My List: 13: Slither (0/10) 12: Attitude (2.5/10) 11: Better Than You (4/10) 10: Carpe Diem Baby (4/10) 9: Prince Charming (4.5/10) 8: Bad Seed (5/10) 7: Low Man’s Lyric (6/10) 6: Devil’s Dance (7.5/10) 5: Fixxxer (8/10) 4: The Memory Remains (8/10) 3: Fuel (9/10) 2: The Unforgiven II (9.5/10) 1: Where The Wild Things Are (10/10)
My list: The Memory Remains (1/10) Low Man’s Lyric (3/10) Slither (3/10) Better Than You (5/10) Devil’s Dance (6/10) Carpe Diem Baby (7/10) Prince Charming (7/10) The Unforgiven II (7/10) Fixxxer (8/10) Attitude (9/10) Where The Wild Things Are (9/10) Bad Seed (10/10) Fuel (10/10)
We ALMOST have the same list! My List: 13 Better Than You 12 Slither 11 Attitude 10 Memory Remains 09 Bad Seed 08 Unforgiven II 07 Fuel 06 Devil's Dance 05 Carpe Diem Baby 04 Prince Charming 03 Low Man's Lyric 02 Fixxxer 01 Where The Wild Things Are
My list: 13. Better Than You (3/10) Boring, plain and bad. 12. Slither (4.5/10) Not THAT bad honestly. 11. Attitude (5.5/10) Sometimes sounds cool, sometimes sounds like a part 2 of better than you. 10. Low Man’s Lyric (6/10) So angry that there’s not a solo. The song sounds plain with the same structure repeated 3 times. Good riffs but so boring. 9. Carpe Diem Baby (7/10) Overhated: no reason to hate this because it’s honestly fun. It drags at times, the reason why the rating is 7. 8. Devil’s Dance (7.5/10) I didn’t like this one but it grew on me. God bass and fun song. Meh lyrics. 7. Fixxxer (7.5/10) Overrated as f, I don’t get the hype on this one, is so mid… outlaw torn is 2000 times better. 6. The Memory Remains (7.5/10) So fun and live is amazing. I don’t like that part, you know it. 5. The Unforgiven II (8/10) Another overrated song. In my opinion is just good, not that epic or amazing. The “worst” of the trilogy. 4. Bad Seed (8/10) Another overhated song. Cmon, this is fun and honestly pretty good also. 3. Prince Charming (10/10) After the intro, the song is soooo good, fun lyrics and energetic song. I like it so much. 2. Fuel (10/10) Imo is incredible that this isn’t the best of the album: this was so good that I could think in something better. 1. Where The Wild Things Are (10/10) FINALLY SOMEONE WHO APPRECIATE THIS! I swear that the chorus send me crazy every time. But looking at the comments this is not so underrated, everyone seems to like it. Good! After all, a good album. It’s worse than load, which in my opinion has something of the worst of Metallica but the best songs from that album are just miles ahead of wtwta.
My list: 13) Slither 1/10 12) Better Than You 3.5/10 11) Prince Charming 5/10 10) Carpe Diem Baby 6/10 9) Attitude 7/10 8) Bad Seed 7.5/10 7) The Memory Remains 8/10 6) Devil's Dance 9/10 5) Low Man's Lyric 10/10 4) Where The Wild Things Are 10/10 3) The Unforgiven II 10/10 2) Fixxxer 10/10 1) Fuel 10/10
Mine: 13 - Slither (2/10, too lazy to enjoy) 12 - Better Than You (2.1/10, some riffs are cool but wasted for this incomprehensible song) 11 - Attitude (6.3/10, finally an enjoyable song) 10 - Low Man's Lyric (6.5/10, this is worse than Mama Said imo) 9 - The Memory Remains (6.8/10, I can give 9.5/10 for live versions such as S&M2) 8 - Carpe Diem Baby (6.9/10, nice song just not for my taste) 7 - Bad Seed (7.2/10, such a funny one) 6 - Where the Wild Things Are (7.8/10, the same reason as Carpe Diem Baby) 5 - Devil's Dance (8.1/10, probably the heaviest track from Reload) 4 - Fuel (9.8/10, so powerful and energetic. if a song is overrated, that means it is nice for general ppl so I have recommended this to my friends who have only listened to pop) 3 - Prince Charming (10/10, Fuel with more energy imo. I love the last solo) 2 - Fixxxer (10/10, I don't care about the length and the main riff is heavy af) 1 - The Unforgiven II (10/10, my favourite ballad)
I do disagree on some of these choices, my list. 13. Low Man's Lyric It's a great song, one of Metallicas best slow songs, I just don't like the meaning of the song, makes you feel down. 12. Better Than You Not a lot to say about this one, it is certainly one of their songs 11. The Memory Remains Good song I'd just rather listen to the other songs 10. Attitude Like Better Than You but it's just a bit better 9. Slither It's catchy 8. The Unforgiven II It's a good song, not a lot to say about it 7. Fixxxer Like The Unforgiven II but a bit better 6. Fuel Fun song, fast and overall pretty good 5. Carpe Diem Baby Fun and catchy 4. Devil's Dance Hella groovy intro, love it 3. Where The Wild Things Are Just a great song overall 2. Prince Charming Great song, fast, catchy and overall just great 1. Bad Seed Just a great song overall, top 10 Metallica songs imo, love the intro
I'm new to Metallica. I already have listened to Reload and reviewed the album. But my opinion might change over time: 13. Slither (1/10) (disgusting song) 12. Attitude (3/10) (Better Than You 2.0) 11. The Memory Remains (3/10) (not well written and Marianne Faithful's vocals feel so out of place. The song would probably have been better without her collaboration). 10. Bad Seed (4/10) (over the top) 9. Better Than You (5/10) (don't mind it too much. Yes, there are some bad parts but there are also great parts). 8. Carpe Diem Baby (5/10) (kinda boring) 7. Where The Wild Things Are (5/10) (pretty good parts but the chorus is lame. I don't like the lyrics "All children touch the sun. Burn fingers one by one". At least the song is really catchy). 6. Fixxxer (6/10) (not bad but it's too long) 5. The Unforgiven II (7/10) (not bad but the original Unforgiven is the best) 4. Devil's Dance (8/10) (Don't know what to say. I just like it) 3. Prince Charming (9/10) (not great lyrics but the song is fun and makes me headbang) 2. Low Man's Lyric (9/10) (Beautifully written. Beautiful melody and really nice lyrics) 1. Fuel (10/10) (Easily the best song. Can't explain why tho) Sorry if I criticize too much this album but it's my 2nd least favorite Metallica album. There are many flaws but at least it's not an abomination unlike St. Anger. St. Anger is the only Metallica album I truly dislike.
I can't rank it, but this is my fifth favorite Metallica album. It's cliche but my favorite is Fuel, it's fun, it's straight to the point, incredibly catchy, it's everything I want in a Metallica song. There aren't really any outright awful songs, but my least favorite is The Memory Remains, it's a fine song up until the Marianne Faithfull part which completely ruins the song for me, so cringy. If they just cut out the vocals there and made it an instrumental section, I'd actually like it, just a poor production choice. I didn't realize until fairly recently that that was a woman singing, I just assumed the vocals were from James or someone else in the band, she has a very boy-ish voice lol.
My ranking - 1. Prince Charming (10/10) 2. The Unforgiven II (10/10) 3. Fixxxer (10/10) 4. Bad Seed (10/10) 5. Fuel (10/10) 6. Better Than You (10/10) 7. Slither (10/10) 8. Attitude (10/10) 9. Devil’s Dance (10/10) 10. Where The Wild Things Are (10/10) 11. Carpe Diem Baby (10/10) 12. The Memory Remains (9/10) 13. Low Man’s Lyric (9/10) Moral of my ranking, Slither is underrated. Reload itself is underrated
Cool list! Where The Wild Things Are at Number 1 is a great choice, that song deserves more love. Even though I think Unforgiven II is heavily overrated and Attitude is underrated, this is still a great list! 👍
13: Slither (2.0/10) (2nd Worst Metallica Song I'd say) 12: Attitude (2.5/10) 11: Bad Seed (3.8/10) 10: Where the Wild Things Are (4.5/10) 9: Better than You (5.0/10) 8: Fixxer (5.5/10) 7: Prince Charming (6.9/10) (Now I know what you're thinking) 6: The Memory Remains (7.3/10) 5: Low Man's Lyric (7.6/10) 4: Carpe Diem Baby (7.6/10) 3: Devil's Dance (7.9/10) 2: The Unforgiven II (9.4/10) 1: Fuel (9.6/10) (Even then it barely made it to S Tier) Reload is A decent album, but by Metallica standards its overall a incredibly Mixed bag.
I enjoy Slither's beat, and James did a good job on the verse vocals The intro is awful, that's true, but the rest of the song isn't that bad! nice ranking, I think the same about the other songs
Ok, let’s all be honest. We’re all wait for “The Unforgiven For”.
My List:
13: Slither (0/10)
12: Attitude (2.5/10)
11: Better Than You (4/10)
10: Carpe Diem Baby (4/10)
9: Prince Charming (4.5/10)
8: Bad Seed (5/10)
7: Low Man’s Lyric (6/10)
6: Devil’s Dance (7.5/10)
5: Fixxxer
(8/10)
4: The Memory Remains
(8/10)
3: Fuel (9/10)
2: The Unforgiven II
(9.5/10)
1: Where The Wild Things Are
(10/10)
its so great to see someone who likes where the wild things are
Extremely underrated track.
The "Off the veil, stand revealed, Bring it on, break the seal, At the mercy, cat is out ..... " of Bad Seed give him a 9/10 in my opinion
where the wild things are, fuel, fixxer, devil dance, unforgiven ii and the memory remains the goat
My list:
The Memory Remains (1/10)
Low Man’s Lyric (3/10)
Slither (3/10)
Better Than You (5/10)
Devil’s Dance (6/10)
Carpe Diem Baby (7/10)
Prince Charming (7/10)
The Unforgiven II (7/10)
Fixxxer (8/10)
Attitude (9/10)
Where The Wild Things Are (9/10)
Bad Seed (10/10)
Fuel (10/10)
Prince charming is so nice. My number 2 right after unforgiven2
We ALMOST have the same list! My List:
13 Better Than You
12 Slither
11 Attitude
10 Memory Remains
09 Bad Seed
08 Unforgiven II
07 Fuel
06 Devil's Dance
05 Carpe Diem Baby
04 Prince Charming
03 Low Man's Lyric
02 Fixxxer
01 Where The Wild Things Are
My list:
13. Better Than You (3/10)
Boring, plain and bad.
12. Slither (4.5/10)
Not THAT bad honestly.
11. Attitude (5.5/10)
Sometimes sounds cool, sometimes sounds like a part 2 of better than you.
10. Low Man’s Lyric (6/10)
So angry that there’s not a solo. The song sounds plain with the same structure repeated 3 times. Good riffs but so boring.
9. Carpe Diem Baby (7/10)
Overhated: no reason to hate this because it’s honestly fun. It drags at times, the reason why the rating is 7.
8. Devil’s Dance (7.5/10)
I didn’t like this one but it grew on me. God bass and fun song. Meh lyrics.
7. Fixxxer (7.5/10)
Overrated as f, I don’t get the hype on this one, is so mid… outlaw torn is 2000 times better.
6. The Memory Remains (7.5/10)
So fun and live is amazing. I don’t like that part, you know it.
5. The Unforgiven II (8/10)
Another overrated song. In my opinion is just good, not that epic or amazing. The “worst” of the trilogy.
4. Bad Seed (8/10)
Another overhated song. Cmon, this is fun and honestly pretty good also.
3. Prince Charming (10/10)
After the intro, the song is soooo good, fun lyrics and energetic song. I like it so much.
2. Fuel (10/10)
Imo is incredible that this isn’t the best of the album: this was so good that I could think in something better.
1. Where The Wild Things Are (10/10)
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO APPRECIATE THIS! I swear that the chorus send me crazy every time. But looking at the comments this is not so underrated, everyone seems to like it. Good!
After all, a good album. It’s worse than load, which in my opinion has something of the worst of Metallica but the best songs from that album are just miles ahead of wtwta.
My list:
13) Slither 1/10
12) Better Than You 3.5/10
11) Prince Charming 5/10
10) Carpe Diem Baby 6/10
9) Attitude 7/10
8) Bad Seed 7.5/10
7) The Memory Remains 8/10
6) Devil's Dance 9/10
5) Low Man's Lyric 10/10
4) Where The Wild Things Are 10/10
3) The Unforgiven II 10/10
2) Fixxxer 10/10
1) Fuel 10/10
Mine:
13 - Slither (2/10, too lazy to enjoy)
12 - Better Than You (2.1/10, some riffs are cool but wasted for this incomprehensible song)
11 - Attitude (6.3/10, finally an enjoyable song)
10 - Low Man's Lyric (6.5/10, this is worse than Mama Said imo)
9 - The Memory Remains (6.8/10, I can give 9.5/10 for live versions such as S&M2)
8 - Carpe Diem Baby (6.9/10, nice song just not for my taste)
7 - Bad Seed (7.2/10, such a funny one)
6 - Where the Wild Things Are (7.8/10, the same reason as Carpe Diem Baby)
5 - Devil's Dance (8.1/10, probably the heaviest track from Reload)
4 - Fuel (9.8/10, so powerful and energetic. if a song is overrated, that means it is nice for general ppl so I have recommended this to my friends who have only listened to pop)
3 - Prince Charming (10/10, Fuel with more energy imo. I love the last solo)
2 - Fixxxer (10/10, I don't care about the length and the main riff is heavy af)
1 - The Unforgiven II (10/10, my favourite ballad)
0:43 Lars's face in the background 😂😂😂
I do disagree on some of these choices, my list.
13. Low Man's Lyric
It's a great song, one of Metallicas best slow songs, I just don't like the meaning of the song, makes you feel down.
12. Better Than You
Not a lot to say about this one, it is certainly one of their songs
11. The Memory Remains
Good song I'd just rather listen to the other songs
10. Attitude
Like Better Than You but it's just a bit better
9. Slither
It's catchy
8. The Unforgiven II
It's a good song, not a lot to say about it
7. Fixxxer
Like The Unforgiven II but a bit better
6. Fuel
Fun song, fast and overall pretty good
5. Carpe Diem Baby
Fun and catchy
4. Devil's Dance
Hella groovy intro, love it
3. Where The Wild Things Are
Just a great song overall
2. Prince Charming
Great song, fast, catchy and overall just great
1. Bad Seed
Just a great song overall, top 10 Metallica songs imo, love the intro
I'm new to Metallica. I already have listened to Reload and reviewed the album. But my opinion might change over time:
13. Slither (1/10) (disgusting song)
12. Attitude (3/10) (Better Than You 2.0)
11. The Memory Remains (3/10) (not well written and Marianne Faithful's vocals feel so out of place. The song would probably have been better without her collaboration).
10. Bad Seed (4/10) (over the top)
9. Better Than You (5/10) (don't mind it too much. Yes, there are some bad parts but there are also great parts).
8. Carpe Diem Baby (5/10) (kinda boring)
7. Where The Wild Things Are (5/10) (pretty good parts but the chorus is lame. I don't like the lyrics "All children touch the sun. Burn fingers one by one". At least the song is really catchy).
6. Fixxxer (6/10) (not bad but it's too long)
5. The Unforgiven II (7/10) (not bad but the original Unforgiven is the best)
4. Devil's Dance (8/10) (Don't know what to say. I just like it)
3. Prince Charming (9/10) (not great lyrics but the song is fun and makes me headbang)
2. Low Man's Lyric (9/10) (Beautifully written. Beautiful melody and really nice lyrics)
1. Fuel (10/10) (Easily the best song. Can't explain why tho)
Sorry if I criticize too much this album but it's my 2nd least favorite Metallica album. There are many flaws but at least it's not an abomination unlike St. Anger. St. Anger is the only Metallica album I truly dislike.
Why is everyones hate better than you imo main riff is so cool. There is nothing bad about the song except the lyrics. Over over over overhated song
I really agree with this, I just thing that attitude is way worse than better than you and slither
I can't rank it, but this is my fifth favorite Metallica album. It's cliche but my favorite is Fuel, it's fun, it's straight to the point, incredibly catchy, it's everything I want in a Metallica song.
There aren't really any outright awful songs, but my least favorite is The Memory Remains, it's a fine song up until the Marianne Faithfull part which completely ruins the song for me, so cringy. If they just cut out the vocals there and made it an instrumental section, I'd actually like it, just a poor production choice. I didn't realize until fairly recently that that was a woman singing, I just assumed the vocals were from James or someone else in the band, she has a very boy-ish voice lol.
bad seed riff goes hard
My ranking -
1. Prince Charming (10/10)
2. The Unforgiven II (10/10)
3. Fixxxer (10/10)
4. Bad Seed (10/10)
5. Fuel (10/10)
6. Better Than You (10/10)
7. Slither (10/10)
8. Attitude (10/10)
9. Devil’s Dance (10/10)
10. Where The Wild Things Are (10/10)
11. Carpe Diem Baby (10/10)
12. The Memory Remains (9/10)
13. Low Man’s Lyric (9/10)
Moral of my ranking, Slither is underrated. Reload itself is underrated
finally someone that thinks that prince charming is badass. Such a cool one!
I saw them play Carpe Diem Baby live at Orion Fest in 2013! Probably the biggest curve ball in that set that night! 🤘
Cool list! Where The Wild Things Are at Number 1 is a great choice, that song deserves more love. Even though I think Unforgiven II is heavily overrated and Attitude is underrated, this is still a great list! 👍
Yeah, I remember your ranking and I don't mind it if you don't like Unforgiven II. I used to not like Attitude but now I kind of appreciate it
13: Slither (2.0/10) (2nd Worst Metallica Song I'd say)
12: Attitude (2.5/10)
11: Bad Seed (3.8/10)
10: Where the Wild Things Are (4.5/10)
9: Better than You (5.0/10)
8: Fixxer (5.5/10)
7: Prince Charming (6.9/10) (Now I know what you're thinking)
6: The Memory Remains (7.3/10)
5: Low Man's Lyric (7.6/10)
4: Carpe Diem Baby (7.6/10)
3: Devil's Dance (7.9/10)
2: The Unforgiven II (9.4/10)
1: Fuel (9.6/10) (Even then it barely made it to S Tier)
Reload is A decent album, but by Metallica standards its overall a incredibly Mixed bag.
Fixxxer is my #1
I enjoy Slither's beat, and James did a good job on the verse vocals
The intro is awful, that's true, but the rest of the song isn't that bad!
nice ranking, I think the same about the other songs
Tbh I liked Better than you and Attitude alot more.
Wow!😬😬😱
I can see why, they have some great parts
@@vinceyrankings Yesss but overall your ranking was pretty solid
Fuel is overrated but the memory remains isn’t
Strange thing about this album:İt has very very good songs and it has some one of the worst garbages that they do in this album.
DONT LET BRO COOK
Wheres 2x4
That's from Load
Couldn't sit through your video, sorry.