Have you ever noticed how a team’s uniforms seem to look great when they’re winning a lot? To me it felt like Packers uniforms didn’t look good when I watching was watching games in the 70s & 80s but they looked sharp since 1996. 😀
@@cyounger5716 Poor Randy, voted worst starting QB in Packers history. 😂 Yes, I agree that everything looked shabby with Randy Wright. To his credit, he made his life in Wisconsin, runs a business & a football camp there. He was a 6th round pick without elite skills who had to learn the NFL version of the position without a true training program. Mike McCarthy put Aaron Rodgers in what he called his “ quarterback college.” Hope the Falcons do the same for Penix. Truth be told most QBs, especially those drafted in late rounds, don’t get a true developmental plan/program & have to figure it out for themselves.
Don Hutson is a great pick for the Greatest Packer. He was so far ahead of the rest of the league that it is still mind-boggling. It speaks well of Antonio Freeman to give him proper respect like he does here. Leaving Forrest Gregg off this list is indefensible, however. Gregg made the NFL's 100th Anniversary team, meaning he was rated as one of the four greatest tackles in the history of professional football. No disrespect to Bart Starr, but he probably wouldn't make most lists of top 20 quarterbacks. It was wise to include Kramer, but foolish to omit Gregg.
Respectfully, I think saying Bart Starr isn’t top 20 is crazy. Having said that, agree with everything you said. Im glad you didn’t decide to shit on Don Hutson, instead you praised him justly. And yeah, holy shit leaving off Forrest Gregg was fucking criminal. He might be the greatest pure football player in terms of ability at a position that the Packers have ever had.
I will definitely defend Lofton on this list. He is one of the greatest WRs ever. So tall and agile. He even thinks of himself as a Packer. He’s never listed as a Bills great. The problem with Lofton is that in the early 80s, the offense was excellent. Lynn Dickey was a great QB and the 3rd man to ever throw for more than 4000 yards. John Jefferson was also there and the TE Paul Coffman was a Pro Bowler for several years. They had a O line was very strong and they had one of the best offenses in the NFL. Problem was their defense was arguably the worst in the NFL. Several years of 8-8 kept him from really being a nationally known player. But his stats from the time really show just how great he is.
Harry Engel i get your position on this, but that would preclude any Lions player from being on the lists that didn’t involve dumpster fires since 1957. Also pre 1970s Steelers, any Cardinals since the Bidwills were awarded the franchise after the Pottsville Maroons we’re booted from the league in 1925 until Kurt Warner. You’re absolutely right about the post Lombardi Packers = garbage, I’m just adding my thought to your point, no offense intended.
Do Du Absolutely right my friend, but you have to consider he put up those numbers in Green Bay when half of his time he had David Whitehurst a guy named Dennis Sproul, and a well passed his prime Bobby Douglass who when he played for the Bears ran the ball more than he threw it. Which at least for me makes those numbers pop. Jim Kelly vs three guys that were forgotten the moment they took the uniform off. I have no issue with someone who remembers him in Buffalo more than Green Bay. If you would ask ten people “when you think of Shaq what uniform is he wearing” 8 of them will say the Lakers and not the Magic.These lists are so subjective that there are really no wrong answers.
I got a chance to have a 30 min conversation with Jerry Kramer and I tried to think of a good question to ask him when it was my turn to talk to him. I asked him who was the greatest athlete he ever played with and he talked about Ray Nitske for 30 mins. He said he could throw the ball 60+ yards.
Too bad that the Packers didn't have the same winning formula with Bart as a coach as with him as the legendary QB. And this is from a Bears fan who actually did have a huge respect for Mr. Starr.
@@scoobycarr5558 He did, the team was pathetic when he took over thanks to the Hadl Trade. However, they made the playoffs once, and for three years in a row, he never had a losing year. Then, they fired him to hire Forest Greg.
2:27 Jim Taylor. 6:32 Jerry Kramer. 9:52 James Lofton. 14:07 Herb Adderley. 17:17 Paul Hornung. 22:04 Ray Nitschke. 24:44 Reggie White. 29:18 Bart Starr. 34:37 Brett Favre. 40:05 Don Hutson.
I'm not a Green Bay Packers fan, but, I love watching episodes of 'The NFL's Top 10' like this one, for example where they focus on one team & you can compare the NFL's list to one that you made, or, vice-versa & an opportunity to see/watch/hear a possibly opposing view is presented & the chance to engage in a debate is available, as well. Depending on what NFL team/teams you like, you could probably watch episodes like this, for example over & over & over, again & never get tired of them.
Reggie White is remembered as a Packer AND an Eagle. Obviously he had great years in Philly. But he had 3 sacks in a SB win for Green Bay. He's remembered as a champion w/ the Packers.
watched this over and over and over when it dropped really made me fall in love with the game and i got a don hutson card bc of this he backthen as a kid and i still got it hes the goat of football
I'm not a Green Bay Packers fan, but, I love watching episodes of 'The NFL's Top 10' like this one, for example where they focus on one team & you can compare the NFL's list to one that you made, or, vice-versa & an opportunity to see/watch/hear a possibly opposing view is presented & the chance to engage in a debate is available, as well.
Favre is the 3rd best QB of this franchise.... Starr and Rodgers any day of the week before him and twice on Sundays. Great call with Don Hutson at No 1, the Babe Ruth of football.
Without Favre, the Packers continue to be irrelevant like they were for 25+ years after Lombardi left. Rodgers inherited a 13-3 team that had just been to an NFC Championship game...Favre inherited an aimless franchise that hadn’t been relevant in decades
Agree with this. Rodgers might be a better QB by just a hair, but Favre (with help from Reggie White) made the Packers relevant again. He's more important to the franchise overall. Also, this list was made in 2011, if it was today Rodgers would at least crack the top 10.
Wrong Brett Favre was the better quarterback! Aaron Rodgers played in a pass happy era were Brett Favre played in an era where you got beat the fuck up on the line all the time. If Aaron Rodgers played in the rules of the way Brett Favre played in the early years of his career there’s no way Aaron Rodgers would’ve had the stats he had. Aaron Rodgers is a great quarterback but he’s not better than Brett Favre period.
@Harry Engel If we go by a legitimate ranking based off NFL networks top 10 of this ranking Jim Taylor would be kicked off since he was number 10 and then you would rearrange it to what number he would be at however NFL network has an inconsistencies of there too 10 of just editing someone out for someone else in their place which I think is fucking stupid. So if we’re going by again in the NFL network top 10 list here I would have Aaron Rodgers at 3 and then move Bart Starr at 4.
Of all players in NFL history to led the league in receptions reception yards and touchdown receptions in a season Jerry Rice (1993) Sterling Sharpe (1992) Steve Smith (2005) Cooper Kupp (2021) Don Hutson Hutson is the only man to do so multiple times in multiple seasons In the 1940s when teams weren’t throwing the football as often as teams in today’s game
I hated Damon Amendolara and Mark Madden on these top 10s if it wasn't the Eagles, Patriots, or Steelers they would trash it. Ray Didinger's takes were usually fair.
I love it when that WR gets his recognition. He was just miles above his competition. I'm not saying he'd be Pro Bowler today, but he'd be a solid #2 minimum for any team today. I mean, even Johnny Unitas, who was from a later era, often threw 10 ish passes a game!
Bart Starr will tell you brett and arron are better , while he sits there , the only QB in nfl history with 3 straight championships. Humble and terrific. He is #1 on my list.
Rodgers yes, but not the others. Nothing but love for them. But Woodson didn't win multiple rings and wasn't arguably the best at his position. He'd get an honorable mention, but no more. NO new lineman is sniffing this list without 3+ rings. And Adams would need to stay healthy long enough to accumulate stats AND win at least 1 ring.
@@rabbijoe316 Rodgers makes the list now, but I wonder where he'd be....? When you step back and now look at his completed Packers career - great numbers, MVPS, playoff appearances, but only one super bowl appearance (a win, obviously..) So I don't know where I'd rank him...probably between 5-10
Now that I’ve paid a VERY well deserved compliment to the GOAT, I must say the fact that Forrest Gregg is not on this list makes me extremely sad. 3rd greatest Packer of all time
Harry Engel Someone is going to have to explain how a player with so many FATAL interceptions (SB XXXII, 2002 playoff against the Rams, 1999 playoff against the 49ers, 2004 playoff against the Eagles, 1995 NFC championship against Dallas, 2007 NFC championship against the Giants...and these are just playoff losses and just as a Packer) is even on this list. The guy has twice as many playoff losses directly attributable to him as Bart Starr has postseason interceptions. When his team needed him to win a championship, only one time he didn't let them down. But Jerry Kramer came through--under pretty brutal conditions and tremendous pressure--every time he had to. I believe Favre is the most wildly overrated player in memory, but if anyone wants to talk me out of this, I'm open to it.
I've heard that Forrest Gregg was outstanding as a player for the Packers but he was shitty as a coach. Just ask Charles Martin who body slammed Jim McMahon.
@@jmgarcia61Favre was incredible. Probably the most exciting quarterback that ever played the game. His ability to extemporize, and what he did to lift that franchise out of the abyss is simply irrefutable. You can try and downplay that because he made some interceptions. He’s one of the all-time great quarterbacks, and he made football really fun to watch.
Well, it’s a player list, so what the hell are you talking about? Don Hutson is arguably the greatest receiver that ever played football. He’s definitely in the top five next to Allsworth, rice, Loften, monk, and Don Maynard.
I love how polarizing Brett Favre is, I don't know much about him apart from his stats, but he doesn't seem to be someone people should hate so much lol but it's fun to see.
He played the game with aplomb. I don’t know if he was the greatest quarterback to ever play the game, but he was certainly the most exciting to watch. His entertainment value alone is undisputed.
This is such a hard list to rank since there were so many legendary players who played in different times this list is good I agree, but the list would be different from person to person
Farvre, Holmgren, Reggie White years. Har, har, har. I grew up in NW Wisconsin. Farve, Holmgren, White won one Title. ONE Title. The kick returner was the MVP. Great years? Har, har, har.
The only team that technically won 7 championships in 7 years if you count the NFL Championship game as a separate game from the Super Bowl. Also the only team that won 3 championships in a row and to do it twice
They need to do a Top 10 on players who played for championship teams in the year before/after they won the title. Edgerrin James is a good one. Signed with the Cardinals in the year the Colts won the Super Bowl.
I'm not a Pack fan by any means....but man, look at the history here. 49ers, Pats, Cowboys, Steelers (and everyone else), you got a LONG way to go..... Sorry.
I would have put sterling Sharpe abead of Reggie White, because white is far more synonymous with the Eagles than with the Packers. Don’t misunderstand me though. Reggie White is probably the greatest defensive lineman of all time.
I used to love watching Randall Cunningham bust the Packers, especially when Reggie White went to Green Bay. Cunningham was 4-0 in games vs. the Packers when Reggie was a in Green and Yellow.
I don't see how Starr is not #1. People dog his numbers because they compare him on yards and TDs to either outlier single seasons in the AFL or to modern numbers. But if you look at his QB rating, his completion percentage, his average yards per attempt, and his interception rates, he is in the top 3 in all of those categories during the 1960s. Add in FIVE NFL titles and some insane playoff stats, and I just don't think there's any comparison. He set the standard for quarterbacking, title-winning, and leadership in Green Bay that will live for eternity.
I agree on Hornung. If you look at the money downs for a back, even in the few close games they had during that Lombardi era, Hornung wasn't the guy they went to at his position. I was one of those angry he got into the Hall and Kramer had not.
Did you know that Mike Ditka went 15-5 against Green Bay as a bears head coach from 1982-1992, since 1993-present Chicago has only beaten Green Bay 14 times.the two teams did not meet in 1982 because of the strike shortened season.
So he beat the Packers a lot when they were not very good. Who cares? Something like that is only worth bragging about if you’re beating a team during an area where they were consistently good.
As a die hard Green Bay Packer fan, I'm offended that they put Brett Favre ahead of Bart Starr on this list. Brett Favre threw way too many interceptions in some very big playoff games that Bart Starr wouldn't have thrown. Bart Starr is the quintessential Green Bay Packer Quarterback the same way Ken Stabler is the quintessential Oakland Raider Quarterback, case closed. Bart Starr was 9-1 in the Postseason. No other quarterback in the history on the NFL, including the greatest quarterback in NFL history, Joe Montana, had that winning percentage in the Postseason.
Look at the talent Starr had around him and the system he played for. He didn’t throw as much. Lombardi was his coach too! Did Favre have a good defense, offensive line, and good coaching?
Why would they not put Forrest on the list??? We know Lombardi's opinion on this. Both Forrest and Kramer are top 10 packers ever but Gregg has to be the 1st offensive lineman mentioned
Definitely. I am not a Packer fan and I always enjoyed watching him play, but at some point you got to say: Man, I'm glad he's not playing for my team. He just brings to much hype and expectations only to burry all your dreams and hopes with disastrous turnovers, and god knows there were plenty of those games.
Harry Engel That Favre made the NFL 100th Anniversary team and Bart Starr didn't, is a catastrophic disgrace. I have an all-encompassing lack of respect for each and every single panelist who voted Starr off and Favre on.
Damon Amendollara is usually one of the better talking heads but he clearly knows nothing about Don Hutson and should just keep his mouth shut on this. Don Hutson would be a star today things he’d did and the numbers he achieved stood as records for 40 years. Perfect #1.
Hutson was asked in his later years, with the rules that the NFL has favoring the passing game now, how many catches he would have in a year. Hutson responded, "Probably fifty." The interviewer said, "Really, only fifty?" Hutson, "Well, I AM 70 years old."
I have a hard time putting a WR at #1. He should be on the list, but I don't know about #1. Sterling Sharpe should be there, as well as Aaron Rodgers. My personal #1 would be Starr or Favre, they each accomplished so much in different ways. I grew up a Bronco fan, but I watched a lot of Packer games, because of where I live.
When it comes to Rodgers keep in Mind this aired right after the 2010 season concluded. So Rodgers only had started for three years at that point. He’d be on an updated list
I always respected what Green Bay Packers it all about cause i think that Aaron Rodgers Donald Driver and Antonio Freeman should be recognized as the heart and soul to the Packers franchise history cause they all won super bowl championships honestly Donald Driver should be in the Hall Of Fame too
A lot of those Cowboys credit Herb Adderly with putting them over the hump with his "Get it done" attitude. I love Nitschke and I am a life long Packer fan. And I'd take Dick Butkus over Nitschke. Nitschke was indeed a hell of a player. Butkus was better. I got a pitch for Bart Starr. Starr was a better QB than Unitas. Keith Dunnavant, backed up by stats from Kerry Byrne, makes a VERY strong case for Starr. Oh, Starr played with great talent and coaching. So did Unitas. In 1962 the Packes had what was probably the best rushing team in NLF history. By 1966 they were last in the league in rushing. Starr wins his only MVP and leads the league with a completion percentage of 62.2 and a 105 passer rating Darren, you are showing your ignorance with the comment about Don Hutson. Hutson was the Babe Ruth of football. A guy whose production matched that of other teams. 99 TDs, broken after 44 years.... think of the changes that occurred between the careers of Hutson and Largent.
Where does Aaron Rodgers go on this list if his Packers career is over now? Most likely 4 MVPs and a 1 championship. I think he's in the best Packers player of all time to me but I didn't watch Lombardi Packers. How about Davante Adams? Does he get in?
Well he did win a SB with the Packers. Plus they made such a big deal about him signing with GB during the first free agency, people remember that too. And I believe he went into the HOF as a Packer. Those three things are probably why he is remembered as a Packer.
Спорт
glad to see Kramer finally got into the HOF
Oh thank God that confused the hell out of me
I watched that HOF ceremony strictly for him.
gregg was better
Next one who needs to get into the Hall of fame #84 SterlingSharpe
He’s Top 10 Packers of All Time for Me
I'm not a Packers fan but i love their uniforms and history
I love the packers
Have you ever noticed how a team’s uniforms seem to look great when they’re winning a lot? To me it felt like Packers uniforms didn’t look good when I watching was watching games in the 70s & 80s but they looked sharp since 1996. 😀
@@cyounger5716 Poor Randy, voted worst starting QB in Packers history. 😂 Yes, I agree that everything looked shabby with Randy Wright. To his credit, he made his life in Wisconsin, runs a business & a football camp there. He was a 6th round pick without elite skills who had to learn the NFL version of the position without a true training program. Mike McCarthy put Aaron Rodgers in what he called his “ quarterback college.” Hope the Falcons do the same for Penix. Truth be told most QBs, especially those drafted in late rounds, don’t get a true developmental plan/program & have to figure it out for themselves.
Don Hutson is a great pick for the Greatest Packer. He was so far ahead of the rest of the league that it is still mind-boggling. It speaks well of Antonio Freeman to give him proper respect like he does here.
Leaving Forrest Gregg off this list is indefensible, however. Gregg made the NFL's 100th Anniversary team, meaning he was rated as one of the four greatest tackles in the history of professional football. No disrespect to Bart Starr, but he probably wouldn't make most lists of top 20 quarterbacks. It was wise to include Kramer, but foolish to omit Gregg.
Respectfully, I think saying Bart Starr isn’t top 20 is crazy. Having said that, agree with everything you said. Im glad you didn’t decide to shit on Don Hutson, instead you praised him justly. And yeah, holy shit leaving off Forrest Gregg was fucking criminal. He might be the greatest pure football player in terms of ability at a position that the Packers have ever had.
Talk about a team putting a city on the map!
Jerry Kramer is also in the Hall of Fame now
I wouldn't put James Lofton on the list, mainly because I think of him more as a Buffalo Bill than a Packer.
I will definitely defend Lofton on this list. He is one of the greatest WRs ever. So tall and agile. He even thinks of himself as a Packer. He’s never listed as a Bills great.
The problem with Lofton is that in the early 80s, the offense was excellent. Lynn Dickey was a great QB and the 3rd man to ever throw for more than 4000 yards. John Jefferson was also there and the TE Paul Coffman was a Pro Bowler for several years. They had a O line was very strong and they had one of the best offenses in the NFL. Problem was their defense was arguably the worst in the NFL. Several years of 8-8 kept him from really being a nationally known player. But his stats from the time really show just how great he is.
Harry Engel i get your position on this, but that would preclude any Lions player from being on the lists that didn’t involve dumpster fires since 1957. Also pre 1970s Steelers, any Cardinals since the Bidwills were awarded the franchise after the Pottsville Maroons we’re booted from the league in 1925 until Kurt Warner. You’re absolutely right about the post Lombardi Packers = garbage, I’m just adding my thought to your point, no offense intended.
if he was playing in some good packers team, there will be no controversy...
Do Du Absolutely right my friend, but you have to consider he put up those numbers in Green Bay when half of his time he had David Whitehurst a guy named Dennis Sproul, and a well passed his prime Bobby Douglass who when he played for the Bears ran the ball more than he threw it. Which at least for me makes those numbers pop. Jim Kelly vs three guys that were forgotten the moment they took the uniform off. I have no issue with someone who remembers him in Buffalo more than Green Bay. If you would ask ten people “when you think of Shaq what uniform is he wearing” 8 of them will say the Lakers and not the Magic.These lists are so subjective that there are really no wrong answers.
I would just because he was one of the only great players in a dark era for Packers football. Never had a good qb either
And thanks for all the videos, Isaac Green. I wish the NFL network would start producing these again.
Loves these nfl top 10
Yap, the NFL top ten are fun to watch!
I got a chance to have a 30 min conversation with Jerry Kramer and I tried to think of a good question to ask him when it was my turn to talk to him. I asked him who was the greatest athlete he ever played with and he talked about Ray Nitske for 30 mins. He said he could throw the ball 60+ yards.
Herb Adderley would be be a superstar today instead of Apple underlining his last name in red as a spelling error.
XD.
That marks the one and only time I have ever agreed with Mark Madden. "The Packers are a reminder of what sports used to be, and maybe should be."
Bart Starr had an addiction to winning.
Too bad that the Packers didn't have the same winning formula with Bart as a coach as with him as the legendary QB. And this is from a Bears fan who actually did have a huge respect for Mr. Starr.
@@scoobycarr5558 He did, the team was pathetic when he took over thanks to the Hadl Trade. However, they made the playoffs once, and for three years in a row, he never had a losing year. Then, they fired him to hire Forest Greg.
@@shrihithtalapaneni9227 Starr was a mediocre coach at best. Packers gave him chance after chance to produce a winner
"He's gonna be fast... going to his grave."
This is why I love Brian Baldinger.
Highly underrated in terms of football knowledge.
Jerry is in the hall of fame now baby
Glad they have Hutson as the greatest Packer. Hutson was a dominanting football player. The Jim Brown of his era.
2:27 Jim Taylor.
6:32 Jerry Kramer.
9:52 James Lofton.
14:07 Herb Adderley.
17:17 Paul Hornung.
22:04 Ray Nitschke.
24:44 Reggie White.
29:18 Bart Starr.
34:37 Brett Favre.
40:05 Don Hutson.
I'm not a Green Bay Packers fan, but, I love watching episodes of 'The NFL's Top 10' like this one, for example where they focus on one team & you can compare the NFL's list to one that you made, or, vice-versa & an opportunity to see/watch/hear a possibly opposing view is presented & the chance to engage in a debate is available, as well.
Depending on what NFL team/teams you like, you could probably watch episodes like this, for example over & over & over, again & never get tired of them.
Reggie White is remembered as a Packer AND an Eagle. Obviously he had great years in Philly. But he had 3 sacks in a SB win for Green Bay. He's remembered as a champion w/ the Packers.
That's why I rank him as the 2nd greatest Eagle behind Concrete Charlie. - Words of a Steelers fan.
watched this over and over and over when it dropped really made me fall in love with the game and i got a don hutson card bc of this he backthen as a kid and i still got it hes the goat of football
don hutson holds one of the NFL Top 10 records that will never be broken
I'm not a Green Bay Packers fan, but, I love watching episodes of 'The NFL's Top 10' like this one, for example where they focus on one team & you can compare the NFL's list to one that you made, or, vice-versa & an opportunity to see/watch/hear a possibly opposing view is presented & the chance to engage in a debate is available, as well.
Favre is the 3rd best QB of this franchise.... Starr and Rodgers any day of the week before him and twice on Sundays.
Great call with Don Hutson at No 1, the Babe Ruth of football.
Without Favre, the Packers continue to be irrelevant like they were for 25+ years after Lombardi left. Rodgers inherited a 13-3 team that had just been to an NFC Championship game...Favre inherited an aimless franchise that hadn’t been relevant in decades
Agree with this. Rodgers might be a better QB by just a hair, but Favre (with help from Reggie White) made the Packers relevant again. He's more important to the franchise overall.
Also, this list was made in 2011, if it was today Rodgers would at least crack the top 10.
That record scratch sound is totally deserved. In no universe does Brett Favre rank ahead of Bart Starr in terms of the all time Packers.
Wrong Brett Favre was the better quarterback! Aaron Rodgers played in a pass happy era were Brett Favre played in an era where you got beat the fuck up on the line all the time. If Aaron Rodgers played in the rules of the way Brett Favre played in the early years of his career there’s no way Aaron Rodgers would’ve had the stats he had. Aaron Rodgers is a great quarterback but he’s not better than Brett Favre period.
@Harry Engel If we go by a legitimate ranking based off NFL networks top 10 of this ranking Jim Taylor would be kicked off since he was number 10 and then you would rearrange it to what number he would be at however NFL network has an inconsistencies of there too 10 of just editing someone out for someone else in their place which I think is fucking stupid. So if we’re going by again in the NFL network top 10 list here I would have Aaron Rodgers at 3 and then move Bart Starr at 4.
Hutson is the right choice. Top 5 best receiver ever without a doubt.
Rodgers is definitely on this list now
Of all players in NFL history to led the league in receptions reception yards and touchdown receptions in a season
Jerry Rice (1993)
Sterling Sharpe (1992)
Steve Smith (2005)
Cooper Kupp (2021)
Don Hutson
Hutson is the only man to do so multiple times in multiple seasons
In the 1940s when teams weren’t throwing the football as often as teams in today’s game
0:00 Even a Chicago Bears legend like Mike Ditka respects the Packers
I hated Damon Amendolara and Mark Madden on these top 10s if it wasn't the Eagles, Patriots, or Steelers they would trash it. Ray Didinger's takes were usually fair.
I love it when that WR gets his recognition. He was just miles above his competition. I'm not saying he'd be Pro Bowler today, but he'd be a solid #2 minimum for any team today.
I mean, even Johnny Unitas, who was from a later era, often threw 10 ish passes a game!
I'm not even a Packer fan but I know this is before 2018, Kramer is in years HOF, and deserved it even up to the point he made it.
Bart Starr will tell you brett and arron are better , while he sits there , the only QB in nfl history with 3 straight championships. Humble and terrific. He is #1 on my list.
These top 10 videos are crazy underrated
Aaron Rodgers and Charles Woodson will be up there on this top 10 list, or even a sequel top 10 if that's the case.
Rodgers , Bahktiari and probably Adams
Talk about a team putting a city on the map!
Rodgers yes, but not the others. Nothing but love for them. But Woodson didn't win multiple rings and wasn't arguably the best at his position. He'd get an honorable mention, but no more. NO new lineman is sniffing this list without 3+ rings. And Adams would need to stay healthy long enough to accumulate stats AND win at least 1 ring.
@@rabbijoe316 Rodgers makes the list now, but I wonder where he'd be....? When you step back and now look at his completed Packers career - great numbers, MVPS, playoff appearances, but only one super bowl appearance (a win, obviously..) So I don't know where I'd rank him...probably between 5-10
Jim Taylor was the original 'Beast Mode'.
19 touchdowns in a single season.
"If you ain't first, you're last" - Vince Lombardi
One of my favorite quotes ever, cause it’s so true. More sports teams should treat a championship like that, you’re either first or last
13:04 Brett Favre's "what happened to me?"
Lol killed me
Jimmy Taylor scored the first rushing touchdown in SB history. And barely missed the second by inches.
Now that I’ve paid a VERY well deserved compliment to the GOAT, I must say the fact that Forrest Gregg is not on this list makes me extremely sad. 3rd greatest Packer of all time
Throw Brett Favre off this list and put in Forrest Gregg.
Harry Engel Someone is going to have to explain how a player with so many FATAL interceptions (SB XXXII, 2002 playoff against the Rams, 1999 playoff against the 49ers, 2004 playoff against the Eagles, 1995 NFC championship against Dallas, 2007 NFC championship against the Giants...and these are just playoff losses and just as a Packer) is even on this list. The guy has twice as many playoff losses directly attributable to him as Bart Starr has postseason interceptions. When his team needed him to win a championship, only one time he didn't let them down. But Jerry Kramer came through--under pretty brutal conditions and tremendous pressure--every time he had to. I believe Favre is the most wildly overrated player in memory, but if anyone wants to talk me out of this, I'm open to it.
Harry Engel I could live with that
I've heard that Forrest Gregg was outstanding as a player for the Packers but he was shitty as a coach. Just ask Charles Martin who body slammed Jim McMahon.
@@jmgarcia61Favre was incredible. Probably the most exciting quarterback that ever played the game. His ability to extemporize, and what he did to lift that franchise out of the abyss is simply irrefutable. You can try and downplay that because he made some interceptions. He’s one of the all-time great quarterbacks, and he made football really fun to watch.
They should make Coaches a part of these lists. I would put Don Hutson on the list, but I would have Vince Lombardi at #1.
Well, it’s a player list, so what the hell are you talking about? Don Hutson is arguably the greatest receiver that ever played football. He’s definitely in the top five next to Allsworth, rice, Loften, monk, and Don Maynard.
I love how polarizing Brett Favre is, I don't know much about him apart from his stats, but he doesn't seem to be someone people should hate so much lol but it's fun to see.
He played the game with aplomb. I don’t know if he was the greatest quarterback to ever play the game, but he was certainly the most exciting to watch. His entertainment value alone is undisputed.
This is such a hard list to rank since there were so many legendary players who played in different times this list is good I agree, but the list would be different from person to person
Farvre, Holmgren, Reggie White years. Har, har, har. I grew up in NW Wisconsin. Farve, Holmgren, White won one Title. ONE Title. The kick returner was the MVP. Great years? Har, har, har.
And sorry but Reggie played 8 seasons in Philly & only 6 in GB...he is an Eagle first. He shouldn’t be #4...maybe #10 or at highest #7
The only team that technically won 7 championships in 7 years if you count the NFL Championship game as a separate game from the Super Bowl. Also the only team that won 3 championships in a row and to do it twice
They need to do a Top 10 on players who played for championship teams in the year before/after they won the title. Edgerrin James is a good one. Signed with the Cardinals in the year the Colts won the Super Bowl.
If coaches were included on this list, you know Vince Lombardi would be number one!
I'm not a Pack fan by any means....but man, look at the history here. 49ers, Pats, Cowboys, Steelers (and everyone else), you got a LONG way to go..... Sorry.
Yet they all have more SB wins than GB
@@marvinlynch1305 but is the trophy named after their coach?
@@_Boobear_ Nah, but Walsh and Belichick were/are better
@@marvinlynch1305 better than Lombardi? Yeah i don't think so
@@_Boobear_ Absolutely...Paul Brown was also better
Max Mcgee from White Oak TX a legend
How can Forrest Gregg not be in the top 10 ??! C'mon man.
I would have put sterling Sharpe abead of Reggie White, because white is far more synonymous with the Eagles than with the Packers. Don’t misunderstand me though. Reggie White is probably the greatest defensive lineman of all time.
He has trouble with the Dallas Cowboys offensive line!
@@AmirKhan-yv8jm
(yawns)
LOVE this! 💚💛🧀 PS Does anyone know the songs that start at 3:45 and 4:48? 3:45 sounds like Round Up by Sam Spence.
4:48 is The Equalizer by Sam Spence.
Isaac Green Thanks!! 🙏
I used to love watching Randall Cunningham bust the Packers, especially when Reggie White went to Green Bay. Cunningham was 4-0 in games vs. the Packers when Reggie was a in Green and Yellow.
I don't see how Starr is not #1. People dog his numbers because they compare him on yards and TDs to either outlier single seasons in the AFL or to modern numbers. But if you look at his QB rating, his completion percentage, his average yards per attempt, and his interception rates, he is in the top 3 in all of those categories during the 1960s. Add in FIVE NFL titles and some insane playoff stats, and I just don't think there's any comparison. He set the standard for quarterbacking, title-winning, and leadership in Green Bay that will live for eternity.
...and, as I keep saying, the only championship threepeat in NFL history.
What did Vince Lombardi say around 21:10-21:14?...
The difference between Bart Star and other Quarterbacks, he had more championships and more consistency during his career.
3 reasons why Starr is ahead of Favre -
2001 NFC Divisional
2007 NFC Title
Literally EVERYTHING AFTER that Game.
Willie Wood should be on the list ahead of Paul Hornung...he was one of the best Safeties of the 60s. Hornung was more reputation than actual play.
I agree on Hornung. If you look at the money downs for a back, even in the few close games they had during that Lombardi era, Hornung wasn't the guy they went to at his position. I was one of those angry he got into the Hall and Kramer had not.
Herb Adderley amazes me every time I hear about him! Goat?!
Did you know that Mike Ditka went 15-5 against Green Bay as a bears head coach from 1982-1992, since 1993-present Chicago has only beaten Green Bay 14 times.the two teams did not meet in 1982 because of the strike shortened season.
So he beat the Packers a lot when they were not very good. Who cares? Something like that is only worth bragging about if you’re beating a team during an area where they were consistently good.
Ticker: "Nick Collins (neck) out for season" 😭
@Harry Engel yes but his career was cut short during the 2011 season
If and when this is updated it'll have Aaron Rodgers, Charles Woodson and Clay Matthews.
Woodson wasn't a Packer for long enough, and Matthews wasn't great for a long enough time. Rodgers is easy top 5 tho, but probably #3 for QBs.
32:03 Cough Cough Matt Ryan.
As a die hard Green Bay Packer fan, I'm offended that they put Brett Favre ahead of Bart Starr on this list. Brett Favre threw way too many interceptions in some very big playoff games that Bart Starr wouldn't have thrown. Bart Starr is the quintessential Green Bay Packer Quarterback the same way Ken Stabler is the quintessential Oakland Raider Quarterback, case closed. Bart Starr was 9-1 in the Postseason. No other quarterback in the history on the NFL, including the greatest quarterback in NFL history, Joe Montana, had that winning percentage in the Postseason.
Look at the talent Starr had around him and the system he played for. He didn’t throw as much. Lombardi was his coach too! Did Favre have a good defense, offensive line, and good coaching?
This is when Top 10 was a good show before they had all those idiot comics who don’t know anything about football ruin it
Damn this is old
Not even an honorable mention for Dave Robinson, one of the greatest outside linebackers of all time??
Why would they not put Forrest on the list??? We know Lombardi's opinion on this. Both Forrest and Kramer are top 10 packers ever but Gregg has to be the 1st offensive lineman mentioned
Not a packers fan but seeing a game there and seeing their history is nothing compared to my broncos
Top 10 Miami Dolphins
How about Top 10 Chicago Bears?
the position thats the most important. 1-rodgers 2-favre 3-starr 4-hudson 5-hornung 6-white 7-nitchske 8-kramer 9-gregg 10-lambeau
In no universe is Brett Favre anywhere close to Bart Starr. Just the sheer number of fatal interceptions is enough to push him off this list.
Definitely. I am not a Packer fan and I always enjoyed watching him play, but at some point you got to say: Man, I'm glad he's not playing for my team. He just brings to much hype and expectations only to burry all your dreams and hopes with disastrous turnovers, and god knows there were plenty of those games.
Milan Barac I'm sure, enshrined in some little known RUclips channel, is a video of all the catastrophic Brett Favre interceptions.
Harry Engel That Favre made the NFL 100th Anniversary team and Bart Starr didn't, is a catastrophic disgrace. I have an all-encompassing lack of respect for each and every single panelist who voted Starr off and Favre on.
3 MVP's, 2 SB appearances, and he personally resurrected them after 20+ years of losing & he was a lot more fun to watch
Plus he retired with every passing record at the time
I think forest greg should of been on here
37:37 it’s 2023 and this aged horrendously
Damon Amendollara is usually one of the better talking heads but he clearly knows nothing about Don Hutson and should just keep his mouth shut on this. Don Hutson would be a star today things he’d did and the numbers he achieved stood as records for 40 years. Perfect #1.
Hutson was asked in his later years, with the rules that the NFL has favoring the passing game now, how many catches he would have in a year.
Hutson responded, "Probably fifty."
The interviewer said, "Really, only fifty?"
Hutson, "Well, I AM 70 years old."
Don Hutson Was Incredible
They need to add A-Rod
Yes Don Huston 🏉 7️⃣/1️⃣4️⃣🏈
I have a hard time putting a WR at #1. He should be on the list, but I don't know about #1. Sterling Sharpe should be there, as well as Aaron Rodgers. My personal #1 would be Starr or Favre, they each accomplished so much in different ways. I grew up a Bronco fan, but I watched a lot of Packer games, because of where I live.
When it comes to Rodgers keep in Mind this aired right after the 2010 season concluded. So Rodgers only had started for three years at that point. He’d be on an updated list
I always respected what Green Bay Packers it all about cause i think that Aaron Rodgers Donald Driver and Antonio Freeman should be recognized as the heart and soul to the Packers franchise history cause they all won super bowl championships honestly Donald Driver should be in the Hall Of Fame too
When it really comes down to it it's Favre #1
I lived in ATL when they offed Brett.....he was no. 3, never really got a decent shot.
VIDEO: greatest players in green bay history
THUMBNAIL: man from philadelphia
Not one mention of Favre asking "what's the capital of Thailand?"
You can thank Jerry Glanville (former Falcons coach) for Brett Favre's presence in Green Bay.
I still can't forgive Jerry for trading him away.
We need one for the New York Giants
Who was Don Hutson side kick at Alabama? The Bear
A lot of those Cowboys credit Herb Adderly with putting them over the hump with his "Get it done" attitude.
I love Nitschke and I am a life long Packer fan. And I'd take Dick Butkus over Nitschke. Nitschke was indeed a hell of a player. Butkus was better.
I got a pitch for Bart Starr. Starr was a better QB than Unitas. Keith Dunnavant, backed up by stats from Kerry Byrne, makes a VERY strong case for Starr. Oh, Starr played with great talent and coaching. So did Unitas. In 1962 the Packes had what was probably the best rushing team in NLF history. By 1966 they were last in the league in rushing. Starr wins his only MVP and leads the league with a completion percentage of 62.2 and a 105 passer rating
Darren, you are showing your ignorance with the comment about Don Hutson. Hutson was the Babe Ruth of football. A guy whose production matched that of other teams. 99 TDs, broken after 44 years.... think of the changes that occurred between the careers of Hutson and Largent.
31:53 cough cough Pete Carole take notes cough
Jerry Hall Of Famer Kramer #64 7:27
💚💛💚💛
Where does Aaron Rodgers go on this list if his Packers career is over now? Most likely 4 MVPs and a 1 championship. I think he's in the best Packers player of all time to me but I didn't watch Lombardi Packers. How about Davante Adams? Does he get in?
Rodgers is top 3 and Davante is top 15 maybe borderline 11th
I think Aaron would be ranked no. 3 or no. 2 or even no. 1 on that list depending on who you’re talking to.
Starr should be #1. Taylor should be a lot higher.
But Sterling. My families dog and friends children were named Sterling.
Aaron Rodgers would be top 5 now
Before looking at the list I’ll say Don Hutson is #1.
I think reggie is remembered more as a packer but should be remembered as a eagle
Well he did win a SB with the Packers. Plus they made such a big deal about him signing with GB during the first free agency, people remember that too. And I believe he went into the HOF as a Packer. Those three things are probably why he is remembered as a Packer.
i clicked this video to see brett favre
When this is updated or redone Aaron Rodgers must be on this list.
Yup
update for 2022 would include Rodgers, Matthews and Nelson. Rodgers would be top 3.
Sterling Sharpe would have been #1…but God had a different idea
1. Bart Starr
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Brett Favre
4. Don Hutson
and Forest Gregg should be on the list instead of Paul Hornung