actually you can evaluate that a person is expert to a certain song if he/she can play it fast, emotion does not help you become great practice does, you can not run if you can not walk
@@stein5927 she really sounds like a midi file... And before you say if i can play it better I already can. Everybody can. she has no emotion and she can't show me or anyone else
I think people forget... for a 12yr old to replicate this piece of music with little to no technical flaws and with some musicality is ALREADY a HUGE achievement that 99.99% of the world cannot even hope to attain with 40hrs of daily practice for YEARS.
yeah man, for a CHILD to play like that is remarkable and shows enormous potential. Cant expect them to have adult nuance and expression as well, through lived life experience. But god damn they are advanced haha
Eh not really true. Like lang lang said, anybody can play the piano. I really believe that if you have the right will and you practice enough you can play a piece that you want, at any age over 3. Playing with passion is different though, and personally I don’t know if one can develop it through practice, it’ll probably just come to them.
Lang Lang is correct. When you play music, you must not lock yourself in a dark room. Open up. Your main focus should be the song, not the keyboard. Improvise the melody to resemble various events in life; like breathing, getting angry, and etc. Also, when playing masterclass, slow down dammit.
You can say what you want about Lang Lang. You might not like his interpretations sometimes, maybe find him exaggerating too much. But he is so full of musical expression. My piano teacher always used to say play the music and the notes will come by itself
@@lefudj4236 how is this "showing off"? The kid obviously has enough skill to play the song. What it lacks is emotion. Emotion and feelings is what makes music great. Otherwise you can just listen to ringtones.
The way he explains the importance of a non-metronomic music experience is absolutely killer. Not a convoluted and empty description to describe rythm and accents and feeling, just play the part in two different ways, with an example: if music could be thaught, explained and experienced in our native languages there wouldn't be a need for music. Great teacher, I wish I had this kind of explanations in my musical education
Respect for the Kid, Double nervous playing for so many people and Lang Lang criticizing the playing style. To be focussed in making no mistake and playing the right notes makes the pianist seem to be emotionless, but the training showed to be a good deal for the kid. Maybe the first time for the kid to show some emotions while playing on a stage.
So much pressure for a 12 year old to change his whole playing style in front of one of the top players in the world with a whole audience, cameras etc. Or is it just me?
It may affect her piano career, if that kid wad taking the advice emotionally. But if he/she find that it's constructive one then, she/he may just take that advice to improve their playing better
I think it is for the better as I am a very basic piano player but I listen to piano music all most through out the day and when this kid was playing fast, it didn't sound nice after the first 8 seconds, it just sounded off beat
don't you find the kid plays mechanical? Fantasie Impromptu has lot of scales, so does many piano music, it does not mean the scale has no feel, just like a ringtone. Even the beginner etude and exercises has musical expression
I don’t know how I would have played it in her age so no offense...but this girl just needs to work on the passion a lot. Playing it faster than average will not make up for the lack of emotion. Especially not while playing a piece written by Chopin.
Fr like I practice and get a piece perfectly but when I start playing in front of judges and/or teachers who aren’t mine AND everyone else it’s like I’ve never even played before so I don’t wanna imagine what I’d be like in front of him 😂
i feel sorry for the kid on one side his parents or teacher is like "You play the score how it was written" and lang lang is like "Let the music take you in" He must be so confused.
well, playing exactly the way it is written is the way to go because the way it is written with the original nuances makes it full of emotion. but this is what is hard to achieve
music has dynamics written into , the issue here is that the piece is so difficult all the focus is going towards accuracy and tempo. this person likely learned this piece without focusing on the dynamics at all which is a very common thing.
@@jesusros5047 True. I find with a new piece once i memorise it i will just mess around with the tempo and dynamics and try to make it sound unique and that will be my own way to play it. its not conventional but i don't perform anymore so i will do what i want too xD
George Missailidis he’s probably trying to cool himself down. I can imagine that it has to be quite warm in there with a all of those people sucking up all the oxygen.
@@HoHoMoMoo I don’t have to be able to write a Harry Potter book to be able to criticize it. So why should I have to be a professional pianist to point out the obvious. (People are going to far in these comments like saying “midi does it better” but she does need more emotion.
@Rithvik Gollapalli but I have played the piano for only 1 year yet and instantly I could tell that most of the other performances sounded much more appealing than the kids, so what is wrong in that?
People criticising the kid for 'playing without emotion' or 'playing too quickly' need to shut up and grow a pair of ears. Do you even know what tempo the Fantaisie-Impromptu is supposed to be played at? The playing in the middle section is expressive and the rubato employed is tasteful, not to mention the good voicing of the melody. It's not a perfect interpretation by any means but if it were an adult playing, you lot wouldn't be making these kind of uninformed comments, they just make you (the commenter!) look stupid.
I think you're a bit misinformed and were trying to vent your anger at the time. The Fantasie Impromptu itself is not supposed to be played at such a fast speed, in fact when chopin composed it, he intended for the focus to be placed on the emotion, not the speed. While I acknowledge that the child is very good for her age, there is no denying the lack of emotion in her playing and failure to express her feelings sufficiently, so perhaps you should be the one doing some self reflection here on your true knowledge on this piece, which must be close to 0 in order to make such an insanely stupid, idiotic and misinformed comment.
@@ggwhynot452 Hilarious you say that; I've played the piece myself. I have a recording up on my channel, if you'd like to listen. It's not perfect by any means, and I wouldn't say I've played it much better than the kid has here. Have you listened to the tempo of, say, Rubinstein's or Yundi Li's recording of it? The kid isn't perfect of course. He's a developing musician, and the dynamic shaping could be improved. But there is clearly evidence of attention to musical detail - you can hear the accents shifting from the thumb to the pinky in the B section of the fast part, for example.
@@jessewang_xj I have also played the piece myself; the point that I am trying to make is that the kid should not be so sacrilegious, as quoted from TwoSetViolin. Sorry as I came across as offensive. P.S. I performed it in 2016.
@@jessewang_xj To be very honest with you, I watched your rendition of the piece and it was absolutely terrible. No emotion at all. You have zero understanding of the piece mr. Grow a pair.
Everyone needs to relax here.The child's playing in all honesty however it lacked emotional interpretation and complete articulation,the tempo was too fast .However,for a child she did an excellent job and as she gets older sooner enough she'll be able to balance both aspects of the piece
Between a phrase and even every bar, there must be obvious strength changes to express emotions, but it should not be too fragmented, to ensure the overall fluency of the music. This is indeed what the master can do.
He's 12, once he's gone through life and experienced all the pain and happiness I'm sure he'll be much better. I played piano without emotion when I was 12-15, now at 20 I play with all my soul after going through my first break up and college rejection that I had my eyes set on...
Mec174 Z you want soul? Play some ludovico einaudi. I’m 26 and hat piano music is like therapy to me. Igiorni and nuvole bianche I think they are called:)
When I first heard her play, I was shocked at how well, how perfectly a little kid could play. At the end of the lesson I was shocked at the massive difference in the performance... Lang Lang is truly something else...
I watch some of Lang Lang Master Class on RUclips. This is the first time Lang lang criticise the Pianist very hars. There's one video when Lang lang just give a little critic and more at saying how good the Pianist playing. It showed how Lang lang very transparent in how he share his knowledge. He realy Honest person. Love this Video.
Lang's criticism was in the right place. These kids are prodigies all over the country. Every teacher probably says you play nice, but not Lang in masterclass
at 16:20 Lang Lang makes a great point... we are singing with the instrument, it's not just pluck that string or press that key, we need to sing with the piano, not play the piano...
I understand that most young players strive first for technical perfection, the expression will hopefully follow after that. I kind of like the way Lang Lang approach the piece. Also I heard a few play (not here) the soft part just a fraction slower to coax a few more tear drops from audience 😊
everyone should play the way they personally think is right. playing the piano should be fun. Criticism is important, but you should note that perception is in the eye of the beholder no matter whether a famous pianist thinks it should be played differently
The most amazing is that he shows how the kid was playing exactly in the same way and shows as well the way that should be, and is impressive the difference! 🎹 👌🏾
When I play the piano I usually play with a completely straight and barely move but I absolutely love playing the piano so just because the kid is playing with a straight face doesn’t mean they don’t love playing it just means they’re focused and moving bunch or smiling a lot might distract them
Skills u can learn, notes you can keep on practise. Dont just play piano. Go on watch a movie, go on listen to the wave, watch the tree leaves moving, flowers waving at you, feel yourself like water.
This was so interesting........and on several levels. My heart goes out both to Lang Lang and the young pianist......on almost equal measure, ........... but not quite!
Not trying to be a " smarty-pants", but Lang Lang said what I was thinking as the 1st youngster played. Invaluable advice , to make the music " sing" , with " light and shade". Fascinating. 😊💕🇬🇧⭐💕😊
I'm 13 and just started playing this piece. The fact that a 12 year old can reach this level is impressive! I could tell the kid was nervous at the beginning. I would be too.
when i was a kid in piano lessons, i had no clue what the teachers meant about the colour dynamic changes lang lang is stressing. even lang lang said that he was only taught techniques as a kid
That was fantastic. It is not easy to teach like this. I know. Because I teach in similar style. One needs to be grown up to understand this concept of feel and flow. I had master lessons in the past and I only understand this now.
A very amazing Lang Lang... 13:44, chopin didnt call it fantasie. Fontana did, for the marketing. However "where is the fantasie" is a spot on expression. BTW in the manuscript, 18:33 no forte. Chopin's MS is very interesting, E.g., 19:20 is the first "forte", holding all the way to bar 25, and BTW in bar 25 it says a tempo, but not piano, so you can wonder, did chopin intend the second time to be in forte? I dont think so, because of the very long poco a poco cresc in bars 19-33, to forte. For this you must begin in piano, or? Also in 19:20, 3 little diminuendos every half bar, as in 23, a sigh motive, in all respects. About left hand in section A (19:33) From bar 5, a prominent melody in the left hand thumb, suggesting that the right hand is in his part an ornamentation of this simple beautiful high tenor melody. Nice edition in IMSLP Josef Friedrich edition. Or if you find the Koenemann edition, preludes and impromptus, 1997, Koeln-Budapest, now out of print.
I am sure this kid got a real help from it ! Lang lang is often criticized and the kid may seem very nervous. But what he teached him was very interesting for a lot of ypung pianists. Look at the end ! "Good !" You don't recieve a master pianist's compliment everyday.. Maybe this one little lesson will give him the force to become a great pianist.
Its an impressive performance, but there was no emotion in there but playing at that speed, i think i can’t do it as a pianist. The only point i can think of with people who plays music without emotions is them only trying to show off/flex..
Another emotionless little kid who gets forced to practice 8 hours a day and is taught to play just the notes as if it were a robot playing. This honestly sounds like a midi file. It's really sad what parents will do to their kids in order to feel successful through them.
I feel bad for the kid.... A lesson in front of a thousand people only to be said that he/she plays without feeling from a man who has played for how long, 30 years, and is one of the best atm? In my experience that part develops after the puberty for most people
lo lind and its pretty ironic too. I love lang lang but it can be said that he likes to show off a little. Which defeats the point of putting emotions into a piece
This maybe a most important affect for the kid’s life .You are not serious enough to watch,Langland has also talked about the skills of playing piano. Pointing to your wrong things can benefit you.If the kid wants to be a professional pianist, he needs to know these things earlier. Maybe later when his skills are very fantastic, and no one point out the lack of emotion, then his piano way maybe not successful or more difficult.In addition,skills are linked by emotion.
I think if I had a masterclass with Lang Lang he would run out of patience and slap me because of my very limited playing skills xd :p However, I do play with emotion, at least that’s what I think I do
Reading comment gives the impression everyone is damn piano player. The girl is fantastic. She is only 12 and needs some fine tuning. I also love the way Lang Lang is passionate about what he wants to say. I think there is a little bit of language barrier here. Sometime he cannot find the best word to describe what he wants to say and uses body language to compensate. Those parts of his brain responsible for music works way faster than the parts controls his speaking.
Whats wrong with people in comments just because he doesnt fell the emotion in this piece doesn’t mean hes emotionless. Probably the piece isnt for him, but no body is emotionless we all feel something in the type of music we like
gugi 8 wrong, passion and emotion are different things You can learn to love the piano and you can learn to press the right keys at the right speed with the right force
See Lang Lang live, get your tickets on StubHub - fave.co/2WF4pgK
But coronavirus
Stop loving your own comment!!!
True,corona
@@urxel5273 1
.
N
N
Thank you for the upload.
Emotion is more important than speed...
actually you can evaluate that a person is expert to a certain song if he/she can play it fast, emotion does not help you become great practice does, you can not run if you can not walk
@@adviknigam if ur not good enough you will lol
Are you better at playing Fantasie Impromptu then?
@@stein5927 she really sounds like a midi file... And before you say if i can play it better I already can. Everybody can. she has no emotion and she can't show me or anyone else
Advik Nigam hitting the correct notes is not all that’s important
I think people forget... for a 12yr old to replicate this piece of music with little to no technical flaws and with some musicality is ALREADY a HUGE achievement that 99.99% of the world cannot even hope to attain with 40hrs of daily practice for YEARS.
yeah man, for a CHILD to play like that is remarkable and shows enormous potential. Cant expect them to have adult nuance and expression as well, through lived life experience. But god damn they are advanced haha
"I think people forget" no, no one forgot
ahahahah not for lang lang and prodigies of this world. a 5 year old can play this at a godly emotional level. its called master class for a reason
Eh not really true. Like lang lang said, anybody can play the piano. I really believe that if you have the right will and you practice enough you can play a piece that you want, at any age over 3. Playing with passion is different though, and personally I don’t know if one can develop it through practice, it’ll probably just come to them.
Johan jo
"Very nice is not good enough"
一 Lang Lang
Haha where??
@@Lnninpz 17:08
“Which is why I practice 40 hours a day”
- Ling Ling
most asian thing ever
Ah, brings me back to my childhood.
Lang Lang is correct. When you play music, you must not lock yourself in a dark room. Open up. Your main focus should be the song, not the keyboard. Improvise the melody to resemble various events in life; like breathing, getting angry, and etc.
Also, when playing masterclass, slow down dammit.
No.
No.
No.
Yes.
yes
You can say what you want about Lang Lang. You might not like his interpretations sometimes, maybe find him exaggerating too much. But he is so full of musical expression. My piano teacher always used to say play the music and the notes will come by itself
Yeah ppl say he boasts, and just shows off, i mean like he spent 15 minutes trying to explain the kid emotions have to have a role...
Music is entirely about exaggeration. that's not something you should criticize Lang Lang of
Don’t think... Feeel.
@@lefudj4236 how is this "showing off"? The kid obviously has enough skill to play the song. What it lacks is emotion. Emotion and feelings is what makes music great. Otherwise you can just listen to ringtones.
I. C. Wiener thats precisely what i said :0
“To play a wrong note is insignificant; to play without passion is inexcusable.” -Beethoven
yeah he never said that
@@eternallyv lol this is Chopin tho
To spell wrong is insignificant
To steal a comment is inexcusable-Mansa Agony
i play like a midi file, and my teacher is VERY pissed.
The way the kid played it in the end (21:20-ish) was so so so much better than 15 minutes ago. Impressive
Great, they've got the first 6 seconds down pat
Each part is important, lang lang is teaching how to feel and show emotion in the piece
6:38
21:31
He is also a great teacher !!!
I like how all the comments keep saying “that kid” because they don’t know his gender
or wait her gender
wait...
Stop complaining, even you don't know his gender... . Or her gender...?
He’s a she, get it right
Lol
Lujee- ... she’s a he, u on crack?
Roman Barnes best comm lol
Now I like lang lang more than ever before
Play with the heart
"yeak ok ok please stop"
Oliver Gao so funnnnnny omg 😂
Hahahahhahahahhaa
"nOnonoNononONONon0no, hold onhold on,,,' *kid continues playing* 'h0ld on"
"This is like a telephone ringtone. "
Savage, merciless.
It's at 13:34 if you're wondering.
17:55 *ATTACK DODGED*
its mortal kombat 12
omg LOL
Я долго так не смеялся
Hahahahaha lmao
The emotion in this particular piece cant be compromised by extreme speed. I think that is something a lot of pianists have to learn.
The way he explains the importance of a non-metronomic music experience is absolutely killer. Not a convoluted and empty description to describe rythm and accents and feeling, just play the part in two different ways, with an example: if music could be thaught, explained and experienced in our native languages there wouldn't be a need for music. Great teacher, I wish I had this kind of explanations in my musical education
i think this kid was more confused after the lesson.
Hii
WHERE'S THE FANTASY
Hahahahah Lang Lang was pretty haft on him
Confusion Is good
Yes
You can actually tell that the kid plays so much better, has better dynamics and emotion compared to the beginning
Respect for the Kid, Double nervous playing for so many people and Lang Lang criticizing the playing style.
To be focussed in making no mistake and playing the right notes makes the pianist seem to be emotionless, but the training showed to be a good deal for the kid. Maybe the first time for the kid to show some emotions while playing on a stage.
So much pressure for a 12 year old to change his whole playing style in front of one of the top players in the world with a whole audience, cameras etc. Or is it just me?
It may affect her piano career, if that kid wad taking the advice emotionally. But if he/she find that it's constructive one then, she/he may just take that advice to improve their playing better
i 100% agree. but its a moment with Lang Lang ...so its the the price one pays.
I think it is for the better as I am a very basic piano player but I listen to piano music all most through out the day and when this kid was playing fast, it didn't sound nice after the first 8 seconds, it just sounded off beat
don't you find the kid plays mechanical? Fantasie Impromptu has lot of scales, so does many piano music, it does not mean the scale has no feel, just like a ringtone. Even the beginner etude and exercises has musical expression
I think the criticism was good for long term but too hard to implement in just a few minutes
I don’t know how I would have played it in her age so no offense...but this girl just needs to work on the passion a lot. Playing it faster than average will not make up for the lack of emotion. Especially not while playing a piece written by Chopin.
-A its a he duh.
Schmendiey agreed
Dude looks like a lady
It is a 12 yo boy.
I mean they are wearing a tux-
Holy shit I would be scared to even claim I know how to hit a single note when he is nearby
The 24th Killer
“I know how to hit middle C”
Lang Lang - Exqqqquse mee?
“N-nothing”
Fr like I practice and get a piece perfectly but when I start playing in front of judges and/or teachers who aren’t mine AND everyone else it’s like I’ve never even played before so I don’t wanna imagine what I’d be like in front of him 😂
*Starts at **06:30** :)*
ΤHANK YOU SO MUCH
Ty
EHRE
Thanks m8
THANK YOU
20:40 I would've flinched like he was about to slap me
bitch, put some feeling into it!
LMAO
Lolllllllllll
William stfu
NOT MY FUCKING TEMPO !!!
17:57 I thought he was gonna punch him lol
Isnt that a she, lol?
lil slim Tedik him?
Her
it's him
@@nickpinkowski what crack are you on? are you bind or sum lmao.. that's clearly a female
13:34 is the funny part.
Why It?
Get it? Hehe
@@mr.clasher-clashofclansboo7286 LUL
@@ilovemilfs69420 I don’t get it :(
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dammit it’s so late in the night and this made me want to play the piano
you fucked up
I thought I was the only one lmao and it's happening really often 😂
DUDE SAME
Marcus Tornea Same Lmao
Same situation here hahaha
Every one of us can play the piano but not everybody will move our heart ~Lang lang
i feel sorry for the kid on one side his parents or teacher is like "You play the score how it was written" and lang lang is like "Let the music take you in" He must be so confused.
Oof more gender confusion feels bad man
well, playing exactly the way it is written is the way to go because the way it is written with the original nuances makes it full of emotion. but this is what is hard to achieve
music has dynamics written into , the issue here is that the piece is so difficult all the focus is going towards accuracy and tempo. this person likely learned this piece without focusing on the dynamics at all which is a very common thing.
@@jesusros5047 True. I find with a new piece once i memorise it i will just mess around with the tempo and dynamics and try to make it sound unique and that will be my own way to play it. its not conventional but i don't perform anymore so i will do what i want too xD
15:34 lmaooo 😂😂
Thank haha
You can see (or should I say hear) the student become better and better with his teaching, really cool
Right on DAve. Most here are not paying attention properly. This was a perfect master session of give and take...
14:05 what is the kid in the background doing?
Xindy Li trying to fly away from there before he says "you know" one more time
He’s probably bored
Being a chicken
George Missailidis he’s probably trying to cool himself down. I can imagine that it has to be quite warm in there with a all of those people sucking up all the oxygen.
Adjusting his jacket :)
Everyone suddenly is a professional pianist
It is possible to criticize someone without being able to do better than them. As long as it isn't shameful, I think it's totally ok.
@@Chisito23 I certainly don't agree with your statement. Can you explain why do you believe that ?
@@HoHoMoMoo I don’t have to be able to write a Harry Potter book to be able to criticize it. So why should I have to be a professional pianist to point out the obvious. (People are going to far in these comments like saying “midi does it better” but she does need more emotion.
@Rithvik Gollapalli but I have played the piano for only 1 year yet and instantly I could tell that most of the other performances sounded much more appealing than the kids, so what is wrong in that?
@@HoHoMoMoo you don’t have to be a world class chef to know if food is good or bad
People criticising the kid for 'playing without emotion' or 'playing too quickly' need to shut up and grow a pair of ears. Do you even know what tempo the Fantaisie-Impromptu is supposed to be played at? The playing in the middle section is expressive and the rubato employed is tasteful, not to mention the good voicing of the melody. It's not a perfect interpretation by any means but if it were an adult playing, you lot wouldn't be making these kind of uninformed comments, they just make you (the commenter!) look stupid.
I think you're a bit misinformed and were trying to vent your anger at the time. The Fantasie Impromptu itself is not supposed to be played at such a fast speed, in fact when chopin composed it, he intended for the focus to be placed on the emotion, not the speed. While I acknowledge that the child is very good for her age, there is no denying the lack of emotion in her playing and failure to express her feelings sufficiently, so perhaps you should be the one doing some self reflection here on your true knowledge on this piece, which must be close to 0 in order to make such an insanely stupid, idiotic and misinformed comment.
@@ggwhynot452 Hilarious you say that; I've played the piece myself. I have a recording up on my channel, if you'd like to listen. It's not perfect by any means, and I wouldn't say I've played it much better than the kid has here.
Have you listened to the tempo of, say, Rubinstein's or Yundi Li's recording of it?
The kid isn't perfect of course. He's a developing musician, and the dynamic shaping could be improved. But there is clearly evidence of attention to musical detail - you can hear the accents shifting from the thumb to the pinky in the B section of the fast part, for example.
@@jessewang_xj I have also played the piece myself; the point that I am trying to make is that the kid should not be so sacrilegious, as quoted from TwoSetViolin. Sorry as I came across as offensive.
P.S. I performed it in 2016.
@@jessewang_xj To be very honest with you, I watched your rendition of the piece and it was absolutely terrible. No emotion at all. You have zero understanding of the piece mr. Grow a pair.
Everyone needs to relax here.The child's playing in all honesty however it lacked emotional interpretation and complete articulation,the tempo was too fast .However,for a child she did an excellent job and as she gets older sooner enough she'll be able to balance both aspects of the piece
21:36 ouchhhhh you could tell he’s fed up with this kid
Zomb
Wow, that was such an asshole move. Didn’t expect that from him.
@@zain4019 you guys are so stupid :DD he was nice.
How so
@@zain4019 How is that an asshole move lmao explain pls?
Hello hello hes a pussy he himself knows that he's a hater he won't come online anymore
What a great sense of space, theater, and poetry this man has.
Summary of what he was saying that whole time: its not just the notes you play, it’s the way you play them
„ don’t lock yourself into a dark room „
„ Where’s the fantasy „ 😍😍😍😍
15:10 Lang Lang is a genius
Bruno Santos Don’t do drugs kids
Between a phrase and even every bar, there must be obvious strength changes to express emotions, but it should not be too fragmented, to ensure the overall fluency of the music. This is indeed what the master can do.
I really like Lăng Lăng and I’m not sure why people are the Internet are always so mean towards him.
Because ppl are stupid
Lang lang is just be himself, and that what makes him unique in his playing styles
Emotion / Feelings is important.. you must know where to put the loud and soft tones.. Thats what Lang Lang is trying to explain.. ♥️
He's 12, once he's gone through life and experienced all the pain and happiness I'm sure he'll be much better. I played piano without emotion when I was 12-15, now at 20 I play with all my soul after going through my first break up and college rejection that I had my eyes set on...
Manuel C its a she
Emma Crowe lmao my bad
C7 Z new account?
Emma Crowe No, it's a actually a he. It was surprising to me too when I found out.
Mec174 Z you want soul? Play some ludovico einaudi. I’m 26 and hat piano music is like therapy to me. Igiorni and nuvole bianche I think they are called:)
Stuck at home and watching these video. . . Love learning from Lang Lang though!
When I first heard her play, I was shocked at how well, how perfectly a little kid could play. At the end of the lesson I was shocked at the massive difference in the performance... Lang Lang is truly something else...
she doesn't play that well lol
I once made a grown man cry because i played turkish march, i really moved him
same, but I can't play Turkish march
Dnc
Omg it’s so much fun to watch langlang’s piano lesson lmao
Aaahh emotion such a hard thing to express even more so to explain and teach
Perhaps a poem reading or event description would help with the wanted/needed emotion
Lang Lang opened his heart.
Didn't hide the game.
Bravo Lang.
Im learning this piece and i finished it and he gives such good tips!
I watch some of Lang Lang Master Class on RUclips. This is the first time Lang lang criticise the Pianist very hars. There's one video when Lang lang just give a little critic and more at saying how good the Pianist playing.
It showed how Lang lang very transparent in how he share his knowledge. He realy Honest person.
Love this Video.
Dulistan Tarigan you know why? Go watch liyudi which Lang Lang hates most play this you will know why. Kid almost got yundis feeling
Lang Lang: You need to breath... You need to open your heart
kid: Are we still talking about playing the piano ?
Lang Lang is a great teacher.
Wtf, completely rushes the start and is trying to play fast rather than actually doing articulation.
He s a kid, chill
"Is not tararararararararararrara is more like breathing you know like: daradaradaradaradaadadadararaaaa"
-Lang Lang
The kid was too nervous, I thought the kid can do better under the stage
aries leung to rushed
Lang's criticism was in the right place. These kids are prodigies all over the country. Every teacher probably says you play nice, but not Lang in masterclass
at 16:20 Lang Lang makes a great point... we are singing with the instrument, it's not just pluck that string or press that key, we need to sing with the piano, not play the piano...
breeeeeeathhhha........
The kid's skill get improved after Lang Lang's instructions, I can tell that.
ABSOLUTELY! You can see, She will carry this day with her forever!
I have learned a lot from Excellent Lang Lang!
I understand that most young players strive first for technical perfection, the expression will hopefully follow after that. I kind of like the way Lang Lang approach the piece. Also I heard a few play (not here) the soft part just a fraction slower to coax a few more tear drops from audience 😊
Lang Lang's teaching is of top class
Master class 2016 with the Cub🧸For 12 years old technically the Cub is doing very well. Lang Lang doing great is helping the Cub to the next level.
Thanks for posting this master class. It is very revealing. I personally feel Lang Lang delivered his message very clearly and helpful.
everyone should play the way they personally think is right. playing the piano should be fun. Criticism is important, but you should note that perception is in the eye of the beholder no matter whether a famous pianist thinks it should be played differently
21:27 I was waiting for that correction the whole video lol
The most amazing is that he shows how the kid was playing exactly in the same way and shows as well the way that should be, and is impressive the difference! 🎹 👌🏾
One y'know = 1 like
Mark Do about 50!
Mark D y’know
I've never seen Lang Lang playing Chopin Fantasias Impromptu in C sharp minor,
fully presented.
When I play the piano I usually play with a completely straight and barely move but I absolutely love playing the piano so just because the kid is playing with a straight face doesn’t mean they don’t love playing it just means they’re focused and moving bunch or smiling a lot might distract them
When he said "It's not dara daradaradaradara" I felt that.
If you want to hear the most perfect fantasie impromptu,
You must watched fantasie impromptu played by Valentina Igoshina!
She played so perfectly
shishkin dmitry's one is better
@@H74-M4facts
that kid was so confused lol
More like she doesn't care or is completely closed-minded like she likes to do it only her way... she definitely won't become professional
do you know the name of the intro music? at 0:01
The smuggler
I think she was playing it too quickly in order to add expression.
It's not as easy as it seems you know to immediately play it as he says to
Skills u can learn, notes you can keep on practise. Dont just play piano. Go on watch a movie, go on listen to the wave, watch the tree leaves moving, flowers waving at you, feel yourself like water.
Be water -- Bruce Lee :)
This was so interesting........and on several levels. My heart goes out both to Lang Lang and the young pianist......on almost equal measure, ........... but not quite!
Remember if you can play it fast, you can play it slow
Oh my god that's golden advice...
Not trying to be a " smarty-pants",
but Lang Lang said what I was
thinking as the 1st youngster played.
Invaluable advice , to make the music " sing" ,
with " light and shade".
Fascinating.
😊💕🇬🇧⭐💕😊
Technically he plays really really well, but you can only go so far technically, the rest is emotion and interpretation
Technically, she is still lacking a bit as well.
Technically, it might be a he
shawn sun technically its a he
Well technically i think that with the piece she has exagerated the pianissimo
No? She doesnt even play technically well what are you saying
I'm 13 and just started playing this piece. The fact that a 12 year old can reach this level is impressive! I could tell the kid was nervous at the beginning. I would be too.
when i was a kid in piano lessons, i had no clue what the teachers meant about the colour dynamic changes lang lang is stressing. even lang lang said that he was only taught techniques as a kid
This kid played for speed. There’s no emotion
That was fantastic.
It is not easy to teach like this.
I know. Because I teach in similar style.
One needs to be grown up to understand this concept of feel and flow.
I had master lessons in the past and I only understand this now.
It's like cooking. It's up to you to make it more flavorful and tasty.
Well said, Lang Lang❤
Qualquer um pode tocar piano, mas nem todos conseguem atingir o coração. "Lang Lang "
When the girl played I felt no emotion.
When Lang Lang played I got goosebumps.
Boy* -_-
@@hisky. Oh LMFAOO
@@hisky. ITS A BOY?
@@srikarrishikesanXF yes lol how can you not tell
@@hisky. how where did you get that information.
A very amazing Lang Lang...
13:44, chopin didnt call it fantasie. Fontana did, for the marketing. However "where is the fantasie" is a spot on expression.
BTW in the manuscript, 18:33 no forte. Chopin's MS is very interesting,
E.g., 19:20 is the first "forte", holding all the way to bar 25, and BTW in bar 25 it says a tempo, but not piano, so you can wonder, did chopin intend the second time to be in forte? I dont think so, because of the very long poco a poco cresc in bars 19-33, to forte. For this you must begin in piano, or?
Also in 19:20, 3 little diminuendos every half bar, as in 23, a sigh motive, in all respects.
About left hand in section A (19:33) From bar 5, a prominent melody in the left hand thumb, suggesting that the right hand is in his part an ornamentation of this simple beautiful high tenor melody.
Nice edition in IMSLP Josef Friedrich edition. Or if you find the Koenemann edition, preludes and impromptus, 1997, Koeln-Budapest, now out of print.
I am sure this kid got a real help from it !
Lang lang is often criticized and the kid may seem very nervous.
But what he teached him was very interesting for a lot of ypung pianists. Look at the end ! "Good !"
You don't recieve a master pianist's compliment everyday..
Maybe this one little lesson will give him the force to become a great pianist.
Way too fast imo. Saps the emotion right out of the piece.
Sam Pinsky what if you feel no emotion?
Lil Piccolo
Then what is the point of playing music?
Its an impressive performance, but there was no emotion in there but playing at that speed, i think i can’t do it as a pianist. The only point i can think of with people who plays music without emotions is them only trying to show off/flex..
@@lilpiccolo6519 yo are you okay bro?
@@samcrackers i was one edgy mofo a year ago damn lmao
Love it. Thanks lang lang. We are emotional being..totally agreed your pedagogy and performance guidance..
Another emotionless little kid who gets forced to practice 8 hours a day and is taught to play just the notes as if it were a robot playing. This honestly sounds like a midi file. It's really sad what parents will do to their kids in order to feel successful through them.
George Pantzikis I don’t think that’s quite true, I think the students are very happy to play!
So true agreed
watching too much shigatsu wa kimo no uso is not a good thing.
Crei D i don’t know about that tho
shes still a kid, playing with a lot of emotion comes over time..
When a piece evokes emotion we all win.
I play violin but this video got me hooked
I feel bad for the kid.... A lesson in front of a thousand people only to be said that he/she plays without feeling from a man who has played for how long, 30 years, and is one of the best atm? In my experience that part develops after the puberty for most people
The child looked scared..
Anyone would be lucky to have a Master class with Lang Lang
Not now for her, but this tube will serve her the best knowledge in years to come:)
lo lind and its pretty ironic too. I love lang lang but it can be said that he likes to show off a little. Which defeats the point of putting emotions into a piece
This maybe a most important affect for the kid’s life .You are not serious enough to watch,Langland has also talked about the skills of playing piano. Pointing to your wrong things can benefit you.If the kid wants to be a professional pianist, he needs to know these things earlier. Maybe later when his skills are very fantastic, and no one point out the lack of emotion, then his piano way maybe not successful or more difficult.In addition,skills are linked by emotion.
I think if I had a masterclass with Lang Lang he would run out of patience and slap me because of my very limited playing skills xd :p
However, I do play with emotion, at least that’s what I think I do
Reading comment gives the impression everyone is damn piano player. The girl is fantastic. She is only 12 and needs some fine tuning. I also love the way Lang Lang is passionate about what he wants to say. I think there is a little bit of language barrier here. Sometime he cannot find the best word to describe what he wants to say and uses body language to compensate. Those parts of his brain responsible for music works way faster than the parts controls his speaking.
He's so right. The music has an ebb and flow and the pianist needs to create that feeling of the ebb and flow, not just play it technically perfectly.
Lang Lang is so fantastic
She started as a robot. But progressed quite well with one lesson
Whats wrong with people in comments just because he doesnt fell the emotion in this piece doesn’t mean hes emotionless. Probably the piece isnt for him, but no body is emotionless we all feel something in the type of music we like
Passion and emotion can't be taught! It is a gift
gugi 8 wrong, passion and emotion are different things
You can learn to love the piano and you can learn to press the right keys at the right speed with the right force
Emotion is something every human(except extreme psychopaths) have.
"You really need to you know make those sound happening"
Deep.