India Now the World’s Largest Illiberal Democracy, Says Financial Times US Editor I Karan Thapar

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 окт 2024

Комментарии • 909

  • @imdxpertm
    @imdxpertm 4 года назад +23

    Karan Thapar is highly underrated Journalist. He deserves much more Respect. Excellent interview and insights as always.
    Thank you 'Sir' Karan Thapar.

    • @vksharma7956
      @vksharma7956 4 года назад +1

      No no, he is highly respected by friends frankly and by foes behind the curtain. But those who deny to recognize his stature are prejudiced.

    • @rizwanullal726
      @rizwanullal726 4 года назад +1

      True... he would be the No. 1 Journalist in India..

  • @sno2worry856
    @sno2worry856 4 года назад +43

    So easy to divide us, no wonder few brits conquered whole of India and ruled for 150 years or more ....

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад +1

      & congress showed the way by following brits by not imposing uniform civil code irrespective of religion when they declared India secular. BJP student just following the tricks adopted by guru Congress. no point worrying when congress shown the way

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад

      Joker pappu

    • @samkubrick7510
      @samkubrick7510 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/d4P7XX3yiWg/видео.html
      #independentfilmmaker #freedomofpress
      This is a short film based on the voilence of Jamia Millia University and North East Delhi .
      How the despotic regime threatens the preamble of our constitution. And when students protest against it, they used lethal force to suppress the voice of the youngsters. The police force enters into the library and bashed with lathis and tear gas. Their batons break their bones, but their spirit of revolution did not break.
      When the helpless and innocent souls were crying for help as the North East Delhi were blazing in hatred of politics.once again human shamed mankind.

    • @sno2worry856
      @sno2worry856 4 года назад +1

      Jotendra Kumar loduram never ever a coutry of federal arrangement and vast diversity can have a uniformity in civil laws ...it’s the cultures and religions and customs which are in practice from centuries which aren’t abusive are perfectly legal ...so don’t just be carrier of faulty logic given to you by it cell stooges

    • @bashirk5898
      @bashirk5898 4 года назад

      Correct these british influenced fegits are influencers

  • @sarbjitsingh9926
    @sarbjitsingh9926 4 года назад +60

    DEMOCRACY IN INDIA
    NO MORE
    R I P

    • @sk-lh7tz
      @sk-lh7tz 4 года назад +5

      Democracy is very much alive it's just that Majority is not going to accept the deal they were getting earlier.they have woken up.

    • @monojdas-gupta5918
      @monojdas-gupta5918 4 года назад +1

      Let us not lose heart, if we really care. One swallow does not make a summer.

    • @manofsan
      @manofsan 4 года назад +3

      Ohhh, and democracy can only exist under Congress? Rubbish.
      When Sonia was ruling India through her National Action Committee, while Manmohan was her meek puppet ("Teek hai?") then you called that democracy?
      Don't talk like a crook.

    • @RaviShankar-ef7hr
      @RaviShankar-ef7hr 4 года назад +6

      Democracy still in good hands of BJP , it's RIP Congress ( Om Shanti )

    • @Kas.Ali25
      @Kas.Ali25 4 года назад

      So true, Democracy is dead in India.

  • @azhadbhaiji4361
    @azhadbhaiji4361 4 года назад +42

    Illiberal Democracy and illiterate ruler

  • @hippopole9657
    @hippopole9657 4 года назад +35

    India has become most illiberal country in the world a saddest statement for everyone who respect democratic values

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      congress guru & BJP student learning tricks shown by guru congress. Why lament now when Guru congress has shown the path.

    • @hippopole9657
      @hippopole9657 4 года назад

      @motivation pirate what is the difference between Guru Congress and Shikasha learned BJP .Both are same . What Congress did damage to the country , the same path is BJP's path but one difference is it is damaging in bullet train speed.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      Ha ha ha. Pak China better than India in terms of Secularism & Democracy & hence Secularism Democracy COMMUNISTS in USA & India love pakistan & Chinese COMMUNIST party. ENJOY PAK & CHINA as they r better than India. Ask Farooq Abdullah Karan Thapar JNU AMU Jamia Milla CPI CMP Arvind Kejriwal Mamta Akhilesh Sharad Pawar. ENJOY CHINA & PAK

  • @IbrahimAv
    @IbrahimAv 4 года назад +32

    Karan Thapar deserves so much more recognition. His interviews are the best in India, if not in the world. He should probably join Ravish at NDTV. That would be a force to reckon.

    • @Atsiful
      @Atsiful 4 года назад +1

      Yes Thapar and Ravish 👍👍👍

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад +1

      @dragon Lover Kick your butt financial Times and kick your butt thapar. Who are you. Your opinion no longer matter than a common man. You can't influence now

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад

      NDTV भगाओ

    • @rahulchaudhary6740
      @rahulchaudhary6740 4 года назад +1

      What a great Idea

    • @indianindian8859
      @indianindian8859 4 года назад

      Hm they can join geo tv also 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁

  • @shahwalkhan5908
    @shahwalkhan5908 4 года назад +55

    Can't expect Godi Media to conduct such interviews.

    • @shivamanand6386
      @shivamanand6386 4 года назад +2

      What about darbari media bro

    • @Okbutiwouldprefernotto
      @Okbutiwouldprefernotto 4 года назад +2

      Print is also secretly Godi Media.

    • @Okbutiwouldprefernotto
      @Okbutiwouldprefernotto 4 года назад +1

      Shivam Anand how about you read a book.

    • @shivamanand6386
      @shivamanand6386 4 года назад

      @@Okbutiwouldprefernotto recommend

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      Karan wasting his time. He should help India by being the president of congress and PM candidate and sideline Sonia dynasty like how BJP sideline losing ADvani . Sadly congress sidelined winning Manmohan and Chidambaram & opted for inexperienced sonia dynasty to help BJP. no use of interviews. Karan heading Congress as supreme PResident and PM candidate helps than interview.

  • @harrysnuggets2799
    @harrysnuggets2799 4 года назад +8

    Not only India but United States. Both are illiberal

  • @ankitalokhande7659
    @ankitalokhande7659 4 года назад +17

    Ironical, that a good portion of comments here arguing that how this Editor from US is no one to tell us about how our country is illiberal democracy, which by in itself tells that we have become so rigid and not accepting of others' opinions (meaning we're illiberal), yet we are talking that out loud only because of the very democracy that our country is built on.

    • @jimmy_xi9342
      @jimmy_xi9342 4 года назад +4

      That's the problem...the government and the people of India dont accept t
      the problems,critical opinions and facts....
      #SabChangaSi

    • @ankitalokhande7659
      @ankitalokhande7659 4 года назад

      @Pray Hope lol

  • @nikhilwasnik5574
    @nikhilwasnik5574 4 года назад +39

    Time for indians or media to rethink their history, politics and nationalism. The condition of average indian people in all of the glorious regimes before British.

    • @TheJoker-kg9rd
      @TheJoker-kg9rd 4 года назад +2

      @sont nagda 2024 again modi will be in power😂

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад +2

      @sont nagda Kick your butt financial Times and kick your butt thapar. Who are you. Your opinion no longer matter than a common man. You can't influence now

    • @karanbirsinghbhullar
      @karanbirsinghbhullar 4 года назад +4

      @@TheJoker-kg9rd kitne paise mile

    • @karanbirsinghbhullar
      @karanbirsinghbhullar 4 года назад

      @@himdude9637 it cell aa gaye

    • @rationalist431
      @rationalist431 4 года назад

      @sont nagda seriously, that's your point

  • @rajeshbista2690
    @rajeshbista2690 4 года назад +41

    From someone looking from the outside, it pains me immensely to see the current decline of India, Indian society, and Indian economy. It seems IndiaInc ended in 2014. The Nation is close to becoming what Nehru had warned: A Hindu Pakistan. This rhetoric and divisiveness, if gone unchecked, is likely to threaten the very fabric of India's pluralistic society.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, ethinic cleansing of Kashmiri pandits 1984 sikh riots

    • @rajeshbista2690
      @rajeshbista2690 4 года назад +1

      @@jotendrakumar2852 I guess then you can go as back as 47 or Jallaianwala Bagh, or Muhammed Bin Qasim.

    • @vaibhavrothe3820
      @vaibhavrothe3820 4 года назад

      don't worry...the next elections will take care of it....

    • @rajeshbista2690
      @rajeshbista2690 4 года назад +1

      @@vaibhavrothe3820 what I'm worried about is that they are still 3.5 years away. Wonder what's gonna transpire until then. When you fire people like Raghurama Rajan, this is what happens.

    • @h1stacean
      @h1stacean 4 года назад +3

      Lol a Hindu Pakistan? Has India started killing muslims or come even close to it just because they follow Islam? Because that's what happened in Pakistan and Bangladesh.

  • @apattnaik
    @apattnaik 4 года назад +33

    Our PM should face Karan Thapar once and explain his six years achievements including those steps taken by him went against the national interest .

    • @shoebraza7199
      @shoebraza7199 4 года назад +6

      Woh apne man ki baat karte hen. Dusro ke swal nhi sunte

    • @sunirmalchakravarthi5657
      @sunirmalchakravarthi5657 4 года назад +5

      Once bitten twice shy. He is not going to come anywhere near Karan Thapar in the foreseeable future.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад +2

      why waste time of PM &Karan. It would be better if Karan is the supreme president of Congress & PM candidate to challenge Modi & sideline dynasty of sonia like how BJP sidelined losing Advani.

    • @RaviShankar-ef7hr
      @RaviShankar-ef7hr 4 года назад

      Modi has already scolded Thapar in one of the interviews.

    • @ymf7376
      @ymf7376 4 года назад +3

      @@RaviShankar-ef7hr You are a blinded bhakt of Modi without any sense of reasoning

  • @abdulwadud3495
    @abdulwadud3495 4 года назад +42

    Every intellectual person of India has been realising the mistake nation did in voting BJP to power.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад +6

      intellectuals dont vote for BJP. They vote for congress. Only nationalists vote for BJP. Sadly GURU Congress shows the way in religious appeasement, communal riots in 1947, operation blue star, Sikh riots in 1984 & the student BJP follows the path shown by congress intellectuals

    • @monojdas-gupta5918
      @monojdas-gupta5918 4 года назад +2

      I have a niggling feeling those who voted BJP are also biting their tongue. Look at the plight of the vast number of migrant workers. I am sure some of them voted BJP too. And that apart people did not have not any viable alternative. Still have not to this day . Total misrule notwithstanding.

    • @marthandsikdar8615
      @marthandsikdar8615 4 года назад

      @@monojdas-gupta5918 well you ask them now who would they vote? They will reply modiji because their hate for anything but upper caste Hindus will never let them think wisely. They know that so they dont care as long as they can inject the fuel of hatred. They will rule. It's just that today India stands isolated from all its neighbouring countries.

    • @h1stacean
      @h1stacean 4 года назад +2

      @@marthandsikdar8615 India stands isolated from it's neighbouring countries due to Communist propaganda by the 50 Cent party.

    • @Geetavish
      @Geetavish 4 года назад

      Marthand Sikdar If India is isolated we would have seen by now all the illegal Bangladeshis return to Bangladesh by now. Can you please tell them to leave the country especially Kolkata. We are tired of them.

  • @gil-nammoon3738
    @gil-nammoon3738 4 года назад +27

    So am I the only American not of Indian familial heritage that watches this frequently?
    I must say, there are currently no major journalists in the US who remotely comes close to the intelligence, eloquence and sobriety of "Sir" Karan Thapar.
    Also, I have to mention that Narendra Modi is not particularly a topic of discussion in the US, like not at all. He's generally thought of as "just another dictator" and knowledge of the subject ends there.
    Unfortunately, most Americans think of India primarily as a source of food recipes, doctors, and uh, musicals.
    I'm sorry.

    • @prashantanand6584
      @prashantanand6584 4 года назад

      Problem is that Karan would never get people in power in his interviews. As for American interviewers, I admire many late night hosts like Trevor Noah, Colbert etc who can ask serious indepth questions

    • @knightofgodserventofholymo7500
      @knightofgodserventofholymo7500 4 года назад

      No need to say sorry...

    • @chaitanyag.8415
      @chaitanyag.8415 4 года назад +1

      Prashant Anand Karan Thapar is a Joker and Congress Stooge

    • @colins3688
      @colins3688 4 года назад

      @@chaitanyag.8415 lol... of course bjp stooge

    • @colins3688
      @colins3688 4 года назад

      you are so right

  • @guruji7921
    @guruji7921 4 года назад +67

    In India At top level ---modiocracy,
    and in public -----mobocracy.
    It's very bad time of India.

    • @sunilj10
      @sunilj10 4 года назад +1

      Guru Ji and everywhere else mediocrity

    • @Kannada_First
      @Kannada_First 4 года назад +1

      👌👌

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад +3

      @@sunilj10 Kick your butt financial Times and kick your butt thapar. Who are you. Your opinion no longer matter than a common man. You can't influence now

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад +1

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, 1984 riots.

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад +1

      Joker pappu

  • @Ameen_Khair
    @Ameen_Khair 4 года назад +27

    India is name sake democracy....
    -Arrest of the protestors( lack of freedom of speech and expression)
    -Give protection to the right wing rioters(Kapil mishra, Komal Sharma etc)
    -No action on hate propaganda (example: Opindia)

    • @nachios
      @nachios 4 года назад +3

      Le mullii tu kr le mera comment reprt 😂😂😂

    • @vijendrapokhriyal6630
      @vijendrapokhriyal6630 4 года назад +5

      What about wire spread hate propoganda

    • @Ameen_Khair
      @Ameen_Khair 4 года назад +1

      @@vijendrapokhriyal6630
      Independent journalism like
      - The wire
      - The Quint
      - Lallantop
      - NDTV
      These are last hope of democracy, bcz they show facts which can't be tolerated by hate mongers

    • @indianindian8859
      @indianindian8859 4 года назад +3

      What about chota owaisi

    • @Manish_Kumar_Singh
      @Manish_Kumar_Singh 4 года назад

      Pakistan ja

  • @sujithkumar2041
    @sujithkumar2041 4 года назад +43

    It's going to be a lost decade for india, if it ends with that. Such reverse turn india has taken...

    • @SumiOccult
      @SumiOccult 4 года назад

      🤔😳😅😅😅😅

    • @Wayseller
      @Wayseller 4 года назад +1

      we have wasted the so called demographic dividend

    • @manojshetty4
      @manojshetty4 4 года назад +1

      @Darkhorse : Some people prefer seeing India as neutral, inactive and a submissive country. Sorry India has disappointed you 😆 Rise of India.

    • @abhimanyukarnawat7441
      @abhimanyukarnawat7441 4 года назад

      Ja be chakke.

    • @chanakyadevil
      @chanakyadevil 4 года назад +1

      @Darkhorse retrospective judgments are not really valid

  • @siby53
    @siby53 4 года назад +26

    India's current situation is that people like me is afraid to write a comment

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, 1984 riots.

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад

      No buddhu joker। pappu

    • @harshitjain575
      @harshitjain575 4 года назад

      That is absurd. The fact that you can comment this proves you wrong .
      Definitely India has been harsher and less liberal but pseudo-liberals like yourself blow it completely out of proportion .

    • @BabbanCarbonate
      @BabbanCarbonate 4 года назад +3

      @@harshitjain575 😁😁😁 and replies on the comments proves him right

    • @RajendraSingh-fz1zc
      @RajendraSingh-fz1zc 4 года назад

      @@harshitjain575 She was pointing to people like you only. Your intentions are not bad but there are people who thinks others are less of a citizen in our country than they are.

  • @reubenpapang5803
    @reubenpapang5803 4 года назад +37

    India is going to have the most poverty in the world per capita by the end of the year. Wah Modi!

    • @shivamanand6386
      @shivamanand6386 4 года назад

      Toh kya tumhe RBI chairman bna de

    • @anshuecon
      @anshuecon 4 года назад +10

      @@shivamanand6386 This is the RBI's own assessment. Stop blaming people who state facts. Bahot ho gaya

    • @astuteobserver1603
      @astuteobserver1603 4 года назад +2

      @@shivamanand6386 agar himmat hai toh Subramanian swamy ko finance ministry banao. Truth is modi hates any expert opinion

    • @Atsiful
      @Atsiful 4 года назад +3

      Sadly that's going to happen

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад

      @@astuteobserver1603 Kick your butt financial Times and kick your butt thapar. Who are you. Your opinion no longer matter than a common man. You can't influence now

  • @bhaskarganguly9643
    @bhaskarganguly9643 4 года назад +4

    What a fantastic interview..for a change, Karan Thapar didn't interrupt much which was a relief!..and Ed Luce was brilliant..on both India and USA.. thanks for this.

  • @creditnc9669
    @creditnc9669 4 года назад +17

    When I hear that india is the biggest democrasy in the world . I think this is the biggest false explanation in the world.

    • @avinashray2213
      @avinashray2213 4 года назад +1

      Dude get some English lessons ,your grammar sucks

  • @rajenpd.1843
    @rajenpd.1843 4 года назад +79

    Who is responsible for this situation? The so called "बहुत ही समझदार जनता, जो सब कुछ जानती है"

    • @janami-dharmam
      @janami-dharmam 4 года назад +15

      We ourselves; politicians are simply using us. We do not see what is good for the nation as a whole and are only concerned about the caste and local politics.

    • @pardeepsingh4459
      @pardeepsingh4459 4 года назад +5

      @@janami-dharmam It's true,

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад +4

      Pappu joker। gaddar hai

    • @vaibhavrothe3820
      @vaibhavrothe3820 4 года назад +1

      janati to germany ki janata bhi thi...lekin ab us pe thukti bhi nahin hai....

    • @MADoctorstrange
      @MADoctorstrange 4 года назад +3

      @@chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 Is he PM?

  • @mohdashraf7986
    @mohdashraf7986 4 года назад +36

    Democracy is evident in KASHMIR, and eye opener for the world

    • @ayushtripathi9969
      @ayushtripathi9969 4 года назад +4

      @vikash ranjan chup reh andhbhakt

    • @sunirmalchakravarthi5657
      @sunirmalchakravarthi5657 4 года назад +3

      vikash ranjan Modi is winking at all of us! Wake up and smell the coffee.

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад

      @Shahid Farooq Kick your butt financial Times and kick your butt thapar. Who are you. Your opinion no longer matter than a common man. You can't influence now

    • @singh-eg5ow
      @singh-eg5ow 4 года назад

      Jaha ye jamat jayegi waha shandidut hi milenge jaise lashkar e taiba mujahideen inka promotion sirf isis aur talibaan me hota hai

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      Ha ha ha when 3 lakh kashmiri pandits were driven out of kashmir the world closed its eyes. How will they open it now. KAshmiri muslims says that Kashmir is only for Muslim & not for other religions. Proves Islamophobia is a drama as most OIC nations don't give equal rights to other religions. where is democracy in Islamic world sirji.

  • @babaribrahim151
    @babaribrahim151 4 года назад +7

    A very balanced well thought analysis.
    Unfortunately whats happening in India is equivalent to what was happening in
    Nazi Germany
    Fascist Italy
    Apartheid South Africa
    Nationalistic Yugoslavia (Serbia)
    All failed.

    • @rajchowdhury3006
      @rajchowdhury3006 3 года назад +1

      Same thing happenned in Bangladesh(east pakistan) with systematic genocide and persecution of bengali hindus, but bangladesh iz not a failure in such sense, so success or failure s'd not be yardstick of an oppressive nasty regime

  • @adityakumarkashyap92
    @adityakumarkashyap92 4 года назад +102

    अब देश को आतंकवादी क्या बर्बाद करेंगे उनसे बढ़िया काम तो देश के न्यूज़ चैनल कर रहे है।
    1.Zee News 2.Aaj Tak 3.News 18 4.India Tv 5.News Nation...ets

    • @roushankumar199
      @roushankumar199 4 года назад +17

      Ndtv,the wire, the quint also🤣😂🤣

    • @palaksingh7016
      @palaksingh7016 4 года назад +24

      @@roushankumar199 you don't need to laugh at your own jokes.

    • @sumittomer4586
      @sumittomer4586 4 года назад +11

      @@palaksingh7016 hello mrs liberal , ndtv ,wire ,quin , print is an anti national and biased news rooms they run agenda against India , you fool people's support them

    • @sammishak4035
      @sammishak4035 4 года назад +13

      This govt has destroyed all the institutions of this nation. Fools are Andhbhakts.. they have made a man bigger than the nation. Insult to all the freedom fighters and leaders who build this nation.

    • @palaksingh7016
      @palaksingh7016 4 года назад +2

      @@sumittomer4586 ‘against india'...

  • @vksharma7956
    @vksharma7956 4 года назад +9

    Thanks Mr Thapar Thapar for presentation of this high level transparent talk as usual.

  • @Vicdhinsa1495
    @Vicdhinsa1495 4 года назад +11

    That’s an interview! Very enriching experience. Karan a show host par excellence. Congratulations.👍🏼

  • @hippopole9657
    @hippopole9657 4 года назад +27

    I feel sad to hear the statement India has become the most il

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, 1984 riots.

  • @rizwanullal726
    @rizwanullal726 4 года назад +11

    Dears - Is it true American Army landing in India...if it happens our country will be the next Yeman, Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan...list continues...see their situation now.

  • @qaroonthapar
    @qaroonthapar 4 года назад +2

    This is true journalism. Factual and honest! Kudos to the wire and Karan Thapar.
    I wish in times like these he had a show like his ‘hard talk’ back on air, for a world that needs to know the truths and the ‘hard truths’ of politics, economics and world affairs

  • @Manish_Kumar_Singh
    @Manish_Kumar_Singh 4 года назад +8

    Democracy is a system of governance
    Being conservative or liberal is the democratic choice of the people.
    And i don't choose Librandu government

  • @syedamjad7694
    @syedamjad7694 4 года назад +31

    Where is Democracy ? and false Media.

    • @TheJoker-kg9rd
      @TheJoker-kg9rd 4 года назад +11

      Ye jo gaali dete hona government
      Aur bolte ho 15 min k liye police hata do dekh lenge..
      Yeh hai democracy...
      Agar koi dusra desh meh bolte .. toh dikhte nahi uske baad..

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад +1

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, ethinic cleansing of Kashmiri pandits 1984 sikh riots

    • @samkubrick7510
      @samkubrick7510 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/d4P7XX3yiWg/видео.html
      #independentfilmmaker #freedomofpress
      This is a short film based on the voilence of Jamia Millia University and North East Delhi .
      How the despotic regime threatens the preamble of our constitution. And when students protest against it, they used lethal force to suppress the voice of the youngsters. The police force enters into the library and bashed with lathis and tear gas. Their batons break their bones, but their spirit of revolution did not break.
      When the helpless and innocent souls were crying for help as the North East Delhi were blazing in hatred of politics.once again human shamed mankind.

    • @Scientist1351
      @Scientist1351 4 года назад +2

      Same as secularism in quran

    • @badkarma1425
      @badkarma1425 4 года назад

      Saudi Arab aur Pakistan me democracy hai. Jao vahan ab..

  • @sharadamberkar3926
    @sharadamberkar3926 4 года назад +6

    Sir,illiberalism mostly began with Advani's Rath Yatra, and ,under Modi it is reaching to sky.Demolishing of the Babari Mosque is the glaring example of Indian illeberalism and thus the brainless Hindutva leaders have laid a foundation for division of India and thus Lal Krishna Advani has emerged as its Chief Architect.

  • @hyogaraj5036
    @hyogaraj5036 4 года назад +5

    When you people still have the freedom to talk and comment on India, how can you call this illiberal democracy?

    • @omersallam794
      @omersallam794 4 года назад +1

      Ask the minorities of India how liberal Modi is and ask the Kashmiris how their civil rights have been respected. You are masters of hypocrisy this is all about the jealousy of the USA of the growth of China.

    • @calm_compost
      @calm_compost 4 года назад

      @H Yogaraj What a weirdly odd thing to say. Almost sounds like you created these people and by your grace you gave them the freedom to talk. It's the fundamental right of anyone born on this planet you idiot. Geez...the level of ego....😲

  • @sainair
    @sainair 4 года назад +5

    Excellent Interview. I would like 'The wire' to interview the ex- Financial Times Correspondence of India, James Crabtree on the topics concerning post covid economy, resurgence of foreign investment (if any) etc. It would be interesting to know his take in these issues.

  • @totalinsight9888
    @totalinsight9888 4 года назад +2

    Spot on Edward Luce. Is our own 56 inch Windbag listening?? Excellent analytical interview . Lago raho Karan.

  • @monojdas-gupta5918
    @monojdas-gupta5918 4 года назад +8

    It is absolutely correct to observe that India is a nebulous ally not only to USA but every nation great or small. Whether that is strength or weakness of India's foreign policy can only be judged at the hour of the need as we find ourselves now in.

  • @AbhishekPandey-jt7co
    @AbhishekPandey-jt7co 4 года назад +2

    We don't subscribe to the idea of liberalism of west. What's left, right and liberal and conservative for US aren't the same for India.

  • @shaikhshahid329
    @shaikhshahid329 4 года назад +5

    If karan thapar interview load with English subtitles,it could be easy for many indian viewers,to got through his interviews...Hope @the wire will tale note of it 😊😊😊

  • @rsjha4933
    @rsjha4933 4 года назад +14

    Who cares it in India? We are slowly losing our freedom.

    • @bashirk5898
      @bashirk5898 4 года назад

      What is your real name ?

  • @eComy
    @eComy 4 года назад +6

    Right, there is no freedom, welcome to the ram rajya. First Muslim started to say but now whole country has started

    • @souvikkundu4058
      @souvikkundu4058 4 года назад +2

      Don't cry! UCC & population control law is coming ✌

  • @rumelaguha4722
    @rumelaguha4722 4 года назад +3

    Good job Karan...!!! It was a very interesting interview. You formulated the questions well and let the guest answer in a proper manner.. kudos to you. Well done.. Keep it up.
    That's the Karan I want to watch more and more... Take care.

  • @shahwalkhan5908
    @shahwalkhan5908 4 года назад +11

    BJP/RSS/MODI has completely destroyed India's integrity, Unity, Fraternity, Economy and most importantly LOVE for each other.

    • @nachios
      @nachios 4 года назад +2

      Kat mulla bola🤣🤣🤣

    • @TheJoker-kg9rd
      @TheJoker-kg9rd 4 года назад +1

      Waah ab modi ne kiya.. aisa kya kardiya bhai

    • @simpslayer7664
      @simpslayer7664 4 года назад

      @@nachios Chutiya Hasaa.....

    • @nachios
      @nachios 4 года назад

      @@simpslayer7664 to baap ko bol chup reh😂😂😂😂

    • @anirudhroy6124
      @anirudhroy6124 4 года назад +1

      Yes brother you are absolutely right...
      Modi government destroyed India's integrity by having the feeling of "sub ka saath sub ka vikas" and building millions of home for poor peoples under "pradhan mantri awas yojna" on the basis of their religion. Isn't it???
      Modi destroyed India's unity by building World largest statue of unity of Sardar patel(Iron man of India), by using the money of the public but not in the form of tax but in the form of donations bu making trust.
      Now India is developing and buying new weapons and investing around 3 to 6 ℅ of its GDP in defence for protection of our Fraternity.
      Economy is one of the major issue since 1947 and surely government will tackle this one day for this you have to also work for your own and for this nation.
      And at last LOVE so this will always remain there, if it is not then why would I typed this whole explanation for just explaining some random person....
      Asking questions and criticizing government is the practice of democracy.... But blaming government for everything is just an excuse some one making for not fulfilling the required duty and responsibility of a citizen.
      I hope this much make you feel comfortable 😊😊. Jai hind Jai Bharat. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @samajikgyan-sudha8552
    @samajikgyan-sudha8552 4 года назад +2

    Self reliant nations are the strongest. Historically speaking, the countries were rich and there were no FDI in those times.

  • @sunirmalchakravarthi5657
    @sunirmalchakravarthi5657 4 года назад +14

    An excellent interview that was informative and so meaningful. Just what the ‘Godi’ media will never learn or do.👏👏👏

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      Karan wasting his time. He should help India by being the president of congress and PM candidate and sideline Sonia dynasty like how BJP sideline losing ADvani . Sadly congress sidelined winning Manmohan and Chidambaram & opted for inexperienced sonia dynasty to help BJP. no use of interviews. Karan heading Congress as supreme PResident and PM candidate helps than interview

  • @kamalikapoddar
    @kamalikapoddar 4 года назад +2

    Wow!!!! This is amazing. The video spoke of so many facets of the growing discord with China, US upcoming elections and Trump's single-minded strategies to get reflected, the implications it means for ongoing border escalations and yet, India's changing political landscape and hindutva was the only thing people commenting here picked up.
    Just wow... What blind faith does to you. 🙄

  • @beingakhiL
    @beingakhiL 4 года назад +34

    its a 'Bananna Republic'.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      why cry as the guru congress shows the path & student BJP follows the path of guru. Remember emergency, operation blue star, 1984 riots.

    • @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360
      @chandrakantpolticallatestn1360 4 года назад

      Pappu joker

    • @manofsan
      @manofsan 4 года назад

      you have bananas in between your ears

    • @samkubrick7510
      @samkubrick7510 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/d4P7XX3yiWg/видео.html
      #independentfilmmaker #freedomofpress
      This is a short film based on the voilence of Jamia Millia University and North East Delhi .
      How the despotic regime threatens the preamble of our constitution. And when students protest against it, they used lethal force to suppress the voice of the youngsters. The police force enters into the library and bashed with lathis and tear gas. Their batons break their bones, but their spirit of revolution did not break.
      When the helpless and innocent souls were crying for help as the North East Delhi were blazing in hatred of politics.once again human shamed mankind.

    • @colins3688
      @colins3688 4 года назад

      i wish. that would mean that we grow bananas to export.. we export nothing, we create nothing but hate.

  • @happy2help1947
    @happy2help1947 4 года назад +7

    Our good PM didn't have guts to face an interview with Mr. Karan Thapar. We had the old record. 😡😠🙏

    • @rohitn8536
      @rohitn8536 4 года назад

      Is Karan thapar is god??? what did Karan thapar asked Sona..did he asked questions about it?

  • @nimishjyotineog6919
    @nimishjyotineog6919 4 года назад +5

    Journalists in true sense...

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      no point . Better if Karan heads congres as supreme president and pm candidate. Sonia dynasty helping Modi win.

  • @ratnakamal1
    @ratnakamal1 4 года назад +1

    Yes, we need people like these to constantly hold a mirror to our faces so that we try to remove the blemishes. Thank your critics for this service, don't blame them.

  • @SinghalLouis
    @SinghalLouis 4 года назад +8

    Bhai sahab kabhi kabhi hum GPS (Google Play Store) strike bhi karte hai.. cloud radar technology aur surgical strike China mein nahi chalta na.. samjha Karo

  • @Chucku153
    @Chucku153 4 года назад +1

    MR LUCE IS VERY VERY ARTICULATE AND VERY KNOWLEDGEABLE!!!! BEAUTIFUL INRETVIEW!!!

  • @malikxec2108
    @malikxec2108 4 года назад +6

    Oh my God the whole world saw the height of illiberality India in Delhi under lockdown arresting those who r questioning Caa law

  • @milindmatang
    @milindmatang 4 года назад +1

    The real question is why liberal democracy lapse into fascism?

  • @siddharthb2633
    @siddharthb2633 4 года назад +6

    Our guy has a degree in "entire political science".
    Modi has calculated everything.

    • @shalashu1954
      @shalashu1954 4 года назад

      siddharth b bro was just waiting for any1ne to write this

  • @bjpwin24
    @bjpwin24 3 года назад +2

    Never seen such type of unpleasant interview in our country 😡
    The worst question, facial expressions and try to knock down other person in sharp, mean less question….! Same done with mr modiji long time b4.
    Well, must be blessed by Congress

  • @EverestClimberNo1
    @EverestClimberNo1 4 года назад +3

    The title defies the reality on the ground.

  • @virendrakumar-motivatorcoa2495
    @virendrakumar-motivatorcoa2495 4 года назад +1

    With all due respect to both of you, how this democracy can be illiberal when this interview and all the material which is done by Wire is seen and heard all around. Each one of us is free to criticize Modi and people do it openly without worrying about any repercussion. Now, if you say that one can be violent and talk of hoodwinking the system then that is possible in Banana republic only and not in India. All those people who are trying to break up India from inside and by taking advantage of the system should be brought to justice. Democracy is fully functional in India and laws are amended through constitution only. Now if someone is not happy with the rule of law it is his problem, not ours.

    • @MohiyuddinShaikh
      @MohiyuddinShaikh 4 года назад

      A journalist has been killed in UP last week for exposing a sand mafia which has connections with the government. Journalists trying to question the government on national television have been thrown out of the channel ( Abhisaar Sharma ). Protesters are being imprisoned with no explanations under the Draconian UAPA. The PM of the country does not come forward and condemn the hate speeches and hateful actions ( Saffron flag on a mosque minaret ). This country is headed towards dictatorship and I believe it is because of so called educated people like you who choose to remain blind to that very fact. People like you are letting my country down.

    • @virendrakumar-motivatorcoa2495
      @virendrakumar-motivatorcoa2495 4 года назад

      @@MohiyuddinShaikh Thanks for your comment and I appreciate it. You will agree that country has to be governed and it is not a pleasant exercise. I am not talking of particular issue but tell me how the rule of law can be enforced if people are not ready to follow the rules passed by parliament . Have you seen the violence in UP ? People firing on the roads , throwing stones on the roads, putting anti national slogans , talking of cutting off India in multiple pieces. For 48 hours in UP, there was no governance. Now if you are SP of a district what will you do ?Tabiligi Jammat spreading virus all around . I do not say that they had support of all Muslims...Doctors beaten in all over the places ....Moradabad , Indore ....You can blame me personally but what will you do with these people. What is the role of educated people in Muslim community? Now, if you say that your country has been let down , please let me know who has done it and what you are planning to do with them ?

  • @saddammansuri9503
    @saddammansuri9503 4 года назад +10

    Good journalism's

    • @jajwalyajoshi5437
      @jajwalyajoshi5437 4 года назад

      Poora video dekh toh lo.....34 mins....btw you mean journalism??

  • @kamalikapoddar
    @kamalikapoddar 4 года назад +1

    The Marshmallow test of instant gratification!!!!! Like

  • @the_mani
    @the_mani 4 года назад +5

    Keep looking for Validation from West.

    • @sunirmalchakravarthi5657
      @sunirmalchakravarthi5657 4 года назад +3

      Modiji does the same: what do you think Namaste Trump and Howdy Modi was all about?

    • @adamharris1406
      @adamharris1406 4 года назад +2

      Not from the west but from the world.

    • @jaigagandeep.s5100
      @jaigagandeep.s5100 2 года назад +1

      @@sunirmalchakravarthi5657 building mutual trust

  • @SajidKhan-jg8bk
    @SajidKhan-jg8bk 4 года назад +2

    Correct, India getting to be a police state.😡😡😡

  • @Shankar-Ayala
    @Shankar-Ayala 4 года назад +4

    signature music is superb👌👌👌👌

  • @AuditorInvestor
    @AuditorInvestor 4 года назад

    Excellent interviewee. Please bring in such quality voices. He has accurately pinpointed the problems with India.
    There is a basic disrespect for foreign capital.
    The key problem is the BUREAUCRACY, which has destroyed the country's potential since 1947.

  • @adityakumarkashyap92
    @adityakumarkashyap92 4 года назад +7

    अरे मतलब माँ भारती के बेटे साम्प्रदयिक होते जा रहे है...मोदी है तो मुमकिन है।।😊

  • @monojdas-gupta5918
    @monojdas-gupta5918 4 года назад +1

    This is a most candid lucid and brutally honest assessment of India and USA alike I have the pleasure of hearing to in a very long time. My wish to KT concentrate on your core competence instead of spreading yourself thin on mediocre studio parrot panelists.

    • @nachios
      @nachios 4 года назад

      Mulle resevation chodh na fire

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      very candid but does not help. Karan should be heading congress as supreme president and pm candidate. congress sonia Rahul r helping Modi as they are not experienced like Karan.

  • @drahmadali9752
    @drahmadali9752 4 года назад +5

    Natural partners term is highly unnatural in geopolitical discourse

  • @niks1298
    @niks1298 4 года назад +1

    This is the problem with most of the media houses. Either they have become pro Modi or anti Modi where unfortunately facts are twisted to align with narratives. That’s why it is no wonder that you will hardly see anti government experts in pro modi news channels and vice versa.
    Amidst this paranoia and extremism of both ends, The Print channel especially Mr. Shekhar Gupta’s coverage seems a bit old fashioned but sensible and logical and as much as unbiased as it can get in current polarised world. So far The Print seems to be able to manage the unbiased reporting. Hopefully it does not lose track as well in this world of information overload and propaganda outreach.

  • @EXPLORADVEN
    @EXPLORADVEN 4 года назад +6

    😂😂 "India's world's largest illiberal democracy" - says the world's worst illiberals.
    Or in other words - making progress and countering millennia of degrading narrative as well as hogwashing & supplanting of real history is being illiberal in the neo-liberal, post modernist's world view.
    Well justs at the moment I saw and heard the phrase, I stopped watching the video and came here to comment after login in, to show my illiberal attitude liberally. 😋😋
    BTW if anything that has brought us Indians to this situation, it is our agen old attitude of tolerating non-sense thrown at us by intolerant - leftists, communists, socialists, Khan-grust party, self appointed intellectuals, so called opinion throwing media, cabal of islamists & evangelists running amok using conversion funding NGOs, etc.
    If we would not have tolerated them at the first place we would not have, self declared morality appraisers calling our biggest illiberal democracy and smilling idiotically with incisors baring bunny (rabbit) smile, once in while in a youtube video 🤧🤧.
    Tolerating intolerant beings long enough makes the whole world intolerant. Better is to call a spade a spade and ignore the intolerant being perennially to take away the importance they get, which they don't deserve.👊👊

  • @avinashchaudhari1878
    @avinashchaudhari1878 4 года назад +1

    Bharat should be declared Hindu nation. Dose Liberty mean freedom to support enemy? If yes then it is better to be stamped illiberal.

  • @ravigupta4252
    @ravigupta4252 4 года назад +6

    Modi ke andh bhakt nhi manenge

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 4 года назад

      Sir, think, Modi dumped losing Advani and opted winning Modi in 2014 while Congress dumped winning Manmohan Chidambarm and opted for inexperienced sonia Rahul and helped Modi win. So why blame Andh Bhakts. please tell congress to dump sonia family and make Chidambaram Supreme PResident and PM candidate of congress to defeat Modi. If not, then again Modi. Why blame Andh Bhakts as they can't see.

  • @TheSASAH1993
    @TheSASAH1993 4 года назад +2

    Very good and honest presentation

  • @adityarajsubham721
    @adityarajsubham721 4 года назад +3

    Hahaha.
    Ye to dhoka hai yaar .
    Atleast find a critical personality to run such a notion for or against India.

    • @damn738
      @damn738 4 года назад +3

      hmm paani milega karan .
      bss dosti bni rhe 😂😂😂😂

    • @akshayah10
      @akshayah10 4 года назад

      @@damn738 yet sad , one is PM of a country and one is a liberall youtuber

    • @shashikantthorat1897
      @shashikantthorat1897 4 года назад

      Edward Lucas is antinational🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @majorrachie
    @majorrachie 4 года назад +1

    People who are criticizing india here including this gentlemen are welcome to think but they should look at their own countries, what they have done till now in syria, Iraq and other places. India is a proud liberal democracy and multi religious and ethnic strong country from the time you were eating grass !

  • @naarumanchimuralikrishna4369
    @naarumanchimuralikrishna4369 4 года назад +1

    Highly ridiculous calling India illiberal democracy... India is the most liberal country in the world with abundance of freedom, infact unmatched freedom vs any country across the world...
    Its meaning less for Karan Thapaar to post such videos on social media calling India illiberal... I wud even term it is irresponsible for KT to post any such thing calling India illiberal...

  • @balajis914
    @balajis914 4 года назад +2

    Well Said Crude Leader of Illiberal Democracy. Even Courts are intimated.... It will remain Country of Tomorrow which will never arrive

  • @amshehzad1677
    @amshehzad1677 4 года назад +1

    You're one of the best Thappar. Much respect from Pakistan.

  • @bidyutchatterjee7195
    @bidyutchatterjee7195 4 года назад +1

    Karan is basically a great Librandu !!

  • @RR_theproahole
    @RR_theproahole 4 года назад +1

    India had been isolated in its own neighbourhood. The anti muslim policies has angered muslim nations and Sri Lanka and Nepal are now with China which has grown manifolds in the same time than India and irony is this is happening in Narendra Modi's tenure who spends his time mostly on the foreign tours.

  • @atultripathi1372
    @atultripathi1372 4 года назад +2

    Britishers teaching true democracy to the world???

  • @mayavalecha7786
    @mayavalecha7786 4 года назад

    People of China and India should pressurise our governments to stop any further fighting. We the people on both sides want peace. The area that is full of glaciers, uninhabited and ecofragile should be declared as No Man's Land. Poet Atal Behari Vajpayee wrote, Hum Jung Na Hone Denge.

  • @karansomwanshi9386
    @karansomwanshi9386 4 года назад +1

    Sir please give subtitles to conversation it will be definitely work for aspirants

  • @vishalgupta-ul7wz
    @vishalgupta-ul7wz 4 года назад +1

    Atleast those responsible for chaos and anarchy in highly disturbed places in the world and carrying burden of racial segregation dont teach us what democracy stands for , we have problems in the country but atleast we havent created geopolitical situations all around the world that led to breeding of violent militias, see middle East.

  • @raildiaries5989
    @raildiaries5989 4 года назад +1

    It's a great achievement slowly we are moving towards Hindutva

  • @umar_mughal.3861
    @umar_mughal.3861 4 года назад +2

    BLACK LIVES MATTER.
    I CAN'T BREATHE, I CAN'T BREATHE.

  • @sashibhusanbarik8535
    @sashibhusanbarik8535 4 года назад +1

    American democracy is best in the world. Is not it? The great love and respect, they continue to shower on blacks should be learnt from Americans.

  • @Kas.Ali25
    @Kas.Ali25 4 года назад +2

    As soon as a top western news paper editor is giving views on current govt, all BJP IT Cell is at work in comments section justifying and supporting BJP govt.

  • @mukeshdhaniramsingh3410
    @mukeshdhaniramsingh3410 4 года назад +1

    karan your audio quality is very poor of every lockdown video, please improve it, thanks sir

  • @shakshakir6941
    @shakshakir6941 4 года назад +2

    India is a Bagger partnership The name is Mootri wine 🍷 for Trump

  • @windswept17
    @windswept17 4 года назад

    Edward Luce is an impeccable reporter with spot on, incisive analysis - this truly was an amazing interview

  • @ureklaviya5536
    @ureklaviya5536 4 года назад +1

    Even he says our prime minister only jst has a smart theoretical strategy....waah modiji waah.....

  • @DrSBHasan
    @DrSBHasan 4 года назад

    The Guest is very candid in assessing the present situation in India. He very rightly remarks that the world at large and US in particular does not cherish the illiberal policies of the Indian Govt as a result of which there is very little trust as no businessman likes to invest in a place where there is social and political turmoil. Trump like Modi because he finds in him a reflection of himself- a man who is in search of more and more power at any cost and does not relish any opposition.

  • @subhasisghosh66
    @subhasisghosh66 4 года назад +1

    You know what is illiberal? The fact that Smt Nidhi Razdan gets an Asst Professor job in Harvard, without any teaching experience or a published peer reviewed paper, while poor Shri Thapar is sitting in his home wearing a jacket and a bow tie (and maybe only shorts below) and the closest he gets to USA is this interview with a journalist? That is illiberal!

  • @harekrsna2721
    @harekrsna2721 4 года назад +2

    Politicians are same whatever country they belong to..! Everything they do or say is to help them win elections..

  • @anilkumarbhatnagar9677
    @anilkumarbhatnagar9677 4 года назад +1

    So funds nahi milte hain toh illiberal otherwise liberal.

  • @subhrajyotilahiri6721
    @subhrajyotilahiri6721 4 года назад +2

    If there is mobocracy then Anti CAA protest would be the mobocracy .......India don't work on mobocracy because today Modi's speech didnot take on China he is cautious of every move than the popular mob demand that is pay back China in blood ....No ..he plays cautiously ..it's more a psychological game between Leaders ..sometimes no decision is the better decision .

  • @poonamsinha9027
    @poonamsinha9027 4 года назад +1

    Well-articulated Mr Luce.But it's the people of India and not Modi who have written epitaph for the Left

  • @sarojprajapati7890
    @sarojprajapati7890 4 года назад +1

    Very nice.

  • @vinayantb4474
    @vinayantb4474 4 года назад +1

    Well evaluated the situation in India

  • @syview
    @syview 4 года назад

    Dear Mr Thapar, I have a suggestion. The pitch of your voice is on the higher side. And the end of your sentences usually taper down in volume so often, you are not heard as well as you should be in the interest of the audience. I think it might help you if you wore your mic closer to the mouth than it is at present. In this video particularly, your sound issues stand out because Ed Luce has a strong voice and he is understood very clearly - from the first word to the last in each sentence.