Nice bags but these are all so huge, not really applicable for me at all fishing freshwater lakes and rivers. If they were 1/2 or 1/3 the size would work great.
Ordering one right now, for our boat! With your endorsement, don't be surprised if the price goes up. I've seen similar happen a lot. You sold me! We always take 2 small coolers, 1 for food and beverages, another for fish. They're constantly in the way! This bag appears to take up less room than either of our coolers! Ordering through your link!
@@spiltmilt Your video didn't result in increased pricing, BUT, it quickly resulted in availability issues lol. Mine is scheduled to arrive tomorrow, finally!
I got the columbia pfg bag 2.5 years ago. The zipper still works. I love this bag. It is so easy to clean. I also take mine ice fishing. It keeps my lunch and drinking water from freezing. I can put my fish in there and keep them from freezing hard by putting snow in the bag to cover the fish. I wish they made a light grey colored bag for those hot sunny summer days.
I literally was just looking for a good catch bag, but wasn’t too sure what to get, so I ended up getting a 20 qt Titan Deep Freeze instead because it was on sale. Great video.
You should check out the Columbia PFG Zipperless Cooler. The 48 can version is 19 inch wide internally so it's perfect for Kokanee and Trout. No zipper to mess with, and it's the same external material as the PFG bag in your video, no leaks, etc.
Thanks for the helpful video. I've been needing to upgrade my kill bag for awhile now. I do enjoy your channel and was happy to use your link to buy the Columbia bag. Thanks again.
Just got one in from sportsman's Warehouse as per your suggestion! They seemed to have fixed yhe zipper issue with rolling the hem. Been great the last few hot days!!!
I was looking to get that Columbia bag but it was out of stock every where so I ended up with your standard catch bag. For Kokanee/trout it was too big so I picked up a smaller bag from wilderness pack specialties and it’s awesome. Plus I’m supporting a company that right down the road from me in Cornelius OR.
Great rundown! Looks like any of the bags could be improved with a magnetic closure system below the zipper for easy in and out access. A Gore Tex certified repair person like the one who who replaced a zipper on a backpack I’ve used for years could help with the zipper on an otherwise ideal catch bag. Thanks for everything.
Perfect timing on this video. I was out at Lake Merwin stacking limits of Kokanee and large trout and some of the bigger ones didn’t fit into the Mini Playmate hard cooler I was using. Might have to invest in a Columbia bag. Awesome review as always
That looks like a much better behind the seat kayak bag than the one I’m using. I often get passes for the Columbia company store, so I’m going to look for one next time I go. Thanks.
Thanks Tyler…just ordered the Columbia one! I’ve been using a $10 insulated zip up bag from Trader Joe’s. It’s cheap and gets the job done, but kinda thin and also it’s primary purpose is for my wife to use it for groceries. So, doing the upgrade makes sense
I was literally just talking to a fellow kayak angler at Lake Merwin yesterday and asking him for his recommendations! Ended up with 5 Kokanee and 1 giant triploid trout thanks to your tips and it's only my second time out.
Love the PFG review. I use a lot of their pants, shirts, and vests while fishing. I was wondering if you could do a review on (what you feel might be) the best PFD Fishing Vest? As always, I appreciate you opinions, and all the knowledge that you freely share> All my best.
I’ve used that Columbia bag for the last three years it’s fantastic. After three years of more than 30 uses per season, the zippers haven’t failed on mine yet; keep your fingers crossed.Thanks for the video Tyler.
The insert bags, do you feel they're puncture resistant, for holding perch, crappie and walleye? I've recently been fishing an area where I'm catching Kokanee, Big Crappie and Perch, all in the same spot. I've thought, once mine arrives hopefully tomorrow, it would allow me to keep Kokanee and trout in one insert, crappie and perch in the other.
They're all way too big Tyler. I've been using black garbage bags with no problems for years. Slip that bag into a Calcutta style kill bag with ice and you're good to go.
Great Video... Would you recommend any of those bags for flying your fish home? Say if your staying at a place with a fridge/freezer & freeze your filets, through them in the bag & possible make it a Checked bag if you've got around 50lbs of fish (minus bag weight) or if you're going to use a carry on or personal bag pack style? What would you recommend for that?
I haven't used bags this big but have used similar smaller bags to move frozen fish across the country. For half day flights we just transport the meat frozen and it makes it there with minimal thawing. For longer cross country flights we will also add some dry ice to ensure it makes there unthawed.
@@spiltmilt I'll be fishing in Florida, just trying to prepare. First time there. About a 5-6 hour flight from where I am plus a 2 hour drive home. I think I might try some ice packs in an Ozark trail backpack cooler.
Thanks for the info, but I have a question cause I have an addicted fishing bag and love it for a year and a half. What leaks on it? Also what do you do for ice I was freezing oj bottles but went with buying 20lbs bag of ice and making a water slurry for my salmon and trout. Fish lake superior.
@@spiltmilt really hmm I have yet to see that. Will keep in mind about a future bag of this goes. What do you do for ice just straight or do you make a ice/water slurry? The slurry is what I do get the fish cold fast.
I have a question. Is there any Kokanee lakes or reservoirs without predators _ trouts, perch. I appreciate your videos. I have put more Kokanee in the freezer this year because of you. Thank you
I have the columbia bag as well and like it a lot. of course my zipper failed after just a couple trips. Im wondering if there is a way I can open the mouth a little more and get someone to put in a new zipper. one that works well.
I don’t kayak fish but I do have an Opah Fathom 5 Bag. For my boat it is the bomb. With the super thick insulation it keeps ice for days! Tuna, ling cod, rockfish and sturgeon have all been in my bag with no issues. Fish fillets in ziplock bags and my lunch and drinks all stored in the inner zippered pocket. They are pricey bags but they are worth the price.
I’ve already been using old version of Columbia pfg bag, hoping to find a better one but found this video and reassured I still had the best one lol. Yes, this bag is awesome, still in a good condition after 3 years of heavy salt water fishing.
I picked up a Columbia one a few years back. Been solid except for the zipper issue as you noted. I had some rockfish spines puncture one of the bags but it was pretty over filled and I wasn’t being careful. If you have employee store access they are even a better deal.
Tyler- Not sure the best video to post a question on so I’ll just post it here. I just got my first fishing kayak and I’m going to fish a reservoir in Colorado for Kokanee as well as other things. I don’t have a downrigger -how can you calculate the depth you’re trolling at when you’re using one of the sliding weight rigs? I know it’s a factor of the amount of weight? Feet of line and trolling speed but if there’s a video that goes into that I haven’t found it yet. Any suggestions or point me in the right direction? Thanks!
Thank you so much for the reviews of items you use. It is so helpful to be able to click a link ang get something that requires some time to research and locate. would you be willing to share info on your foldable storage case for wobblers ?. Thank you again for your time and confidence building.
I fish here in Fl and most have a lot of spines and poke holes in bags like that. The best thing I’ve found are the small igloo marine coolers that are 20” long, 12” wide and 12” deep.
Nice bags but these are all so huge, not really applicable for me at all fishing freshwater lakes and rivers. If they were 1/2 or 1/3 the size would work great.
you link for the Columbia PFG First Cast 45L Catch Bag doesnt work just so you know
CHICKENS!!!
CHICKENS
CHICKens
Chickens
chickens
chick?
Are you trying to get us drunk? 🥴🤤😵💫😵
How many chickens can you get in that bag?
😂
For cheap bags, don’t use raw ice. Ice cuts soft cooler liners causing them to leak. Use ice packs instead or frozen water bottles
Ordering one right now, for our boat! With your endorsement, don't be surprised if the price goes up. I've seen similar happen a lot. You sold me! We always take 2 small coolers, 1 for food and beverages, another for fish. They're constantly in the way! This bag appears to take up less room than either of our coolers! Ordering through your link!
Thank you! I really appreciate it.
@@spiltmilt Your video didn't result in increased pricing, BUT, it quickly resulted in availability issues lol. Mine is scheduled to arrive tomorrow, finally!
I got the columbia pfg bag 2.5 years ago. The zipper still works. I love this bag. It is so easy to clean. I also take mine ice fishing. It keeps my lunch and drinking water from freezing. I can put my fish in there and keep them from freezing hard by putting snow in the bag to cover the fish. I wish they made a light grey colored bag for those hot sunny summer days.
thankkkk youuuuu finally an answer to the question "where do I put my fish when I catch one on my kayak?"
*immediately sends the Columbia bag link to wife for a future present since she never knows what to get me*
Thanks as always for the great content!
I literally was just looking for a good catch bag, but wasn’t too sure what to get, so I ended up getting a 20 qt Titan Deep Freeze instead because it was on sale. Great video.
Great video. Thanks for producing it. I’ll give the Columbia bag a go.
Thanks for the review. Been shopping for an affordable kill bag 👍🏻
Perfect, I am in the market for a new bag; going with the Columbia PFG First Cast 45L Catch Bag, thanks!
You should check out the Columbia PFG Zipperless Cooler. The 48 can version is 19 inch wide internally so it's perfect for Kokanee and Trout. No zipper to mess with, and it's the same external material as the PFG bag in your video, no leaks, etc.
I have look at those but they are much taller which makes it more challenging to get the fish in the bag from the seat.
Thanks for the helpful video. I've been needing to upgrade my kill bag for awhile now. I do enjoy your channel and was happy to use your link to buy the Columbia bag. Thanks again.
Just got one in from sportsman's Warehouse as per your suggestion! They seemed to have fixed yhe zipper issue with rolling the hem. Been great the last few hot days!!!
How did you use that white bag for 5 years if the zipper broke so quickly?
I was looking to get that Columbia bag but it was out of stock every where so I ended up with your standard catch bag. For Kokanee/trout it was too big so I picked up a smaller bag from wilderness pack specialties and it’s awesome. Plus I’m supporting a company that right down the road from me in Cornelius OR.
It would be nice if they went to magnets on top. Would last for a long time
I agree
I currently have a mustang bag but want to die is I'll probably switch to your recommendation. :) Thanks again for the video!
The columbia bag is down to $53 so I bought one immediately. Thanks for your great suggestions!
Great rundown! Looks like any of the bags could be improved with a magnetic closure system below the zipper for easy in and out access. A Gore Tex certified repair person like the one who who replaced a zipper on a backpack I’ve used for years could help with the zipper on an otherwise ideal catch bag. Thanks for everything.
That’s a really good idea
…. a really really good idea
That's an awesome idea! You know, once the zipper falls, that wouldn't be too difficult to accomplish!
Perfect timing on this video. I was out at Lake Merwin stacking limits of Kokanee and large trout and some of the bigger ones didn’t fit into the Mini Playmate hard cooler I was using. Might have to invest in a Columbia bag. Awesome review as always
That looks like a much better behind the seat kayak bag than the one I’m using. I often get passes for the Columbia company store, so I’m going to look for one next time I go. Thanks.
Thanks Tyler…just ordered the Columbia one! I’ve been using a $10 insulated zip up bag from Trader Joe’s. It’s cheap and gets the job done, but kinda thin and also it’s primary purpose is for my wife to use it for groceries. So, doing the upgrade makes sense
I was literally just talking to a fellow kayak angler at Lake Merwin yesterday and asking him for his recommendations! Ended up with 5 Kokanee and 1 giant triploid trout thanks to your tips and it's only my second time out.
Love the PFG review. I use a lot of their pants, shirts, and vests while fishing. I was wondering if you could do a review on (what you feel might be) the best PFD Fishing Vest? As always, I appreciate you opinions, and all the knowledge that you freely share> All my best.
Here you go ruclips.net/video/xP87h9Am0kk/видео.html
I’ve used that Columbia bag for the last three years it’s fantastic. After three years of more than 30 uses per season, the zippers haven’t failed on mine yet; keep your fingers crossed.Thanks for the video Tyler.
I have both the Addicted catch bag and the PFG. I have had the PFG for 4 years or so. Really like the removable liners. I wish more bags had this.
The insert bags, do you feel they're puncture resistant, for holding perch, crappie and walleye? I've recently been fishing an area where I'm catching Kokanee, Big Crappie and Perch, all in the same spot. I've thought, once mine arrives hopefully tomorrow, it would allow me to keep Kokanee and trout in one insert, crappie and perch in the other.
Used them for rockfish and walleye for years with no issue
Very valuable topic with great points. Thank you for this.
They're all way too big Tyler. I've been using black garbage bags with no problems for years. Slip that bag into a Calcutta style kill bag with ice and you're good to go.
Seems like a waste of plastic to me
Great Video... Would you recommend any of those bags for flying your fish home? Say if your staying at a place with a fridge/freezer & freeze your filets, through them in the bag & possible make it a Checked bag if you've got around 50lbs of fish (minus bag weight) or if you're going to use a carry on or personal bag pack style? What would you recommend for that?
I haven't used bags this big but have used similar smaller bags to move frozen fish across the country. For half day flights we just transport the meat frozen and it makes it there with minimal thawing. For longer cross country flights we will also add some dry ice to ensure it makes there unthawed.
@@spiltmilt I'll be fishing in Florida, just trying to prepare. First time there. About a 5-6 hour flight from where I am plus a 2 hour drive home. I think I might try some ice packs in an Ozark trail backpack cooler.
Thanks for the info, but I have a question cause I have an addicted fishing bag and love it for a year and a half. What leaks on it? Also what do you do for ice I was freezing oj bottles but went with buying 20lbs bag of ice and making a water slurry for my salmon and trout. Fish lake superior.
Mine developed a seam leak in the lower right corner on the third trip. Into the garbage it went. My Calcutta lasted only two trips. LOL.
@@spiltmilt really hmm I have yet to see that. Will keep in mind about a future bag of this goes. What do you do for ice just straight or do you make a ice/water slurry? The slurry is what I do get the fish cold fast.
I just put them on ice directly no slurry
I have a question. Is there any Kokanee lakes or reservoirs without predators _ trouts, perch. I appreciate your videos. I have put more Kokanee in the freezer this year because of you. Thank you
I don’t know of any pure Kokanee lakes. Most have trout, bass, or pikeminnow present
For the columbia pfg bag, do you put ice in the inserts or in the bag?
In the inserts
I am a raft guy but I love my pfg bag!! Great review video!
I have the columbia bag as well and like it a lot. of course my zipper failed after just a couple trips. Im wondering if there is a way I can open the mouth a little more and get someone to put in a new zipper. one that works well.
Some viewers suggested some sort of magnet system. That would seem easy to pull off
I don’t kayak fish but I do have an Opah Fathom 5 Bag. For my boat it is the bomb. With the super thick insulation it keeps ice for days! Tuna, ling cod, rockfish and sturgeon have all been in my bag with no issues. Fish fillets in ziplock bags and my lunch and drinks all stored in the inner zippered pocket. They are pricey bags but they are worth the price.
I use a Costco bag. Not sure how much longer it will last but was under 20
I used those for a while too. Good value
Great video as usual!
I’ve already been using old version of Columbia pfg bag, hoping to find a better one but found this video and reassured I still had the best one lol. Yes, this bag is awesome, still in a good condition after 3 years of heavy salt water fishing.
I picked up a Columbia one a few years back. Been solid except for the zipper issue as you noted. I had some rockfish spines puncture one of the bags but it was pretty over filled and I wasn’t being careful. If you have employee store access they are even a better deal.
Great video, thanks for the info. Just ordered the Columbia bag.
I definitely needed this video!!👍👍 Thanks 😁
Tyler- Not sure the best video to post a question on so I’ll just post it here. I just got my first fishing kayak and I’m going to fish a reservoir in Colorado for Kokanee as well as other things. I don’t have a downrigger -how can you calculate the depth you’re trolling at when you’re using one of the sliding weight rigs? I know it’s a factor of the amount of weight? Feet of line and trolling speed but if there’s a video that goes into that I haven’t found it yet. Any suggestions or point me in the right direction? Thanks!
I use this calculator liveprecise.com/tdepy.html
Use zipper spray lube or a solid lube stick on your zippers you'll be amazed with the difference in using them.
Thanks for the tip
@@spiltmilt You're Welcome.
You could run a bar of soap down the zippers too. Works really well.
@@crowman5936Which brand do you use to lube the zipper? There's so many mixed opinions
Thank you so much for the reviews of items you use. It is so helpful to be able to click a link ang get something that requires some time to research and locate. would you be willing to share info on your foldable storage case for wobblers ?. Thank you again for your time and confidence building.
Lure safe dodger luresafe.com/product/39vm-kokanee-dodger-20-pocket-jacket-pockets-2-%c2%bc-x-6-%c2%bd/
Wish I could have seen footage of you trying them in your yak
They just sit in the stern.
I fish here in Fl and most have a lot of spines and poke holes in bags like that. The best thing I’ve found are the small igloo marine coolers that are 20” long, 12” wide and 12” deep.
We have the same here with our rockfish, cabezon, and some spiny rays species. Luckily the Columbia inserts have held up well.
I can’t see any of them bags being any good for a kayak