Stockwell II definitely won this comparison. But the Emberton is what I can afford lol. I guess it's all about personal preference, I bought the Emberton as a replacement speaker because I broke my old one. If I were younger, I'd definitely go beyond my means to get the Stockwell II and listen to all the loud songs I used to listen to. I listen more on ambient sounds and frequency music, y'know, mind alignment things lol. Both speakers are awesome as their own. The 20 hours playback is also a plus so I can stay focus on day, and use it for a peaceful sleep at night.
Great review. I agree you need the bass to balance the sound more. The coolest throwaway feature is the sound on the on/off button - it's a nice touch.
@@alanrossreviews yep the job time. My next buy is second motion boom and btw u made my buy it. 😜 Edit: actually u made my buy my first motion + and motion boom but my parents really liked motion + so i sold it to them for 50$ 👍
tracks: 4:34 Vinsmoker & Marin Hoxha - Touch Me Again (feat. CRÈME) 7:08 Szaby & Robbie Rosen - Thin Ice 10:23 Ruby Amanfu - I Miss You 13:56 Tiny Kingdoms - All I Know
Fun tip: scroll through playlist at speed to see an Alan rainbow 🌈! I've just clocked your array of t-shirt colours after watching your amazing mattress reviews, Alan merch please!!❤🧡💛💚💙💜
Great detailed video man, helped me make my decision 🙏🏾 Interesting though at 1:04 you call them Full range drivers on the Stockwell 2, thought maybe it would’ve been considered a “tweeter” because (maybe, but I’m not too sure) most of the frequency range would’ve been coming from the woofer?? Keep it up the great work man!!!
@@alanrossreviews Ah thanks man, that makes perfect sense!!! Just subbed to you my man. Watch a couple of your videos, and really liked how you break compare speakers, and break down and analyze the the differences of speakers 🙏🏽
I would take the Stockwell 2 all day over the Emberton, as well. I'd even take my 2 boosts over the Emberton and have money to spare. 😝 The Emberton isn't a terrible speaker but for the price and versus the competition it just doesn't hold up for what it offers imho. Outstanding job as always, Alan. 👏👍😁
Hello! Thank you for this comparison and that you actually displayed the graphs with dB-freq! What I felt was that with Emberton, I feel like I am being robbed of the mids. I don’t care about the base as much as with the mid and high accuracy. And in that conparison, I feel like I get more nuances out of Stockwell.
I guess the problem is that when googling for best wireless portable speakers, there is a bloat of lazy advertisement pages with vague tests and comparisons, many not even having phisycally tested devices, just compiled claims from manufacturers’ websites. So if I want to buy one, it is all emotional appeal. In this review I heard the actual differences, and meaaurement results. Thanks! And in my region, these speakers are only available in e-shops, not in retail shops, so I cannot go and test them in real life. Just buy and pray that they are good. After this review, I am certain that for me, Stockwell is a more suitable option.
i care more about sound quality than loudness....who listens to music or anything at full up volume? i dont think ive ever owned any speakers that sound good at full volume.... its definitely about quality and not quantity for me.... so which one wins on quality? i just got my stockwell 2 a day ago...and am having probs with the usb ports going on and off intermittently but it charges fine...its just so annoying the windows sound of it going on and off as though i was unplugging it repeatedly...anyone else have that problem? ive submitted a return claim via amazon...should i get a replacement? is the speaker even defective? i cant find the answers online...took 10 days to get and now im hesitant of getting the emberton 2 which i also want...what to do??? thanks for any help that can be offered here!!! sincerely ,Dan.
Great video thanks 😋 i properly wont react to your videos from tomorrow till 8-8 as im on holiday then😎 will have to watch a bunch of video's i guess after🤔 but you should also take a break!
Hi Alan - thank you for the great upload!! Wondering if you have any future plans to review the ION Audio Total PA Glow Max, or if you have any thoughts on it? It has a 3 band Equalizer & am curious to know if you have any advice on best custom settings for a 3 band EQ for a larger speaker like this. Cheers!
Just for fun, can you do a Gravastar Mars vs Promate Invader episode? 👽 I think you'd be the only reviewer here who'd be capable and credible enough to pull off such a showdown. ✊🏼😁 Keep safe!
thanks for your videos they really helpead me to have a better view of the speakers, what are your thoughts about the VIFA OSLO, could you do a comparison of the marshall stockwell2 and the OSLO, saying hello from Mexico .
What is the best Speaker with AC Input up to 120€?! The battery life of my Soundcore Motion Plus is terrible when I'm at Work.At 80-90% loudness i maybe get only 1,5 hours and i need it this loud becaus of all of the Machines around me
Hello. Do you think two jbl Charge 5 is a better option vs two weiking D8? in term of overall bass, sound quality, stereo image, naturalness? For use in pair for stereo. I could get an instant refund from the store for weiking d8 and i wonder its a better option 2 jbl charge 5. (i bought a pair of weiking d 8 at 90 euros, and the cheapest jbl charge 5 i found is 120euros per piece).Does it worth to do that? thank you.
may i know the reason why the bass is set to 8 while 3 for the treble? i have the stockwell 2 btw , having the hard time setting for the treble and bass
@@alanrossreviews thanks man. I was planning for Stockwell too. But thought it was a bit old. Also compared to Bose soundlink flex, B&O BeoSound play and Stockwell 2, would you still recommend it?. I am getting all of these in similar range. Or would you recommend something else under 150 bucks. I am lookinh for a good full sounding portable Bluetooth speaker. Thanks again
@@alanrossreviews Thanks Alan. The only deal I could find was on the stockwell and that's why I was tempted to buy it. Tho if you have any suggestions, that would be great. PS: Really enjoy your detailed reviews :)
Alan Ross Reviews Top Picks: Pound for pound world champion: Soundcore Motion Boom: geni.us/motionboom Amazingly deep bass to 40hz for its size and price. Still worth a look: My former world champ the Soundcore Motion Plus can still offer great clarity. geni.us/soundcoremotionplus £50 champion: Soundcore Boost: geni.us/soundcoreboost Hi End Pick: Minirig mk3 2.2 system: geni.us/minirigmk3 Great for portable low deep kick: Onyx Studio 6: geni.us/onyxstudio6 Best Micro Options: Bose Soundlink Micro (warm): geni.us/bosesoundlinkmicro Tribit Stormbox Micxro (clinical): geni.us/tribitstormboxmicro Worth a Look: W-King T9: geni.us/wkingt9 The T9 is a reasonably loud and balanced party speaker with a big bright detailed sound. Budget Loud Boombox: no clear winner but my pick for fun outside listen would be: W-King X10 geni.us/wkingx10 Travel Speakers: Marshall Stockwell 2: geni.us/stockwell2 offers a decent immersive sound with full and tight bass. Beware though it does not go very loud JBL Charge 5: geni.us/jblcharge5 Only mono but has a very clear and dynamic sound at low volumes and can go reasonably loud but will become a little screechy over 80%.
@@gus6391 2 motion Booms (1 is solid, but depending on how loud you want to go outside, I recommend pairing 2) W-King D8, W-King D9 or X-10, JBL Extreme 3, JBL Boombox 2 (very hefty and the biggest of them all. Portable, but a big hassle) Sony XB43, Neo Core Wave A4. Now all of these can go pretty loud, but all have different things they excel in. It’s just up to you what your taste is upper base, deep base, mids, treble, big soundstage, narrow soundstage etc.
Love the wig… 😜 I’m not so sure about these speakers as I listen at moderate volumes not really that low… hmmm… 🤔 Did you see Floss reviewing the Motion+? 🤣
Yes, Floss is a legend. He's just got round to agreeing with us lot that the motion plus is a fantastic speaker for the cash. Wait till he hears the Boom. His complaint of lack of bass is totally compounded with his custom EQ curve pushing the high bass and not the lower frequencies. To say that the flip 5 beats it is folly!
@@TheBootruss I love the Motion+ when mine works, but the Boom brings the bass… maybe not as much as my Exos 9…. But for something portable it’s great! 😊
@@alanrossreviews respect your opinion, but I don’t like the muffled sound, and again, the buttons missing on the stockwell made me stick with the Emberton
@@alanrossreviews I did have an emberton the max volume is like the most annoying thing.Most of the tracks seems very loud without any base, disappointed with emberton.
Hi. Please tell me..... for stereo image, detail, clarity, rich sound, which portable speakers you recomand? For indoor use, i have 2 Wking D8 and sounds good, is something better than this? my budget is 350-400$. I want hi-fi flavor, emotional listening, feeling😊
It worries me that you describe the holy grail of hifi but are happy with the d8. Spending more will either gain massive bass or a more hifi listen, i question which would suit you more.
Marshall Stockwell 2: geni.us/stockwell2
Marshall Emberton: geni.us/emberton
#AmazonCommissionsEarned
Got my Marshall Emberton for £103 when there £130 everywhere else
Chapters
0:00 intro
1:51 specs
4:34 45% sound test
7:08 65% sound comparison
8:38 65% frequency analysis
10:23 80% test
13:56 100% maximum loudness test
15:31 100% frequency analysis
16:19 conclusion
This is such a fascinating comparison that few others (if any) will likely do. I was SHOCKED at the 100% volume test how different it is.
like chalk and cheese!
I finally found a good review about Marshall Emberton & Stockwell, with tech data etc.Thanks.
No problem 😊
Stockwell II definitely won this comparison. But the Emberton is what I can afford lol. I guess it's all about personal preference, I bought the Emberton as a replacement speaker because I broke my old one. If I were younger, I'd definitely go beyond my means to get the Stockwell II and listen to all the loud songs I used to listen to. I listen more on ambient sounds and frequency music, y'know, mind alignment things lol. Both speakers are awesome as their own. The 20 hours playback is also a plus so I can stay focus on day, and use it for a peaceful sleep at night.
What a great comparison! We would love to see more of such quality videos from you. And I will definitely go for stockwell 2.
Thank you 👍
Great review. I agree you need the bass to balance the sound more. The coolest throwaway feature is the sound on the on/off button - it's a nice touch.
Soo happy im listening to this vid on my new hd560s! I bought them my self and that's actually big for me lol.
woohoo welcome to the big time 🤗
@@alanrossreviews yep the job time. My next buy is second motion boom and btw u made my buy it. 😜 Edit: actually u made my buy my first motion + and motion boom but my parents really liked motion + so i sold it to them for 50$ 👍
looks like we are on a roll 🤗🤗
@@alanrossreviews or I'm just adducted to anker (bought life q30 too but then sold them for more) 😁
another facinating ALAN ROSS LAB REVIEW!! i think the little marshall is neat looking. like my big guitar stack head..
It looks good but becomes ear piercing as you push the volume. Better options out there. But yeah for musicans they love it looks like an amp 😊
Thank you! Great tests
tracks:
4:34 Vinsmoker & Marin Hoxha - Touch Me Again (feat. CRÈME)
7:08 Szaby & Robbie Rosen - Thin Ice
10:23 Ruby Amanfu - I Miss You
13:56 Tiny Kingdoms - All I Know
perfect review/comparison. great work
Thank you 👍
Fun tip: scroll through playlist at speed to see an Alan rainbow 🌈! I've just clocked your array of t-shirt colours after watching your amazing mattress reviews, Alan merch please!!❤🧡💛💚💙💜
Great idea!! i just tried this myself and it really works 👍👍😁
This is very helpful and insightful! Thank you for this review!
Thanks for watching!
Great detailed video man, helped me make my decision 🙏🏾
Interesting though at 1:04 you call them Full range drivers on the Stockwell 2, thought maybe it would’ve been considered a “tweeter” because (maybe, but I’m not too sure) most of the frequency range would’ve been coming from the woofer??
Keep it up the great work man!!!
Full range as in no crossover and getting the whole frequency range. Of course all drivers have their own roll offs.
@@alanrossreviews Ah thanks man, that makes perfect sense!!!
Just subbed to you my man. Watch a couple of your videos, and really liked how you break compare speakers, and break down and analyze the the differences of speakers 🙏🏽
Welcome aboard 😁😁👍
Listening this on my Onyx Studio 7 haha (that I got for 180€ btw, crazy value), I prefer the Stockwell 👍
Shout out to your mum 😋
😝😝😝
I prefer the marshal 🤪
Another Alan Ross video??? Today is a good day
hope you had your milk 😛😛
@@alanrossreviews Had some for this video 🤪
I would take the Stockwell 2 all day over the Emberton, as well. I'd even take my 2 boosts over the Emberton and have money to spare. 😝 The Emberton isn't a terrible speaker but for the price and versus the competition it just doesn't hold up for what it offers imho. Outstanding job as always, Alan. 👏👍😁
yeah me too! #metoo but emberton really the travel friendly one here
Hello! Thank you for this comparison and that you actually displayed the graphs with dB-freq! What I felt was that with Emberton, I feel like I am being robbed of the mids. I don’t care about the base as much as with the mid and high accuracy. And in that conparison, I feel like I get more nuances out of Stockwell.
I guess the problem is that when googling for best wireless portable speakers, there is a bloat of lazy advertisement pages with vague tests and comparisons, many not even having phisycally tested devices, just compiled claims from manufacturers’ websites. So if I want to buy one, it is all emotional appeal. In this review I heard the actual differences, and meaaurement results. Thanks! And in my region, these speakers are only available in e-shops, not in retail shops, so I cannot go and test them in real life. Just buy and pray that they are good. After this review, I am certain that for me, Stockwell is a more suitable option.
the stockwell 2 is the hidden gem from marshal, none of the others i heard have the same magic imho
Very good and technical review!
thank you 🙏
Still going with the stockwell
I wanted to buy the SW 2 before but heard some reviews that some songs doesn't sound right on it and it lacks volume.
yes if you listen very analytically, but it brings enough to the table for me to be an enjoyable listen just cant party to it.
@@alanrossreviews 🤔 👌 whatever you say.. You are my bt speaker GURU. 😊 😁
18:09 Bass... no bass. All I need to know thanks.
i care more about sound quality than loudness....who listens to music or anything at full up volume? i dont think ive ever owned any speakers that sound good at full volume.... its definitely about quality and not quantity for me.... so which one wins on quality? i just got my stockwell 2 a day ago...and am having probs with the usb ports going on and off intermittently but it charges fine...its just so annoying the windows sound of it going on and off as though i was unplugging it repeatedly...anyone else have that problem? ive submitted a return claim via amazon...should i get a replacement? is the speaker even defective? i cant find the answers online...took 10 days to get and now im hesitant of getting the emberton 2 which i also want...what to do??? thanks for any help that can be offered here!!! sincerely ,Dan.
Great video thanks 😋 i properly wont react to your videos from tomorrow till 8-8 as im on holiday then😎 will have to watch a bunch of video's i guess after🤔 but you should also take a break!
Funny you said that cause issues here might force me to., 😭😭
@@alanrossreviews why? What is going on?
aggravation 😂😂
Nice Mötley Crüe look! 😂Who would ever listen to Emberton at max volume !?!?!? It is CACOPHONY altogether !!!!!
I bet you play scrabble a lot 😁😁
@@alanrossreviews i'm definitely good at it😉
I send back W-king d8 and i kept JBL go 3 and W-king T8 ( very good, natural sound with subwoofer bass).
Hi Alan - thank you for the great upload!!
Wondering if you have any future plans to review the ION Audio Total PA Glow Max, or if you have any thoughts on it? It has a 3 band Equalizer & am curious to know if you have any advice on best custom settings for a 3 band EQ for a larger speaker like this.
Cheers!
What does 70 on the Emberton equal to on the Stockwell if you volume matched?
not sure if you set them to exact in terms of lufs, not much in it.
Can you do a review of whole portable speakers line up from marshall
I want to know how tufton sounds next to emberton
I only ever liked the stockwell 2
Sir I’m torn between stockwell 2 and uxbridge. Really need an advice for this. Thanks in advance ❤
Just for fun, can you do a Gravastar Mars vs Promate Invader episode? 👽 I think you'd be the only reviewer here who'd be capable and credible enough to pull off such a showdown. ✊🏼😁 Keep safe!
very informative and lifelike
thanks for your videos they really helpead me to have a better view of the speakers, what are your thoughts about the VIFA OSLO, could you do a comparison of the marshall stockwell2 and the OSLO, saying hello from Mexico .
oslo will be much beefier but more mono
What is the best Speaker with AC Input up to 120€?! The battery life of my Soundcore Motion Plus is terrible when I'm at Work.At 80-90% loudness i maybe get only 1,5 hours and i need it this loud becaus of all of the Machines around me
Hello. Do you think two jbl Charge 5 is a better option vs two weiking D8? in term of overall bass, sound quality, stereo image, naturalness? For use in pair for stereo. I could get an instant refund from the store for weiking d8 and i wonder its a better option 2 jbl charge 5. (i bought a pair of weiking d 8 at 90 euros, and the cheapest jbl charge 5 i found is 120euros per piece).Does it worth to do that? thank you.
Do both of these support hifi music, Alan?
huh? do you mean hd?
@@alanrossreviews yeah i mean HiRes Music
my stockwell supports aptx but others and official specs say there stockwell only supports aptx
@@alanrossreviews Hi Sir Alan! How do you check with an android phone if the the stockwell is aptx? Thank you!
Anker soundcore boost upgraded is the WİNNER! Ho Ho Ho ⭐🥳
🤓🤓
may i know the reason why the bass is set to 8 while 3 for the treble? i have the stockwell 2 btw , having the hard time setting for the treble and bass
Just my preference
You're the best my friend. Ray usa
st2 for me👌🏻
of course, a screechfest will never do 😁
@@alanrossreviews 👍🏻
Would you still recommend this or emberton 2?
stockwell
@@alanrossreviews thanks man.
I was planning for Stockwell too. But thought it was a bit old. Also compared to Bose soundlink flex, B&O BeoSound play and Stockwell 2, would you still recommend it?. I am getting all of these in similar range.
Or would you recommend something else under 150 bucks. I am lookinh for a good full sounding portable Bluetooth speaker. Thanks again
@@Akshat1ahuja well sometimes you can get a blast for that money if you can find a deal.
@@alanrossreviews Thanks Alan. The only deal I could find was on the stockwell and that's why I was tempted to buy it. Tho if you have any suggestions, that would be great.
PS: Really enjoy your detailed reviews :)
The Acton II is my favorite one out of the bunch.
but its not portable.
I prefer Stanmore II
Alan Ross Reviews Top Picks:
Pound for pound world champion:
Soundcore Motion Boom: geni.us/motionboom
Amazingly deep bass to 40hz for its size and price.
Still worth a look:
My former world champ the Soundcore Motion Plus can still offer great clarity.
geni.us/soundcoremotionplus
£50 champion:
Soundcore Boost: geni.us/soundcoreboost
Hi End Pick:
Minirig mk3 2.2 system: geni.us/minirigmk3
Great for portable low deep kick:
Onyx Studio 6: geni.us/onyxstudio6
Best Micro Options:
Bose Soundlink Micro (warm): geni.us/bosesoundlinkmicro
Tribit Stormbox Micxro (clinical): geni.us/tribitstormboxmicro
Worth a Look:
W-King T9: geni.us/wkingt9
The T9 is a reasonably loud and balanced party speaker with a big bright detailed sound.
Budget Loud Boombox: no clear winner but my pick for fun outside listen would be:
W-King X10 geni.us/wkingx10
Travel Speakers:
Marshall Stockwell 2: geni.us/stockwell2
offers a decent immersive sound with full and tight bass. Beware though it does not go very loud
JBL Charge 5: geni.us/jblcharge5
Only mono but has a very clear and dynamic sound at low volumes and can go reasonably loud but will become a little screechy over 80%.
thanks, Alan!
@@halcb my top picks are in the description of every video 📹
Is your new hair a speaker also?
only if you're nice to to it 😆
@@alanrossreviews 😁🐶
Having issue with stockwell 2 while connecting to my macbook. Any suggestions?
dont touch apple, sorry.
Ooh but is it better than the motion + 🤔jk lol
😲😲 i guess you mean the stockwell? ruclips.net/video/HBky_51Uq_g/видео.html
Hi I’m looking for a new Bluetooth speaker to go outside with what’s loud and enjoyable any recommendations ??
Portable or no?
@@thatboyneedssomemilkholemd817 portable
@@gus6391 2 motion Booms (1 is solid, but depending on how loud you want to go outside, I recommend pairing 2) W-King D8, W-King D9 or X-10, JBL Extreme 3, JBL Boombox 2 (very hefty and the biggest of them all. Portable, but a big hassle) Sony XB43, Neo Core Wave A4.
Now all of these can go pretty loud, but all have different things they excel in. It’s just up to you what your taste is upper base, deep base, mids, treble, big soundstage, narrow soundstage etc.
Only a few Stockwell 2 got aptX, but I doubt you can tell the difference!
depends what tracks you play, its not just about the bitrate
If you had to choose only one bluetooth speaker, what would it be? Thanks for your views.
At what budget and what taste. Im happy enough with the motion boom but its not great for clarity
@@alanrossreviews thank so much bro
Cool
👍🏻👍🏻
👍👍👍
I don't know why but i don't like marshall's bt speakers so far...
Too harsh for me i think...
Ye, same for me
the emberton is harsh, i wouldnt really say that about the stockwell.
Alan please compare them with motion plus and motion boom
i did that already for the stockwell
@@alanrossreviews then please compare with motion plus
😁 Little late for marshall emberton 😁
I just do what im interested in knowing, 😁
@@alanrossreviews ow, yes, i mean it late because you have to call the emberton twice, then it came 😁
ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh 😭😭😭😭😭😭
u had the base high and treble low
Wot?
Love the wig… 😜 I’m not so sure about these speakers as I listen at moderate volumes not really that low… hmmm… 🤔 Did you see Floss reviewing the Motion+? 🤣
not yet but im hearing about it! he is a train blazer huh? 😲
@@alanrossreviews He used a knife to try open the back 🤦🏼♀️ Only the newest tech for our Floss 🤣
Yes, Floss is a legend. He's just got round to agreeing with us lot that the motion plus is a fantastic speaker for the cash. Wait till he hears the Boom. His complaint of lack of bass is totally compounded with his custom EQ curve pushing the high bass and not the lower frequencies. To say that the flip 5 beats it is folly!
@@TheBootruss I love the Motion+ when mine works, but the Boom brings the bass… maybe not as much as my Exos 9…. But for something portable it’s great! 😊
social
Twitter twitter.com/alan_ross_4u
Facebook: facebook.com/alanrossreviews
TikTok: vm.tiktok.com/ZSCkH2Fk/
Nawwww the stockwell sounds muffled half the time, plus it has no buttons. Emberton all the way
i would strongly disagree.
@@alanrossreviews respect your opinion, but I don’t like the muffled sound, and again, the buttons missing on the stockwell made me stick with the Emberton
@@alanrossreviews I did have an emberton the max volume is like the most annoying thing.Most of the tracks seems very loud without any base, disappointed with emberton.
Hi. Please tell me..... for stereo image, detail, clarity, rich sound, which portable speakers you recomand? For indoor use, i have 2 Wking D8 and sounds good, is something better than this? my budget is 350-400$. I want hi-fi flavor, emotional listening, feeling😊
minirig 2.2? but it can be a hassle
@@alanrossreviews I don t want annoying connection... 😆
It worries me that you describe the holy grail of hifi but are happy with the d8. Spending more will either gain massive bass or a more hifi listen, i question which would suit you more.
@@alanrossreviews Hi fi listen :) But 2.2 will cost over 600$. Even if i biy them i m afraid of trouble connection🙁
How will you use it? Indoor or outdoor?
Saoundcore flare 2 is better than those overpriced speakers in terms of sound quality and visual (LED) 👻
i do like the flare 2 but prefer the stockwell over it.
@@alanrossreviews how dare you Alan! 👻👻👻