We Were RIGHT! Every Episode Reviewed - Doctor Who 2024 Season 1 | Review / Reaction -The Movie
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 июл 2024
- Here's a compilation of all of our reviews for Doctor Who 2024 Season 1 or series 15 in an epic LOTR extended edition length movie. We were right all along so its validating so see people slowly turning our way after the finale disapointed everyone
Join Steven and Dan as they tear Season 1 2024 apart and do a breadown. Did they like ANYTHING?
#DoctorWho #EmpireOfDeath #RubySunday 
Развлечения
We hope this compilation video helps out anyone that missed our earlier reviews and also those that like some longer stuff.
Also HUGE THANKS to everyone that helped us hit 2000 SUBSCRIBERS!
Very cool!
Feel free to subscribe if you haven't already to help us out
Kinda baffling that no one picked up on the lack of character depth and tension throughout the whole seasons scripts and didn't think to add in even a single tiff
Woah. Mega longform content. Finally something I can fall asleep to
I missed your earlier reviews so now I can listen on a road trip haha!
Because Ncuti was filming another show, RTD didn't have him on screen long enough to build his character or his relationship with Ruby. He got around that by just making them besties from the start, but it felt forced and strained for the entire series. We were supposed to believe that because they were both orphans and LGBTQ+, that would be enough to have them insta-bond, but that's not how anything works. That was the main problem with every episode. 'They Just Did' was used over and over again, and we weren't supposed to notice the massive plot holes. How did he get there? He just did. How does that make sense? It just does.
A few years ago there was a film maker in the downhill bike racing scene who very obviously had a thing for one of the riders. He made a few movies about him, full of long slow close ups and lingering shots. It looked good for 5 minutes, but it became really dull after that. That's what RTD is doing with Ncuti. He likes to watch him smile, dress up, dance around the sets, and cry, so that's what we're getting. The stories are secondary to his fawning.
"The stories are secondary to his fawning." ???
And Ruby is not LGBTQ as far as we have seen so that's not true, she's an ally but she herself is straight as far as we know.
@@friendlyotaku9525 pretty sure its been made clear that she's fluid.
@@tussk. It has not, one of her friends is trans and her adopted mother had a girlfriend but Ruby herself is straight as far as we know as in 73 Yards we see her dating different people who are all men.
@@friendlyotaku9525 i dont think you know what fluid means. ruby is bi.
The fluid girl was in "The Pilot" heh heh heh puddle girl joke
Amazing
I watched the entire video in one sitting and loved every second. I could listen to you guys talk for hours, and did!😂
The scenes early on in the season with the doctor and ruby were pretty good and a big step up from the non companion connections in the chibbnall era, boom is fine, 73 yards also fine, legend of ruby Sunday also fine, but unfortunately the finale ruined it for me, the way they ruined suetekh and the empty mystery boxes just made the season a waste of time really, much like the finale of season 6 made that season redundant ( he was in a robot suit garbage cop out). The doctor not wearing his proper outfit was super annoying and really annoyed me when he wore it in the last scene of the last episode....The way this season was promoted was pretty bad also, just davies everywhere talking nonsense and turning people against the season even before it started, guy needs to give hes ego a rest and let the actors and his leading star, THE DOCTOR take the helm as he should be ..
Might I ask, how did they ruin Sutekh exactly?
"davies everywhere talking nonsense and turning people against the season" examples of this if I might ask?
@@friendlyotaku9525 his moronic and hypocrite claims of the sonic looking like a gun then literally has a child character shooting a machine gun at a living thing in the finale, saying that were all equal then has a scene at the end of the star beast where the female characters chastise the doctor for being a male and saying how he should have stayed a female and the doctor stands there like a plum taking it looking a fool, saying the classic writers were wrong and 'old fashioned ' to have davros in a wheelchair ( even though it isn't one ) and being hypocritical having davros in his own season in his chair and having an actual villain IN a wheelchair in season 2 and much much more. As for suetekh he's ruined because of how easily and ridiculously he was defeated making him look super pathetic and making any future threat's irrelevant
@@phantomsidious2934 "his moronic and hypocrite claims of the sonic looking like a gun then literally has a child character shooting a machine gun at a living thing in the finale" While what he said about the sonic was odd neither of these things are comparable since the latter was a life and death situation.
" saying how he should have stayed a female" this is never said.
"saying the classic writers were wrong and 'old fashioned ' to have davros in a wheelchair ( even though it isn't one )" Davros's life support machine functionally serves as a wheelchair.
"being hypocritical having davros in his own season in his chair and having an actual villain IN a wheelchair in season 2" ...back in the mid 2000s, his views will obviously have changed since then.
"suetekh he's ruined because of how easily and ridiculously he was defeated" you could say that about any Doctor Who antagonist though, especially when the stakes are super high!
@@friendlyotaku9525 they literally said he should have 'stayed as a women', just because other villians have been defeated ridiculously and stupidly doesn't mean it's ok it KEEPS HAPPENING!! Your suppose to learn from past mistakes and DO BETTER!!! Plus suetekh was super powerful and wiped out the universe with his dust and he stands there with a dog lead on he can't get rid of? And Davros's chair isn't a wheelchair, it's a life support travel machine, half of what kelads will end up in, are they offensive to? Never seen a wheelchair that looks like that before.
@@phantomsidious2934 they do not say this, Donna says "shame you're not a woman anymore, because she'd have understood".
"he stands there with a dog lead on he can't get rid of?" Because it's intelligent rope, which is designed so it can't be destroyed or removed by the target and usually I'd have an issue with this but I don't because it has been set up since the Church on Ruby Road with the Intelligent Gloves (invented by the Doctor) so those are essentially a Chekhov's gun!
And Davros's life support travel machine is functionally a wheelchair, it might not have wheels but it is a chair designed to support a disabled man who was badly injured at some point during the Kaled-Thal War.
RE: Dot and Bubble. Black person here. I immediately picked up the fact that everyone was white. I always notice that in media, but it struck me as unusual in modern Who, because RTD has always made a point to have multiracial casting. At first I thought it was simply an oversight, but as the episode went on, I thought it they might be AI avatars or something. But the reveal contextualized so many previous elements. I wish the rest of the season had been as well crafted…
The stepping on the butterfly is a time-traveling trope from "A Sound of Thunder" by Ray Bradbury.
And if you look at all the work of RTD back to _Queer as Folk,_ Ruby is a continuation of his archetype I call Little Red Riding Hood, in the context of Bad Wolf. Rose 0 from _QAF_ and _Bob and Rose,_ Rose 1 by Piper, Rose 2 by Finney, and Ruby _(Rubia_ means blonde in Spanish). There's also Little Red Riding Hood All Grown Up, _c.f._ Donna and maybe Amy, depending on how tight RTD and Moffat were.
The series was terrible.
The doctor cries more times than he actually saves the day.
He was totally useless.
"We were right all along" So you went in with a negative bias anyway so you never actually gave it a fair chance? I really don't like that approach since no matter what because of that bias you're always going to end up feeling that way because you've convinced yourselves that you'll feel that way.
@@friendlyotaku9525 nope, we went in very hopeful but the problems that we saw in episode one and talk about in the first review are the same problems the show kept having every other episode. It's unfortunate
@@burgunbeerd Still, I think that affected bias somewhat. I just tend to critique media very differently, with every episode I always go in with zero expectations and want to be surprised.
Though out of curiosity what problems were those? Genuine question.
@@friendlyotaku9525 they're all in the video for your viewing pleasure
@@burgunbeerd maybe if I have the time.
Well acted, well directed, well written, good themes, not really a single bad episode. Critics and audiences both seem to agree. There’s really not a reason to dislike the season except for bigotry.
ruclips.net/video/2sRS1dwCotw/видео.htmlsi=B4hvUx2Go6EEqHOY
What planet are you living on, most of the audience hated this season and rightly so, nobody wants to be lecturered to every 5 mins
This whole video gives an in depth reasons why this season had bad things in it, like most people do, if you just label someone with a word then you clearly are just a baby, listen to the criticism and understand most are just critiquing the episodes for legitimate reasons, season was far from perfect that's a fact, and you can find hundreds of reviews online from level headed fans why this season didn't work, stop spreading dumb shit
I see that you're not a Slayer fan. They have good songs that are well written, well played and the guys in the band are really nice. Most metal and rock fans agree. If you don't like them, you must be a bigot.
See how stupid you sound?
I just want to apologise on behalf of the other commenters for your debilitating deaf and blindness - I hope you're getting support 😢