+LiskowicStudios Good luck with all the trials facing Europe and know that many in America will proudly die beside you in defense of republican freedom
if you look at alot of her comments I argue with her a decent amount, but an opinion is worthless if it can't be defended ask her to defend hers and she can't we should strive to be better than all of them
I descend from Morris's company of Virginia Rangers and William Powell. You don't speak for me and a Southern man like Jackson would not hear of it. You betrayed the Constitution and worked with the British foe. And now you want to dishonor Robert e Lee's solemn promise not to raise his sword. It's not a joke.
have a look at some of the songs from the Irish Rebellion. This song, or rather the actual music is pinched from one of them.... The Rising of the Moon
Minus some of the bigotry that some of the songs have , I think the confederate songs really express the heart of America , which is why I feel the war was so disturbing , you can feel America in the music of both sides.
They can take down every statue in existence but they can never extinguish the pride of all southerners who still remember the bravery and honor of those who wore the gray.
If your "heritage" is fighting for the right to own other people, you would forgive the rest of us for exercising our GOD giving right to be contemptuous of you.
Open carry, it is still legal in NC. Do it. I am a Marylander and would be put in jail for it. You still have that right. Exercise it, and if you have a rifle for me, I will take part in your picket.
@@mohameddiaby835 I do not attempt to condescend, and as such, I truly hope that you might read reputable sources such as Bruce Catton's 'This Hallowed Ground'; to assume the war was ENTIRELY about slavery is asinine even amongst reputed historians. Certainly it was a major factor, but it ignores a half century of economic 'bullying', for lack of a better word imposed upon the south. I care for you as a human, and as such wish the best for you. I would hope that you might at least consider the same for myself, and look at the many other factors that led to the war. A war of that magnitude cannot be maintained for that long, with such an EXTREME body count without the will of the common man of the dissident faction, and (forgive me for I do not recall) something to the order of 95%-99% of all southerners did not own slaves.
it was the battle flag my great grandfather fought for, when his home state of GA.surrendered he did not. He died in Osaka Japan and never took an oath of allegiance to the United States. He married my Grandmother there in Osaka. I honour his life and what his honour taught me. Nothing to do with slavery.
That is just about the dumbest, (and most incorrect), analysis of the Civil War that I have ever heard. Where do you people get such unrealistic ideas?
I am a Pole, so were my ancestors. My family has served in the army for very long, even before my country was brought back they fought for the Austrian Kaiser as Poles. Today i found an old picture of my grandpa in his uniform, a picture completely worn out and almost falling apart. It was then that I was reminded of this song. You might wonder why I say this all, after all it is not about the CSA, but this songs reminds me of all the men who stood up for something in their lives, especially in the army. Glory to them.
@@kronosdarkness5202 they were fighting to be free! They were fighting for states' rights! Look at the Federal Government? Wiped out the South, then Indians, now it is out of control!
Lived in northern states before. Didn't like them. Way too regulated. Nothing like being Southern. Starting with freedom to own firearms. Then there is our cuisine. Pure Southern. Also the hospitality is greater.
Take a chill pill. I believe your post had some racist overtones such as and I am quoting you: "Your black people." That is a bit over the top and sounds quite bigoted and insensitive. But then most liberals are the real bigots and hide behind a false sentiment of patriotism.
@@hickspaced2963 Exactly! We should stop worsipping soviet union, british empire and nothern us., for they are a great example of '''how to win a war and still be a loser'' stuff..
In what’s now known as the “Cornerstone Speech,” Stephens told a Savannah, Ga., crowd in 1861 that “our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas [as those of slavery foes]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.” He went further: the battle over slavery “was the immediate cause of the late rupture and present revolution.” you are a horrible parent if your Teaching hatred to your children @@rokasvalickas9686
rosemarie443 God Bless The C.S.A. too and the greed was from the North, also slaves where not liberated in the North either till after the war, it was on the way out all over the World anyway, your Civil War was about power & the Blacks lost, their still slaves today, only now to the very federal government that purported to "free them." what a fucking joke. Revenge is a dish best served cold. The South will rise again and this time we should separate America into two Nations then the rest of you Godless folks can go your own way.
rosemarie443 Ha, do you really think the people in Our military will fight us? If they do, they will have to be pretty corrupt to do so. If a civil war does breakout, I believe groups of soldiers will refuse to obey orders.
rosemarie443 We have a right to protest, but it should not have violence. If the police attack peaceful protesters that is corruption. No doubt about it.
rosemarie443 Ha, I didn't vote for no one. Why vote when it never fixes anything? It's all run by big corporations and your vote never counts. This is why we need a civil war, to get back our country from these evil corps. After all You have voted for them.
I had ancestors from Virginia, West Virginia, Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Missouri and Texas who fought for the Confederacy. Monuments can always be replaced but nothing can erase facts.
Though my family fought the british for 800 years I must say I respect how the brits were ready to jump into the civil war on the side of the confederacy but Jefferson davis didnt want to destroy the union just wanted to back them up
less than 2% of southerners had slaves, still people believe that it was fought over slavery. Abe lincoln himself said "if I could save the union without freeing any slave, I would do it" The emancipation was a political move, not out of compassion for the blacks. The proof is that, after the war, slavery still existed, in different forms, and that the segregation was active untill very recently, all under the Union now.
Say the full quote not just apart "If I could save the union without freeing any slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."
AND YET, Lincoln refused to parley or compromise, or even receive the delegation from the southern states, where a compromise could have been made! War is never about what it seems to be.
@Peter Grahame The South never said anything about abolishing slavery either infact in the Confederate Constitution it protected the institution of slavery and Lincoln made steps to abolishing in 1863 issuing the Emancipation Proclamation freeing slaves in the rebelling states two years later in 1865 Congress passed the Thirteenth Amendment abolishing slavery in the United States
My Great Grandfather fought in the Confederate Army. He was one of 65 that survived in his Unit. I am Proud to be Southern Born and My Great Great Grandfather.
many free black men fought for the confederacy. There was one guy, forgot his name, who bought himself out of slavery in the 1850's, and was paid a fortune by the confederate army to build bridges to transport troops and equipment...
@@chaosmarine8166 FREE black men, not slaves. Several free black men actually kept their own slave plantations in the antebellum south. It wasn't until the end of the war that slaves were given a chance to fight as soldiers, but by then it was too late and they never got to the battlefield before the war was over...
Hell it was not that long ago when the Irish fought for their freedom. The Irish have an indomitable spirit, and have fought for their liberty throughout all of history, no matter how harsh they are punished by England.
iamharald. Absolutely correct. The tune itself is used in several Irish ballads aswell like the Orange and the green, the rising of the moon, and the wearing of the green. I had never heard of this american version of the tune until now, how wonderful the internet is.
@Caroline Lees What are you waffling on about? Read a book and learn some history, my own ancestor from Wicklow fought for the South with his adopted state of Georgia, he was an Irish Catholic along with plenty of others who immigrated across the Atlantic in the 1840s. Get that Scots- Irish only fought for the Confederacy nonsense out of your head.
So you tear up over your southern heritage, the conjured ideas of a sullied honor, that makes you cry. Poor baby, I wish I had some not so well used Pampers for you.
@@Gunshipurl Lincoln invaded innocent Americans and cost this nation over 600,000 lives. Continue idolozing a tyrannical Federal government that has been on the war path since 1861! You Republicans love war though, it is what gets you off at night👍
@@kerentolbert5448"waa!waa! Other people have a history and culture! Waa!" Maybe you should have thought about that before sucking so much. On the one hand, I have heard that I have ancestors that fought on both sides, but I really never heard of the Union ones achieving anything near the honors accorded to the southerners. You guys are pathetic, I would rather face off against 200 drugged up junkies with 5 Florida Men than with 500 of you yankees. You'd run away because you're cowards, and since you're yankees you wouldn't even feel bad about that. Can't y'all yankees just join Canada or something and leave us well enough alone? You suck and you're cowards and I hate you. Now go be part of Canada, oh I swear we'll miss you. Yep we certainly will. Please don't screw off into the Canadian wilderness.
No!I am not a nazi,i hat this idiots and i dont like the slavery I only like the south of the USA,nothing else,they had a good army. And i love Great bBritan too! I lived in the british sector of Berlin and proud of it. The guards in Belsen and Auschwitz wear Fieldgrey ;-) Please, don't be angry with me.
+rosemarie443 Guess why?Because the UK/GB was a state much older then the USA slavery has been a thing since BC and GB/UK was one of the first nations to outlaw slavery.
+keithmcgrath it got a lot worse under under the irish! 40 dark years for for the common man and woman, the mainland was a refuge for the those people, they never went back, their progeny are now british, lol.
@David Broadley You're obviously a product of our government school system that teaches a biased history ... do yourself a favor and read some stories from the other side ... grow into a better person instead of just being an ignorant troll.
My father's mother was from Poznan (she was a Monczak). She told me stories about how speaking Polish in public was illegal during the German kulturkampf. My mother was from South Carolina. Her Great grandfather was a company commander in the 18th SC and died in action at 2nd Bull Run. His brother was Joseph Wofford Tucker. My mother spent summers on her grandmother's farm, and there she heard stories from her great aunts about how it was when the yankees came.
My Babci was btought to America by her uncle, Fr. Jan Pawłowski, before the first world war. The good priest brought her and my Dzaidz, Wm. Szymborski, togeher. Their son, my father, met my mother during the Second World war when he was stationed at an army base near Spartamburg, SC.
I was born and will forever be a Confederate being of this world God bless the south and america. I am proud of my family and all who wore the gray uniform for us so I say everyone wave ur flags high and proud and never let anyone take away what was fought for in the USA. We are proud Confederates and Confederacy. NO ONE CAN TAKE THAT FROM US! The civil war was not fought over slavery but between the north and south and who did not want to be told what to do.
Then you would've fought for the preservation of slavery if you wanted to or not In what’s now known as the “Cornerstone Speech,” Stephens told a Savannah, Ga., crowd in 1861 that “our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas [as those of slavery foes]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.” He went further: the battle over slavery “was the immediate cause of the late rupture and present revolution.”
Not officially but there were some black regiments. Near the end of the war black soldiers could actually enlist and earn their freedom. But yes, both North and South were very racist back then.
@clandau1618 While we should respect the good both sides, the war was definitely about slavery. Lincoln only let the border states keep their slaves because they would join the confederacy of they were taken away. The emancipation proclamation also didn't effect them because it was about weakening the south, not achieving Lincoln's personal interests. While slavery wasnt the reason every soldier enlisted, it was by far the biggest cause of the war. Alexander Stephens said "Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite idea; its foundations are laid, its corner- stone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery-subordination to the superior race-is his natural and normal condition" Mosby, an anti-slavery confederate cavalry leader even said "I've always understood that we went to war on account of the thing we quarreled with the North about. I've never heard of any other cause than slavery." While I think respecting the south is important, dismantling the lost cause is too. I would also add that we should judge soldiers from the time, slavery was excepted in the south at the time and it was key to the southern economy. If southern society didn't say it was evil then it wasn't evil for the politicians and planters to fight for it, nore any confederate soldiers who fought for slavery either.
rosemarie443 First of all if you don't like the south why do you listen to this music? Go listen to your Yankee trash. Second of all I have a first amendment right to free speech.
To the finest Fighting Man the world has ever seen God bless you God bless the Confederacy God bless you Robert E Lee they say time travel is just a myth but if I could you know if I could live another life I would be proud to serve a long u and General Jackson I would do my best and I would love to sit and drink chicory coffee with you over the campfire and talk about stories of the old days
@@TKDragon75 If someone showed up at your door with a rifle and said they were going to burn your neighborhood to the ground, kill anyone who tries to stop him and it was your duty to help him, what would you say?
As a reenactor, recalling songs like this in the field makes the scene unfolding before you seem purely surreal and genuinely scary at moments. I honor anyone who was brave enough to stand when they were actually firing at each other. May the Confederate battle flag stand over Charleston not as a symbol of hate, but as a reminder of a noble past.
rosemarie443 it symbolizes many things. State rights and the right to secession are some of the more important things.On a side note: A common joke in the Louisiana tigers, another unit, the Confederates had the stars n' bars, the battle flag n' white, and the soldiers blood, but in the end the white flag was the only one that mattered.
rosemarie443 When I say states rights I feel you don't understand what I mean. States rights doesn't necessarily mean representation in congress. It means the state has a right to determine what is best for the state as long as it doesn't harm other states in the Union, but with the federalization of the union and growing power of the executive, what gets passed by the executive is universal across all the states. One example before the civil war was the "tariff of abominations" which satisfied the merchants of the north but the raised prices directly harmed the south. If there were states rights the tariffs would only apply to northern ports and the south wouldn't have to suffer, however this wasn't the case and the south was embittered by this and protested. this is where the palmetto tree came in for S.C.. The issue with slavery in the south wasn't that all white people hated blacks and felt they all needed to be enslaved, in actuality the south needed the labor and if they were freed they would go north for better opportunities in the factories causing wages to inflate destroying the southern economy. If states rights were in place there would be no new slave states, but the south would keep theirs till they can grow out of it if you will. If you still think the south was the only racist party look north shortly after the war. In Detroit in 1863 only measly 8 years after the war and the blacks left the south, as predicted, Race riots ensued between the whites and the blacks but the Union never got attention to it
rosemarie443 I don't believe you read a single word I wrote...also, when the south joined the United States there was little power in the executive. which meant the south can still make decisions that benefitted the state. I still recommend you thoroughly read what I wrote
We should build a new monument to honor all of the Native American men who served in the Confederate Army during the American civil war and then charge BLM with a hate crime against a racial minority when they try to tear it down!!
@@thorpeaaron1110 In witch most of the northerners would try to kill you. Meanwhile the Confederate army were much more tolerable. Just look up what they don't tell you about the civil War in school.
A timeless song to honor those who fought during a tragic era in our Nation's history. Having lived in both the North and the South for long periods of years at a time, I can honestly say that most of the bizarre and warped hatred rests with Northerners. Although there are many intelligent Northerners who understand history and context, there is an inordinate amount of mentally deficient, vitreol-spewing Yankees who are polluting our nation with their venom. Just stand up to them, or better yet, ignore these hate-mongers.
+rosemarie443 Who the hell asked you to be there? Or here? You live in a region whose culture you hate, so why the hell not move? The ignorant folks up north might welcome you.
+rosemarie443 Why would I care enough to "try to find out"? Do you honestly think I give a flying fuck why you're actually here? Well no, the only reason I'm still even talking is because you're disrespecting Southerners as a whole.
I love the Irish influence in many of these beautiful songs. Up the Irish. I understand why those Irishmen of the South fought for the Southern States. They came from a place of government oppression and understood it well. They also were well aware of the treatment their kin in the North were dealing with at that point in time. Bless the Confederacy and the ideals they held dear, which were States Rights and what they felt was overburdening and unwarranted taxation by a government that was disinterested in them. Gee, does that sound familiar? These proud men wore their uniforms of Grey with honor. I salute them, and all who chose to do so.
+rosemarie443 , With all respect I don't know where you got your facts from. I've gotten mine from the written history of the Irish immigrants that were in New York at the time and what they endured. We will agree to disagree on this I suppose.
+rosemarie443 , I sincerely doubt that we've ever met. Not that it's impossible, only improbable. I do know that many Irish across the North called themselves Scotch-Irish in an attempt to separate themselves from the other Irish immigrants to try to avoid the discrimination. This discrimination was based solely on appearance. If you had fair skin and red hair( the classic stereotype attributed to the Irish)you were a target in the North. The fair skinned, red haired Irish immigrants also had a name for those that called themselves "Scotch-Irish"(or to be more accurate, my Mothers ancestors)they called them the "Black Irish." It's no secret that discrimination was as rampant in the North as it was in the South. Even among the Irish themselves.
+rosemarie443 , I'll not say another word Ma'am. No other group received the kind of treatment that the American Indians did from all races that immigrated to this country. This shocking truth was something I first became aware of as a youngster in a Junior High School History class. We were studying our local history. I was born and raised in Erie, Pa., on the banks of Lake Erie itself. Now I'd never given much thought to why the city or County was named Erie, it's not the type of thing that would have interested a Junior High School student back then and maybe even now. But the revelations I was exposed to were shocking and troubling then and to this day when I think about it. The area that became the County of Erie and city of Erie was, when the European settlers arrived in the area, inhabited by the Eriez(I think that's how they spelled it)tribe of American Indians. Now it's well known that there were times that the tribes warred between themselves over disputed territory. But this was different. From what we were taught there more than likely was some friction between the Eriez Tribe and these foreign invaders. It's understandable, your homeland is being taken from you, what are you supposed to do? What horrified me, then and now, was the solution the Europeans came up with. Instead of trying to work something out between them the Europeans, banking on their superior weaponry attacked and annihilated the entire Tribe. The Eriez Indian Tribe disappeared from the face of the earth, not one was left alive. I couldn't believe it Warriors, women, and children, all killed. The oldest and youngest, all massacred. The final straw for me was when we were taught that after the entire Tribe had been eliminated the Europeans decided to name the County and the City after them. There's also an Erie County in New York State and I suspect the same thing must have happened there although I don't know for sure.
+Bill Neice please read your history there was no north and south in Ireland at the time and most of the Irish confederates were Ulster Scots not as you wish to romanticize poor Southern Irish
I raise my glass to Honor all the brave men who fought for the Confederate States of America During the War Between The States “War of Northern aggression” Aka “War for Southern Independence” To All Confederate Veterans To the Cherokee Braves,and all the Native American Confederate Veterans,like Stand Watie the Last confederate general to surrender and a Cherokee. To the 30,000 Tejano/Hispanic Confederate Veterans. To all the Black Confederate Veterans both Free and slaves who fought for the South. To the Asian Confederates veterans. And to the entire kingdom of Hawaii who sided with the confederacy and those Hawaiian Confederate Veterans.
I commented on this video about 6 years ago saying I didn’t get this video, but I get it now. This song is really about the tragedy and grief and sense of loss that comes with war. The South really has been vilified beyond all recognition. They were ordinary Americans who law states’ economies relied on slaves, which is wrong obviously, but lots of those young 18 year olds that fought weren’t fighting for that. The random poor kid in Atlanta who heard the Union was coming wasn’t fighting because he hated minorities, he thought he was protecting his home. The random Tennessee volunteer, who was so eager to volunteer even though her never owned a slave in his life did it because he thought he was being patriotic and wanted to be a hero to his state. Lots of these people aren’t these evil people racists that despise African Americans , they were just fighting for their homes because it’s all they had. I think it was we a good thing that the Union got rid of slavery, but to call every Southerner, not just “the bad guys”, but also “evil, nazi, racists,” just simply isn’t an accurate description of our American history. The truth is that we’re all Americans and no one is perfect, we all make mistakes. Slavery ending was a good result, but at the terrible price of brother against brother, family against family. American against American . It’s truly heartbreaking. And I think that’s the deeper meaning of the song, the grief and heartbreak of not only fighting a losing war and seeing your friends die, but you also were fighting the people who were supposed to get your brothers as well. Think about it, they shared the same culture, the same language, a kid from Ohio could easily bond with a kid from Texas over baseball and rural life, they were very similar Americans. To fight the people you’re so similar to must’ve been hard. All in all, war is always a tragedy, but war of brother against brother is especially heartbreaking. Again, in my eyes, the Union winning brought the best net positive of being strong enough to win WW1 and Ww2 and the Cold War which wouldn’t have been possible as two separate rival countries, as well as eliminating slavery. But to call every southern soldier and evil person is simply not a nuanced enough view of history. Lots of them never saw a slave , let alone owned them. And the grief after a war is always terrible no matter if you’re the victors or the losers. I think that’s what this song is about. It’s a beautiful, but such a sad song. Adieu
May you rest in peace. You fought the good fight, and stood up for what you believed was right. May your courage never be forgotten. May your your sacrifice never be besmirched and may your nobility stand for all time. God bless you in all eternity.
i love how parallel the civil war songs are to irish folk music. the melody to this song comes from "rising of the moon" a song about the 1798 irish rebellion. proud texan/southerner here as well! hails!
My descendants fought for the Confederacy and I'm proud of my heritage I'm proud to be a southerner and I will gladly lay my life down for Dixie God bless America God bless Dixie God bless Robert E Lee and Nathan Bedford Forrest
Dear Rosemarie443, kindly do NOT inflame passions and arouse hatred on my videos. These are pro-Southern videos intended to honor our brave Southron soldiers who fought for what they believed was RIGHT. I hate the idea of banning people from my videos unless they are utterly obnoxious and anti-Southern, so please refrain from provoking PROUD Southern folks. We fellers don't go 'bout dissin' the North on Northern videos, and at the same time don't take it kindly to some folks maligning our PROUD SOUTHERN HERITAGE. God bless.
rosemarie443 bat the wicket rosie! your reward is a seat in valhalla. the hall of the warrior's, the truth cannot be diminished like the flame of a candle.
Bronsonkicks How are you related to Robert E Lee? He is my 5th cousin 7 times removed. His 4th great grandfather Richard Lee (the first Lee in America) was my 10th great grandfather. Robert is through his son Richard Henry and I ham through Hancock. Hancock was Zachary Taylors grandfather making Taylor my 2nd cousin 13 times removed. Taylors granddaughter married Jefferson Davis making him some kin. I would have to look the exact relation up. So somewhere we must be related. Lol. Eli and Peyton Manning are descended from Richard also.
Things seem to be on a near repeate of the events that happened prior to our first civil war, tho I pray we dont have a second it would be ignorant of me to not notice the signs and hyper polarization that exists once more in our nation
@@thegamingzilla6269 More of a repeat of what went on in the 1950s and 1960s during the time of the Civil Rights movement when racism actually did exist, those people that were out rioting and looting and defending low life criminals simply cause their skin color then turning around calling blacks that don't support them "not real blacks" wouldn't know what racism really is if it hit them over the head, worst thing about racism is the people who are actually racist often don't know they're racist.
Be proud of who you are and don’t let them put you down as southerners we are privileged to wear the gray tattered clothing of our Southern birthright and in my eyes and heart I say let the flag of the south land wave all respect from Tennessee
Let's not forget Johnny Reb, almost to a man a poor boy who took up arms to defend the rights of his State and people. In academia we may say and rightly so that the Civil War was "about slavery", but it wasn't to most of those folk who shed their blood for the Confederacy, who never owned a slave, nor hoped nor wanted to, and that is often forgotten. They fought and died for their rights, as Americans, by the ideals and promises of our founders, in the "Second American War of Independence", and every American should honor them, not only Southerners, as much as we honor any of our war dead. And I do hope their spirit is not lost, because now we face the immediate consequences of oppressive federal government again, and wherever we may come from, it is time for the people to rise. And this time, I do hope we will win, though it's not for victory we should fight, but because those who oppose us support an evil and a cruel system. And maybe we will wear gray, and think, upon our sacrifice, of old Johnny Reb.
rosemarie443 Can you seriously sit there and think that Republicans and Democrats are different? Bush took your rights so did Obama. The system is broken it's thrown the average man overboard it's only interest is corporations.
Dazza Smith I agree; both parties are rotten to the core and will just screw ordinary folk over in slightly different ways; it's a tag-team, and a good cop/bad cop routine that they've worked out amongst themselves. It's also an insidious tool to make the American people think they have real choices and real input in government when, really, we no longer do, except in matters that powerful people deem insignificant.
rosemarie443 Not when only one of two parties ever gets elected to anything, because they're the only ones with the financial backing to get elected in this system, and they stand for basically the same things -- they can speak very different rhetoric, and do, but if you look at the substance of their policies, there is virtually no difference, e.g. Republicans will pass gun control legislation, Democrats will approve the Patriot Act without question, "Obamacare" is identical to "Romneycare", they all commit to sustaining an endless "war on terror" ... I could go on. That's a nice illusion of choice, but it's been designed to deceive the electorate. This is why the founding fathers did not like the idea of political parties, in spite of the federalist/anti-federalist divide, which *was* a genuine ideological difference.
Civil War was not about slavery. It was about states rights and citizens rights. The same rights that are getting trampled today by our Government. I truly believe the South will rise again. Only this time it will be to save the whole country. Im glad that most of our Army forts are in the South. Also Southerners make up a good share of our Army. Think more so than the other parts of the US. God Bless the USA and thank you to the patriotic southerners. And that is from a Northerner.
![KSI - Thick Of It (feat. Trippie Redd) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/At8v_Yc044Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Respect to y'all who support and love the South, wherever y'all are from. Love from Texas. Proud Texan/Southerner.
+AmericanZeus spain here
+AmericanZeus greetings from Poland :)
+LiskowicStudios Good luck with all the trials facing Europe and know that many in America will proudly die beside you in defense of republican freedom
banning her is not the right thing to do, we need to be more able to defend our opinions with logic, morals and so on and so forth
if you look at alot of her comments I argue with her a decent amount, but an opinion is worthless if it can't be defended ask her to defend hers and she can't we should strive to be better than all of them
Am from Virginia with a proud history of my family who fought for our beloved south. I fly the 3rd national flag all the time. It is a privilege
Deo vindice brother! o7
As a real southerner this hits home hard. Brings a tear to my eye and fire in my heart. Johnny Reb still lives in us the offspring of warriors.
Choctaw and Cherokee Confederate soldiers!!
I descend from Morris's company of Virginia Rangers and William Powell. You don't speak for me and a Southern man like Jackson would not hear of it. You betrayed the Constitution and worked with the British foe. And now you want to dishonor Robert e Lee's solemn promise not to raise his sword. It's not a joke.
Damn near a million died and fools like you go joking about the rebel spirit blah blah blah
I am now officially hooked on Confederate songs.
have a look at some of the songs from the Irish Rebellion. This song, or rather the actual music is pinched from one of them.... The Rising of the Moon
Minus some of the bigotry that some of the songs have , I think the confederate songs really express the heart of America , which is why I feel the war was so disturbing , you can feel America in the music of both sides.
@@lisalovelylpa huh elaborate on: Bigotry
Check out rebel son they have a ton of good songs
@@nextlifearotti was it not called 'wearing of the green'?
They can take down every statue in existence but they can never extinguish the pride of all southerners who still remember the bravery and honor of those who wore the gray.
Stonewall Jackson agreed
And there he stands, a great Stone Wall. As right now as he was then.
Amen and amen!
I think I'm related to him
And butternut!
In North Carolina the protestors tear down a confederate soldier statue ... sad day in Dixie when being proud of your heritage is a sin.
If your "heritage" is fighting for the right to own other people, you would forgive the rest of us for exercising our GOD giving right to be contemptuous of you.
@@mohameddiaby835 Ignorance, Put your brain in a bird, the bird would fly backwards!
Open carry, it is still legal in NC. Do it. I am a Marylander and would be put in jail for it. You still have that right. Exercise it, and if you have a rifle for me, I will take part in your picket.
@@mohameddiaby835 I do not attempt to condescend, and as such, I truly hope that you might read reputable sources such as Bruce Catton's 'This Hallowed Ground'; to assume the war was ENTIRELY about slavery is asinine even amongst reputed historians. Certainly it was a major factor, but it ignores a half century of economic 'bullying', for lack of a better word imposed upon the south. I care for you as a human, and as such wish the best for you. I would hope that you might at least consider the same for myself, and look at the many other factors that led to the war.
A war of that magnitude cannot be maintained for that long, with such an EXTREME body count without the will of the common man of the dissident faction, and (forgive me for I do not recall) something to the order of 95%-99% of all southerners did not own slaves.
I don't see it as a sin. Love your heritage and history. Everyone else can eat sh-t.
it was the battle flag my great grandfather fought for, when his home state of GA.surrendered he did not. He died in Osaka Japan and never took an oath of allegiance to the United States. He married my Grandmother there in Osaka. I honour his life and what his honour taught me. Nothing to do with slavery.
What part of Georgia and the regiment my great3x granddaddy fought with is brothers in the 65th Georgia volunteers regiment
Proof us southerners ain't racist.
Rory Gibbons He sounds like he was a great man, we need more people like him nowadays
It was about slavery
@@thorpeaaron1110 cool all they good for
The finest soldiers America has ever produced! God bless! The confederacy! love from England.
"God bless the Confederacy"? Tell that to the slaves. I say GOD DAMN THE CONFEDERACY!
+Michael Palmieri oh fuck off the north had slaves too you uneducated fuck
LOVE FROM SCOTLAND AND THE 27th Virginian Scottish inf
Enclave Officer u fuck off bitch
another brainwashed fucking eejit, that war had nothing to do with slavery
Im an Australian, all respect to the boys in grey, If my Government was going to charge me with 47% TAX i would of put on the grey too. All the best.
That is just about the dumbest, (and most incorrect), analysis of the Civil War that I have ever heard. Where do you people get such unrealistic ideas?
I would've put it on when it was 1% .
You'll have a price to pay if you wait until it reaches 100%
Be proud!
Same America -a lot of Americans do not either-they just regurgitate the bile and propaganda of others.
Philip Dwight -opinions are like assholes, everybody has one,guess you have heard that one, or just kiss my grits.lol
may those who have died in pursuit of freedom rest in peace... and may future generations also dare to wear the grey
David Cartland amen brother
Those who died in pursuit of freedom to deny other people freedom, amen brother.
@@deezboyeed6764 Yeah, bunch of hypocrites.
Fascists and a chance of 'em
Are you challenging the south because if you are then come and face us you coward
im honored to live in the south
Me too.
SCV proud member.
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
I am a Pole, so were my ancestors. My family has served in the army for very long, even before my country was brought back they fought for the Austrian Kaiser as Poles. Today i found an old picture of my grandpa in his uniform, a picture completely worn out and almost falling apart. It was then that I was reminded of this song. You might wonder why I say this all, after all it is not about the CSA, but this songs reminds me of all the men who stood up for something in their lives, especially in the army. Glory to them.
Poland is not yet lost
God bless you all you guys took your country back from three Empires now that's impressive
I know and I understand. We stand with you.
zawsze
@@TheAlbanoJackass ok took back is an over exaggeration
And Poland is one of the last nations rejecting the mass import of Muslims. Hold fast poland
Southerns were fighting to be free.........states rights...........God Bless the Heroes of the South
Yeah they wanted the right to own slaves in their States. The Confederacy were a bunch of traitors who died for nothing.
@@kronosdarkness5202 Robert e lee had a plan to free the slaves ........fact. Yankees wiped out Indians ///////// what about that?
@@mrsuperbruce If you had a plan then why did he fight to keep slavery?
@@kronosdarkness5202 they were fighting to be free! They were fighting for states' rights! Look at the Federal Government? Wiped out the South, then Indians, now it is out of control!
@@kronosdarkness5202 They seceded for economic reasons and state right to selfgovern themself.
The south Will always be there ,respect the women parents church and god ,blees you all good people of the south 😊😊😊
Mr.. Confederate man, I'd like to shake your hand, for giving your life for Dixie land, Mr. Confederate man. - Rebel Son
Makes so proud to be Southern.
Lived in northern states before. Didn't like them. Way too regulated. Nothing like being Southern. Starting with freedom to own firearms. Then there is our cuisine. Pure Southern. Also the hospitality is greater.
Take a chill pill. I believe your post had some racist overtones such as and I am quoting you: "Your black people." That is a bit over the top and sounds quite bigoted and insensitive. But then most liberals are the real bigots and hide behind a false sentiment of patriotism.
Nothing is lost. I'm a Lithuanian from Europe, and confederates and southern soldiers are my heroes, they are heroes of my both sons aswell,
we need to stop worshipping losers.
@@hickspaced2963 Exactly! We should stop worsipping soviet union, british empire and nothern us., for they are a great example of '''how to win a war and still be a loser'' stuff..
In what’s now known as the “Cornerstone Speech,” Stephens told a Savannah, Ga., crowd in 1861 that “our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas [as those of slavery foes]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.”
He went further: the battle over slavery “was the immediate cause of the late rupture and present revolution.” you are a horrible parent if your Teaching hatred to your children @@rokasvalickas9686
my Great Grandfather (Ivy Cockerham) was a Confederate States Soldier.......I am Grey all the way through....God Bless the South.....
God Bless The C.S.A. it will live in men's Hearts as long as men last.
rosemarie443 God Bless The C.S.A. too and the greed was from the North, also slaves where not liberated in the North either till after the war, it was on the way out all over the World anyway, your Civil War was about power & the Blacks lost, their still slaves today, only now to the very federal government that purported to "free them." what a fucking joke. Revenge is a dish best served cold. The South will rise again and this time we should separate America into two Nations then the rest of you Godless folks can go your own way.
rosemarie443 Ha, do you really think the people in Our military will fight us? If they do, they will have to be pretty corrupt to do so. If a civil war does breakout, I believe groups of soldiers will refuse to obey orders.
rosemarie443 Yes they do. They usually throw tear gas at them.
rosemarie443 We have a right to protest, but it should not have violence. If the police attack peaceful protesters that is corruption. No doubt about it.
rosemarie443 Ha, I didn't vote for no one. Why vote when it never fixes anything? It's all run by big corporations and your vote never counts. This is why we need a civil war, to get back our country from these evil corps. After all You have voted for them.
I had ancestors from Virginia, West Virginia, Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Missouri and Texas who fought for the Confederacy. Monuments can always be replaced but nothing can erase facts.
semitic people can replace facts
Amen!
AMEN!
But they fought for an evil cause
Get over it.
Look at he Union we live in now. God Bless the CSA
looking rough
CSA wouldn't look any better
@thorpeaaron1110 too bad you can factually say that.
Damn Right!!
Down with the eagle and up with the Cross
God bless the South, from England.
Though my family fought the british for 800 years I must say I respect how the brits were ready to jump into the civil war on the side of the confederacy but Jefferson davis didnt want to destroy the union just wanted to back them up
God Bless England
From the South.😊
Long live the free people of the Confederacy and God bless General Robert E. Lee
less than 2% of southerners had slaves, still people believe that it was fought over slavery.
Abe lincoln himself said "if I could save the union without freeing any slave, I would do it"
The emancipation was a political move, not out of compassion for the blacks. The proof is that, after the war, slavery still existed, in different forms, and that the segregation was active untill very recently, all under the Union now.
Say the full quote not just apart "If I could save the union without freeing any slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."
AND YET, Lincoln refused to parley or compromise, or even receive the delegation from the southern states, where a compromise could have been made! War is never about what it seems to be.
The war was fought over slavery
@Peter Grahame The South never said anything about abolishing slavery either infact in the Confederate Constitution it protected the institution of slavery and Lincoln made steps to abolishing in 1863 issuing the Emancipation Proclamation freeing slaves in the rebelling states two years later in 1865 Congress passed the Thirteenth Amendment abolishing slavery in the United States
@@fixitmann6685 Lincoln did want to compromise and there were more Southerners in Congress at the time
Wear your Gray and wear it proud boys! Don’t let the Gray fade! God bless the Confederacy!
My Great Grandfather fought in the Confederate Army. He was one of 65 that survived in his Unit. I am Proud to be Southern Born and My Great Great Grandfather.
I just shared this song in a post on our channel. We support the preservation of the C.S.A and would appreciate the support from you by subscribing
@@thereisermoviecompany2758 done.
You guys definitely have slaves
❤🇺🇲🍻💪
I’m african American but I love these songs love from over here
True I don't support 'dixie' but this music is quite good
many free black men fought for the confederacy.
There was one guy, forgot his name, who bought himself out of slavery in the 1850's, and was paid a fortune by the confederate army to build bridges to transport troops and equipment...
@@-jank-willson from the cotton field to the field of war
@@chaosmarine8166 FREE black men, not slaves. Several free black men actually kept their own slave plantations in the antebellum south.
It wasn't until the end of the war that slaves were given a chance to fight as soldiers, but by then it was too late and they never got to the battlefield before the war was over...
@@-jank-willson bro chill out i made a joke didn't need the hole FNAF lore dropped on my skull
God Bless Robert E.Lee
And Jefferson Davis.
@@germainemanuel1775 stonewall to
What about Nathan Bedford Forrest?
God bless your mom
@@scrubhq9130 no u
Johnny Reb never went away.
+TexanPatriot Strategy johnny reb Like Scottsh compatriots
Hell it was not that long ago when the Irish fought for their freedom. The Irish have an indomitable spirit, and have fought for their liberty throughout all of history, no matter how harsh they are punished by England.
TexanPatriot Strategy never will
He just moved to Bitchute
Alt Meme stfu ginger
I just recently discovered that the tune of this song is based on that of The Rising of the Moon, an Irish ballad.
iamharald. Absolutely correct. The tune itself is used in several Irish ballads aswell like the Orange and the green, the rising of the moon, and the wearing of the green. I had never heard of this american version of the tune until now, how wonderful the internet is.
thank you!!! I knew I knew the song and it was an Irish song but could not think of what it was!
@Caroline Lees the kkk and confederacy are not the samething lol. there were many irish that fought for the south and for the north.
@Caroline Lees What are you waffling on about? Read a book and learn some history, my own ancestor from Wicklow fought for the South with his adopted state of Georgia, he was an Irish Catholic along with plenty of others who immigrated across the Atlantic in the 1840s. Get that Scots- Irish only fought for the Confederacy nonsense out of your head.
@Caroline Lees The KKK was a Democrat Party invention. Not the Ulster Scots. Get off drugs
I get tears in my eyes as I think about my southern heritage, Its about honor not hate that they are remembered.
So you tear up over your southern heritage, the conjured ideas of a sullied honor, that makes you cry. Poor baby, I wish I had some not so well used Pampers for you.
They truly had the honor but not the heart;spirit like the republicans ♥
@@Gunshipurl Lincoln invaded innocent Americans and cost this nation over 600,000 lives. Continue idolozing a tyrannical Federal government that has been on the war path since 1861! You Republicans love war though, it is what gets you off at night👍
@@kerentolbert5448"waa!waa! Other people have a history and culture! Waa!" Maybe you should have thought about that before sucking so much. On the one hand, I have heard that I have ancestors that fought on both sides, but I really never heard of the Union ones achieving anything near the honors accorded to the southerners. You guys are pathetic, I would rather face off against 200 drugged up junkies with 5 Florida Men than with 500 of you yankees. You'd run away because you're cowards, and since you're yankees you wouldn't even feel bad about that. Can't y'all yankees just join Canada or something and leave us well enough alone? You suck and you're cowards and I hate you. Now go be part of Canada, oh I swear we'll miss you. Yep we certainly will. Please don't screw off into the Canadian wilderness.
I´m from Germany and i love the grey!
No!I am not a nazi,i hat this idiots and i dont like the slavery I only like the south of the USA,nothing else,they had a good army. And i love Great bBritan too! I lived in the british sector of Berlin and proud of it.
The guards in Belsen and Auschwitz wear Fieldgrey ;-) Please, don't be angry with me.
rosemarie443 Did you know that America(the North) had slaves as well?
rosemarie443 And the British freed slaves before the USA did. :)
+rosemarie443 Guess why?Because the UK/GB was a state much older then the USA slavery has been a thing since BC and GB/UK was one of the first nations to outlaw slavery.
+keithmcgrath it got a lot worse under under the irish! 40 dark years for for the common man and woman, the mainland was a refuge for the those people, they never went back, their progeny are now british, lol.
I aint american.. but i love the beauty of the American Civil War and i gave my snappy salute to my idol.. General Robert Lee .
@@Sterndessudensfcb The Generation of the new US americans breaks my heart. I dont know if they were still US Americans or not?
God bless the South
Support from Poland brothers!
As a southerner I think you Mr Winged Hussars May your future be ever bright and happy
@David Broadley You're obviously a product of our government school system that teaches a biased history ... do yourself a favor and read some stories from the other side ... grow into a better person instead of just being an ignorant troll.
Just did a military rotation in Poznan. I love poland!
My father's mother was from Poznan (she was a Monczak). She told me stories about how speaking Polish in public was illegal during the German kulturkampf.
My mother was from South Carolina. Her Great grandfather was a company commander in the 18th SC and died in action at 2nd Bull Run. His brother was Joseph Wofford Tucker. My mother spent summers on her grandmother's farm, and there she heard stories from her great aunts about how it was when the yankees came.
My Babci was btought to America by her uncle, Fr. Jan Pawłowski, before the first world war. The good priest brought her and my Dzaidz, Wm. Szymborski, togeher. Their son, my father, met my mother during the Second World war when he was stationed at an army base near Spartamburg, SC.
Love from Mississippi!! still flying the flag strong
May Mississippi keep flying the Confederate Flag Emblem in her state flag and not give in to the PC crowd! Deo Vindici!
Stay strong, and stay true to your Southern heritage, it's who you are. Good luck to y'all down there, from Oklahoma
That is because you are a racist hillbilly traitor.
@@Jay-cj7xu how is he racist? For having a different opinion or seeing the flag stand for heritage instead of hate like you see it.
@@Jay-cj7xu plus do you and others like you just come here to get offended and try to start shit with people who have different opinions than you?
I'm proud Confederate and don't care what anyone thinks. Im a supporter of Dixie
Yea not yours
Wow no and plus I don't have a problem you on the other hand have a problem don't you
U have the problem so solve it
Rosemarie443+
rosemarie443 your a Stupid liberal
I was born and will forever be a Confederate being of this world God bless the south and america. I am proud of my family and all who wore the gray uniform for us so I say everyone wave ur flags high and proud and never let anyone take away what was fought for in the USA. We are proud Confederates and Confederacy. NO ONE CAN TAKE THAT FROM US! The civil war was not fought over slavery but between the north and south and who did not want to be told what to do.
Yes and Amen to everything you said. Very proud of my ancestors who fought for the South.
NOT gone... and Never forgotten.
🌹
@@maryannparrish2570 thank you never be ashamed of what and who u r. Wear it proudly. Rebels hold ur head high and never back down from a fight.
The south will rise again !
@@verandi3882 yes we will bro no doubt there thank for the like and support
Yessssssss my great great great grandfather was a Confederate
I'm from New Jersey but if I lived then I would have fought for the South!
Hope springs eternal ....thank you from Tennessee
Then you would've fought for the preservation of slavery if you wanted to or not In what’s now known as the “Cornerstone Speech,” Stephens told a Savannah, Ga., crowd in 1861 that “our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas [as those of slavery foes]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.”
He went further: the battle over slavery “was the immediate cause of the late rupture and present revolution.”
God bless all who took the Grey, no matter creed, religion or colour
i dont think many colours could be in the confederate army.....
Not officially but there were some black regiments. Near the end of the war black soldiers could actually enlist and earn their freedom. But yes, both North and South were very racist back then.
@@pintoffanta2510 Well, like the most states in world were racist.
@clandau1618 While we should respect the good both sides, the war was definitely about slavery. Lincoln only let the border states keep their slaves because they would join the confederacy of they were taken away. The emancipation proclamation also didn't effect them because it was about weakening the south, not achieving Lincoln's personal interests. While slavery wasnt the reason every soldier enlisted, it was by far the biggest cause of the war.
Alexander Stephens said "Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite idea; its foundations are laid, its corner- stone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery-subordination to the superior race-is his natural and normal condition"
Mosby, an anti-slavery confederate cavalry leader even said "I've always understood that we went to war on account of the thing we quarreled with the North about. I've never heard of any other cause than slavery."
While I think respecting the south is important, dismantling the lost cause is too. I would also add that we should judge soldiers from the time, slavery was excepted in the south at the time and it was key to the southern economy. If southern society didn't say it was evil then it wasn't evil for the politicians and planters to fight for it, nore any confederate soldiers who fought for slavery either.
@@aguy6771actually the confederate army was more diverse then the union army lol
i wear the grey and im a proud aussie go the south we salute you.
This is kinda personal because my great great grandpa was in charge of the last confederate unit to stand down. Long live the South!
rosemarie443 Excuse me miss but you add a C instead of a U.
rosemarie443 I respect your opinion, but the CSA is better than the USA.
rosemarie443 First of all if you don't like the south why do you listen to this music? Go listen to your Yankee trash. Second of all I have a first amendment right to free speech.
rosemarie443 So you like the south but you don't like the confederacy. But you live in Texas. I was born in San Angelo
rosemarie443 San Angelo is in Texas.
To the finest Fighting Man the world has ever seen God bless you God bless the Confederacy God bless you Robert E Lee they say time travel is just a myth but if I could you know if I could live another life I would be proud to serve a long u and General Jackson I would do my best and I would love to sit and drink chicory coffee with you over the campfire and talk about stories of the old days
Respect from France, God save the South !
Always proud of this beautiful flag hanging in my room
WEARING THE GREY TILL I DIE,LOVE FROM GREECE TO Y'ALL CONFEDERATES!
The confederacy doesn't exist anymore but ok
@@jerrylopez1810 Didn't last 5 years
@@SStupendous Club penguin lasted longer than the confederacy 💀
@@jerrylopez1810 Roblox is 4x as old as the confederacy 🥶
@@jerrylopez1810 You are talking to me Indio?Really?
I had six members in my family fight for the grey. Only too sad that I couldn't been there to join them!
Why would you want to join them?
@@TKDragon75 Why shouldn't he
Grey might be a popular color in a few years
@@TKDragon75 If someone showed up at your door with a rifle and said they were going to burn your neighborhood to the ground, kill anyone who tries to stop him and it was your duty to help him, what would you say?
@@spectre111 Yankee detected.
a tear just dropped from my eye with the last two sentences
I am proud of the SOUTHERN LIFE. My Mother came from eastern KY. There is still the feeling of pride in their believe.
Don't you or anyone doubt my loyalty to this country!!
Bless all the brave men who fought for us. keep Dixie alive in your hearts and minds think alike and think right from Alabama God bless the south.
fellow Texan and child of the South.....and also Irish!!! love this song!!
Proud to be a Southerner and proud to be a Tennessee fan
Respect to the Grey from Brazil
God bless the South
South Brazil
Respect from Czech, this song is so amazing, the South has right.
Fun Fact: Robert E. Lee's wife was the granddaughter of John Parke Custis, George Washington's wife's child.
I love The South. Greetings from Bulgaria!
Thank you from Tennessee
Love this song! I can imagine soldiers on the southern side singing this to keep their spirits up after they lost!
From those of us born and bred in the south of England, we salute the confederacy and this wonderful song. God bless the America and the South.
beautiful song, respect from England.
Beautiful song. God bless the South. Respect from Serbia :D
after being stuffed in slovenia, croatia, bosnia and kosovo, i thought you might be keeping your head down, good advice.
rosemarie443 good lass dearest rosie, bat the wicket, up nebraska!
Brian Kiernan Smith i just saw that when you got the hard word from zeus, that there were 156 replies , bless you! only you can, lol.
God Bless CSA and Poland. (citizen od Poland)
rosemarie443 I love brave southern heroes from civil war
GOD BLESS THE SOUTH!!!
DAMN STRAIGHT!!!
rosemarie443 Fuck up. The CSA should have won
***** That makes absolutely NO sense whatsoever.
The 8th Hokage good luck
really ??
I'm proud to be a southerner don't care what people say Southern soldiers fought for their freedom.
Their freedom to opress others?
@@Lp-army1 no the Confederacy declare their independence because they believe they were being oppressed.
Hail to the freedom fighters of the Confederates. Love from Hong Kong
Huh.
God bless Dixie's Land, respect from Italy.
As a reenactor, recalling songs like this in the field makes the scene unfolding before you seem purely surreal and genuinely scary at moments. I honor anyone who was brave enough to stand when they were actually firing at each other. May the Confederate battle flag stand over Charleston not as a symbol of hate, but as a reminder of a noble past.
rosemarie443 it symbolizes many things. State rights and the right to secession are some of the more important things.On a side note: A common joke in the Louisiana tigers, another unit, the Confederates had the stars n' bars, the battle flag n' white, and the soldiers blood, but in the end the white flag was the only one that mattered.
Matt McAvay despite the fact you posted twice, nit picking, lol. i can grasp the meaning of what you say, good on you sir, i can go along with that.
rosemarie443 When I say states rights I feel you don't understand what I mean. States rights doesn't necessarily mean representation in congress. It means the state has a right to determine what is best for the state as long as it doesn't harm other states in the Union, but with the federalization of the union and growing power of the executive, what gets passed by the executive is universal across all the states. One example before the civil war was the "tariff of abominations" which satisfied the merchants of the north but the raised prices directly harmed the south. If there were states rights the tariffs would only apply to northern ports and the south wouldn't have to suffer, however this wasn't the case and the south was embittered by this and protested. this is where the palmetto tree came in for S.C.. The issue with slavery in the south wasn't that all white people hated blacks and felt they all needed to be enslaved, in actuality the south needed the labor and if they were freed they would go north for better opportunities in the factories causing wages to inflate destroying the southern economy. If states rights were in place there would be no new slave states, but the south would keep theirs till they can grow out of it if you will. If you still think the south was the only racist party look north shortly after the war. In Detroit in 1863 only measly 8 years after the war and the blacks left the south, as predicted, Race riots ensued between the whites and the blacks but the Union never got attention to it
rosemarie443 gettysburg, 3rd of july, picket's charge for what it was worth, bring 'em on!
rosemarie443 I don't believe you read a single word I wrote...also, when the south joined the United States there was little power in the executive. which meant the south can still make decisions that benefitted the state. I still recommend you thoroughly read what I wrote
God bless the south and our ancestors who wore the grey.
They have been so great I hope that we can wear it again
Respect to the confederacy, love from Great Britain
God bless the Confederacy and may dixie rise once more the irish will die and fight with you boys again and again..from the Irish brigade descendents
I would have been honoured to fight for the South. May god bless those wonderful brave soldiers.
We should build a new monument to honor all of the Native American men who served in the Confederate Army during the American civil war and then charge BLM with a hate crime against a racial minority when they try to tear it down!!
If the South will stand up again to take its honour back, I'll be a volunteer in the italian brigade. Long live to the CSA
The South fought over slavery
EBONIE THORPE didn’t Abe day if he could end the war without “freeing” and single man he would
@@unknown-dq6df This was early part of the war
@@unknown-dq6df If I was a slave during the Civil War I would side with the Union then the Confederacy
@@thorpeaaron1110 In witch most of the northerners would try to kill you. Meanwhile the Confederate army were much more tolerable. Just look up what they don't tell you about the civil War in school.
A timeless song to honor those who fought during a tragic era in our Nation's history. Having lived in both the North and the South for long periods of years at a time, I can honestly say that most of the bizarre and warped hatred rests with Northerners.
Although there are many intelligent Northerners who understand history and context, there is an inordinate amount of mentally deficient, vitreol-spewing Yankees who are polluting our nation with their venom. Just stand up to them, or better yet, ignore these hate-mongers.
+rosemarie443 No...you don't. I've found you on at least three Confederate songs just bashing the South.
+rosemarie443 Who the hell asked you to be there? Or here? You live in a region whose culture you hate, so why the hell not move? The ignorant folks up north might welcome you.
+kongen norge Amen!
+rosemarie443 Why would I care enough to "try to find out"? Do you honestly think I give a flying fuck why you're actually here? Well no, the only reason I'm still even talking is because you're disrespecting Southerners as a whole.
+rosemarie443 We all have our opinions here, ms. We here just feel that these men deserve more respect than what you're showing here.
"Johnny Reb", the best soldier America's ever had.
The “Lost Cause” will never be forgotten! Long live the rebellion! 🇸🇴⚔️
The csa was founded to preserve slavery, not freedom or anything else
Never be lost, for the South will never forget the true nature of the northern culture is to exploit, and subdue those that disagree.
I love the Irish influence in many of these beautiful songs. Up the Irish. I understand why those Irishmen of the South fought for the Southern States. They came from a place of government oppression and understood it well. They also were well aware of the treatment their kin in the North were dealing with at that point in time. Bless the Confederacy and the ideals they held dear, which were States Rights and what they felt was overburdening and unwarranted taxation by a government that was disinterested in them. Gee, does that sound familiar? These proud men wore their uniforms of Grey with honor. I salute them, and all who chose to do so.
+rosemarie443 , With all respect I don't know where you got your facts from. I've gotten mine from the written history of the Irish immigrants that were in New York at the time and what they endured. We will agree to disagree on this I suppose.
+rosemarie443 , I sincerely doubt that we've ever met. Not that it's impossible, only improbable. I do know that many Irish across the North called themselves Scotch-Irish in an attempt to separate themselves from the other Irish immigrants to try to avoid the discrimination. This discrimination was based solely on appearance. If you had fair skin and red hair( the classic stereotype attributed to the Irish)you were a target in the North. The fair skinned, red haired Irish immigrants also had a name for those that called themselves "Scotch-Irish"(or to be more accurate, my Mothers ancestors)they called them the "Black Irish." It's no secret that discrimination was as rampant in the North as it was in the South. Even among the Irish themselves.
+rosemarie443 , I'll not say another word Ma'am. No other group received the kind of treatment that the American Indians did from all races that immigrated to this country. This shocking truth was something I first became aware of as a youngster in a Junior High School History class. We were studying our local history. I was born and raised in Erie, Pa., on the banks of Lake Erie itself. Now I'd never given much thought to why the city or County was named Erie, it's not the type of thing that would have interested a Junior High School student back then and maybe even now. But the revelations I was exposed to were shocking and troubling then and to this day when I think about it. The area that became the County of Erie and city of Erie was, when the European settlers arrived in the area, inhabited by the Eriez(I think that's how they spelled it)tribe of American Indians. Now it's well known that there were times that the tribes warred between themselves over disputed territory. But this was different. From what we were taught there more than likely was some friction between the Eriez Tribe and these foreign invaders. It's understandable, your homeland is being taken from you, what are you supposed to do? What horrified me, then and now, was the solution the Europeans came up with. Instead of trying to work something out between them the Europeans, banking on their superior weaponry attacked and annihilated the entire Tribe. The Eriez Indian Tribe disappeared from the face of the earth, not one was left alive. I couldn't believe it Warriors, women, and children, all killed. The oldest and youngest, all massacred. The final straw for me was when we were taught that after the entire Tribe had been eliminated the Europeans decided to name the County and the City after them. There's also an Erie County in New York State and I suspect the same thing must have happened there although I don't know for sure.
+Bill Neice please read your history there was no north and south in Ireland at the time and most of the Irish confederates were Ulster Scots not as you wish to romanticize poor Southern Irish
+peter algie True there was no border in Ireland, but that doesn't change the fact that 25,000 Irish fought for the south.
I raise my glass to Honor all the brave men who fought for the Confederate States of America
During the
War Between The States
“War of Northern aggression”
Aka “War for Southern Independence”
To All Confederate Veterans
To the Cherokee Braves,and all the Native American Confederate Veterans,like Stand Watie the Last confederate general to surrender and a Cherokee.
To the 30,000 Tejano/Hispanic Confederate Veterans.
To all the Black Confederate Veterans both Free and slaves who fought for the South. To the Asian Confederates veterans.
And to the entire kingdom of Hawaii who sided with the confederacy and those Hawaiian Confederate Veterans.
I love this song I'm proud of my southern heritage
Beautiful Song. And yes, there is nothing wrong to be proud of his home!Greez from Switzerland!
I commented on this video about 6 years ago saying I didn’t get this video, but I get it now.
This song is really about the tragedy and grief and sense of loss that comes with war.
The South really has been vilified beyond all recognition. They were ordinary Americans who law states’ economies relied on slaves, which is wrong obviously, but lots of those young 18 year olds that fought weren’t fighting for that. The random poor kid in Atlanta who heard the Union was coming wasn’t fighting because he hated minorities, he thought he was protecting his home. The random Tennessee volunteer, who was so eager to volunteer even though her never owned a slave in his life did it because he thought he was being patriotic and wanted to be a hero to his state.
Lots of these people aren’t these evil people racists that despise African Americans , they were just fighting for their homes because it’s all they had.
I think it was we a good thing that the Union got rid of slavery, but to call every Southerner, not just “the bad guys”, but also “evil, nazi, racists,” just simply isn’t an accurate description of our American history.
The truth is that we’re all Americans and no one is perfect, we all make mistakes. Slavery ending was a good result, but at the terrible price of brother against brother, family against family. American against American . It’s truly heartbreaking.
And I think that’s the deeper meaning of the song, the grief and heartbreak of not only fighting a losing war and seeing your friends die, but you also were fighting the people who were supposed to get your brothers as well. Think about it, they shared the same culture, the same language, a kid from Ohio could easily bond with a kid from Texas over baseball and rural life, they were very similar Americans. To fight the people you’re so similar to must’ve been hard.
All in all, war is always a tragedy, but war of brother against brother is especially heartbreaking. Again, in my eyes, the Union winning brought the best net positive of being strong enough to win WW1 and Ww2 and the Cold War which wouldn’t have been possible as two separate rival countries, as well as eliminating slavery.
But to call every southern soldier and evil person is simply not a nuanced enough view of history. Lots of them never saw a slave , let alone owned them.
And the grief after a war is always terrible no matter if you’re the victors or the losers. I think that’s what this song is about. It’s a beautiful, but such a sad song. Adieu
Also black people fought for CSA Army, plus they seced for economical reasons and for their states rights
God bless the South forever. Also a proud Texan/Southerner.
I'm a first generation American patriot with Mexican decent and I love my country and history and love the CSA! AND THE FLAG
Mexicans served in the Confederacy to from Texas look it up you learn more about it
@@waynesigmon5628 do you have more information about that i need for an investigation, love from Spain
May you rest in peace. You fought the good fight, and stood up for what you believed was right. May your courage never be forgotten. May your your sacrifice never be besmirched and may your nobility stand for all time. God bless you in all eternity.
Love seeing the Texas flag next to the Confederate battle flag!!! God bless the south, God bless Texas.
i love how parallel the civil war songs are to irish folk music. the melody to this song comes from "rising of the moon" a song about the 1798 irish rebellion. proud texan/southerner here as well! hails!
Makes me proud and all of my life I will honor those who wore the Gray, our defenders.
My descendants fought for the Confederacy and I'm proud of my heritage I'm proud to be a southerner and I will gladly lay my life down for Dixie God bless America God bless Dixie God bless Robert E Lee and Nathan Bedford Forrest
I meant to say my ancestors LOL
Beautiful song !!!
Dear Rosemarie443, kindly do NOT inflame passions and arouse hatred on my videos. These are pro-Southern videos intended to honor our brave Southron soldiers who fought for what they believed was RIGHT. I hate the idea of banning people from my videos unless they are utterly obnoxious and anti-Southern, so please refrain from provoking PROUD Southern folks. We fellers don't go 'bout dissin' the North on Northern videos, and at the same time don't take it kindly to some folks maligning our PROUD SOUTHERN HERITAGE. God bless.
rosemarie443
Awww... whiny child rosie got scolded and her wittle fweelings all hurt. Po' lil girl!
rosemarie443 bat the wicket rosie! your reward is a seat in valhalla. the hall of the warrior's, the truth cannot be diminished like the flame of a candle.
Bronsonkicks
How are you related to Robert E Lee? He is my 5th cousin 7 times removed. His 4th great grandfather Richard Lee (the first Lee in America) was my 10th great grandfather. Robert is through his son Richard Henry and I ham through Hancock. Hancock was Zachary Taylors grandfather making Taylor my 2nd cousin 13 times removed. Taylors granddaughter married Jefferson Davis making him some kin. I would have to look the exact relation up.
So somewhere we must be related. Lol. Eli and Peyton Manning are descended from Richard also.
FastPonyGT Hey GT!! It's good to see your avatar back.
***** Thank God for that! I got attacked by three adverts trying to get to this post, good to see you Mike!
Greetings from Montenegro. Confederate America=True America
Good Job I love it thanks for posting this, God Bless the CSA and God Bless the USA
God bless our fallen heroes and God bless Dixie! Deo Vindice!
They may take down the flag from the sky
But it will always fly in our hearts
God bless the south and pray for those who I
died and suffered....
anyone here after the riots and "protesting"?...
Things seem to be on a near repeate of the events that happened prior to our first civil war, tho I pray we dont have a second it would be ignorant of me to not notice the signs and hyper polarization that exists once more in our nation
Yeah.
@@thegamingzilla6269 More of a repeat of what went on in the 1950s and 1960s during the time of the Civil Rights movement when racism actually did exist, those people that were out rioting and looting and defending low life criminals simply cause their skin color then turning around calling blacks that don't support them "not real blacks" wouldn't know what racism really is if it hit them over the head, worst thing about racism is the people who are actually racist often don't know they're racist.
Be proud of who you are and don’t let them put you down as southerners we are privileged to wear the gray tattered clothing of our Southern birthright and in my eyes and heart I say let the flag of the south land wave all respect from Tennessee
God bless the south
God bless our fallen veterans who for the South we from o Dixie will never forget you
ALL of Virginia is here with you.
I'm pretty sure you don't speak for all of Virginia. It's pretty arrogant that you think you do.
@@kronosdarkness5202 You right, true virginians
long live my home.....DIXIELAND!!!
I love the us, I pray to God, I believe in my southern ancestors, and no one can take that away. God bless America and old glory
I live in Maryland, but I love everything about the southern culture. God bless the South!
Let's not forget Johnny Reb, almost to a man a poor boy who took up arms to defend the rights of his State and people. In academia we may say and rightly so that the Civil War was "about slavery", but it wasn't to most of those folk who shed their blood for the Confederacy, who never owned a slave, nor hoped nor wanted to, and that is often forgotten.
They fought and died for their rights, as Americans, by the ideals and promises of our founders, in the "Second American War of Independence", and every American should honor them, not only Southerners, as much as we honor any of our war dead.
And I do hope their spirit is not lost, because now we face the immediate consequences of oppressive federal government again, and wherever we may come from, it is time for the people to rise. And this time, I do hope we will win, though it's not for victory we should fight, but because those who oppose us support an evil and a cruel system.
And maybe we will wear gray, and think, upon our sacrifice, of old Johnny Reb.
rosemarie443 Can you seriously sit there and think that Republicans and Democrats are different? Bush took your rights so did Obama. The system is broken it's thrown the average man overboard it's only interest is corporations.
Dazza Smith
I agree; both parties are rotten to the core and will just screw ordinary folk over in slightly different ways; it's a tag-team, and a good cop/bad cop routine that they've worked out amongst themselves. It's also an insidious tool to make the American people think they have real choices and real input in government when, really, we no longer do, except in matters that powerful people deem insignificant.
You can't change the system it's to deep with the corporations there needs to be a massive change to something similar to a nightwatchman state
rosemarie443
Not when only one of two parties ever gets elected to anything, because they're the only ones with the financial backing to get elected in this system, and they stand for basically the same things -- they can speak very different rhetoric, and do, but if you look at the substance of their policies, there is virtually no difference, e.g. Republicans will pass gun control legislation, Democrats will approve the Patriot Act without question, "Obamacare" is identical to "Romneycare", they all commit to sustaining an endless "war on terror" ... I could go on. That's a nice illusion of choice, but it's been designed to deceive the electorate.
This is why the founding fathers did not like the idea of political parties, in spite of the federalist/anti-federalist divide, which *was* a genuine ideological difference.
Civil War was not about slavery. It was about states rights and citizens rights. The same rights that are getting trampled today by our Government. I truly believe the South will rise again. Only this time it will be to save the whole country. Im glad that most of our Army forts are in the South. Also Southerners make up a good share of our Army. Think more so than the other parts of the US. God Bless the USA and thank you to the patriotic southerners. And that is from a Northerner.