Nightwish - Ghost River (Live) [Reaction/Review]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 123

  • @Chouyren
    @Chouyren 5 лет назад +71

    After Anette left the band I began thinking 'Am I a Anette fan? Yes! Is she the only reason for me to be a fan of Nightwish? No, definitely not!' and then I also thought 'What about Tarja? Am I a fan of her? Yes I am, but not of her character and her husband! So I can't be a Nightwish fan just because of her! What is it that made me a fan of this band then?' I came up with an answer and the answer was and always will be 'The music itself is the reason for me to be a Nightwish fan and therefore it's Tuomas and his songwriting skills! But not just him! Marco, Emppu and Jukka are also part of this band! They are all great people and awesome musicians and Marco has an awesome Voice too!'
    So yeah, I never really cared as much about who's the singer of this band as others because I never had a problem with any of the singers. Actually I wouldn't mind if Marco was the one to do all the vocals^^ Nevertheless I like all 3 of Nightwishs female singers equally and of course they are/ were an important part of the music! Tarja has an awesome operatic voice, Anette has a beautiful calm voice and Floor can do it all perfectly so there's nothing to worry about as long as Tuomas writes the music and Marco, Emppu and Jukka are there as well even though Jukka still needs time to recover from his insomnia but Kai is a cool dude and I wouldn't mind if he stays with the band in case Jukka doesn't come back. Oh and last but not least there's also Troy who has a really great voice too and he knows how to play them pipes! He's a nice guy and became an important part of this band because Tuomas wanted more folk elements and I totally agree. The folks make Nightwish much more versatile! I will always love this band and why should I be angry about some singers who left the band years ago if the music is doing perfectly fine and the band keeps on getting better and better?

    • @MrAKH820
      @MrAKH820 5 лет назад +2

      @WrathOfStars I could not agree more. For anyone who has not yet checked out Wintersun go check them out on RUclips with their live performance at SonicPump Studios (I think I got the studio name right :p) Enjoy :D

    • @stephaniekuhne764
      @stephaniekuhne764 5 лет назад

      Hey! Yes! Truely words... do you know that Marco sang the songs in demo versions from DPP?
      Here is one example....
      ruclips.net/video/2oECYCV5-5w/видео.html
      🤘😁

    • @Chouyren
      @Chouyren 5 лет назад +1

      @@stephaniekuhne764 Yeah, I know^^ The demo of Cadence of her Last Breath is on the Made in Hong Kong album while the demos of Eva, Amaranth and The Poet and the Pendulum are still here on RUclips somewhere, don't know about the other songs... The demo of Amaranth even has a different name and chorus (It's called Reach) :)

    • @constantinciubotaru6687
      @constantinciubotaru6687 5 лет назад +1

      Troy don't u forget Troy he adds soo much harmony...i miss Jukka soo damn much come back man get some sleepin'and come back

    • @lexluthor6497
      @lexluthor6497 4 года назад

      You've got it right.

  • @Gladius6
    @Gladius6 5 лет назад +10

    Floor just memerizes you when you hear her sing, its like you get lost in her voice and don't want to find the way out!, like listening to a siren luring you in and keeps your attention, so perfect!

  • @oraculodeavalon
    @oraculodeavalon 5 лет назад +19

    Everytime that I see A&P Reacts with Nightwish I always open. Your reactions from they and all your work is wonderful. Love your channel and I'm waiting anxiously for your Ayreon reaction. Best wishes for a happy new year!

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад +3

      Thank you!!!

    • @toni.tapola
      @toni.tapola 5 лет назад

      @@APREACTS You guys have probably done an *Ayreon* reaction or two (or three, dare I hope?) by now (26 Sep 2019), but I _haven't_ searched thru your 2019 Reactions yet - I'm working on it, I'm working on it... Has anyone told you that *both* Floor and Marco have been on Ayreon records *and* peformed in the first ever _official_ Ayreon concert (2015's _The Theater Equation_ is considered a stage performance), which was in September 15-16, 2017, and was released as _Ayreon Universe - The Best of Ayreon Live,_ on BD/DVD/CD in 2018?

  • @paulmartin7241
    @paulmartin7241 5 лет назад +4

    Nightwish are utterly brilliant & so good live , I've seen them twice now in the UK at Wembley London. \m/

  • @syriell1720
    @syriell1720 5 лет назад +52

    Hello, I am the german Girl, drinking my coffee and cursing your Spelling of Wacken. Now you can curse my English. Anyway, its not that bad.

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад +3

      😁😁😁😁

    • @FunIsGoingOn
      @FunIsGoingOn 5 лет назад +8

      @@APREACTS German guy here, it's late, already at beer instead of coffee, reacting to reacting comments under videos about guys reacting to videos shot at german festivals.

    • @WarlonWinterheart
      @WarlonWinterheart 5 лет назад +2

      Did you say Das Auto or Schnell?

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад +1

      Yes

    • @timomastosalo
      @timomastosalo 5 лет назад

      @@WarlonWinterheart Yeah, just think the language he uses! :)

  • @metalloverjames215
    @metalloverjames215 5 лет назад +10

    check out Nightwish's live version of 'Yours Is An Empty Hope' it's another heavier song of theirs, Floors vocals are powerful and during the chorus, Floor actually growls under Marcos vocals.

  • @CountCrapula.
    @CountCrapula. 5 лет назад +1

    I waited so long for this one... was not disappointed. Ghost River is probably one of my all time favourites from Nightwish, and this specific version (with Floor) is absolutely godlike

  • @drolzak7
    @drolzak7 5 лет назад +7

    If you guys really want a good impression of Marco's clean vocals, you should search for 'The Islander' or 'While Your Lips are still Red'.

  • @suvivainio134
    @suvivainio134 5 лет назад +2

    Ghost River gives me goosepumps from start to finish, soooooo good!

  • @MrValium100
    @MrValium100 5 лет назад +25

    The growl at 3:39 and 5:10. There's something that she can't sing?

    • @pedrotrust
      @pedrotrust 5 лет назад +3

      Yes, she can't sing bad.. :D

    • @warhammer5690
      @warhammer5690 5 лет назад

      Lol dig thatname. Horizon.. Zero Dawn

  • @tarmotyyri6733
    @tarmotyyri6733 5 лет назад +19

    Thank you guys for this. I really like your reaction videos. In case you're more interested in Marco/Marko singing, please check something from Northern Kings or Nightwish's cover of Pink Floyd's "High Hopes".

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад +1

      Thanks for the tips

    • @MrDollarRoxx
      @MrDollarRoxx 5 лет назад +3

      High Hopes. It's an amazing cover. Really shows Marco's vocal abilities and Emppu's take on the solo gives me chills every time. Also I think it's kinda cool to see how well the boys do on their own. 😄

  • @mjpmattos
    @mjpmattos 5 лет назад +19

    Great song! Still missing:
    - With Floor: Song of myself (Wacken), Yours Is A Empty Hope (Nightwish Cruise).
    - With Anette: Scaretale
    - With Tarja: Slaying the Dreamer (end of a era), The Pharaoh Sails to Orion (From Wishes to Eternity)
    Happy New year guys! Cheers!

    • @timor86
      @timor86 5 лет назад

      Already done Slayings the dreamer, check older videos

    • @mjpmattos
      @mjpmattos 5 лет назад

      @@timor86 thanks 👍🏼

    • @julijakordic6462
      @julijakordic6462 5 лет назад

      Yeah maybe Planet hell then. 🤗

  • @JLTS76
    @JLTS76 5 лет назад +11

    Also one of the heavier Nightwish songs that i love (like Romanticide)

  • @madhatter6708
    @madhatter6708 5 лет назад +4

    Thanks for the video and reaction.. Marco sings in several songs and is featured in few as the lead...The islander, High Hopes and Master Passion Greed..press on. Nightwish is special.

  • @lottasvard953
    @lottasvard953 5 лет назад +3

    FINLANDS MOST WANTED LIST:
    1. Tarot - Tides (live) (Marco from Nightwish)
    2. Thunderstone - Veterans of the apocalypse
    3. Diablo - The Preacher
    4. Torture Killer - Forever dead (vocals by Chris Barnes)
    5. Battle Beast - Iron hand (live)
    6. Magenta Harvest - Spawn of neglect
    7. Stratovarius - Hunting high and low
    8. Swallow The Sun - From happiness to dust
    9. Gloria Morti - Slaves
    10. Darkwoods My Betrothed - Inside the circle of stones (Tuomas & Emppu from Nightwish)

  • @zdenekdolezal9646
    @zdenekdolezal9646 5 лет назад +12

    Hi guys.
    You should try those:
    For much harder NW song: Yours is an Empty Hope - Live from Nightwish Cruise on Baltic Princess
    For Marco's sweet vocals: The Islander Live from Tampare
    For little surprise: Ayreon - Everybody Dies - Live
    (I hope you didn't already did them)
    And Happy New Year, I'm lookong forward to your videos in 2019. Cheers.

  • @juanchibrossa8569
    @juanchibrossa8569 5 лет назад +10

    Nightwish - Song Of Myself (Wacken)

  • @philygames7213
    @philygames7213 5 лет назад +3

    One of my favourites...thx guys for the reaction!

  • @thisusernamenowtaken
    @thisusernamenowtaken 5 лет назад +3

    Catching up with your videos I missed, *part* *4:* It's so great that you guys have put so much effort into pronouncing the names correctly-most reactionists (eh?) don't even bother to guess how 'Tuomas' is pronounced, for example. Marco's given name Marko is of course, more or less pronounced just like 'Marco', so no problems there. I think you've gotten 'Jukka' and 'Eppu' correctly in the past too :) Great Wacken performance, great reactions!

  • @gamelle71
    @gamelle71 5 лет назад +2

    Nightwish - 7 Days To The Wolves (Live at Wembley Arena) , you'll also probably like it , very good underrated Nitghwish song !!!

  • @billmichaels6381
    @billmichaels6381 5 лет назад +1

    Let me first start off and say I hope that you and your family had a great Christmas and a Happy New Year..
    Next time I want to say the beard is looking great LOL..
    Also I want to say I love your show..
    Now on to Nightwish.. this by far is music art.. the arrangement and composition and production of their music is amazing.. and also let us not forget the musicianship of this band.. this song is awesome. It was also my first time hearing it..
    And the thing about the cowbell. This isn't Blue Oyster Cult Don't Fear the Reaper LOL..
    And I now see that you guys are under the spell of Nightwish and I also have a confession I am also under that spell. I am so glad you guys have broadened Your Horizon and perspective about metal music and appreciate it..
    I have two requests either or will be good and different..
    1. Pink Floyd high hopes by Nightwish.
    2. Ava Marie by Nightwish.. this version right here is quite amazing..
    Well keep on keeping on looking forward to your next reaction.. and thank you for Nightwish Sundays

  • @fdsannie
    @fdsannie 5 лет назад +4

    I say it the same way Antonio does........ :-) I am so glad you finally did this song. I knew you would really like this one. Marco is amazing. The two of them together are really good. I am glad you pointed out Emppu. He kind of gets forgotten. Thanks for the reaction. You do know Nightwish has over 100 songs. And that doesn't count the ones that had different singers. At the rate you are going I will be dead before you listen to them all..... lol Maybe you would consider making it Nightwish Sunday until Wintersun has a new album. Or you could pick any day you want. It is just a thought.............. :-) Happy New Year!

    • @Piia2023
      @Piia2023 5 лет назад +2

      Ann, don't say that...but a Nightwish song once a week would be great 🤘

    • @davidmachado11
      @davidmachado11 5 лет назад +2

      Yes, a Nightwish song once a week is good for our souls!
      It's scientifically proven!! 😉

    • @Piia2023
      @Piia2023 5 лет назад +2

      @@davidmachado11 I like that research 🤘

  • @warhammer5690
    @warhammer5690 5 лет назад +2

    FINALLY GHOST RIVER!!!!!

  • @aliyahburnette8231
    @aliyahburnette8231 5 лет назад +4

    You should do Nightwish storytime live in Tampere please.

  • @SwedeMackster
    @SwedeMackster 5 лет назад +2

    anybody with a sensne of metal and good stuff, would bought this amazing DVD/Bluray by now....
    Why wait?

  • @marcmetz5597
    @marcmetz5597 5 лет назад +2

    great way to end the year! I don't think you have reacted to "Nightwish - Song of Myself".(Wacken version because the pyro was perfect for this song). I think it could be a top 5 Nightwish song for you.

  • @mode3247
    @mode3247 5 лет назад +3

    "while your lips are still red" nightwish

  • @sulrics
    @sulrics 5 лет назад +1

    Another great reaction. Keep up the good work guys.

  • @julijakordic6462
    @julijakordic6462 5 лет назад +1

    Should check out PLANET HELL. Amazaballs. Also THE KINSLAYER!! can't wait for it in next year. Happy holidays guys and a lot of love 🤗🤗

  • @Ublabaah
    @Ublabaah 5 лет назад

    You guys need to check out Nightwish - Weak Fantasy live at Wembley. Right up your alley, I guarantee that.

  • @davemason4055
    @davemason4055 5 лет назад

    I've never heard anyone suggest cowbell, but now I'm intrigued.

  • @Eluarelon
    @Eluarelon 5 лет назад +1

    You know, I don't know about those other two germans, but everytime I spit my coffee watching your videos it's because I'm laughin my ass off. So by all means keep butchering my language and, even more importantly, keep reflecting on that butchering in your absolutely hilarious and humorous way. I totally love it. So, and on a more serious note, I have to admit, that everytime I hear Floor sing an Imaginaerum song I keep thinking that those songs sound that much more awesome if sung by Anette, because they were written with her voice in mind. Not saying Floor doesn't nail those songs, but to me it's a testament of ruclips.net/user/Nightwishofficialhow good a singer Anette actually is. And I stand by my opinion that Imaginaerum is the best Nightwish album ever with and because of Anette.

  • @teijoh
    @teijoh 5 лет назад +5

    IF you really, I mean really want to watch some heavy and pure NW live stuff to headbang to I recommend you to listen to FantasMic (third part) LIVE from year 2000!! All the band members going totally crazy...

    • @diandraa_
      @diandraa_ 5 лет назад +1

      Yes please !!!!

    • @FunIsGoingOn
      @FunIsGoingOn 5 лет назад +1

      It's crazy to realize that those records are >=20 years old

    • @julijakordic6462
      @julijakordic6462 5 лет назад +1

      Yeeeeees. PHARAON SAILS TO ORION. 😍😍😍

  • @Dorlonf
    @Dorlonf 5 лет назад

    Guys, as I would recommend for you.. try a live version of Yours is an Empty Hope. It's really heavy one and I'm sure you'll enjoy this one ^^

  • @HerrXabu
    @HerrXabu 5 лет назад +2

    NEIN, NEIN NEIN!! SO GEHT DAS NICHT!!
    HAHA! Love you Guys 🙂 Greetings from North Germany

  • @eijalammi
    @eijalammi 5 лет назад +1

    Marco´s voice is amazing

  • @dyyddyyd3410
    @dyyddyyd3410 5 лет назад +2

    Turmion Kätilöt Lataa & Varmista
    We need it 🤘🏼

  • @petrisilvonen6058
    @petrisilvonen6058 5 лет назад +1

    Older masterpieces from Nightwish that you should try: The Kinslayer, She is my sin, Elvenpath and Nightquest.

  • @n_vselm7052
    @n_vselm7052 5 лет назад +1

    Within Temptation!!!!!!

  • @InquieteNightshade
    @InquieteNightshade 5 лет назад +1

    Between the lead vocals I tend to go: Floor, Annette, and than Tarja (unpopular opinion-I know), but if I'm to be honest I more stan Marco and Toumas.

  • @lioubinos99
    @lioubinos99 5 лет назад +10

    Imaginaerum is probably the best album by Nightwish.
    Tuomas surpassed himself with the composition in this album

    • @entelechy2020
      @entelechy2020 5 лет назад +1

      I have to agree, he hit a major creative peak with this album. Every song on this album is perfect and flows so beautifully.

  • @kimhedqvist2685
    @kimhedqvist2685 5 лет назад +12

    As much as I love the song, the backing track with the orchestra and ESPECIALLY the children's choir are way to low in the mix for this performance. The children's choir actually sings along from the second chorus and it's so epic in the studio version, as are the strings toward the end, but here you can hardly hear them.

  • @rodolfotardin435
    @rodolfotardin435 5 лет назад

    Nightwish - " Dark Chest Of Wonders " - Live at Wacken 2013

  • @peterkarargiris4110
    @peterkarargiris4110 5 лет назад

    Awesome end to 2018 guys ! See you next year for more laughs and great music. \m/\m/

  • @GabrielaHernandez-kj3ip
    @GabrielaHernandez-kj3ip 5 лет назад +2

    Epica-Kingdom of HEaven

  • @marcosap9035
    @marcosap9035 5 лет назад

    I love this song!!!

  • @Medley3000
    @Medley3000 5 лет назад

    I highly recommend you to watch a band called "Band-Maid"
    5 very talented female musicians from Tokyo. Hard Rock at it's best.

  • @jhonny357
    @jhonny357 5 лет назад +1

    Please, react to "The Writer", "Back to Zero", "Infest", "Deep Sleep" , "From The Depths" or "Story Of a Strange" from Breakdown Of Sanity!

  • @millerf22
    @millerf22 5 лет назад +2

    Stargazers live in Tampere

  • @claudiachiulli36
    @claudiachiulli36 5 лет назад

    🖤

  • @VKaiserV
    @VKaiserV 5 лет назад

    I'll just leave this here:
    Myrath - Believer
    or the latest release: Myrath - Dance

  • @pavolridrich3434
    @pavolridrich3434 5 лет назад +1

    Any chance for
    Theocracy - The Mirror Of Souls
    or
    Celesty - Legacy Of Hate pt3
    both masterpieces

    • @EsaValkama
      @EsaValkama 5 лет назад

      Seconded. Both are really epic songs (And REALLY long too, well over 30 minutes if listened back to back XD), and really underrated. As for what style they are, MoS is progressive power metal, and LoH is progressive symphonic power metal with a bit of growls halfway through (Some of the best growls I've ever heard. The singer sounds really vicious when doing them).

  • @ThomasRenneis
    @ThomasRenneis 5 лет назад

    Earth Crisis -Nemesis, Heaven Shall Burn - Corium

  • @Vandroivs
    @Vandroivs 5 лет назад

    SONG OF MYSELF - LIVE ...!!!!!!!

  • @kimseymour5250
    @kimseymour5250 5 лет назад

    The live version feels slower than the album version for some reason? I’m probably just imagining it lol. Still freaking amazing ❤️

    • @TerranigmaQuintet
      @TerranigmaQuintet 5 лет назад

      Nope it is, they likely picked a yt version ripped from the bluray, that has he infamous pal to ntsc speed conversion applies, making it 5-10% slower than the original. Or maybe I'm just imaginign things here.

  • @timomastosalo
    @timomastosalo 5 лет назад

    A bit like they would've listened to Beastie Boys just before making this. Kinda rappy moments in the singing of Marco :)

  • @constantinciubotaru6687
    @constantinciubotaru6687 5 лет назад

    Nightwish Swanheart live review please please-it The Absolute Best masterpiece Ever!!!It's Loop fo ever and ever...
    Alsoe My Walden Live at Tampere 2015 OMG soo much harmony there wijt Troy absouletly amazing pls review also

  • @jesusgyr
    @jesusgyr 5 лет назад +1

    Please do Diablo - The Preacher!

  • @shortygamerboy3131
    @shortygamerboy3131 5 лет назад

    You should do Murch

  • @themadmagi
    @themadmagi 5 лет назад

    You guys should really redo Ghost Love Score now that you like Nightwish; you really didn't care for it when you reviewed it.

  • @robertperrotto870
    @robertperrotto870 5 лет назад +2

    MORE COWBELL!!!!!!

  • @warren54
    @warren54 5 лет назад

    React to Ether by Make Them Suffer

  • @corneliusantonius3108
    @corneliusantonius3108 5 лет назад

    I will just leave this here: MARCO+FLOOR+DELAIN 2009 Delain a Day for Ghosts (Live Pro Shot Broerenkerk ft. Floor & Marco) LINK: ruclips.net/video/hHtJsiLAkM4/видео.html

  • @ronaldboers8061
    @ronaldboers8061 5 лет назад

    Nice review as always. It has been awhile since you guys reviewed a Epica clip. A good one by them would be "Chasing the dragon" from their Retrospects live DVD where they were supported by a full symphonic orchestra, choir and this case also acrobats . ruclips.net/video/Dx-FsHAQHp8/видео.html

  • @WhatDayIsItTrumpDay
    @WhatDayIsItTrumpDay 5 лет назад

    It's not Wacken it's VAUKEN.

  • @andreidan2878
    @andreidan2878 5 лет назад

    Whenever I hear him I imagine it spelled Whacken!

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад

      Exactly

    • @andreidan2878
      @andreidan2878 5 лет назад

      @@APREACTS Hey I'm just gonna throw this in. If you can find the time for it you should react to the new Ancient Bards video called Impious Dystopia! Judging by what stuff you've enjoyed so far I am CERTAIN you'll like that one. Also there's Martino Garattoni from Ne Obliviscaris on the bass.

  • @Piia2023
    @Piia2023 5 лет назад +4

    This is great, as is the whole concert, yes, but take your time and listen to the original with Anette...it is a bit faster and the music is a bit creapier, and Anette is amazing!

    • @jbo4547
      @jbo4547 5 лет назад +1

      Im soooo glad i listened to Nightwish with Floor first. If i had heard it with Annette i really think i would have been turned off completely. But thats just me

    • @Piia2023
      @Piia2023 5 лет назад

      @@jbo4547 that is true if you had seen Anette live first...but in the studio she was great, and had one of the greatest song to sing, and Floor is great how ever you look at her, listen to every Nightwish song she has done

  • @stevekanakanui7033
    @stevekanakanui7033 5 лет назад

    PRONOUNCED ....VOCKEN ..

  • @gameplayfirst-ger
    @gameplayfirst-ger 5 лет назад +1

    Germans are not offended that easily. After being called Nazi by stupid people from all over the world and hated by some Europeans, mispronunciation of Wacken is the least of our problems. ;)

    • @APREACTS
      @APREACTS  5 лет назад

      When you put it in that perspective I can see that you do have bigger problems to deal with. lol

    • @larapapa3862
      @larapapa3862 5 лет назад

      gnadenlos 2-4 😎

  • @dangerx7697
    @dangerx7697 5 лет назад +1

    Its pronounced...."VAH-KIN".

  • @Ama-Elaini
    @Ama-Elaini 5 лет назад

    Again, the non official video has been slowed down...

  • @RataCosmica
    @RataCosmica 5 лет назад

    First :v

  • @petermemez1983
    @petermemez1983 Год назад

    I don't like this version since it is not in the original key the studio album is.

  • @lintu25
    @lintu25 4 года назад

    Did you say Finnish? Germans don't spit on Finnish and that is visa versa.
    Most of Finns respect German soldier. So should you. Those death camps are not whole true.
    and btw. this is shit song.

  • @timor86
    @timor86 5 лет назад

    Antonio, you need to cut your hair, c'mon you're a man now, it's time to get a new look for the new year.

    • @codyshafer6881
      @codyshafer6881 5 лет назад +2

      why he still is pretty young though . lol

    • @vailismyname
      @vailismyname 5 лет назад +1

      Number one- he's still a teenybopper.
      Number two- fuck no lol

    • @comicozy8786
      @comicozy8786 5 лет назад

      He has beautiful hair

  • @mode3247
    @mode3247 5 лет назад

    ❤️