Have served with Australian Army for one year..The Young officers of Combat Arms of Indian Army/Navy/ Airforce are far better than Australian officers..In so far as professionalism is concerned
@@natalkumar6132 dude excellence comes from skills and preparedness only. What even are u saying? Military is skilled, however the brains behind it, is the problem
India is making most of it's ships in house and latest diesel electric submarines are of French origin. Indian Navy is most indigenous Indian armed wing comapred to Airforce and Army. Tired of this India bashing in such a general manner.
@@sharthakghosh970 Not completely true .. yes there are Israeli products but most of them are made under India-Israel collaboration. The ships main computers, combat management system, sonars and most vital electronics are purely Indian.
the IAS training has to be changed , the corrupt have to be sacked and sent to 100 year jails terms , IFS needs to be also changed , professionals can be appointed as ambassadors .
very good discussion!!! in my View Trump is going to Win this election and this will be good for India, QUAD. Can you please organize a program to discuss taking back Gilgit, Baltistan, Mirpur, Muzzafarabad areas of J & K. Regards Kapil Bhardwaj
I've watched quite a lot of Mitra on various channels and mostly he makes sense. He's also mostly appreciative sometimes critical about Indian policy makers which is also good. My question is when you give certain data and intelligence information and other privileged information , what's the source or authenticity of that, why am I to believe to what you're putting out there. The authenticity of information, I think you get my point.
He's right in the favouritism in huge bureaucratic defense setup whose in a different loop & the political leadership so far had no priority or time for longterm defense strategizing .... it's important that there's definite need for drastic reforms to make it a stronger fighting force considering the intends of a desperate expansist neighborhood whose equipped with 21st century weapon & 19th century leadership.... the government must even consider few years of compulsory defense tenure for the youth graduating out of college....
@@govindjayakumar Infrastructure is bogus, if hindus don't remain in majority, nitin gadkari is in the right place. Subramanian swamy or yogi will be best PM and we need them before 2024.
@@bajrang03010 Dont think yogi should be unleashed this quick.....Swamy is done...didnt even have finance this term and is 80+.....maybe its too soon for yogi probably 2029 would be ideal......either modi gadkari or amit shah
@@govindjayakumar India will divide into parts if modi continued till 2029. Age is just a number, jaitley died early, swamy is still very fit, I bet modi will not survive till 2029. We need a aggressive replacement, gadkari is not aggressive.
First of all, you must understand that Abhijit is a staunch advocate of everything American. He comes with the same prejudice an American analyst would about rest of the defence tech elsewhere in the world. Heavily opinionated. That's one bad quality to have for any analyst. Secondly, what is the whole point of having these exercises? To understand each other's challenges/strengths and try to bring about a synergistic output by addressing/aligning them. Else, you might as well have the Indian systems replaced by American systems over night. You will see Abhijit singing praises about it.
4 года назад
Dear Pgurus please if you can make a video on India's military issues like indigenous issues at ofb reg barrel bursts ,missile failures.🙏
But Abhijeet was only strongly recommended india must be seen as or in front appearance in part of Quad..Can not hide behind our earlier non alignment policies...Etc etc. The exercise like Malbar is one of such occasion. Forget about who gets alienated and all. And here In exercise like Malabar one can not change the military hardware we have overnight..And cursing same is not seen as good sense. One has to go through the exercise process which wl help us finding solution to the problems comes up in the whole juncture which surely el teach us to cope up and how to handle the situation with Quad members ; if things arise against China.
Except Sunder ji and inter communication problem of Navy , he is talking utter nonsense.. Please visit Army's Military Secretary Branch to know promotion n selection ststem..The system is not perfect , but it is the best in India
I'm agreeing with Mr. Aiyar, that how incompatible our military attaché is and congruence of right person in the highly sensitive job. Certain things must be developed for national interest rather chapluci. Moreover I think Mr. Aiyar quoted few sensitive words like how Indian Navy communicate from rumours spread by semi military experts floating around press staff.
@Programming Buddy u stole what i was thinking. absolutely spot on. "Nindak nihare rakhiye, aangan kuti chhaway Bin pani bin sabun, nirmal kare subhav"
Seems like the British were successful making Abhijit an apologetic, miserable feeling Indian!! The same 'engineers' who supply him with information regarding incompatability will be the ones participating in Malabar soon. Yet there will be several hundreds of engineers who would be patriotically part taking to tie up loose ends. When will you get info from them? P.S: Shree Iyer, sincere request to invite only ex-servicemen to talk on technical defence topics, not some theoretical computer war game playing 'expert'.
Job of engineers is to make things work to the best possible way. Problem is when you operate 2 devices which are made from competitors and expect them to work in sync wont happen even smartest of engineer would have to cut corners to make it work Example try syncing android with IOS will it sync yes but how effortlessy and how efficient is question and now sync Android to Android or IOS to IOS and how effortlessly and efficiently it will sync....?and now multiply that problem with 1000 times more difficulty.
@@chanakyajoshi3085 Actually bhai the reason i requested Shree Iyer for an ex-serviceman was that he would certainly provide some solutions to the interoperability issue as long as its not classified. Navies of 3 other nations are certainly not coming to India for Diwali😉 They sure have some level of coordination which can be stepped up in case of actual conflict.
@@dattarajhaldankar9600 brother I definitely agree on the point ur making actually there is a video of ex air marshal speaking on same topic of inter operability I believe host is major Gaurav arya I will post link if I can I think reason for abhijeet being upset is regards to what happened during conflict in 2019 feb when our air defense system shot down our helicopter and 6 air men got martyr
@@chanakyajoshi3085 Thanks bro! yeah indeed a helicopter was lost that day. Maj. Gaurav , Air Marshal Barbosa etc. provide a lot of solutions being ex-servicemen actually having been on the front and thats why i enjoy their insights.
Abhijit is smart but very opinionated. You need to take anything what he says with a pinch of salt. Per his analysis we should dump our military hardware in the middle of Indian ocean and just say " hail ching ping ting" because otherwise China will be very angry.
@samudra gupta I am an agreement with that thought but his projection usually is that Indian defense forces can't do anything right which I completely disagree with taking into account all our issues.
I don't agree with Abhijit. How can you know how indian navy communicate. If they don't communicate, then how can indian navy do naval exercise. Those details are classified. How Abhijit can about those classified details.
@john doe the way of communicating with other navy is classified. We civilian cannot know about this. If they can't communicate then the navy will modify it's equipment. India buys defence equipments from other countries but those are modified equipment as per india's requirements.
AIM could well become leader of oposition in the Lok Sabha. And in 2024 the PM of India. Sonia Gandhi must listen to what all AIM has to say and include him in INC✋🏼
I dont agree with you Mr. Iyar regarding "communication". We do "test" before sending a product in market. And it is not something we do explore in "production environment". And, we do test all the features. So, better not spread confusion 😐
@@sangramsingh1465 ha ha ha ha ........ no man I am an engineer. I just explained what we do across the industry. it is same process every one follows.
what is your opinion?are you saying that the Indian troops will disengage from Indian territory, and the Chinese will disengage from Indian territory also. It seems to me that the Indian soldier are moving back from their own soil.it's look like China outsmarted us. The Chinese are not known to give up that easy, they reanalyze that winter is approaching and their troops, tanks, and other vehicles will have problem to operate in a hash winter, the Indian military planners must study this carefully and make the right decisions.
under present circumstances the IN seriously needs a fleet of two 53,800 ton (66,000 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) aircraft carrier powered by cutting edge bio fuel cell & Li-ion iSmart-HYBRID marine propulsion system . . . unit cost €5.0 Bn - €8.2 Bn approx . . . IN will also require atleast one 18,090 ton (22,000 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) light aircraft carrier powered by the same bio fuel cell & Li-ion iSmart-HYBRID marine power pack . . . private sector investment solutions in future naval acquisitions can realize even the most daring of naval projects . . . it's rather simple the Indian private sector buys new state-of-the-art flat tops & surface combatants for the IN & leases the same back to the IN at a fair & affordable lease rate . . .
Mitra , in early part of discussion cursing Indian army that joint exercises with western fleet is futile, because of different source code . Later part he praised Japanese Navy , How come Japanese Navy has same source code ? That work with western NAVY? Care to explain ? For his information , JAPANESE NAVY BUILD FIRST AIRCRAFT CARRIER “Hosyo” in 1922.
Majority of viewers are optimists and they do not like to see the truth. Remember, Abhijit supported BJP and he is criticising only when he needs to do. War can not be won on optimism. Let us analyse only the facts before us and do not judgemental on Abhijit. He is supporting India on many occasions and we need to listen to criticism and be prepared to make corrections.
Now with BECA signed and sealed, Abirjit's assessment on military interoperability falls to the ground. He should have hold his negative comments on his own motherland.
To get all the filth in this world exposed we need another four years 🙂 and may be we need him right upto 2029🤭 who knows. Some unthinkable may happen during the next four years
Never heard anything good about India from Abhijit. He is so negative and spreads negativity everywhere 🙄 Does he not have any thing good about India, and we criticize RG all the time?
4 года назад+1
He is very intelligent who can simplify complexity 👍
"Nindak nihare rakhiye, aangan kuti chhaway Bin pani bin sabun, nirmal kare subhav" Keep your critic close, you get to know your faults if someone criticizes you, and you have a chance to correct them. Give your critics shelter in your courtyard and listen to the criticism without annoyance, because critic is not your enemy, he is helping you to clean the rubbish from your life without soap and water.
@Shashank Kumar why can't we build our own communicating device? Encrypted communicating device is not a big thing. Even an engineering student can do that.
4 года назад
QUAD should decimate China and salami slice it into 6 pieces
AIM is basically volunteering as a lobbyist for American arms manufacturers. The guy should be paid for his efforts. What a joker of an analyst lol. Doesn't know Australian and Japanese navies can't operate far from shores without American fleet support. No wonder they have excessive interoperability- us satellite directly to japanese/australian missile systems or us sensors directly to japanese monitoring stations etc. India has good stand alone capability - we dont need to integrate at a "granular level" . We have anti submarine/ anti ship info sharing through P8i s , sikorsky s and maybe guardian drones in the future. Indian navy can alone handle the rest. So why invest in extra US equipment and ignore our brahmos , barak 8 , ins arihant developed in collaboration. Should we turn into a US lackey just to placate Abhijit's intellect ?
Sir, with all due respect, please get this interviewer gentleman to either do his homework or not interview people like Abhijit Iyer Mitra. Too embarrassing! 🙄
Abhijit Bhai, so in a war which will last say 7-21 days max, all these best brains cant have a system where command comes on a newly planted system and then theold system based on that.. So you are not boiling the sea but just an alternate system ..You don't get into the research project but 5-10 commands of shoot not shoot etc and to whom, rest the Israeli and Russian system will t Please leave your pessimism for India, we have seen the best of best and quick learning by ur force is not a Himalayan task! My 2 cents ... You have just too much respect for China and guess that is making ur analysis very predictable...
Why it is so difficult for your self proclaimed strategic thinker mind to understand that, if India is using russian and israel equipments , there is a need to do so. India can't afford F22 so we have to adjust with SU 30 MKI or Mig 29, and India is one of the few countries with whom Israel shares her technology , so why not make the best of both worlds. Yes you are right when you explains how seamless American,Japanese and Australian Military can operate due to their interoperability , Our systems may not be that seamless but atleast we are trying to find a solution to it. Do you want india to be american stooge in exchage of the latest tech ?And for God sake , stop crying russian equipment and israel radars in each of your show.
One hundred percent pessimistic approach I don't understand why this obsession of inferior rating of Indian military equipments Doesn't he aware of the detailed planning that goes well ahead of such big military exercise Or our military experts r fools n naive not to know the remedial actions in the areas reqd?
Iyer , la de de da Where do you pick this guy from , Does he has any military back ground in engineering ? What source code he is talking about , Give this idiot an example of windows and chrome work in same computer with different source code. India does have amalgamation of military equipment, it is working fine , if not than there are ways to worked it out , DO NOT DEMEAN PEOPLE WHO WORKED THEIR ENTIRE LIFE IN ARMY , One word DELUSIONAL OF GRANDEUR
This Iyer guy has lost it! Dude we are just doing military excercise not forming matrimonial relationship! This guy I'm sure never have even held a glock in his hand thinks he has more knowledge than all the generals admirals in indian forces
Thats how it works. You don't necessarily need to be a general to know how to analyse defence policies. Would your opinion have been different if Abhijit was a retired NCO ?
![Abhijit Iyer Mitra explains [ancient] history of Israel - Palestine conflict](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qF3Ngvlot7k/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Q/A] Cutting The Chaff: Rafale & What Ails Defence Procurement In India | Abhijit Iyer Mitra |MMRCA](/img/1.gif)
He is speaking the truth. We should not feel bad if he is showing us the mirror.
I have listened all his speech and in youtube and I have learn to use his words, " La di da di da"😂
And I learnt his twisting hand expressions 💁😂
I think he is fond of those words and sound 100 times in conversation with his daughter.
@@LIVEONWHEEL
He has a daughter ?
Every time I listen to him he comes across as indian version of Zaid Hamid...only sophisticated version
I love his hindi too😇
Have served with Australian Army for one year..The Young officers of Combat Arms of Indian Army/Navy/ Airforce are far better than Australian officers..In so far as professionalism is concerned
Sir excellence is not a substitute for lack of skill . We need more skills to be added to our soldiers .
@@natalkumar6132 dude excellence comes from skills and preparedness only. What even are u saying? Military is skilled, however the brains behind it, is the problem
Abhijit's knowledge and understanding of global politics and defense is absolutly fabulous
La di da di da...,😂🤣
Keep it up Abhijit.. 😉😉
i have no idea how abijith knows all this.. but always sounds amazing
Research. He is working with well established think tank.
He is a defence analyst
Har har Mahadev 🚩
This fellow Abhijit Iyer Mitra is half as clever as he seems.
Any proof for the statement you wrote
Congrats on your new Book Sree Sir,also AIM's assessment of the data integration and seamless data sharing is spot on
Congratulations PGurus for achieving the first goal of reaching 100 thousand subscriptions. Kudos to the team. 250K is not too far...keep it up...
I want Kevin Rudd to listen first few minutes
Iyer mitra is a gem.... brilliant 🙏
Dear Abhijit. Har Har Mahaadev. Ur the only, the only scholar who does best research, homework, Frank, honest, true Indian Jewal in the Crown 👑
My complements to Sri Iyer gaaru for such a pleasant starting music.
I always wait for A.I.M.
La De de da
MITRA , YOU ARE
DELUSIONAL OF GRANDEUR
He speaks the truth .
As always very informative session with Abhijit ,dhanyawadaha 🙏
🙏 🙏 🙏 ♥️ Both of you
Abhijit should be asked, what India should do to strengthen its armed forces and how Indian forces can get the maximum benefit from the QUAD?
he will just tell us to dump all russian and ingenious equipment in the sea and buy american overpriced crap
Love the clarity with which Abhijit speaks but he is running out of ammo. He needs to go back to doing some fundamental research to outdo himself. 😀
Thanks for making me feel old 😭
4 more years is the only way to go. Go Trump Go. God Bless America. Har Har Mahadev.
its trump as long as someone better for India comes along.
@@adisj5696 👍
Pompeo for president 2024 .....pro indian govt needed all over the world
It is always funny and unique to listen to Abhijeet 👍❤
India is making most of it's ships in house and latest diesel electric submarines are of French origin. Indian Navy is most indigenous Indian armed wing comapred to Airforce and Army.
Tired of this India bashing in such a general manner.
You got the building part right, but what goes into the ships ? Please look it up first. Most electronics is israeli, biggest example is the radar
@@sharthakghosh970 Not completely true .. yes there are Israeli products but most of them are made under India-Israel collaboration. The ships main computers, combat management system, sonars and most vital electronics are purely Indian.
I came, I saw Abhijit, I clicked
Very informative. Thanks.
the IAS training has to be changed , the corrupt have to be sacked and sent to 100 year jails terms , IFS needs to be also changed , professionals can be appointed as ambassadors .
very good discussion!!! in my View Trump is going to Win this election and this will be good for India, QUAD.
Can you please organize a program to discuss taking back Gilgit, Baltistan, Mirpur, Muzzafarabad areas of J & K.
Regards
Kapil Bhardwaj
Very enlightening. Thanks to both stalwart
Every Abhijeet's analysis.. We can win a T20 war but will be Tough to sustain a Test match war.
Cool! I liked the Analysis. Thanks!
I've watched quite a lot of Mitra on various channels and mostly he makes sense. He's also mostly appreciative sometimes critical about Indian policy makers which is also good. My question is when you give certain data and intelligence information and other privileged information , what's the source or authenticity of that, why am I to believe to what you're putting out there. The authenticity of information, I think you get my point.
Always wondered why India refused to include Australia in the quad. Maybe should've kept them waiting and begging longer!
Abhijit's Favorite word " La di da di da"
Israel-Russian equipment incompatibility/interoperability can be use to devise counterstragtegy
Combatiable systems will be installed in all the platforms to use all the agreement useful.
So Abhijit has a tendency to pain picture in broad strokes. I wish he would develop a faculty for nuanced argument
to suit to our palette? why are we sensitive to criticism and acceptance of problem?
He's right in the favouritism in huge bureaucratic defense setup whose in a different loop & the political leadership so far had no priority or time for longterm defense strategizing .... it's important that there's definite need for drastic reforms to make it a stronger fighting force considering the intends of a desperate expansist neighborhood whose equipped with 21st century weapon & 19th century leadership.... the government must even consider few years of compulsory defense tenure for the youth graduating out of college....
La di da di da..... 🤣 I can not stop myself adding it to my vocab.
Is there an option available for India to replace the Russian electronics & communication in these war ships with the US equipment’s?
No, again compatibility issues.
Abhijit Iyer Mitra is the civilian counter part of Ajay Shukla.but I like Abhijith.On Rafael deal he skinned Rahul Gandhi alive.
India can do nothing under modi, we need yogi as PM
@john doe just wait for 2029
Nitin Gadkari 2024 is what I would love to say....the infrastructure based governance...💪
@@govindjayakumar Infrastructure is bogus, if hindus don't remain in majority, nitin gadkari is in the right place. Subramanian swamy or yogi will be best PM and we need them before 2024.
@@bajrang03010 Dont think yogi should be unleashed this quick.....Swamy is done...didnt even have finance this term and is 80+.....maybe its too soon for yogi probably 2029 would be ideal......either modi gadkari or amit shah
@@govindjayakumar India will divide into parts if modi continued till 2029. Age is just a number, jaitley died early, swamy is still very fit, I bet modi will not survive till 2029. We need a aggressive replacement, gadkari is not aggressive.
Doron
Nice Virtual background..
Arrogance is the ultimate hallmark of intelligence.
First of all, you must understand that Abhijit is a staunch advocate of everything American. He comes with the same prejudice an American analyst would about rest of the defence tech elsewhere in the world. Heavily opinionated. That's one bad quality to have for any analyst.
Secondly, what is the whole point of having these exercises? To understand each other's challenges/strengths and try to bring about a synergistic output by addressing/aligning them.
Else, you might as well have the Indian systems replaced by American systems over night. You will see Abhijit singing praises about it.
Dear Pgurus please if you can make a video on India's military issues like indigenous issues at ofb reg barrel bursts ,missile failures.🙏
Abhijit "La di da di da" Iyer mitra mitra.
But Abhijeet was only strongly recommended india must be seen as or in front appearance in part of Quad..Can not hide behind our earlier non alignment policies...Etc etc.
The exercise like Malbar is one of such occasion. Forget about who gets alienated and all.
And here In exercise like Malabar one can not change the military hardware we have overnight..And cursing same is not seen as good sense.
One has to go through the exercise process which wl help us finding solution to the problems comes up in the whole juncture which surely el teach us to cope up and how to handle the situation with Quad members ; if things arise against China.
Give fifteen minutes to Rahul ,we can save thousands of crores
U mean thousands of crores for his mummy and him...
every knowledge belongs to one man.. 😏
Except Sunder ji and inter communication problem of Navy , he is talking utter nonsense..
Please visit Army's Military Secretary Branch to know promotion n selection ststem..The system is not perfect , but it is the best in India
You talk nonsense.
I'm agreeing with Mr. Aiyar, that how incompatible our military attaché is and congruence of right person in the highly sensitive job. Certain things must be developed for national interest rather chapluci. Moreover I think Mr. Aiyar quoted few sensitive words like how Indian Navy communicate from rumours spread by semi military experts floating around press staff.
I don't know why they call him, he is like I know everything type of a guy and undermines everything.
@Programming Buddy u stole what i was thinking. absolutely spot on. "Nindak nihare rakhiye, aangan kuti chhaway
Bin pani bin sabun, nirmal kare subhav"
Dude I watch you its a pleasure when you arenot talking perfect Hindi.
Discussion on QUAD was a bit too short. With Little more time and questions, topic interest enhance.
Abhi looks like he is about to take haircut
😂😂 i were also thinking this 😂
Putin said it may join Russia China Military alliance ,
👉 Is it threat for India or QUAD.. … ??? Please ask him next time..
Seems like the British were successful making Abhijit an apologetic, miserable feeling Indian!!
The same 'engineers' who supply him with information regarding incompatability will be the ones participating in Malabar soon. Yet there will be several hundreds of engineers who would be patriotically part taking to tie up loose ends. When will you get info from them?
P.S: Shree Iyer, sincere request to invite only ex-servicemen to talk on technical defence topics, not some theoretical computer war game playing 'expert'.
Job of engineers is to make things work to the best possible way. Problem is when you operate 2 devices which are made from competitors and expect them to work in sync wont happen even smartest of engineer would have to cut corners to make it work
Example try syncing android with IOS will it sync yes but how effortlessy and how efficient is question and now sync Android to Android or IOS to IOS and how effortlessly and efficiently it will sync....?and now multiply that problem with 1000 times more difficulty.
@@chanakyajoshi3085 Actually bhai the reason i requested Shree Iyer for an ex-serviceman was that he would certainly provide some solutions to the interoperability issue as long as its not classified. Navies of 3 other nations are certainly not coming to India for Diwali😉 They sure have some level of coordination which can be stepped up in case of actual conflict.
@@dattarajhaldankar9600 brother I definitely agree on the point ur making
actually there is a video of ex air marshal speaking on same topic of inter operability I believe host is major Gaurav arya I will post link if I can
I think reason for abhijeet being upset is regards to what happened during conflict in 2019 feb when our air defense system shot down our helicopter and 6 air men got martyr
@@chanakyajoshi3085 Thanks bro! yeah indeed a helicopter was lost that day. Maj. Gaurav , Air Marshal Barbosa etc. provide a lot of solutions being ex-servicemen actually having been on the front and thats why i enjoy their insights.
Looks like GT is quoting Mr.AIM !
Abhijit is smart but very opinionated. You need to take anything what he says with a pinch of salt. Per his analysis we should dump our military hardware in the middle of Indian ocean and just say " hail ching ping ting" because otherwise China will be very angry.
@samudra gupta I am an agreement with that thought but his projection usually is that Indian defense forces can't do anything right which I completely disagree with taking into account all our issues.
Kivi even those two passenger planes Not needed because they doesn’t have the neighbors like us have pak and corona father😂
I don't agree with Abhijit.
How can you know how indian navy communicate. If they don't communicate, then how can indian navy do naval exercise. Those details are classified. How Abhijit can about those classified details.
@john doe the way of communicating with other navy is classified. We civilian cannot know about this. If they can't communicate then the navy will modify it's equipment. India buys defence equipments from other countries but those are modified equipment as per india's requirements.
@john doe those may be not compatible with Australia,USA, Japan
But they can communicate.
Those exercise are meant to shares tactics and get knows each others protocols which will leads to get compatible with others navys.
@@ankitbaral367 he is not talking about personal communication. Its about the missiles, radars, weapon systems communication.
@@ghosh25281 well
Those are classified how they work
Abhi look high
Not Quad its 'Triad plus Something'! That 'Something' we don't know how much is it?
Abi-hypersonicjet of knowledge?
Neighbors என்ன நினப்பாங்க 😂✌️👌👏🤪
AIM could well become leader of oposition in the Lok Sabha.
And in 2024 the PM of India.
Sonia Gandhi must listen to what all AIM has to say and include him in INC✋🏼
Today's discussion have soccer moms too....😁😁
I dont agree with you Mr. Iyar regarding "communication". We do "test" before sending a product in market. And it is not something we do explore in "production environment". And, we do test all the features. So, better not spread confusion 😐
Do you deal in Defence comm equipment???
@@sangramsingh1465
ha ha ha ha ........ no man I am an engineer. I just explained what we do across the industry. it is same process every one follows.
Using equipments of two enemy nation. How can they work perfectly. It is like mixing oil and water expect it to mix like lemon and water
IT engineer commenting on Naval technology 😆
@@bijucyborg
Btw, he was talking abt code. Hope u noticed it 😉
what is your opinion?are you saying that the Indian troops will disengage from Indian territory, and the Chinese will disengage from Indian territory also. It seems to me that the Indian soldier are moving back from their own soil.it's look like China outsmarted us. The Chinese are not known to give up that easy, they reanalyze that winter is approaching and their troops, tanks, and other vehicles will have problem to operate in a hash winter, the Indian military planners must study this carefully and make the right decisions.
under present circumstances the IN seriously needs a fleet of two 53,800 ton (66,000 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) aircraft carrier powered by cutting edge bio fuel cell & Li-ion iSmart-HYBRID marine propulsion system . . . unit cost €5.0 Bn - €8.2 Bn approx . . . IN will also require atleast one 18,090 ton (22,000 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) light aircraft carrier powered by the same bio fuel cell & Li-ion iSmart-HYBRID marine power pack . . . private sector investment solutions in future naval acquisitions can realize even the most daring of naval projects . . . it's rather simple the Indian private sector buys new state-of-the-art flat tops & surface combatants for the IN & leases the same back to the IN at a fair & affordable lease rate . . .
Mitra , in early part of discussion cursing Indian army that joint exercises with western fleet is futile, because of different source code .
Later part he praised Japanese Navy ,
How come Japanese Navy has same source code ? That work with western NAVY?
Care to explain ?
For his information , JAPANESE NAVY BUILD FIRST AIRCRAFT CARRIER “Hosyo” in 1922.
Most of our ships are no longer Russian
Majority of viewers are optimists and they do not like to see the truth. Remember, Abhijit supported BJP and he is criticising only when he needs to do. War can not be won on optimism. Let us analyse only the facts before us and do not judgemental on Abhijit. He is supporting India on many occasions and we need to listen to criticism and be prepared to make corrections.
Now with BECA signed and sealed, Abirjit's assessment on military interoperability falls to the ground. He should have hold his negative comments on his own motherland.
To get all the filth in this world exposed we need another four years 🙂 and may be we need him right upto 2029🤭 who knows. Some unthinkable may happen during the next four years
Never heard anything good about India from Abhijit. He is so negative and spreads negativity everywhere 🙄 Does he not have any thing good about India, and we criticize RG all the time?
He is very intelligent who can simplify complexity 👍
"Nindak nihare rakhiye, aangan kuti chhaway
Bin pani bin sabun, nirmal kare subhav"
Keep your critic close, you get to know your faults if someone criticizes you, and you have a chance to correct them. Give your critics shelter in your courtyard and listen to the criticism without annoyance, because critic is not your enemy, he is helping you to clean the rubbish from your life without soap and water.
@Lady Anon he talk the truth.
@@ghosh25281 I always remember this Kabir das Ka doha
@Lady Anon man
He speaks shit regarding tech issues
His comments on Gen Sunderjee is misplaced. Quite incompetent to comment on military matters
Is Sree Iyer making those weird sounds with moving some stuff while Abijeet is speaking? Whatever that is, very annoying
Iyer speaks funny English .... Did you hear him saying I am sorry to give you all this information 😃
Why do ships needs to talk? Isn't it people who run those ships need to talk for co-ordination?
@Shashank Kumar so a nation cannot buy an encrypted secure channel that people in two different ships can talk securely?
@Shashank Kumar why can't we build our own communicating device? Encrypted communicating device is not a big thing. Even an engineering student can do that.
QUAD should decimate China and salami slice it into 6 pieces
Not impressed with this talk
Don't abuse first dislike
Why dislike? We need critical persons like Abhijit in order to improve upon and rectify our shortcomings. Jai Mata Di 🙏🙏
There is a serious need to fact check what mr. Iyer says with some technical experts. I do not trust everything he says.
AIM is basically volunteering as a lobbyist for American arms manufacturers. The guy should be paid for his efforts. What a joker of an analyst lol. Doesn't know Australian and Japanese navies can't operate far from shores without American fleet support. No wonder they have excessive interoperability- us satellite directly to japanese/australian missile systems or us sensors directly to japanese monitoring stations etc. India has good stand alone capability - we dont need to integrate at a "granular level" . We have anti submarine/ anti ship info sharing through P8i s , sikorsky s and maybe guardian drones in the future. Indian navy can alone handle the rest. So why invest in extra US equipment and ignore our brahmos , barak 8 , ins arihant developed in collaboration. Should we turn into a US lackey just to placate Abhijit's intellect ?
Russians have just signed a military alliance with our cheeni friends my brother.....😭😭😭
What's with those fake backgrounds !?!
Sir, with all due respect, please get this interviewer gentleman to either do his homework or not interview people like Abhijit Iyer Mitra. Too embarrassing! 🙄
Abhijit Bhai, so in a war which will last say 7-21 days max, all these best brains cant have a system where command comes on a newly planted system and then theold system based on that.. So you are not boiling the sea but just an alternate system ..You don't get into the research project but 5-10 commands of shoot not shoot etc and to whom, rest the Israeli and Russian system will t
Please leave your pessimism for India, we have seen the best of best and quick learning by ur force is not a Himalayan task!
My 2 cents ... You have just too much respect for China and guess that is making ur analysis very predictable...
Thank god he didnt join Navy.if he commands a ship he would bang it in no time.if he he operates a fleet,the ships would be sitting ducks.
Obla di obla da.tata bye bye.
As soon as he mentioned that he is a trump supporter parroting the republican propaganda his credibility went to zero.
Ladidadida 😂😂
Why it is so difficult for your self proclaimed strategic thinker mind to understand that, if India is using russian and israel equipments , there is a need to do so. India can't afford F22 so we have to adjust with SU 30 MKI or Mig 29, and India is one of the few countries with whom Israel shares her technology , so why not make the best of both worlds. Yes you are right when you explains how seamless American,Japanese and Australian Military can operate due to their interoperability , Our systems may not be that seamless but atleast we are trying to find a solution to it.
Do you want india to be american stooge in exchage of the latest tech ?And for God sake , stop crying russian equipment and israel radars in each of your show.
Annoying 🤔
One hundred percent pessimistic approach
I don't understand why this obsession of inferior rating of Indian military equipments
Doesn't he aware of the detailed planning that goes well ahead of such big military exercise
Or our military experts r fools n naive not to know the remedial actions in the areas reqd?
Not worth listening Abhijeet. Stopped watching him. I stead call some one with balanced view
Iyer , la de de da
Where do you pick this guy from ,
Does he has any military back ground in engineering ?
What source code he is talking about ,
Give this idiot an example of windows and chrome work in same computer with different source code.
India does have amalgamation of military equipment, it is working fine , if not than there are ways to worked it out , DO NOT DEMEAN PEOPLE WHO WORKED THEIR ENTIRE LIFE IN ARMY ,
One word
DELUSIONAL OF GRANDEUR
Abhijit iyer come up with some new topics. U r doing same talk everywhr. No new substance.
Then your question should be on Shree Iyer. Also, Abhijit is a strategic affairs expert, do you expect political analysis from him?
This Iyer guy has lost it! Dude we are just doing military excercise not forming matrimonial relationship! This guy I'm sure never have even held a glock in his hand thinks he has more knowledge than all the generals admirals in indian forces
Thats how it works. You don't necessarily need to be a general to know how to analyse defence policies. Would your opinion have been different if Abhijit was a retired NCO ?