Young girl shocks Sheikh with a difficult question!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 авг 2021
- The famous contention "If everything needs a creator, then who created God?" is addressed in a short educational film with Sheikh Ibrahim Abdullah.
If you enjoy OnePath content, please consider supporting us to grow! ►onepathnetwork.com/dollar-a-d...
Download the OnePath Network App for access to the latest and exclusive videos:
onepath.onelink.me/mJxr/3de973bd
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @onepathnetwork
Facebook ►: / onepathnetwork
Instagram ►: / onepathnetwork
Patreon ►: / onepathnetwork
Who made God?
Here's an example
Who painted the wall
- The painter
Who painted the painter?
- Noone because the painter is not a painting
-------------------------
Who created the creation?
- Allah
Who created Allah
- Noone, because Allah's not a creation
Btw I saw this on a comment from a different video from a different channel
I just thought I'd share it
That is a very nice explanation sister
Never heard this explanation before. Pretty good ma shaa Allah.
Mashallah... Nice example to understand it... Jazakallah khair
Jazakallah Khair, can you also share that video
Jazaak'Allahu Khayran sister!
“The fact that we exists proved God exists”.SHEIKH AHMED DEEDAT
1.Everything which has a begining have a cause.
2.The universe and all the things within universe has a beginning.
3.Therefore universe has a cause.
And that cause is Allah.
(Imam Ghazali RA)
Which God?
@@doyouknoworjustbelieve6694 The One true God who created the universe,you and me.The God of all Prophets.Moses,Jesus and Mohammed etc peace be upon them all.Doesnt matter with which name you call him but the name should be respectful.
It prooves that we evolve, not in god. Man it's 21st century. Grow up mannn 😂😂
@@rohaannaskar8174 Hummm but how the first cell came into existance?Have you study the origion of life?
What do you mean its 21st century?Does this answered that universe came into existance by its own?
“Is there any doubt about Allah, the originator of the heavens and the earth?”
Quran 14:10
Allah is not conceived, Allah is made up
@@fatimaachy5764 apostate
@@fatimaachy5764 You don't really believe what you wrote. But you wish it were true, and you convince yourself that it is so, because it is also fashionable, convenient and the so called "intelligentsia" says so too.
But nah. We exist because he exists, but he does not exist because we exist.
@@fatimaachy5764 May Allah ( God ) guide you, Ms. Fatima
@@rafayshakeel4812 That people in this time need to believe this nonsense BsThat people in this time need to believe this nonsense Bs
I love the way how teacher explains in a gentle manner without getting angry
Sheikhs are always calm
@@thedictationofallah Dont Make Those Claims
If only my teachers were like that, i would at least score in my exam...
I would love to go to school if my teacher was like him
@@galaxee4980 I wish if :(
Beautifully articulated 👍🏻
Beautiful stupidity. These are just meaningless words. You can't explain the universe with words or medieval theology. One example: can God make a square that it's also a circle? If not, he's not omnipotent. Can God incarnate as a man? No, because it's bellow his majesty. But the universe is bellow his majesty, the universe is subjected to entropy and energy decline. Everything that it's not perfect it's bellow his majesty. Therefore, God didn't create the universe. See? Words!
@@antoniorocha3967 allah created it you May not belive but we muslims believe that allah created everything and the universe our brain is weak and can't understand how the universe works this shows how powerful allah is
@@G1ost99 Which is completely wrong. Everything you say. My positiion it's not a matter of belief, as your belief is not important also. Belief is irrelevant, it's not an argument. There are many different faiths in the world, often contradictory. And people believe equally in all of those. Doesn't mean much. About weak brains, it's true for some. We can in fact understand how the universe works. You must read astrophisics and cosmology, relativity and quantum mechanics, M theory. That way your brain won't be that weak. Of course that we don't know everything, and we don't hold absolute truths. Absolute truth is something from religion. Religion owns the truth. Although that truth is nothing more than lies. Anyways, do you know how the electronic technology you're using right now works? It's not magic, it's not religion. It's science. That's the thing with science. It not only explains, it creates. Religion does neither.
@@antoniorocha3967 1st question are u an atheist? 2nd question why are u watching this video? 3rd question whats ur theory on who created man and the universe?
@@muhammadshami1312 First question, it doesn't really matter. Second question, i must know something before having a view on it. Imagine if i was an atheist regarding religion. I should learn about, at least, the major religions before addressing it. For example, what do you think about the satanism from Anton Szandor laVey? Have you read the satanic bible? If not, you can't really think anything, can you? Third, what's my theory on who created man and the universe? That's all absurd. First, i don't have theories. I'm not even a scientist. Second, asking who instead of how it's completely wrong. I suggest you study cosmology, for the problematic of the origin of the universe, and paleontology, chemistry and biology on the man's origin stuff. Hope i could help.
what i understand is like this :
God already exists, before the word exists.
God is the creator of TIME,
before there was a concept of time, God existed,
So the concept of time, past, present & future, is Allah's creation..
that's why the question of who created God should not be asked, because before God created time, there was no time,
Before God created something, nothing existed..
"before & after" time is created by God, such that concepts are not programmed in the human brain which is very limited,
while Allah's knowledge is unlimited,
So the answer to that question will never be reached by humans.
Exactly!
He is the First and the Last, the one with no begining and no End.
This used to blow my mind since I was a kid, particularly teenage age, Master of Time....wow
@@salampakistan3691 in the human brain everything is conceptualized in a time system..
past, present & future,
Question like : What's happenned in the past, how God was created?
Maybe in fact, all these concepts did not exist before God created "time".
The concept of immortality, which is in God, cannot be understood in details by us, humans,
our brains are not programmed for such knowledge, the concept of "beginning" of God may never exist, or we don't understand,
because in God's "time" (not human time) there is no beginning and no end
@@nayanika3599 yep this is the point of God..we can't fully understand him or how he is
In science actually, time is used to present something that's been changing, for example, speed is a change in position with respect to time and we age as time goes. A change only happens if something is under the influence of time. if we pause time there is no change happening.
Allah (SWT) doesn't change under any circumstance that is Allah (SWT) is not under the influence of time and he causes the change in everything so He created time. (it's just my thoughts so you can correct me if I am wrong).
His answer gave me a goose bumps, and tears in my eyes. Subhanallah
Stay away from islam ruclips.net/video/Q_IPujht79E/видео.html
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Stay away from islam
Kindly make a series of such lessons for the kids,so that the lessons of tawheed and seerah could be inculcated in them.
ماشاءاللہ
Vedio
Such heavy words but why Vedio
the spelling is videos😂
"When the sage points to the moon, the fool looks at the finger"
The production level on this video is without a doubt professional. Mashallah.
Alhamdulilah, it's so simple that even kids get it. MashaAllah.
Adults who lack belief in the creator will try and do mental gymnastics to avoid the question. Being weak to our whims and desires has this affect on us. Kids still enjoy a pure fitrah so they have no problems with understanding who Allah is.
Grow up man , your Allah is the reasons for so many terrorist attacks . And there is no allah is pure science and go to school to learn how universe is created 😂😂
@@rohaannaskar8174 AHHHHH another stupid person who thinks terrorism is from Islam while it isn't
@@rohaannaskar8174 tell me a verse that says be terrorist or kill innocent people
@@rohaannaskar8174 Well please don't blame the religion of Islam or any other religion for some extremists and deviant people. Islam never says to kill innocent people. Well you believe in science right? Please explain how the universe came out of nothing... or tell me where science says there is or there is no God. And where do you get your morality? From science textbooks lol? Grow up kiddo... don't go on a road to nothing... your just afraid to quit your desires. Get a life lol.
Alhamdullilah.
Also, it's good to write "SWT" (and say the phrase this abbreviation stands for) after mention the name of God Almighty.
Like this: Allah (SWT)
Writing it like this is the appropriate way (its not exactly necessary but it's thikr that's beneficial to you and appropriate) talk about Allah (SWT).
This phrase stands for "subhanahu wa ta'ala", which means "The Most Glorified, The Most High".
Saying SWT after mentioning Allah (SWT) both gives the praise, respect, and glory which is due to Allah (SWT) and also gives you free hasanat (good deeds).
By the way SWT is not usually said/written after saying things inshallah or bismillah and similar tathkir but if you want more hasanat then you can feel free to write it down / say it.
JazakAllahukhairan for reading this.
Also, read this for more info if you would like (its a very easy to read and short article that covers a lot): en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_honorifics
so beautifuly explained.... wish I had a teacher like him when I was younger
So if asking who created Allah is like asking someone to draw a squared circle, why not asking who created the creation is like asking some one to draw a squared circle????? Isn't creation itself enough unto itself?
@Mary Does that mean that you believe that a square can be drawn by itself in the table without me having to touch the pen with my hands, right ?
There are explanations about this question on the internet. But there is no one that explained this clearly. Jazakallahu Khayran for making such a good, beneficial, explained video for us.
Assalamualaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wabarakatuhuhu♥️♥️
Subhanallah...he is the khaliq...very well explained sheikh...fan of Onepath Network from India
These doubts need to be explained to children
Beautiful sheikh, with his beautiful students, with a beautiful question, with an even beautiful answer.
I knew the anwer already, but really the two examples here blew my mind away. Masha Allah.
Laa ilaaha illaa Allah…Allah is the Greatest🥰❤️
May peace and blessings of Allah be upon our beloved prophet his companions and entire household✨✨✨
Allah is not conceived, Allah is made up
@@fatimaachy5764 Nah bro, Allah does exist. He isn't just made up. As Muslims, we believe in Allah and if you don't, maybe you shouldn't comment something that you know us Muslims wouldn't like. There's so much signs and clear proof of Allah's (God's) existence. Maybe you're heart is blind. Try reading the Qur'an. It's a miracle. No way a human could ever write down such a book filled with miracles, predictions, scientific facts and a way for humanity to live. It was revealed 1400 years as well. Anyways, how can you deny Allah. How can you be arrogant with the One who Created you? Bye. I like debating with people in the comments now lol
@@fatimaachy5764 your mind doesn't exist ..it's made up by your parents
@@munt07 I know very well what is in the Quran. There are many mistakes. Many Muslims start to doubt, also thanks you tube. A person is curtailed in his freedom by this cult and in some countries threatens with death if he Islam turns his back.
@@fatimaachy5764 lmao then state the mistakes you waste of time
Masha Allah. May Allah bless your activities. Ameen
آمين
Ameen
Ameen
A simple explanation for Contingency argument. Well done OnePath 💟
Also there is alternative like Kalam cosmological argument. Either way there are multiple ways to prove existence of Allah Swt.
@@orionemperor5319 It's good to write "SWT" (and say the phrase this abbreviation stands for) after mention the name of God Almighty.
Like this: Allah (SWT)
Writing it like this is the appropriate way (its not exactly necessary but it's thikr that's beneficial to you and appropriate) talk about Allah (SWT).
This phrase stands for "subhanahu wa ta'ala", which means "The Most Glorified, The Most High".
Saying SWT after mentioning Allah (SWT) both gives the praise, respect, and glory which is due to Allah (SWT) and also gives you free hasanat (good deeds).
By the way SWT is not usually said/written after saying things inshallah or bismillah and similar tathkir but if you want more hasanat then you can feel free to write it down / say it.
JazakAllahukhairan for reading this.
Also, read this for more info if you would like (its a very easy to read and short article that covers a lot): en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_honorifics
@@zendarkritical jazakallah brother. I have edited it.
how can you say universes has to have a beginning,I can say that universe has always existed just like Allah, if you argue that it is possible for things to exist without a beginning like Allah, then I can also argue that universe has always excited
@@prasadramesh326 Hello prasad ramesh, are you ok with the assertion that says that everything that our minds can process has to be classified as either: possible, impossible or obligatory? with no other categories, knowing that:
- Possible: it could be or it couldn't.
- Impossible: it can never be.
- Obligatory: it must be.
😏 Me being an intellectual, already knew that a sheikh from the One Path network would easily be able to answer this question before I even clicked on the video.
yeah man you are great😅
@@abdullahnaveed9625 😂 Allah is the greatest
@@saims.2402 bro I found u many time at Comment
@@artisticrayyan8475 lol me too
Same lol
No one made Allah swt he was always there
How?
@@ok-mv3wh when you can’t answer something and not in Quran then stop thinking or the question can hurt your iman
@@Ihave2behasan ok😅
What a best and simplicity in answer... May Allah rewards and increase knowledge...
Yo do one thing. Do not eat any thing for one month. May allah reward you with food.
Wallah this is the best explanation I have ever came across, may Allah bless one part network and all it's donars Ameen
I agree may God bless him
So if asking who created Allah is like asking someone to draw a squared circle, why not asking who created the creation is like asking some one to draw a squared circle????? Isn't creation itself enough unto itself?
@@alonkulungrai3796 creation is enough for creation!! How can that even make sense! Are humans self sufficient in all aspects?
@@dharshud08 Yes. That is why creation evolves. If it has been created by some external agency, that is a full stop. But it is not. And even in your wedding night, you have to copulate with your partner to create offsprings, I doubt you chant " Allah, bless her womb with babies"
@@alonkulungrai3796 so u r self sufficient in all aspects of life nd u don't need anyone's help so u r saying that u don't need a pen to write, a chair to sit, water to drink etc. In ur life, everything just happens when u command? C'mon yaar get some valuable points before arguing. U wanna keep on saying that there is no creator na? Footprints over sand show u that someone must had walked, ur claim Iz that footprints came on its own without anyone.. U wanna disagree nd keep on telling that there is no creator,, go ahead man n when ur death arrives u will know who was in error. Khalas I end the debate here coz u don't seem to understand the concept of creator creation etc wa Allahu alam pls try to read the qur'an at least once with an open mind nd may Allah guide u ameen
That's probably the best answer I have seen to this question. So simple and to the point
That teacher's answer was very logical
ALLAHU AKBAR.
Respect from Scotland.
Really liked this video, I would ask my dad this question, but he'd say not to talk about it much, so after a while I gave it up, now I have my answer! Thank you so much!
That question is actually a very good one
This question never occurred to me, but I like to be prepared to answer if someone else asks. Great answer, mashallah!
It first occurred to me when I was in 3rd grade .
Liked it so much. This is also true. Allah is the mightiest and the most merciful he created all of us. He is uncreated, he creates everyone humans, animals, earth, etc
Both Allah and muhmmad are practically same coin with two opposite side.
Muslims can see one side of the coin, , which is Mohammad, Allah was hidden in another side of the coin and Muslims cannot see other side.
Muslims had to believe on Mohammad for Allah.
If Muslims go to another side to see Allah then, Allah will become Mohammad and Mohammad will become Allah.
In science actually, time is used to present something that's been changing, for example, speed is a change in position with respect to time and we age as time goes. A change only happens if something is under the influence of time. if we pause time there is no change happening.
Allah (SWT) doesn't change under any circumstance that is Allah (SWT) is not under the influence of time and he causes the change in everything so He created time. (it's just my thoughts so you can correct me if I am wrong).
You are quite right bro
You're right. In fact Allah exists outside of those concepts. He created them. He's the ultimate boundlessness
I like this teacher honestly.. He's not the one who is very angry at a single question
❤️HE IS ONE WHO MAKES DECISION WITHOUT ASKING ANYONE
Even as a Christian, I've learned a lot from this video. Well done!
May Allah guide you to the truth.
@iRyannity which is Islam.
@iRyannity he can belive whatever he wants, but in the end he'll get to meet Allah and Allah may not be merciful
This question was always on my mind! After watching this video,I haven't got the question in my head ever again. Thank you OnePath!
So if asking who created Allah is like asking someone to draw a squared circle, why not asking who created the creation is like asking some one to draw a squared circle????? Isn't creation itself enough unto itself?
@@alonkulungrai3796 that's true,but I'm just stupid and haven't thought of it before 😅
@@livia450 If Allah creates, then what is the need of copulation?
The silence is deafening.
Masha Allah such a short and strong video. May Allah bless you all for your hard works and bless your family's and the ummah all❤️
Wow -- that was a powerful and well scripted video! My heart is at ease now ..
MasyaAllah, simple answer but answer everything
Allahu Akbar! Jazakum Allah Khair for helping this ummah!
أسأل الله العظيم رب العرش العظيم ان يوفقكم إلى كل خير..
محبكم الشاب / محمد عبد الرقيب من اليمن 🌹Thanks
آمين واياك
سلام الله على أرض اليمن
@@tawh1d يبارك المولى فيك يا أخي
MashaAllah, Best way of Preaching Allah's Message all over the world♥️
Jazak Allah Khair For the content
Thanks I also had this question on my mind for an year
I love onepath network team. ❤️when the kids went to "Astaghfrall" 😂😂
Subhanallah, great dawah training.
SubhanAllah,what a perfect explanation it is❤️
I love how he had the patience to answer that question alhamdulillah! if I had a student asking me that question I'd faint out of confusion and lay on the ground!
Jazakum-Allahu-khairan Shaykh Ibrahim and One path
I asked someone this question and they hesitated and told me to give them a day or two to answer. The next day the person came back with an answer. They said "God isnt created by anyone and thats why God is God" that simple answer was enough for me.
It is simple. If there was no creator of everything, then there will be no systems. No world. No start for everything.
Human brains just can't imagine it because they are limited. So how can a limited thing imagine the unlimited. And because human brains were programmed that way. But the human heart understands it by feeling and connection.
In my opinion, if a God does exist, it would be dark energy. You know that unexplained force that is expanding the universe exponentially? I dont think that they would resemble a person or a living thing, more of a force or law that affects how the universe works. But i think that you can go on an endless cycle with "who created that? what created that?" "who created the creator of the creator of the creator of that?". And i think its such an incomprehensible thing for us humans to understand that we should just try and enjoy life as we know it
@@alextheconfuddled8983 if thats how you see it and that gives you peace, then by all means. I respect that. But i dont experience what you just described. It actually gives me understanding, faith, strength, happiness with a little sadness cuz we're humans and thats normal. My purpose in life is clear and i feel more secure and confident. Im at peace and doing my best to be the best person i can be for myself and others.
@Mary Who created all these laws of physics and chemistry? How is it even possible for all these laws to exist perfectly with the perfect accuracy together? Why isn't the universe in randomity, instead it is in perfect sync? There is nothing that is created randomly. An engineer creates a car, a building, a boat while considering the smallest details in mind for these creations to not fail and be in perfect sync. And if something was wrong, the creation might fail. How about this universe we live in? The universe that never failed? It should be a perfect creation with perfect accuracy . No way it was created randomly with all its laws and science.
If there was no creator, what happens after death? Were humans just bprn to live like nothing? If there was no afterlife where the creator judges everyone on what they did, anyone can do anything and just escape with it. What restricts someone from killing another? From being evil? The law? The law never gives the true justice. Many people die without justice. How would these people get away with it while good people die ugly deaths for example? There should be an ultimate justice somewhere, right? Humans existence is random and there were just living by coincidence? What is even the purpose of this life? Enjoying life then dying? For what? Right?
Humans can't even imagine the infinite expansion of the universe and what it contains. How would they imagine things greater than that? Humans are finite. Everything in this universe is finite even the universe itself. The universe is expanding, right? If it was infinite, it wouldn't expand because it is already infinite. This means it has boundsries and expanding. It will sometime reach a certain point. How is it even expanding in a way that we can't imagine? The universe is only infinite to us relatively because we are so small compared to it.
So for there to be an intity that created every finite thing, it should be infinite. It should have no boundaries. No limitations. For there to be an entity who judges people and gives each one their perfectly fair judgement, it should be the infinite justice. For there to be an entity that created everything, it should be like nothing it created, or else it would apply to the same rules of the things it created. It should be above all laws of any science we know and don't know. It should be unique and perfect. It should have no similarity with anything. To be truely the creator of everything. This is Allah.
I hope I explained it in an easy way.
But that didn't answer anything. It's just another claim. It's also a circular argument. The real answer is simple: Man created god.
amazing work by one path 💖.
The logics were unbelievable.
Truly a his logics are worthyful.
And now I will say alhamdulillah.
New initiative. Enjoying a lot. Jazakumullahu khoiran
Very good explenation, i was always ask myself that question. As humans we always think about this.
The term ''create/created, beginning, end" are only exist in the human and worldly realm.
Woah, I feel satisfied with the answer
Thanks for teaching kids with this kind of videos. May Allah accept your works and Grant you guys ease and comfort in this world and the life hereafter
I ask Almighty God, Lord of the Great Throne, to guide you to all the best.
Your young lover / Mohamed Abdel Raqib from Yemen 🌹 Thanks🇾🇪🇾🇪
you too brother/sister :)
Such a vedio is so fine to educate everyone one. Hope they will do more in such vedios.
ome scientific verses of Mohammad's Quran!😅😂⤵️
Qur’an 15:26 - man is created from CLAY.
Qur’an 7:189 - humans created from a single being.
Qur’an 2:117 - human creation happened in an instant.
Qur’an 18:86 - sun sets in murky water
Qur’an 91:1-2-1 - moon and sun orbit the earth
Qur’an 35:41 - Earth does not move
Qur’an 40:64 - The Earth does not move
Qur’an 2:258 - sun moves the earth is still
Qur’an 45:13 - everything in universe orbits earth
Qur’an 81:2 - stars are small enough to fall on us
Qur’an 67:5, Qur’an 37:10 - shooting stars are missiles for devils.
Qur’an 65:12 - says there are 7 planets. Actually number is 8 planets +5 dwarf planets leaving the grand total at 13.
Qur’an 71:15-16 - moon is farther away than the stars
Qur’an 76:13 - cold air at night is caused by the moon
Qur’an 71:16 - moon emits light
Qur’an 54:1 - moon was split in two
Qur’an 7:54 - sun is not a star
Qur’an 21:32 - The sky is concrete and impenetrable
Qur’an 67:3 - there are no black holes
Qur’an 36:40 - Allah is ignorant of the north and south poles
Qur’an 86:6-7 - Sperm comes from between the spine/backbone and ribs
Qur’an 31:34 - ONLY Allah knows the gender of an unborn infant
Qur’an 25:45 - female participation (ovum) completely omitted
Qur’an 23:14 - Bones are formed before flesh (the first muscles are actually formed BEFORE the bones.
Qur’an 41:12 - Earth has 7 atmospheres
Qur’an 2:149 - earth is level
Qur’an 88:20 - earth is flat
Qur’an 16:15 - mountains prevent earthquakes
Qur’an 16:15 - Allah created the mountains by casting them down on the earth
Qur’an 16:45, Qur’an 29:37 - Earth quakes are for non-muslims only.
Qur’an 17:68 - hurricanes and blizzards are punishment for non-muslims only.
Qur’an 43:11 - Allah didnt know about the water cycle
Qur’an 5:116 - Christians worship Mary(even though she was NEVER worshiped as part of the trinity).
Qur’an 18:11 - humans can sleep for 300 years
Qur’an 2:187 - Allah was not aware of eskimos
Qur’an 6:38 - ALL animals live in communities(never mind animals like the Jaguar, right?)
Qur’an 55:33 - SPACE FLIGHT IS IMPOSSIBLE
Still 2B idiots believe
@@user-rj5fv6ze4c Knock Knock DumbAss,Quran has 114 Suras,Every Suras Have their own Awats.Like Surah An-Naba has 35.
@@user-rj5fv6ze4c pls all these have been refuted. Pls try to b an open minded person nd read the qur'an by urself pls don't believe Wtever u read in internet
Masha a Allah. 100% clear explanation. Not only for kids but for everybody.
Very intelligent Sheikh, Ma sha ALLAH
Subhan'Allah powerful answer Alhamdulillah
SUBHANALLAH ❤️🤍❤️
Beautifully Articulated 👍🏻👌🏻
We knew this before innit? 🥱
Excellent answer, JazakaALLAH khair
Masha ALLAH this question will be asked by many of us.Jazakumullahu khairan for uploading such a video.❤
Our Lord, grant us the good things
in this world and the good things in the next life and save us from the punishment of the Fire.
Amîn
The sister asked a good question
But the Sheik had a better answer. ☪️💜
thank you for this video. this is philosophically correct way of looking at the question.
The fact that our eyes, mouth, nose are not under our feet that itself tells me there is an intelligent designer behind this and to me that is the creator. That is Allah the almighty. Peace ✌️
The best explanation ive ever heard 🥰 so easy and helpful
If this is explaination, i am then god.
@@alonkulungrai3796 what?
@@J-DUDE- I am just implying how is this explaination is best? Even here with his analogy, Asking to draw a square circle is pointless because square circle doesnot exist. Similarly, asking about god is asking to draw square circle because god doesnot exist just like square circle doesnot.
@@alonkulungrai3796 the squared circle eg was given to make us understand that God, He isn't created.
@@dharshud08 So if god can exist without being created, why can not the creation exist without being created?
It’s not too hard to answer, nobody created allah SWT, it’s just too difficult for humans to comprehend, whoever enters jannah will know the truth
This thought provoking vedio has left me awestruck. Masha'Allah.
May Allah tala reward the team one path network for such a wonderful work.
that means, you are blessed with Eemaan
Mashallah. 😍 🥰 pls make a whole series like this. Jazakallah Khair.
Every question makes sense, and every questions makes you think 💭
The fact that we don’t know anything until we die and find out the truth.
Ok.
Is water a rock?
Can i see with my nose?
@issam guiti he said every question made sense..
@@playernova7431 ur using an equavacation fallacy as the question u asked is illogical
but the question who created god is completely sound and there is no way to answer it expect invoking special pleading
@@arianagrandaremix8858 to you its completely sound question..to theists its not..u know why? Because God is The Beginning (al Awwal), The End (al Akhir), The Self-Sufficient (as Samad) and The Creator (al Khaliq). That means he is independent from a creator. Its like asking atheist can everything come from literal nothing? To you its logic, to us, theists, its totally not!
@@playernova7431 sorry but it's a philosophical question
u again used special pleading
what makes u think that ur assumed first cause is an exception to the same logic u use to identify him
secondly, The problem I see with this argument is that u have now accepted that not all things are created; God isn’t. And if it’s possible for this one thing not to have been created, why isn’t it possible for all things not to have been created?
Allah created time so Allah is not bound by time. He created space so he's not bound by space. He created birth and death and he's not bound by birth and death. Basically, we can't understand him, except for what he told about himself.
Mashallah well said
Jazak Allahu kheiran beautifully said
the same thing applies to the universe
Creation is an event and events occur within time and that goes for consciousness too which I assume is an attribute of your god. What I mean is time would also have to be an attribute rather than a creation.
@@enemysub9057 First of all, consciousness of Allah is not like ours, so it's not necessary for his consciousness to be bound or limited like ours is. Second, time is an attribute of the creation so automatically it has been originated by Allah and he is the master of time and time cannot bind it's own master.
Best Answer of this Question I've ever seen..😊
Jajakallah Khairan
Stay away from islam ruclips.net/video/Q_IPujht79E/видео.html
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Stay away from islam
Very nice. JazakumAllah Khair.
Infinite regress is a logical absurdity. The causal chain will ultimately start from an UNCAUSED CAUSE.
It's okay for a childrens asking it...
Because they are need to learn and on the phase of learning... and because of human natures is always want to know...
It will be a different cased when the old men still asking about it...
So its okay for children asking but not adults? Stfu
الحمدلله على نعمة الاسلام . Thank God for the blessing of Islam
and he is beyond everything, our brains cant comprehend
Literally every kid once in childhood:Who created god?!
The vid: "GIRL SHOCKS SHIEKH WITH A DIFFICULT QUESTION!!"
I guess it’s because it’s a very good philosophical question about existence (wether you are Muslim or not). Or maybe because it just gets views and I’m trying to sound like an intellectual.
@@Oghuz
Lol
he is first without begining and last with out ending he isnt two or three he is ultimately SINGULAR ,UNIQUE , his proper name isnt GOD ,nor father his proper name is ALLAH the one ,unique and the only SWT MY glory and exalt to him swt
Thanks I needed this
Jazakallah khairan Shiekh
The idea of creation was created by Allah
“Difficult question” 😂😂😂
Maybe you should’ve worded it as “interesting question”. Still, this is educating for kids so they can understand infinite regress and the pre-eternality of Allah SWT
He did say interesting question….
@@jenniferkhan3686
He is talking about the title of the video I think
Jazakkillah khair ❤️
What a beautiful answer and easy to understand Mashallah
There is an easy way to answer this question.
Let’s start with a question - Does everything need a creator ? We get into the scenario of infinite regress, ie if everything need a creator, then then no creation would have ever existed , because the creator himself is waiting to be created !!
The only logical explanation is that there is one creator who existed at the beginning, and has always existed, and is himself not created. He is the source of all creation. It is this creator who breaks the chain of infinite regress, and is source of all creation. This is the only logical explanation that can explain existence of the universe, and everything in it.
The other option which the atheists choose to believe is that the entire universe and everything in it originated from absolute nothingness, and all happened by absolute chance! How can something come out of nothing ?
How logical and scientific is it to believe that the UNIVERSE CREATED ITSELF !
How can intelligence come out of emptiness. Just doesn't make sense ! The atheists all swear by Big Bang , and still don’t have an explanation for how the matter that existed before Big Bang came into being. The atheists don't have a clue , but yet they are 100 % confident that there is no God!
By the way, for all those who think that evolution is undisputed, think again. There are secular atheist scientists who have questioned the very basic tenets of Darwinism and his theories of evolution. Pls search for the talks of Suboor for the Islamic perspective on evolution. Darwinism is not all that perfect as it is made out to be ! The fundamental theories of Darwinism have been challenged by other athirst scientists.
@Black Mirrah to each his own. I don't wish to engage in a debate.
If you find it logical to believe that the UNIVERSE CREATED ITSELF OUT OF NOTHING, great !
If you choose to believe that everything that we see in the universe exists, because of SHEER ACCIDENT , sure go ahead. While you're at it , pls calculate the mathematical probability of the confluence of events happening in tandem.
If you choose to believe that the very fundamental tenets of DARWIN'S theories have not been challenged by other secular atheist scientists, sure ! But then pls Google a little bit.
Blissful Ignorance is a fantastic and beautiful thing, ain't it ?
By the way, while you are at it , I hope you take some time to study atheism and understand the core beliefs of atheism.
As a start , Pls search for the the terms "atheism incest, " on RUclips and pls don't be surprised to find how the poster boys of atheism , Richard Dawkins and Lawrence Krauss, are on video stating that THERE IS NOTHING WRONG with INCEST ( Yukh !) Have a great rest of your day !
When we think of creation, we think about a start and an end, i.e., a time span. Every creation has a beginning and an end. We have a concept of time because we are created. We have a beginning and an end: the concept of life. The time span can be as long as the life of the universe or as short as the life of a Top Quark, the shortest-lived matter in the universe. We cannot imagine what it would be like if we lived in “a timeless universe”, where time does not exist because we are not immortal. However, Allah (SWT) is immortal. He is outside time. He is timeless. Therefore, we can think that he has no beginning and no end. He is NOT a creation that needs to be created. Think about that. You’ll see that it makes sense.
MashaAllah jazakallahu khayr one path network all team
Finally got a proper answer...Alhamdulillah 🥰
Bad explanation to a difficult question! Chain of command exists everywhere in Nature but not for God/Allah? And there are ways to resolve them without saying 'the question is wrong' with plenty of deadlock resolution examples in Computer engineering. So the question remains unanswered unfortunately.
What should be your answer?
@@SYusuf-kj6xp My answer is that our ancestors explained the extremely complex Universe we live in with too simple an answer (That God/Allah is responsible for it all) that gave them some sort of resolution and they're now forcing that old answer on us when so many scientific advancements of the last two centuries point in some other direction. Why do we assume that there's a God/Allah in the first place? Life goes on just as well even if we assume that there's no God/Allah! This is a simple explanation of the question.
@@tipycalflow1767 Scientific advancement can create non recycling items like radio active elements. But it will never create life! Some scientific discipline shall embrace our creator more and more.
I was amazed when I provide some food grains to birds. They ate and leftover became natural fertiliser for the soil.
@@SYusuf-kj6xp But science has already created life my friend (test tube babies, cow clones, etc)! It has explained the Universe much better than any religion ever will and it's just the beginning! Religious scriptures won't change and hence won't improve but science keeps getting better and better.
You are not understanding nature is a creation his point was if A causes B which causes C which Causes D will it ever stop? NO hence its clear there was a Initial state where it started (God) you affirming science is irrelevant what has science got to do with metaphysics? Science is a beautiful tool which is used through the emprical eyes to make conclusions but you forgot even science has its metaphysical assumptions which are
- the External world exists objectively
-we humans have cognitive faculties that affirm true beliefs
-we are not living in a simulation
Science has no answers for this, we muslims are not denying science you saying science has made progress is irrelevant.
Islampropaganda👆🤣
That will be 3:40 minutes of your lifetime. Thanks for visiting.
More like this for the kids.. awesome video and perfect man for the job.
MaşaAllah
Beautifully explained, thank you.
سبحان اللہ
Such a beautiful explanation.
Thank you for these beautiful examples
Nyc way of teaching
Wow I wish I had such teachers
Thanks for the great knowledge. May Allah protect us from every calamities and grant us all Jannah.