Thank you for all the comparisons! Wow, a couple of these look very unique. I love that they decided to make matte single shadows and hope for many many more shades. Pretty disappointed there is still squishy issue and inconsistencies and/or problems with quality control. I do not really want to spend cost of a Clionadh shadow on something I would have to fix myself. It is so confusing why this keeps happening.
You are such a LEGEND for doing this. I'm actually considering picking up the empty palettes & mattes ngl. Course I JUST said I wasn't going to purchase from oe anymore 😅
Great review, swatch comparisons and thorough explanations. I have been disappointed by this brand both mattes and shimmers within the last year, I will not be purchasing anything until I hear about improved formulas.
your metallic eyeshadow comparison video has been THE reference for me lately. have you since found a true silver dupe for terra moon's moon kissed (discontinued). does terra moon's nebula whisper compare? I just wanna be an aluminum foil robot sending out signals to my extraterrestrials.
Love the video and the swatch comparisons. I'm so torn on this. I have acquired so many singles the last few years (including all the Stained Glass from Clionadh) so I'm having a hard time justifying more singles. I will for sure get the empty palettes because the round one Odens Eye singles are in the clunky plastic ones lol, but I'm struggling with the singles. Do I need them? No. Not do I want them anyways? Yes. 😅🤣
Milly❤❤❤ omgosh!!! Thank you for this Video & absolutely THE WAY YOU CONVERTED the eyeliner Case into a magnet to hold the singles SHADOWS 🙏 👍🏻 GENIUS 😂🎉😂❤👏 👏 👐
I love how thorough you are and that you explain the feel of each shadow. You show off the shifts sooo well, too! I'm considering trying a few of these, but I am not sure if I will... the fact that they never answered any of their emails about the formula issues is very off-putting. And isn't it weird that they still launch new singles with the same issues?? It seems like it's their formulation for the shadows that is the issue, so i find it very odd that it isn't even consistent within the multichromes/shimmers. Very confusing for the customers.
I was about to tell Millie to check your IG to see how to fix overly oily eyeshadows 😅 Anyways thanks to you I managed to fix every eyeshadow that creased on me!!! Thank you thank you thank you ❤❤❤
@@MartesMakeup yes, frustration mostly!!!! 😁 My friends call me the little chemist now. I had to dry up all the shimmers in the Harvest Moon as well, some were ok just by pressing some tissue paper on them, but the others I had to treat with alcohol as well. But now she's perfect!! 🙏🙏🙏
Sometimes I get a vibe that brands don’t take people with creasing issues seriously, as if it’s our fault and we aren’t using the eyeshadow correctly. It’s really frustrating. Even more so when I see brands claiming “budge proof”. Im sure they will get emails with this collection as well as people receive their orders. The more people who voice their issues the better.
Where can I go for that video on fixing the shadows? I may buy a couple and risk it as a newbie, but want to make sure I have a back up plan in case I find it creases on me. Thanks
Hi Milly, just commenting to keep up engagement! I just love your multichrome content, and appreciate the comparisons. Those comparisons remind me of which shades I actually use once I buy them!
You are THE best at swatches! I wasnt going to pick anything up since I don't really reach for my other odens eye singles but Mason, looking, ve and Matthew are intriguing.
Thank you for all the work you put into these videos Milly. I think I'll be making my first Oden's Eye order. That magnetic palette is to die for and they have some unique shadows😍.
Your videos are so helpful! I especially appreciate you mentioning the ones that are very squishy vs not. I have very oily eyelids & hooded eyes. And your tip about pressing out some of the oil?! So useful! Thank you!!!! I do have a question: what is your fave brush to use on some of these more squishy shades? I often feel like I’m just pushing the product around, and nothing‘s getting on the bristles. I do often use my finger, but sometimes I need a brush to just neaten things up.
*Used your code thank you so much for all the effort you put in your satches and comparisons. You have saved me a lot of money from impulse purchases lol!*
Thank you, Milly! Your videos are always so helpful. And I totally agree with you - I wish there were more mattes! Those are what I'm most interested in. Also thank you for discussing the formulas! I have problems with creasing, and the only squishy formula that has ever not creased on me is the Touch of Glam Color Me Multi shades. I don't know how, but those babies are bulletproof on me! I'm leery of all other squishy shadows, though. lol
Thank you, your videos are the most informative among all beaty bloggers. The job you are doing with catching all the shifts and comparisons is incredible! ❤ I bought some of that creamy sticky shades (e.g. Mason), probably we'll need a video for how to fix that kind of shades 😅
You are so thorough. I love your comparisons. Those empty palettes are amazing. I am tempted to pick up a few. Some of those individual are now on my list as well. Thank you ❤
That FIRST look took my breath away! So beautiful! So, Loki, Linnea, Angelica and Grace are definites for me. Not sure how I could get some of those sticky, wetter eyeshadows to work on my genetically super-hooded, prone to being oily even though I'm 65 years old eyelids, but I WILL try at least one just to see an idea I have may just work: lay down my MAC Painterly paint pot, set that down with a matte eyeshadow... and take small amounts of the sticky emollient ones and hope for the best!
Very helpful video. It’s so many shadows that I get overwhelmed with the deciding process and just want say f it and get it all but your video helps me pick out what I don’t need ❤
Thanks Milly! Tempted but I just bought a ton of Clionadh shadows (with your code!) thanks for being so thorough it helps when shopping and of course for the comparison bop music you play lol
thank you so much for the detailed description of each of the formulas in addition to the swatches. such a bummer that all the shades that draw me in are squishy. big no-go because I can see them settling into my lid folds.
You mentioned that the texture is squishy on many of those.. last time with the singles I think some were very dry and flaky. I think it sucks that everyone raves about oden's eye eventhough their quality isn't consistent. Thank you for being transparent.
Well, this is exciting. They look so pretty, but it sounds like I won’t be able to use some of the squishier ones (thank you for telling us that). Is Loki similar to Leon? I see a bronze flip, but the red reminded me of Leon immediately.
The only newer palettes I own from Odens Eye is Trick Or Treat. How would you say the shimmers/metallics compare? Cause the dark green is so wet that it creases bad on my very hooded lids... Thank you for going in dept and showing every single shade 😊
What are your recommendations for creasing issues? I spent sooo much money on these because i heard the nyx glitter primer would help, but they still crease like crazy. Is there anything you do??
Thank you for this! Can you please enlighten me what you mean by pressing the oils out? I criticized the squishy-ness in my swatch video too and I don't like this texture at all! If you have as solution - I am here for it
🎉 Affiliate code: MILLY
I used it!! thank you!!!! I agree they should do all primary mattes then do Neutrals and build from that, I like to build my own palettes, i love leon
I love how you show similar shades feom other brands. Makes it so very helpful when shopping ❤ Thank you, Milly
Im so glad! I hope to prevent people from getting duplicates
Thank you for all the comparisons!
Wow, a couple of these look very unique. I love that they decided to make matte single shadows and hope for many many more shades.
Pretty disappointed there is still squishy issue and inconsistencies and/or problems with quality control. I do not really want to spend cost of a Clionadh shadow on something I would have to fix myself. It is so confusing why this keeps happening.
So far from watching other videos it seems the squishy shades are consistently the same shades. I hope they do adjust them
You are such a LEGEND for doing this. I'm actually considering picking up the empty palettes & mattes ngl. Course I JUST said I wasn't going to purchase from oe anymore 😅
🤣 I want to buy two more empty palettes to put the original shades in!
You and Seeking Shifts are the best channels for swatches and reviews! These look so pretty, but not a good formula match for my hooded eyes.
Great review, swatch comparisons and thorough explanations. I have been disappointed by this brand both mattes and shimmers within the last year, I will not be purchasing anything until I hear about improved formulas.
Thank you for such in depth descriptions!!! Some of these shades look sooo gorgeous but I’m so torn after not loving the formula last time around 😭
These are definitely consistent with the previous shades. Idk if it’s worth the risk!
your metallic eyeshadow comparison video has been THE reference for me lately. have you since found a true silver dupe for terra moon's moon kissed (discontinued). does terra moon's nebula whisper compare? I just wanna be an aluminum foil robot sending out signals to my extraterrestrials.
Love the video and the swatch comparisons. I'm so torn on this. I have acquired so many singles the last few years (including all the Stained Glass from Clionadh) so I'm having a hard time justifying more singles. I will for sure get the empty palettes because the round one Odens Eye singles are in the clunky plastic ones lol, but I'm struggling with the singles. Do I need them? No. Not do I want them anyways? Yes. 😅🤣
Enjoy your Clionadh shadows for some time, and see if you still would like any of these, any shades that stand out to you. They will be around!
Milly❤❤❤ omgosh!!! Thank you for this Video & absolutely THE WAY YOU CONVERTED the eyeliner Case into a magnet to hold the singles SHADOWS 🙏 👍🏻 GENIUS 😂🎉😂❤👏 👏 👐
Thank you!!! I felt so accomplished 🤣 love the desin of it and wanted my oden’s eye shades to be in branded palettes
I love your work. So thorough.
I so agree❤
Thank you! I try!
I love how thorough you are and that you explain the feel of each shadow. You show off the shifts sooo well, too! I'm considering trying a few of these, but I am not sure if I will... the fact that they never answered any of their emails about the formula issues is very off-putting. And isn't it weird that they still launch new singles with the same issues?? It seems like it's their formulation for the shadows that is the issue, so i find it very odd that it isn't even consistent within the multichromes/shimmers. Very confusing for the customers.
I was about to tell Millie to check your IG to see how to fix overly oily eyeshadows 😅 Anyways thanks to you I managed to fix every eyeshadow that creased on me!!! Thank you thank you thank you ❤❤❤
@@theblondefaery aw I'm so glad to hear it! Seems like it's a quick trick that saves a lot of time and frustration! 🤭❤️
@@MartesMakeup yes, frustration mostly!!!! 😁 My friends call me the little chemist now. I had to dry up all the shimmers in the Harvest Moon as well, some were ok just by pressing some tissue paper on them, but the others I had to treat with alcohol as well. But now she's perfect!! 🙏🙏🙏
Sometimes I get a vibe that brands don’t take people with creasing issues seriously, as if it’s our fault and we aren’t using the eyeshadow correctly. It’s really frustrating. Even more so when I see brands claiming “budge proof”. Im sure they will get emails with this collection as well as people receive their orders. The more people who voice their issues the better.
Where can I go for that video on fixing the shadows? I may buy a couple and risk it as a newbie, but want to make sure I have a back up plan in case I find it creases on me. Thanks
Oooh…that matte red! ❤ Thank you, queen of swatches, comparisons, and multichromes!
🥹🫶🏻
Hi Milly, just commenting to keep up engagement! I just love your multichrome content, and appreciate the comparisons. Those comparisons remind me of which shades I actually use once I buy them!
You are THE best at swatches! I wasnt going to pick anything up since I don't really reach for my other odens eye singles but Mason, looking, ve and Matthew are intriguing.
That makes sense! Save your coins!
Thank you for all the work you put into these videos Milly. I think I'll be making my first Oden's Eye order. That magnetic palette is to die for and they have some unique shadows😍.
You’re SO welcome!! Which shades do you have your eye on?
Now that I know nothing has changed with the formula, I'll be saving my money and looking into Clionadh instead. Thank you so much, as always!!
Your videos are so helpful! I especially appreciate you mentioning the ones that are very squishy vs not. I have very oily eyelids & hooded eyes. And your tip about pressing out some of the oil?! So useful! Thank you!!!! I do have a question: what is your fave brush to use on some of these more squishy shades? I often feel like I’m just pushing the product around, and nothing‘s getting on the bristles. I do often use my finger, but sometimes I need a brush to just neaten things up.
*Used your code thank you so much for all the effort you put in your satches and comparisons. You have saved me a lot of money from impulse purchases lol!*
The undisputed swatch champ 🏆✨💛 Thank you!
🤣❤️❤️ thank you
Thank you, Milly! Your videos are always so helpful. And I totally agree with you - I wish there were more mattes! Those are what I'm most interested in.
Also thank you for discussing the formulas! I have problems with creasing, and the only squishy formula that has ever not creased on me is the Touch of Glam Color Me Multi shades. I don't know how, but those babies are bulletproof on me! I'm leery of all other squishy shadows, though. lol
I appreciate your content so much, it's so informative and great visuals 💜
Thank you so much!
Thank you, your videos are the most informative among all beaty bloggers. The job you are doing with catching all the shifts and comparisons is incredible! ❤
I bought some of that creamy sticky shades (e.g. Mason), probably we'll need a video for how to fix that kind of shades 😅
You are so thorough. I love your comparisons. Those empty palettes are amazing. I am tempted to pick up a few. Some of those individual are now on my list as well. Thank you ❤
The palettes are SO beautiful and inexpensive, I hope they make even more!
That FIRST look took my breath away! So beautiful! So, Loki, Linnea, Angelica and Grace are definites for me. Not sure how I could get some of those sticky, wetter eyeshadows to work on my genetically super-hooded, prone to being oily even though I'm 65 years
old eyelids, but I WILL try at least one just to see an idea I have may just work: lay down my MAC Painterly paint pot, set that down with a matte eyeshadow... and take small amounts of the sticky emollient ones and hope for the best!
I admire your reviews, they are so detailed and beautiful. Thanks especially for the comparisons, it helps a lot
Ohhh, this is so tempting. I'm on a no buy when it comes to palettes right now, but singles are fair game..
🤣🤣
Very helpful video. It’s so many shadows that I get overwhelmed with the deciding process and just want say f it and get it all but your video helps me pick out what I don’t need ❤
Thanks Milly! Tempted but I just bought a ton of Clionadh shadows (with your code!) thanks for being so thorough it helps when shopping and of course for the comparison bop music you play lol
I have referred back many times to the comparisons. Thank you, Milly!
thank you so much for the detailed description of each of the formulas in addition to the swatches. such a bummer that all the shades that draw me in are squishy. big no-go because I can see them settling into my lid folds.
You mentioned that the texture is squishy on many of those.. last time with the singles I think some were very dry and flaky. I think it sucks that everyone raves about oden's eye eventhough their quality isn't consistent. Thank you for being transparent.
Great comprehensive video. Did the same thing with my eyeliner palette x
🙌🏻
you sharing other brands similar colors is soooo helpful!
Dupes for Leon:
"Lights Out" by Karla Cosmetics
"Head Rush" by Terra Moon
What a gorgeous combo "Leon & Loki" would make!😍
Lights out and head rush aren’t dupes for Leon
so helpful!!!
Well, this is exciting. They look so pretty, but it sounds like I won’t be able to use some of the squishier ones (thank you for telling us that). Is Loki similar to Leon? I see a bronze flip, but the red reminded me of Leon immediately.
Omg that Mason shade has me drooling 🤤
Gorgeous ❤❤😮
Thank you! 😊
The only newer palettes I own from Odens Eye is Trick Or Treat.
How would you say the shimmers/metallics compare? Cause the dark green is so wet that it creases bad on my very hooded lids...
Thank you for going in dept and showing every single shade 😊
Thank you for your honest and detailed review❤
Thank you so much for your honesty!!!. Did you do a wear test on a squishy shades? I have hooded eyes and question if i should buy these.
Lovely video as always! Can you tell what are the shade names you point at at the end?
What are your recommendations for creasing issues? I spent sooo much money on these because i heard the nyx glitter primer would help, but they still crease like crazy. Is there anything you do??
Making a list with video.
Thank you for this! Can you please enlighten me what you mean by pressing the oils out? I criticized the squishy-ness in my swatch video too and I don't like this texture at all! If you have as solution - I am here for it
Here is a video on how i press the oils out! ruclips.net/video/AOSD0XV8dQk/видео.htmlsi=r0os3L589wumWOnG
@@badtothebrowthank you!! ❤
Great in depth review as always, I’m so sad about the formulas because some of the shades were truly unique. Sighhhh 🙃
Loki and Matthew and Ve aren’t squishy and those I think are the most unique!
Matthew,That is Halloween👻🎃🧡💚💜🖤 , no way Christmas🤣😂 but I guess it can be what ever you want it to be‼👍🤣😂
On the purple blue eye look what brushes are you using?
don't know if the link part also matters but I don't see an Oden's Eye link
👍🏻
🖤
❤️❤️
❤
🥰🥰🥰
lol 24:40 if you ever wanna do ASMR with makeup..
Angelica Elara luna sol mason WyattLogan loki matthew bragi