20 Differences Between Captain America and Red Guardian
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 май 2024
- The greatest sign of success is when you find out there are a lot of imitators out there trying to be you. Not only did the success of Project Rebirth in turning scrawny Steve Rogers into the guy we affectionately call ‘Cap’ lead to his own country trying to recreate that success, but a lot of other countries wanting their own symbol and super-soldier. During the Cold War, the Soviets created their own counterpart to the Cap and gave him the moniker of Soviet super-soldier. Who died. So they recruited another one. Who also died. But they just kept at it. Like with the attempts to replicate the super-soldier serum, the attempts to replicate Cap magic were met with mixed results and some unintended consequences. Most importantly, though, they missed the mark in some key attributes that make the Russian version of the hero. Some differences were baked in and reflect the differing philosophy of the people in charge and some of them are just proof that what Professor Eskine said about power and who has it and who respects it is an important part of The Cap formula. Like most foes who take on the role of being the hero’s opposite, it’s in the similarities that you can sometimes see the biggest differences. Here are some of those. What do you think is the most important difference between the Soviet super-soldier, and our homeland hero? Let us know in the comments and be sure to like and subscribe for the latest content in your inbox.
Subscribe: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-CBR
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:54 Entry # 1: Knock off brand vs Original formula Super Soldier Serum
02:00 Entry # 2: Homeowners, Brooklyn/St Petersburg
02:44 Entry # 3: Symbol of Freedom/Symbol of the Workers
03:32 Entry # 4: Color Scheme
04:25 Entry # 5: Paraphernalia, Shield vs No Shield
05:09 Entry # 6: Brains vs No brains
05:35 Entry # 7: Family man vs Man out of time
06:32 Entry # 8: Jailbird/Clean Record
07:18 Entry # 9: Obedient to superiors/Obedient to ideals
07:54 Entry # 10: Cold War Rivals
08:27 Entry # 11: Hero who fell, the villain who reformed
09:16 Entry # 12: Kill vs no-kill
09:50 Entry # 13: Tatted up vs no tats
10:15 Entry #14: Keeping it tight vs Dad Bod
10:53 Entry # 15: Heavy drinker, can’t get drunk
11:22 Entry # 16: Speechmaker, not so much a speechmaker
12:03 Entry # 17: Leader vs Follower
12:37 Entry # 18: Precision vs brute force
13:16 Entry # 19: All Juice and Heart vs Qualified Soldier before being juiced
14:10 Entry # 20: Mad Steve nobler, Mad Soviet super-soldier, meaner
Our Social Media:
/ cbr
/ comicbookresources
/ cbrvideo
/ comic-book-resources
Follow CBR’s Podcast, CBR Saga, on Spotify, Apple Music, and SoundCloud:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
open.spotify.com/show/7JXbatx...
/ therealcomicbookresources
Our Website
www.cbr.com
Written by: Ryan Carbrey
Narrated by: Jacoby Bancroft
Edited by: Muhamed P.
For copyright matters please contact us at: legal@valnetinc.com 
Развлечения
I just wanna see Red Guardian and Thor get drunk together, would be amazing, joking about the captain etc.
Bro. THIS is my dream now
Thor cannot get drunk
@@cardoplays72 no he can
But in a few thousand gallons of beer or whisky whatever
@@cardoplays72 eyh yo this tru thou
@@cardoplays72 if he takes 100,000 a week, he will
Clear Difference:
Red Guardian: *Blood Walk*
Captain America: *Crip Walk*
Hahahah oh God i almost died of laughter
Jesus haha
Whats a crip walk?
Maybe we can get an old man Cap VS. Red Guardian
@@hweckrsonkira some kind of gangster dance
honestly I think the only people in black widow movie who were entertaining was red guardian and Yelena
I loved when a Yelena was giving Nat crap about being a poser with her superhero landing. She later did it herself and just said “ disgusting “. Still looked pretty hot when she did it. Yelena was hot even though she wasn’t trying to be.
@@gregrowe1168 you sound.horny as hell
Na, see your wrong, Captain America doesn’t represent the American government, he’s supposed to represent the American ideals, where as Red Guardian is supposed to represent the Soviet government.
Have to wonder how a red guardian that embodied Ideals as well would turn out (no I’m not pro communist, all ideology however have interesting ideals at the core.)
The United States will be Communist in a few years. That’ll be the science experiment.
"The Anti-Hero just shoots the bad guy"... he's talking about Deadpool isn't he 😏
Or the Punisher.
Venom would just eat him.
I’ll tell u, Cap murica is who u wanna look like, red guardian is who u actually look like
fuck yea, red guardian's sweet!
Well I guess the Russian version doesn’t keep you from getting fat when you get old. Even 100 + years old Steve in the alternate reality Endgame was still ripped.
CBR: "Captain America doesn't take lives"
Captain America: in the beginning of TWS, kicks dude in the back going 90 mph, sends him flying into metal railing, breaking his back, and then falling into the ocean where he drowned.
Its just like how they say Batman never kills, but he literally throws people off skyscrapers and hits people in his batmobile at like 200mph
@@jeremiahdanvers4190 Captain America doesn't have the "no kill" rule like Batman have. I don't know why they keep mistaking Cap for a boyscout like Superman when Cap is literally a WW2 Soldier.
Come on he killed hundreds of German Nazi back in WWII
How many Hydra agents, Mind controlled Shield Agents, Chitauri and Space Dogs did he kill till now?? 🤔
@@holyflame2 He is a boyscout like Superman.
To be honest I don’t know their similarities
They both have a star and red and white in their costume
they both have a suit and a mask to go with it
They both are white
And you cant say thats racist bcuz I didnt even say something racist and thats just a fact
they both super soilders
They both know Natasha Romanoff
@Damon Moles it's called vibranium shields not frisbees
I never imagined that this Alexi will turn out to be Red Guardian also a supersoilder but when he lifts the trailer, I got suspicious. Alexei Red Guardian was Natasha's husband but here they entirely changed his arc.
I really wish we saw more of how strong the red guardian was. It felt a bit watered down considering how much we saw of Bucky and Rogers being super soldiers
A fight between captain America and red guardian can possibly be more epic than Connor mcgregor vs Dustin poirier.
Connor turned out to be a lil bitc as he broke his ankle trying to kick mans...
Captain america would crush him with 1 hand tied behind his back
Cap is literally one of the most skilled fighters in Marvel and possibly all of comics. He washes him.
@@daquanthebroncosfan Black Panther is a better fighter than Cap, in the comics at least. Even in the MCU, Cap struggled a bit against him.
@@ChuMpFantic I’m still mad about that 🤣
Accidentally clicked but since I'm here I love your channel and have a good day😁
David Harbour is such a good choice to play Red Guardian, he is such a good actor!
The difference is that one has a sense of humour and the other one doesn't
Both are good though
You say that like it's a bad thing. Having a funny or serious personality are both good things it keeps characters balenced.
@@FictionalFanatic and you sound like someone who has no sense of humour 😁😁, stop assuming I said it like it's a bad thing. I like jokes and you should keep quiet. Assumption is the mother of all........ You know the answer and you should stop putting words in people's mouths. The red guy is the best thing in that movie. And you can say that the whole movie is a bad thing. It was not as good as I expected.
@@augustinoita158 dude its not that damn deep, stop acting like your on your period
@@solol2909 i take everything seriously, even my periods😁😁
I believe when Red Guardian faces taskmaster, and puts his hand up like claws.. thats a wrestling position, traditional wrestling is hugeee in Russia and neighbouring countries, national sport at schools etc. Cool detail!
The sad thing about this fight is that we won't see this fight.
We don’t know that yet, the multiverse makes it so we literally have endless possibilities and can see anything and bring anyone back
Chris Evans isn't coming back
It's still possible, remember Cap was not on ice in the time line, they just thought he was. Who knows if he fought in the back ground and they crossed paths. Shield and Peggy Carter were together and who knows, Cap was always after super soldiers
Maybe not, but may we can see the next best thing, Bucky Barnes/ Winter Soldier vs The Red Guardian!
We could see him fight John walker
Seeing this 2 fight would be awesome
The difference was one was completely wasted where he could have been cool, and the other was Captain America.
Steve Rogers, " I can do this all day."
Same
MCU red guardian has the special sauce right I mean it looked like he did
Yes
Yes, he got a knockoff version.
The special sauce was the vita rays
Yeet
Bet he got the same serum as bucky did or probably a slightly better version of it.
Great vid
In retrosepct, cap's cg shield looks so bad lol (first shot)
There can be multiple super soldiers or Captain Americas, but there's only one that can wield mjolnir.
Red guardian can also be worthy
You mean Jonathan
I needed this
_Red Guardian_ is not stronger than Captain America, but I like this character 🥰
Difference-
Steve:Captain America
Alexei:Captain Communist
@Rashid Ahhmad cap doesn't like capitalism
@@drewvalenzuela1122 he also doesn't like swearing, throwback to AAOU (Age of Ultron)
Captain russia
@@drewvalenzuela1122 good lmao i hate it too
@@skeed7573 then why, in Avengers: Endgane, did he say “Let’s go get that son of a b*tch”?
I am 100% believer that you have a more loyal family from those you choose over the ones you're born with
Imagine alexi becoming Captain America and steve become red guardian 😂
Winter Soldier also had the super solider serum too. Man-Thing was created by the same serum too,in the MCU. That goes to show that it does different things based the individuals that it is used on,but enhanced meta-human traits seems to be the one common guarantee.
I think Natasha had some sort of super soldier serum too. But since she was female, it didn’t really give her super strength comparable to captain America, only slightly more than an average human.
It would be great if marvel's all shielded hero gathered in one video
I hope Red Guardian will appear again soon . He s alot of potential .
Yes he ll return as hopper in s t season 4
@@Supha07 LOL 😂
Its funny you say its almost like Steve Rogers has been working for Hydra all along because there is an entire branch of Comics where Steve was killed and Hydra created a clone to take his place. It's an interesting read.. Highly recommended
Alexei is a super soldier in the mcu. Would love some backstory on him, maybe an R rated type comedy.
Are you going to do differences between Iron Man and the Crimson Dynamo?
They're potraiting the red gaurdian as a goofy clumsy dumb charactor. That's not fair😂. Red gaurdian is no jokes.
hey 8 prefer red guardian cuz him being goofy, funny, ect makes him interesting to watch but if you piss him off then he's no joke
@@Mango_lovaa135 being a russian and goofy at the same time is not russian at all. American, yes. But not russian.
Black Widow was amazing 🤩 I loved it
Two of the greatest Marvel characters that came out of Russia is the Black Widow and Colossus from X-Men. Nothing against the Red Guardian but he just seems like a regular guy with some anger issues just saying.
What about omega red he was a cool villain of the marvel characters
@@danielzikmund997
Omega Red's not that popular he's not even good enough to look at Black Widow he's like the Russian cousin nobody likes just my opinion.
Would it have been awesome if we saw the two of them together in the MCU or Red Guardian appearing in the Falcon and Winter Soldier TV show?
Red guardian is not a regular soldier he slung a whole wagon witnone hand like it wus nothing to clear the runway for his family to escape
I was jus thinking the same thing, he even shows the video of him kickin a metal door thru 😆 sum regular soldier
You forgot the reinforced maximum security prison door he tackled through.
No he is regular in the comics
Now I want to see what a Reg Guardian looks like WITH the super soldier serum. There has to be a comic out there about this.
I thought it was odd how at any time Red Guardian could have easily broken out of that prison but never did. I suppose he would have had nowhere to go and since he’s not bulletproof would have gotten shot. Cap isn’t bulletproof either, he’s just really good at blocking bullets with his shield.
Red Guardian in MCU is definitely stronger
But he's got unfit by time
Bro Cap in the MCU is a superhuman strong enough to damage the Iron Man suit with his bare hands. Plus strong enough to make Thano's head flinch(Even though it's zero damage) with just punches.
@@holyflame2
Red Guardian is also a super soldier
@@kinjalroy9407 Yes but i doubt he can do the things Cap did. Winter Soldier is also a Supersoldier, but he's no Cap.
@@holyflame2
I'm talking about physical strength
@@kinjalroy9407 But Steve showed more achievements with his strength. We barely saw much with the Red Guardian.
Its tough to compare their mcu versions since Red Guardian has become a "Fat Thor" Cap but they both have super strengrh, speed, and durability as everyone has after the super soldier serum
We wanna see more of Red Guardian in MCU please
The farther and farther along the much goes. The more and more super soldier people we get.
To be fain, Major America would've sounded pretty damn cool too!
I would give so much to see post reuniting with peggy steve rodgers take on Alexi Red Gaurdian incognito during the cold war. But at the same time fighting with anthony mackie will do
Finally in 18 seconds
Detail: if you see the tattoos of Alexi aka red guardian there will be black widow and Yelena belova picture will be there.
Easy
Captain America: filthy Capitalist
Red Guardian: visionary communist
Nah, filthy commie, cap is a hero
@@TheGeechman nah
I would love a video of a Steve Rogers vs John walker.
Hawkeye scene in Budapest
walker would clap him
@@pixel3042 Never in a million years
@@dornelas8065 he could stand a chance against steve before the serum, and after the serum he could pull a truck and keep away 4 other super soldier at the samr time, as much as i like steve he doesnt stand a chance
Summons mjolnir becomes captain thunder ⛈, destroys john walker
Caption should have spoiler alert since there some scenes we haven’t seen in the trailers
Why the fuck would you watch a video about a character from a movie you haven't seen?
@@piggysmalls4373 hahaha 🤣
@@piggysmalls4373 because he's not just a character from a movie?
Red guardian :
"He was created for propaganda"
Captain America:
2:58 "The plan was to raise money for the war effort"
So...both were created for propaganda ?
10:48-10:54 is exactley what i was thinking as soon as i saw red guardian at old age in black widow.
I only heard about red guardian last night when I was trying to get thru Black Widow
Cap has the pure version of the serum with the vita rays, noone else has that.....so his has the ability to take him beyond what others can..they seriously underpowered him in the MCU. Cap has faith, dedication, loyalty and a code which set his ideals high for himself more than he envisioned for others..he led by example
He was great in the MCU but I wish they didn't get rid of him in endgame but contracts are a thing
Even old cap was still ripped. Old red guardian, well not so much.
Could it be possible that The Red Guardian was talking about Isaiah Bradley in the 80's? Especially considering Ursa mentioned that he was wrong in saying it was Steve. I know Bradley did jail time too after Vietnam, but its difficult to place it all.
They didn't even focus on red guardian character. Even if we remove him it wouldn't make a difference.
And the big disappointment of taskmaster. Lol
Edit 19 like appreciate that
Uhh.. that's because the movie is called Black widow not red guardian don't u think?
@@GeorgeLouie lmao
@@GeorgeLouie funny because black widow didn't feel like the main character either
@@randomcontentguy2521 yessss she had like no fighting most times on her
@@randomcontentguy2521 the movies is about the black windows.
One of the theories is that the real supersoldier Serum was actually the Wakadan flower that give black panther his power . So Steve Rogers may be the only Non-Wakadan that have the favour of their goddess bath.
That serum was stronger. Black panther was stronger than cap.
What if captain America was the other guy and the other guy was captain America
If you seek similarity.. check US AGENT vs Red Guardian.. both are Govt agents.
Never made sense why you wouldn’t send a guy who could kick all kinds of ass into battle.
Damn! Beat me to it
Maybe 2nd shield was pure vibranium, but 1st was an alloy.
Which of these two do you think is the best and would win against each other?
Red Guardian got trashed by taskmaster. Kinda disappointed
Task masker is a demon doe
@@reddogg8348 she is lit bro
@@reddogg8348 yeah bro same
Task Sister was very deadly
I agree, its his only fight scene in the movie, I wish he had least one more fight scene where he beat up red room bots
Is it just me, or did anyone else want to see Red Guardian kick more a$$ in Black Widow
Original recipe! The Colonel would be proud!
I haven't seen the black widow movie yet and I understand America doesn't want the Russians to show us up. But it would have been interesting if they choose a younger fit version of the red guardian that somewhat resembles Chris evens and have them duke it out for the countries for entertainment purposes, kinda like Hulk Hogan vs I forgot the Russian dude name lol.
Well that would be cool it well could not happen because of well he would need to be in his 40s because of the time the Soviet union fell and also it would not work with the movie
"Natalia" is just a formal form of a name "Natasha".... So, she didn't change her name at all..
The difference is that red guardian is EPIC
In the comics,Isaiah Bradley came before both of them.
Captain America became the 1st avenger in comics and the MCU. Red Guardian was a soldier for the Soviet Union.
Both fought for their respective countries.
Both are equal in stature.(That's my opinion)......
I dont think the serum means anything, skinny steve had the same mindset of truth and his ideals.
I dont think they're different. They look like they're really similar.
Nah they are way different.
@@Salik96 how?
@@CoolMan1_SonicAndOtherStuff Well they are different in personality cap has had more experience in fighting than him. Cap can lift thor hammer and his shield is made out of vibranium.
@@Salik96 true.
@@CoolMan1_SonicAndOtherStuff Yeah the only thing similar about them is that they both are super soldiers and have a costume with a star on it and a shield.
Isn’t the red guardian a super soldier or something similar
Not all these
Thor in end game : I knew it!
Steve the secret sauce.
8:30, captain America should have bounced straight up right back into the sky due to how vibranium works...
Chirs Evans / Steve Rogers Captain America
When captain America throws his mighty shield all those who dare to oppose it must yield but unless you’re a plane or a bomb or some ice or a brainwashed buddy or a Spiderman or Tony Stark or a version of yourself or just plain Thanos or the Dora milaje then you don’t necessarily have to yield
The difference is one's worthy and the other is not, being worthy of thor's hammer says alot about a person
We actually do not technically know that yet. For All we know, one day Red Guardian just shows up, pockets Mjolnir and leaves with a magic hammer capable of summoning bolts of lightning and tempests.
He has heart
LOL, im the second person in the world liking this vid XD
Secret ingredient is integrity
Depending on which comic you go on black widow got the knock off version of the super serum.
I heard that too. It didn’t really give her super strength though. Just enhanced agility and stamina.
@@gregrowe1168 don't forget she from the cold War time and she is Older than she looks.
How come Steve doesn't say I can this all day anymore?
When you realized cap's suit has 1 star and that means he's actually captain Puerto rico lmao
Captain America is the ideal but Red Guardian is the realistic supersoldier
The closest to Captain America is Bradley ( the Black Captain America) the serum Bradley took gave him similar abilities but not identical
Captain America drinks pepsi and red guardian drinks coca cola, that's the differences.
Ronaldo hates Red Guardian
@@The90DegreeOfficial lol
Ayy but let’s not forget thanos broke Caps shield in endgame, man was going in with his sword
In rocket raccoon's words one's blue!
Honestly I love black widow red guardian. Not really true to the character but he’s so funny in the movie. Seriously just every scene is so funny and I’m not kinda mad because it makes sense being in jail for so long he would be like that just living in his glory days
Tbh first time hearing of red guardian
Some where someplace in the mcu the real task master is some where I will wait till Tony masters shows up
See this is why I'm willing to bet cap didn't stay in the past with Carter risking a butterfly effect.if the kree can change their faces maybe one of them pretended he was old cap.maybe he's up in space with nick fury on a secret mission and requested old cap kree to give the shield to sam? Maybe black widow is up there too? And vision,coulson,Sean bean....😆
Red Guardian in his original appearance in the Avengers was honorable and heroic. He was equal to Cap. He supposedly died. When he was written back to life in comics, writers made him into a different man who was much more of a bad guy(nowhere an equal to Cap). Since then Red Guardian has really only appeared in Black Widow comics stories where he has been treated horribly. In the movie, Red Guardian is a father to Black Widow and was married to someone else. In the movie, he is basically comic relief, not good for much. He is easily beaten by Taskmaster. By the way, please explain how the Red Guardian is able to get tattoos and get fat in a Siberian prison?
Lots of vodka and perlovka
Why is the thumbnails Red Gaurdian and Captin America’s suits so weird
Captain America is too much of a boy scout. I like my hero's a bit flawed. That's why i like Red Guardian.
A spare tire to start with