Due to popular demand, the scenario in 20:13 which is the German Government in Exile, I decided to write a whole book about it. You can see the amazon page from here, and it's available for purchase worldwide! - www.amazon.com/dp/B0CY8CLLCZ
There are some ideas for alternative history moments 1.What if Poland refused to give Danzig and Polish corridor to third reich in 1939 2.What if German empire survived the November revolution 3.What if Austria refused anchluß? 4.What if America never nuked Hiroshima and Nagasaki 5.What if Japan won Second Sino Japanese war? 6.What if Roman Empire survived 7.What if Stalin was never a ruler of the SU 8.What if Ukraine stayed independent after WW1 and wasn’t captured by Soviets 9.What if Mexico won Mexicano-American war 10.What if Ethiopia was never occupied 11.What if Yemeni civil war never happened 12.What if Somalia won Ogaden war 13.What if Israel never given back Sinai to Egypt after Doomsday war of 1973 14.What if Sea Lion was successful
What about the Stalin notes becoming reality scenario? I heard a condition for it was that the SPD becomes the majority after ww2, the notes say that Germany can regain its former pre ww1 eastern territories from Russia on the condition that Germany becomes a neutral country after ww2.
Given British naval superiority there is a 0.000 percent of that. I don't think people appreciate how powerful Britain was in 1914. They could have won the war by themslves with minimal casualties if they didn't send troops to France and just did the blockade.
About the “what if Germany never unified” scenario. Bavaria and the other middle states didn’t want integration with Austria and Austria pushing towards it might lead to them actually being on Prussia’s side in that war (much of the Bavarian population favored Prussia over Austria)
4:10 you got this Part a bit mixed up. The Saar Basin was more or less it's own State after WWI, but the French had Access to our Coal Mines. After 15 Years, there was set to be a Votum if the Saar Basin should join Germany, France, or keep the Status Quo under Governance of the League of Nations acc. to the Treaty of Versailles. What caused the Hyperinflation was Belgium and France marching into the demilitarized Zone (all German Areas on the left Side of the Rhine River) which included Germany's industrial Heart Land, the Ruhrgebiet, in order to get the Reparations the Weimar Government couldn't pay. It was then that the General Strike was started by the German Government as a Way for the French-Belgian Mission to fail, as no Goods would be produced to collect. But as the Weimar Government then had to pay the Wages of the Workers which was Money they didn't have, they simply printed it. This is important to understand the Scale of the Events. The Saarland, even today, has hardly a Million People (that includes me) and was expanded westwards in Comparision to the historical League of Nations Mandate State Saargebiet. The Areas on the left Side of the Rhine had several Million People and Workers. 7:00 In Addition, could have very well been possible. There was a briefly existing German State in 1848, that ultimately failed because the chosen Kind refused the Crown and then led the Counter-Revolution. But there were actually different Approaches to what the Territory of the State should be: The Kleindeutsche Lösung (pretty much the 1871 German Reich), the Großdeutsche Lösung (that included Moravia, Bohemia and Austria) and the Siebzigmillionenlösung that included all Holdings of the the Habsburg Empire. The Großdeutsche Lösung would have pretty much been what you suggest here, but it failed because the Habsburgs were unwilling to give up Hungary, Galicia etc. But if we assumed that a hungarian Uprising was successful and the hungarian Lands entirely lost, this could have maybe happened to prevent further Revolutions and Break-Away-States. Maybe if the hungarian Revolution was successful but the German one not under the Erfurter Union suggested by Prussia which was much more favourable for the Nobles.
13:10 The most interesting scenario of Germany going communist is ww1 lasting year longer and going the same way it did IOTL, and the government gets couped in late 1919 by the Sparticus league and growing more powerful that OTL (similarly to Russia IOTL), and the social democrats are unpopular due to their support in the war. The Sparticus league is joined by millions of defecting soldiers and they crush the Freikorps which are outnumbered, outgunned, and unsupported by the central government. The civil war is over by early 1922 with a communist Victory.
Weird scenario that i think could change some stuff: what if the usa didn't demand repayments of loans when the great depression hit? This could lead to europe being much more stable (economically and politically), possibly weakening Hitler's popularity for instance. It could also lead to a weaker usa in the short term (and some radicalisation is possible) though they should actually recover quicker due to trade and stuff being easier (its hard to trade if everyone else is bankrupt)
Also you should've added an ending where the germans went into exile to the dark side of the Moon, like the popular movie Iron Sky. Or you could do a separate video on it, it would be awesome. Or a video where the germans went into exile to their controlled part of Antarctica lol.
@@davimendesboni8777 Well, there's some nutjobs that call themselves the imperial german government in exile in Germany, so called "Reichsbürger". I just wanted to make sure you weren't suggesting a video about them.
I be down for and unified German Realm and having those cantons that aren’t German being annexed by Italy and France. And I agree the Belgians shouldn’t be a thing anymore, the buffer state had its time in the sun.
Slight nit pick, but the occupation borders of Germany were agreed apon before the end of WWII, at the Yalta conference i believe, so there's no way they'd get all of Germany, especially when the west hated communism so much. Still a really good video and it's easy to tell you spend lots of time and effort making your videos, please keep up the good work
Good afternoon brother, I'm sorry if I'm annoyig,you're very busy and I understand that but will my sugestion be ready this month, I wish you a nice day and God bless you.
@rewriting-history Hey comrade, can you make an alternative history were in the ww2 peace treaty the SFR Yugoslavia had annexed Bulgaria with Stalin's permission?
Content is good, it’s just…. And I hope this won’t cause any offense… it’s difficult to listen to because the narrator rolls their “R”s, every single one… Kind of makes it sound like they’re talking underwater… *not trying to be a jerk, hopefully it’s constructive feedback*
@@rewriting-history thank you can some of the endings be Kilkenny Stays the capital , and another one being Johnathan Swift gaining independence for Ireland and the last idea is If Saint Bernadad made a country in North America and it was an empire when the Europeans Came to America plz
![Eminem - Temporary (feat. Skylar Grey) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaK9Wi5ho0o/mqdefault.jpg)
Due to popular demand, the scenario in 20:13 which is the German Government in Exile, I decided to write a whole book about it. You can see the amazon page from here, and it's available for purchase worldwide! - www.amazon.com/dp/B0CY8CLLCZ
wow, such cool!
Woww
Іф Џермани коулд гаве ўон ЎЎ1 ор ЎЎ2?
@@rewriting-historybro forgot to go to his other account
Can you make What If Greece was an ally of Bulgaria in the Second Balkan War?🎉
Judging by the amount of likes, I would consider it!
@@rewriting-historycan you consider a what if the US and USSR lost the cold War
Sounds interesting. It could have happened if Serbia attacked Bulgaria, especially if Turkey helped Serbia
An Idea Of Kaiser wilhelm II Exile In East Africa Is A Great Idea Man
We Need Full Video Of That!
Many people have requested that, so I will do something special for that!
MittelAfrika
7:00 "all german speakers united" - 67% of Switzerland... well looks like we speak chinese now.
Did you miss the part where German annexed that 67% a minute later?
@@ryanfarrelly4647i did, also, there is no italian speaking wallis.
@@JustAToeBee i didn't even know german people existed
@@Aariz981are you living under a rock or are you a rock?
@@ZukiTheMapper no I educated myself now on Germany and the Austrian language 👍
If you're reading this, you're a cutie
I appreciate that!
Oohhh~ ☺️☺️☺️
I am 47 year old man In real life 😳
Edit: Dude I am a boring bot Why did you like
😂😂😂@@idovolodarsky
AHHHHH 😊😊😊
No I'm nawwwt
saw the "all endings" and though i would be seeing the Liechtenstein thing you have been making us make.
Liechtenstein would be next video I think
I like how you gave us backstories on how these endings (even if its a bit unrealistic) could happen
I appreciate that! I threw some unrealistic scenarios just for the fun. Many people liked them, especially the last one!
What if Romania was OverPowered?
ur stories and althist vids r rlly good and deserve more likes and views and subs for this good quality 🎉🎉
Appreciate that! I'm slowly getting there!
you're my fav history channel. keep up the good work😁
LOVE these! Please do austria next
congrads for 10k
Thank you so much 😀
All endings Russia would be interesting.
It would also be a massive video. I will do it eventually!
Please continue the government in exile one, and I'm sure I'm not the only one that would love a hoi 4 mod for this idea.
People really love that! I will do something better than a HOI4 mod, although I love the idea!
bro used monster zero aka king ghidorah from monsterverse as a thumbnail big w for that my dude
But who better king ghidorah or Space Godzilla?
@@CanadianBricks both
Can you make an alternate video on falkland war 😅
My second ever video is about that, check it out!
👍
@@rewriting-historyyour 3rd* ?
There are some ideas for alternative history moments
1.What if Poland refused to give Danzig and Polish corridor to third reich in 1939
2.What if German empire survived the November revolution
3.What if Austria refused anchluß?
4.What if America never nuked Hiroshima and Nagasaki
5.What if Japan won Second Sino Japanese war?
6.What if Roman Empire survived
7.What if Stalin was never a ruler of the SU
8.What if Ukraine stayed independent after WW1 and wasn’t captured by Soviets
9.What if Mexico won Mexicano-American war
10.What if Ethiopia was never occupied
11.What if Yemeni civil war never happened
12.What if Somalia won Ogaden war
13.What if Israel never given back Sinai to Egypt after Doomsday war of 1973
14.What if Sea Lion was successful
Bruh 1 already happened
I LOVE HOW THE THUMBNAIL IS KING GHIDORAH! W TOHO W MONSTERVERSE W RUclipsR
6:15 Big Poland or Big Germany? Turns out you CAN have both in the same alt-hist scenario!
What about the Stalin notes becoming reality scenario? I heard a condition for it was that the SPD becomes the majority after ww2, the notes say that Germany can regain its former pre ww1 eastern territories from Russia on the condition that Germany becomes a neutral country after ww2.
This was a great video. 👍 Peace ✌🏻
Appreciate all that!
OMG can't wait! Love these
2nd time asking for "what if everything went perfect for Serbia" Love your videos ❤
I can do all endings, so expect that next month maybe
@@rewriting-history thx ❤️
One Problem With The No Oil Ending Is They Can Just Buy From Norway
6:12 italy would still loose south tyrol because most are and were german, but they would still keep trentino, since trentino isnt german
Hmm, what if Germany managed to save some colonies even after ww1, there is a chance of that😮😅
There is a really cool scenario about that!
😊👍
Given British naval superiority there is a 0.000 percent of that. I don't think people appreciate how powerful Britain was in 1914. They could have won the war by themslves with minimal casualties if they didn't send troops to France and just did the blockade.
@@commodorezero themselves Really ?
@@commodorezero and why are you saying all this here ?
About the “what if Germany never unified” scenario. Bavaria and the other middle states didn’t want integration with Austria and Austria pushing towards it might lead to them actually being on Prussia’s side in that war (much of the Bavarian population favored Prussia over Austria)
The Holy Roman Empire was VERY holy, VERY roman and VERY imperial 😡
Are they tho? 🤣🤣
5:26 you forgot to colour in Prussia
5:43 you forgot our boy East Prussia!!!
video idea: what if after the Austro-Prussian war, a confederation was formed between Prussia, south Germany, Austria and Hungary
kaiser in exile ending seems epic
Nice video!
In the Weimar ending, I think there would be a chance that Italy would also lose the German majority parts of South Tyrol to Germany.
What if Poland Lithuania won the coalitions?
6:08 Italy can lose German-speaking South-Tyrol.
I’ll watch this after the premiere as I don’t want to watch The end before watching the start
The churhill ending was kinda cursed with south germany or danube confediration being a long boi
It was, and it's funny it was a real proposal
5:28
I'm not sure if you noticed but east prussia isn't closed in
Will u make a interactive video for ww2 i loved the first one❤
4:10 you got this Part a bit mixed up. The Saar Basin was more or less it's own State after WWI, but the French had Access to our Coal Mines. After 15 Years, there was set to be a Votum if the Saar Basin should join Germany, France, or keep the Status Quo under Governance of the League of Nations acc. to the Treaty of Versailles.
What caused the Hyperinflation was Belgium and France marching into the demilitarized Zone (all German Areas on the left Side of the Rhine River) which included Germany's industrial Heart Land, the Ruhrgebiet, in order to get the Reparations the Weimar Government couldn't pay. It was then that the General Strike was started by the German Government as a Way for the French-Belgian Mission to fail, as no Goods would be produced to collect. But as the Weimar Government then had to pay the Wages of the Workers which was Money they didn't have, they simply printed it.
This is important to understand the Scale of the Events. The Saarland, even today, has hardly a Million People (that includes me) and was expanded westwards in Comparision to the historical League of Nations Mandate State Saargebiet. The Areas on the left Side of the Rhine had several Million People and Workers.
7:00 In Addition, could have very well been possible. There was a briefly existing German State in 1848, that ultimately failed because the chosen Kind refused the Crown and then led the Counter-Revolution.
But there were actually different Approaches to what the Territory of the State should be: The Kleindeutsche Lösung (pretty much the 1871 German Reich), the Großdeutsche Lösung (that included Moravia, Bohemia and Austria) and the Siebzigmillionenlösung that included all Holdings of the the Habsburg Empire. The Großdeutsche Lösung would have pretty much been what you suggest here, but it failed because the Habsburgs were unwilling to give up Hungary, Galicia etc. But if we assumed that a hungarian Uprising was successful and the hungarian Lands entirely lost, this could have maybe happened to prevent further Revolutions and Break-Away-States. Maybe if the hungarian Revolution was successful but the German one not under the Erfurter Union suggested by Prussia which was much more favourable for the Nobles.
Plz full video for the empire in exile
I can do something better! Stay tuned!
@@rewriting-history thanks
26:44 Kevin Baugh is angry
Can you make a full cenario on Ernst Thälman island?
I assume it won't get many views, but I can do a short!
Okay , new idea:
What if: ww1 lasted for longer, and everybody were so exhausted by war that all great powers collapsed , except for USA and Japan
That german Empire in exile looks interesting
I knew people would love it! Expect to see something really interesting about that!
13:10 The most interesting scenario of Germany going communist is ww1 lasting year longer and going the same way it did IOTL, and the government gets couped in late 1919 by the Sparticus league and growing more powerful that OTL (similarly to Russia IOTL), and the social democrats are unpopular due to their support in the war. The Sparticus league is joined by millions of defecting soldiers and they crush the Freikorps which are outnumbered, outgunned, and unsupported by the central government. The civil war is over by early 1922 with a communist Victory.
The thumbnail💀
Hah, did you like it?
@@rewriting-history idk man gives some wehraboo vibes
Weird scenario that i think could change some stuff: what if the usa didn't demand repayments of loans when the great depression hit? This could lead to europe being much more stable (economically and politically), possibly weakening Hitler's popularity for instance. It could also lead to a weaker usa in the short term (and some radicalisation is possible) though they should actually recover quicker due to trade and stuff being easier (its hard to trade if everyone else is bankrupt)
Where's the ending where Liechtenstein forms Germany :(
I should have really added it. No worries, soon I will do all endings Liechtenstein, and no, I'm not joking!
Also you should've added an ending where the germans went into exile to the dark side of the Moon, like the popular movie Iron Sky. Or you could do a separate video on it, it would be awesome. Or a video where the germans went into exile to their controlled part of Antarctica lol.
14:03 18:40 and 19:36 is prob the nicest in my opinion for some obvious reasons
Good video I like the ending with democratic Germany it was interesting
No South Tyrol for Weimar? This is so sad
Honestly I should have added it in some endings, so I forgot. Should have added it
@@rewriting-history It’s alright. The Tanzania ending was definitely my favorite of them all. Definitely the most unique in the list.
@@blazingblizzard-6894 I appreciate that! Will definitely make a video on that! Or even, something more special?
You forgot one Ending: Dutch uniting Germany, the Idea is acutaly from the Flanders region of Belgium and is called Alldutch Movement
Damn bro I cant believe you -didn't- -do- *edit: did* Turkish Germany ending 😔
TURKEEEEEY
All Endings Vila La France
About the next video I can
The German empire in exile needs a video
Soon I will do one! I can even do something more special soon!
@@rewriting-history good ur videos are very awesome
You mean Wilhelm II. after his abdication?
@@huntingrunner sure I guess
@@davimendesboni8777 Well, there's some nutjobs that call themselves the imperial german government in exile in Germany, so called "Reichsbürger". I just wanted to make sure you weren't suggesting a video about them.
I be down for and unified German Realm and having those cantons that aren’t German being annexed by Italy and France. And I agree the Belgians shouldn’t be a thing anymore, the buffer state had its time in the sun.
Amazing Endings, Nice! German Empire is my personal favorite. 👍
Same here! I'm thinking of doing something special around this ending!
I think in the Weimar Republic Scenario Germany could buy Danzig from Poland
It's likely, I don't rule it out as a posibility
All endings france maybe?
Slight nit pick, but the occupation borders of Germany were agreed apon before the end of WWII, at the Yalta conference i believe, so there's no way they'd get all of Germany, especially when the west hated communism so much. Still a really good video and it's easy to tell you spend lots of time and effort making your videos, please keep up the good work
I like the Weimar ending the most
Can u make Bulgaria all endings pls🙏🙏🙏
In the future I will. I can focus my effort and recent videos on doing more "All Endings"
Good afternoon brother, I'm sorry if I'm annoyig,you're very busy and I understand that but will my sugestion be ready this month, I wish you a nice day and God bless you.
full video!
All endings France please
I could do it next, depends on what the people vote!
10:49 so unrealistic. Österreich would also have reconquered Schlesien.
And I don't think that Preußen would have lost Brandenburg as well.
Do you remember about warsaw uprising idea?
Bulgaria gets macedonia and serbia is mad so they declare war on bulgaria but greece becomes a bulgarian ally instead of a serbian one
@rewriting-history Hey comrade, can you make an alternative history were in the ww2 peace treaty the SFR Yugoslavia had annexed Bulgaria with Stalin's permission?
i want full video on the german empire in exile
plus i wanna see an independent saxony scenario
Many people want a video on the German Empire scenario, will announce something big regarding that soon, stay tuned!
as a german, i appreciate this video! love from germany to bulgaria! 🇩🇪❤🇧🇬
Appreciate that! Love Germany! This year I will go to Munich, so cheers
@@rewriting-history when exactly?
good video but please stop having the Subscribe Button appear on screen in the video and have the mouse clicking it, its very distracting
I am having bloody diarhirea from the tension as we speak
What tension?
What program u use for ur mapping
And did u make the maps?
All endings germany 🎉🎉🎉
Finally! Hope you will like it!
@@rewriting-history from your channel is only the best
Scrumptious
Lore of All Endings: Germany momentum 100
This is a good comment
This is a good reply and liking and giving heart ro the comment
@ChaseAus_this is a good emoji
@@rewriting-historyThis is a good reply to a reply.
What do u use to make these vids
I map with paint. net and edit with Camtasia Studio
We are on the 4 gdp place not on the 3
I wanted the Frankish republic or Frankish empire ending
bro what where those hre borders uve taken to represent it? (also holy , roman, and an empire)
I don't think you want to suggest that a free democratic Germany is the bad version like you do in the thumbnail. As a German, not cool
Content is good, it’s just…. And I hope this won’t cause any offense… it’s difficult to listen to because the narrator rolls their “R”s, every single one…
Kind of makes it sound like they’re talking underwater… *not trying to be a jerk, hopefully it’s constructive feedback*
What if Russia was lead by a competent family and leader during the industrial revolution?
Im german really hard to undertsand
Can’t wait please do all endings Ireland
I can do it soon!
@@rewriting-history thank you can some of the endings be Kilkenny Stays the capital , and another one being Johnathan Swift gaining independence for Ireland and the last idea is If Saint Bernadad made a country in North America and it was an empire when the Europeans Came to America plz
is this live or not??
It was live, now you can watch it!
VERY excited For the video! Hearth please ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
There you go! Hope that you will like it!
@@rewriting-history thanks! 🙏🙏🙏
Crimea?
Danish germany 1864 never again
Nice
You reminding me my friend bulgarian, but he lives in odesa(ukraine)
How come? What do we have in common?
@@rewriting-history knows like everything bout history and everything, Bulgarian, etc.
All Endings USA
In the next few videos I can do this!
In your opinion how far would german puppets be into russia?
Not further that the A-A line
@@raiden5181 tbh I agree
I'm like 1000 😎
Hello
ai
I hate Oster ending
Why is that?