How Does The Sarasvati River Debunk Aryan Invasion Theory? | Abhijit Chavda

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
  • #AskAbhijit Episode 43, Question 5
    WATCH FULL EPISODE (Aryan Invasion? Migration? Tourism? Picnic?) ► • #AskAbhijit 43: Aryan ...
    #AryanInvasion #AryanMigration #AryanMyth
    SUBSCRIBE ► www.youtube.co...
    SHORT CLIPS CHANNEL ► www.youtube.co...
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
    ►PayPal: paypal.me/Abhi...
    ►Become A Member on RUclips: / @abhijitchavda
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    JOIN #AbhijitChavda
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ★Discord: / discord
    ★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
    ★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
    ★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
    ★Website:
    ★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    #AskAbhijitPodcast
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ★Spotify: open.spotify.c...
    ★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
    ★Google Podcasts: podcasts.googl...
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    #AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow

Комментарии • 370

  • @arcane3464
    @arcane3464 3 года назад +119

    The Western people were known as barbarians to the ancient Indian. Now they want to be Aryans, it's quite funny to think about it... 😂

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer 3 года назад +9

      Because, they don't want to take desert cult heritage.
      Even greeks called Europeans barbarose equivalent to mlechacha (in Saraswati dharma)

    • @aryanchakraborty5175
      @aryanchakraborty5175 3 года назад +20

      @@MrSoothsayer The Europeans called the Greeks and Romans as Mediterranean , and when they realized they have no History , Greece and Rome became European lmao

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer 3 года назад +8

      @@aryanchakraborty5175 Yup. Pagan greeks & Romans don't exist anymore, & Europe today is a wealthy continent giving a pride to Mediterranean.

    • @Bhatti_Saab_7773
      @Bhatti_Saab_7773 2 года назад +13

      Yaa, 😂...
      one freak was hitler who was insanely trying to proove himself aryan and others impure that he killed millions and started WW2 😂

    • @Blastizor
      @Blastizor 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@aryanchakraborty5175 HAHHAHAHA SO TRUE LOL

  • @statickk14
    @statickk14 3 года назад +138

    This Aryan Invasion Theory needs to die. We have to challenge this BS from Western academics , and write our own history. Srikanth Talageri has done excellent job to debunk this from a linguistic perspective.

    • @sukhjohal8998
      @sukhjohal8998 2 года назад +8

      out of India theory

    • @reddituser166
      @reddituser166 2 года назад +2

      We can do it by our own theory and popularized it

    • @Xyz22346
      @Xyz22346 Год назад +4

      Not possible Communist won't let it go .

    • @TheaverageMeluhan
      @TheaverageMeluhan 11 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@Xyz22346There are coomunists who can't think for themselves. Let them chitter chatter.

    • @ribhuchattopadhyay1106
      @ribhuchattopadhyay1106 4 месяца назад

      All must come together in order to intellectually debunk this Aryan invasion theory ,we should research our own history and should popularise it in the mainstream media, again from the above video it is quite clear that indus Valley civilization was a proper vedic civilization and after the drying of Saraswati river during 2000BCE our ancestors moved eastwards and a new civilization started ,of course some austo asiatic gene flow may take place but all things were done in a peaceful manner ,the westerners are desperate to prove that our ancestors were involved in almost a kind of genocide or torturing of other people but all indian intellectuals must challenge and debunk this theory .

  • @ILLUTIX
    @ILLUTIX 3 года назад +228

    There is a reason why Indra was praised more than any other Devas, because of the Great Monsoon, as soon as Monsoon started Declining, Indra's presence in People's mind too.

    • @ashketchum5466
      @ashketchum5466 3 года назад +17

      Indra the slayer of dragon vitra, the deity who ended ice age.

    • @paritoshjha28
      @paritoshjha28 3 года назад +13

      Wow now everything makes sense

    • @paritoshjha28
      @paritoshjha28 3 года назад +29

      You have more intelligence than the pseudo intellectuals who created aryan picnic myth

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer 3 года назад +2

      Indra is not one.
      Two indras do exist one is isana indra, the indra of all Gods is of north Aryavartha
      Of South Aryavartha is sukra indra.

    • @SainaBidi
      @SainaBidi 3 года назад +12

      @@MrSoothsayer Indra is not a person it's a whoever sit in indra aasan he/she becomes Indra

  • @debashishmaahanta214
    @debashishmaahanta214 3 года назад +284

    Western society tries to keep down the great history of india. We should know our actual history and culture which is the greatest of all time.

    • @devisnayak8677
      @devisnayak8677 3 года назад +23

      @@vineethjoshy4819 another babbons of westerner

    • @nikhilsingh9789
      @nikhilsingh9789 3 года назад +1

      You are independent so stop blaming other and start action

    • @Rishi123456789
      @Rishi123456789 2 года назад +21

      @@vineethjoshy4819: "The Indus Valley Civilization was great , but it is not your civilization."
      Wrong. It's my civilization, because the Indus river and the Indus Valley Civilization are located in India and India itself is named after the Indus river. Keep seething.

    • @devisnayak8677
      @devisnayak8677 2 года назад +4

      @K nikhilesh Vaibhav Krupakar ok I understand this I know already about but just tell me the meaning of Dravidian

    • @devisnayak8677
      @devisnayak8677 2 года назад +1

      @K nikhilesh Vaibhav Krupakar meaning of amt and ivc please

  • @krishnadas_3740
    @krishnadas_3740 3 года назад +213

    I've read & watched many videos regarding the river Saraswati & when it dried up. And many studies showcase that it can be dried in 25,000bc or more or it can also be 8000-9000 years ago. Regardless of it's date it's clear that Rig Vedic times are really majestic & beyond our current understanding of history & technology.

    • @abhisheksumanAS
      @abhisheksumanAS 3 года назад +7

      Milankovitch cycle, the monsoon becomes strong and then weak. And this is why the change in state of the Saraswati River

    • @gamerdude3126
      @gamerdude3126 3 года назад +1

      @@abhisheksumanAS i feel the ending of ice age 10k years ago must have played some part in this.

    • @hsram1985
      @hsram1985 3 года назад +4

      In Mahabharatha war last battle between Duryodhana and Bhima happened in the banks of dying river Saraswati. Saraswati river dried up 6000 years ago.

    • @hsram1985
      @hsram1985 3 года назад +5

      @@gamerdude3126 There was no ice age in India. It didn't affected India anyway.

    • @gamerdude3126
      @gamerdude3126 3 года назад +9

      @@hsram1985 it affected the entire world, obviously not as much as the areas near poles but still. The global temperature was much lower and that will change the monsoons and maybe even the glaciers in Himalayas were much bigger too.
      Did you know that during ice age sea level was lower by 120meters? That meant Sri Lanka and india were connected by land. Google sea level during ice age and check the land areas. South East Asia was so much bigger and costal areas of India were even larger than now. Makes sense that Dwaraka is submerged in the sea now
      That means events of Ramayana must have happened after the ice age was over.

  • @KuldeepPerfect10StudyGroup
    @KuldeepPerfect10StudyGroup 3 года назад +93

    This guy is a storehouse of knowledge

  • @invictousjoker4527
    @invictousjoker4527 3 года назад +94

    I am from Prayagraj where the 3 rivers, Ganga, Yamuna and Saraswati met. Abhijit sir is absolutely right. Sarswati River is now a seasonal river call as SASUR KHASERA it's near Fafamau region in Northern part of Prayag raj. Till now also there is a well which is in the Akbar's fort which have crystl clear Water from Saraswati river.

    • @AnandSingh-mx2bx
      @AnandSingh-mx2bx 3 года назад +12

      That Saraswati is different from the Saraswati of rig Veda which flowed through rajasthan and gujarat not Prayagraj

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer 3 года назад +2

      @@AnandSingh-mx2bx It was metaphor created by regional pundits.
      Everyone knows Saraswati flows through haryana

    • @AnandSingh-mx2bx
      @AnandSingh-mx2bx 3 года назад +1

      @@MrSoothsayer hmmm.....

    • @invictousjoker4527
      @invictousjoker4527 3 года назад +1

      @@MrSoothsayer if it's so I take my words back, but as far as I have heard from The Pujari of Veni Madhav Temple, in Prayag, three rivers, Ganga, Yamuna, ans Saraswati met at Triveni here

    • @MrSoothsayer
      @MrSoothsayer 3 года назад +1

      @@invictousjoker4527 You ain't wrong by & large
      Saraswati flowed from himalyan, it doesn't mean, she mate chose haryana and Punjab on the way to Gujrat
      More likely, she would have turned eastward as well that is to utter pradesh and bihar

  • @gamingrepair1338
    @gamingrepair1338 3 года назад +87

    And fun fact is it is not mentioned in the oldest book of Rig Veda it is mentioned in 4th and 5th book of Rigveda so you can think Rigveda could be even older than 12000 bC because there are many mansions of astronomical events in Rig Veda that could be dated back to 12000 BC

    • @hsram1985
      @hsram1985 3 года назад +20

      Vedas were in oral route for more than forty thousand years before it was written down. Vedas were written down in the banks of river Saraswati 7000 years ago. Maharishis understand human DNA is degrading. They wrote down Vedas because they realized such knowledge cannot be memorized by humans anymore.

    • @anonymous-ui8xw
      @anonymous-ui8xw 3 года назад

      @@manishmishraji i believe perhaps global civilization didn't exist but many civilizations which had so many common traits that we could term them as a whole, global civilization like indra zeus thor etc

    • @anonymous-ui8xw
      @anonymous-ui8xw 3 года назад +1

      @@manishmishraji i agree with your opinion but for now I'm just focusing on getting a job lol. I would like to dig up more about this after i get a job.

    • @purnachandramondal9802
      @purnachandramondal9802 2 года назад +7

      Knowledge of Vedas is far old beyond our imagination of past. Maharshi Vyas just composed Vedas in systematic categorized manner for the first time. It recomposed again and again in different periods. Most of ancient compositions available now are from Gupta periods, very little from Maryan periods

    • @ASFACT2805
      @ASFACT2805 6 месяцев назад

      which is the oldest book of rigveda as per your knowledge

  • @janardansingh5926
    @janardansingh5926 3 года назад +33

    Sir not only the mighty today's Indians will have lot of difficulty in recall ing that lots of metal industries trades & technology existed in almost all big villages of India

  • @inquisitivetriangulator7465
    @inquisitivetriangulator7465 3 года назад +141

    I get very furious whenever I see our history like Ramayan, Mahabharat termed as mythology. Please all of you, advocate the truth. I am doing the same.

    • @harshit2.02
      @harshit2.02 3 года назад +20

      even when i was in school and used to see words like Mythology in front of Ramayan and mahabharat i used to think it might be another word used to say history but later when i came to knew that it means 'imaginary story' , i stopped using that word

    • @user-ip5up2on4s
      @user-ip5up2on4s 3 года назад +2

      Maharishi Ved Vyas
      And Maharishi Valmiki
      Used figures of speech in their writings which made it more like a story in some parts
      This shloka tells us what itihasa is
      Dharm arth kaam mokshanam updesham samanvitam
      Poorvavrittam Kathayuktam Itihasa prayachhate
      Meaning
      One which gives the Updesh on The four purusharths(Dharm,Arth,Kam,Moksha)...WHICH HAS HAPPENED BEFORE and
      Which is written in the form of a KATHA......Is Itihasa(this is how it happened)

    • @lautheimpaler4686
      @lautheimpaler4686 2 года назад +1

      It's called mythology because It has mythological elements. If it was written in a realistic way, it would have been treated as history.

    • @Yogis_BitterTruth_Nirvan
      @Yogis_BitterTruth_Nirvan 2 года назад

      @@lautheimpaler4686 if some parts of history is exaggerated then it becomes supernatural so instead of considering those smaller parts as mythological elements. western Christian missionary funded antihindu historiens are serious about erasing our history and therefore they instead of ignoring supernatural elements they are discarding whole history. for eg. if in the full sack of rice there are few small rocks then the rice needs to be filtered. but these idiots are throwing whole sack of rices. another eg. if there is a bucket filled with diamonds and there are some rocks in it. then you need to filter them but you are throwing whole bucket of diamond because of some rocks in it? that is the most worst epitome of stupidity. is it stupidity or is it deleberate erasing of our history. because their stupidity is beyond true to even exist.

    • @rithiek5446
      @rithiek5446 2 года назад +6

      @@lautheimpaler4686 what was realistic a few milleniums back need not be realistic now.
      We can't build Great Pyramid even with today's technology. Does that mean Pyramids are myths? No. They are majestically standing in the deserts of Giza.

  • @Saint.Topman
    @Saint.Topman 3 года назад +32

    Abhijit sir please make a video on battle of ten kings. When it happened,how it happen and why it happened.

    • @basudevrout5188
      @basudevrout5188 3 года назад +2

      Yes brother that's a interesting topic

    • @chittodnaresh9568
      @chittodnaresh9568 3 года назад +2

      #AskAbhijit Dashrajnya Yuddha-The earliest recorded major war in India?

    • @lll2282
      @lll2282 2 года назад

      yes please even I eant to know the entire story

  • @jagadeeshdomalapelli487
    @jagadeeshdomalapelli487 3 года назад +21

    It is surprising that in NCERT The Date of Writing the Rigveda was 3500bc, first time they have done something good.

  • @anmolpandey9670
    @anmolpandey9670 2 года назад +5

    And it is also mentioned that, Kaliyuga will end the day when Ganga river will completely dry...

  • @sujitbose7627
    @sujitbose7627 3 года назад +10

    The Rann of Kutch was till recent years was a brackish water deltaic region in to which Saraswati discharged its water. The northeastern tectonic thrust of the tectonic plate against the Asian plate was responsible for the river bed that caused it's disappearance.

  • @amit1090059
    @amit1090059 3 года назад +51

    Plot twist: Historians from the future went back in time to write rig Vedas, just to prove Aryan tourism theory wrong.

    • @adityasarap
      @adityasarap 3 года назад +1

      :0

    • @animax1034
      @animax1034 3 года назад +15

      Nice joke. aryan invasion/tourism/picnic dogma theory is embarassing and open lie and those who support it should he ashamed.

    • @user-ip5up2on4s
      @user-ip5up2on4s 3 года назад

      To again state that time travel is 99% not possible
      Just a made up , attractive fantasy

    • @aayushhwtf
      @aayushhwtf 3 года назад

      Sarcasm level 100%

    • @harshkulkarni963
      @harshkulkarni963 3 года назад

      @@user-ip5up2on4s
      Who said that it is 99% *not* possible?

  • @dustaatma550
    @dustaatma550 2 года назад +5

    There is a tirth known as kapalmochan tirth @kalayat a small town near Narwana, it has its connection with river saraswati. Till date it gets its water from same river bed naturally..Govt of Haryana has started a program on River saraswati...& Found some of its tracks near Adibadri in Yamunanagar district.
    Braham sarovar in kurukshetra also has a link to this river

  • @krishnaats7141
    @krishnaats7141 Год назад +3

    We should start calling Arabian sea as Sindhu Sagara, Bay of Bengal as Ganga Sagara and Rest of Indian ocean as Hindu Sagara or Hindu Maha Samudr or Bharata Sagara

  • @abhishekshukla579
    @abhishekshukla579 3 года назад +3

    Much needed work finally done.

  • @shouryadas7758
    @shouryadas7758 3 года назад +17

    Many people say Mortimer wheeler a British archaeologist had made this Aryan invasion theory.

  • @rahultiwari8703
    @rahultiwari8703 3 года назад +5

    Can we consider that the Sanskrit is also atleast 8000 years old based on Saraswati reference?

  • @meherunissajahan3388
    @meherunissajahan3388 3 года назад +8

    Bakhtiyar khilji did severe damage to History of Bharat Varsha when he destroyed the Nalanda University The History of Bharat Varsha was lost

    • @JaqenHegar
      @JaqenHegar 3 года назад +5

      There were many universities not only Nalanda.

    • @rasikadurbule3025
      @rasikadurbule3025 4 месяца назад

      There wasn't just one University in the humungous subcontinent duh 😂😂

  • @dancingglobe4427
    @dancingglobe4427 3 года назад +4

    Mother of floods & loudly roaring river in Rigveda :- Saraswati River

  • @paritoshjha28
    @paritoshjha28 3 года назад +21

    Every pseudo intellectual is gangsta & can call our ancient texts just mythology
    ,until advancement in technology gradually starts proving every fact in it

    • @Bobby_kavitha
      @Bobby_kavitha 4 месяца назад

      Wow 10+ likes , that means 10+ 🤡 exits in this space

  • @user-xs2fl1uf9j
    @user-xs2fl1uf9j 3 года назад +5

    Please invite nilesh oak and question him on mahabharat and ramayan ratings. He has done ground breaking work.

  • @subhi222
    @subhi222 3 года назад +3

    A curse is said about why the Saraswati river disappeared. It is said that the Saraswati river was cursed by Ved Vyas. The reason for this was that when Ved Vyas was composing the Mahabharata, he was disturbed by the noise of the Saraswati river

    • @ramparmar3805
      @ramparmar3805 3 года назад +2

      That's how indian recorded their history in story form. Here they recorded drying up of sarswati river.

    • @purnachandramondal9802
      @purnachandramondal9802 2 года назад +2

      There are many interesting colourful stories. We have take that as just colorful stories. We have to take the lesson & inner meaning from such stories. But we cannot scientifically rely & believe that as literal truth on all such stories .

  • @asmaaftab4497
    @asmaaftab4497 Год назад +2

    In Pakistan Mustansar Hussain Tarar has written a novel "Bahao" in 1992, in which he wrote about the disappearance of ghagra river and the cities relied upon it.

    • @manurr10
      @manurr10 Год назад

      It is Saraswati river

  • @amitpratap7551
    @amitpratap7551 2 года назад +3

    Abhijeet jee, Please network with Prachyam to present your talk in a hard hitting video format 🙏🙏.

  • @anonymous-ui8xw
    @anonymous-ui8xw 3 года назад +2

    Shri Nilesh oak's work is absolutely fantastic on this topic.

  • @pandafighter1903
    @pandafighter1903 3 года назад +2

    saraswati river still flows at mana village,uttarakhand.

  • @parthapaul1249
    @parthapaul1249 2 года назад +2

    Jai Ma Saraswati

  • @IshanKesharwani
    @IshanKesharwani 3 года назад +2

    In Prayagraj you can still aee Saraswati Koop in Allahabad Fort which is actually said to be Saraswati River. Even ASI says it

  • @संजयगोस्वामी-ग6ह

    Think a real world parallel of might and volume of the Saraswati would be the Brahmaputra river. Also both rivers have similar flow direction

  • @itsdailyrahul
    @itsdailyrahul Год назад +3

    Can't wait to burn down the research papers of "ARYAN PICNIC THEORY" 👌🤣

  • @shyammishra3816
    @shyammishra3816 3 года назад +2

    #askabhijit my question is that who was raja dahir sen and did he save the generation of Muhammad and also tell about dahir sen daughter

  • @someshupadhayay6834
    @someshupadhayay6834 3 года назад +2

    #askabhijit sir please tell that in our veda's is there any mention of that vedic people eat meat our teacher who is preparing for uppsc have taught us that vedic people eated meat, they also offer it to their guest please clearify this sir

  • @r_a_
    @r_a_ 3 года назад +1

    Just another opinion. Apart from that I guess the slope, landscape, etc (eg flat lands rather than gorges or valleys, layers of earth, soil, etc) of Saraswati river's path (from the mountains to the Arabian sea) also could've been minor, if not major, factors in its disappearance.
    For example suppose there are 2 rivers with equal amount of water flowing through them. Suppose river 1 flows through drier, wider, less slanting, water absorbing, etc type of path. So it'll dry out much quicker than the river 2 which flows through opposite kinds of landscape/pathways.
    So maybe Saraswati had to go through river 1 type of pathways/landscape etc.
    Geology, climate, nature, etc is so complex & unpredictable that all of us can only speculate. There could also have been some mysterious factor or unknown phenomenon which caused the disappearance & we might never know.

  • @ska4666
    @ska4666 3 года назад +27

    I feel like throughout itihasa whoever has questioned bharat's credibility, has suffered a blow right in the face by cosmic causality itself, it's almost like, ....somebody is listening to all the nonsense, and when things get out of hands.... they somehow manage to show the path to redemption.
    In short, India never Roars back untill it gets smacked. Lol

  • @saneperson101
    @saneperson101 2 года назад +4

    #ASKABHIJIT When did vegetarianism dominate indian culture, more specifically, among brahmins? From evolution theory, we know that all humans were meat eaters at some point. Was vegetarianism due to buddhism or was it from brahmins from vedic times?

    • @SekadarPendapat
      @SekadarPendapat Год назад

      When did idolatry dominate indian culture?

    • @adish7839
      @adish7839 6 месяцев назад

      From the Vedic times. Vedas considers meat eating as sin.

  • @loginmisc123
    @loginmisc123 Год назад +1

    Rig Veda could be much older than 6000 or 7000 BCE. Sarasvati river also could be much more ancient a water body than 6000 BCE.

  • @bulbulmukherjee2736
    @bulbulmukherjee2736 6 месяцев назад

    Excellent, just excellent.

  • @mazaaaya4283
    @mazaaaya4283 3 года назад +4

    Aryan Conspiracy Theory

  • @focus_seeker
    @focus_seeker 3 года назад +2

    #AskAbhijit
    I wish you talked more about how to improve the quality of our youth power. Though we have a huge quantity but its of bad quality the average human capital indeof india is falling in each year there a huge danger ahead we can never achieve our trillion dollar dream no matter how much economic policies we change, no matter how many infra projects we build we must have a capable dynamic youth who must be able to handle it and make it more prosperous.
    Its almost same as a rich man handing his business to his son but if the son is not calculative,intelligent, capable enough he may soon gamble and loose it away. Our youth has lots of potential but not a correct system.
    But there are some things which i feel if would have been included been better-
    1)lessons for india from the successful education system & science technology part of Israel. In 2019, Israel was ranked the world's fifth most innovative country by the Bloomberg Innovation Index.[2] It ranks thirteenth in the world for scientific output as measured by the number of scientific publications per million citizens.[3] In 2014, Israel's share of scientific articles published worldwide (0.9%) was much higher than its share of the global population (0.1%).[4][1]
    Israel counts 140 scientists and technicians per 10,000 employees, one of the highest ratios in the world. In comparison, there are 85 per 10,000 in the United States and 83 per 10,000 in Japan.[5] In 2012, Israel counted 8,337 full-time equivalent researchers per million inhabitants.[1] This compares with 3,984 in the US, 6,533 in the Republic of South Korea and 5,195 in Japan. Israel's high technology industry has benefited from both the country's highly educated and technologically skilled workforce coupled with the strong presence of foreign high-tech firms and sophisticated research centres.
    We must decode their secret to develop so many successful things from scratch whats their family environment, society environment that so many people emerge as successful innovators WHY? WHY?
    1)IS it because of their upbringing when in their childhood they are usually kept away from cartoon and all and more focus is put to archery,math,business those which can boost the focus and concentration of the child
    2)is it because of the compulsory military training they have to go through so they have a high amount of focus self discipline and also understand machines technologies better.
    3)or is it because as its surrounded by enemies even many countries don’t recognise it as a country so it is forced to be selfdependent and focus only on knowlwdge and brain because as they moved from country to country were totured massacred murdered so they learnt
    1)it was brain that was the permanent and the deadliest weapon in the world
    2)they couldn’t ask help from any country to help them defend themselves from their enemies the learnt it the hard way at the earliest. As said Neccessity is the mother of invention
    In their game of survival they became the best of best.
    WHY? WHY? A country which is surrounded by enemies| which is lesser in size and population than even many of our states| with no oil minerals natural resourses a bare desert|
    is now the starup nation the inventory and innovation capital of the world aheiving much more than their share of population
    But our india which produces more engineers than the US and China combined is nothing but a bunch of digital coolies and unemployed people.
    Where are we lagging WHAT IS THE SOLUTION CAN WE NEVER BECOME LIKE ISRAEL.
    Because india also shares the same problems of terrorism| surrounded by enemies | huge massacre in ww1&2
    Then why Indians lack so much in innovation and entrepreneurship and holds entitled to employer mentality, what forced Israelis to be so innovative and why we aren’t the same

  • @mj-ck4br
    @mj-ck4br 3 года назад +1

    #AskAbhijit sir should India consider signing CTBT & the new ban treaty. It's implications?

  • @tusharsharma6715
    @tusharsharma6715 3 года назад +2

    #AskAbhijit Sir, if the Ancient Sarswati river flowed through modern-day Rajasthan and Gujrat into the Arabian sea, then why there is a common belief that Ganga, Yamuna, and Saraswati met at Prayagraj (Triveni Sangam)?

  • @aranyaraj4843
    @aranyaraj4843 3 года назад +10

    #AskAbhijit Who was the Mauryan and what is it today, please tell their history

    • @mogambochamchokaabaap7262
      @mogambochamchokaabaap7262 2 года назад

      Suryavanshi Shakya branch of Kshatriyas.
      Presently the Moris of Rajasthan and Mores of Maharashtra are their descendents

  • @saurabhtalele1537
    @saurabhtalele1537 3 года назад +1

    u r 💎 sir

  • @maheshdave8012
    @maheshdave8012 3 года назад +1

    WRONG.!
    It was dried up
    Due to diversion of Sutlej and Yamuna river water , which were tributaries of saraswati river not by monsoon effect.The river had several tributaries like today's ghaggar hakra have ..
    The river dried gradually and not by sudden accident...
    The dholaveera at gujrat , bhatner at punjab or raj., Deravar at Sindh are the ancient towns developed on the bank of saraswati river.
    SOURCE : on the trail of the saraswati. By Michael danino

  • @krishnabhat1606
    @krishnabhat1606 3 года назад

    Thank you for the educative video 🙏

  • @mcocplayer26
    @mcocplayer26 3 года назад +5

    #Askabhijit what are the things that India has invented but are claimed by others in world. It may include concepts technology etc.
    Plane was created by wright bros or shivkarji talpade?.

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад

      Sadly This has no evidences

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +1

      @Akhand Bharat u r comparing Yoga to invention of aeronautics interms of origin.
      Even westerns widely are aware of India being origin of Yoga. It's only a few racist people making these claims

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +1

      @Akhand Bharat we should not believe everything Dharmic scriptures said too much. I mean vimanas and stuff are too much of pseudoscience.
      No one were able to recreate Vaimanika Shastra to create a flying machine.

    • @hitopdesh4202
      @hitopdesh4202 3 года назад +2

      Gurutvakarshan by Aryabhatta which later became Gravity of Newton. Kanad maharshi gave the theory of atom. Plastic surgery by sushruta....and the list goes on

    • @harshit2.02
      @harshit2.02 3 года назад +3

      problem is our scientist never patient anything with the mentality that these invention should be free so that other can contribute in like but sadly west patented.
      Other wise scientist like Shivkar Bapuji or Jagdish chandra bose etc would have been given the credit for there inventions/discovery

  • @raghavjajoo1047
    @raghavjajoo1047 3 года назад +3

    Guruji when you are coming live?

    • @vardhanarya
      @vardhanarya 3 года назад +1

      next week probably . he is sick now ,maybe covid . check the community tab in his channel ,he has posted about the same

    • @raghavjajoo1047
      @raghavjajoo1047 3 года назад

      @@vardhanarya ya i got it, guruji must recover soon I pray for him..

    • @vardhanarya
      @vardhanarya 3 года назад

      @@raghavjajoo1047 yes our prayers are with him .may he recover asap

  • @zester5704
    @zester5704 3 года назад +2

    You should write a book with all the Real History about India that westerners are so afraid of and that book should be made a part of the Indian School Cariullum

  • @shashipatteri963
    @shashipatteri963 3 месяца назад

    The Helmand river, Afghanistan, known in ancient Iranian Avestan as Harahvati is the real Sarasvati river because the early aryans who lived in Persia and Afghanistan named the Helmand river Saraswati. The name Helmand comes from the avestan Haetumant which is cognate with Sanskrit Setumati.

  • @bhuvaneshs.k638
    @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +3

    I recently read existence of river Saraswati is still disputed. Recent studies challenges this claim

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад

      @Akhand Bharat 84K years ago is too old for vedic or Indus valley civilization....
      It doesn't fit the known idea of river Saraswati.

    • @harshit2.02
      @harshit2.02 3 года назад +4

      @@bhuvaneshs.k638 in this same live session sir had shown a satellite image of it . which clearly looks like a river way which dried later

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад

      @@harshit2.02 yeah I'm not saying it's not there. I'm just playing devils advocate to this claim and see how strong are these claims

    • @harshit2.02
      @harshit2.02 3 года назад

      @@bhuvaneshs.k638 oh

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +1

      @@harshit2.02 new one study challenges this that's all... I'm not sure how they did all their measurements etc
      Plus age of Dwarka is also in dispute. It's not 9000 years old. It's more likely 1st century BC etc

  • @vespasian266
    @vespasian266 4 месяца назад

    No, the discription is of a river re-flooding anually. its because two thousand years back thats what was left of it.

  • @divyaraj8705
    @divyaraj8705 2 года назад

    Respected sir, there is an anime name one piece which is centralised around the idea of a great kingdom which used to exist 800 years ago but something happened and it was wiped out from the pages of history, i sometime feel that our situation is kind of similar we don't know about our past , the people who knew hace control over the information and they don't want us to know centuries after centuries it kept getting destroyed in case of universities, invasions, having leftist and westerns right "our history for us" i don't think that there is any community in the world more ignorant than us. A wise man once said know your roots and you shall touch the sky but we have lost the touch with it. Sir what you are doing is a remarkable job and needs guts we will support with everything we have,.. you have our respect sir
    Thank you sir

  • @mayurdead9210
    @mayurdead9210 3 года назад +2

    Wow

  • @jee9988
    @jee9988 3 года назад +1

    Thanks sir... I won the bet... 😁😁😁😁

  • @Shiva-wo2sj
    @Shiva-wo2sj 2 года назад +1

    #AskAbhijit sir please tell about prakrit skript

  • @ayushmishra4375
    @ayushmishra4375 3 года назад +2

    #askabhijit
    Please speak on mesopotamian civilization

  • @goodGirl43521
    @goodGirl43521 2 года назад

    Nice information

  • @vikasgupta-dk1du
    @vikasgupta-dk1du Год назад

    #ASKABHIJIT There is also a belief that the saraswati river starts near the Mana village in Uttarakhand which exists today as well. So which one is an archaeologically correct claim?

  • @milancbhatt
    @milancbhatt 3 года назад +1

    #AskAbhijit thoughts on dismantling global hindutva conference

  • @krishnadas_3740
    @krishnadas_3740 3 года назад +2

    #AskAbhijit , can you share more information on 9th reincarnation of Parabrahm Vishnu. I know Buddha are believed to be it & I too believe it but still,can it be possible that 9th Avatar is still to be born ?

    • @nirahua2367
      @nirahua2367 3 года назад

      @@Vedantindian2012 so Buddha is also included in those Avatar ?

    • @krishnadas_3740
      @krishnadas_3740 3 года назад +1

      @@Vedantindian2012 Yes, I too have heard about 24 avatars, well we really need to research our history for more information but sadly what's lost is still heartbreaking & we'll never know what that scripts behold.

    • @purnachandramondal9802
      @purnachandramondal9802 2 года назад

      You may be the avatar if you can increase your inner ability

  • @biplobmajumder7155
    @biplobmajumder7155 10 месяцев назад +1

    No myth in Sanatan Darma.

  • @adkyya2373
    @adkyya2373 2 месяца назад

    Why any vedas didn't mentioned about Indus valley civilization??

  • @Puran.
    @Puran. 3 года назад +2

    #AskAbhijit How is R&AW Powerful make a video

  • @animax1034
    @animax1034 3 года назад

    Beautifully explained. wonderful. very nice. Aryan invasion/tourism/picnic dogma theory is really embarrassing and those who supported should also be ashamed.

  • @NewLife-gw6si
    @NewLife-gw6si 9 месяцев назад +1

    If the theory is wrong, then how the similarities in language and religion be explained? Did indians migrate to the regions , historians say is the origin of aryans? And may be some of them did return to the subcontinent , there are so many questions!

    • @GyanTvAmit
      @GyanTvAmit 9 месяцев назад +1

      because rigveda mentioned out of india migration into Europe

    • @tsamgurkhan
      @tsamgurkhan 8 месяцев назад +1

      Also genetics. I actually read the papers in Nature and other peer reviewed places. Even the most Western Accepted Research wrote that probable start of R1a is Central Asia, Eurasia or South Asia. They also cannot reject India as the proponent. Not a single paper. India has so many markers that it's impossible to ignore. Incase the Dravidian Supporters are irked, the West also have papers to designate that Dravidians also came from outside. They are related to Arabs as they say. The whole plan is to keep Indians divided and confused. When the Indian scientists, from North and South, present genetics evidence, the Marxist Academia doesn't accept. Even neutral papers are rejected.

  • @shaks5351
    @shaks5351 2 года назад +1

    I think this theory was also propagated so that christianity's claim that humanity started somewhere around 3000 BC can be maintained. Not sure of this thing though. Can someone comment on this.

  • @reeteshs02
    @reeteshs02 Год назад

    Can you pls show instead of describing the satelite images which show the Saraswati river, everywhere even on searching in google I could find descriptions only of how the river has been found. If you are talking about Paleochannels, multiple of them have been found in Rajasthan and describing one of them as Saraswati could be right also but could be wrong also as rivers have changed course multiple times.

  • @h.s.negiculturalheritageof2120

    भारत में बहुत सारी नदियों के नाम के अंत में "ती" शब्द मिलते है जैसे:- गोमती, अमरावती, सरस्वती, आदि। सरस्वती भी भारत की इतिहासिक नदी है जो वर्तमान में विलुप्त हो चुकी है लेकिन इस नदी के अवशेष भूवैज्ञानिक खोज चुके है। इस नदी का नामकरण हमभाषी लोगो द्वारा इस नदी की विशेषताओं को देख क्र किया गया है। सरस्वती का अर्थ हमभाषा के अनुसार 'पानी' अर्थात नदी होता है। सरस्वती चार शब्दों (सर+सोव +व+ती) के मेल से बना है। प्रथम 'सर' 'खंडित या टूटता-फूटता', द्वितीय 'सु या 'सोव् '' 'उगना- ; सोव्ती' सरोवर या चश्मे का पानी तृतीय ;व्' आया,और चौथा 'ती' पानी या नदी। इस प्रकार सरस्वती का का अर्थ एक ऐसी नदी या पानी जो टूटती या लुप्त होती है,और सरोवरों या चश्मे में प्रकट हो कर बहती है अर्थात "सरस्वती" एक ऐसी नदी जो टूटी-फूटती है और सरोवरों के चश्मों से निकल बहती है।

  • @rangaswamyn8506
    @rangaswamyn8506 3 года назад

    Can you tell us about archeological findings of gulf of cambay

  • @Nunu_Butter_Masala
    @Nunu_Butter_Masala 3 года назад

    #AskAbhijit why it is important to India developed indigenous weapons like submarines, missiles and fifth generation fighter jets and what is the India's new rocket force it is important for India??

  • @biswajeetdassh9305
    @biswajeetdassh9305 Месяц назад

    Came here after NCERT history book correction of Sindhu-Harappa civilization in 2024....

  • @kuunaldeshmukh7752
    @kuunaldeshmukh7752 3 года назад

    sir shat shat panaam

  • @prasadasgoa
    @prasadasgoa 3 года назад +1

    Kindly view videos on this subject by Shri. Nilesh Nilkanth Oak on youtube.

  • @bhuvaneshs.k638
    @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +5

    River Saraswati dried up 6000 years ago due to tectonic shift

  • @pritish3484
    @pritish3484 3 года назад +1

    Is there any hope of recovering Saraswati river in it's former glory in the future?

    • @vardhanarya
      @vardhanarya 3 года назад +4

      its a natural process . takes thousands of years

    • @santusanturohit4832
      @santusanturohit4832 2 года назад

      We can build dam on river Indus in Ladakh..transfer water from there to Saraswati via Satluj river..

  • @subhranshuganguly2246
    @subhranshuganguly2246 Год назад

    OM GANGE CHA JAMUNE CHAIBA GODAVARI SARASWATI NARMADE SINDHU KAVERI MALAHASMINAH SANNIDHING KURU.

  • @rishabhvyas6473
    @rishabhvyas6473 3 года назад

    What are your views on Nilesh oak ji's video on Saraswati river where he dates the events related to the river?

  • @ekdanta_homedecor
    @ekdanta_homedecor 3 года назад

    Make a video on lalitaditya muktapida

  • @shrutijain9986
    @shrutijain9986 3 года назад +2

    You said so-called Arabian Sea... was it called something else at that time? Maybe some other mention with a different name?🤔

    • @bhanupratap1063
      @bhanupratap1063 3 года назад +3

      It was called Sindhu Sagar.

    • @shrutijain9986
      @shrutijain9986 3 года назад +1

      @@bhanupratap1063 Okay. It might be having its own history.

  • @janardansingh5926
    @janardansingh5926 3 года назад

    Mighty Saraswati River

  • @arpanmalakar11
    @arpanmalakar11 Год назад

    #AskAbhijit what would have happened if India opened up its economy in the 1960s itself? Could we have seen a more developed and prosperous India Today?

  • @alokkumar-wz9vb
    @alokkumar-wz9vb 3 года назад

    #Askabhijit sir, can you make a detail video on Adi Shankaracharya .

  • @sycrox5201
    @sycrox5201 2 года назад

    Simple before rig Veda actually written rishis munis were used to spread it by talks aur muhbola gyaan dete the

    • @Xyz22346
      @Xyz22346 Год назад

      Pahala ya jano ki veds ha kya or inko kitna purna mana jata ha . Rig ved is why oldern then 6,000 BC.

  • @avinashkomaravolu2781
    @avinashkomaravolu2781 2 года назад

    How do some one from out of Indian subcontinent come and write Vedas only after reaching saptha Sindhu region. How can they get sudden enlightenment after reaching Indian sub continent.

  • @fsbt5229
    @fsbt5229 3 года назад +4

    Today, since India is an independent country, Europeans have no longer any reason to prefer Aryan Invasion Theory to Out of India Theory. They know their ancestors came from Asia, Wether they came from Central Asia or South Asia doesn't matter at all. But it's still a debate in India because according to Aryan Invasian Theory, the ancestors of Southern Indians would have come from Eastern Africa and the ancestors of Northern Indians would have come from Central Asia. This could be threat for national unity of India. It's just an indian domestic issue.

    • @fsbt5229
      @fsbt5229 3 года назад

      @@ayushgaurincredible Most people agree to say Greece was just the first advanced civilization in Europe, thanks to knowledges from neighboring west Asia. But the debate AIT theory versus OIT theory is not closed yet. No dogma is accepted by everybody.

  • @adityashukla2317
    @adityashukla2317 3 года назад

    Its believed Yamuna and Sutlej were the tributaries of Sarasvati as mentioned in Vedas.

    • @HistoryDecode
      @HistoryDecode 3 года назад

      Yamuna is

    • @adityashukla2317
      @adityashukla2317 3 года назад

      @@HistoryDecode anpadh ho kya be pura. Kuch bhi likh rahe ho. Kya sasta nasha kr re ho??

    • @HistoryDecode
      @HistoryDecode 3 года назад +1

      @@adityashukla2317 Once yamuna and sutudri were the tributaries of saraswati river, it is conformed by some recent research

  • @kaustubhjaiswal5785
    @kaustubhjaiswal5785 3 года назад

    Great River🙏

  • @WilliBond0007
    @WilliBond0007 3 года назад +2

    when I couple Hopi mythology with India's .... I am willing to bet they are much older than 8k years old. Interesting how the Hopi in North America have similar belief in chakras too.

    • @Yogis_BitterTruth_Nirvan
      @Yogis_BitterTruth_Nirvan 2 года назад

      america and india were connected civilization and indians went there and built pyramids.

  • @mrk1238
    @mrk1238 Год назад

    JAI MATA MAHASARSWATI

  • @Historymystry03
    @Historymystry03 4 месяца назад

    I am still confused about Aryan theory. Was Aryan exiet? What happen after hadappa decline? Who was the Aryan? What is the origin of Aryans? If haddapan people know about there is something wrong and we can die, then they reallocate anywhere in India? And this reallocated people are Aryan's or not? If anyone know the authentic proof plz help me.

  • @yjspoder
    @yjspoder 3 года назад

    Saraswati dries up and India stops research. Coincidence? I think not.

  • @bhuvaneshs.k638
    @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад +4

    #AskAbhijit I have this burning question in my gut...!!
    Why no one like DRDO DARPA ISRO NASA etc tried recreating Experiments or models mentioned in Vaimanika Shastra. Is it just Pseudoscience or is there any scientific evidence/ Experiments??

    • @pratyushnaigaonkar3208
      @pratyushnaigaonkar3208 3 года назад

      That's why we need to invest more in R&D so that such things can be tried out

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 3 года назад

      @@Vedantindian2012 definitely not DARPA DRDO will have better expertise and resources. I'm talking about real research on ancient scriptures

    • @kaustubhjaiswal5785
      @kaustubhjaiswal5785 3 года назад

      Good question

    • @purnachandramondal9802
      @purnachandramondal9802 2 года назад

      I will, I hope getting the opportunity oneday

    • @Bobby_kavitha
      @Bobby_kavitha 4 месяца назад

      ​@@pratyushnaigaonkar3208 to burn the money of public

  • @maheshnayak2941
    @maheshnayak2941 3 года назад

    What about the Helmand river which is identified with first saraswati in rig veda?

    • @praveenhegde8107
      @praveenhegde8107 2 года назад

      Halmand doesn't drain into the sea, Saraswati did , they are not the same.

  • @mtt112
    @mtt112 3 года назад

    #Askabhijeet please tell untold story of acts that Naadir-shah did to Delhi.

  • @ajatashatru4198
    @ajatashatru4198 3 года назад

    Sir will you write history books?

  • @vinayakshah2892
    @vinayakshah2892 3 года назад +1

    This is extent of our Mr.Nehru and #Brigandhi view of our India.
    Now open up your mind my fellow citizens of India.

  • @RajaBabu-th7hm
    @RajaBabu-th7hm 3 года назад

    #AskAbhijit Sir, reports have came that US wants a military base in INDIA, should the INDIAN GOVT. allow them to make a base in our country under COMCASA, BECA, LEMOA. Or we should reject their proposals when they'll officially raise this issue.