Food Theory: Can You Bake Cookies from Cookie Dough Ice Cream? (And Which is Best?)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 ноя 2021
  • Holiday Theory Wear is Here! ►► creatorink.co/l6s
    SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►► bit.ly/2CdCooV
    Disclaimer: Typo at 8:49 -- the Ben & Jerry's container is 16 oz, and the Harris Teeter container is 48 oz
    Today we're testing one of our sweetest theories ever! Can you make cookies from Cookie Dough Ice Cream? And if so, are they actually good? Well today, Steph and I put it to the test with a variety of different ice cream brands.
    Want More FOOD THEORY?
    McDonald's McFlurry Cake ► • Food Theory: Testing t...
    You've Been SCAMMED! (Supermarket Secrets) ► • Food Theory: You've Be...
    Tootsie Pops, How Many Licks? ► • Food Theory: Tootsie P...
    Never Order McDonald's Medium Fries! ► • Food Theory: Never Ord...
    Kool Aid Man Is A Marvel Villain! ► • Food Theory: Kool Aid ...
    Don't Trust Your Cake! ► • Food Theory: Don't Tru...
    Join our other Theorist Communities!
    Game Theory! ► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
    Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
    Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
    Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/theFoo...
    Credits:
    Writers: Justin Kuiper, Luke Barats, and Matthew Patrick
    Editors: Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick and Pedro Freitas
    Assistant Editor: Caitie Turner (Caiterpillart)
    Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
    #IceCream #Cookie #Bake #Ben&Jerry's #Breyers #CookieDough #FoodTheory #MatPat #GameTheory #FilmTheory
  • ХоббиХобби

Комментарии • 6 тыс.

  • @ShortHax
    @ShortHax 2 года назад +17025

    Imagine being the poor soul that gets the ice cream out of the freezer only to find that all of the cookie dough pieces have been surgically removed

  • @SebasTian58323
    @SebasTian58323 2 года назад +6511

    I love that Pillsbury knows enough people eat their cookie dough raw that they started making it actually pretty safe to do so.

    • @emmaf5705
      @emmaf5705 2 года назад +463

      If you can't beat em, join em

    • @bigbundle3223
      @bigbundle3223 2 года назад +512

      They understood the actual meaning of "the customer is right"

    • @WoodlouseChucker
      @WoodlouseChucker 2 года назад +352

      @@bigbundle3223 which was preventing the customers fron dying, not satisfying the karens but keeping them alive lol

    • @matthewalbright6108
      @matthewalbright6108 2 года назад +53

      It hasn’t tasted the same since they did

    • @meepbeep7928
      @meepbeep7928 2 года назад +32

      @@matthewalbright6108 well you won't die so-

  • @Bibochan18
    @Bibochan18 2 года назад +305

    A few brands, like Toll House, are selling straight up edible cookie dough in a tub. It says on the label not to bake it, so I want Mat and Steph to bake it instead and see how it compares between actual cookies and these ice cream cookies.

    • @awak3nedx
      @awak3nedx 2 месяца назад +1

      221 likes and no replies? lemme fix that

    • @Wellingstern
      @Wellingstern 2 месяца назад +1

      That’d be interesting

    • @qu9353
      @qu9353 Месяц назад +1

      Speak english

  • @aidenschmitt6487
    @aidenschmitt6487 Год назад +42

    Fun note, I’ve heard the reason that Ben and Jerry’s had the most chunks is because one of them, I think Ben, has no sense of smell or at least very limited, so he prefers ice cream with more texture so he can enjoy it without having to be able to taste it as well

  • @Patterrz
    @Patterrz 2 года назад +3178

    nothing looks sadder than warm ice cream

    • @pokiepuff3010
      @pokiepuff3010 2 года назад +18

      This is true

    • @pineflowers
      @pineflowers 2 года назад +92

      Depressed people eat frosting, really depressed people eat warm ice cream.

    • @JMac586
      @JMac586 2 года назад +20

      How about a warm child

    • @Fhadul-I-am
      @Fhadul-I-am 2 года назад +9

      @@pineflowers so then all of us (not me) eats frosting 24/7

    • @Bigjess2you
      @Bigjess2you 2 года назад +10

      Ice cream soup

  • @coffeeaddict9605
    @coffeeaddict9605 2 года назад +2137

    I'm reminded of Mark and Ethan trying this, with Mark getting it out by eating the icecream and spitting the dough out into a bowl.

  • @devilish4480
    @devilish4480 8 месяцев назад +94

    Hearing Steph saying she is scared of escalators made me laugh so hard cause I’m absolutely terrified of them

    • @normalhuman9878
      @normalhuman9878 8 месяцев назад +5

      Me too! I always have to watch my feet to make sure they don’t get sucked in

    • @yoshifan33
      @yoshifan33 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@normalhuman9878personally i'm more worried about the panel at the end of the stairs breaking or falling loose.

  • @drigondii
    @drigondii 2 года назад +115

    I imagine each of those “cookie doughs” would also need its own fine tuning for baking time and temperature

  • @Jcat_Nguy23
    @Jcat_Nguy23 2 года назад +1332

    "I can assure you, that Edy's slow-churned cookie dough dough is not going to be the same as...edy's...slow churned cookie dough dough..." the look of pure confusion lmaooo

    • @hank1318
      @hank1318 2 года назад +12

      it looked so fake lol

    • @30watermelon.
      @30watermelon. 2 года назад +3

      Time stamp pls

    • @hank1318
      @hank1318 2 года назад +1

      somewhere from the start to the end of the video

    • @30watermelon.
      @30watermelon. 2 года назад +2

      @@hank1318 ok

    • @hank1318
      @hank1318 2 года назад

      I am so informational, in fact I am sure no one has ever been more specific

  • @juniper3749
    @juniper3749 2 года назад +1943

    Can we just appreciate how ollie’s art is hanging on the fridge in the background

  • @kenzi5559
    @kenzi5559 Год назад +211

    The fact that MatPat has watched Nailed it makes me feel really happy because Nicole Byers and Jacques Torres are freaking hilarious.

  • @carabkb
    @carabkb Год назад +232

    MatPat infiltrated my dream last night. I was listening to one of his videos, and my subconscious could still hear him. 😆😆😆

    • @hellhound4873
      @hellhound4873 Год назад +12

      same had a fnaf nightmare once 😂

    • @danyfirerloveluck5548
      @danyfirerloveluck5548 Год назад +5

      yeah that happens sometimes. I got one whit the real time fandub of sonic

    • @starboi141
      @starboi141 Год назад +4

      (IT'S JUST A THEORY) played 2000 times

    • @3raccoons-ina-trenchcoat
      @3raccoons-ina-trenchcoat Год назад +2

      I had a dream I no-clipped into the backrooms and matpat was staring at a wall scribbling on a note pad angrily and muttering to himself and then he turned around and his face was I big red circle and then he said "hëllø mïkå" like a friggin demon.
      But thats what happens when you fall asleep to a generation loss theory vid lol

    • @elephaux5671
      @elephaux5671 Год назад +1

      Squeaking away

  • @medical-cyanide1526
    @medical-cyanide1526 2 года назад +838

    something i love about dear ole Mat and a few others is that they arent using the kids intentionally for content, sometimes they pop up but its not deliberate (at least from my POV) and its just apart of life.

    • @zadok23
      @zadok23 2 года назад +60

      never noticed that...in fact I think Matt and Steph have only had their son appear in one food theory episode.

    • @iamacatperson7226
      @iamacatperson7226 2 года назад +21

      @@zadok23 Yea, I think only the mcflurry cake one

    • @paulhodgers
      @paulhodgers 2 года назад +48

      Mat appears to be a big enough kid anyway 🤣

    • @DarkBunsCult
      @DarkBunsCult 2 года назад +2

      @@paulhodgers omg 😂😂😂

    • @Alexkralie
      @Alexkralie 2 года назад +6

      @@zadok23 he also appears in the bread gloves episode for a second

  • @Indie-pendentUser
    @Indie-pendentUser 2 года назад +1807

    That salmonella visual joke at 1:08 is pure gold, it deserves more acknowledgement!

    • @mansirattoor7523
      @mansirattoor7523 2 года назад +30

      That was good tho

    • @foodofthegods
      @foodofthegods 2 года назад +24

      YES I loved it

    • @DevranUenal
      @DevranUenal 2 года назад +41

      I didn't notice it. Thanks for pointing out! 😂

    • @i-lack-creativity
      @i-lack-creativity 2 года назад +23

      Only realized what i was looking at after like 30 seconds of thinking

    • @supresoft6699
      @supresoft6699 Год назад +14

      Potential Disney Princess Over here

  • @williamstotzkowski148
    @williamstotzkowski148 Год назад +58

    Eating some dippin dots cookie dough right now. Far and away the easiest cookie dough to extract if you ever revisit this.

  • @blazinbethpheonixgirl294
    @blazinbethpheonixgirl294 Год назад +33

    This video only did 1 thing for me, convince me to make my own frozen cookie dough bites using raw cookie dough and place them in ice cream.

  • @slashtheporcupine6746
    @slashtheporcupine6746 2 года назад +4043

    Fun Fact: I went to a party in high school, and everyone needed to bring a dip. I decided to be different from everyone making chicken or salsa dip and I made a cookie dough dessert dip and had vanilla wafers as the “chips”. The dip ended up as one of the top 3 best dips out of everyone’s.

  • @anthonybarbara3311
    @anthonybarbara3311 2 года назад +8967

    I still want to see a FOOD THEORY on: DOES CHICKEN SOUP ACTUALLY HELP HEAL A COLD?

    • @oldveryveryoldmanfromthe1900s
      @oldveryveryoldmanfromthe1900s 2 года назад +239

      yes it does help by heating you up

    • @official-obama
      @official-obama 2 года назад +100

      @@oldveryveryoldmanfromthe1900s but there might be a chemical with some sort of name like xananthatrillithide that is the cure for cancer or something

    • @zombiepegasus
      @zombiepegasus 2 года назад +321

      I've heard it does, partly from the steam and partly from knowing someone else wants you to get better (if someone is preparing it for you), but given that I doubt it would help you any more than other soups.

    • @SolisSlays
      @SolisSlays 2 года назад +215

      I mean I think it’s because it’s 1. An easily eaten food (its liquid and mush with chicken) 2. Fairly easy to make (broth, chicken, veggies, seasoning, done) 3. Full of nutrients (chicken is protein, mixed vegetables are vegetables) 4. It has a light flavor (saltines with stomach issues anyone?). Note: this is just my hypothesis, not fact in the slightest and is based on personal experience

    • @cloverpepsi
      @cloverpepsi 2 года назад +54

      they do scientific tests in a lot of their episodes so will Mat and Steph catch a cold for this episode

  • @AustinD_YT
    @AustinD_YT 2 года назад +21

    This video really highlights what I like most about this channel, the fact we get to see Mat and other members of Team Theorist just goofing around with food stuffs. Obviously their getting actual findings and doing actual experiments, but the energy given off in these videos is much more relaxed and feels like Team Theorist is bringing you into their home to talk about foods. Unlike the other channels (which i still absolutely adore so dont get the wrong idea) which both have much more of a presenter feeling where the fact cold hard facts are being given to you is really pushed to the forfront.
    Don't get me wrong, I love all 3 theory channels regardless, but I have to be in a specific "learning" mood for the other channels, whereas it doesn't matter what mood im in im always happy to watch food theory.

  • @cautionhazardous2236
    @cautionhazardous2236 Год назад +15

    Shoutout to Mat for buying that extra dough thus saving this cookie episode that I enjoy so much

  • @incognitogirl6201
    @incognitogirl6201 2 года назад +325

    "Mat, why did you buy two of these?"
    The look of genuine confusion... I see this look from my dad so often. Lol

    • @TaranTatsuuchi
      @TaranTatsuuchi 2 года назад +1

      Obviously watches Technology Connections....
      For the 'magic of buying two of them'.

  • @mallomon
    @mallomon 2 года назад +485

    It doesn't only "melt," there's another problem... imagine running a ball of bread dough under running water... you're going to wash a lot of the flour out of the dough. In fact, that's a method of isolating the gluten from flour, run a ball of dough under water until the starches are all washed away, leaving the gluten behind

    • @Jurgler
      @Jurgler 2 года назад +23

      Was looking for this. Thank you

    • @GremlinSciences
      @GremlinSciences Год назад +12

      It's actually not melting at all. The bits of cookie dough do remain solid at room temperature, but are very soft and the combination of water and sifting serves to break them apart.
      They could have gotten all the dough a lot easier by simply emptying the tub onto a sieve to melt, maybe use a heat gun or blow drier if that's too slow.

    • @llcoolray3000
      @llcoolray3000 Год назад +7

      Yeah, that was stupid and disgusting.

    • @themudkip5295
      @themudkip5295 Год назад +6

      @@llcoolray3000 jeez thats aggressive

  • @ezrarichardson279
    @ezrarichardson279 Год назад +20

    I’m actually surprised that ANY of these made a passable cookie! I love m’y B&J cookie dough ice cream but I never assumed it was something you could actually use as cookie dough. It always just seemed like of those things were they tried to get it to taste right and look right but wasn’t actually cookie dough. Interesting!

  • @evelynbossov143
    @evelynbossov143 2 года назад +14

    My favorite theory episodes are when Steph and Matt messing around in their kitchen xD can yall do more of those?

  • @davidrinker4860
    @davidrinker4860 2 года назад +326

    A good chunk of Bryer’s actually is not considered ice cream. According to the FDA, the amount of toppings in some of their flavors puts the proportions of milk and cream outside of the standards they have for calling something ice cream.

    • @adiksaff
      @adiksaff 2 года назад +35

      That's a fun fact worthy of a Food Theory episode! Bump!

    • @SomeName_AlsoHandlesSucc
      @SomeName_AlsoHandlesSucc 2 года назад +15

      What's it classified as then?!

    • @davidrinker4860
      @davidrinker4860 2 года назад +44

      @@SomeName_AlsoHandlesSucc it’s just classified as a frozen dessert.

    • @Freetreedumb
      @Freetreedumb 2 года назад +7

      Still gonna consider it my favorite ice cream brand

    • @annaisannaing
      @annaisannaing 2 года назад +9

      To clarify, this isn't because they have a lot of extra flavors in there, it's because they use weird syrupy stuff instead of ice cream. Most of it doesn't even melt, it's gross

  • @GreatGatzB
    @GreatGatzB 2 года назад +1252

    My girlfriend worked for her grandmother’s Dairy Queen growing up and got a box of just the cookie dough before it was added into ice cream. Apparently that made decent cookies!

    • @thenewlbj
      @thenewlbj 2 года назад +24

      I wanna try it now.

    • @rustyboii21
      @rustyboii21 2 года назад +68

      As a former DQ employee, I can confirm that they make good cookies

    • @repentofyoursinsandbelieve629
      @repentofyoursinsandbelieve629 2 года назад +3

      Jesus loves you! I warn you of your sins, repent and believe the Gospel! If you love Him then keep His commandments! MAKE THE CHOICE, JESUS OR THE WORLD, JESUS IS ETERNAL, THE WORLD IS PASSING AWAY!!

    • @dieidiot3413
      @dieidiot3413 2 года назад +7

      @@repentofyoursinsandbelieve629 who

    • @randompersononline9532
      @randompersononline9532 2 года назад +22

      @@repentofyoursinsandbelieve629 This is the reason why I'm atheist

  • @louisjb9798
    @louisjb9798 2 года назад +8

    16:44 you call it The Great British Baking Show? Over here in Britain it’s called The Great British Bake Off. Not the main plot of the video. Just surprised me

    • @Fredsterface
      @Fredsterface 3 месяца назад +1

      Yeah. Some company in America has a copyright on the phrase “bake off”

  • @YanntastischGER
    @YanntastischGER Год назад +11

    8:50 I've watched an entire show about food industry tricks. And yeah super markets just squinching as less ingredients as possible for as low cost as possible is so common in there, it didn't wonder me at all. It actually reminded me of the show watching you take out the cookie dough.

  • @TheRealGuywithoutaMustache
    @TheRealGuywithoutaMustache 2 года назад +3811

    Everyone knows that you have a risk of getting sick from eating cookie dough, but it feels like it's worth it from the taste alone.

    • @mooselove
      @mooselove 2 года назад +132

      Did you know it’s the flour that’s the biggest risk, not the eggs? Edit- can you tell I typed this before I watched it and he said it

    • @abby_babber
      @abby_babber 2 года назад +6

      So true

    • @NotfullyTh3r3
      @NotfullyTh3r3 2 года назад +32

      I’ve seen you in the comments in almost all of the videos I’ve watched today

    • @Nullzeros
      @Nullzeros 2 года назад +11

      Que the “ok it’s worth it” memes

    • @_systemaddict6206
      @_systemaddict6206 2 года назад +16

      @@thesilentone4024 it's "edible, non-toxic" antifreeze made from gelatin. It's not the same as the stuff that goes in a vehicle radiator.

  • @GreasyPhil420
    @GreasyPhil420 2 года назад +246

    I really hope that one dude who suggested Ben and Jerry's put cookie dough in their ice cream back in the 80s got some good compensation.

  • @Verse_5
    @Verse_5 Год назад +5

    When she said CRISPY EDGE PROBLEM thats a problem???? 16:23

  • @catniplovescake
    @catniplovescake 2 года назад +4

    😹😹❣ @ 10:37 my mom & I used to have an inside joke about this also! "pin/pen/pan!" I would tell her when I was small & heard Texas accents 🤣😜 then we said it forever

  • @AMEERkhan-ol5hm
    @AMEERkhan-ol5hm 2 года назад +648

    “My mom made me scared of escalators”
    gonna needs some backstory on that Stephanie

    • @Sly-Moose
      @Sly-Moose 2 года назад +24

      I present to you the irl event of that one Asian mom who got crushed to death by an escalator while saving her son. There's a yt vid about it.

    • @stogucheme
      @stogucheme 2 года назад +2

      Final Destination. 3, I think. Watch the whole series anyway.

    • @Sly-Moose
      @Sly-Moose 2 года назад +11

      @@stogucheme You're thinking elevator

    • @kaboom6127
      @kaboom6127 2 года назад

      When you don’t grow up around them. You look like elf, it’s about not looking like a moron lol.

    • @allisonpozzo
      @allisonpozzo 2 года назад +8

      @@Sly-Moose Nope, escalator is correct. It was the fourth one called The Final Destination, and it was in 3D, so I think that's where they got the 3. There is a brutal escalator death scene in a mall.

  • @MagnusArchvile
    @MagnusArchvile 2 года назад +910

    Actually, for anyone who wants to know, it's actually really easy to make edible cookie dough that has no risk of getting you sick. The main two things you really have to worry about with the dough is salmonella from the eggs which can be removed entirely from the recipe (Remember back to the cake ingredients recipe, eggs are really only a binding agent to hold it together while it cooks, something you don't have to worry about if it's raw), and E. Coli from the flour. That is a bit harder to deal with, but all you do is put the flour you need on a cookie sheet and cook it in the oven at 350 degrees for about 5 minutes. After that you just combine all of the ingredients except eggs and voila, safe edible cookie dough.

    • @SaltyMikan
      @SaltyMikan 2 года назад +26

      Did you watch the video? They literally said that 1:34

    • @hebermasseque4314
      @hebermasseque4314 2 года назад +99

      @@SaltyMikan he was probably just writing it out so you could read instead of going back to the video and either way this helped

    • @jcers
      @jcers 2 года назад +23

      You could also just pasteurize the eggs and use them, too.

    • @MagnusArchvile
      @MagnusArchvile 2 года назад +43

      @@jcers oh. Alright. I just wanted to share the quickest and easiest way of doing it. I also really don't know much about pasteurization and I really didn't wanna suggest doing something I don't know how to do or understand myself.

    • @meowmeow3532
      @meowmeow3532 2 года назад +7

      thanks!

  • @chairosyamail1206
    @chairosyamail1206 2 года назад +4

    13:16 that feeling when you bite into a cookie

  • @wendyguajardo7792
    @wendyguajardo7792 4 месяца назад +5

    Out of all your channels food theory is probably my favorite

  • @Syphronic
    @Syphronic 2 года назад +1317

    I like how Matt literally makes theories on ruining everything and we all appreciate him for it

    • @blknite9337
      @blknite9337 2 года назад +13

      I need to learn how to read. Fot a moment i thought you said: "I like how Matt makes theoris on ruining everything we appreciate of him"

    • @sonnylondon0657
      @sonnylondon0657 2 года назад +9

      He’s the only one who can do it too. I ain’t letting anyone else ruin my childhood but him

    • @KickAss5671
      @KickAss5671 2 года назад

      Some don't, lol

    • @c.a.a.n7874
      @c.a.a.n7874 2 года назад +2

      More like theories on stealing content

    • @Syphronic
      @Syphronic 2 года назад

      @@KickAss5671 the entirety of game theory subscriber count would like to disagree with ya there

  • @LittleBigHamm
    @LittleBigHamm 2 года назад +261

    Stephanie's rant on Southern accents reminds me of a story from my high school theater class: I also live in the south (Tennessee), and an exercise in that class was enunciating words differently. Two of those words were pen and pin. There were a few people that had trouble with it because of their accent. They managed to train themselves to distinguish the two, but you could tell it took some effort.

  • @elise7650
    @elise7650 9 месяцев назад

    I love food theories with Steph so much

  • @baileym8959
    @baileym8959 11 месяцев назад

    ugh i love rewatching this episode- one day i too will do this, i think about it everytime i eat my favorite ice cream, chocolate chip cookie dough mmmmmm

  • @billys.3258
    @billys.3258 2 года назад +458

    I worked in the production department of an ice cream factory for quite a while and can say that many times during a maintenance shut-down, a stainless-steel sheet of ice cream cookie dough inclusion bits was run through the shrink wrap conveyor-oven repeatedly until the cookies were baked and enjoyed by the crew.

    • @annslow41
      @annslow41 2 года назад +20

      Sooo, which company, time period, and did the "cookie dough" cookies come out tasting like real cookies?

    • @ducksongfans
      @ducksongfans Год назад +2

      replying cause i want the answers like the guy above

  • @shelbyteague7928
    @shelbyteague7928 2 года назад +436

    My instinct of “Ew they took a bite out of the same area of cookie!” is no match against the knowledge that they are in fact a married couple

    • @gorman750
      @gorman750 2 года назад +68

      Isn't it funny how people would normally react to that with a level of concern, just like you did, but once you know they're a couple it goes out the window. Like, they could eat from the same spoon and you're just like "eh, they're married, it's fine" lol

    • @keksteig3707
      @keksteig3707 2 года назад +76

      @@gorman750 When you share all of the germs in your saliva on a daily basis anyway, it doesn't really matter whether you share a spoon or not

    • @sergiorubens8475
      @sergiorubens8475 2 года назад +3

      @@keksteig3707 based

    • @sleepyhuman3816
      @sleepyhuman3816 2 года назад +14

      Me who shares drinks with friends and food just as long as they look healthy: 👁👄👁 guess im disgusting

    • @playlists7789
      @playlists7789 2 года назад

      @@keksteig3707 tubggggg

  • @alexa_palenchar
    @alexa_palenchar 10 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks MatPat for putting in the effort to answer this question I’ve had for so long! ❤️

  • @aiden5769
    @aiden5769 2 года назад +1

    I've wondered about this for so long

  • @theirishninjasanimations
    @theirishninjasanimations 2 года назад +499

    That merch segment was a train wreck and I loved every second of it.

    • @luckyafsdjflasioandfi6939
      @luckyafsdjflasioandfi6939 2 года назад +2

      ikr lol

    • @nobodyfamousX
      @nobodyfamousX 2 года назад +10

      This whole video was a bit of a train wreck. But that's what we're here to see

    • @ViktorErikFade
      @ViktorErikFade 2 года назад +6

      Honestly the train wreck aspect of the plug made me want to go check it out and usually I don't

    • @ibanheadhunter8317
      @ibanheadhunter8317 2 года назад

      Same.🤣🤣🤣

    • @CXLVIII
      @CXLVIII 2 года назад

      The way Mat just maintained eye-contact with the camera when he wanted Mirror Matt to throw him more objets was so good omg

  • @AlekMax64
    @AlekMax64 2 года назад +498

    You know You’re hanging out with a bunch of nerds when you hear
    “ For fun we calculated the percentage of cookie dough in each ice cream”.
    Not saying that’s a bad thing though.

    • @coyraig8332
      @coyraig8332 2 года назад +12

      *pushes up glasses* um aktually thats a geek *takes off glasses* but as a geek I still approve

  • @2DJoYogurt
    @2DJoYogurt 2 года назад +2

    Honestly it would be quite an interesting episode seeing Matt Pat and Stephanie trying to make a safe cookie dough ice cream recipe

  • @yqq1309
    @yqq1309 Год назад +1

    Man, we love steph. She’s so funny lmao

  • @laurenkempenaar6492
    @laurenkempenaar6492 2 года назад +291

    The “Oliver” on the fridge made this episode infinitely better 🥺🥺🥺

  • @statesofgracie
    @statesofgracie 2 года назад +635

    “all I want for Christmas is a roll of cookie dough” thinking about my parents used to actually put a roll of cookie dough in our stockings for us to straight eat

  • @abcdefg9386
    @abcdefg9386 2 года назад +4

    I’ve been debating this for years with everyone I know. THEY AREN’T COOKIES!! Thank you Matt for clearing this up

  • @dottyspot
    @dottyspot 2 года назад +2

    this is the video that made me get into baking. i've made a ton of sugar cookies and choc chip cookies. one day, i may step up to cakes...one day.

  • @donovan802
    @donovan802 2 года назад +706

    I never got sick from cookie dough. It’s just so good. Of course, I’m mindful of what ingredients might cause potential sickness, but I have yet to suffer from it.

    • @maxkavumpuram4142
      @maxkavumpuram4142 2 года назад

      Mann

    • @TwiceXpenn
      @TwiceXpenn 2 года назад +14

      Same I ate like a whole bowl of it and didnt even get a stomache ache

    • @chopsticks7623
      @chopsticks7623 2 года назад +6

      You have gained a resistance to its effects

    • @saberchampion3339
      @saberchampion3339 2 года назад +2

      It’s the eggs because Salmonella

    • @dieptrieu6564
      @dieptrieu6564 2 года назад +13

      People have different immune system. That's why some people can eat raw eggs and be fine

  • @zachary4807
    @zachary4807 2 года назад +420

    Matthew Patrick, it is time for a music channel “Tune Theory.”

    • @Redhot_speed
      @Redhot_speed 2 года назад +4

      Video game music haha

    • @ninl1n498
      @ninl1n498 2 года назад +13

      yeah but copyright

    • @sharkyytea
      @sharkyytea 2 года назад +6

      Yes
      but copyright

    • @boop8871
      @boop8871 2 года назад +5

      @SimSam I don’t think so cause he’s done theories on movies that were inspired by books, and it would be really boring cause like what theories would they do? And what images would they use? Pages get bored after a bit

    • @eddiegrimm2439
      @eddiegrimm2439 2 года назад

      He could literally just call it music theory which is a thing

  • @MetaCake-
    @MetaCake- 2 года назад

    12:19 Matt-Pat unknowingly makes a no game no like reference, gotta love it

  • @just_em99
    @just_em99 Год назад +2

    I love how the food theory intro has so much going on you never know what to pay attention to

  • @scarletspooks9000
    @scarletspooks9000 2 года назад +422

    I actually tried this myself before, I used ben & jerry's edible cookie dough bites and it turned out really bad, they were really chewy and crispy, super thin and had a weird aftertaste.

    • @SlowpokeSpartan
      @SlowpokeSpartan 2 года назад +45

      I’m so tired of comment bots. I see why it’s a problem

    • @shawnroy7806
      @shawnroy7806 2 года назад

      @@SlowpokeSpartan fixed it

    • @williamlangdon1132
      @williamlangdon1132 2 года назад +3

      wait so is the cookie though in the ben & jerry's ice cream better than the edible cookie bites!?!?!

    • @scaper8
      @scaper8 2 года назад

      @@williamlangdon1132 That was my thought! It's not just the same thing?!

  • @picturebreakdown
    @picturebreakdown 2 года назад +429

    Disclaimer: this episode was “not sponsored” by Ben and Jerry’s ice cream
    If you’re interested, I do MARVEL and Star Wars Breakdowns (if you’re not interested, just ignore this and have a great day:)

  • @arceusinsanity301
    @arceusinsanity301 2 года назад +5

    4:52 you're forgetting about solubility, it's probably just dissolving

  • @yymdd1
    @yymdd1 2 года назад +2

    2:15 Matt Patt man-splains everything Steph just said 😂😂

  • @Videomen102
    @Videomen102 2 года назад +254

    I gotta say, these "homestyle" Food Theory episodes are really nice. It's like Food Theory lite, really cozy vibes

  • @rymatang10
    @rymatang10 2 года назад +269

    Omg, when Matt said “Don’t be a Stephanie”, it gave the same energy as “You’re just a Steph” from No Game No Life

    • @patrickvalk
      @patrickvalk 2 года назад +10

      Don't be a imanity xD

    • @autumwho
      @autumwho 2 года назад +1

      I love her eyeroll when she says "don't do it" lol

    • @shane658
      @shane658 2 года назад

      haha anime reference you so funny and relatable

    • @rylace
      @rylace 2 года назад

      @@shane658 Haha anime references aren't allowed you're so cool and normal.

    • @tamashi4242
      @tamashi4242 2 года назад

      Based

  • @NathanJamesJerritze
    @NathanJamesJerritze Год назад +2

    Everything Mixed Together at Once sounds like if Gordon Ramsay made Everything Everywhere All at Once

  • @CHOOICHENGXIMoe
    @CHOOICHENGXIMoe 8 месяцев назад +2

    this man asks the weirdest questions and answers them with very convincing reasons.

  • @NoodleSoup23
    @NoodleSoup23 2 года назад +468

    They should've used the mcflurry cookie dough aswell. And it would've been pretty easy since all the cookie dough is on the top

    • @SicariusYT
      @SicariusYT 2 года назад +14

      There is no mcflurry cookie dough in the US

    • @pennyforyourthots
      @pennyforyourthots Год назад +33

      I feel scammed now that I know that somewhere in the world exists say cookie dough McFlurry.

    • @NoodleSoup23
      @NoodleSoup23 Год назад +8

      @@pennyforyourthots Oh yeah, i didn’t think about the fact that its not available in different places. Also it tastes amazing :)

    • @gianna526
      @gianna526 Год назад +4

      wtf that's a thing? Where and how much would it cost to move there?

    • @NoodleSoup23
      @NoodleSoup23 Год назад +6

      @@gianna526 hahahahaha, we have that here in Sweden, it’s great lol

  • @c-nami5551
    @c-nami5551 2 года назад +269

    I remember Mark and Ethan doing this exact thing before. Its a surprise that its so stupid, yet it still sounds like something that would and did work.

    • @TomatoSauceGaming626
      @TomatoSauceGaming626 2 года назад +21

      Except they extracted the cookie dough with their mouths, which absolutely was stupid

    • @jakemoresea7415
      @jakemoresea7415 2 года назад +38

      @@TomatoSauceGaming626 Stupid? Maybe. An entertaining and priceless moment we shall remember? Definitely.

    • @sethavila7169
      @sethavila7169 2 года назад +8

      Ah I see you’re a man of culture as well

    • @m.j.2578
      @m.j.2578 2 года назад +12

      maybe my tinfoil hat is too tight but its interesting that this video is on today the 1 year anniversary of the goodbye stream leading to the deleting of the channel at midnight.....momento mori :)

    • @Manthab
      @Manthab 2 года назад +11

      I love that they released a video about something UA did on the anniversary of deletion

  • @SemiO11
    @SemiO11 Год назад +2

    “Hello internet, welcome to food theory, where cookies are called cookies even though we bake them. But, why- why is it called an oven when you of in the cold food and of out hot eat the food?”

  • @tweetspie06
    @tweetspie06 9 месяцев назад +1

    I never thought about why Ben and Jerry's and Breyers were my favorite, but this is absolutely why

  • @operatorbeygx4501
    @operatorbeygx4501 2 года назад +364

    "DON'T BE A STEPHANIE"
    Girls named stephanie: Why are we here? Just to suffer?

    • @jennifers550
      @jennifers550 2 года назад +9

      Also if anyone out there is a fellow anime lover instantly "Don't be a Steph" from No Game No Life went through my head. 🙂

    • @meinfretr1298
      @meinfretr1298 2 года назад

      Same

    • @funfeels
      @funfeels 2 года назад +1

      @@jennifers550 Why.... Stephanie is a normal name... That's like someone saying don't be a mike and you getting reminded of mike from tokyo revengerz

    • @jennifers550
      @jennifers550 2 года назад

      I can't say really. It just struck me at the time.

    • @ecokrazy
      @ecokrazy 2 года назад

      Stephs 🙄🙄

  • @fedrickthegreat2138
    @fedrickthegreat2138 2 года назад +67

    This is why I’m shelling out big bucks for Ben & Jerry’s because I trust them to the fullest

  • @gamesdeen3768
    @gamesdeen3768 Год назад

    Love to see it. No obscure research. No speculation. Just some practical experimentation.
    Screw Nestle.

  • @Ocean.DreaMz
    @Ocean.DreaMz Год назад

    Good eats show, had an icecream episode. A big icecream co. Spokesperson was interviewed he said that cookie dough icecream can't really be baked with, as the traditional cookie ingredients would be affected when frozen for the time & temp. That icecream needs to be to keep icecream consistency. So it kept some of the cookie dough ingredients but they differ a bit to be proper icecream consistency

  • @thestickmahn2446
    @thestickmahn2446 2 года назад +212

    *MatPat talking about how raw cookie dough is dangerous*
    Scandinavian people: *I have no such weaknesses*

    • @HistoricalOlive
      @HistoricalOlive 2 года назад +5

      can someone explain the joke? i don't get it.

    • @stefthorman8548
      @stefthorman8548 2 года назад +8

      @@HistoricalOlive i also don't know, but, they probably eat raw eggs or something, or the germs can't reproduce, since the country is basically an natural freezer.

    • @marihove
      @marihove 2 года назад +1

      I was thinking the exact same!

    • @marihove
      @marihove 2 года назад +8

      @@HistoricalOlive yes, there are no worries eating neither raw eggs or flour here. Extreme fitness people drink raw eggs to gain some extra protein.

    • @sander303
      @sander303 2 года назад +2

      I am scandinavian and I feel like Ive been lied to for 10 years about cookie dough

  • @DreadKyller
    @DreadKyller 2 года назад +96

    It's worth noting that not all edible cookie dough has the egg removed. The temperature required to pasteurize an egg is lower than the point where it becomes solid, so some brands still use egg, just pasteurized egg, similarly to the flour. The resulting dough ends up having a different texture (a bit more grainy and less smooth usually) and will tend to spread out more in the oven.

    • @silverdragonslair
      @silverdragonslair 2 года назад +3

      Also, in other countries, raw eggs are considered salmonella safe and fine to consume.

    • @ChaosTherum
      @ChaosTherum 2 года назад +2

      @@silverdragonslair In the US they are completely safe as well, we actually pasteurize most store bought eggs. There is basically zero risk of eating eggs raw.

  • @solosheeep
    @solosheeep Год назад +1

    “Can you bake cookies with cookie-dough ice cream?”
    Me at 3:00am *Well well then let’s find out!*

  • @ItsMe-rr1bc
    @ItsMe-rr1bc 2 года назад

    I find it so cute how they have art from Oliver on their fridge!

  • @billyj4317
    @billyj4317 2 года назад +233

    LOL. I always wondered this as a kid. Good job Food Theory for looking into the can you bake cookies from cookie dough ice cream debate.

    • @PansyPops
      @PansyPops 2 года назад +1

      @Zoe Guy report them. I’ve gone through the entire comment section and reported about 50 bots for spam. You can also report the people spamming a bunch of weird hashtags and stuff for s3xual content because they kinda do.

  • @silentwolfie9154
    @silentwolfie9154 2 года назад +298

    OLIVER'S ART ON THE FRIDGE IS SO CUTE 🥺🥺🥺 Also could a theory be made on what foods actually help with sickness? Chicken soup doesn't work for me, but apple juice instead of water does

    • @ars6187
      @ars6187 2 года назад +1

      War Won Ton soup, not win ton, but WAR won ton

    • @BrainrotWatcher
      @BrainrotWatcher Год назад +17

      Apple juice has lots of vitamin C in it which helps the immune system

    • @Alpha_Synergy
      @Alpha_Synergy Год назад +1

      For me it's always been mini beef ravioli, though that may be correlation and the fact it is easy to cook for me.

    • @killersawofficials7224
      @killersawofficials7224 Год назад

      I think thats just placebo effect

    • @-enbyfrogartist-6631
      @-enbyfrogartist-6631 Год назад

      I justget given water, throat lozengers, and simple foods (like grilled cheese) when i get sick, i usually feel better after a day or two anyway tho

  • @kodabear1996
    @kodabear1996 Год назад

    I'm watching this video again because RUclips recommended it. The beginning talk about the dangers of eating raw cookie dough reminded me of how great cake batter tastes.

  • @xdaisy3408
    @xdaisy3408 2 года назад +1

    Watching these videos makes me so hungry.

  • @liamgriffin218
    @liamgriffin218 2 года назад +174

    Last November: "I love turkey, turkey makes me so happy."
    This November: "I love ice cream, ice cream makes me so happy."
    Ahh... Glad to see some things never change

    • @LexiLunarpaw
      @LexiLunarpaw 2 года назад +2

      War... War Never Changes...

    •  2 года назад +1

      What about... Turkey ice cream?

    • @LunizIsGlacey
      @LunizIsGlacey 2 года назад

      @ no.

  • @SaintoftheHonest
    @SaintoftheHonest 2 года назад +135

    Aquafaba is actually used as a replacement for egg whites in a lot of vegan cooking - for example, vegan meringues are just sugar whipped into aquafaba. As such, if B&J were to use Aquafaba as a SAFE replacement for eggs in their dough, this would explain how that ended up being the only one to get an A. Instead of completely cutting the role, they found a replacement.

  • @StormiezQuadz
    @StormiezQuadz 7 месяцев назад

    This episode is making me hungry 😩

  • @DaBluees
    @DaBluees Год назад +1

    The cookie dough from cookie dough ice cream is the real definition of happiness

  • @AHurdOfBronies_
    @AHurdOfBronies_ 2 года назад +127

    You guys know Ben & Jerry’s sells packs of just the bits of cookie dough, which they named “Snackable Dough”, right?

    • @missdreavus649
      @missdreavus649 2 года назад +15

      There’s a chance the dough is actually different from what goes in the ice cream

    • @bigjake360t
      @bigjake360t 2 года назад +10

      No I did not know that. I have only one thing to say. Shut up, and take my money.

    • @sathirafernando6036
      @sathirafernando6036 2 года назад +2

      it's very different to what they actually add to the ice cream

  • @Foster_94
    @Foster_94 2 года назад +192

    The look on Stephanie's face when she said not to eat raw cookie dough lol.
    I'm not going to stop, you can't make me.

    • @bluecooper901
      @bluecooper901 2 года назад +3

      12:20

    • @liserxsarah
      @liserxsarah 2 года назад +7

      As most people know you can get salmonella from that. I got it (not from eggs though) when I was around 7 and nearly died from it. Do I still lick the spoon after putting the cake in the oven? Yes. Yes, I do :)

    • @Foster_94
      @Foster_94 2 года назад +2

      @@liserxsarah Oh, I know that lol. It still won't stop me. :D

    • @Foster_94
      @Foster_94 2 года назад +3

      @@liserxsarah What's life without a little risk?

    • @liserxsarah
      @liserxsarah 2 года назад +1

      @@Foster_94 Nothing! :D

  • @help_wanted
    @help_wanted 8 месяцев назад

    Oli's little arts and craft work hung up on the refrigerator is just so cute and wholesome until you realize that his dad is mat pat, destroyer of childhood and all movies, video games and TV shows nostalgic

  • @RorysOnPaws
    @RorysOnPaws 4 месяца назад +1

    2:32 matpats face looks like he’s rethinking his past decisions

  • @BuddaDawgDawgWitDaBudda
    @BuddaDawgDawgWitDaBudda 2 года назад +63

    Crispy edge problem? Thats literally the best part of a cookie, that crispy yet chewy edge of a cookie that feels and tastes amazing in your mouth

    • @Lomus23
      @Lomus23 2 года назад +1

      Center piece is superior

  • @bafon867
    @bafon867 2 года назад +411

    Man, three minutes in and I'm sold. MatPat, I need to know. Does Edy's Slow Churned Cookie Dough contain more cookie dough than Edy's Slow Churned Cookie Dough?

    • @nick08841
      @nick08841 Год назад +7

      what does this mean!???

    • @blackhole7818
      @blackhole7818 Год назад +2

      You said the same thing twice, "Edy's slow churned cookie dough"

    • @blackhole7818
      @blackhole7818 Год назад +6

      @Ian Gustafson is this a joke, I'm too dumb to understand?

    • @purple.st4rz_556
      @purple.st4rz_556 Год назад +29

      Edy's Slow Churned Cookie has CLEARLY more cookie dough than Edy's Slow Churned Cookie, it makes more sense

    • @noahh6186
      @noahh6186 Год назад +17

      To anyone who's still confused by the joke here, the joke was that there's two tubs of Edy's Slow Churned Cookie Dough that Mat accidentally compared in the intro

  • @manifestationsofasort
    @manifestationsofasort 2 года назад +1

    When I was little, my mom would get pre made, pre cut cookie dough from Costco, and I'd go down into the freezer and eat it. I'd eat the entire (90-ish count) box over a couple weeks. It's a miracle I never got sick or got in trouble.

  • @seb12game9
    @seb12game9 Год назад +1

    quote: "what monster doesn't eat cookie dough?" MY MOM DOESN'T, so, acurate.

  • @attakrus
    @attakrus 2 года назад +19

    Steph:Cookie dough is a solid at room temperature.
    MatPat:You’re a solid 10 at every temperature.

  • @SoniasWay
    @SoniasWay 2 года назад +63

    Not gonna lie, that intro was the cutest. The face he made after “welcome to food theory” was priceless

    • @johnmichael8462
      @johnmichael8462 2 года назад

      Wowww ruclips.net/video/FSSFgWlDbJU/видео.html .

  • @xtcharaplayz7760
    @xtcharaplayz7760 Год назад +1

    I love Oliver’s little Mac n’ cheese picture on the fridge

  • @moonandstars9529
    @moonandstars9529 Год назад

    I know you guys will probably not see this but I just wanted to say thank you for making this videos I suffer from very bad anxiety so I get anxiety attacks and periods of sadness very often and your video’s always manage to make me smile and forget my dark thoughts thanks for that

  • @thecosplaycrafter8017
    @thecosplaycrafter8017 2 года назад +146

    I'd like to take a moment to appreciate Matt's immense self-control not to eat the food he analyses prematurely.

  • @WorldVRC
    @WorldVRC 2 года назад +33

    "It's already pretty sussy."
    Please don't make this normal I'm going to cry

    • @Quocalimar
      @Quocalimar 2 года назад

      You're so late

    • @goodnight63
      @goodnight63 2 года назад

      Among us has seeped into my vocabulary too. I said sus at work in front of my supervisor lmao

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 года назад

      Apparently sussy is a thing now. I hate it. It's _equivalent_ to sus. Now they're _adding back in_ extra sounds for no reason.

  • @mythicaxis9757
    @mythicaxis9757 Месяц назад

    Best ad for merch I've ever seen

  • @Blitz6804
    @Blitz6804 2 года назад +96

    Two data issues I noticed this episode you don't usually have...
    8:53 Column C has row 4 and 5 swapped. Ben & Jerry's is a pint, Harris Teeter is three pints.
    9:05 Breyer's is 3x larger than Ben & Jerry's, not three and a half.

    • @gussug2498
      @gussug2498 2 года назад +9

      Oh wow wait this is actually kinda wonky; did they just not notice that?

    • @AndrewWilliams-bm9ik
      @AndrewWilliams-bm9ik 2 года назад +2

      Came to the comments to see if anyone else noticed.