Many and probably lots of them had as much of a hatred fro seperatist scum as the clones and sure as hell werent so willing to be all nice and pacifist as jedis. in fact in the EU a lot of the things the empire will be infamous developed during the clone wars especially during the outer rim sieges be it forced labor(slavery), mass murders and brutal suppresion , remember the cis is basically a rebellion and grievous committed horrifying atrocities particularly against human worlds especially during operation durges lance a pusch into the core that was only topped by the battle of coruscant, a lot of these republic officers had an axe to grind with the cis and wanted revenge and werent that obedient to annoying hippie jedi thats why they push to strip more and more power from the jedi so that the officer core got more control
There was a lot of Republic officers that that became Imperial officers. The ones that were not „loyal“ to the empire and the emperor were executed. At least that’s what the book heir of the empire told which is legends Star Wars
@@Adri_sw Oh yeah I know, but comparing espically legends to canon, I would like to know how many followed & either agreed with destroying the Jedi & how many just followed orders until they found out the truth like Dodana who was in A New Hope, who is suggested in both canon & legends to be a Republic commander. Ozzel was a commander that was with Wolfe when he got his scar amongst the 104th. Tarkin of course we know was a fleet captain & GAR admiral. Captain Needa was the very ship captain that attacked the invisible hand while Anakin & Obiwan was saving the chancellor apprantly. Yularen of course became head of the ISB. Panaka while not an offical GAR officer, became the moff & governor for Naboo which is ironic. Thrawn worked with the GAR & Anakin a few times in canon. Admiral Screed was supposedly a GAR commander. Gallius Rax was temporarily with the GAR in the beginning of the war. The point being many of the Impeerial officers in the Empire were part of the GAR one way or another & encounter or knew of the Sith, the Jedi & very few, the whole plot of Order 66, so it makes one wonder many of their standpoints when they fought against the Jedi later down the line as the Empire & became the threat the Separatist were practically were at the time & was totally cool with it.
@@pope2552 I know, & I know it’s a small detail but i would kinda like to see things from their perspective for a change. We’ve seen stormtroopers & clones between bad batch & of course clone wars, agent kallus was a good story but is reused with iden sadly. Hux isn’t much.
Everyone in star wars uses 18th to 19th century tactics. Every space combat is literally a broadside Napoleonic action with WW2 style carrier based craft mixed in.
This scene always confused me. Are the citizens saying "Long live the Republic?" It's sounds like the voice of the Officer, but it can't be, because this is the Empire timeline, and the Republic doesn't occupy homeworlds. But then in an earlier scene, Andor's mom calls the separatists aboard that downed shuttle "Republic", which makes it sound like they are separatists. I like Andor, but sometimes the lore gets confusing.
@@Chris_ThorndykeIt wasn't even poor writing. The entire scene was during the Republic Era. However, it's showing a different side of it. Since unless you were with Jedi you often were seen as nothing but a disposable soldier and a number. Which means individualism and personally were almost none existent.
The folks were protesting the rise of the new Empire i believe. The Republic being unceremoniously replaced by the Empire must have been a jarring thing
I know you're joking but my INTP ass still want to explain so sorry in advance. In real life indetical twins are not evenly tall too, so this is possible in my opinion, but good notice tho.
@@TuTuVanOers2 Bodie Taylor is one of the clone trooper actors from Attack of the Clones & Revenge of the Sith. He is what the Clones look like between the age gap between Boba aka Daniel Logan & Commander Cody aka Morrison. He is notably in the scene wearing the red uniform in the cafeteria eating when Obi-wan was first shown the army.
The attention to detail in this scene is amazing when a realistic perspective is considered. First of all, it's a flashback of a person's pretty traumatic memory of a civilian population's massacre by a military force, and no they didnt show it happen in the typical way like how the Mandalorian did with the camera in slow-mo, blasters blazing, people screaming, etc. What we instead have in Andor is a methodical build up to how such tragedies could have and would have happened in real life. Plenty of atrocities committed on civillians were due to soldiers reacting too impusively, be it a protesting mob or a large group of people straight up harrassing them. A historical case very similar, and most likely an inspiration to the scene depicted in Andor was the Boston massacre, where a mob of colonial Americans were fired on by British troops after they were harrassed by said colonial Americans...
How did andor get the clones to look so much better than in ahsoka, ahsoka's clone troopers look like they have oversized, cheap plasti cosplay armor, whereas here those clones look so good, like theyre straight out of RoTS
Phase 1 live action had a different design closer to tcw since it fitted better on real humans. They probably just made a small amount of kit for the quick scene.
It exists. Its called clone wars, altho i rly hate the fact they once AGAIN DIDNT MAKE THE EPISODES IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER, and now i AS AN IDIOT have to watch videos about the guide to watch them.
@@spartandk7660 That's only in legends during the Kamino rebellion and they decide to forgo using clones anymore (But still kept the ones serving and gave them good retirements). In the Dinsey version they just sort of get rid of clone troopers for no reason and blow up Kamino.
Nope. The flashback is immediately after the end of the Clone Wars, hence why there are still clone troopers in service (obviously) and a protestor yells "Long live the Republic", because the Republic had just fallen/reorganized.
I believe that these are not clones, but conscripted soldiers in clone armor, considering that there was a brief time after the empire first came to power where normal humans wore clone armor while stormtrooper armor was being developed.
It was covered in the clone wars (briefly) that due to the demands of the war, more and more clones were sent into battle before their training was complete. My guess is, that the shorter individuals in clone armour are just younger clones that hadn't reached full maturity before being deployed.
@@orbaitv5991they might have during the siege of mandalore flashback? Ashoka was young af in the earlier one and that’ll be why they made phase 1 armour instead of using these.
@@CT_Taylor but just seeing them from behind just looks so off to me. I mean I wouldn't have noticed if they were used for the shot at the leg sequence marching, but it looks so awkward
Clones are literally bred for combat at accelerated speed in numerous batches, and shown on screen to be different ages, hair colors, facial structures, etc… height is nothing
@@jackrutledgegoembel5896 What are you yapping about? They all look like Jango fett, some just decided to dye their hair, shave it, grow facial, etc. Only exceptions like 99 or the bad batch have differences, but the average clones have the same height. Stop making up excuses for poor casting.
Actually I’m sick of everyone thinking troopers have bad aim. Both stormtroopers and clone troopers were excellent marksman’s. It was thier rifles. Have you ever tried shooting an e-11 while wearing a bucket that big? With thier HUDS and everything it was a lot harder than it looked. Yall just small minded.😂😂😂😂
@@ttvRED-WRATHmost of it was plot armor. Aside from shooting at the main characters, stormtroopers were great shots. Literally the first fight we ever see them (A New Hope) they body a rebel unit despite being held at a choke point in a ship. They only lose two soldiers and literally decimate the entire defense force that had a strategic advantage
Now THAT was satisfying. Their commanding Officer had their backs. Nobody throws a rock at his men and gets to get away with it. Also, I'm assuming "79's" is a reference to A New Hope's initial; release year?
@@vanillachungus9546it’d be expensive to do that and lets be honest here, nobody hates Star Wars more than Star Wars fans, if they CGI’d it fans would’ve gotten mad and called it bad CGI 😂
[Julio and Marcy observing the street as Stormtroopers blast civilians] Julio: "Are they really shooting the civvies for that?" Marcy: "The troopers are uncivilized. They don't realize that any use of force only creates resentment; makes them look like cowards, even." Julio: "Should we report Commander Caulfield for this incident?" Marcy: "No. We will commence covert operations at night. Plant some anti-Empire propaganda to 'scare' the loyalists into a frenzy." Julio: "So cast them with doubt and keep our hands clean?" Marcy: "That's the plan." Julio: "Hmm... that might just work."
This was 1 year after the end of clone wars, when Cass was 13 they hanged his father clem and cassian was sent to prison (he tried to attack the clones with baton) for 3 years until he was 16, then empire sent him to Mimban, he was there until he deserted. Idk they just used diego luna face for this flashback.
@@aGiraffePretendingToBeaMan the one I found odd was the bit where cassian is a kid and finds the crashed “republic” ship, whose crew members all have an emblem very similar to the CIS one on their uniforms. I got the impression that was supposed to be a separatist ship but they changed it to a republic one too late for the uniforms to be changed. But then it could also maybe be some secret Palpatine shit, idk. It was a little confusing but the flashbacks definitely still achieved what they were supposed to, and these scenes with the clones on ferrix were very well executed imo.
This happened before the clone wars started and before the CIS seceded from the republic, your average person let alone scavenger like Maarva and Clem would just assume they were republic officers bc they weren't the CIS yet that we see in Episode 2.@@Shot5hells
@@JuggernautHunter02 Take the sith/corporate influence from the Republic and you still have a corrupt and ineffecient government supported by a stagnant Jedi order Take sith/corporate influence from the Confederacy and you have a collection of planets and races who want the freedom to rule themselves and prosper without the heavy taxes and zero help the central government has brought
@@FierySpirit7 the bulk of it courtesy of the people of Geonosis, as opposed to the Trade Federation who also has control over the Republic (they even have representation in the Senate after de invasion of Naboo)
@@FierySpirit7 the few Separatists conquering worlds were aliens in Palpatine's plans to create xenophobia in as many worlds as possible, many of which are of neutral corporations like Wat Tambor
@AIRWAY26 "Cognitive correlations" meaning telling yourself things contradicted by canon and legends? A second grader experimenting with 3 syllable words, good luck kid - you've got a long way to go.
Siiigh and the empire keeps failing even basics of crowd control 1, you do not deploy soldiers against internal threats ever 2, if YOU are the reason for the aggression and no one else is in danger de escalate and just leave the area. 3, come back later with a clear mission objective and or just fine them in their absence.
@@GoklasM empire doesn't glass planets, this isn't halo. Plus this represents the fundamental misunderstanding of the political situation. The empire was a continuation of the republic in all but the name. Just like Roman empire was a continuation of the Roman republic. Unless this is about the ideals the republic is supposed to represent, which would be strange, considering the republic was void of these ideals for the past century and not even people on coruscant knew what republic was supposed to be about. So this is an obvious set up to get sndor going a set up that twist the wider narrative. Which makes it bad writing.
0:34. These clone actors really sucked. They don't even stand the same. And are not the same height. They should have at least rehearsed there movements to be identical.
Would you rather they be cgi? Those turns require weeks worth of practice and discipline and identical movements or exact heights isn't practical. You'd have to find a squad of men with similar heights and builds with basic training experience and with exact movements that's intense sentinel guard training. Having fans that love star wars is better if you just subvert your disbelief in world of aliens and magic guys with laser swords
@@thedragon1363 CGI isn't the answer to everything. Look at Marvel right now. And rehearsing moves turns do take weeks, but you also have to understand the source material. They are playing CLONE troopers, Clones is the main word. There moves and height are meant to be identical. When these actors signed for it, they should deliver it well.
@@SILENTBULL_9er Look at it from a budget standpoint, if you want smaller shows and stories they're gonna have less budgets. Doesn't mean they can't be enjoyed with a lil suspension of disbelief
@@Lilrob06 TK Troopers don't wear Clone Armor. It would be illogical to assume these aren't Clones because of a height difference that extends to the Kenobi, Book of Boba Fett, and Ahsoka series when they show live action Clone Troopers.
@@oldwolffe3636 unlikely, in Legends, the uprising happened 5 years after ROTS, meaning the youngest clones are 14 years old (28 physically) by the time of ANH. It is also explicitly mentioned that some of them started from Geonosis all the way to Hoth. While Filoni's Canon seems to make every clone trooper go into retirement for some reason 1 year after ROTS.
God the Vader’s Fist is just great I still think those are the clone troopers that are legitimate Never liked the chips thing Never liked Rex And heck, I once heard long ago that the hat guy didn’t even like Commandos, but someone on the animation team loved them so much so Delta was only a cameo in the 2008 CW, and a complete joke in Bad Batch
Yeah, what ended up happening to the clones in canon is honestly some of the dumbest shit ever. And I really appreciate that Legends had the balls to make some of the Stormtroopers clones.
To be fair to Filoni, that decision was made by Lucasfilms well before even Rebels was launched. His stuff merely is enforcing and elaborating upon the company policy. Does that make it right? Not really, but it does demonstrate he is just a tool to corporate shitbags.
“Wait a second Teardown, why are we all different heights?”
*exactly* 😭
Because you never ate your breakfast on Kamino!
“Teardown, don’t tell me you’re fasting again”
They’re the Sparta clones or whatever the 1 year batch are
That or according to Disney lore, they did try to clone after Kamino was destroyed
@@j.w.5718 Or...you know,the actors aren't the same height obviously.
Don't excuse bad decisions.
I love Andor and I love the clones. This scene was perfect. Wish we had more live action pre stormtrooper Dark Times
"But they through a fucking rock at me..."
*threw
@@mannanmorvi1806*throuooeauxgh
You’re not the only one they threw a rock at
My main question is I wonder now how many “Imperial Officers” such as the one here, were originally Republic Officers.
Many and probably lots of them had as much of a hatred fro seperatist scum as the clones and sure as hell werent so willing to be all nice and pacifist as jedis. in fact in the EU a lot of the things the empire will be infamous developed during the clone wars especially during the outer rim sieges be it forced labor(slavery), mass murders and brutal suppresion , remember the cis is basically a rebellion and grievous committed horrifying atrocities particularly against human worlds especially during operation durges lance a pusch into the core that was only topped by the battle of coruscant, a lot of these republic officers had an axe to grind with the cis and wanted revenge and werent that obedient to annoying hippie jedi thats why they push to strip more and more power from the jedi so that the officer core got more control
There was a lot of Republic officers that that became Imperial officers. The ones that were not „loyal“ to the empire and the emperor were executed. At least that’s what the book heir of the empire told which is legends Star Wars
@@Adri_sw Oh yeah I know, but comparing espically legends to canon, I would like to know how many followed & either agreed with destroying the Jedi & how many just followed orders until they found out the truth like Dodana who was in A New Hope, who is suggested in both canon & legends to be a Republic commander.
Ozzel was a commander that was with Wolfe when he got his scar amongst the 104th.
Tarkin of course we know was a fleet captain & GAR admiral.
Captain Needa was the very ship captain that attacked the invisible hand while Anakin & Obiwan was saving the chancellor apprantly.
Yularen of course became head of the ISB.
Panaka while not an offical GAR officer, became the moff & governor for Naboo which is ironic.
Thrawn worked with the GAR & Anakin a few times in canon.
Admiral Screed was supposedly a GAR commander.
Gallius Rax was temporarily with the GAR in the beginning of the war.
The point being many of the Impeerial officers in the Empire were part of the GAR one way or another & encounter or knew of the Sith, the Jedi & very few, the whole plot of Order 66, so it makes one wonder many of their standpoints when they fought against the Jedi later down the line as the Empire & became the threat the Separatist were practically were at the time & was totally cool with it.
plenty
@@pope2552 I know, & I know it’s a small detail but i would kinda like to see things from their perspective for a change. We’ve seen stormtroopers & clones between bad batch & of course clone wars, agent kallus was a good story but is reused with iden sadly. Hux isn’t much.
never knew the republi- *ahem* the empire used 18th century tactics
* Boston massacre flashbacks *
@@bistalkerbistalker1759the Brits were in the right tho
Everyone in star wars uses 18th to 19th century tactics. Every space combat is literally a broadside Napoleonic action with WW2 style carrier based craft mixed in.
@@sunnex474ain’t no fucking way. Bro is slobbering on the old ass imperial boot
@@ianlambert1316 what? No, it was literally the colonists who began harassing the soldiers first
I love how scary and intimidating the clones were here. This is how the galaxy saw clones before they were discarded.
him: throws rock
clones: throws plasma bolt
This scene always confused me. Are the citizens saying "Long live the Republic?" It's sounds like the voice of the Officer, but it can't be, because this is the Empire timeline, and the Republic doesn't occupy homeworlds.
But then in an earlier scene, Andor's mom calls the separatists aboard that downed shuttle "Republic", which makes it sound like they are separatists.
I like Andor, but sometimes the lore gets confusing.
Blame poor writing
@@Chris_ThorndykeIt wasn't even poor writing. The entire scene was during the Republic Era. However, it's showing a different side of it. Since unless you were with Jedi you often were seen as nothing but a disposable soldier and a number. Which means individualism and personally were almost none existent.
Andor and his folks *were separatists.* He told Jyn that he was in this fight since childhood (fight against the republic/empire).
The folks were protesting the rise of the new Empire i believe. The Republic being unceremoniously replaced by the Empire must have been a jarring thing
So in this scene clones didn't free people from separatist occupation, they brought the occupation.
Who threw a rock at me????? That is treason!"
RedSun's voice acting is a pathway to many abilities, some consider to be unnatural
Ok
i thought it was AI
it's AI lol.
I believe he's using eleven labs.
No, Its not Ai
@@RedSun446then use Temura Morrison
Suddenly everyone is pro-cgi
This must be early in the Empire
it is.
Clone trooper 1: hell yea feel my vengeance you ungrateful heathens 0:42
Wait no one else like the comment it’s the perfect number for Star Wars reference f
This brings back the memories on coruscant stopping those protest with thire and thorn
It’s good to see the elite of my forces getting proper recognition for their… services.
“Why are some of the clones shorter that can’t be canon!?!”
Explanation: Their Bodie Taylor Clone Troopers
I know you're joking but my INTP ass still want to explain so sorry in advance.
In real life indetical twins are not evenly tall too, so this is possible in my opinion, but good notice tho.
@TuTuVanOers2 they aint twins theyre clones
@@TuTuVanOers2 Bodie Taylor is one of the clone trooper actors from Attack of the Clones & Revenge of the Sith. He is what the Clones look like between the age gap between Boba aka Daniel Logan & Commander Cody aka Morrison. He is notably in the scene wearing the red uniform in the cafeteria eating when Obi-wan was first shown the army.
The cloning isn’t perfect. By the end of the clone wars Jango’s DNA is so degraded that most clones produced by it have defects
@@TuTuVanOers2twins doesn’t have same DNA either smarty
First non cgi live action appearance
They were portrayed by real actors in Obi-Wan Kenobi
Their about-face turn was atrocious.
Your mom was atrocious last night with me
@@Diogo_Castaneda How original
@@knightartorias3201 Not original, but succinct.
Their about-face tells you which ones were paying attention during drill.
lol,. yeah. two on the right looked pretty good, 2 on the left need some more practice it seems
The attention to detail in this scene is amazing when a realistic perspective is considered. First of all, it's a flashback of a person's pretty traumatic memory of a civilian population's massacre by a military force, and no they didnt show it happen in the typical way like how the Mandalorian did with the camera in slow-mo, blasters blazing, people screaming, etc. What we instead have in Andor is a methodical build up to how such tragedies could have and would have happened in real life. Plenty of atrocities committed on civillians were due to soldiers reacting too impusively, be it a protesting mob or a large group of people straight up harrassing them. A historical case very similar, and most likely an inspiration to the scene depicted in Andor was the Boston massacre, where a mob of colonial Americans were fired on by British troops after they were harrassed by said colonial Americans...
How did andor get the clones to look so much better than in ahsoka, ahsoka's clone troopers look like they have oversized, cheap plasti cosplay armor, whereas here those clones look so good, like theyre straight out of RoTS
Phase 1 live action had a different design closer to tcw since it fitted better on real humans. They probably just made a small amount of kit for the quick scene.
As for the difference in quality of Kenobi, andor & ahsoka would come down to who's making it and if it was in house or lucky fans
Funny considering the questionable height difference in Andor, which is something the other shows did correct better.
@@SWDude2710 in universe Papa Palpatine 1yr clones on one of coruscant moons wasn't perfect specially with jango's usable dna decreasing.
@Captain_Yorkie1 isn't that Information Legends material?
What we need is an animated tv show JUST about the clone troopers stories
It exists. Its called clone wars, altho i rly hate the fact they once AGAIN DIDNT MAKE THE EPISODES IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER, and now i AS AN IDIOT have to watch videos about the guide to watch them.
@@seynpurrp dude…the majority of the clone wars really doesn’t focus on clones, it’s really season 4 that we start really seeing their personalitied
I mean, The Bad Batch exists. But I agree it would be cool to get a Tales of the Clones or something like that.
I never realized the storm troopers in andor were clones still
Only in this particular scene
before the clones tried to revolt and then the empire switch to stormtroopers I think
@@spartandk7660 That's only in legends during the Kamino rebellion and they decide to forgo using clones anymore (But still kept the ones serving and gave them good retirements). In the Dinsey version they just sort of get rid of clone troopers for no reason and blow up Kamino.
@@Gdsryrox well not.. you total didnt whacht the BAD BACHT,, 2 season explain better what happened to clones..
I always saw the Clones as the bad guys waiting to happen. And I think Andor did too.
"told you this would blow over" 😂
"Just freed them", This is like 15+ years later, lol. The Clone troopers are grandfathers due to the accelerated aging.
Nope. The flashback is immediately after the end of the Clone Wars, hence why there are still clone troopers in service (obviously) and a protestor yells "Long live the Republic", because the Republic had just fallen/reorganized.
Tear down: Big mistake pal, prepare to eat some heat!
I didn't even remember seeing clones...? 🤨🤔🤯
Episode 7
Tear down: I’ll fuck it do it again
Was a Jedi in the crowd
“What? That was a warcrime?…Can I do it again?”
live action clones with clones wars clones' voices
Temuera Morrison slander
I'm having the most hella intense Mandela effect during this because I don't remember clones showing up AT ALL in Andor.
its a flashback from when Clem ( Cassian adoptive father) is killed. It take place a year after order 66
Here what people are looking for
0:18
I believe that these are not clones, but conscripted soldiers in clone armor, considering that there was a brief time after the empire first came to power where normal humans wore clone armor while stormtrooper armor was being developed.
just watch bad batch
The Bad Batch explains how human conscripts were fitted with different armor
yep, some are shorter than the others. 100% not clones
@511kinderheim. They are clones, just that they are the actors are not the same height.
It was covered in the clone wars (briefly) that due to the demands of the war, more and more clones were sent into battle before their training was complete. My guess is, that the shorter individuals in clone armour are just younger clones that hadn't reached full maturity before being deployed.
Rex: So that explains why they’re down there instead of up here so disappointing they just shot civilians with no hesitation
Replacing the clones was thee stupidest decision sidious
Made...
Those boys were loyal and badass bastards ❤❤❤
Are you sure about that? *points to some clone rebellions*
They were inferior to stormtroopers
@Delusionaryvisionary_407 the were vastly superior.
For 1 thing they had 10 years training not to mention the genetic engineering for war
They were costly and aged quite fast. Emperor wanted to put his resources on other projects like the death star.
@jyotirani8187 death star was stupid idea.
Emperor was minted, he could afford the clones.
I’m still pissed that they made these amazing clone costumes and they don’t do anything with them.
Weird how they didn't use them for Ashoka
@@orbaitv5991they might have during the siege of mandalore flashback? Ashoka was young af in the earlier one and that’ll be why they made phase 1 armour instead of using these.
We have so far seen them here, a few in Ahsoka, & in the Mandalorian season 3, however in Kenobi they only used 501st variants.
@@ColDylanG They didn’t use the same clone costumes in anything else.
My wife left me
😢
At least you have andor season 2 to look forward to.
You may have lost your queen but don’t lose yourself king
Star Wars would never abandon you like that
You're free from chains now
The Owner: Yeah, he deserves punishment, but dont be excessive we dont want trouble at work.
The Manager that hates you: 0:37
How the boston massacre of 1775 probably happened
The Ferrix Massacre, far far away
6'0 for a clones height. Why are there "CLONE-LETS" IN THE RANKS 😭😭
im guessing they just got multiple people adult height to be in clone trooper armor
it doesnt bother me
@@CT_Taylor but just seeing them from behind just looks so off to me. I mean I wouldn't have noticed if they were used for the shot at the leg sequence marching, but it looks so awkward
I get it. They could have even CGIed the difference to match@@darksideorseid0066
Ah, some must've been taken out of their growth-jars too soon. Figures, given the rush for fresh troops later in the war.
"As you know, there is no one way to make a clone..."
The end about 79’s was great xD
what a fresh air of sw under disney, man...
Not a war crime if nobody is left to report it.
and- not a warcrime if you won the war
It's not a war crime if there's no laws against it in the first place.
I know it offtopic, but... pay attention to legwork then "Turn" command being issued
POV: your a kid who threw a rock at military personnel as your father panics to try not to end there whole blood line 💀💀💀🥲
I’m guessing these clones were still under order 66
666, the devil
"tHiS iS bAd ThEy DoN‘t EvEn ArE tHe SaMe SiZe“
It is bad. And so is your writing 😂
@@odinthevikinggod8726go back watch your shitty ass boba, obi and mando, oh and ahsona 😂
@@Belle75468He literally criticizes something thats objectively wrong what are you on about
Maybe he’s the Bodie Taylor Clone?
@@odinthevikinggod8726maybe. But you can’t really criticize the show on that passes or you can but no one will take you seriously if you do
Why we stop, the emperor just said watch the people
Teardown: Wait... HOW DID I MISS EVERY SHOT?!
Answer:
Welcome to the Empire🥳
Arnt some of these clone trooper short to be a soldier
As long as your trigger finger ain’t short you’re fine.
Yes they are, but consistency has never been a thing in disney canon.
Clones are literally bred for combat at accelerated speed in numerous batches, and shown on screen to be different ages, hair colors, facial structures, etc… height is nothing
unfortunately its harder to clone people irl, and since most clones are often 501st volunteers that also didn't help
@@jackrutledgegoembel5896 What are you yapping about? They all look like Jango fett, some just decided to dye their hair, shave it, grow facial, etc. Only exceptions like 99 or the bad batch have differences, but the average clones have the same height. Stop making up excuses for poor casting.
For the rebuild clone trooper brother
Just like the simulations
They just ordered 66 some planet
Sorry to sound like a nerd but in this case they just ordered 37 on this planet
I'm assuming by the lack of screams that they didn't actually hit anyone. Of course.
Wouldn't it be the opposite? If they didn't hit people then they would still be alive to scream.
They are clone troopers not storm troopers
people get shot in killed in the movies yet don't scream, do they?
Actually I’m sick of everyone thinking troopers have bad aim. Both stormtroopers and clone troopers were excellent marksman’s. It was thier rifles. Have you ever tried shooting an e-11 while wearing a bucket that big? With thier HUDS and everything it was a lot harder than it looked. Yall just small minded.😂😂😂😂
@@ttvRED-WRATHmost of it was plot armor. Aside from shooting at the main characters, stormtroopers were great shots. Literally the first fight we ever see them (A New Hope) they body a rebel unit despite being held at a choke point in a ship. They only lose two soldiers and literally decimate the entire defense force that had a strategic advantage
Now THAT was satisfying. Their commanding Officer had their backs. Nobody throws a rock at his men and gets to get away with it.
Also, I'm assuming "79's" is a reference to A New Hope's initial; release year?
It was made in 1977 so no.
@@CloneTrooperCT-5076 Oh, oops. My bad. For some reason I thought it was 79.
Mistakes happen.
@@CloneTrooperCT-5076Well, thanks for correcting me on it.
79’s is just a famous bar that caters to clone troopers on Coruscant during the war
Are the clones going to have a holiday break soon?
well well well whacht the 2 seasons of the bad bacth to see than ITS EVEN WORST..
Bro, I was just watching that episode of Andor with my Dad ‼
Please stop. They couldn’t find a lot of same height actors. THESE ARE CLONES.
Still kind of poor on their part, but tbh this scene is pretty good regardless.
@@SWDude2710 yeah granted they can use cgi to fix it
@@vanillachungus9546 you make a good point there.
@@vanillachungus9546it’d be expensive to do that and lets be honest here, nobody hates Star Wars more than Star Wars fans, if they CGI’d it fans would’ve gotten mad and called it bad CGI 😂
@@3adgamd3r no lie there lol
帝国もクローンにこんな事やらせてるからクローンの離反者を出しちゃったんだろうな。バッドバッチのコーディみたいに。
What the!!! Someone who threw and hit with clone troopers?
Everytime I read "RedSun" it only reminds me of Sundowner's boss fight
Why are people complaining about the height they literally all look the same height. SW fans will find anything to complain about
Tbf some of them are a bit taller than others. I mean cmon, one of then in the middle is like 6 inches shorter than the guy on his left
Love those troopers lol
[Julio and Marcy observing the street as Stormtroopers blast civilians]
Julio: "Are they really shooting the civvies for that?"
Marcy: "The troopers are uncivilized. They don't realize that any use of force only creates resentment; makes them look like cowards, even."
Julio: "Should we report Commander Caulfield for this incident?"
Marcy: "No. We will commence covert operations at night. Plant some anti-Empire propaganda to 'scare' the loyalists into a frenzy."
Julio: "So cast them with doubt and keep our hands clean?"
Marcy: "That's the plan."
Julio: "Hmm... that might just work."
0:06 LONG LIVE THE REPUBLIC! FREE FERRIX!
HALT!
READY ARMS!
@@vaclavottobireley8337 FIRE!
Long live the Confederacy of Independent Systems!!!
honestly im just sayin
roger roger
It sounds like the clones had a blast.
Good soldiers follow orders.
Man I feel really bad about Cassian's father.
They were so robotic In this flashback
...That's how soldiers behave in such formations in real life.
@@LukiKruki you have a point there but as compared before in universe
@@epicsshadesmaster-animatio4398Look at clones in Bad batch they lost their personality after order 66
Literally how they were before TCW
@@SkyscannerGuyJr. Before TCW they were babies or not "born"
Honestly, some of prequel scenes in Andor are confusing and like they were made last minute
Why is it confusing?
This was 1 year after the end of clone wars, when Cass was 13 they hanged his father clem and cassian was sent to prison (he tried to attack the clones with baton) for 3 years until he was 16, then empire sent him to Mimban, he was there until he deserted. Idk they just used diego luna face for this flashback.
@@aGiraffePretendingToBeaMan the one I found odd was the bit where cassian is a kid and finds the crashed “republic” ship, whose crew members all have an emblem very similar to the CIS one on their uniforms. I got the impression that was supposed to be a separatist ship but they changed it to a republic one too late for the uniforms to be changed. But then it could also maybe be some secret Palpatine shit, idk. It was a little confusing but the flashbacks definitely still achieved what they were supposed to, and these scenes with the clones on ferrix were very well executed imo.
@@Shot5hellsor the Separatists used an iconic but lesser know Republic symbol as their own.
This happened before the clone wars started and before the CIS seceded from the republic, your average person let alone scavenger like Maarva and Clem would just assume they were republic officers bc they weren't the CIS yet that we see in Episode 2.@@Shot5hells
never seen a march that clean in Star Wars. the about-face could've been better tho
Threw a rock? Must be a terrorist.
Israel be like
Those are the initial stages of terrorism, the Empire knows that all too well.
And they said the Separatists were the bad guys
It's better to be with the separatists than to be with Empire, I would like to be with those goofy B1 Droids
Uh. Because they are? Like the republic are definitely not the definitive good guys, but to try and say the CIS wasn't evil is ridiculous
@@JuggernautHunter02 Take the sith/corporate influence from the Republic and you still have a corrupt and ineffecient government supported by a stagnant Jedi order
Take sith/corporate influence from the Confederacy and you have a collection of planets and races who want the freedom to rule themselves and prosper without the heavy taxes and zero help the central government has brought
@@FierySpirit7 the bulk of it courtesy of the people of Geonosis, as opposed to the Trade Federation who also has control over the Republic (they even have representation in the Senate after de invasion of Naboo)
@@FierySpirit7 the few Separatists conquering worlds were aliens in Palpatine's plans to create xenophobia in as many worlds as possible, many of which are of neutral corporations like Wat Tambor
At this point, I don’t know what to say about them being different Heights(my comment used to be something else)
Blasphemy.
nah
source: me
your assuming star wars fans have the mental capacity to make cognitive correlations like that?
@AIRWAY26 "Cognitive correlations" meaning telling yourself things contradicted by canon and legends? A second grader experimenting with 3 syllable words, good luck kid - you've got a long way to go.
@@kevinzhang6623 what do you mean by blasphemy?
Siiigh and the empire keeps failing even basics of crowd control
1, you do not deploy soldiers against internal threats ever
2, if YOU are the reason for the aggression and no one else is in danger de escalate and just leave the area.
3, come back later with a clear mission objective and or just fine them in their absence.
yeah, but that is not the point here, the point of this dumb ass scene is to give Andor some motivation to fight the empire.
So what? Empire is willing to glass the whole planet at any given time. Throw a rock? Get shot. Empire de-escalates through extreme escalation.
Did no occupier ever.
Wow you're right, it's so unrealistic that the bad guys that make bad decisions lose at the end of the series :O
@@GoklasM empire doesn't glass planets, this isn't halo. Plus this represents the fundamental misunderstanding of the political situation. The empire was a continuation of the republic in all but the name. Just like Roman empire was a continuation of the Roman republic. Unless this is about the ideals the republic is supposed to represent, which would be strange, considering the republic was void of these ideals for the past century and not even people on coruscant knew what republic was supposed to be about.
So this is an obvious set up to get sndor going a set up that twist the wider narrative. Which makes it bad writing.
Is that real clone armor?
Yes, it isn't CGI
Yeah does anyone one feel like something bad will happen?
Teardown didn't deserve to get hit by a rock...
How come they say? This is what you get when you mess with the empire meanwhile, a minute ago The guy said long live the rep.
Protestors were the ones yelling "long live the republic."
Bruh people are getting mad at the moments like it's Twitter just dislike and move on
Why does the end sound so up of context?
I’m just wounding what will happen when they are shown half life 1 music?
Can you try morrison’s voice.
What movie is this?
Fortnite
From the series andor
st ar awrs
Paddington 2
Dune Part Two
You watch your language!
But you can’t see sound waves🤣😂
0:34. These clone actors really sucked. They don't even stand the same. And are not the same height. They should have at least rehearsed there movements to be identical.
Would you rather they be cgi? Those turns require weeks worth of practice and discipline and identical movements or exact heights isn't practical. You'd have to find a squad of men with similar heights and builds with basic training experience and with exact movements that's intense sentinel guard training. Having fans that love star wars is better if you just subvert your disbelief in world of aliens and magic guys with laser swords
@@thedragon1363 CGI isn't the answer to everything. Look at Marvel right now. And rehearsing moves turns do take weeks, but you also have to understand the source material. They are playing CLONE troopers, Clones is the main word. There moves and height are meant to be identical. When these actors signed for it, they should deliver it well.
@@thedragon1363 how fast the bootlickers emerge for the multi-billion dollar company is truly astonishing
@@thedragon1363Because Disney couldn't possibly afford to do that, right?
@@SILENTBULL_9er Look at it from a budget standpoint, if you want smaller shows and stories they're gonna have less budgets. Doesn't mean they can't be enjoyed with a lil suspension of disbelief
Absolutely based.
9 days ago 😮
Remake it...but with the beatles voices
Shut up Ringo!
Названия?
Андор
@@kyrylomartyniuk2655 а какая серия?
those are NOT clone troopers 😭 some are shorter than the others, def normal people in clone armor since they were conscripting
Womp womp 🥸
You just can't conceive that Clones would be capable of being "evil".
They are Clones.
yeah, they actually didn't raise a clone army for the series and these are just some random normal humans; it sucks
@@richardched6085meaning they are all the same exact height. These are not clones.
@@Lilrob06 TK Troopers don't wear Clone Armor. It would be illogical to assume these aren't Clones because of a height difference that extends to the Kenobi, Book of Boba Fett, and Ahsoka series when they show live action Clone Troopers.
The sergant giving commands sounds an american sergant giving commands lol
If only Filoni did not retcon the 501st Vader's Fist Clone-Stormtroopers with his Bad Batch charades.
Who knows, Vader may have retained most of the clones for his legion
@@oldwolffe3636 unlikely, in Legends, the uprising happened 5 years after ROTS, meaning the youngest clones are 14 years old (28 physically) by the time of ANH. It is also explicitly mentioned that some of them started from Geonosis all the way to Hoth. While Filoni's Canon seems to make every clone trooper go into retirement for some reason 1 year after ROTS.
God the Vader’s Fist is just great
I still think those are the clone troopers that are legitimate
Never liked the chips thing
Never liked Rex
And heck, I once heard long ago that the hat guy didn’t even like Commandos, but someone on the animation team loved them so much so Delta was only a cameo in the 2008 CW, and a complete joke in Bad Batch
Yeah, what ended up happening to the clones in canon is honestly some of the dumbest shit ever. And I really appreciate that Legends had the balls to make some of the Stormtroopers clones.
To be fair to Filoni, that decision was made by Lucasfilms well before even Rebels was launched. His stuff merely is enforcing and elaborating upon the company policy. Does that make it right? Not really, but it does demonstrate he is just a tool to corporate shitbags.
I don’t get it
Так там уже начали заменять клонов на людей простых, а форма осталась
В новом каноне простые люди ТК броню носят, а не фазу 2
@@WindRunner04 это новый, для меня Лукас легенда, а не вот этот микимаус
Как название фильма
@@ИльяКриворучка-н9ф 101 долматинец 🤣
where tk troopers.
I think this is a flashback
The clones where fased out, not directly disbanded. Altough it would have been cool to see them, this isnt inaccurate.
this based show doesn't care about new troopers for toy sales from baby dave's cartoons
live action tk troopers cool see😍
@@RobertDripplersonhe's not even involved in the show lol(but Andor is a based show nonetheless)
Worst looking clone troopers ever.
yea cuz actors dont know how to wear helmets
They're not the same height.
They’re too short to be troopers they need to be the exact height
Nope, they’re the best looking stormtroopers ever!
0:12