Why I stopped Euthanizing my Fish 💉

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 авг 2024
  • #shorts
    Live fish +: fish bowls: fishportals.com
    Instagram: / fish4everchannel
    TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
    My tank: amzn.to/3q0XeMw
    All the products I use: www.amazon.com...
    Music: Peer Gynt, Op. 46, IV. In the Hall of the Mountain King (I Dovregubbens hall): • Peer Gynt, Op. 46, IV....
    Email:
    Fish4EverChannel@gmail.com

Комментарии • 2,7 тыс.

  • @SleepyCod467
    @SleepyCod467 2 месяца назад +82778

    DEFORMED BABY SANCTUARY 💀🎸

    • @Fish4Ever
      @Fish4Ever  2 месяца назад +4490

      a safe place for everyone

    • @beneficent2557
      @beneficent2557 2 месяца назад +1165

      ​@@Fish4Evercan I stay there? 🥴

    • @TheRegularSalmon
      @TheRegularSalmon 2 месяца назад +736

      Hey as a deformed salmon this is quite offensive

    • @Rednax1128
      @Rednax1128 2 месяца назад +612

      Absolute killer band name.

    • @melsgamingsessions8371
      @melsgamingsessions8371 2 месяца назад +103

      @@TheRegularSalmonOMG IT'S SMALLFRY FROM SPLATOON 3

  • @Galactic_Orca
    @Galactic_Orca 2 месяца назад +37785

    Looks kind of like cooled lava

    • @Fish4Ever
      @Fish4Ever  2 месяца назад +2543

      ❌mountain
      ❌rocks
      ✅lava

    • @StarlaTheBat
      @StarlaTheBat 2 месяца назад +87

      I agree

    • @kimberlylewistyner2070
      @kimberlylewistyner2070 2 месяца назад +55

      @@Fish4Everyes!

    • @dandecande
      @dandecande 2 месяца назад +57

      Lava rock mountain ✅ ​@@Fish4Ever

    • @Kleidoscop
      @Kleidoscop 2 месяца назад +23

      ​@@Fish4EverI mean, most islands and mountains form because of lava so it's kinda of accurate

  • @chasingdragontales7180
    @chasingdragontales7180 2 месяца назад +23136

    "Deformed Baby Sanctuary" that was the name of my daycare when I was growing up.

  • @LuciaVillar-bz6qi
    @LuciaVillar-bz6qi 2 месяца назад +8014

    I used to work with different chemicals for over 10 years in lab work, the foam you’re using (even when cured and hardened) still releases small amount of chemicals/gases into your fish’s water. I strongly advise changing their tank as it can become extremely toxic

    • @nicolec5841
      @nicolec5841 Месяц назад +891

      The stuff she’s using is made for fish tanks so I assume it would be ok!

    • @meleleinnegarza6630
      @meleleinnegarza6630 Месяц назад

      And they’re already deformed 😂

    • @ginab6142
      @ginab6142 Месяц назад +283

      I was wondering about that . . . .

    • @ginab6142
      @ginab6142 Месяц назад

      @@nicolec5841 I looked it up and it doesn't specifically say fish tanks. It says this: GREAT STUFF Pond & Stone Filler, Sealer and Adhesive is a ready-to-use, closed-cell polyurethane foam that bonds to porous and nonporous rocks or stones without the use of mortar. Specifically designed to blend in and withstand moist conditions, GREAT STUFF Pond & Stone can be used on a variety of projects such as retaining walls, water features and landscaping.

    • @terrapax8554
      @terrapax8554 Месяц назад

      Assumptions that lead to deformities? Same with humans. All that plastic breaks down to Dioxin which causes birthdefects. Watch "Trashed" documentary narrated by Jeremy Irons. ​@@nicolec5841

  • @brooke6286
    @brooke6286 12 дней назад +432

    I love that you care. Too many people would have just been like "oh well".

    • @chronic_payne5669
      @chronic_payne5669 10 дней назад +16

      Allowing the fish to continue breeding, knowing they’re producing deformed babies, is inhumane. If you stop the fish from breeding, there wouldn’t be a need for an extra tank for the deformed fish

    • @wopezstarz
      @wopezstarz 6 дней назад +4

      @@chronic_payne5669 how are you going to stop little fish from breeding when most fish are unrecognizable with gender, that and they do it when you least expect it, and not even factoring in how you could even find WHICH fish is breeding these out.

    • @ArtisticlyAlexis
      @ArtisticlyAlexis 5 дней назад +3

      @@wopezstarzDidnt you know the mama fish having all these issues with malformations in her children went to a Harvard trained OBGYN who sent her to a geneticist. The hardest part was tracking down all the daddies in the tank to give their DNA samples so they can run an in depth genetic analysis.

  • @Sinornis42
    @Sinornis42 2 месяца назад +7955

    the opposite energy of Luke's Baby Goldfish Tea

    • @Shadow-jk6ip
      @Shadow-jk6ip 2 месяца назад +39

      Lmao

    • @shannarafryer3111
      @shannarafryer3111 2 месяца назад +29

      Baby goldfish tea?

    • @Sinornis42
      @Sinornis42 2 месяца назад +808

      @@shannarafryer3111 Luke over at the Luke's Goldies channel breeds fancy goldfish, which can produce several hundred babies at a time per brood. To reduce strain on valuable resources, he culls the babies with defects when they're big enough to see, and it's been a running joke on the channel that a cup full of baby goldfish looks like a cup of iced tea.

    • @shannarafryer3111
      @shannarafryer3111 2 месяца назад +78

      @@Sinornis42 Oh, I stopped watching his stuff a while ago I did not know that 😅

    • @Rg_Dragontree
      @Rg_Dragontree 2 месяца назад +16

      They should do a collab!!

  • @nirvanasingh2
    @nirvanasingh2 2 месяца назад +9264

    I would have thought that expanding foam would be toxic

    • @HerbanVibesApothecary
      @HerbanVibesApothecary 2 месяца назад

      And create deformed babies 🤔

    • @micheleclark3672
      @micheleclark3672 2 месяца назад +780

      Kinda what I also thought🤔

    • @vimmiv
      @vimmiv 2 месяца назад +1470

      I thought so too, but the bottle briefly said pond stone, so maybe it's safe???? Im so curious about this !

    • @CatDaddy.
      @CatDaddy. 2 месяца назад +481

      Also round fish bowl..

    • @umhi9778
      @umhi9778 2 месяца назад +675

      ​@@CatDaddy.I heard most of what makes them bad is being too small for the fish that normally go into them (like putting a goldfish in a small bowl)

  • @RandySoWavvy
    @RandySoWavvy 2 месяца назад +827

    Have you tried adding more genetics to your tank? Deformities usually mean too much inbreeding every time I start to notice deformed babies I add 3-5 new guppies and that usually solves the problem for a while

    • @VipesVonHarlot
      @VipesVonHarlot 2 месяца назад +26

      She adds new fish quite often

    • @stellahebden8965
      @stellahebden8965 2 месяца назад +73

      @@VipesVonHarloteven so, a change of supplier may help

    • @waner17
      @waner17 2 месяца назад +63

      @@VipesVonHarlotif she’s getting them from the same place that doesn’t mean anything

    • @pmwyy
      @pmwyy 2 месяца назад +6

      Just curious… how often are they having babies?

    • @Crystalclear17693
      @Crystalclear17693 Месяц назад

      She gets more views from having deformed guppies so she purposely keeps breeding them. Hence why she is mixing male and female deformed guppies together, so they can breed amd have even worse deformed babies.
      This is what makes this girl happy, some professional may take this as a pretty strong sign of a menta! imbalance...

  • @balkanbaba
    @balkanbaba 2 месяца назад +1836

    Absolutely no hate (but with sincere concern), I’m a scientist that works in a lab and deals with a lot of medical device extracts. All materials have chemicals that leech out when submerged in water or oil after a certain amount of time. We determine whether these extracts are toxic/mutagenic. I highly recommend being cautious when it comes to deciding what to put in your fish tank. For instance, I’ve never tested that “black foam” before but it doesn’t seem like something that is meant to be submerged in a fish tank, for fish to live in. I know you want what’s best for your fishies and it definitely was a cool idea, but you may want to consider that.
    Edit: I now see that it’s a product purposely meant for fish tanks, etc. It’s my bad for not catching that. It's still good to keep in mind though that literally everything releases an extract of some sort- even things like metals, wood, plastic, etc. I see so many things that we test that turn out to be mutagenic/toxic and yet are still available to the public and marketed as "safe". Having worked with plenty of chemicals and test substances, this was the first thing that came to mind. I found the MSDS sheet for the product where you can see/research each individual ingredient (important for use in the laboratory as well as for the consumer). These types of things usually contain toxins and I was not surprised to find some. Just something to keep in mind is all.

    • @jillcaryltamang654
      @jillcaryltamang654 Месяц назад +116

      I believe they are fish safe as they are specifically for tanks, ponds, etc. type. Have seen my dad used it and there were no problems. Kinda curious if it really is bad though as I see nothing through the net on my end as well hehehe

    • @Becizz
      @Becizz Месяц назад +76

      That was my first thought when she pulled out the black foam lol

    • @user-wb6mg6uf6u
      @user-wb6mg6uf6u Месяц назад +11

      ​@@Becizzmine too

    • @laurendavis6490
      @laurendavis6490 Месяц назад +50

      Same thoughts. No wonder the babies are deformed. Why use chemicals inside tank. I won't even use soap to clean tanks & tank items.

    • @somerdae4060
      @somerdae4060 Месяц назад +17

      ​@jillcaryltamang654 it's actually for filling cracks in homes & other things, not made for water or tanks specifically.

  • @Amasterpiece-ns5tk
    @Amasterpiece-ns5tk Месяц назад +139

    I believe it’s called a walstad aquarium method, it’s when there are no filters because of the plants inside the tank . The plants use the waste as a natural fertilizer. And if you look at the bottle it says POND expanding foam, it’s for deformed fish which I’m assuming means blind so they won’t be bothered by the bowl, but the other fish I’m not really sure, but I hope this comment clears up most issues!

  • @unitnippynipz
    @unitnippynipz 2 месяца назад +490

    Most of those deforms will outlive your normal guppies.
    I made a tank for my deformed males, started with 4 about 3 years ago and now got 2 left but the other 2 only died a few months ago.
    The other 50 odd healthy males all died within a year.
    I think it’s because the deforms are left to do their own thing in peace where a tank full of healthy guppies is constant excitement.
    I think the constant excitement is what lowers the life expectancy of the guppy.

    • @kathleenmoore9534
      @kathleenmoore9534 10 дней назад +1

      Jesus is coming back. . Please Get right with the Lord and read the Bible.

    • @kathleenmoore9534
      @kathleenmoore9534 10 дней назад +1

      Jesus is coming back. . Please Get right with the Lord and read the Bible.

    • @eeemoose3494
      @eeemoose3494 10 дней назад +9

      I don't think it's too much excitement that leads to a short life. It's more likely the guppies you had in that tank died off because their large population allowed the spread of disease. In the other tank with the deformed guppies there were fewer fish so diseases like parasites had a hard time spreading.

    • @ChristSaves88
      @ChristSaves88 7 дней назад

      @@kathleenmoore9534🙏🏾

    • @leebliss3622
      @leebliss3622 5 дней назад +1

      I think it’s probably because the new generations have adapted to their environment and whatever specific water and chemicals and temperature etc there is, evidence of obvious deformities means that animal has changed slightly or a lot more than its parents, and probably changed a lot more to be better suited to its environment which is why anything changes

  • @adrfercho
    @adrfercho 2 месяца назад +1959

    Poor water condition's, lack of minerals while guppys are expecting and too much inbreeding can cause deformity in your fish.

    • @donnaspahr5585
      @donnaspahr5585 2 месяца назад +264

      I suspect she’s using toxic props too. ☠️

    • @TheMythicalArtist
      @TheMythicalArtist 2 месяца назад +208

      Why would you think she is using toxic props? She takes a lot of care of these fish so that doesn’t make sense at all.

    • @believeinshadows139
      @believeinshadows139 2 месяца назад +77

      @@donnaspahr5585she isn’t using anything toxic.

    • @karinametenkaite6990
      @karinametenkaite6990 2 месяца назад +280

      @@TheMythicalArtistall the plastic shit you get at a pet store is bad for the fish. Tanks should have only real driftwood, rocks/sand and plants. Expanding foam??????????? Forreal?

    • @Pigeonman1810
      @Pigeonman1810 2 месяца назад +223

      @@karinametenkaite6990it’s literally intended for fish tanks, like designed around it, not like those lumps of plastic that are spongebob themed from pet shops.

  • @camelorcaramel5732
    @camelorcaramel5732 29 дней назад +98

    They should put me in the “messed up fish” tank for failure to thrive.

  • @Tori_H.
    @Tori_H. 2 месяца назад +13

    Pov, you're a baby fish thanking your normal, and you get put in the deformed baby sanctuary 💀

  • @thatonebab7351
    @thatonebab7351 2 месяца назад +658

    anyone with concerns about unfiltered tanks: please look up the walstad method. by the looks of it she did timeskip to when it was cycled as well, see how the water goes cloudy to clear and the plants look more settled.

  • @bonnief6285
    @bonnief6285 2 месяца назад +1700

    You would of thought that the expanding foam would be toxic or am I just stupid

    • @themmemezandgamez451
      @themmemezandgamez451 Месяц назад +42

      Look up tanks for nothin

    • @kiiratonin
      @kiiratonin Месяц назад +39

      no no its fine

    • @corvus0
      @corvus0 Месяц назад +369

      She is likely using a foam specifically made for aquascaping

    • @ananyabansal9162
      @ananyabansal9162 Месяц назад +27

      would have thought*

    • @TheMunchyelena
      @TheMunchyelena Месяц назад +135

      First thing I thought but she seems very concerned about their health so pretty sure she researched that first

  • @keyboard2655
    @keyboard2655 2 месяца назад +903

    Please upload a fish store update ? ❤

    • @Fish4Ever
      @Fish4Ever  2 месяца назад +201

      yes soon 🫧🐠 i can’t wait to share my new logo with you all!

    • @mango_2804
      @mango_2804 2 месяца назад +7

      ​@@Fish4EverI'm excited

    • @Rg_Dragontree
      @Rg_Dragontree 2 месяца назад +6

      ​@@Fish4EverLogo!? OMG Im so excited!

    • @justarandomrobloxplayer-dj4hm
      @justarandomrobloxplayer-dj4hm 2 месяца назад +3

      @@Fish4Ever super exited!!

    • @iloafanimalsHi
      @iloafanimalsHi 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@@Fish4EverEEEEEKKKKK I'm so excited 😁😁😁

  • @Aaliyah1909
    @Aaliyah1909 17 дней назад +8

    Dang didn't think this video would be so nostalgic. Spent my childhood in deformed baby sanctuary, glad they fonally opened one up for fish to. Brought a tear to my eye and a rush of memories and whoopings. Thank you ❤

    • @emshizzel1598
      @emshizzel1598 2 дня назад

      lol and whoopins is righttttt!!!!!!

  • @sheriff_clementine
    @sheriff_clementine Месяц назад +24

    that’s one hell of a first line

  • @095_surgasriagustin5
    @095_surgasriagustin5 2 месяца назад +98

    Oh, hei! I have deformed guppy myself. They have super wavy curved back when they just a fry. So I separate them in a tank that always exposed to morning sun. When they get a lot bigger, the curved back just healled little by little until they looks normal.

  • @missdonttrip7283
    @missdonttrip7283 2 месяца назад +60

    Am I the only one who thinks the expanding foam is toxic to the fish so this is more like a funeral home rather than a sanctuary?
    I know that isn’t the creators intent, so don’t come for me I’m not accusing her of animal cruelty.

    • @lizh1988
      @lizh1988 Месяц назад +5

      Not the only one but apparently that stuff is made for fish habitat.

    • @SamuPohjala
      @SamuPohjala Месяц назад +2

      Ffs I've seen so many comments about this, do you guys honestly think someone who loves fish wouldn't use aquarium safe products? That foam is animal safe and is used by hundreds of aquarists

  • @kimlombard639
    @kimlombard639 2 месяца назад +146

    Hopefully, the black expanding foam isn't toxic to the fish.

    • @kayleerogers1403
      @kayleerogers1403 2 месяца назад +14

      It’s pond foam! It won’t breakdown and Leech

    • @thedonovan
      @thedonovan 2 месяца назад

      It's insanely toxic, no such thing as safe foam. Just because it's marketed as 'pond foam' doesn't mean that it's safe. All foams cause cancers, birth defects, and other diseases.

    • @reguin7684
      @reguin7684 2 месяца назад +17

      After looking into the components of the foam stuff it seems a lot of them actually aren’t fish-safe so if that gets damaged in anyway those fish will slowly be poisoned end up passing 😅

    • @JeninaB
      @JeninaB 2 месяца назад +14

      The one she's using is a fish friendly foam I've looked into getting it before, but I'm sure any old foam could be toxic since they do market that one as non toxic for your fish lol

  • @midzy_banana
    @midzy_banana 4 дня назад +2

    "deformed baby sanctuary" sounds like a band

  • @morgaia7784
    @morgaia7784 2 месяца назад +2

    Maybe should you add a quick warning that round tanks are usually harmful to fishes, so the beginners among us don't get fooled? :'0
    Looks super pretty btw ❤

  • @lizziesangi1602
    @lizziesangi1602 2 месяца назад +11

    The other day I was in a dollar store and they had black fan tail guppies bring sold in solid glass sealed bowls. Their skin was dull, they were not happy fish. One had his mouth directly on the tiny air hole. I wanted to buy all of them but have nothing to keep them. My friend said, Keep walking but it was one of the saddest things I ever saw.

    • @user-ql5um2fx7w
      @user-ql5um2fx7w Месяц назад +4

      this is so sad - poor babies

    • @Bambisgf77
      @Bambisgf77 15 дней назад

      I cannot believe there are humans still willing to do things like this in 2024…

    • @3moon3witch3
      @3moon3witch3 12 дней назад +2

      I feel the same when I see bettas trapped in those tiny cups at the pet stores😢

  • @Paperstickman657
    @Paperstickman657 2 месяца назад +92

    Someone correct me if Im wrong. No hate intended. But I thought that fish bowls were very disorienting to the fish and unhealthy?

    • @misteriosa5932
      @misteriosa5932 2 месяца назад +8

      For what i search, not really, they require more care tho, because of things like "less surface area" and "limited placement of equiment", but it's possible to successfully keep fish in them, "just needs to be sure to have sufficient oxygenation"
      Anyway, i am no expert, this is just what i found

    • @duolingoOvvl
      @duolingoOvvl 2 месяца назад +32

      Yes you're right, ex-fish shop employee here, many years ago all round bowls were recalled from fish stores where I live because they're ab*sive. The round bowl reflects the fish's image with that "fish eye" effect making them constantly think they're being chased by a larger fish. It's horrible!!!

    • @galaxydragonet8722
      @galaxydragonet8722 2 месяца назад +10

      It can be pretty bad for fish from what I understand.
      Besides what was already commented here, it can also stunt the growth of a fish depending on how big they get, for example: Goldfish
      They get pretty big, but being kept in small fish bowls stunts their growth

    • @Animation27
      @Animation27 2 месяца назад +1

      I don’t know, my goldfish lived to almost 20 (yes same fish, he was missing scales so I know he wasn’t replaced by my parents) in a small goldfish bowl. We cleaned the bowl monthly and used distilled water.

    • @cutiechan7876
      @cutiechan7876 2 месяца назад +7

      It’s disorienting for seeing fish…but luckily they can’t see so they don’t get disoriented. :D

  • @oreoisntacat
    @oreoisntacat 2 месяца назад +457

    (EDIT!!!! So people have told me the foam doesn’t leech into the water, so please do your own independent research to reach your own conclusions. The foam is made of polyurethane, which is a type of plastic used in kitchen sponges. Some articles and research papers state Polyurethane leeches into water, so I’m not sure where people are getting the idea that it’s safe. My other points still stand though, especially about the uncycled and non-filtering fish bowl!).
    Expanding foam doesn’t sound very eco friendly or animal friendly especially to fish. Plastic is known to leech harmful chemicals over time. Being submerged in water doesn’t help slow that down either. Expanding foam definitely doesn’t sound like it’s made to be under water and not leech. You should stop putting plastic products in your water for your fish…

    • @Binstabih
      @Binstabih 2 месяца назад +49

      It’s about as harmful as you sitting on a plastic chair with shorts on

    • @xi0su
      @xi0su 2 месяца назад +98

      There is expanding foam made specifically for ponds, aquariums, and other aquatic environments. It's meant to be safe for fish; they will be completely fine (assuming she's using the correct product, that is.) We appreciate your concern and no offense, but I recommend you do your research next time before criticizing others.

    • @SpaceRaT123
      @SpaceRaT123 2 месяца назад +55

      the bottle says it’s pond foam (not trying to be rude) so it should be ok for the fish

    • @namjoonie936
      @namjoonie936 2 месяца назад +4

      @@Binstabihidk I find this a really funny wait to explain it

    • @Cloudyconfusion
      @Cloudyconfusion 2 месяца назад +13

      100% agree this is so bad for the fish. If this is what she does no wonder her fish babies are coming out deformed. That’s probably how it happened in the first place!

  • @lazyfoxplays8503
    @lazyfoxplays8503 3 дня назад +1

    “I don’t want to euthanize them anymore” is a wild sentence.

  • @hextral9295
    @hextral9295 8 часов назад

    Thank you for taking care of them :,)

  • @Eork149
    @Eork149 2 месяца назад +137

    Legitimate question here- how are you not having a Hapsburg level canon event with your fish inbreeding so much?
    And if the deformed ones start breeding what then

    • @VipesVonHarlot
      @VipesVonHarlot 2 месяца назад +12

      Fish genetics are different than humans. Inbreeding isn't a problem for them

    • @RhiannonChann
      @RhiannonChann 2 месяца назад +100

      ​@@VipesVonHarlot unfortunately that is just not true. Inbreeding is an issue for fish as well, as demonstrated by the birth of so many malformed offspring. While fish are more tolerant of inbreeding than mammals they absolutely do suffer ill effects when not managed properly.

    • @susanthefish2559
      @susanthefish2559 2 месяца назад +4

      Guppy's breed quickly so inbreeding is pretty much unavoidable

  • @CK_LethalNJector
    @CK_LethalNJector 2 месяца назад +239

    From my perspective, saving lives that were meant to end by natural causes can be considered just as cruel. Deformations occur naturally, and parents will eat any offspring born with them. Since You can't be certain that these deformities won't cause issues with eating, breathing or digestion for the fish, isn't it just as plausible you're causing them more pain by forcing them to live with their deformities?
    There's a reason animals kill/eat their deformed offspring in the wild and people don't interfere with it.

    • @iaacryign
      @iaacryign 2 месяца назад +87

      I dont want to be a negative nancy either but keeping any super deformed babies alive can be super painful for them especially if they have more internal issues from a spine deformity or a organ issue

    • @sparrowtakesflight
      @sparrowtakesflight 2 месяца назад +79

      Ikr, this video is so disappointing coming from the same person who made a video talking about why humane euthanasia of deformed guppies is necessary and important, definitely not just something you stop doing because you don't feel like it anymore.

    • @piya_404
      @piya_404 2 месяца назад +31

      Plus the deformed babies might have more deformed babies right?

    • @elkynethehorde5592
      @elkynethehorde5592 2 месяца назад +30

      @@sparrowtakesflightright. Im confused why she doesnt just separate the males and females if shes going to have two tanks anyway. Then they literally cant breed.

    • @sparrowtakesflight
      @sparrowtakesflight 2 месяца назад +28

      @@elkynethehorde5592 She's a fish breeder and sells the babies, which is fine and all, but she needs be responible about it and euthinze the babies with deformities

  • @lottetower448
    @lottetower448 2 месяца назад +45

    I see a lot of people saying the foam is toxic it is not she’s using one that’s safe for fish. And about the fish bowl if its the right diameters it should mostly be fine but a lot of the deformed babies won’t be able to see or even be able to live long even if it has a good home. Hope this helps.

    • @tenetennba6529
      @tenetennba6529 11 дней назад +1

      Bowls like these have been proven to be bad for fish. It'll leave them disoriented and unhealthy

  • @tebohondamase
    @tebohondamase 3 часа назад

    This’s so adorable! 🥹🥹🥹

  • @Venturahighwayride
    @Venturahighwayride 5 дней назад

    Fish eugenics goes crazy

  • @anongirlfrompoland
    @anongirlfrompoland 2 месяца назад +200

    You shouldn't put fish in bowls like that. The curved glass makes the outside world look deformed to the fish, stressing them out. I advise you to get rid of this bowl and replace it with a box shaped aquarium instead ❤

    • @The-one-and-only-Fruitcake
      @The-one-and-only-Fruitcake 2 месяца назад +52

      She knows. Likely, this will be for blind guppies. She’s addressed this before

    • @DM-wu5hn
      @DM-wu5hn 2 месяца назад +10

      How would a guppy know that the outside world is deformed?

    • @78cottoncandy
      @78cottoncandy 2 месяца назад

      What a condescending comment❤

    • @Lennyxx
      @Lennyxx 2 месяца назад +41

      shes letting putting deformed fish in it did you not watch the video? Shes mentioned before that round bowl are better for blind fish so they can find food better and such. Fishes are her life dont assume you know more

    • @taylamuller1811
      @taylamuller1811 2 месяца назад +20

      Its literally for blind fish. She explains this in the video. She has done many videos on this before. Its crazy how people say shit without actually paying attention.

  • @carlawilliams4281
    @carlawilliams4281 2 месяца назад +11

    “Deformed baby sanctuary” 💀

  • @bluebosnian
    @bluebosnian 2 месяца назад +34

    wont they suffer just being alive though?

    • @thatonebonkchoyguy
      @thatonebonkchoyguy 2 месяца назад +10

      I don't really think so. I'm pretty sure the deformed babies mainly suffer from being bullied by other fish, so this kind of solves that problem and gives them a chance at a nice life.

    • @Waspinmymind
      @Waspinmymind 2 месяца назад

      @@thatonebonkchoyguyNo.
      You don’t know shit.
      Many deformed fishes die because the defects make it impossible for them to live. She’s been per-formatively cruel.

    • @Ateezwooyoung
      @Ateezwooyoung 2 месяца назад +1

      No they don’t suffer.

    • @ashleykozior2067
      @ashleykozior2067 2 месяца назад +1

      Depends, my family's oldest fish - a catfish by the name of Ginger - has scoliosis yet he's been around for over 10 years, never moved tank since we got him when I was still a toddler.

  • @joohhn
    @joohhn Месяц назад +3

    those fish must be having alot of fun in those tiny fish tanks

  • @Avery-tz9by
    @Avery-tz9by Месяц назад +1

    "the deformed baby sanctuary" 💀

  • @fluffy3049
    @fluffy3049 2 месяца назад +146

    But... Round bowls aren't good for fish?? I thought an avid hobbyist would know that?? 😅

    • @oreoisntacat
      @oreoisntacat 2 месяца назад +23

      Yeah I dunno weird thing to add in there. I think it’s probably temporary???? But she should have said in the video that keeping fish in fishbowls is not right and damaging to them, just so people know not to copy

    • @upumpkin
      @upumpkin 2 месяца назад +3

      I thought the same thing

    • @kayleerogers1403
      @kayleerogers1403 2 месяца назад +52

      The deformed fish are mainly blind, or have difficulty with normal swim patterns, so it’s honestly not too bad for the deformed ones

    • @78cottoncandy
      @78cottoncandy 2 месяца назад +15

      Shes been doing this for 15+ years and runs a fish store… she knows lol. That doesnt apply here which is why shes using it. Idg how ppl can assume she’s ignorant when one look at her channel shows fish are her life

    • @fluffy3049
      @fluffy3049 2 месяца назад +10

      @@78cottoncandy Don't get flip with me. 😑 In my heart of hearts, whether the fish are blind or not, I'M NOT USING A GOD DAMN ROUND BOWL. I wouldn't even dare buy one. Encouraging companies to continue making/selling them. Hell no.

  • @UtahimeLori-ik2mr
    @UtahimeLori-ik2mr 2 месяца назад +8

    im shocked that u just create ALL OF THAT YOURSELF
    u're a very good fish mom love yah

  • @ceetolchowdhury7587
    @ceetolchowdhury7587 2 месяца назад +30

    I may sound rude but please make more videos and shorts I think you should do more updates and I think you should add more guppies (from different lines )to prevent such incidents and prevent inbreeding

    • @AylaGarton
      @AylaGarton 2 месяца назад

      You're not being rude, if you demand then you would but you asked nicely.

    • @ceetolchowdhury7587
      @ceetolchowdhury7587 2 месяца назад +1

      @@AylaGarton 👍🏻

    • @RandySoWavvy
      @RandySoWavvy 2 месяца назад +1

      You can’t prevent inbreeding but new genetics every once in awhile does help prevent deformities

    • @VipesVonHarlot
      @VipesVonHarlot 2 месяца назад +3

      She adds new fish all the time. She's working very hard at setting up her new physical store location while also running her online business. It's understandable that she doesn't have time to be making new videos all the time right now

  • @B3r3nic3
    @B3r3nic3 Месяц назад +4

    The fact that you took time of ur day and money to make something for the fish instead of killing them shows how much luv you have for them and I respect that❤

    • @Kravges
      @Kravges Месяц назад +1

      She did kill them thou 😢

  • @iyxxyyy
    @iyxxyyy 3 дня назад

    "Tortured poets department" fish version

  • @ScibelsDoesArt
    @ScibelsDoesArt 2 месяца назад +154

    You are such an awesome person, how's the store going?

    • @Fish4Ever
      @Fish4Ever  2 месяца назад +42

      great i’m posting an update soon! i hope to open this year

    • @ScibelsDoesArt
      @ScibelsDoesArt 2 месяца назад +2

      That's amazing, I know you'll do great

  • @BluePanda37
    @BluePanda37 2 месяца назад +16

    Isn't a circular or round bowl proven to be cruel for fish? Why are you doing this?

    • @Lennyxx
      @Lennyxx 2 месяца назад +1

      she legit says they are deformed and as she has said before that means they are blind

    • @Dragonkitty_101
      @Dragonkitty_101 Месяц назад

      ​@@Lennyxx it isn't even about sight. It's actually worse for me that these fish are blind because they rely on having navigatable surroundings, and bowls are the opposite of that for fish

  • @minty094
    @minty094 2 месяца назад +104

    You may think thats nice but its so cruel to let them live in pain and suffer till they die

    • @Amber_Phoenix
      @Amber_Phoenix 2 месяца назад +33

      Yes I agree and also they will most likely breed and create even more deformed fish that will also just be in pain.

    • @minty094
      @minty094 2 месяца назад +11

      @Amber_Phoenix she should know this since she is a so-called professional and has so many fish already

    • @Amber_Phoenix
      @Amber_Phoenix 2 месяца назад +29

      @@minty094 This is what happens when someone puts more impotance on their feelings than the animals quality of life. Sometimes it's better to let them go peacefully than force them to live with health issues because the person "felt bad".

    • @minty094
      @minty094 2 месяца назад +4

      ​@Amber_Phoenix she should know better since she's opening a store too

    • @Choni939
      @Choni939 2 месяца назад +6

      Gracias, no me gusta ver como todos la complementan sin saber lo mal que esta lo que hace

  • @wickedrose6746
    @wickedrose6746 2 месяца назад

    I love that you are giving them sanctuary, that’s beautiful♥️

  • @katharinewhits
    @katharinewhits Месяц назад

    So happy you chose to do this! 😊

  • @SMANI_ROSE
    @SMANI_ROSE 2 месяца назад +5

    Fish Living better life than me😔

  • @lolaravioli
    @lolaravioli 2 месяца назад +26

    How is it ethical to breed deformed fish when they would literally be food in nature

    • @techwithbec
      @techwithbec Месяц назад +1

      It's not. Any ethical breeder would not continue breeding fish that are having deformities. Inbreeding and poor nutrition lead to deformities. I kind of hate her channel and how everyone says how she takes great care of her fish. No idea why her videos keep popping up in my feed when I keep removing them. I like people that actually know how to take care of fish and care about them not the influencers just trying to get views.

  • @earth_mapper8902
    @earth_mapper8902 2 месяца назад +39

    This girl is the fish angel-princess, please post more we love you and your fishies❤

  • @Edit-u7n
    @Edit-u7n 9 дней назад

    Your baby fishes are cute 😊

  • @jocelynclara3352
    @jocelynclara3352 28 дней назад

    i love this account so much 😭😭

  • @tarynkathleen3699
    @tarynkathleen3699 2 месяца назад +13

    That spray foam, what's it made of? just wondering if items like this are putting toxins in the water causing deformations

    • @stellarjuju8788
      @stellarjuju8788 2 месяца назад +1

      Google Black waterfall foam. Its the product that shes using..

  • @Crystalclear17693
    @Crystalclear17693 2 месяца назад +23

    You need to separate the males and females so you dont keep purposely breeding deformed guppies.
    In fact there is nothing worse that you could do than putting in male and female deformed guppies together, im pretty sure i don't need to explain what will happen next...

    • @fanpet3912
      @fanpet3912 2 месяца назад +3

      Yeah I thought this too

    • @Crystalclear17693
      @Crystalclear17693 2 месяца назад +8

      ​@@fanpet3912 I don't mind people monetising their animals if they're taking care of them but this girl is really not taking any responsibility for her animals at all. It's sad to see and I hope she educates herself soon 🤞🤞

  • @1234-t2s
    @1234-t2s 15 дней назад +2

    Ur sooo kind i love how you care for fish as much as you can and will do anything to save them❤

    • @chachachazki
      @chachachazki 6 дней назад

      Maybe if she took better care of her fish in the first place there would not be any deformed fish babies. People are clueless these days

  • @GGiblet
    @GGiblet 12 дней назад

    You are such a sweet fish mama🐠💗

  • @DonnaMichelleStensland1976
    @DonnaMichelleStensland1976 2 дня назад +2

    That foam is toxic it's going to make it worse ...Black foam in a can, such as spray foam insulation or polyurethane foam, can contain toxic chemicals. These chemicals can cause health risks, including respiratory disease, eye irritation, and gastrointestinal issues.

  • @marcella929
    @marcella929 2 месяца назад +4

    is this a big enough tank for the fish? it was only 8 gallons before and adding in all that expanding foam only made it smaller. I heard there should be one inch of fish per gallon, so hopefully those babies dont get too big

  • @stillhere1425
    @stillhere1425 Месяц назад +4

    I found myself worrying that the black foam might leech chemicals myself, and also, after a disaster my sister’s aquarium experienced at the hands of her well-meaning life partner, I learned that just any old water won’t do. The temperature and purity of the water, how saline it is or isn’t, even how the bowl was washed, all matters. I had no idea! So find out from an exotic fish expert at a shop that specializes in them.

  • @minoraavem922
    @minoraavem922 2 месяца назад +7

    Well that didn't really explained why you let deformed fish suffer instead of giving them a easy way to go

  • @simonotori1948
    @simonotori1948 2 месяца назад

    I love how she really takes good care of her fishes😊❤

  • @JolieUTU
    @JolieUTU 2 месяца назад

    Omg, how sweet is this! Love the sanctuary 🐡🐟🐠♥️❤️💖🩷

  • @katz0625
    @katz0625 Месяц назад +3

    You’re just so sweet and adorable!! You’re Mama Fish 🐠 🐟 the way you care about your fish just shows how big your heart is 🫶🏼

  • @Reef_builder
    @Reef_builder 2 месяца назад +14

    Maybe add some external filter or at least aerator?

    • @believeinshadows139
      @believeinshadows139 2 месяца назад +5

      With all those plants and the likelihood she does regular water changes she doesn’t really need a filter. That’s not a lot of fish so a bio active setup should work just fine

  • @csreiter
    @csreiter 2 месяца назад +5

    That is not safe, using the foam. Anything submerged should be covered in silicone before water is added to prevent leaching.

  • @thenoobperson9405
    @thenoobperson9405 2 месяца назад

    I have been watching you for a long time but then sadly stopped. I never thought you would show your face because of how you acted to people that asked for you to show your face, but it appears that you finally have felt comfortable enough to show your face! Congrats!

  • @user-ik3us3lx6b
    @user-ik3us3lx6b Месяц назад

    Omg! Just noticed she started showing herself! lol I used to watch these all the time and remeber once she had a face reveal so glad to see she’s comfortable in front of the camera now! Probably makes things so much easier

  • @heyiamsecret
    @heyiamsecret 2 месяца назад +11

    I am literally watching you from the start ..you were my inspiration after watching lots of your videos I decided to purchase two fishes ...your videos were really helpful and over the time she has given babies they all are very healthy and happy just the mother is not with them anymore!
    it's so nice to see you grown this much!!
    love ya❤

    • @Jabeen_Shaikh.
      @Jabeen_Shaikh. 2 месяца назад

      I wish the babies a healthy life😊

  • @blackbird1234100
    @blackbird1234100 2 месяца назад +5

    Nature was trying to eliminate these genes that cause suffering via natural selection...and you just said "nahhhh i feel bad for these fish....KEEP EM GOING"

    • @K4RT3N3T
      @K4RT3N3T 2 месяца назад

      Ngl she does euthanized it in the past but many people think that she is killing them for nothing.

    • @Abbyf
      @Abbyf 2 месяца назад +2

      @@K4RT3N3Tthen instead of posting those videos for clout, she can post other ones that don’t mention it and continue to cull the fish like a responsible fish breeder instead of putting all the mess ups in a tank together where they’ll breed as well, if she keeps doing this she’ll have a million tanks before long 😂 does she just hope they’ll slowly die out a painful death because of their issues?

  • @AquaticTips
    @AquaticTips 2 месяца назад +11

    I’m so glad you’re giving them a second chance at life.❤

  • @Elcreeperpro287
    @Elcreeperpro287 Месяц назад

    You are such a good fish protector 👍

  • @gitteheberg5752
    @gitteheberg5752 22 дня назад

    She's an angel

  • @StrayMoth
    @StrayMoth 2 месяца назад +21

    Isn’t that tank kinda.. small?
    I mean I’m in no way an expert but that just looks so tiny for them to live all their lives in.
    I just googled it and it says it should at least be a 54 Liter tank (60 x 30 x 30 cm) for Guppy’s.
    The bigger it is the better

    • @Waspinmymind
      @Waspinmymind 2 месяца назад +7

      They’re unlikely to live happy mature life due to deformities she’s very aware of the cruelty she committing here.

    • @Urmom-ts8gp
      @Urmom-ts8gp 2 месяца назад

      Their babies rn so no

    • @beakerface
      @beakerface 2 месяца назад +1

      ​@Waspinmymind It's a temporary baby sanctuary, if they live to maturity she will move them somewhere bigger

  • @MoonTatii
    @MoonTatii 2 месяца назад +570

    Cute! I like that you completely change how you do things all the time and make sure all your fish are fresh with everything they need and more. It's insane and so cool to see fish finally getting taken care of

    • @dont_harsh_my_mellow
      @dont_harsh_my_mellow 2 месяца назад +7

      Agreed! Seeing videos of fish getting treated as if they’re toys time and time again is beyond rage inducing. Not to mention how most fish owners put them in decorative bowls that are not enough. This is SUCH a breath of fresh air to see. Totally. ❤

    • @Welisdoingwell
      @Welisdoingwell 2 месяца назад

      Getting enough deformed fish to be able to set up their own tank 🚩
      Not euthanizing deformed fish🚩
      Pairing up deformed fish to eventually breed more deformed fish🚩
      Posting this on social media spreading bad fish care🚩
      Putting your own morals and “peace of mind” over doing what’s right for your “pets”🚩

  • @ConservativePrincess
    @ConservativePrincess Месяц назад +6

    Maybe yhe expanding foam is causing the deformation? Just a thought. A lot of those foams have a lot of toxins in them. My husband is a contractor & he says a lot of those have chemicals in them to deter rodents from chewing the foam. Just a lil FYI for you. Hopefully switching tanks helps. Maybe just try a smaller bowl or real rocks. 🤔 Keep up the hard work. This comment isnt meant for criticism but to inform.

  • @Discotheque2002
    @Discotheque2002 2 месяца назад +4

    The tank looks nice but how much space did you take up adding all that foam??

  • @muddha5763
    @muddha5763 2 месяца назад

    This is so thoughtful 💖

  • @V-nMontague
    @V-nMontague 4 дня назад

    The one with two different size eyes is so cute 😂

  • @MichelleHood-se5ic
    @MichelleHood-se5ic 2 месяца назад +5

    Are there specific precautions and cleaning measures to keep in mind when using expanding foam in a tank?
    I don’t know much about expanding foam to begin with, let alone when adding fish (as far as toxicity, how it “seals” when set, etc).
    This is the coolest idea and I’d love to try it.

    • @believeinshadows139
      @believeinshadows139 2 месяца назад +4

      Once the foam sets it’s completely safe for the fish. Expanding foam is extremely common to use when setting up Aquascapes or terrariums. It’s most commonly used to hold a hard scape of rocks and branches together but it can also be carved to look like rocks as well. It’s not usually as noticeable as how she used it here. But still a safe and easy material to use.

    • @believeinshadows139
      @believeinshadows139 2 месяца назад +1

      It’s maintenance is pretty straightforward. It’s not much different then having wood or rocks.

    • @VipesVonHarlot
      @VipesVonHarlot 2 месяца назад +1

      Make sure the foam you use is meant specifically for use in aquariums, not the kind you get in a hardware store

  • @CaseyEyers
    @CaseyEyers 2 месяца назад +5

    Damn I didn't know there was a sanctuary for my brother

  • @lilaloveschrist
    @lilaloveschrist 2 месяца назад +4

    i’m early does the fish queen respond??

  • @jacmar16
    @jacmar16 2 месяца назад

    I LOVE YOU!!!! THANK YOU FOR BEING YOU AND PLEASE NEVER CHANGE 🫶🏻 you are the sweetest my gosh 🫶🏻

  • @amywoolley4522
    @amywoolley4522 2 месяца назад

    the tank looks so nice!

  • @lizlevins4908
    @lizlevins4908 2 месяца назад +10

    SANCTUARY?! are u freaking kidding 😂😂😂 ROUND BOWL IS WORST YOU CAN DO TO FISH. WHERE IS WATER FILTER?! you need fucking education before keeping those poor fish

    • @Schwefeldrache
      @Schwefeldrache 2 месяца назад +1

      If the tank is big enough, the shape is not a problem, it is quasi a nano tank and there are definitely filterless aquariums, you just have to find a balance between fish and plants, but this is more of a professional level... I'm more worried about the foam in the water

    • @lizlevins4908
      @lizlevins4908 Месяц назад

      @@Schwefeldrache yes the shape IS THE PROBLEM you donut

  • @hannagg9365
    @hannagg9365 Месяц назад

    You’re a good fish mom! Lots of love, care, time, attention. And responsibility. I’m afraid a gold fish may die after just a few days in my care =\ it’s not easy keeping another living organism ALIVE and THRIVING at the same time! Great job!!!!

  • @dotesondots
    @dotesondots 4 дня назад

    I'm sorry to hear your little fishies are deformed. Poor babies, do you think getting new babies will help stop them from being deformed? You made them a lovely sanctuary. I am worried that the foam may leach into the water as toxins.

  • @voxle3976
    @voxle3976 20 дней назад +1

    Sped class room be like

  • @SafiIsBetter-Yt
    @SafiIsBetter-Yt Месяц назад

    That fish be real emo at the start

  • @kaylinfaulkner9260
    @kaylinfaulkner9260 Месяц назад

    YAAAAS😊🎉
    EVERYONE & EVERYTHING
    DESERVES A CHANCE AT HAPPINESS!!!! ❤ Absolutely love this you did an amazing job 👏🏻

  • @Nothingisavailible
    @Nothingisavailible 2 месяца назад

    The new version of the disappointments room

  • @Settingstare1
    @Settingstare1 2 месяца назад

    I am sorry for the deformed fish hope everything works out fish4ever

  • @helenjohnson7021
    @helenjohnson7021 2 месяца назад

    Years back I always had a fish tank. I loved up 3 sizes finally to a large tank. From the very beginning I always loved the deformed fish. The store I visited would always let me buy them for $1 each. They enjoyed life like the others without issues. It was great❤❤❤

  • @Englishindetails_pou
    @Englishindetails_pou Месяц назад

    LOVE YOUR WORK

  • @ramisaanjum1717
    @ramisaanjum1717 Месяц назад

    Girl you’re so pretty 🥹🫶🏻♥️

  • @MoonForever-uw6zd
    @MoonForever-uw6zd Месяц назад

    You finally posted again❤❤

  • @kiwimangotheparrots
    @kiwimangotheparrots 25 дней назад

    You are the best fish owner❤

  • @gracevhe6496
    @gracevhe6496 2 месяца назад

    Awhhh god bless you fish mama !

  • @oliverwortley3822
    @oliverwortley3822 2 дня назад +1

    that foam is why the fishies are coming out deformed lol.