Banana Fragrance Comparison | This, That, or Both?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
  • In this video, I'm comparing 2 banana fragrances in my collection, L'artisan Parfumeur Bana Banana & Comptoir Sud Pacifique Vanille Banane.
    If you love perfume, check out more of my content!
    --This, That, or Both? Playlist
    • This, That, or Both? F...
    --Fragrance Playlist
    www.youtube.co....
    --Fragrance Fridays (on the blog)
    simplyayesha.c....
    PRODUCTS MENTIONED
    L'artisan Parfumeur Bana Banana bit.ly/2SYmOFI
    Comptoir Sud Pacifique Vanille Banane amzn.to/2Rozt47
    Kwailnara Banana Milk Body Lotion bit.ly/3pkWQs0
    Other banana lotions that look promising (I haven't tried)
    --go.magik.ly/ml...
    --bit.ly/3fPPrOe
    --bit.ly/3po6A4y
    WHAT I'M WEARING
    Hair: 16 inch amzn.to/34N8YbT
    Headband: bit.ly/3uW8fzD
    Foundation: Fenty Eaze Drop #15 bit.ly/2SzmQDH
    Bronzer: Iconic London Spiced Tan bit.ly/2Q3ohcF
    Blush: NARS Liquid in Torrid bit.ly/3g4u8qU
    Lipstick: Loreal Framboise Frenzy bit.ly/3z4lxxj
    Nails: Sally Hansen Sugar Poppy bit.ly/2RoysJo
    LINKS YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN
    My Poshmark Closet & Boutique: posh.mk/xQteTd...
    My Amazon Store: www.amazon.com/shop/simplebeautyblog
    My Mercari: www.mercari.co...
    --For $10 off, use my invite: merc.li/gKgWrxVhb
    OTHER PLACES TO FIND ME
    Visit my blog! www.simplyayesh...
    Instagram: simply.ayesha.blog
    **If you are a company that would like me to give an unbiased review of your product, please contact me via email or at the address listed below:
    ayesha@simplyayesha.com
    Simply Ayesha
    5804 Boyette Road #7692
    Wesley Chapel, FL 33545
    Disclosure: All items in this video were purchased by me unless otherwise mentioned in the video. Some links listed may be affiliate links, which means that if you purchase through it, I will earn a small commission. As always, all statements represent my honest opinion!
    #banabanana #vanillebanane #bananaperfume #bananafragrance

Комментарии • 47

  • @ciganyweaverandherperiwink6293
    @ciganyweaverandherperiwink6293 2 года назад +10

    I have both of these and was happy to come across this video to hear your thoughts and share mine in turn. For me, Bana Banana is the superior one. It evokes elegant, creamy, comfortable vintage classics whilst having that fizzy, champagne-like effervescence and the oddball candy note all at the same time. It settles into a surprisingly well-rounded, elegant, creamy and mature fragrance. I headed to Fragrantica to see if anybody else on planet Earth felt the same desperate disappointment as I did after trying Vanille Banane. I was thrilled to see that almost everybody had the same sad complaint: that opening is UNBELIEVABLE, there's nothing else like it, it's genuinely addictive and uplifting. But holy smokes, it says 'hi' and 'bye' in the same sentence. That extraordinary banana note evaporates and the entire thing turns into the cheap, basic supermarket toiletries kind of vanilla. Once that unusual, special note leaves the show, I'm left with an old vanilla Little Tree that I found under the front seat of the car. All of us wanted this fragrance to live up to its promise and the reason we all whine and give it low ratings is because it hurt us with this performance: nobody needs another crappy vanilla fragrance! It's all about the banana, that's why we all bought it!! I'm almost angry about how close Comptoire Sud Pacifique came to creating a classic and how lazy they were, failing us all.😢👎

    • @Bluedoll28
      @Bluedoll28 2 года назад

      Anybody that’s finds joy in someone else’s pain needs therapy. These fragrances are beautiful and remind me of all the kind smells.

  • @Ai_TheGreat
    @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +4

    I saw Banana and clicked Hella fast. I love both of these. Can't wait to hear your thoughts

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад

      😆 I can’t wait to see if you agree with me!

  • @Bluedoll28
    @Bluedoll28 2 года назад +2

    Your ring is gorgeous!! 🤩 💎 💕

  • @San-ui9cr
    @San-ui9cr 3 года назад +4

    First, can we talk about how beautiful you look! I'm starting to get into fragrances and love this review. I also love the support of my YT faves in the comment section. Queens supporting each other!

  • @PaolaBianka
    @PaolaBianka 3 года назад +3

    I am more drawn to Vanille Banane based on the notes and scent profile.. been wanting to try that for soooooo long ! 😁 but i do know that The one from L’Artisan Parfumer is beautiful too.. i can imagine how beautiful a floral banana is 🍌

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад +1

      They are both so beautiful and fun!

    • @ciganyweaverandherperiwink6293
      @ciganyweaverandherperiwink6293 2 года назад

      Oh Paola, get back to me when that magnificent banana 'hook note' in Vanille Banana evaporates after 30 seconds and you start the period of mourning. I will provide some 'cyber tissues' here online as I console you in your terrible disappointment. ;D If there were some way for Comptoir Sud Pacifique to incorporate that UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS AND UNUSUAL first 'hook note' into the main scaffolding between top and heart notes then it would be the superior banana fragrance, no question. As it stands, once the actual banana has evaporated cruelly the fragrance just remains as a very dusty, dry, ordinary 'supermarket vanilla' body spray in vibe. It reminds me of those dangling cardboard air fresheners that people have in their cars, the Little Trees. The attempted seduction by deploying that amost weaponised note (the delicious alluring banana note, you'll know it when you smell it) is part of rather mean trick, boo! WHERE'S THE BANANA IN BANANE VANILLE?!
      With all this taken into consideration and if it were a showdown, an 'either or' situation, then my vote goes to Celline Elena's kooky but surprisingly elegant, well rounded and creamy 'Bana Banana' for L'Artisan Parfumer. It kind of reminds me of slightly unripe plantains mixed with expensive hotels, ice cream and those foam banana sweets. It also reminds me of YSL's 'Yvresse' for some reason. There's a mild echo of past effervessence, like champagne and bon bons. I was lucky to buy it when it was on sale on the brand's website. I'd love to know which one you ended up liking the most and why. xo :)

  • @1eaglefan960
    @1eaglefan960 3 года назад +4

    Great video! Best of Luck getting to 10K! With all the hard work & content you bring to the videos, you absolutely deserve it!

  • @ChiChicScents
    @ChiChicScents 3 года назад +2

    I love that banana lotion! It smells just like the banana Laffy Taffy candy

  • @KeikoBeauty
    @KeikoBeauty 3 года назад +2

    Ooh interesting! I’m not really a fan of bananas, but I may be one day! Always here for the support boo ❤️❤️🤩

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад

      Thank you for always showing luv! I don’t eat bananas, but I love the smell of banana scented stuff.

  • @lifeonabudget8513
    @lifeonabudget8513 3 года назад +2

    I have 3 comptoir sud pacifique scents and while they all smell yummy, they don't last. That's eau de toilette for ya. I have been eyeing Bana Banana.

  • @jkayeworld650
    @jkayeworld650 3 года назад +1

    Always interested in hearing about a fruity fragrance! And congratulations on 10, 000 milestone 🤗! Thanks for sharing 🤗👜🛍️👛.

  • @Naturallyliz41
    @Naturallyliz41 3 года назад +2

    This was a great review. I’ve been eyeing Vanille Banan. Lush has a banana lotion I’ve been wanting to try.

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад +1

      Ooh, I hadn’t heard of that one. I used to really love Lush products, but I haven’t been there in forever!

    • @Naturallyliz41
      @Naturallyliz41 3 года назад

      @@SimplyAyesha I believe it’s called Symphony For The Skin if you’re interested.

    • @Naturallyliz41
      @Naturallyliz41 3 года назад

      I ordered this last night fingers crossed 🤞

  • @jujuzeeD
    @jujuzeeD 3 года назад

    You have educated me on Banana fragrances, which is totally new to me. This review covered important details to decide on these products. I would take your advice and get the least expensive perfume. Good luck reaching 10K subscribers.

  • @nikamarks4u
    @nikamarks4u 3 года назад +1

    I love banana scent

  • @tonyafelice4908
    @tonyafelice4908 3 года назад

    Great Video! I love these series for sure.

  • @tonyafelice4908
    @tonyafelice4908 3 года назад

    I love Bana Banana 🍌. I need to try the other one you mentioned as well.

  • @Simplytracy2
    @Simplytracy2 3 года назад

    I purchased that same banana 🍌 lotion from Marshall’s last week for $5.99 . I had never smelled a banana lotion or fragrance before then. I like the lotion, now I am looking for a banana cream. TFS 💞🍌💞🍌

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад

      I kinda want to go look for another, but I know it will take me forever to get through the one I have.

  • @missie49
    @missie49 3 года назад +1

    Posie has a scent called Arctic Monkeys that is Banana Violet scent and it is AMAZING!

  • @carolynhamilton5098
    @carolynhamilton5098 3 года назад

    I'm curious about a 🍌 scent. I need to get a sample. Thanks 4 sharing💕...lovin your colours💚💚

  • @annes5795
    @annes5795 Год назад

    Ooh like to get vanille banana,but i cant offer it anywhere to my Country.Take care

  • @Bluedoll28
    @Bluedoll28 2 года назад

    Hunny, you’re so pretty. Thank you for sharing 🙏

  • @LKauf279
    @LKauf279 Год назад

    I want to try both, but I think I'm going to start off with Sud samples, not full sizes!

  • @NatalieDavis
    @NatalieDavis 3 года назад

    Love ur videos girl!! Like,likeeee❤️

  • @Spicylooks
    @Spicylooks 3 года назад +1

    Hey girl

  • @Ai_TheGreat
    @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +2

    I saw BiG Beard talking about Vanille Banan the other day. I was actually shocked. In my opinion Bana Banana smells more unisex than Vanille Banan. However I didn't want my man smelling like either of them 🤣🤣😂

    • @SimplyAyesha
      @SimplyAyesha  3 года назад +1

      😂 I saw that video too and it made me want to smell it on a man, just not my man. 😂

    • @Ai_TheGreat
      @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад

      @@SimplyAyesha 🤣🤣😂😂 💯‼️

  • @Ai_TheGreat
    @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +1

    I agree Vanille Banan smells like a juicy sweet Laffy taffy or a now and later. Now I want a banana candy😩

    • @Naturallyliz41
      @Naturallyliz41 3 года назад

      Hey AI. Did you click on her banana lotion links? I believe the first one is your beloved Banana Body Cream from the Bodyshop on Fragrancenet for $11

    • @Ai_TheGreat
      @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +1

      @@Naturallyliz41 heeeey Bella no I didn't. I have back ups and should be good for the next 2 summers on banana creams

  • @Ai_TheGreat
    @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +1

    🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌

  • @Ai_TheGreat
    @Ai_TheGreat 3 года назад +1

    First