@@alexsandroalvesartecultura5116 Both the score and Wikipedia list Mottl as the arranger of this one, so I'm not quite sure where you got this information from.
@@mrtchaikovskyLook at the score: You'll find Mottl listed as arranger only on the top of nr. 1 to 4. Concerning "Im Treibhaus": Wagner used material from this in "Tristan und Isolde" (beginning of act 3), so Mottl of course took over Wagner's instrumentation here.
@@helmutmuller2216 What point are you trying to make? The video description lists Mottl as the sole arranger, which is why I pointed out that, as far as I know, the last song was orchestrated by Wagner himself. Besides, a close inspection of the scores will show that Mottl's orchestration of the beginning of the third song differs significantly from Wagner's; he did not simply copy Wagner's score.
![Christa Ludwig Wesendonck-Lieder [Klemperer] by Wagner](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pFsuim3crfA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Christa Ludwig Wesendonck-Lieder [Klemperer] by Wagner](/img/tr.png)
Merci pour ce merveilleux enregistrement ❤
Thank you Ryan . It's one of my favourite pieces There are many inspiring recordings
so good...
Wasn't "Träume" orchestrated by Wagner himself?
According to Japanese Wikipedia, that's right.
Yes. And also "Im Treibhaus".
@@alexsandroalvesartecultura5116 Both the score and Wikipedia list Mottl as the arranger of this one, so I'm not quite sure where you got this information from.
@@mrtchaikovskyLook at the score: You'll find Mottl listed as arranger only on the top of nr. 1 to 4. Concerning "Im Treibhaus": Wagner used material from this in "Tristan und Isolde" (beginning of act 3), so Mottl of course took over Wagner's instrumentation here.
@@helmutmuller2216 What point are you trying to make? The video description lists Mottl as the sole arranger, which is why I pointed out that, as far as I know, the last song was orchestrated by Wagner himself. Besides, a close inspection of the scores will show that Mottl's orchestration of the beginning of the third song differs significantly from Wagner's; he did not simply copy Wagner's score.
Qui chante?