gimmick card and chosen one end up splitting apart due to so many being in between which risks being caught as the spectator that’s infront of you might see that there is a card there all of a sudden that wasn’t before and cards going in between them possibly. And the other reason I found which makes this not practical the most is even after making the tape not as sticky, when you square the cards up or the cards going in between make the gimmick split, it makes a loud noise like tape being unstuck, a sticky noise. I tried doing it different ways, slowly, fast. Didn’t matter. I am impressed that you were able to think of this but I wish it was more practical and less risky.

    • @jonnathan9034
      @jonnathan9034 2 года назад +2

      Eliminate the tape hold 2 cards & pre crimp the top card problem solved

    • @spurlingjohn2
      @spurlingjohn2 11 месяцев назад

      Way off partner

  • @muhammadowais1881
    @muhammadowais1881 3 года назад +3

    Great video man
    Liked the tutorial
    Liked your effort aswell
    Keep up the good work
    ♥️

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +1

      Thank you so much and wait for the next videos. I’m preparing very good things.

  • @Terrorbrot
    @Terrorbrot 3 года назад +50

    A few guys in the comment section have said that wild himself stated that he actually sorted out the joker cards live on show but it just didn't make it into the final cut, and he also said that it was in fact an entirely new deck

    • @rickracine9758
      @rickracine9758 3 года назад +13

      Thats right infact if there wasn't any jokers in the brand new deck P & T wouldve caught that right away

    • @rockdesu
      @rockdesu 2 года назад +3

      @@rickracine9758 yeah you can see the jokers. The show just edit that out.

    • @craftylemon2460
      @craftylemon2460 2 года назад +6

      And they also took the cards back with them. If there were a sticker on it i'm sure they would notice it.

  • @fintogive8704
    @fintogive8704 2 года назад +1

    I loved this method, idk if it's the same but thanks for teaching this, subbed

  • @maddoncel
    @maddoncel 2 года назад +4

    Good guess but probably not the way he used.
    Penn called card Number 3 and Boris handled him the 3 cards for him to check... he did not handle him 4 and they were able to check the cards looking for adhesive tape if there was any

  • @lp4969
    @lp4969 2 года назад +4

    I don't think it is his method but awesome way to recreate the same effect, thanks man

  • @philipnguyen3107
    @philipnguyen3107 2 года назад

    Thanks for posting. Great trick.🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

  • @wijayabandara9882
    @wijayabandara9882 2 года назад +1

    Very good explanations.

  • @financematters15
    @financematters15 3 года назад +42

    There were only 3 cards in Penn's hand when he took the cards to show. So he used a different method. Anyway good video..

    • @realmexicanroman
      @realmexicanroman 2 года назад +4

      No. Iys actually that method. Boris for this trick always control the espectators card to the third position. Iys was a coincidence that penn said number 3

    • @freegee3503
      @freegee3503 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@realmexicanromanIt is known that Penn likes to choose the 3. I believe the effect was setup with P&T.

    • @nicco-sixty
      @nicco-sixty 3 месяца назад

      @@freegee3503 What do you mean "set up" ?

    • @freegee3503
      @freegee3503 2 месяца назад

      @@nicco-sixty There was some kind of communication in some way before the routine between Boris and Penn and Teller. In other words, the effect was stooged.

    • @nicco-sixty
      @nicco-sixty 2 месяца назад

      @@freegee3503 Why do ignorant people like you always assume that there is a stooge when you can't explain an effect with your limited knowledge of magic?
      Besides stooges aren't allowed

  • @HafizDenali
    @HafizDenali 3 года назад +4

    You are so genius! 👏

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +1

      Thank you sooo much my friend 😻😻

  • @beastmusic7197
    @beastmusic7197 3 года назад +1

    Crazy stuff bro🔥🔥🔥

  • @mahdexkidega7073
    @mahdexkidega7073 3 года назад +2

    Great revealed bro, I love it

  • @liinnee2536
    @liinnee2536 3 года назад +8

    I don't think this is the way he did it but good guess.

  • @eyewaves...
    @eyewaves... 3 года назад

    Pretty good. Thank you for sharing it.

  • @tonyalientrippier989
    @tonyalientrippier989 3 года назад +3

    Brill!! Can you do a reveal of Alpha Deck ? Much love my friend

  • @lkmens9281
    @lkmens9281 3 года назад +7

    You are great. Wonderful I think the first reveled of this magic trick

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +1

      Thank you so much for recognizing that ❤️

  • @Musikpunx
    @Musikpunx Год назад +2

    Actually I think that Boris Wild did it a different way.
    But anyway this is a very interewsting way to do the ACAAN, I have never seen before.

  • @salvor1
    @salvor1 6 месяцев назад +1

    and it was a fresh deck.

  • @yairthwayhan9056
    @yairthwayhan9056 3 года назад +1

    Awesome bro

  • @kashcreates
    @kashcreates 3 года назад +22

    Okay this was an amazing way to do an ACAAN, I agree.❤️ I have a question though, when Pen took the cards from Borris's hands, he examined it thoroughly and they were only 3.
    Where did the extra card go!?

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +10

      That’s a great question. I hope I’ll be able to give you the answer someday.

    • @adhithadias2103
      @adhithadias2103 3 года назад +2

      @shikha Kashyap Yes, this cannot be the way he did the trick. If you saw the video on that blind card mechanic on Penn and Teller. We could think he somehow managed to get the selected card to the top. And then handled the second card until the 3rd card, I think this can be done with practice.

    • @brianmagicman3556
      @brianmagicman3556 3 года назад +5

      @@cardmagic Stop uploading tutorials of how YOU think tricks are done as opposed to how they ARE done
      Trying to make yourself look good and clever by using the wrong method in fact makes you look stupid and clueless

    • @antalantal2366
      @antalantal2366 2 года назад +5

      @@brianmagicman3556 his videos are interesting, the problem is in the title... clickbait...

    • @timscoviac
      @timscoviac 2 года назад +1

      @@brianmagicman3556 it’s still a neat method, and he’s clever for thinking of a way to even do this effect which is hard to grasp. But saying in the video that this is how he did it is misleading because it isnt

  • @LinusKnightXY
    @LinusKnightXY 2 года назад

    this was awesome! and fun! even though i still don't think i could pull this off haha

  • @l84eva49
    @l84eva49 2 года назад +1

    the cards were already squared up before Penn chose a number

  • @kishorekaranth6572
    @kishorekaranth6572 3 года назад +1

    Very nice 👌

  • @tsmith3286
    @tsmith3286 9 дней назад

    Boris has said on his own YT channel they cut out the removal of the jokers for time.

  • @EngFranciscoFernando
    @EngFranciscoFernando 3 года назад

    Thanks a lot!!!!

    • @EngFranciscoFernando
      @EngFranciscoFernando 3 года назад

      Pen was left with three cards in the very end. Don't you think that he would have noticed the gimmick?

  • @gokarotmd.yeasin6382
    @gokarotmd.yeasin6382 3 года назад

    Awesome love your video from Bangladesh

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад

      Thank you so much ❤️🇧🇷

  • @kingrobert1st
    @kingrobert1st Год назад +1

    Penn selected a fresh sealed deck of cards mate.

  • @hmmm4140
    @hmmm4140 3 года назад +1

    Great method.

  • @darrenhadden1037
    @darrenhadden1037 7 месяцев назад +1

    Very clever 🎉

  • @vqfive
    @vqfive 6 месяцев назад

    That's one theory, but if you go back and look at the actual trick he did on pen and teller. When he counted out 3 cards. If the first two cards were the gimmick cards, then that means that on the third card he counted out he would have to had shoved it in between the first and two cards to make it the third card. But he didn't, he counted out 3 cards and the third card went on to the bottom of the first two cards. Penn Got the handle and inspect the last three cards and if there was some kind of sticky tape on there, he would have found that.

  • @aranyak1881
    @aranyak1881 3 месяца назад

    This stuff is already hard to practice, imagine how much skill it took to do the original damn. But thanks for your video, this method is clever too.

  • @sevidg
    @sevidg 2 года назад +1

    I’m sure Boris just did his winning Puracaan routine and like always culled the selection to a 3rd position and then just got lucky with penn choosing 3. But I have to watch it again.

  • @BrokeTheSeal
    @BrokeTheSeal 5 месяцев назад

    The problem is he just took the deck back from Teller after the shuffled and didn’t do anything with it other than held it in mechanics grip. How did he move the gimmick cars to the top?

  • @travelfoodetc5192
    @travelfoodetc5192 3 года назад +1

    Can you reveal the trick of shin lin how he fooled the 3rd time

  • @KryddaFesten
    @KryddaFesten 8 месяцев назад

    Very intresting method

  • @film_magician
    @film_magician Год назад

    He doesn't sandwich the cards in the routine though. He deals the one at a time very fairly.

  • @trendingera488
    @trendingera488 2 года назад

    But in your case you have one extra card which can be cought while counting

  • @pascalcallemien2498
    @pascalcallemien2498 Год назад +1

    Did he not give the deck to Penn after the trick? It is very unlikely Penn or Teller would not see the gimmick. If Penn chose a very high number, he would certainly have seen that Boris did something fishy when counting.

  • @courierslife3793
    @courierslife3793 Год назад

    Wow can't believe this is how it's done

  • @mikewatson5254
    @mikewatson5254 2 года назад

    Interesting however after teller shuffled the cards the deck was not cut again and the penn chooses 3 the deck was not messed with during this time and he only pulled 3 cards so you trick is one way it could be done , but I don’t think you solved how Boris did it

  • @rockdesu
    @rockdesu 2 года назад

    BTW Card Magic You can see the jokers for a frame but then on the next frame you can't. That's because the show edit that part out.

  • @scarletbegonias2359
    @scarletbegonias2359 5 месяцев назад

    I went back and watched Boris do it again, I don't think he did it the way you're suggesting. The cards clearly went underneath the previous cards by quite a gap.

  • @BlueVelvet777
    @BlueVelvet777 3 года назад +2

    It was a new deck.

  • @Barreloffish
    @Barreloffish 2 года назад +1

    Surely, if Penn picked 52, the trick would fail. Since it would be the last or bottom card. Then there is no sense in counting to 52 and is logically forced, i.e. Penn could comment it must be the bottom card, to show the bottom card. And even if he were to count all the cards, he would be 1 short unless he added 1 extra card for the grimmick.

  • @uniqueman396
    @uniqueman396 Месяц назад

    They took whole box card and the checked...you believe they will missed what you found??? Man , they are closed and them eyes on cards

  • @joblessness101
    @joblessness101 3 года назад +5

    Since P&T examined the cards in the end.. I do not believe there were any gimmicked cards in his performance.
    However, based P&T's particular question on when he 'squared' the deck. I am pretty sure he used a Stripper deck with one edge slightly tapered in one direction which allowed him probably control the top or bottom of the deck. ( or 2nd position like in this reveal)

    • @MikkoRantalainen
      @MikkoRantalainen 2 года назад

      I think the question about squaring the deck was because they thought that if the deck was fanned out before calling the number, Boris could have moved the bottom card to correct position while closing the deck. I think they weren't fooled by any other part but how to get the correct card to the 3rd position.

  • @vojtechpilar5809
    @vojtechpilar5809 3 года назад +2

    How can you call this the Boris Wild's trick since on Fool us it happened totally differently? This is NOT the method at all.

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +1

      I know it. As I described in the description this is just a variation. And surprisingly it’s the closer to the original effect we can found in RUclips.

    • @MikkoRantalainen
      @MikkoRantalainen 2 года назад +1

      @@cardmagic You you also add the word "variation" in the title, too? It wouldn't make the title too long and it would be way less misleading then.

  • @powerbrain840
    @powerbrain840 3 года назад

    Can you plz teach me Asi Winds Accan plzzzz

  • @lbrxndonlyt_4947
    @lbrxndonlyt_4947 Год назад

    This is not how he does it he used a brand new deck from the factory with the seal on it how could he set this up?

  • @potorrero
    @potorrero 3 года назад +3

    Nice video. You're onto something here, but I don't think this is exactly how he did it. It would be too risky to use cheap gimmick cards. Also, Penn examined the cards, so, he would get caught. Nice job though.

  • @MikkoRantalainen
    @MikkoRantalainen 2 года назад +1

    Nice method but I don't think this was the way Boris Wild did it. The way he count to three at the end was way too clean. I would guess his method had the right card at position 3 always and he was just lucky and Penn selected it directly. Had Penn said any other number, he would have done something like this video suggests to reveal it. However, if Penn had said 1, revealing the card from position 3 would need triple lift which I assume would have been caught by P&T.

  • @sol_mental
    @sol_mental 8 месяцев назад

    Man, this is insane, this trick should be illegal, it's so slicky and it fools just about anybody!! I do not make any magic tricks but if for a single event I need to do a trick, this gotta be the one

  • @tinyentropy
    @tinyentropy 3 года назад +4

    But the cards (including the gimmick) were handed over to Penn, so he should have noticed the stick tape.

    • @jtmagx
      @jtmagx 10 месяцев назад

      That and he chose 3, yet there would be 4 cards

  • @madgenius1534
    @madgenius1534 3 месяца назад

    Not the trick.The only thing that i caught Boris do was when Teller picked his card while he was looking at Penn, he was still going through the cards searching for his gimmick. He didnt allow Teller to freelly put the card back into the deck so thats def where his move happened. But other than that I still dont know how he had Penn choose a number and then without (at least on tv) doing anything else to the cards having his card in the third position. He even seperates every card until he got the third so.. im getting closer to the original method but man.. this has to be most baffling trick ever.

  • @megc18
    @megc18 3 года назад

    Cool method. But he gave the cards to Penn and Teller. They can count to 3 or can see bends and glue. They know their stuff ha

  • @BlackDidThis
    @BlackDidThis 6 месяцев назад

    You have come up with a FANTASTIC trick!!! (I am assuming the possibility that it was how Boris did it, more as a speculation at this point.. Due to the P&T FoolUs presentation, I had to re-watch because of you)
    And you freely shared it with everyone!
    My VERY good (and undoubtedly generous) friend... If this does not deserve for me to subscribe; I fail to find what would.
    This is a VERY creative and massively elegant set up. THANK you
    I currently fail to prevent the cards from making snapping sounds...
    Hypothetically, assuming that this WAS the method (Or something of these lines):
    The cards used in the show were cards with air gaps (To prevent from sticking to each other) as I am assuming; so thus for such a trick to work double-sided tape does seem the root to go... But the tape just makes too much noise.
    Maybe the box was repopulated with a Chinese knock off of sort (made without an airgap surfaces) to produce them more cost effectively?

  • @nikolaosezikis7622
    @nikolaosezikis7622 2 года назад

    Can't be. The cards were taken from Penn after. If there is any gimmick they would know

  • @tanmayanayak8716
    @tanmayanayak8716 3 года назад +7

    Yes that was not a brand new deck, but if he would do that then penn and teller could easily catch tha while examining

  • @franciscopacora
    @franciscopacora 11 месяцев назад

    Penn and Teller would've noticed all gimmicks on this video

  • @bigkeb1
    @bigkeb1 3 месяца назад

    Not even close how he does it I got Boris wild dvd with this trick and I can tell you it don’t involve double sided tape

  • @youtubey6527
    @youtubey6527 2 года назад

    This is not how he did it . .but your think is also not bad great job!

  • @rickracine9758
    @rickracine9758 3 года назад

    ya that makes alot of sense there's another channel irehman7 that reveals' fool us trick and on this one basically said the magician influence penn to say 3 and i dont believe that at all , oh like to mention alot of times they edit footage for the purpose of saving time so you dont see them un wrap the deck and or see jokers ,most likely everything including jokers were in there to make it appear to be a normal deck cause lets be honest if jokers were missing P & T would of known somethings fishy right away

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад

      Yeah 🙂👍🏻👍🏻

    • @rickracine9758
      @rickracine9758 3 года назад

      @@cardmagichey you figured this out no one else did

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад

      Thank you ❤️

    • @rickracine9758
      @rickracine9758 3 года назад

      hey if you want a challenge on a trick noel on fool us just recently fooled P & T , all i got was forced card deck switch but thats not even important, cause the magician new exactly what position the card was in , and cards examinable you have to see the act to understand fully but the reveal from the same one i mentioned i think hes wrong again but i have no clue either

  • @pizmen24
    @pizmen24 Год назад

    yes. nice try. but what Penn asked Boris in the end is what we all should be asking. did Boris shuffle the deck after he gave the number 3. it wasn't. and the card was not at the top neither as many try to explain this method. Boris was so clean in counting the card to 3.
    But one thing is clear. Boris knows exactly the card Teller picked. i believe he used marked cards and not gimmicks card.

  • @user-mj6ux8fg4m
    @user-mj6ux8fg4m 7 месяцев назад

    It is a good method you proposed, but that is not how he did it. If you look closely, you see that moves you are suggesting do not take place and at the end, Pen takes the whole deck with him to examine and has it in his hands the whole time. He would hide the deck at the end if he had a gimmicked card in it.
    Thank you for sharing, was interesting, but i don't think this is the main backbone of how the trick was done.

  • @Lance514
    @Lance514 Год назад

    Great interpretation, but not the method. You should change the title this video. But props to you for figuring out another way to achieve the effect.

  • @Mark_B544
    @Mark_B544 2 года назад +1

    Penn has the 3 cards t the end and counts them he would have seen 4 if this was true but unfortunately you’re a chancer and don’t know how he did it

  • @MagicMattHawkins
    @MagicMattHawkins 2 месяца назад

    This is nice but it’s not what Boris did on fool us

  • @bijolicideris1293
    @bijolicideris1293 2 года назад

    Not true, Boris let Penn and Teller take the cards and they should've see right away if it is gimmicked

  • @jtmagx
    @jtmagx 10 месяцев назад

    Why not do 3 like in the show??? 6:14

  • @diesel8067
    @diesel8067 Год назад

    That’s 100 percent not how it’s done. The method is actually much easier

  • @sulzisaque
    @sulzisaque 3 года назад

    your accent sounds kinda Brazilian to me kkkkkkkkk

  • @151samm
    @151samm 3 года назад

    Method is impressive however issue is he gave three cards to Penn and I assume Penn is smart enough to differentiate between 3 cards and 4 cards... Idk y u guys don't accept that u have no clue how the trick was done...

  • @whitenip84
    @whitenip84 2 года назад

    Great version of the trick but i don't think it's the way boris did it

    • @rockdesu
      @rockdesu 2 года назад

      Did you see the jokers?

    • @whitenip84
      @whitenip84 2 года назад

      @@rockdesu boris said in an interview they edited out the new deck opening/jokers being taken put for the show

  • @user-fn8nq5yr8l
    @user-fn8nq5yr8l Год назад

    That is NOT how he did the trick buddy. Not even close

  • @KvkenshinKv
    @KvkenshinKv 3 года назад

    If only you were right... But it's not the method man. But nice video

  • @BarbaSouEu
    @BarbaSouEu 3 года назад

    nope, nope, nope

  • @seanoliver1218
    @seanoliver1218 2 года назад

    Bullshit, watch him count the the 3 cards again, they are placed in order as counted there’s no trick. You can see the edge of the cards as he counts fall in correct order

  • @yudaaugusta985
    @yudaaugusta985 8 месяцев назад

    Not like that bro, it’s different:(

  • @cedric7936
    @cedric7936 2 года назад

    That is not it. But good idea.

  • @evertontrindaderisso8855
    @evertontrindaderisso8855 3 года назад +1

    Ta com cara de ser BR. Kkkk

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад +1

      🤫 kkkkkkkk sou sim do cartomagia mesmo

    • @evertontrindaderisso8855
      @evertontrindaderisso8855 3 года назад

      @@cardmagic to ligado. kkkk ganhou mais um inscrito nos dois canais.

    • @cardmagic
      @cardmagic  3 года назад

      @@evertontrindaderisso8855

    • @ThomazCorrea
      @ThomazCorrea 3 года назад

      Mano kkkkk também imaginei ser BR pelo sotaque

  • @Tecom38415
    @Tecom38415 Год назад

    literal clickbait

  • @sheepsaga7235
    @sheepsaga7235 2 года назад

    Stop it with these false reveals, just click bait, show the tricks separately and claim as your own tricks as personally I think that’s a better path

  • @nossingo
    @nossingo Год назад

    Nope!

  • @HolandaFilmes
    @HolandaFilmes Год назад

    "itis a teribol ackscent!" So annoiyng! Sorry!

  • @theroseproject9681
    @theroseproject9681 2 года назад

    Wrong

  • @redraymondreddington853
    @redraymondreddington853 3 года назад

    Each time I hear about Boris Wild's ACAAN on Penn & Teller, my brain enters into complete flow just to knlw how the trick was done......but how ever, your review is pretty lame and that can only be used to fool babies in the Kindergarten.
    Every adult who isn't a virgin, would realize something fishy instantly when you "start counting cards and struggling to put them under other card".

    • @Gaming1590
      @Gaming1590 3 года назад

      ...

    • @Terrorbrot
      @Terrorbrot 3 года назад +1

      I think with tons of training and skill you can do it well enough so even Penn and teller wouldn't realize he slid the cards in between. That's not actually the true problem with this explanation though but rather how he actually gave them only 3 cards not 4