The way these Officials answer questions. The awkward pauses, hurried ‘off-mic’ whispers, endless paper shuffling, inter-departmental buck passing and the infuriatingly lawyered answers to deflect responsibility are contemptible. Not one of these people seem engaged on actually addressing this issue.
Has it occurred to you that maybe they are there as smoke and mirrors and in reality they are not invovled in running this country in any way shape or form. Wouldnt that explain why they have no clue even regarding the most basic procedures.
So often the bureaucrats seem to squirm and struggle to give answers. It's like they are determined to give out as little information as possible so as not to expose their ineptitude.
THIS is what should be on our national news broadcasts!! Just imagine if the people knew of such incompetence, especially in the protection of children from known predators.
I stopped watching mainstream media 4-5 years ago, interested to see how much coverage they've given this so that the public in general would have any knowledge of these people that are in positions of power and just how incompetent these bureaucrats are.. Frankly it's embarrassing that they represent you and me and all of them are as dumb as 'phucking' dog shit! Just saying...,...
Senator James Paterson, you have the patience of a saint 🙏❤ Seriously.... how can these beaurecrats be in their jobs ???? I thought the protection of our Australian families was their 'duty of care'.... 😮 this is absolutely deplorable, imho...
What is wrong with albo, sex offenders do not stop being offenders, albo is allowing sex offenders to be allowed to offending other children, this is as sick as it gets with albo. These are all adults, allowing children to be harmed, what is wrong with them , what they dont have children or what.
in the too hard basket for this weak willed prime minister ,, these peodaphiles are mainly men who beleive there's nothing wrong with taking children,, God help our little ones because these people should be charged with pre consent because they know 98 percent reoffend !
But in the meantime, Albo telling the public that banning social media for under16 is keeping our kids safe.... yet they got Child sex offenders living next to schools.
What the hell are we doing in the Country; protect the immigrants and criminals and not worry about the hard working 'financially struggling' Aussies that pay for this shit! It's disgusting.
This shows that the value of the work of this department or agency in supervising criminal migrants is the equivalent of going to a fair and having fairy floss or not. In short, the cost of running this organisation is nothing more than money down the drain. Criminal migrants who are a risk to the community should be either deported or imprisoned until they are no longer a risk. Why should the Australian public be put at risk at the behest of politics or courts? Australian Government is just a joke, as this type of responsibility is the best we can ever expect from it. Sack the Australian Government Corporation which in law is not our government at all, but is a Coup D eTat after Queen Victoria died, and that has not had a lawfully installed and recognized Monarch since. This government is a FARCE, AN ABORTION, DISGRACE, A SHAME TO OUR NATION.
Dear Senator James Paterson, we the Australians would really love you to be our Prime Minister, NOT ALBANESE I NEVER VOTED FOR HIM. Cant we the Australians Fire Albanese? He is a repulsive little man.
@@agirlfrommars3441he cant he is a SENATOR!!! Learn how the Australian parliament works and pass it on to others who constantly ask for Patterson and Senator Hanson, who can not be PMs. Only Lower house politicians can become PM!s and most of the time they are selected from. NSW.
Why are people not being sent back to where they came from if they are breaching our laws on this level ? And dam the government is dropping the ball massively. Great Work Senator Paterson
Thousands came in under peter duttons watch. The LNP hurried thru laws that weren't tested before locking people up. Or up dating the legislation when in government. Dutton had criminal gangs bring in girls for prostitution.
Convicted s*x offender Dr Peter Macarthur, ENT surgeon of Armidale and Taree in Australia, held positions on the International Grammar Schools Board and another school board for decades. He applied for the positions a year after a six month only conviction of s*x assault on girls and women as they were being transferred onto the operating table. He did this to my young daughter, too but I didnt know as his surgery to remove her tonsils was so brutal she could not speak for weeks. I should sue him now, but dont have the energy as my daughter now has cancer. This man is just one of the monsters still working in our communities. We have to protect our children from them at all costs. Parents, never allow this man near your girls ever. Paedophiles and s*x offenders hide in plain sight at all levels of our society, but particularly in medicine, education, politics, the judiciary and police forces. It is worldwide, just look at trump and his administration full of perverts.
A prudent question might be how many of these offenders live in Canberra. I suspect it's none which could help explain the level of apathy these bureaucrats are showing,
those pathetic public servants must tremble in their seats when James comes to question them! They cringe and shuffle and prevaricate and lie to escape answering his questions. What a joke they are!!! Hope when the LNP take over the government these people are fired!
These public servants (remember they are servants of the people who are the tax payers) need to be reminded that their sole purpose is to serve Australian public and uphold Australian law. This is just another example of public servants failing in their duties and by virtue being paid for doing nothing. Time has well passed that we remove these filibustering bludgers from the public service. Well done Senator Patterson showing up these people.
All this money and time wasted on these lowest common denominator criminals, thank God for Senator Paterson in motivating the Government and it's lackluster Public Servants to earn their bread while we all suffer ontological insecurity at their inaction.
Why should they get housing catered to them but law abiding citizens don’t ? Why should they be given handouts and preferential treatment ? Ridiculous! Have them work in correction facilities. 😒
Senator James Paterson has so much patience. This looks bad. Is this a normal practice? Why does it seem they have no idea what they're doing? Are people in charge of Australia usually this awkward to answer and incompetent? Or is it just this years troupe? Paterson for prime minister I say.
Yea your right the LNP didn't change legislation when they lock up these refugees. And the high court found it was illegal to lock people up indefinitely.
Clare Sharpe you are so incompetent in your role. You are not able to give clear and precise answers to the committee, so is the whole team in your department. A waste of taxpayers money paying your salaries.
Keep up your brilliant work Senator. You are making the Majority of the ALP stumble and fumble on a daily basis. Your making ALP members look absolutely incapable and uneducated.
Have there been any unmonitored sex offenders in Parliament house. I can think of one straight off the bat , also a former attorney General and a state Labor party member in South Australia.
Keep up the good work James . Im sure these bureaucrats dont really believe this diatribe either but are doing their job. Australia should not be keeping sex offenders or violent criminals without close monitoring and support.
Ms Foster, how do you justify your position in the department. We have heard you and team waffling on with your responses to the committee all day. You and your team are so evasive giving clear answers. It is very disappointing and all of your team should step down from your role.
What a mess. Surely, we as a society can do much better than this. I find it very concerning that the people in the panel seem to be content with their honesty-based system for free range foreign sex offenders in Australia.
Dutton label a 17 yr old boy a pedophiles the day he turn 18 because his gf was two yr younger. He label another refugee a pedophiles because gave a 10 yr some fruit.
Dodgy, devious and deceitful public servants. And what contempt they always display towards the public which pays them. Thanks for your efforts, senator Paterson.
The incompetence and obfuscation at these sessions is alarming. You’ve the patience of a saint. I hope LNP wins govt at the next election and makes a clean sweep of the Cth bureaucracy.
tax table low income tax payer require discount card to compete with gst cgt international student austudy pension discount card and backpacker hostel cheap rent Islanders build cabins to use discount card
"um l think we've provided this previously" who cares, just answer the question you are being asked if you have provided it previously you know how to answer the question instead of stonewalling
IOW - they don’t know if these people are breaching their visa conditions, until they know, which could be too late for potential victims. 🤔 …. this panel spends a long time not saying it as it is.
I think 48 assessments of prioritised caaes in 10 days is adequate. Sure, the department might be able to unlock infinite/unlimited resources..... but 5 completed, risk-assessed assessments a day is very good. Sure not perfect, but rectively very good. Assessments, in theory, might accelerate with learnings and lower priority. Zero political capital taking dept to task over this output.
Senator Paterson it was Coalition legislation that was declared illegal by the High Court that required these people to be released. So these sex offenders have to be legally restrained either behind bars or with tags otherwise millions of dollars of taxpayer dollars will be wasted again by court challenges. Each sex offender had differing circumstances which must be considered before the appropriate action can be taken which takes time and money. The Coalition should have taken the appropriate time to draft legislation that prevented this from happening in the first place but you enjoy grandstanding at Senate hearings. Statistically kids in Australia have far more to fear from family members, a relative or family friend regarding sex offending then these imported sex offenders who shouldn’t have arrived anyway.
With Tony Jerk in charge no wonder everything's a mess one of the most useless MP'S around should have been sacked years ago he's a moron Australian politics the more you stuff up the longer you retain your seat
There is 8 of them and Senator Paterson makes them all look absolutely incompetent! Truly what an absolute legend this man is!
A legend he sure is! Thank goodness we have Senator Paterson!
Thank you Senator James Paterson.
I thought that the law was for the protection of the people, not the law breakers.
Not on 2024.
Look at Ireland, Scotland & the UK.
Same is happening here.
Prepare your finances & invest in some lead.
That's all I'm saying. 😊
The law protects those it protects. Law breakers still have protections under law.
You clearly have no idea of how the separation of powers works. Do you?
The way these Officials answer questions. The awkward pauses, hurried ‘off-mic’ whispers, endless paper shuffling, inter-departmental buck passing and the infuriatingly lawyered answers to deflect responsibility are contemptible. Not one of these people seem engaged on actually addressing this issue.
Has it occurred to you that maybe they are there as smoke and mirrors and in reality they are not invovled in running this country in any way shape or form. Wouldnt that explain why they have no clue even regarding the most basic procedures.
So often the bureaucrats seem to squirm and struggle to give answers. It's like they are determined to give out as little information as possible so as not to expose their ineptitude.
They’re vague. They go close to giving an answer and hint at answers but zero promises or concrete answers. No absolutes.
Yes, they are totally incompetent. A total disaster by this inept government.
What a unholy mess. This is normal for Labor.
THIS is what should be on our national news broadcasts!! Just imagine if the people knew of such incompetence, especially in the protection of children from known predators.
What a joke! Unbelievable.
I don't like to think what would happen without James Paterson to hold this hopeless government and its lackeys to account.
I stopped watching mainstream media 4-5 years ago, interested to see how much coverage they've given this so that the public in general would have any knowledge of these people that are in positions of power and just how incompetent these bureaucrats are..
Frankly it's embarrassing that they represent you and me and all of them are as dumb as 'phucking' dog shit! Just saying...,...
Senator Paterson….you’re best! Without a shadow of a doubt!
Senator James Paterson, you have the patience of a saint 🙏❤ Seriously.... how can these beaurecrats be in their jobs ???? I thought the protection of our Australian families was their 'duty of care'.... 😮 this is absolutely deplorable, imho...
Sick of all these incompetent people
its the women. the reason things are so f'd atm is because of women being in positions like this.
I’m not incompetence it’s by design
What a bunch of incompetent fools. The harsh earned taxes are paying for these clowns. God help us.
James Patterson doing Tony Burke’s job for him!
Exactly!
Burkes a moron.
What is wrong with albo, sex offenders do not stop being offenders, albo is allowing sex offenders to be allowed to offending other children, this is as sick as it gets with albo. These are all adults, allowing children to be harmed, what is wrong with them , what they dont have children or what.
in the too hard basket for this weak willed prime minister ,, these peodaphiles are mainly men who beleive there's nothing wrong with taking children,, God help our little ones because these people should be charged with pre consent because they know 98 percent reoffend !
But in the meantime, Albo telling the public that banning social media for under16 is keeping our kids safe.... yet they got Child sex offenders living next to schools.
What the hell are we doing in the Country; protect the immigrants and criminals and not worry about the hard working 'financially struggling' Aussies that pay for this shit! It's disgusting.
Ireland sound familiar? Scotland? The UK?
Its because they want to genocide us mate.
Oh my, our hard-earned tax money pays for these morons.
Wouldn't it be different if it was their kids at a school near these predators 🤔
@@paulmartin3962exactly! 💯
@@paulmartin3962 Depends how woke they are.
They are CRIMINALS that cannot get arrested...
And round and round we go🙉🙉
Senator Paterson for PM❤😊
Thank god for Senator Paterson asking the logical questions !
This shows that the value of the work of this department or agency in supervising criminal migrants is the equivalent of going to a fair and having fairy floss or not.
In short, the cost of running this organisation is nothing more than money down the drain.
Criminal migrants who are a risk to the community should be either deported or imprisoned until they are no longer a risk.
Why should the Australian public be put at risk at the behest of politics or courts?
Australian Government is just a joke, as this type of responsibility is the best we can ever expect from it.
Sack the Australian Government Corporation which in law is not our government at all, but is a Coup D eTat after Queen Victoria died, and that has not had a lawfully installed and recognized Monarch since.
This government is a FARCE, AN ABORTION, DISGRACE, A SHAME TO OUR NATION.
Great job, Senator Patterson, in exposing the lack of common sense in these highly paid positions!
Dear Senator James Paterson, we the Australians would really love you to be our Prime Minister, NOT ALBANESE I NEVER VOTED FOR HIM. Cant we the Australians Fire Albanese? He is a repulsive little man.
YES!
Leprechaun more like it.
Real men have balls. Albo does not.
@@agirlfrommars3441he cant he is a SENATOR!!! Learn how the Australian parliament works and pass it on to others who constantly ask for Patterson and Senator Hanson, who can not be PMs. Only Lower house politicians can become PM!s and most of the time they are selected from. NSW.
@@whatever9770 I actually know thanks but I can still agree 👍
I feel an uprising of the Australian Citizens heating up
The Law is an ass, prove me wrong.
The man the myth the future prime minister hopefully!
Appalling, letting pedes out of prison with out supervision.God help the kids that live close to them.
OMG. They are colluding in an inquiry !
Why are people not being sent back to where they came from if they are breaching our laws on this level ? And dam the government is dropping the ball massively. Great Work Senator Paterson
Thousands came in under peter duttons watch. The LNP hurried thru laws that weren't tested before locking people up.
Or up dating the legislation when in government.
Dutton had criminal gangs bring in girls for prostitution.
Convicted s*x offender Dr Peter Macarthur, ENT surgeon of Armidale and Taree in Australia, held positions on the International Grammar Schools Board and another school board for decades. He applied for the positions a year after a six month only conviction of s*x assault on girls and women as they were being transferred onto the operating table. He did this to my young daughter, too but I didnt know as his surgery to remove her tonsils was so brutal she could not speak for weeks. I should sue him now, but dont have the energy as my daughter now has cancer. This man is just one of the monsters still working in our communities. We have to protect our children from them at all costs. Parents, never allow this man near your girls ever. Paedophiles and s*x offenders hide in plain sight at all levels of our society, but particularly in medicine, education, politics, the judiciary and police forces. It is worldwide, just look at trump and his administration full of perverts.
😢❤ that's f......
Any idiot can lie over the phone. How stupid are these people not todo face to face or go to their place of residence
One very astute person vs a handful of very blunt tools.
NSW just passed a ‘self I’d ‘ law. Labor has literally held open the change room door for sex offenders. They are truly sick
A prudent question might be how many of these offenders live in Canberra. I suspect it's none which could help explain the level of apathy these bureaucrats are showing,
What are these ignorant people being paid for again?
More than the politicians.plus Albanese has increased their number exponentially. Your taxes.
those pathetic public servants must tremble in their seats when James comes to question them! They cringe and shuffle and prevaricate and lie to escape answering his questions. What a joke they are!!! Hope when the LNP take over the government these people are fired!
we are stuffed
What in the world is she doing there then. ??????
Collecting very good pay!
All I can do is shake my head. Thank you Senator, for your intelligent and articulate investigation. You’re all over it. Impressive.
These public servants (remember they are servants of the people who are the tax payers) need to be reminded that their sole purpose is to serve Australian public and uphold Australian law. This is just another example of public servants failing in their duties and by virtue being paid for doing nothing. Time has well passed that we remove these filibustering bludgers from the public service. Well done Senator Patterson showing up these people.
All this money and time wasted on these lowest common denominator criminals, thank God for Senator Paterson in motivating the Government and it's lackluster Public Servants to earn their bread while we all suffer ontological insecurity at their inaction.
Some of them are still in office.
Wtf .who are these Dei incompetent clowns? Omg.These clowns are a total embarrassment .This lot are putrid.
Why should they get housing catered to them but law abiding citizens don’t ? Why should they be given handouts and preferential treatment ? Ridiculous! Have them work in correction facilities. 😒
These people are totally unprepared!
Criminals Self-reporting. Clown show.
Absolutely!
Not just criminals, they're illegal immigrants.
Senator James Paterson has so much patience. This looks bad. Is this a normal practice? Why does it seem they have no idea what they're doing? Are people in charge of Australia usually this awkward to answer and incompetent? Or is it just this years troupe? Paterson for prime minister I say.
How long is this going to go on?
And what happens when they breach do they get deported?
the whole situation is due to inability to deport, hence why this relates to detainees
WTF......
Omg this is crazy!!!!!!!
So. , my understanding is “The Law “ is to protect the offenders , not the public! 😳
And these dumbos are all costing us taxpayers a fortune for nothing….zero….nada…..rien!
What I heard from that female is she cannot protect the kids
Oh good God, what next.
What an incompetent government,
Yea your right the LNP didn't change legislation when they lock up these refugees.
And the high court found it was illegal to lock people up indefinitely.
Clare Sharpe you are so incompetent in your role. You are not able to give clear and precise answers to the committee, so is the whole team in your department. A waste of taxpayers money paying your salaries.
I’m so glad these interactions are recorded. What a joke these people are.
What a joke. So who takes responsibility of a serious crime when they breach their visa conditions particularly if a child is involved.
all talk about convictions and suspended sentances and visas and monitoring but not a single word about deportation
Should be mandatory forever senator.
Keep up your brilliant work Senator. You are making the Majority of the ALP stumble and fumble on a daily basis.
Your making ALP members look absolutely incapable and uneducated.
Have there been any unmonitored sex offenders in Parliament house. I can think of one straight off the bat , also a former attorney General and a state Labor party member in South Australia.
Keep up the good work James . Im sure these bureaucrats dont really believe this diatribe either but are doing their job. Australia should not be keeping sex offenders or violent criminals without close monitoring and support.
Why don’t these people know anything about the situation of these matters ? And they are being paid for knowing nothing.
these DEI hires are beyond a joke. NFI
Boss if Labor are releasing child abusers near schools why dont you contact the Police
Ms Foster, how do you justify your position in the department. We have heard you and team waffling on with your responses to the committee all day. You and your team are so evasive giving clear answers. It is very disappointing and all of your team should step down from your role.
@5:48, quite a big if.
If they, are not being monitored, how in f.s. could it be proven a pdf is near, stalking etc, a Child ?
FFS...
# woodchipper
They are morons
SEN. J PATERSON...SPOT ON, LET THE PEOPLE LEARN THE TRUTH.....
What a mess. Surely, we as a society can do much better than this. I find it very concerning that the people in the panel seem to be content with their honesty-based system for free range foreign sex offenders in Australia.
Not good enough bureaucrats!
Time to go Labor! Bye bye to the useless socialists.
That day can't come soon enough.
They can call from anywhere and say, “I’m not near a school” 😮
More care for prohibited person's welfare than welfare of children they are preying on, but isn't that always the way with the "compassionate woke".
Dutton label a 17 yr old boy a pedophiles the day he turn 18 because his gf was two yr younger.
He label another refugee a pedophiles because gave a 10 yr some fruit.
Why are we paying taxes towards this absolute horror. I jave lost faith in the system. Thank you Senator for fighting for our communities.
Thank you Senator Paterson, this is a disgusting failure by the government for Australians safety
Dodgy, devious and deceitful public servants.
And what contempt they always display towards the public which pays them.
Thanks for your efforts, senator Paterson.
DEIs should not be in these positions-that is why Australia is doomed.
I know nothing.
The incompetence and obfuscation at these sessions is alarming. You’ve the patience of a saint. I hope LNP wins govt at the next election and makes a clean sweep of the Cth bureaucracy.
So they have no actions in place to prevent these criminals being near kids, they can only be discovered AFTER they have breached.
tax table low income tax payer require discount card to compete with gst cgt international student austudy pension discount card and backpacker hostel cheap rent Islanders build cabins to use discount card
James Patterson is excellent and has good instincts and integrity and intent
"um l think we've provided this previously"
who cares, just answer the question you are being asked
if you have provided it previously you know how to answer the question instead of stonewalling
So inclusive, I love it! 🙄
Incompetence at it's best, the exact reason why Parents take actions themselves
Comedy capers
IOW - they don’t know if these people are breaching their visa conditions, until they know, which could be too late for potential victims. 🤔 …. this panel spends a long time not saying it as it is.
When did this enquiry occur?
Senator Paterson is amazing, makes these tools look so stupid. James Paterson for PM next year.
Protection for crims and terrorists is this current status of Australian law ?
I think 48 assessments of prioritised caaes in 10 days is adequate. Sure, the department might be able to unlock infinite/unlimited resources..... but 5 completed, risk-assessed assessments a day is very good. Sure not perfect, but rectively very good.
Assessments, in theory, might accelerate with learnings and lower priority.
Zero political capital taking dept to task over this output.
What qualifations do these need apart from mumbling & wafflling, I feel embarasse for them
Senator Paterson it was Coalition legislation that was declared illegal by the High Court that required these people to be released. So these sex offenders have to be legally restrained either behind bars or with tags otherwise millions of dollars of taxpayer dollars will be wasted again by court challenges. Each sex offender had differing circumstances which must be considered before the appropriate action can be taken which takes time and money. The Coalition should have taken the appropriate time to draft legislation that prevented this from happening in the first place but you enjoy grandstanding at Senate hearings. Statistically kids in Australia have far more to fear from family members, a relative or family friend regarding sex offending then these imported sex offenders who shouldn’t have arrived anyway.
When a child is abused, thats how they will know.
This mob are a disgrace, not their child, seems to be the motto
The lady in red(Ms Foster) holds a high position with a big fat wage. Yet she comes across as someone who is totally ignorant of everything.
With Tony Jerk in charge no wonder everything's a mess one of the most useless MP'S around should have been sacked years ago he's a moron Australian politics the more you stuff up the longer you retain your seat
this is disgraceful. wtf is going on. how do these people sleep at night.
Border force doesn’t seem to know anything and sharp has to help out…with zero
Labour don't register em
Want their vote !!
🙇♂️