What if Palpatine told the senate he was Sidious when he was elected (not illegal by the time of the prequels)? What if Padme didn’t trade Anakin for grievous when they were both captured on naboo What if Anakin used force lightning in various moments throughout the clone wars? What if Palpatine sensed vadar’s betrayal in return of the Jedi? What if Gungi stayed with the bad batch? What if Caleb joined the bad batch when his master died? What if Caleb survived the fire on Lothal? What if Ahsoka got to coruscant with maul before Mace windu left for the chancellors office? What if Ezra found luke instead of obi wan on Tatooine? What if Illum gave Anakin a red kyber crystal?
@@nderdragon7 these r definitely good concepts but seemingly difficult to write im sure, that’s probably why no one has actually done them, or its cus they dont like the ideas
This What If NEEDS a part 2. You’re really good at writing stories that have twists and turns, so regardless of what events transpire, I do know it’ll be well-worth watching!
@@starwarsquillyou gotta start putting part 1, part 2, etc in the titles. Cuz I get excited when you say you’re gonna do a part 2 then I can never find it.
Anakin: He could actually...save people from death? Palpatine: The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural. Anakin: I mean cool and all - but I already learned this ability from the Jedi archives. Thanks for the proposal though. Palpatine: What?
Mace Windu - we grant you the rank of master but we don’t have enough chairs Anakin - What how can you do this this is outrageous it’s unfair how can I be a master and not have a chair Mace - take a seat master Skywalker oh wait you can’t
Darth Sidious: "A powerful Sith, you shall become! Henceforth, you shall be known as Darth… Vader!" Nightfall Vader: "No! A powerful Sith, I already am! You shall bow before me, and show me the information I must know! … Or else!" _That would be a plot twist!_
I hope we get a part 2 where Anakin because of his self healing training and deeper connection to the force, manages to come out of the stasis or even use it to regrow his arm, frees Yoda and Obi Wan and they lead the Jedi Order and go ballistic on Palpatine's ass with Palpatine shitting bricks because full potential Anakin is after him.
When Anakin tells Yoda that someone is going to die , " don't mourn and don't grieve be happy that they died ." But when Anakin tells the little green hypocrite that jedi are going to die , " Prepare for war !!!! , lose our power I must not . !!!! " .
Man, this is really good. You have to continue with part 2. This story is really interesting. You are really good at making these scenarios, you are very precise. Keep up the good work!!!! I would imagine that the bad batch might or would come for them, but Rex would not play any role in this due to Ahsoka not having been there for him, and not removing his chip. The bad batch would regardless find their way to Tantiss I imagine even without Rex or maybe they could kidnap Rex and save him, with Jesse and many more troops because of Echo. If they would run to each other the batch would save Rex and his squad I think. Sooner or later the empire would find Omega, due to Nala Se's reasons in the Series and Hemlock would search for her. That's my opinion. Also, Anakin could heal himself to a certain degree because of his now-learned abilities, maybe resist the transfer. Also, I would imagine that the Jedi Masters who leading the Outpost would try to search for allies, seek information, or maybe just scout for potential younglings, and survivors like Cal Kestis, Caleb, and Ezra. Regardless of what they do the Order wouldn't be totally isolated I think.
I wish to give you my thanks for the use of Plagueis and his powers in Palpatine's hands. It's fantastic horror tool - I can confirm as a horror writer. Thank you thousand times. I am looking forward to what goals will Palpatine achieve by mutating, cloning and midichlorianing the Jedi council, the ways and possibilities are enormous! Please, take as good care in the 2nd part as you did in the 1st part. Thank you for a great experience! ❤🎉
Terrific story. And what a finish! Wow, that was darker than _Revenge of the Sith_ in my opinion. Always love it when Sidious is respected as a villain in what ifs, even if it spells a horrible fate for our favorite Jedi.
The plotline of Anakin panickin' over Padme's death never made sense to me. Padme is a senator, she was the queen of naboo. So logically she should have access to the best hospitals and doctors in the galaxy. So wouldn't she drag Anakin to a check up (under the guise of a guard or put on a mustache and glasses as a disguise 🥸) and show that she and the babies are healthy.
This story is one of the saddest and most unnerving ones, knowing that everything and everyone is about to become Palpatine’ s own puppets gets you to question the very future of the Galaxy
Try this one 👌🏾 “What if Bode Akuna never betrayed Cal Kestis & joined the mantis crew” This I’ve been requesting to multiple Star Wars fan fictioners but nobody has done it yet 🤣🤷🏾♂️
What if Anakin *broke Bariss out of Prison* to use her Force Healing to save Padme? As for context, I imagine he wouldnt be aware of any healers on Coruscant. Shak Ti is a maybe? I know her location is supposed to be secret, but if Anakin had his visions earlier, he could try to convince the Chancellor to tell him, wherein the Chancellor, likely knowing his game, would either encourage this or try to off Bariss before he frees her?
I’m inclined to believe that the Skywalker family would be too strong-willed for Palpatine to succeed in using Essence Transfer on them, although he could manipulate them into turning to the Dark Side. However, Sidious is more interested in being the ultimate power in the universe and would most likely merely train them to act on his behalf when needed rather than as true apprentices when he realized that he couldn’t use Essence Transfer on them.
What if Dooku convinced Maul to join him and they killed Palpatine together and decided to continue fighting the republic until the Separatists were recognised as official
I have an Idea for a multi- episode what if scenario. This was inspired by the injustice comics. The premise Anakin becomes Emperor after he defeated Obi Wan on mustafar and Killed Palpatine soon after. The story involves political intrigue, heroics, as well as a deep dive into just how far someone can fall For example, Anakin may be a good leader of men but I believe he would be a poor emperor. From purging people he would see as slighting him, Taken and other Palpatine supporters, to just an outright purge if the senate as he would see them as all corrupt. He would rule through brut force. I don't believe he would reach his full potential in this time line. In his mind he killed Palpatine, who defeated Yoda, he killed Obi-Wan, and has even convinced himself he beat Windu, he believes he is already the best and his ego will stunt him. And I don't want to get too much into how he " saves" Padme, but if you are interested in this story please let me know.
What if Ahsoka Tano trained Starkiller after Order 66? What if Obi wan Kenobi trained Starkiller after order 66? What if Baylen Skoll after order 66? What if The Ghost Crew adopted Starkiller as a child?
I say go with the bad batch story but combine it on the tantis story but with clone rebels with rex and ect realizing what happened afterwards and saving Anakin and the children and other force users and go with the rebellion story afterwards
Lol "Force healing" Only seen in video games. In the movies it never worked on blaster wounds or light saber stabs. Any healing was ever done by robots and bacta tanks.
What if Luke and Leia got married and had children BEFORE learning they're brother and sister. What if when Anakin went to ILUM to get his first kyber crystal he found the first NATURAL RED crystal. What if JarJar had a kultz attack and knocked over the vase revealing Palpatine's hidden lightsaber. What if due to childhood trauma Palpatine developed a split personality thus Palpatine DIDN'T KNOW he was Sidious. What if while tinkering with machines Anakin accidentally created a force sensitive droid.
"What if while tinkering with machines Anakin accidentally created a force sensitive droid." Oh god, imagine R2 or *shudders* Choppenheimer having the force. Then their would be 2 sith lords skulking about!
If able to ..basically escape, I envision him having a revelation of how he would happen to have his own healing powers..and would see his children for who and what they were..and in healing them..all 3 would near instantly defeat the Emperer..though not unscathed; in time-line..Luke, looses his left hand, but sadly Leah, lost her right hand and arm..and the same leg.. His prosthetic is as the other Luke's would be, Leah, a fondness MANDILORIAN armored systems and tools they are known to favor.. In particular..the ones..BOBA FET.. is well known to prefer. Of course she naturally made additions and modifications of her own..making her more than a match..even without the FORCE... The children..grown up, would by his healing efforts..would recognize who-and-what he was to them. He.. seeing this, would emedately take them to the hidden Jedi world. There, they would be more deeply trained by Masters..that had come to see for a more fully encompassing teaching and view of the FORCE.. as the, JE-DI, once did..making Anakan, very satisfied with how the order had changed.
or MAYBE Jedi Knights have different aptitudes and Anakin was a warrior at heart and not a healer, whereas Barris is more of a healer and not so much a warrior.
The video of the what it is Good, however.. you waste to much time on the "SIDE NOTE" recapping. Which breaks away from the "What If" story your trying to tell. Just cut out all the Side Notes, and explain stuff. And just focus on the What if story. Fans of star wars Should/Will already knows what happen in the Original.
I'm sorry but I have to disagree. I have seen more than a few of your videos now and in all of them literally everything, or almost everything,that could go wrong with the jedi does while sidious seems to be an omnipotent god, where everything works out for him. While, yes it is your theory, it just feels, to me sidious has extreme plot armor. Just my opinion on this, not an attack or anything.
I don't see the top jedi masters captured. They become test things to experiment on. hahahhahahaha yeah right. Wouldn 't ever happen. Even in a fictional story. Yoda and Windu force pushed a whole droid army away along with their ships. With the help of Obi Wan, Anakin, Ashoka and the other masters, they could demolish the clones. Sorry but I don't see them losing that fight. I liked the story up until that point. That is when it fell apart. It made the best of the jedi look like weak fools which they were not. Both Yoda and Windu defeated Sidious by themselves. Only the betrayal of Anakin did Sidious get the chance to hit Windu with lightning and because a thousand clones were approaching the senate was Yoda forced to retreat. With the combined powers of those jedi masters, they would have demolished the attacking clones no matter how many there were. Plus nobody but dark and evil people want the dark side to win. Good always defeats evil. Just the way it is. Palpatine must die. No transfering into Anakin or anyone else. After the jedi destroy the clones at the temple. They find Sidious and carve him up like a turkey during thanksgiving. The ending is just to wrong to make this story good and enjoyable. Like I said, it started out really good but ended in disaster. Sorry but thumbs down on this one.
What if Palpatine told the senate he was Sidious when he was elected (not illegal by the time of the prequels)?
What if Padme didn’t trade Anakin for grievous when they were both captured on naboo
What if Anakin used force lightning in various moments throughout the clone wars?
What if Palpatine sensed vadar’s betrayal in return of the Jedi?
What if Gungi stayed with the bad batch?
What if Caleb joined the bad batch when his master died?
What if Caleb survived the fire on Lothal?
What if Ahsoka got to coruscant with maul before Mace windu left for the chancellors office?
What if Ezra found luke instead of obi wan on Tatooine?
What if Illum gave Anakin a red kyber crystal?
Ain’t no way this man casually handed Quill the guidebook to a starwars what if franchise-
He is a true genius!
@@nderdragon7 these r definitely good concepts but seemingly difficult to write im sure, that’s probably why no one has actually done them, or its cus they dont like the ideas
This What If NEEDS a part 2. You’re really good at writing stories that have twists and turns, so regardless of what events transpire, I do know it’ll be well-worth watching!
Yes👍 Part 2 would be amazing
Thanks, man :) Means a lot to me :)
@@starwarsquill please part 2!!
Please part 2
@@starwarsquillyou gotta start putting part 1, part 2, etc in the titles. Cuz I get excited when you say you’re gonna do a part 2 then I can never find it.
Anakin:
He could actually...save people from death?
Palpatine:
The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural.
Anakin:
I mean cool and all - but I already learned this ability from the Jedi archives. Thanks for the proposal though.
Palpatine:
What?
it's outrageous it's unFAIR. How can you save people from death, and not be a Sith
Mace Windu - we grant you the rank of master but we don’t have enough chairs
Anakin - What how can you do this this is outrageous it’s unfair how can I be a master and not have a chair
Mace - take a seat master Skywalker oh wait you can’t
I just picture Mace Windu saying that with a totally straight face and tone, but in his mind he's laughing maniacally at Anakin.
Yoda: jarrel poofs seat you may use, out getting pizza he is
@@JediMasterZim the whole council exept Obi Wan is laughing
Anakin: *Force-chokes Windu and knocks him out of the window before taking his seat*
@@99thJediWarrior kicked out less then a few min of becoming a master great job lol
Darth Sidious: "A powerful Sith, you shall become! Henceforth, you shall be known as Darth… Vader!"
Nightfall Vader: "No! A powerful Sith, I already am! You shall bow before me, and show me the information I must know! … Or else!"
_That would be a plot twist!_
I hope we get a part 2 where Anakin because of his self healing training and deeper connection to the force, manages to come out of the stasis or even use it to regrow his arm, frees Yoda and Obi Wan and they lead the Jedi Order and go ballistic on Palpatine's ass with Palpatine shitting bricks because full potential Anakin is after him.
When Anakin tells Yoda that someone is going to die , " don't mourn and don't grieve be happy that they died ."
But when Anakin tells the little green hypocrite that jedi are going to die , " Prepare for war !!!! , lose our power I must not . !!!! " .
Man, this is really good. You have to continue with part 2. This story is really interesting. You are really good at making these scenarios, you are very precise. Keep up the good work!!!!
I would imagine that the bad batch might or would come for them, but Rex would not play any role in this due to Ahsoka not having been there for him, and not removing his chip. The bad batch would regardless find their way to Tantiss I imagine even without Rex or maybe they could kidnap Rex and save him, with Jesse and many more troops because of Echo. If they would run to each other the batch would save Rex and his squad I think. Sooner or later the empire would find Omega, due to Nala Se's reasons in the Series and Hemlock would search for her. That's my opinion. Also, Anakin could heal himself to a certain degree because of his now-learned abilities, maybe resist the transfer. Also, I would imagine that the Jedi Masters who leading the Outpost would try to search for allies, seek information, or maybe just scout for potential younglings, and survivors like Cal Kestis, Caleb, and Ezra. Regardless of what they do the Order wouldn't be totally isolated I think.
I wish to give you my thanks for the use of Plagueis and his powers in Palpatine's hands. It's fantastic horror tool - I can confirm as a horror writer. Thank you thousand times. I am looking forward to what goals will Palpatine achieve by mutating, cloning and midichlorianing the Jedi council, the ways and possibilities are enormous! Please, take as good care in the 2nd part as you did in the 1st part. Thank you for a great experience! ❤🎉
You're very welcome!
@@starwarsquill Thank you, I am honored ♥️
Terrific story. And what a finish! Wow, that was darker than _Revenge of the Sith_ in my opinion. Always love it when Sidious is respected as a villain in what ifs, even if it spells a horrible fate for our favorite Jedi.
What if Revan spoke to Anakin while he waited in the council chambers
19:20 here I said, “Please say Tanalorr.” And 20 seconds later it’s brought up. Thank you 🙏 😊
The plotline of Anakin panickin' over Padme's death never made sense to me.
Padme is a senator, she was the queen of naboo. So logically she should have access to the best hospitals and doctors in the galaxy. So wouldn't she drag Anakin to a check up (under the guise of a guard or put on a mustache and glasses as a disguise 🥸) and show that she and the babies are healthy.
This was incredible, what a cliffhanger, please make a part 2 🔥
great story. this is a rare one in that it manages to have an even worse ending than canon. (well, complicated, but more or less worse)
A great setting for a Star Wars DnD campaign...the Meme Team comes to the rescue!
This story is one of the saddest and most unnerving ones, knowing that everything and everyone is about to become Palpatine’ s own puppets gets you to question the very future of the Galaxy
Anyhow, wonderful and terrific story! Amazingly hit😃😊
A part two would be greatly appreciated.
How do you only have 8k subs ;-;
Please do a part 2. This story feels incomplete
That’s actually a truth of our world.
To heal others you must first heal yourself
Revenge of the Sith, but Sly Moore slips on a banana and dies instead of always killing Padme in these video's
Gee, when arriving on Tanelorn, do they meet Grand Master Elric, with his legendary lightsaber "Stormbringer?"
Try this one 👌🏾
“What if Bode Akuna never betrayed Cal Kestis & joined the mantis crew”
This I’ve been requesting to multiple Star Wars fan fictioners but nobody has done it yet 🤣🤷🏾♂️
Definitely needs more
Not necessarily on the "Destroy Luke and Leia"... redemption is still always possible. Revan proved that.
He already was a master...
of Getting Caught
What if Anakin *broke Bariss out of Prison* to use her Force Healing to save Padme?
As for context, I imagine he wouldnt be aware of any healers on Coruscant. Shak Ti is a maybe? I know her location is supposed to be secret, but if Anakin had his visions earlier, he could try to convince the Chancellor to tell him, wherein the Chancellor, likely knowing his game, would either encourage this or try to off Bariss before he frees her?
Nicee
That’s a great idea!
I didn't understand why you didn't have Palpatine fight the three Jedi. Other than that, I thought this was a very well done fanfict. Excellent job!
I’m inclined to believe that the Skywalker family would be too strong-willed for Palpatine to succeed in using Essence Transfer on them, although he could manipulate them into turning to the Dark Side. However, Sidious is more interested in being the ultimate power in the universe and would most likely merely train them to act on his behalf when needed rather than as true apprentices when he realized that he couldn’t use Essence Transfer on them.
What if Anakin and Obi-Wan and Qui-gon started a secret jedi order away from the Core planets and told only Padma
What if Palpatine's Sith identity got exposed to EVERYONE early in the Clone War?
Please make what if Palpatine got burnt on Mustafar instead of Anakin in Revenge of the Sith?
What if Shmi was a wandering Jedi Master and trained Anakin when Qui-gon found them. Or what if Anakin and Shmi were decendents of Jedi Master Revan
What if Dooku convinced Maul to join him and they killed Palpatine together and decided to continue fighting the republic until the Separatists were recognised as official
We need part 3
26:02 If the story had progressed this far into our normal history wouldn't Grevious have been killed on Utapo by now? Or atleast Dooku dead?
I figured since he led the Separatists as well, Sidious would have no problem finishing them off even without the Jedi :)
I have an Idea for a multi- episode what if scenario.
This was inspired by the injustice comics.
The premise Anakin becomes Emperor after he defeated Obi Wan on mustafar and Killed Palpatine soon after.
The story involves political intrigue, heroics, as well as a deep dive into just how far someone can fall
For example, Anakin may be a good leader of men but I believe he would be a poor emperor. From purging people he would see as slighting him, Taken and other Palpatine supporters, to just an outright purge if the senate as he would see them as all corrupt.
He would rule through brut force.
I don't believe he would reach his full potential in this time line. In his mind he killed Palpatine, who defeated Yoda, he killed Obi-Wan, and has even convinced himself he beat Windu, he believes he is already the best and his ego will stunt him.
And I don't want to get too much into how he " saves" Padme, but if you are interested in this story please let me know.
part 2 pls
What if Ahsoka Tano trained Starkiller after Order 66?
What if Obi wan Kenobi trained Starkiller after order 66?
What if Baylen Skoll after order 66?
What if The Ghost Crew adopted Starkiller as a child?
I love the idea about Sidious being fully open about being a Sith. Endangered religion protected by the Republic. ❤
Thank you, your Veronika
Can you please do "what if Palpatine was genuinely a good person and the Jedi were wrong about him"
Anakin could also be released by the Bad Batch, if they still make their way there and join forces with them
Part 2 we need a part 2 of this !!!!!
What if the Jedi suddenly vanished while setting up clones/Senate in a way to make the Clones/Senate look like they are at fault?
I say go with the bad batch story but combine it on the tantis story but with clone rebels with rex and ect realizing what happened afterwards and saving Anakin and the children and other force users and go with the rebellion story afterwards
Ultimately turning this into a rather unique trilogy
Make a part 2
You got that right ! Palpatine wouldn't fight Windu if he didn't expect Anakin to join his side.
What if c3po appeared instead of obi wan on mustafar lol
What if only grievous survived the beginning of Revenge of the Sith
What if Darth Maul cloned his Mandalorians specifically Rook and Saxon and made a whole army of them because they where the most loyal?
Lol "Force healing"
Only seen in video games.
In the movies it never worked on blaster wounds or light saber stabs.
Any healing was ever done by robots and bacta tanks.
What if Dooku and Grievous betrayed Palpatine
Can you make part 2 with the good ending please?
I think Anakin would use the healing arts he learned to free himself and his children
What if Luke and Leia got married and had children BEFORE learning they're brother and sister.
What if when Anakin went to ILUM to get his first kyber crystal he found the first NATURAL RED crystal.
What if JarJar had a kultz attack and knocked over the vase revealing Palpatine's hidden lightsaber.
What if due to childhood trauma Palpatine developed a split personality thus Palpatine DIDN'T KNOW he was Sidious.
What if while tinkering with machines Anakin accidentally created a force sensitive droid.
"What if while tinkering with machines Anakin accidentally created a force sensitive droid."
Oh god, imagine R2 or *shudders* Choppenheimer having the force. Then their would be 2 sith lords skulking about!
Dear God All-Mighty,NO! The first one is to messed up.
So here it would have been best for anakin to have fled because darkness now rains supreme for the rest of eternity
If able to ..basically escape, I envision him having a revelation of how he would happen to have his own healing powers..and would see his children for who and what they were..and in healing them..all 3 would near instantly defeat the Emperer..though not unscathed; in time-line..Luke, looses his left hand, but sadly Leah, lost her right hand and arm..and the same leg..
His prosthetic is as the other Luke's would be, Leah, a fondness MANDILORIAN armored systems and tools they are known to favor.. In particular..the ones..BOBA FET.. is well known to prefer. Of course she naturally made additions and modifications of her own..making her more than a match..even without the FORCE...
The children..grown up, would by his healing efforts..would recognize who-and-what he was to them. He.. seeing this, would emedately take them to the hidden Jedi world. There, they would be more deeply trained by Masters..that had come to see for a more fully encompassing teaching and view of the FORCE.. as the, JE-DI, once did..making Anakan, very satisfied with how the order had changed.
What if Loot Skywalker opened the wrong treasure chest?
He’d be pulled into the House of the Dragon universe
Part 2 dew it
what if bail organa was the sith lord
Maybe Omega or the clones would save the jedis during the uprising
Do more Rebels what if 🙏🙏
What if the Sith Empire (swtor) attacked during the clone wars
Well that sucks. :/
or MAYBE Jedi Knights have different aptitudes and Anakin was a warrior at heart and not a healer, whereas Barris is more of a healer and not so much a warrior.
Lol. I messed my previous comment up with bad grammar. My apologies.
haha thanks, man :)
What if Anakin became Chancellor? 🤨
Last one
what if yoda was doctor who?
The video of the what it is Good, however.. you waste to much time on the "SIDE NOTE" recapping. Which breaks away from the "What If" story your trying to tell. Just cut out all the Side Notes, and explain stuff. And just focus on the What if story. Fans of star wars Should/Will already knows what happen in the Original.
I used to not do that but them some people got mad at some of the ways the stories went so I ended up doing that again :/
Nop all three wack Palpatine
I'm sorry but I have to disagree. I have seen more than a few of your videos now and in all of them literally everything, or almost everything,that could go wrong with the jedi does while sidious seems to be an omnipotent god, where everything works out for him. While, yes it is your theory, it just feels, to me sidious has extreme plot armor. Just my opinion on this, not an attack or anything.
I'm batman
Noice.
Another fantasy of Palpatine fanboy.
If you don’t like a video, please keep the rudeness to yourself
second
:)
FIRST!
Thanks for watching :)
@@starwarsquillThank you! I love your content, man.
I don't see the top jedi masters captured. They become test things to experiment on. hahahhahahaha yeah right. Wouldn 't ever happen. Even in a fictional story. Yoda and Windu force pushed a whole droid army away along with their ships. With the help of Obi Wan, Anakin, Ashoka and the other masters, they could demolish the clones. Sorry but I don't see them losing that fight. I liked the story up until that point. That is when it fell apart. It made the best of the jedi look like weak fools which they were not. Both Yoda and Windu defeated Sidious by themselves. Only the betrayal of Anakin did Sidious get the chance to hit Windu with lightning and because a thousand clones were approaching the senate was Yoda forced to retreat. With the combined powers of those jedi masters, they would have demolished the attacking clones no matter how many there were. Plus nobody but dark and evil people want the dark side to win. Good always defeats evil. Just the way it is. Palpatine must die. No transfering into Anakin or anyone else. After the jedi destroy the clones at the temple. They find Sidious and carve him up like a turkey during thanksgiving. The ending is just to wrong to make this story good and enjoyable. Like I said, it started out really good but ended in disaster. Sorry but thumbs down on this one.