does speed effect quality on the Bambu labs P1P 3d printer? (surprising results)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 янв 2025

Комментарии • 53

  • @TheFpc20
    @TheFpc20 Год назад +9

    Really thanks for this, this kind of test can help others that usually print this kind of products on their printers, a lot of people print customized keychains for sell them, i'm one of them and most of the time the design have letters that due to the size of them is not possible to print them fast without get bad quality, and print time is always a big issue for offer good price to client, this test show exactly what i was trying to find for decide to buy the p1p, I was thinking that by printing fast the letters could be affected but bambulab printers are absolutely game changer, thanks to this test I will buy my first one🙌

  • @joebroderi
    @joebroderi Год назад +29

    I can't tell anything from this video ! because you have your camera movement in ludicrous mode ! slow it all down mate..... steady

  • @iron_sight_8727
    @iron_sight_8727 Год назад +2

    My vape cartridge holder i designed prints in 9hrs on my ender3 v2 neo & on the p1p it takes only 2 & half hrs in standard speed which is awesome

  • @spayrex_
    @spayrex_ Год назад +4

    you maybe want to change the top surface layer pattern and enable "print thin walls" so you get a nice finish

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +2

      Indeed. This was my first Bambu printer. I have 6 now!

    • @PatrickFaulkner-pm8ci
      @PatrickFaulkner-pm8ci 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@jrc-fabs1634 How's reliability been? My p1s with AMS comes in tomorrow!!!! My first ever 3d printer!

  • @randystevens2710
    @randystevens2710 Год назад +7

    Nice video, Some people are just jealous because they are still fighting with their printers like we used to have to do also. It is hard to believe what a fine printer this really is. I print something new every day now. Before, it was just so frustrating having to readjust the setting all the time and hope for a fair print. Now I keep looking for sales on filament in 10 to 20 rolls at a time. Enjoy

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +2

      Couldn't agree more, I used to have a bunch of enders, I had failed prints all the time and I was tired of transporting a bunch of SD cards back and forth to my laptop. Now I have 1 Bambu and 2 more X1Cs on the way. These really revolutionized 3d printing!

  • @bodstrup
    @bodstrup 5 месяцев назад

    I have seen the higher speed modes fail several times - when using ABS or ASA - which are much more prone to warping if layer adhesion is not sufficient.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  5 месяцев назад

      Good call. I agree with this all the way, for an application like this though, there's no problem with full speed

  • @sergeantgaf2212
    @sergeantgaf2212 2 дня назад

    Does printing in L mode lead to greater wear and tear on the printer? Or does speed play no role when it comes to wear? I'm a bit worried about the axles; bearings; Motors and belts. I would appreciate an answer.

  • @Defyant123
    @Defyant123 Год назад +4

    Very nice! is there any structural difference? layer sep?... dry layers overall strength between the fastest and the slowest? Cheers

  • @MitchM240
    @MitchM240 Год назад

    It all comes down to what you print. I use ludicrous on my P1S about 75% of the time and my prints come out perfect. I am making decorative items and toys. There have been many test done and it is fact that layer adhesion and strength of the item is worse the faster the print gets. With that being said for a vast majority of what people print ludicrous is fine.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  10 месяцев назад

      I agree, for this application it's fine for max speed.

  • @dandouge5257
    @dandouge5257 Год назад +3

    Works for a keychain but not on everything. I did the same test on benchies and thevresults were not the same .

  • @davidgalstyan1569
    @davidgalstyan1569 Год назад

    I feel that increasing temps in ludicrous mode will make it much better

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад

      Yeah and I could have put surface ironing on

    • @davidgalstyan1569
      @davidgalstyan1569 Год назад

      @@jrc-fabs1634 I’m not sure what that is, only recently got a printer and I’m still a beginner, could you explain?

    • @OhImKiCkiN
      @OhImKiCkiN Год назад

      ​@@davidgalstyan1569Ironing will run the nozzle over the printed surface without extruding any filament. It smooths the print surface and removes any lines

  • @dovan4092
    @dovan4092 Год назад +1

    It's totally worth silent mode if it's actually silent but you didn't show us the difference in sound

  • @julesgoldstein634
    @julesgoldstein634 Год назад +2

    Was there a noticeable noise difference between the different speeds?

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +4

      Silent mode and normal mode makes a .9 decibal change I believe (that's like nothing)
      On ludicrous mode it's definitely louder but I don't really care because my printers are all in a separate room.

  • @hasserecht3678
    @hasserecht3678 Год назад +1

    Saying Speed doesn't have any negative effect by printing an almost flat object is pretty hilarious

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +1

      Make your own video than

    • @hasserecht3678
      @hasserecht3678 Год назад

      @@jrc-fabs1634 Well if you need a video to realize that molten plastic needs to cool down to properly form intricate features and overhangs ... man than you shouldn't do any 3D printing at all.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад

      I don't need to realize anything because this is my application to 3d printing. It helps for me to know if the speed affects quality.

    • @hasserecht3678
      @hasserecht3678 Год назад

      @@jrc-fabs1634 so now that i told you that speed affects printquality if you are not only printing flat rectangles... well you learned something new. Isn't that awesome? Have a good day.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад

      I didn't learn anything new from you. But I did learn that the speed doesn't affect the quality for my specific application.

  • @rickyneeter69
    @rickyneeter69 Год назад +1

    Insane holy shit! Is changing the print speeds on the machine itself just increasing the speed you choose in the slicer by a certain percentage? I see everyone just changing the speed on the machine but what if I want it to go slower than silent mode? I ordered a p1p aswell so I am curious

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +1

      Yes it just multiplies the slicer speeds! Good question

    • @NarcoSarco
      @NarcoSarco Год назад

      Jeah switching from changing the print speeds to just changing the flow rate like the modes on the P1P is really helping.

  • @CS-pl8fc
    @CS-pl8fc Год назад

    Is there a reason it is printing PLA at 250C? I thought typical ranges for PLA were 185-210

    • @andybolfert2277
      @andybolfert2277 11 месяцев назад +1

      It's just heating to 250 to purge old filament. It will drop to printing temp after that. But I usually print pla around 220. Have to increase temp to match up to the faster speeds.

    • @CS-pl8fc
      @CS-pl8fc 11 месяцев назад

      @@andybolfert2277 thanks for the info.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  10 месяцев назад +1

      Heat needs to go up for higher speed

  • @dosdont
    @dosdont 8 месяцев назад

    can the different modes be chosen in orca or does it have to be chosen manually on the printer screen?

  • @RussDahlberg
    @RussDahlberg Год назад

    um, wow. This was very impressive. I just... yeah wow.

  • @user-tj7xr6xd9z
    @user-tj7xr6xd9z Год назад +3

    This really isnt a good test lol speed I think is more of a case by case basis... You choose the most simple thing to print try doing more complex items you may get some different results 3d printing isn't always a blanket statement.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +6

      Stop hating bro😭 it was a good test for me because I make keychains and sell them.
      Respect it or leave

    • @user-tj7xr6xd9z
      @user-tj7xr6xd9z Год назад +3

      @@jrc-fabs1634 I respect that context is key sometimes keep calm and print on.

  • @Dadgrammer
    @Dadgrammer Год назад

    I’m using x1c for month now. I try fastest mode few times, 100% was failed. In normal speed was printers perfectly.
    Usually I mix slow and normal, because I’m in same room.
    For me fastest is not useable for now.
    I love this printer, but this speed is not usable yet.

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад

      Been using a while on ludicrous mode it just takes some adjustments on slicer

  • @מתןיהונתןרובינשטיין

    The only thing a scam here is your life

    • @jrc-fabs1634
      @jrc-fabs1634  Год назад +5

      What?

    • @core36
      @core36 Год назад

      What?

    • @מתןיהונתןרובינשטיין
      @מתןיהונתןרובינשטיין Год назад +1

      @@jrc-fabs1634 you've said in the video that ludicrous mode and all other modes of speed give the same results, that is not true at all, most models disform badly using Ludicrous. which is not seem to be well tested in your video since your using a very easy to print stl. almost all other uses of models will be worsen when printing in Ludicrous.

    • @מתןיהונתןרובינשטיין
      @מתןיהונתןרובינשטיין Год назад

      @@core36 And sorry for my language I was tripppin' so that was my subconsciousness speaking when I saw it.