Delhi Riot Survivors Feel 'Abandoned and Stunned': Farah Naqvi to Karan Thapar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024
- The activist and author Farah Naqvi, who has visited some of the riot-affected areas of Delhi, says: “Muslims feel scared, vulnerable and threatened in Modi’s India and are reduced to second class citizenship but the CAA protests are a significant turning point. They are reclaiming their citizenship and other rights.” In a 50 minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, she spoke at length about what she has seen and learnt in the riot-affected areas but also about what it feels like to be a Muslim in Modi’s India.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/sup...
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewir...
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewi...
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
![Yailin La Mas Viral, @kreizyk.official - Dale 2 (Remix) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JaYHBzgqz94/mqdefault.jpg)
Bold, Courageous and a real "HE MAN" Journalist, who knows how to dissect a situation practically. People and Politicians need to understand it for their own survival even.
😂😂
Grievest misery is experienced when family members are made to wait for days for the postmortem of a family members body who was killed in a riot.
Compassion seems to be extinct.
The lady is absolutely right. Media coverage always either by choice or necessity tend to be sanitised. She is again painfully right when she says what victims feels like abandoned by their own country.
@I D Don't be stupid.No one wantsr Sharia
this is the type of conversation we want, we need....beautiful. Thanks #KARAN #THAPAR JI
Delhi Police are criminals that’s why they got beaten by Delhi lawyers sometime ago. Now I got the picture. The full picture might show the lawyers, the ministers and the HM and PM as criminals too. Real Heroes are social workers and the followers of insaaniyat principles...🙏🙏🙏
In 2002 Gujarat govt give 03 days to communal people to revenge Muslims,likewise this time Delhi police handlers give enough time to raitors to evenge
Godhra kand began after Muslim burnt two bogey's of hindu. Every action have a equal and opposite reaction.
@@Arjun147gtk
It is still an ambiguity who burnt those bogies ! Foreign journals from Europe indicate their fingers on fringe elements of RSS.
Go ahead get sharjil Imam and Pathan did you say anything about these guys and what right do you have to block traffic for 70 days
@@antxaveace it seems like people will believe foreigner when the point is in their favour. I wonder how accurate are the foreigner? Once European had a survey of how insecure india is for women regarding rape, and it was above 70% insecure. Later came to know the participants were European of strength around 600. We don't live on the judgement of other, have some backbone and live upto your expectations.
A Beautiful stunning video . A wake up call to all sensible sane Indians .
Here in Bengal, particularly where I live, we have a Muslim neighborhood and we live together in peace and harmony. There has been no problems whatsoever and certainly Muslim people do not feel 2nd class citizens here. Also the fact that we don't really care who is what. We are Bengalis, we're Indians and that's what matters. We work, we earn, we eat, we celebrate, we help each other out and we are kind to each other.
Actually, a lot of people in Delhi said the same thing - that they lived harmoniously for decades. Turned out that there were people who were only pretending to be tolerant.
💜🌹🙏🌈
@@JonathanNeilRhodes The attack was all pre planned and intentional for Delhi. People came from outside of Delhi. Stones and other weapons were brought in from outside. People don't have tonnes of stones handy for 'just in case' situations.
I saw the interviews of the residents of different areas that were attacked, both Hindus and Muslims told that the people they saw attacking were not locals ... they were outsiders! ... Go figure !
@@yogitasharma9120 Yes
Just wait for bjp to come
These are 2 individuals ,did the riots in Gujarat in 2002 . They looked the other way when Gujarat was burning . Judges of courts are behaving like enuchs watching the fun .
This is one of the most memorable and impactful interviews I have ever had the privilege of hearing...not because of the interviewer but because of the interviewee...Karan is very eloquent and has very good command of the English language unlike most of his compatriots in India, but then he is also full of himself (and too British for my liking)...Ms. Farah Naqvi is something else...I now have a tremendous amount of respect for this elegant lady, her ability to analyze and express...I am an old Bombayite living for the past 44 years in the U.S. and nowadays an avid seeker of news from my motherland...Over the past few years I was feeling very warm towards Mr. Modi and what he was trying to achieve in India, especially regards mitigating the plight of the poor and efforts towards national sanitation, etc....But Farah has given me a deep yet subtle peep into the psyche of the Muslims living in India that I feel very few ever can...as an educated woman that could make any nation proud, even though she likely hails from a privileged background, the way she explained the state of mind of the common Muslim in India today facing the barrage of Hindutva slogans and imagery, this is indeed an eye opener, and I am eternally grateful to her for this...her explanation of how her mother always wore the bindee, and so did she till her experience analyzing the Gujarat riots, is quite enlightening...an identity of an educated and brilliant Indian woman being reduced to a Muslim first, then woman, then Indian, is quite sad and a painful insight into the state of affairs in India today...I still believe we cannot blame Modi directly for this, but surely he is responsible for this since he has not muzzled the parade of idiots in the BJP that parrot just the wrong things about the denizens of a proud and most universal of all countries on the globe today...these idiots mouthing on behalf of Modi are the lowest on the totem pole of understanding of the universal nature of all of India's great leaders, saints, mystics and sufis...Unless Modi brings his cadre under his direct control and sacks every police official/political leader responsible for last week's unfortunate Delhi mayhem he should be booted out of office at the earliest opportunity...and I was thinking India had finally found a great leader !!!!!
While I go with almost everything that you wrote, I am amazed that a horrible massacre of Muslims in Delhi had to happen to change your opinion about the PM as otherwise you believed he is the greatest PM India ever had. Sad!
@@lailajoseph2759 at least he is willing to recognize the follies of this administration, there is a larger base out there which is in fact happy that one again Muslims have been shown their place.
Sir, Modi can be directly blamed because he has tacitly remained silent of what his ministers have been saying n doing. I refuse to believe he is so weak a PM who can't reprimand his ministers. By keeping silent he is pandering to bigotry of his base.
Your analytical mind and pure soul has penetrated deep in karan as well as farah's.
@Arun Someshwar ji
>> I still believe we cannot blame Modi directly for this, but surely he is responsible for this since he has not muzzled the parade of idiots in the BJP
This is like saying , I still believe we cannot blame Hitler directly for the gassing of the millions !!!
Wake up Sir and overcome the delusion of your infatuation with Feku.
An interview which has the potential to change the life of listeners !
MARIAPPAN TENNYSON ... really? I watched while interview. It’s a conversation between a Muslim lover and a Muslim.
@@sravanvedala7811Exactly
Really a game changer interview .
@@sravanvedala7811 It is a conversation between a Humanist and a lover of humanity.
@@sravanvedala7811 no no its an interview which makes of andh bhaktss asses burn very badly...also it reminds some years back this interviewer makes ur feku to drink water and then suddenly he left with half interview...it reminds us all those cartoon of godi media anchors who does fanatic cartoon show everyday on their channels...so this interview if for human not for andh bhaktss...but what to do still andh bhaktss comes here to watch real news
I know this is an aside, but I really like Farah Naqvi's accent: sophisticated and clear, whilst being distinctly Indian. Beautiful!!!
Do u fancy going to a police station (42.02) lol
Excellent interview and honest interview enjoyed , suggestions are excellent too
A comprehensive analysis of the recent planned attack on Delhi, protest reclaiming new horizon, and the current situation of a particular specific community. Thank you Karan for hosting Tarah naqvi who is an honoured human being who sheds light to the path of liberals.
Taiyab Ali Faizan not only planned but it was well planned and orchestrated pogrom
@@ssinvllc bade bade desh me chote chote pogroms hote rehte hai.. chill
h mcmaster paid BJPee IT Ce!!
@@ssinvllc BJP is rich but not rich enough to afford my time.. it all for the love of hinduvta and hindu rastra
h mcmaster lol 😝
Good Interview. Interview karne ka art Mr Karan Thapar se sikhna chahiye.He knows his job very well ,Clear, transparent and to the point.
Karan sir Why you ask about the compassion of PM towards victims? You already knew that PM has no regard even the HM towards the people..
Remember "Dosti Bani Rahe".
well said... by the way didn't Modi showed any Compassion or Sympathy towards Victims of Gujarat?
i think that's a Million Dollar Question! stay blessed!
Compassion is a word that doesn't find a place in modi's lexicon.
@Mohini S are you Justifying?
@Mohini S
Se; this is what the revange follows with you.. You take an example which do not have any relavence with current issues..
In 1947 both the sides were affected not only one side..
India before independence and pertation is different than one now..
Simply writing "we the people" deosnt mean you have clear faith in this.. "We the People" is title of our democracy and it was written after the 1947..
This is how BJP's mentality always remain executing their hatered.. When one expect them to show condolence for the perticular issue on humanaterian grounds then they go 200 years back and ask to show ours condolences for that time when even our ghosts were never born...
Showing one wrong thing of the past never justify you are right at this time..
At least have some Ethics and logic..
Go and check yourself on Humanity Scale..
Shame dear..
@Mohini S This is the reason how BJP's and anti national elements utilises these boneheaded people for their use to spread hatered towards one community.. Babar did this Aurangzeb did this in 1947 muslim did this.. and what are you doing now..?
If some one speaks against Modi it goes directly to one religion..
😊😊😊
Just go and read the history every thing what RSS and BJP teches you is not correct.. atleast do some efforts to find truth..
Calling Police on # 100 for 72 hours and police does not show up or instead the Cops shows up with more rioters is the EPITOME of GUJARAT MODEL!
Farah Naqvi is candid in saying what it is like for a .Muslim to live in Modi's India.😥😥😥
You are being punished for the crimes your prophet Muhammad committed. He has ordered women to be stoned to death. Denounce, disown and disassociate yourself from Muhammad if you want to lead a life of dignity in this nation.
@@keyurpatel503 u r mad. N the ones u follow. N I am not muslim
ya in modi s india they can say all antinational things still wire supports them.In modi india they can block roads for 70 days.in modis india they can block roads of metro just to gain attention and defame india.ab kya chahiye suna hai five percent reservation bhi mil raha hai maharastra me muslims ko.ab kya muslims ka kaam hai darna.aut tum jaise media toh unhe roj darate rahoge.sach bolu dange la ek reason wire bhi hai.din raat minority ko darata rehta hai.kitno ki ctizenship gayi abhi tak ?
@@footballforyou8856 ...Modi's India....hahaha...like - Modi's underwear...you are quite naive...
@@vaibhavrothe3820 how naive.talk on facts.when you watch the wire you are not going to be happy in modi era.never.so dont blame on modi blame on what you watch.you become ultra extreme left.
We proud of you medum, people will remember you, so loong, I always see your debet, you are the hope, whenever I see you my hope, still alive, to fight with the nation dividing people.
Karan thappar is a true journalist
Add 1 more
ruclips.net/video/ETR_EIFUtAE/видео.html
Worst journalist India has ever seen!
@@devikaanil6866 Karan or Dhurv - Which 1 (Y-mostly coz... Understanding their journalism takes certain intellectual skill) wats Ur excuse 🤣🤣🤣
RUclips Commentor A true journalist would not take sides.. his work will be impartial.. Watch Karan Thapar’s history.. he is anti Modi and hears only that he wish to hear.. the person who leads others by reporting shud be the kind of person who has overcome his own internal enemies like a prejudiced, partial mind...he should reassert his own humanity and shud have openness to new experiences....not a one track mind......he is seeing Modi as his enemy and is fighting against him.. little he knows that he nurtures prejudiced attitude and failed to fight against his own flaws and internal enemies...let him be impartial and report from every perspective.. then he will be a true journalist...
Modi is the enemy outside him.. his true enemy is inside him - it is a prejudiced mind .. amount of work he has done till now, says that aloud about him...
Wat a shame on seeing India burning at the hands of its govt. When can v prosecute those in power. This is so frustrating seeing our people hurt n a govt day could care damn than their agenda. Unbelievable at the level of hatred spread by govt.. when a company fails v blame the CEO. So when country in burning we should blame the leadership. The worst President to head India too. Sad day. Our innocent people....Lord have mercy on our people in India
go read the book Delhi riots and stop listening to KT..hes paid by foreign NGOs to make hindus look bad..infact throughout the interview he is putting words in her mouth ! they absolutely didnt talk about how muslims were getting prepared for a all out war, how there were petrol bombs, stones, molotovs, pistols found from a muslim councillors house, home umar khalid and his whatsapp chat confirms he was talking to tukde tukde gang, separatist and taking orders..(pre planned riots to make india look bad as trump was visiting)
Sad to hear the lady views.
Talking of compassion from PM and Home Minister who hands are full with blood from Gujarat. What can you expect from them.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO sick
Good one @KaranThapar 👍
Karan, this interview was too good, and Farah was very honest. But I wonder would this do any harm to the central government rulers,
As I view this video, my heart hurts, tears in my eyes and my faith on social govt systems shaken.
❤️😢😞 feel the same way
You are human being with human soul . Your mother has raised you well. Modi is a human with rakshas soul. Hope someday you shall rise to a position to educate modi and his bhakts how to be a human and how to be striving for Maryada Puroshottam.a human with highest good
behavior.like that of shree Ramchander jee
go read the book Delhi riots and stop listening to KT..hes paid by foreign NGOs to make hindus look bad..infact throughout the interview he is putting words in her mouth ! they absolutely didnt talk about how muslims were getting prepared for a all out war, how there were petrol bombs, stones, molotovs, pistols found from a muslim councillors house, home umar khalid and his whatsapp chat confirms he was talking to tukde tukde gang, separatist and taking orders..(pre planned riots to make india look bad as trump was visiting)
Institutional authority has gone and it's time to hit streets ....
AAP has proven to be B Team of BJP and Kejriwal has shown his shameless lust for power ..
Congress is the only party which has taken a strong and clear stand on CAA NRC and NPR. Priyanka Gandhi has been active in UP and been face of Congress in Delhi too. They need to get their act together .. sack Rahul Gandhi who has proven to be a useless politician and get Priyanka out on the front ... People need leadership and she has it ..
Rahul simply doesn't ..
The way Syed Shahabuddin wrote an article in the year 1980 on the riots in Moradabad in Sunday Weekly by the heading, "Let Me Cry For Moradabad", I found the same sombre words used by Farah Naqvi and Najeeb Jung in interviews to Karan Thapar. They have put their hearts on their sleeves. I admire and adore all three of them. Nobody else could do the same except for Harsh Mandar of late who has incurred the wrath of the Political Masters of BJP. I salute Harsh Mandar for doing so as he did for Indian Muslims and the entire Ummah owes thanks and gratefulness for the compassion and empathy of this mortal human being at the cost his life. Hats off to him.
Police busy snooping like thier boss...how wud they respond to 100 !!
Thank you Mr Thappar for this enlightening conversation.
THANK YOU FOR THIS INTERVIEW IT RE INGNITE THE HUMANITY WE NEED TO LIVE FOR NOT HINDUTVA KILLING OF SOME ONE OF DIFFERENT FAITH> WE ARE DESTROYING BHARATMATA. SOOON NO COUNTRY WILL SEE INDIA DEVELOP .WE SEE IT NOW NO COUNTRY IS WILLING TO INVEST OR SEE US DEVELOP THANK YOU MODIJI. USA JAPAN UK GERMANY FRANCE WILL GIVE LIP SERVICE BUT NOTHING MORE. NO WONDER TRYING TO BUY FRIENDSHIP BY BUYING WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION WHICH WILL DESTROY HIM FINALLY.WONDER WHO ARE THE FORCES WHO PLANTED ACID BOTTLES AND STONES ON TARIK ROOF TOP NO OTHER THAN BJP HINDUTVA GUYS SHAMEFUL THIS BJP TRUE
What a pity, people in general don't even have any expectations from a particular Govt(system)! This feeling of hopelessness in the mind of common man is very very dangerous for the entire country. I need not elaborate further. I would like to sum up with one of my Urdu couplets:
Hisaar e lafz (ambit of words) mein har shai (issue) kahaaN samaati hai !
Suno, ke meri kh'moshi (silence) bhi kuchh sunaati hai. !
حصارِ لفظ میں ہر شے کہاں سماتی ہے!
سنو، کہ میری خموشی بھی کچھ سناتی ہے
(ارشد کمال)
Notwithstanding the above, thanks a lot for a very useful and enlightening discussion.
What a beautiful couplet 👌👌👌
@@priyaaditya309 Thnx for your kind words.
jihadi
Karan Thapar loves Muslims, he is extremely passionate about them, he loves what they wear, what they eat , what they speak and how they live. Actually he was a Muslim in his previous birth and by mistake he was born as Hindu in his present life.
Your Best Interview I liked was with Modi as Gujarat CM... Tooo Good
Her voice trembles when she recall the views, she's speechless she sound lost, broken, betrayed... A common feeling of riot victim...
Kejriwal we though u r PM material. But u lack guts. We will have to look for or may b produce yet another leader.
ruclips.net/video/ETR_EIFUtAE/видео.html
Mauth sab ko aayegi zaalim ki bhi zulm sehne waleki. Jo log eh murders karre Ya karrethe unke gharomebhi aisa maatam chayega. Insaaf is duniya me nahi to us duniya me bohot bura hoga. Us duniya ka aag kya hi jalkar Bataana tum raakh bankarbhi cheekh maroge. Insaaf to hoga.
Dekho m apki photo p Jake apke comments dekh sakta hu.. Aap bhi mere photo p Jaye or mere recent comments dekhe.. Or fir btaye kya m it cell s hu.. Muje nhi Jana apka address bus it's okay comment p likhdo.... m samghuga aap muje pehachan gyi.. Tc behn or ek baat Har Hindu nhi hota bura.. Jab koi Islam k bare m galat kehta muje bhi dukh hota.. Agar bagwan bhi apke khilaf hoga m apka sath duga
Ek bar bat to krlo..Allah apke sath h behn fir dar kyu.. I like u a lot.. Your comments show lot of pain and honesty.. I like u a lot.. Tc abb m or comment nhi kruga.. Tc
Thank u Farah and Karan fr bringing out and speaking out the truth till the time we have people like u we will believe in secularism thank u again
Very nice discussion 👌
When the AZZADI slogans travelled to Delhi, so did KASHMIR.
you are really stupid, azaadi from bjp and it is hatered politics that bjp did since 1992,
If we analyzed since 2014 did government care about jobs economy womens safty country prestige. 1 word we lost everything each day.
Very well said
What does all this says about Media.....the Bhakt media, Dalli media, Giddha media, Bahramman media.....Speak up against Bahramman media.
Nice discussion , thanks to Karan and Farha Naqvi , Farah has articulated feelings of muslims as Indian citizens very well.
BJP and RSS ideology is not based on hindu religious ideologies as because the fundamental ethics of all religions and I repeat all religions are peace and harmony undisputedly. The BJP and RSS ideology is that only these people have the right to exist and under this cover they are using the hindu religious sentiments. It is not only painful but it is dangerous for the whole of humanity. Hatred, fear and despair will not be in the interest of the country as a whole because there are places where either of the community lives in minority and they will remain under this psycho.
ENLIGHTENING DISCUSSION.
DELHI CM MR KEJRIWAL WOULD HV DONE SO MUCH TO THE VICTIMS. HE IS AFRAID OF USELESS HOME MINISTER. JE SHOULD HV SEND POLICE TO CONTROL R IMPOSED CURFEW. HE LOST PEOPLES CONFIDENCE. I DON'T KNOW HOW HE WILL GET PEOPLES CONF. ONCE AGAIN.DELHI PEOPLE VOTED FOR HIM N GAVE SO MUCH LUV N AFFECTION. NOW HE LOST EVERYTHING. BEING A CHIEF MINISTER HE WOULD HV GAIN MORE N MORE CONFIDENCE BY HELPING THEM SO NOW WHAT HE CAN EXPECT ??????
THE INTERVIEW EXPOSES THE LACK OF HUMANITY ,ETHICS EMPATHY IN ALL OF US BE HINDU MUSLIM CHRISTIAN AND EVERY INDIAN LIVING IN INDIA.ONLY GOD CAN SAVE US FROM TWO MOST HATED CHARACTERS FROM GUJULAND
Any comment on the fate of Ankit Sharma and how he was killed?
this bjp made our country like seria and pakisthan-
hahahahaha singh sahab i request you to come pakistan and see the hospitality of PAK, otherwise ask those who have been here
Pakistan is not like that dumbass. We dont kill our minorities. It only happens in your Bharat mata
@ji sadhu ruclips.net/video/ue040bufNhM/видео.html
As ever very eloquent conversation brokered by Karan
One commie interviewing other so heartfelt and touching to watch them assist each other during the whole interview. Good job wire as long as you exist india will see what it should ignore and not believe.all the best.
So you say we believe on what the Aajtak and Zee News mongrels bark? Or have faith on the words of those filthy pigs - Modi and Amit Shah?
You could sense the coordination here on what they were conveying to the public. But could you not sense the venom and hatred this Bhajpa government fills in the hearts of those misdirected youths who are holding sabres and katta revolvers at a time they should be holding pen?
Majority of educated youth don't have this unidirectional mindset of hatred that Modi has propagated. His creed is uneducated and crude and he is making full use of them. Use sense and ethics. May be you'll have a clearer sight of what you are seeing today.
put educated people in administrative system from lower to high hierarchy, not on basis of running,
What ever good laws are enacted, as long as scoundrels are at the helm of affairs, nothing good can happen.
Learned people are discussing. Very nice. Uneducated people are ruling. Excellent. Common people are thinking how to get justice. Situation continues, discussion continues, unethical ruling continues.....The big question is Who can give justice and When?
I saw her debate on ndtv where is desperate to express her view which is not possible in limited time...where as here she not only expressed here view precisely but shared here emotional touch as well...kudos to this lady
Well, thanks for this interview, Karan. The story is getting clear day by day. What you see on videos ...You have Chand bagh video where even Muslim ladies in Burqa have seen stone pelting the policemen, cornering them and probably ultimately leading to the killing of constable Shyam Lal, injuring the police officials, you have Tahir Hussain, Shahrukh Khan, Shahnawaj Khan doing what they were assigned to do...Do you see any Hindu mob pelting on police ..now if you say Muslims have lost the property...I think the situation very clear that who started the riots, who got prepared in advance with storage of stones and acid bombs etc .....if the entire purpose of this interview is to say that Muslims feel threatened and abandoned .....must be after the riots ...maybe the innocent one who did not have the guts to stop the community rioters .....The fact is that genuine Muslim leadership has failed the community and I include Farah Naqvi as well...Karan ...will you take the interview of the family of Ankit Sharma as well who was killed as part of target killing. Yes, I do blame the police ...they should never have allowed the Shahin Bagh ab initio but the journalist like you would have made a lot of noise if ladies there who did not have the clue of CAA, were to be uprooted from their illegal occupation of public property...Fact is that Indian journalists have a lot to answer for instigating these riots and now shielding the real culprits now. These attempts are bound to fail.
Superb sir
You have to understand the cronology. We have a PM and a HM who rose to power on the back of a riot which happened in 2002.
You have to understand the cronology of this numbers
1984 + 18 = 2002
2002 + 18 = 2020
Gujarat model has come to a full cycle. It has reached Delhi.
2002 mei Gujarat mei karaya
For 0 ko 2 ki jagah aur 2 ko 0 ki jagah hone tak ka intezar kiya
2020 mei Delhi mei karaya
Such a farsighted bastard we have as our Prime Minister!
Example for Godi media , Great Journalism sir 🙏🙏🙏
We have failed as humans. Leave aside faith and national lines, we have truly failed as humans, all over the world.
Oh sad humanity. I can’t believe all this is happening in 2021.
I must confess that despite Right hand side(logical) brain of Karan Thapar always on hyperdrive, this is the most humane version of him, I have watched till now.
Save india. Not by comments. Tweet .. let them know. Unite.
Agar in politicians Ko hosh mei Lana hai to aap logo Ko economy aur unemployment per regular sarkar Ko gherna chahiye.
This is exactly the current dispensation want this particular community to feel, unfortunately.
Kejriwal proved that he is not leader, he is still behaving like exicutive
Kejri is keeping healthy distance from mullahs these day.. he know the consequences otherwise
@@hmcmaster3941 he is now full fledge politician. For him power matters rest can be negociated.
As Muslim I don't believe in broader because my religion Islam always talk about One Muslim Umah but Let's Agree my brother and sisters of Islam that the ideology of Jinah was Absolutely right May Allah Help our Muslim brother and sisters in India what this lady have been saying it is absolutely Alarming
I won't reply because as the great Jinnah said you people are undecidable
For us Islam is the way of life not just religion
And as my religion don't allow me to say anything bad about other religions so I won't say anything about Hindu religion
Humanity should be the highest dharma
Indian Media is still reporting inaccurate numbers for 1984 Anti Sikh pogrom victims:official figure 3.350,independent estimates between 8000 to 17000. There were 5000 victims in New Delhi alone!
Sikh Army officers returning home from duty were killed on trains and stations,no effort was made by even the Indian Army to investigate what happened to them! If politicians, media and religious zealots from whichever side do not stop fanning flames of hatred, India's plight will be very bleak ! Unless people of all backgrounds come together and rescue India from clutches of extreme communal narratives India is doomed! India will no longer be able to blame Pakistan for its own feeble weaknesses and India's image will be severely tarnished in the global community!
BJP and RSS supported the rioters because of support for Kerrijwal. President Trump in town and Muslims blood spill over in Delhi. Shameful leaders of the largest democracy and world should open their bloody eyes. I salute Trump as he has guts to praise Pakistan and Imran Khan.
The sound of silence is greater then voice.....
.
If you are attached for no reasons of yours, only because of your particular religion and what if the party to which you have gone all out to bring in power has discarded you, and when the police was standing on the rioters side,then there is not only fear but physcosis in the people.
We are the crying fishes shedding our tears in the ocean and no one can see or wipe it.
I strongly request the Christian community to join all such protests on a regular basis n join voices ! They seem to be missing in action . Don't think NPR n CAA will not be for you. They will surely tsrget one community at a time.
THIS IS D REAL ART OF INTERVIEW WHEREIN D INTERVIER IS GREAT,CLEAR AT HIS HEART.KARAN APPEARS AS GREAT HISTORIC BEING HAVING AN INTELLECT OF SARBAT KA BHALLA WHICH IS THE FIRST AND LAST GOAL OF SIKHISM.HE REPRESENTS REAL HINDUISM WHO STANDS WITH MUSLIMS IN THIS HOUR OF CRISIS
FARAH WAS AT HER BEST WHEN SHE ANSWERS THE QUESTIONS. HER PAIN AND AGONY BRINGS THE TEARS THROUGHOUT THE INTERVIEW. CLARITY OF THOUGHT AND FEELINGS R AT PAR EXCELLENCE
Video problem , for much part of the interview only black screen but audio is ok !
i like your Guts and way of taking interview Karan Thapar
While the topic of this interview is really lovely and I highly enjoyed listening to Farah Naqvi speak , unfortunately I could not fully enjoy this interview with Karan constantly interrupting her and over talking while she's speaking and it felt like listening to nails on a chalkboard due to the frequent interruptions and overtalking. Listening skills are very important, not just talking. This is my polite request to please let the interviewee speak uninterrupted and finish their point before the interviewer poses the next question or statement in any future interviews, thank you.
Thank you very much for unearth the reality of the Delhi riots...... One thing which really hurts is intimidating the poor muslim women and children by so called public seviour...
This is the worst, what can happen to a nation.
Kejariwal lost the love of the people who liked him till a week ago. He didn't show the mettle/courage of becoming a real leader of people of Delhi when needed most. He lost his moral authority to lead even the People of Delhi what to think of India.
@Arun Kumar . By that logic Modi lost the love in Gujarat in 2002. But he still won elections.
Totally agree..He lost the chance to show the nation that he was a leader of mettle.Do disheartening...where do we go from here..no strong opposition , no person to lead in these chaotic times ?
@@Dumbliberal Gujarat was not under such scrutiny..there was no watsapp , not so much social media and no viral videos uploading events live.The media was easily controlled then , not now because there is independent media . The shadow of the Gujarat riots will always follow Modi and now the Delhi riots will follow Kejriwal.
hela6208 . If you are pointing out the differences the first and major one is that Kejriwal doesn’t have the state police under him. Where in Modi did have that in 2002. So even Kejriwal wants he can say some brave words wouldn’t mean a thing when it comes to managing the issue cause police is under shah. Delhi is the only state where police under central. And one more thing. We select our government the reason we dnt have strong opposition is cause we have signalled them in last 6 years that whatever bjp does we are with them. The opposition took notice special after 2019 election. We knew we are selecting bigoted people. Mob lynching was rampant in last 5 years. There was no growth but we lied to ourselves cause most of the Hindus do want Hindu rastra. Or at least some kind benefit compare to other religion. It wasn’t Modi won some seats he kinda nailed it. So whatever is happening is cause majority are bigoted.
@@Dumbliberal true.There seems to be feeling that in the case of the majority a sense of that it is now our turn to rule or be an in your face majority.I feel that many believe that the hindu way is under threat.Appeasement to minorities , education to the poor ,women in the workforce and in places of authority , modern ways of thinking and now with whole world opening up to people who before stayed quiet in their slots of the indian caste system, is creating upheavels. Many want the old ways , back to times when everyone knew their place and stayed there.Thats why the harping to ancient glory days and sanskriti .It doesnt help when various self styled gurus and godmen add their narrowminded views to the mix.These are indeed very difficult times.
39.39 No Sir, not every neighbor, still many more Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Parsis, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists, Mulvasi who don't respond to the agenda are very Soft & Good. I do work on the ground with many people. Hate is there but still, we can save our country.
Politicians and Miscreants often tend to Manipulate the poor and the needy to fullfil their political agendas. Its a shame how a wall has been created between once brothers and now defined as a hindu or a muslim.
Although being a muslim i never go to the mosque for prayers neither i celebrate eid. I see all religions at the same and treat everyone equally. But Travelling to any part of the country is now scary. Even if i just went anywhere as a tourist, my heart would be afraid and avoid going anywhere because of the gruesome hatred spread everywhere in the country
Fara Naqvi and Karan Thapar did not talk about the inflamatory and hate speeches of Waris Pathan or Akhbarauddin Owaisi,
How shameful is this for Indian democracy
Quite an interview!
We think karan is the jaichand of media world ...but there are many many who feel proud of hindu bashing and maligning India ...for money of course ...has he converted to Islam ... think so but do we care 😤
KUDOS! HEARTFELT & INSPIRING!! The incident of offering of apple in a train… TELLS A TON about the prevailing mentality then, but much more - NOW! A century and quarter ago, a letter was written by a man born in a HINDU family, to a MUSLIM friend, in India: -
My Dear Friend,
I appreciate your letter very much and am extremely happy to learn that the Lord is silently preparing wonderful things for our motherland.
Whether we call it Vedantism or any ism, the truth is that Advaitism is the last word of religion and thought and the only position from which one can look upon all religions and sects with love.
I believe it is the religion of the future enlightened humanity. The Hindus may get the credit of arriving at it earlier than other races, they being an older race than either the Hebrew or the Arab; yet practical Advaitism, which looks upon and behoves to all mankind as one's own soul, was never developed among the Hindus universally.
On the other hand, my experience is that if ever any religion approached to this equality in an appreciable manner, it is Islam and Islam alone.
Therefore, I am firmly persuaded that without the help of practical Islam, theories of Vedantism, however fine and wonderful they may be, are entirely valueless to the vast mass of mankind. We want to lead mankind to the place where there is neither the Vedas, nor the Bible, nor the Koran; yet this has to be done by harmonising the Vedas, the Bible and the Koran. Mankind ought to be taught that religions are but the varied expressions of THE RELIGION, which is Oneness, so that each may choose that path that suits him best.
For our own motherland a junction of the two great systems, Hinduism and Islam - Vedanta brain and Islam body - is the only hope.
I see in my mind's eye the future perfect India rising out of this chaos and strife, glorious and invincible, with Vedanta brain and Islam body.
Ever praying that the Lord may make of you a great instrument for the help of mankind, and especially of our poor, poor motherland.
Yours with love,
* * * * *
Today, in 2020, does it look even more relevant; or an eye opener; or an inspiration; or a caution for course correction, or prophetic - depending on the mentality of the reader?!
If you didn’t know who wrote it, or guessed it (correctly, or not), this letter was written by the legendary Prophet and Pathfinder, SWAMI VIVEKANANDA, from Almora, to Mohammed Sarfaraz Husain of Nainital, on 10 Jun 1898 [vide The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda - Volume 6, Epistles - Second Series- Letter No. CXLII]
For those who may not be familiar with the Sanskrit terminology, Swami Vivekananda essentially preached, both in the East & West, and strived to bring out, in a manner which even a child will understand, the universal truths in ‘Vedanta’. It is ‘Veda’ + ‘Anta’ - the end (anta) portion literally, but signifying the essence, of the ancient Vedas. Vedanta is also known as Upanishads. Vedanta has three basic forms or approaches- Dvaita (dualistic path), Vishishta- Advaita (qualified non-dualism) and the highest, A-dvaita (Non-dualistic path or Monoism).
These are mutually complimentary in a spiritual seeker's progress.
Nowhere has Swamiji talked of anything called ‘Hindu Rashtra’ - being fantasized by some weird section of the populace! The term ‘Hindu’ itself is nowhere in Vedanta. In fact, Swamiji has brought out that it is of a much recent origin, merely due to historical/ geographical reasons [based on the river Indus - Sindhu, in Sanskrit - introduced by the ancient Persians, who pronounced the ‘S’ as ‘H’ - (refer The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, Volume 3, Lectures from Colombo to Almora - Vedantism).
In 1897 he said in a prophetic mood that if you work for the motherland you will get freedom in 50 years (and we all know it did happen in 1947!). But he knew that during his lifetime, the countrymen were too much degraded in spirit and energy, and the time was not yet ripe to handle independence. It had to wait. Furthermore, he told that even after getting political freedom, true freedom of citizens will come only if good amount of spiritual progress takes place in the people. He said, “…Before flooding India with socialistic or political ideas, first deluge the land with spiritual ideas. …” [refer: The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda - Volume 3 / Lectures from Colombo to Almora / MY PLAN OF CAMPAIGN (Delivered at the Victoria Hall, Madras)]. He had cautioned that the whole of Europe is sitting on a bomb which can explode anytime - World war I & II happened. He told communist revolution will come from the East- either Russia or China. He had foreseen the huge potential of youth in India.
Hope and pray this 'small' letter of Vivekananda, though a century and quarter old, ALL THE MORE TODAY in 2020, will:
* STRENGTHEN and INSPIRE all who follow, and support, COMMUNAL HARMONY in our democracy;
* WARN/ CAUTION those who don’t- the gang which recognises communities by their ‘clothes', or eating biryani, or Poha, Shamshan-Kabristaan, Taj Mahal- 'Tejomahal!'...etc etc etc - to make serious COURSE CORRECTIONS;
* Be a PATHFINDER (Maargdarshak!) for the fence-sitters!!
Don't tell one side story
What happened dahli its organize by modi gov't and authorities fully supported
Why do you think "15min ko police hata do" And "15cr 100cr pe bhari padenge" does not lead to such things?
I don't understand why media is focussed on coronavirus while India has such a major problem, we need to protect our minorities. The basic thing is, we are not a Hindu country. If we don't change our mindset towards minorities, how will we be different from Pakistan.
Coming to police, filing a case is difficult irrespective of religion.
मुझे गर्व था भारत एक सेक्युलर देश है । लेकिन अभी शर्मिंदा हूं कि मोदी को हमने प्रधान मंत्री बनाया है जो मास मुर्डरर है।
Keep burnol with you modi haters.
Now we people of delhi know who is doing such riots.
Going by your standards for a second class citizens, Hindus in many many parts in india have been second class citizens for years. I urge both of you to travel West Bengal, and move out of kolkata when you're here, and go to the border districts. Probably you'll get a slightly wider space to construct your opinions. Yes, what happened in Delhi, the state has to take responsibility. Having said that it doesn't not surprise us from this part of India.
Excellent talks.
Brilliant stuff Karan am a huge fan of Farah Naqvi she makes very assertive points that should strike our collective conscience
KARAN SIR N MAM FARAH NAQWI GREAT. DISCUSSION IS VERY MUCH SOOTHING. I.ACCUSE MR KEJRIWAL. HE WOULD HV DONE A LOT BY HELPING THE VICTIMS WHAT THE PM N HM HAS NOT DONE.
Gujrat 2002 has been repeated in Delhi 2020 by Ranga-Billaa of bjp
Each and every word resembles the stories of 1984. Those were even worse as there were no cell phone those days. I think Center government should delegate the police authority to the Delhi government.
On a second thought our kindly lady is being too charitable. Abandoned ? If the ugly truth be told the matter is much worse. Country, ruling administration, institutions, who is supposed to protect the innocent careworn victims has actually red in fangs and claws turned on to them. Every right thinking people amongst us, hand on their heart should feel belittled by it. It is a day of national shame.
I agreed on almost everything that the both Farah and karan said till the moment when Farah argued the saheen bag gathering was protesting against the decision on article 370 and ram mandir verdict.if we come in streets for religious angle to all decisions which have no impact on our lives we might end up being in state where protest holds no meaning but dissent.also i contest the idea that you have to examine all government policies and court verdicts through the lens of religion.your seeing abrogation of 370 exclusively as attack on Muslims not as a measure to enhance national security and integrity (which is debatable) proves the larger point that muslims can't see anything other than as a muslim,which as farah pointed out,she has huge disagreement on.
they shouldhave exerted moral authority..
The point about "bindi" is so true! I cannot rationally explain why I refuse to wear the bhagwa today simply because it is now part of symbolism that I refuse to be part of. When things to return to normalcy, I will adorn bhagwa as much as I adorn blue or white or black today.
Police is always unprofessional. In Punjab too, they act at the behest of the political masters and their goons and the land grabbers. I speak this of our personal experience. They have sold out their uniform to the Political masters for favours and to the Goons for exponential gains.
Shame RSS agenda. SHAME BJP.
yeah. yeah... nowadays anybody can make narratives, and score TRP . there should be regulations to hold these types of senseless traitors responsible & action taken.