I’m Kyrgyz from Kyrgyzstan and wanna thank the authors for incredible work could imagine how you did this shots in this cold. However what I understand from it that they survive not live especially winter I know our government did some programs to relocate some families but as our economy and situation in Afghanistan make it much difficult. I could understand maybe half of their dialect it’s sound mix of Turkic and Persian languages but some speak pure north dialect of Kyrgyzstan so I can understand 100% only one thing I wanna mention form people who criticise them that change your perspective don’t expect human rights as other world even some civilised countries still live even in worth conditions. The way they choose live this the will of people who don’t want to live under oppression , reach for the freedom and they call themselves Kyrgyz make me proud. I wish they will at least stabilise their life being get international aid and if they decide to move to Kyrgyzstan hope our government will support them. P.S the traditional clothes stunning absolutely gorgeous red colour ohh that beautiful
There's nothing wrong with their way of life. Its how we humans were ought to live. Now we have lost our freedom and are prisoners of progress. Love their clothes. The gypsies and tribals of India also have clothes like this. Red beng
I just came back from a trip to Kyrgyzstan and came across their distant nomadic relatives in the land. It is incredible to imagine how the same people can have so different lives. The Kygyzstan nomads are able to roam freely in the lands and are not confined to such an extreme altitude.
Есть в мире Киргизы китайские Киргизы, Афганские Киргизы, Узбекистанские Киргизы, Таджикистанские Киргизы (памирские), Сибирские Киргизы, Киргизы в Турции и.т.д. У всех немножко отличается традиции, одежды национальные, говорят на тех государственных языках которые они живут и на кыргызском. Все они считают себя Кыргызами всегда.
They don't say "buying" women; but the English text says so. Also, the sister is getting married to a man from the bride's family; don't know why the speaker keeps saying she's being traded. They all need to get married. At one point the speaker says judgmentally that after her marriage, the sister is leaving to help her husvand's family. It will be her own family. What is she supposed to do? Stay home? They all get married and move on with life. Documentaries didn't used to be so judgmental in the past.
it's called "woke" culture and in the west it's infected education deeply. greetings from Canada. it's an attitude that the narrator has to remind us, the great unwashed, as to how much more informed they are than mere mortals.
They are scared that we might finally figure out that we are many, and they are few. So they make everything divisive, in order to divide the people and make us weak.
I'm from Kabul, Afghanistan. I'm proud of the diversity of our nation, but at the same time, I am ashamed and sad that our people still live in such a hard condition. I hope we build a big highway through the Wakhan Corridor to prepare a better life for our Kyrgyz compatriots. We should work to bring new opportunities including education, tourism, agriculture, and development to this region. Love all my countrymen. Be safe wherever you are.
Afghanistan never got a break between invasions having its resources stolen until today. Invaders brought nothing but misery like opium addiction and death. Let’s hope regional countries will get smarter and cooperate with each other for the better future
Certain Native Americans lived this way, too. Such as the Dene Navajo peoples . They were reliant on sheep herding and cattle. They immediately took on that lifestyle culture once the introduction of sheep to the southwest American continent.
This is one of the most fascinating documentarys I`ve ever seen. I often think about the people in it and come back ro rewatch it from time to time. It`s like a deep echo in my soul.
I'm from Hunza, Pakistan. Wakhan Corridor shares a border with Hunza. These poor people were not trapped because of China, Pakistan and Tajikistan , Rather they have been trapped since 1800 because of British Empire & Tsarist Russia. They Divided Badakshan between Afghanistan and Tsarist Russia in order to create a buffer zone between Russia and British Empire of India.People in South and central Asia are still suffering from colonial divisions even after 200 years. This Wakhan Corridor stuff is one of the many dark legacies of British Colonial policies. Must Read this article for some knowledge before making a documentary "The ‘Great Game’ in the Pamirs and the Hindu-Kush: The British Conquest of Hunza and Nagar", You guys make Unions like EU where you can travel and do business comfortably but for us you made buffer zones and barriors so that we remain poor and dependent
You are so right my friend. Old Western powers have been vicious, brutal, segregationist and much more. Democracy and prosperity are for them, not for others.
Before the arrival of Tsarist Russia on the territory of Central Asia, the Uzbeks had three states. Kokand Khanate Bukhara Khanate Khiva Khanate. Over the course of 12-15 years, tsarist Russia conquered these three Uzbek states, and then the authorities of tsarist Russia and the Bolsheviks drew the map in different ways several times, and in order to specifically weaken the titular people of Central Asia, the Uzbeks, out of the three former territories of the Uzbek state, they drew fiverepublics; commonwealth Uzbekistan Turkmenistan Kyrgyzstan Tajikistan Kazakhstan and the Uzbeks were deliberately left with a small territory, even without access to the Caspian Sea
@@ILYAS-7 Uzbeks were slavetraders and bandits. If they weren´t kidnapping Russians and selling them at slave markets, Russia wouldn´t touch them. Blame it on yourself and your ancestors
@@ILYAS-7 It is unbelievable that Uzbekistan has no coastal connection to Caspian Sea. Russians planned so that Uzbekistan is a very isolated country with a small land. Russians also destroyed Ottoman Empire, along with British and French.
You are obsuletely correct. I was born in the ex Soviet Union, half Kyrgyz and half Uyghur. My grandfather fled the Chinese goverment to Kyrgyzstan. Then the borders were closed and he could not go back to his wife and children.....
i am hazara, I have met many kazakhs and krygyz think I am kazakh or krygyz and I too have grandparents that live around the base of a high altitude mountains in the "countryside" , I would say when you're in Afghanistan, What's for dinner isn't expected like it is in modern countries, you will be thinking a lot "where is this next meal gonna come from". The summer is hot dry, you can count the number of rainy days in a year on your hand, the winter is harsh and snowy and you can look at vast plains with minimal homes in sight, your neighbors are few and far between with a very low population density, its easy to feel like its just your family there. I would also like to add that their persian language sounds identical to the hazara accent
@@kevindevaojoo8882 before texting something check the information instead. Those who want move to Kyrgyz Republic can return anytime, there's a special program where any ethnic kyrgyz out of Kyrgyz Republic can apply for passport it's called "Kairylym" / "Returnees". Today thousands of ethnic kyrgyz people became our citizen, and not only! There are special villages were built for them, with free houses. Also they have plenty of benefits, aids. Free education, free medicine, employment opportunities provided. If they don't want to leave the country they live in, we don't force them to come. Also Kyrgyz government periodically sends them humanitarian aid. Just some of them don't want move because they don't know what's expecting them here, since it's now secular country, with communist past, nowdays with the focus to national values .
@@kevindevaojoo8882maybe they don't want to go there... they live strictly nomadic life which wouldn't be possible in the Kyrgyz Republic. Also at the time they migrated there wasn't a clear state of Kyrgyz Republic with its borders as it is now, which were established relatively recently as the result of the Soviet past.
@@kevindevaojoo8882Кыргызстан хочет переселить их на родину но не может так как афганцы не выпускают их .. Не знаю почему..Мы обращались в ООН чтобы помогли их переселить в Кыргызстан но всё заглохло после прихода Талибов..
Спасибо создателям фильма , очень интересно снято про кыргызов в Афганистане , я из Кыргызстана ,но к сожалению не знаю английский язык,можно вы сделаете субтитры на русском языке ,мы хорошо знаем русский язык,И ещё если хотите можно бы в другом фильме снять об истории как эти кыргызы оказались в Афганистане и Турции после Октябрьской революции в России,снять фильм о кыргызых в Китае , Турции,и как живут в Кыргызстане, ещё что этим кыргызам в Афганистане наше правительство оказывает постоянно шум помощь и туда даже медики ездили , Некоторые желающие эти кыргызы переселились н
In 1982, 1150 Pamirid Kyrgyz asked for internation help and were relocated to southeast Turkey. Their entire community lives in a village called Ulupamir where only Kyrgyz live. I wish these Kyrgyz would also be able to come or go to Kyrgyzistan. There is no future for them in Afghanistan.
These Kyrgyz people should come and settle in Turkiye if they wish. Our culture, history and language are common. Instead of taking care of millions of bedouins coming from the Middle East who have disgusting culture and mindset from polygamy to child marriage, we should support our own Turkic kins such as Kyrgyzs, Uyghurs, Turkmens.
@@maimsahb I am not racist. I don't discriminate against people because of their race or the country they come from, but yea i do discriminate against ppl because of their disgusting culture, behavior and mentality. Because I have no tolerance for any ppl or culture that is backward, lives in the cave age and disturbs people, especially women and children in the country they came. This was not caused by a few things i saw in the media or heard from someone. This was caused by my personal experiences with more than 12 million refugees and illegal immigrants in my country. These people we have hosted in our country for years have brought us nothing but harm. And also, wanting to take care of my own Turkic kins who are in a difficult situation instead of people that i have no ancestry, history or language ties, no matter how ''good'' they are, is not racism too. Family comes first. I hope u get it. They speak both Kyrgyz and Persian btw. Kyrgyz is also a Turkic language like Turkish and the mutual intelligibility of both is high.
@@maimsahb The men were speaking either a dialect of Dari persian or the Wakhi language (probably for the camera) while the women appeared to be speaking Kyrgyz (it might just have been Wakhi though, with men switching between Wakhi and Dari)
Wow this one is sad. By now are they even still around? I know the documentary is old, the conditions there are so harsh. It's amazing to think a community can live so isolated in such an extreme place for a hundred years or more.
Though they have tough way of getting married this is also a way to keep the population down too, in India it is so bad that the lady pays the man to marry her imagine that? And that is why the population of India is gone out of control but in Afghanistan it is the old method , you must prove that you are a man before you can marry rather than the lady pays you like in India unfortuantley.
@@KurkasiroSiro so who pay the dawry? Indian population was 600 million 30 years ago, now? In thirty years it doubled that is not 2.1 percent population rise. In Pakistan is Muslim but they have the same culture in marriage, the lady gives the dawry and they also doubled population in 30 years, India and Pakistan stinks
@@KurkasiroSiro you have the highest population in the world. With such little land, it’s actually insane. Maybe the growth now isn’t high but think about how your country got there.
Sad live without prospects. I am not getting why Kyrgyzstan is not supporting them? Mongolia used to offer scholarships (the government, private or by a university itself) to Afgan's hazaras, especially girls, now this program has been stopped few years though. I remember often seeing strangely dressed girls who were mostly by themselves, I guess the free-spirited metropolitan lifestyle was not that easy for them to adjust to.
Kyrgyzstan helps them always, send humanitarian aids and government relocate some from there to Kyrgyzstan, some of them couldn’t adapt in Kyrgyzstan, and decided to go back to Pamir. Government offered free education, even housing as I remember.
These Wakhan Kyrgyz are nomads but lived on Little Pamir for at least 350 years. In 1894 they came under control of Afghanistan's Emir Abdurakhman by the decision of Great Powers, British Empire and Tsarist Russia to keep Wakhan Corridor as a buffer zone between India and Russia .Prior , from 1884 to 1892, Little Pamir was controlled by Qing China until all Qing China outposts in Alichur Pamir, Great Pamir and Little Pamir were driven away by summer military expedition of Russian General Ionov in 1892, that also attacked and pushed away Afghan troops that temporarily occupied Sumetash near Yashil Kul Lake in Alichur Pamir. Here Afghans in April 1892 defeated 200 Qing China troops who were sent from Urumchi by Xinjiang Province administration to build a fort. In 1895 Russia and British Empire signed agreement that formed present Wakhan Corridor as part of " buffer" Afghanistan, but Qing China refused to sign it, claiming loss of 20,000 sq km of Pamir Lands and retaining only Taghdumbash Pamir of Sarikol within Xinjiang Province. China-Afghan border was first defined and demarcated only in 1965, but border continued to be closed. During 1979-1989 Soviet occupation of Afghanistan Wakhan Corridor was controlled only by Soviet troops, Afghan troops were not allowed to get in. When on December 27 1979 Soviet troops entered Little Pamir they found here 500 Kyrgyz soldiers of local Rahmankul Khan, in Chinese uniform and armed with Chinese weapon, who fled to Pakistan without engagement with Soviet troops. From 1989-2001 Wakhan Corridor was free from turmoil of civil war in Afghanistan. The same from 2001 to 2021. When Taliban came to Wakhan Corridor in summer 2021 , Afghan Government aviation heavily bombed region and at least 50 Kyrgyz were killed, 500 fled to Tajikistan but were detained and then turned back by Tajikistan authoriries. At present time, about 1,200 Kyrgyz remained in Little Pamir and in 2024 about 500 of them for the first time received Afghan passports.
I want to know what Slice or any of the film crew does to help these people, or if they impose on the already strained resources of these poor folk trying to scratch out an existence? Please bring them food and medicine, don't just exploit them for these videos
Hospitality is part of the Afghan ethos. If someone asks for food and shelter, they give it, even if this person has harmed them. I served in the Peace Corps in the late 60's. I saw young, rich Americans travelling thru Afghanistan, sponging on the hospitality of impoverished villagers. They had money in their pockets for souvenirs and luxuries. Shameless.
@@patemmert2672 I understand that, but part of hospitality is not refusing a gift from your guest, and the guests should be giving provisions to these people. Especially because who knows what germs they're exposing the people to? Many of them could wind up dying from COVID or anything else the film crew gives them when their immune systems have never experienced it. I just hate seeing exploitation. I have been one of those children who grew up starving and not knowing if I would live or die the next day
Pretty awesome documentary, amazing tough people, amazing scenery, but damn that is sad. Al this drug addiction and basically surviving only. Hope things get better for them ❤️
They can't live like this....They must migrat to Kyrgyzstan 🇰🇬 or Kazakhstan 🇰🇿.... The Afghanistan 🇦🇫gevrment ( Taliban ) must give the permtion to leave....... I'm Ethiopian🇪🇹
Afghanistan is not a good country it doesn't help it's inhabitants I pity these people they are living in harsh poor conditions with no money and basic facilities.
@@daniellalyngdoh6211Afghanistan has been defending against British, Soviet, US, and NATO invasion. What help do you think it could provide to these ppl who actually were safe from all the wars and violence?
Why should they migrate they aren’t the only Turkic minority. As an Uzbek w e are also Turkic then migrate within Afghanistan but why should they leave their homelNd?.
You can't be serious. The women are *literal slaves.* They don't even try to hide that fact, yet you have "respect and admiration" for them? Disgusting
I am a kyrgyz from kyrgyzstan living now in US state of pensylvania and traveling right now through the state of UTAH,Salt Lake city march 2024.Why don't they come to their homecountry kyrgyzstan?There are a lot places to live .I just don't understand why they don't wanna come over there.
this documentary is NOT objective these people can choose staying there or they can go to their Motherland kyrgystan or even Further to Turkey where they will welcoming them with open arms they have choices that other people don't have
Hi havepleasuretime , in 7:45' it's wrong translated of man's explanation about the number of his family (children) in correct he says: I have five children two daughters and three sons, or three of them are male
An excellent documentary! Do these Kyrgyz nomads speak Tajik, or they simply took the word for 'daughter' from Tajik (an Indo-European language, hence the similarity with the English word), as we can hear "'duhtar"? Kyrgyz is a Turkic language, and it would be strange not to use their own terms for kinship.
The women appeared to be speaking Kyrgyz to me (I couldn't understand) but the men were speaking Local dialect of Dari or Wakhi language, probably for the benefit of their guests. Either that or the women were speaking Wakhi as well while the men were speaking Wakhi with each other and Dari with the interviewers. Dari and especially Wakhi are related to Urban Tajiki Farsi.
The men were speaking both Persian and Kyrgyz, the women were speaking just Kyrgyz. I’m Kyrgyz from Kyrgyzstan, it’s amazing they still speak pure Kyrgyz language
@@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য Really ? Actually,Nobody in the World can be more primitive then radicalists like talibans.For example you can look to the Poor Farkhunda Murdery Case !
primitive? the way the rest of the world lives is primitive these poeple know how to survive they have skills ur people couldnt replicate in a million years @@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য
@@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্যbecause they are in absolute isolation. Kyrgyzstan should try to reach them and get them connected to the world . Otherwise they’ll stay addicted to either vodka or opium
@@அவானிஉயர்ந்தது They think they are superior than Kyrgyzstan because during Soviet invasion Afghan Kyrgyz Mujahideen killed many Soviet Kyrgyz soldiers.
whats this in the beginning, i never saw someone fishing with throwing stones!!! i saw all kind of fishing, survival techniques etc, why the hell wouldnt you report more on that? the movie just kept on as if it wasnt ultimately rare. damn this reporter
Bro we tried to do it, but as Kyrgyzstan not rich country it’s difficult for the moment in 2016 there were programs by government to relocate them but this is going with difficulties and now Afghanistan new power in head seems would be more problematic to support them in future
این ها مردومی فارسی زبان نیست. ای ها مردومی قیرگیز است وه مردای شی فارسی گب میزنه از خاتیری که ده افقانستان زندگی میکونه فقد زن هایشی قیرگیزی گب میزنه.
Conditions... Until 1 or 2 centuries ago, ur thoughts and choices as a woman were nothing in the West. Women in many western countries gained the right to vote in the ''last century''.
I was blessed to be born Māori in New Zealand and as a woman in Māori culture my female ancestors were equal to the men. Western culture brought the concept of woman being secondary...
@@bernadinemarr8432 If western culture brought the concept of women being secondary, then why do u feel blessed to be a woman in a western country? The Kyrgyz people mentioned in the video are a Turkic people. In Turkic culture and Tengrism the religion of our ancestors, women and men were equal. Our history is full of female heroes, warriors, soldiers, commanders and rulers. Hundreds of years ago, in a world where women weren't even considered human beings, Turkic women could be doctors, judges and shamans. However, some conditions and the influence of other religions or cultures can ruin this.
The plain and simple reason for the high mortality rates during births is due to their poor diet of wheat bread and tea. If they would eat more of the sheep instead of trading them for wives then their women would survive in higher numbers.
no, you find the same amount of death everywhere around the world , it's just how humanity is , childbirth for women is the most dangerous in the whole animal kigdom. That's why you should be thankfull for what you have, epidurals, doctors tending to you, Er's, germ theory etc... childbearing is brutal and is the reason why women have accepted male domination everywhere on earth.
They speak Farsi(dari) persian which I understand and the reason that life get harder for them is they get converted by force to a faith did not do them good! With my deep respect 👍🙏
WTF are you talking about they have been muslims centuries even before migrating to this place. Women seemed to be speaking Kyrgyz, men were speaking Dari or Wakhi (probably switching between the two) for the benefit of their visitors
Я сам понял половину это смешанный диалект южных и северных племен некоторые говорят на чистом северном диалекте который я понимал без проблем а в основном уже смешка языка с персидскими языками микс с тюркскими тяжело нужно изучать
life of this people become more bad whean Afghanistan and chaina make highway betwean Afghanistan and chaina because they are better away from tgis world life of them heard but beautiful life in nowadays technology more bad than any other time
Mate you see in the documentary he condemned their addiction I am not protecting them but as any society can destroy their lives and future, they need to be brave to totally change their perspective but without responsibility it’s impossible and they feel that their life not going to change till they decide it
It’s possible and government do have programs for them but situation in Afghanistan and weak economy of Kyrgyzstan do not allowed it in near future only hope that they will stabilised their living by receiving medical care and education institutions
Правительство переселили таких людей в Кыргызстан дали им скот построили дома ,но многие не захотели переселятся ,хотя здесь их дети ходят в школы и все условия
Кыргызстан хочет переселить их на родину но не может так как афганцы не выпускают их .. Не знаю почему..Мы обращались в ООН чтобы помогли их переселить в Кыргызстан но всё заглохло после прихода Талибов..
It’s very informative to know about what’s going in different parts of the world through your channel but it doesn’t mean you don’t keep privacy of that poor woman. It would be better if the feeding section was blurred.
Why should we blurr it? It is natural and human nature. also she did it in front of the camera man, so she didn't mind it and perhaps they don't see tits as sexual objects, only assets to feed babies. 🤷🏻♀️
@@jonam7589 so that is why the comment I replied to said "It would be better if the FEEDING section was blurred"? Even if it was meant, through some linguistic code, to refer to the smoking, we do not know what she smoked, how much she smoked, how often she has smoked it (or that she ever did it off camera, before or after), how her family or community would react, or that she didn't give informed consent to being in the documentary. Any assumptions we make are based on our lives and cultural contexts, not hers, so I choose to assume that she is a competent adult able to make decisions for herself.
Even though life is not going well for them this is the pure example of heritage of Kyrgyz ethnic genome 🧬 couldn’t live under oppression nor party nor khan
There is no central government unless you count the Taliban Government and most of their Villages are the same which is why rural Pashtuns support them because the Western Puppet central government only enriches itself. Taliban with all their vices are still trying to change the country but Western Nations have sanctioned Afghanistan and USA has frozen their assets and confiscated half of them. They are more worried about education of some elite girls which is low on the list of priorities for Taliban government right now, than saving Millions dying from Hunger right now, which is their top priority and priority of any logical Human being in their place.
@@phoenixrising8640 the dumpster fire of morons that has to keep their engineers hostage because no one wants to live in that hell hole? Sure, If it's so great can you please tell the hundreds of thousands of Afghans that keep crawling to western countries that the Taliban is a great government, and they should go back that would be great. Now that the big mean Americans are gone, they can go live with the Taliban.
I’m Kyrgyz from Kyrgyzstan and wanna thank the authors for incredible work could imagine how you did this shots in this cold. However what I understand from it that they survive not live especially winter I know our government did some programs to relocate some families but as our economy and situation in Afghanistan make it much difficult. I could understand maybe half of their dialect it’s sound mix of Turkic and Persian languages but some speak pure north dialect of Kyrgyzstan so I can understand 100% only one thing I wanna mention form people who criticise them that change your perspective don’t expect human rights as other world even some civilised countries still live even in worth conditions. The way they choose live this the will of people who don’t want to live under oppression , reach for the freedom and they call themselves Kyrgyz make me proud.
I wish they will at least stabilise their life being get international aid and if they decide to move to Kyrgyzstan hope our government will support them.
P.S the traditional clothes stunning absolutely gorgeous red colour ohh that beautiful
There's nothing wrong with their way of life. Its how we humans were ought to live. Now we have lost our freedom and are prisoners of progress. Love their clothes. The gypsies and tribals of India also have clothes like this. Red beng
Red being very dominant colour as it stands out against nature and easy to spot.
I just came back from a trip to Kyrgyzstan and came across their distant nomadic relatives in the land. It is incredible to imagine how the same people can have so different lives. The Kygyzstan nomads are able to roam freely in the lands and are not confined to such an extreme altitude.
turks are a hardly people indeed.
Есть в мире Киргизы китайские Киргизы, Афганские Киргизы, Узбекистанские Киргизы, Таджикистанские Киргизы (памирские), Сибирские Киргизы, Киргизы в Турции и.т.д. У всех немножко отличается традиции, одежды национальные, говорят на тех государственных языках которые они живут и на кыргызском. Все они считают себя Кыргызами всегда.
They don't say "buying" women; but the English text says so. Also, the sister is getting married to a man from the bride's family; don't know why the speaker keeps saying she's being traded. They all need to get married. At one point the speaker says judgmentally that after her marriage, the sister is leaving to help her husvand's family. It will be her own family. What is she supposed to do? Stay home? They all get married and move on with life. Documentaries didn't used to be so judgmental in the past.
it's called "woke" culture and in the west it's infected education deeply. greetings from Canada. it's an attitude that the narrator has to remind us, the great unwashed, as to how much more informed they are than mere mortals.
It should be called dowry
They are scared that we might finally figure out that we are many, and they are few. So they make everything divisive, in order to divide the people and make us weak.
@@zzyzzy5466 It's called Dower or Bride Price in the case of how these people do it, but yes the way the documentary presented it was very biased.
Best line in the entire video:
Hey Mr. Tax man, I have twenty yak turds for you, but keep me waiting.
I'm from Kabul, Afghanistan. I'm proud of the diversity of our nation, but at the same time, I am ashamed and sad that our people still live in such a hard condition. I hope we build a big highway through the Wakhan Corridor to prepare a better life for our Kyrgyz compatriots. We should work to bring new opportunities including education, tourism, agriculture, and development to this region. Love all my countrymen. Be safe wherever you are.
No thanks 🥵
Afghanistan never got a break between invasions having its resources stolen until today. Invaders brought nothing but misery like opium addiction and death. Let’s hope regional countries will get smarter and cooperate with each other for the better future
Certain Native Americans lived this way, too. Such as the Dene Navajo peoples . They were reliant on sheep herding and cattle. They immediately took on that lifestyle culture once the introduction of sheep to the southwest American continent.
@@larsfischer816 who are you I mean why your jealous?
It will never happen under Pakistani Taleban terrorist regime
This is one of the most fascinating documentarys I`ve ever seen. I often think about the people in it and come back ro rewatch it from time to time. It`s like a deep echo in my soul.
Greetings from Kyrgyzstan 🇰🇬
❤Kyrgyzstan ❤
🎉
Love Kyrgyz people from Turkey!
Huge round of applause for louis and taimani films for an amazing journey.
I'm from Hunza, Pakistan. Wakhan Corridor shares a border with Hunza. These poor people were not trapped because of China, Pakistan and Tajikistan , Rather they have been trapped since 1800 because of British Empire & Tsarist Russia. They Divided Badakshan between Afghanistan and Tsarist Russia in order to create a buffer zone between Russia and British Empire of India.People in South and central Asia are still suffering from colonial divisions even after 200 years. This Wakhan Corridor stuff is one of the many dark legacies of British Colonial policies. Must Read this article for some knowledge before making a documentary "The ‘Great Game’ in the Pamirs and the Hindu-Kush: The British Conquest of Hunza and Nagar", You guys make Unions like EU where you can travel and do business comfortably but for us you made buffer zones and barriors so that we remain poor and dependent
You are so right my friend. Old Western powers have been vicious, brutal, segregationist and much more. Democracy and prosperity are for them, not for others.
Before the arrival of Tsarist Russia on the territory of Central Asia, the Uzbeks had three states.
Kokand Khanate
Bukhara Khanate
Khiva Khanate.
Over the course of 12-15 years, tsarist Russia conquered these three Uzbek states, and then the authorities of tsarist Russia and the Bolsheviks drew the map in different ways several times, and in order to specifically weaken the titular people of Central Asia, the Uzbeks, out of the three former territories of the Uzbek state, they drew fiverepublics;
commonwealth
Uzbekistan
Turkmenistan
Kyrgyzstan
Tajikistan
Kazakhstan and the Uzbeks were deliberately left with a small territory, even without access to the Caspian Sea
@@ILYAS-7 Uzbeks were slavetraders and bandits. If they weren´t kidnapping Russians and selling them at slave markets, Russia wouldn´t touch them. Blame it on yourself and your ancestors
@@ILYAS-7 It is unbelievable that Uzbekistan has no coastal connection to Caspian Sea. Russians planned so that Uzbekistan is a very isolated country with a small land. Russians also destroyed Ottoman Empire, along with British and French.
You are obsuletely correct. I was born in the ex Soviet Union, half Kyrgyz and half Uyghur. My grandfather fled the Chinese goverment to Kyrgyzstan. Then the borders were closed and he could not go back to his wife and children.....
i am hazara, I have met many kazakhs and krygyz think I am kazakh or krygyz and I too have grandparents that live around the base of a high altitude mountains in the "countryside" , I would say when you're in Afghanistan, What's for dinner isn't expected like it is in modern countries, you will be thinking a lot "where is this next meal gonna come from". The summer is hot dry, you can count the number of rainy days in a year on your hand, the winter is harsh and snowy and you can look at vast plains with minimal homes in sight, your neighbors are few and far between with a very low population density, its easy to feel like its just your family there. I would also like to add that their persian language sounds identical to the hazara accent
Love from Kyrgyz Republic 🇰🇬❤️
Why don’t ur government bring them to Kirgiz????
Shame on you
@@kevindevaojoo8882 before texting something check the information instead. Those who want move to Kyrgyz Republic can return anytime, there's a special program where any ethnic kyrgyz out of Kyrgyz Republic can apply for passport it's called "Kairylym" / "Returnees". Today thousands of ethnic kyrgyz people became our citizen, and not only! There are special villages were built for them, with free houses. Also they have plenty of benefits, aids. Free education, free medicine, employment opportunities provided. If they don't want to leave the country they live in, we don't force them to come. Also Kyrgyz government periodically sends them humanitarian aid. Just some of them don't want move because they don't know what's expecting them here, since it's now secular country, with communist past, nowdays with the focus to national values .
@@kevindevaojoo8882maybe next time ask if they're allowed to go there. I also wish they could be saved, but don't be rude to a whole country.
@@kevindevaojoo8882maybe they don't want to go there... they live strictly nomadic life which wouldn't be possible in the Kyrgyz Republic. Also at the time they migrated there wasn't a clear state of Kyrgyz Republic with its borders as it is now, which were established relatively recently as the result of the Soviet past.
@@kevindevaojoo8882Кыргызстан хочет переселить их на родину но не может так как афганцы не выпускают их .. Не знаю почему..Мы обращались в ООН чтобы помогли их переселить в Кыргызстан но всё заглохло после прихода Талибов..
Спасибо создателям фильма , очень интересно снято про кыргызов в Афганистане , я из Кыргызстана ,но к сожалению не знаю английский язык,можно вы сделаете субтитры на русском языке ,мы хорошо знаем русский язык,И ещё если хотите можно бы в другом фильме снять об истории как эти кыргызы оказались в Афганистане и Турции после Октябрьской революции в России,снять фильм о кыргызых в Китае , Турции,и как живут в Кыргызстане, ещё что этим кыргызам в Афганистане наше правительство оказывает постоянно шум помощь и туда даже медики ездили , Некоторые желающие эти кыргызы переселились н
In 1982, 1150 Pamirid Kyrgyz asked for internation help and were relocated to southeast Turkey. Their entire community lives in a village called Ulupamir where only Kyrgyz live.
I wish these Kyrgyz would also be able to come or go to Kyrgyzistan. There is no future for them in Afghanistan.
These Kyrgyz people should come and settle in Turkiye if they wish. Our culture, history and language are common. Instead of taking care of millions of bedouins coming from the Middle East who have disgusting culture and mindset from polygamy to child marriage, we should support our own Turkic kins such as Kyrgyzs, Uyghurs, Turkmens.
@birdost5781
I thought they were speaking Persian, it did not sound like Turkish .
It's not good to be racist...
@@maimsahb I am not racist. I don't discriminate against people because of their race or the country they come from, but yea i do discriminate against ppl because of their disgusting culture, behavior and mentality. Because I have no tolerance for any ppl or culture that is backward, lives in the cave age and disturbs people, especially women and children in the country they came. This was not caused by a few things i saw in the media or heard from someone. This was caused by my personal experiences with more than 12 million refugees and illegal immigrants in my country. These people we have hosted in our country for years have brought us nothing but harm.
And also, wanting to take care of my own Turkic kins who are in a difficult situation instead of people that i have no ancestry, history or language ties, no matter how ''good'' they are, is not racism too. Family comes first. I hope u get it.
They speak both Kyrgyz and Persian btw. Kyrgyz is also a Turkic language like Turkish and the mutual intelligibility of both is high.
@@maimsahb The men were speaking either a dialect of Dari persian or the Wakhi language (probably for the camera) while the women appeared to be speaking Kyrgyz (it might just have been Wakhi though, with men switching between Wakhi and Dari)
@birdost5781 is speaking the truth; the middle east have disgusting culture and never seek help from arab countries, ever.@@maimsahb
I love the part how he can't imagine places with no shepherds,lol. And his uncle tells him, they watch their herds on the computer.
Wow this one is sad. By now are they even still around? I know the documentary is old, the conditions there are so harsh. It's amazing to think a community can live so isolated in such an extreme place for a hundred years or more.
Though they have tough way of getting married this is also a way to keep the population down too, in India it is so bad that the lady pays the man to marry her imagine that? And that is why the population of India is gone out of control but in Afghanistan it is the old method , you must prove that you are a man before you can marry rather than the lady pays you like in India unfortuantley.
@@DailymailnewzI live in India never heard about it😂 and population growth rate here's 2.1 less than world average what are u talking about?
@@KurkasiroSiro so who pay the dawry? Indian population was 600 million 30 years ago, now? In thirty years it doubled that is not 2.1 percent population rise. In Pakistan is Muslim but they have the same culture in marriage, the lady gives the dawry and they also doubled population in 30 years, India and Pakistan stinks
@@KurkasiroSiro you have the highest population in the world. With such little land, it’s actually insane. Maybe the growth now isn’t high but think about how your country got there.
@@Dailymailnewzyou should just say “dowry” then everyone will understand it😂
Sad live without prospects. I am not getting why Kyrgyzstan is not supporting them? Mongolia used to offer scholarships (the government, private or by a university itself) to Afgan's hazaras, especially girls, now this program has been stopped few years though. I remember often seeing strangely dressed girls who were mostly by themselves, I guess the free-spirited metropolitan lifestyle was not that easy for them to adjust to.
I know right. Mongolia should resume the scholarship to Hazaras
Kyrgyzstan helps them always, send humanitarian aids and government relocate some from there to Kyrgyzstan, some of them couldn’t adapt in Kyrgyzstan, and decided to go back to Pamir. Government offered free education, even housing as I remember.
These Wakhan Kyrgyz are nomads but lived on Little Pamir for at least 350 years. In 1894 they came under control of Afghanistan's Emir Abdurakhman by the decision of Great Powers, British Empire and Tsarist Russia to keep Wakhan Corridor as a buffer zone between India and Russia .Prior , from 1884 to 1892, Little Pamir was controlled by Qing China until all Qing China outposts in Alichur Pamir, Great Pamir and Little Pamir were driven away by summer military expedition of Russian General Ionov in 1892, that also attacked and pushed away Afghan troops that temporarily occupied Sumetash near Yashil Kul Lake in Alichur Pamir. Here Afghans in April 1892 defeated 200 Qing China troops who were sent from Urumchi by Xinjiang Province administration to build a fort. In 1895 Russia and British Empire signed agreement that formed present Wakhan Corridor as part of " buffer" Afghanistan, but Qing China refused to sign it, claiming loss of 20,000 sq km of Pamir Lands and retaining only Taghdumbash Pamir of Sarikol within Xinjiang Province. China-Afghan border was first defined and demarcated only in 1965, but border continued to be closed. During 1979-1989 Soviet occupation of Afghanistan Wakhan Corridor was controlled only by Soviet troops, Afghan troops were not allowed to get in. When on December 27 1979 Soviet troops entered Little Pamir they found here 500 Kyrgyz soldiers of local Rahmankul Khan, in Chinese uniform and armed with Chinese weapon, who fled to Pakistan without engagement with Soviet troops. From 1989-2001 Wakhan Corridor was free from turmoil of civil war in Afghanistan. The same from 2001 to 2021. When Taliban came to Wakhan Corridor in summer 2021 , Afghan Government aviation heavily bombed region and at least 50 Kyrgyz were killed, 500 fled to Tajikistan but were detained and then turned back by Tajikistan authoriries. At present time, about 1,200 Kyrgyz remained in Little Pamir and in 2024 about 500 of them for the first time received Afghan passports.
Such beautiful land ❤
very impressive...stunning. I believe I came to europe from one of these places and one of those men, similar I mean. Thank you for the video!
Fascinating documentary. Those poor folks always worry about the fortunes in life.
No one can understand the pain of being uzbek , hazara ,Turkmen and Kyrgyz in afghanistan 💔😭
May God bless them with everything they need, I hope their people survive. What strong beautiful people
Beautiful place and beautiful people
Incredible! ❤ 🇲🇳
beautiful and heartbreakin' at da same time.
da whole tachibana family send all their love and prayers.
wish der could be more done to help.
💖😭😘🤗💎🌟💕
Great documentary. Thanks!
This is an astounding documentation of a dying culture. Thank you
Very strong and impressive folks. God bless such beautiful people. The typical American would die in 24 hours.
My Kyrgyz people.
Incredible human survival. May their governments, we improve their life conditions🙌
no government has ever done that, that I can see. Not really the gov'ts responsibility.
Türkiye must help this people!!
I want to know what Slice or any of the film crew does to help these people, or if they impose on the already strained resources of these poor folk trying to scratch out an existence? Please bring them food and medicine, don't just exploit them for these videos
I'm pretty sure the tribe wouldn't let themselves being filmed if journalists came with "empty hands"
Hospitality is part of the Afghan ethos. If someone asks for food and shelter, they give it, even if this person has harmed them. I served in the Peace Corps in the late 60's. I saw young, rich Americans travelling thru Afghanistan, sponging on the hospitality of impoverished villagers. They had money in their pockets for souvenirs and luxuries. Shameless.
@@patemmert2672 I understand that, but part of hospitality is not refusing a gift from your guest, and the guests should be giving provisions to these people. Especially because who knows what germs they're exposing the people to? Many of them could wind up dying from COVID or anything else the film crew gives them when their immune systems have never experienced it. I just hate seeing exploitation. I have been one of those children who grew up starving and not knowing if I would live or die the next day
09:39- Why is the wall clock positioned upside-down?
Wow, and we think our lives are difficult!
Kami dari Indonesia kami menyukai bapak ibu dan saudara 2 walau jauh di mata tapi sangat dekat di hati kami ❤🎉salam dari Indonesia 🙏🙏🙏
YOUR COUNTRY IS DESTROYED BY TOURISM NOTHING WAS LEFT UNTOUCHED
Pretty awesome documentary, amazing tough people, amazing scenery, but damn that is sad. Al this drug addiction and basically surviving only. Hope things get better for them ❤️
Love and peace to our Kyrgyz and big shame to our government . from Kabul
I hope Turkeye or Kyrgyzstan will come to help them.
"Türkiye"
Turkiye took some of them in 1978
@@serkantemiz7565 1982
They can't live like this....They must migrat to Kyrgyzstan 🇰🇬 or Kazakhstan 🇰🇿.... The Afghanistan 🇦🇫gevrment ( Taliban ) must give the permtion to leave....... I'm Ethiopian🇪🇹
They are Turkic nomads and they move freely. They have no border
Afghanistan is not a good country it doesn't help it's inhabitants I pity these people they are living in harsh poor conditions with no money and basic facilities.
@@daniellalyngdoh6211Afghanistan has been defending against British, Soviet, US, and NATO invasion. What help do you think it could provide to these ppl who actually were safe from all the wars and violence?
they live a good life@@daniellalyngdoh6211
Why should they migrate they aren’t the only Turkic minority. As an Uzbek w e are also Turkic then migrate within Afghanistan but why should they leave their homelNd?.
Imagine when they have a toothache, or appendicitis with no doctor nearby..
Nice video thanks
I love watching your videos.❤
It's a very nice documentaries..
❤Jako dobar video👍
Great documentary.
Harsh life,to say the least!These have to be some of the toughest Humans on the planet!
OMG that's no way to live I wouldn't last a hour I have great respect and admiration for those people 🙏💕
You can't be serious. The women are *literal slaves.* They don't even try to hide that fact, yet you have "respect and admiration" for them? Disgusting
I am a kyrgyz from kyrgyzstan living now in US state of pensylvania and traveling right now through the state of UTAH,Salt Lake city march 2024.Why don't they come to their homecountry kyrgyzstan?There are a lot places to live .I just don't understand why they don't wanna come over there.
Isn’t this a reupload?
They talk a mix of Kyrgyz and Afgan. Even in the isolated mountains they are being asimilated from their language into speaking Dari
I am somber as I watch them trying to eke happiness and existence in such a forbidden and harsh place. Nothing comes easy to them.
this documentary is NOT objective these people can choose staying there or they can go to their Motherland kyrgystan or even Further to Turkey where they will welcoming them with open arms they have choices that other people don't have
Salomu alekum ba kasoneki bo zaboni forsi gap mezanand مشءالله الحمدلله ولله اكبر bo ehtirom az tojikiston MashaAlloh ☝️❤️👍
I never live in this situation I like your videos
Hi havepleasuretime , in 7:45' it's wrong translated of man's explanation about the number of his family (children) in correct he says: I have five children two daughters and three sons, or three of them are male
An excellent documentary! Do these Kyrgyz nomads speak Tajik, or they simply took the word for 'daughter' from Tajik (an Indo-European language, hence the similarity with the English word), as we can hear "'duhtar"? Kyrgyz is a Turkic language, and it would be strange not to use their own terms for kinship.
The women appeared to be speaking Kyrgyz to me (I couldn't understand) but the men were speaking Local dialect of Dari or Wakhi language, probably for the benefit of their guests. Either that or the women were speaking Wakhi as well while the men were speaking Wakhi with each other and Dari with the interviewers.
Dari and especially Wakhi are related to Urban Tajiki Farsi.
The men were speaking both Persian and Kyrgyz, the women were speaking just Kyrgyz. I’m Kyrgyz from Kyrgyzstan, it’s amazing they still speak pure Kyrgyz language
AFGHANISTAN❤
There are a lot of fair Kyrgyz people like us 😮
In what year was this docmentary made?
omg these kids are more skillful and brave heart than i'm at the age of 20😂😢
น่าอยุ่มาก❤❤❤
Great documentary. May the Sovereign Lord protect and provide for them in their point of need
Top 👍👍👍
Kyrgyz are Türkic people,they have very strong Culture from very old time,thats why They can live still in this harsh situation altough Taliban.
Their lifestyle is more primitive than Taliban.
@@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য Really ? Actually,Nobody in the World can be more primitive then radicalists like talibans.For example you can look to the Poor Farkhunda Murdery Case !
primitive? the way the rest of the world lives is primitive these poeple know how to survive they have skills ur people couldnt replicate in a million years @@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্য
@@গুরুত্বপূর্ণউপপাদ্যbecause they are in absolute isolation. Kyrgyzstan should try to reach them and get them connected to the world . Otherwise they’ll stay addicted to either vodka or opium
@@அவானிஉயர்ந்தது They think they are superior than Kyrgyzstan because during Soviet invasion Afghan Kyrgyz Mujahideen killed many Soviet Kyrgyz soldiers.
they claim the Kyrgyz "struggle to survive", but this way of life seems to be working pretty great for them.
Its way too cold for most us. Never mind the long walk with cattle thats worth this or that.
Amazing documentary. Some of the language used was a bit...
Harus ada tanaman Tumbuhan saudaraku..itu penstabil kehidupan Alam sekitar kita👍
whats this in the beginning, i never saw someone fishing with throwing stones!!! i saw all kind of fishing, survival techniques etc, why the hell wouldnt you report more on that? the movie just kept on as if it wasnt ultimately rare. damn this reporter
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
They’re gonna be so jacked up when mw3 drops
Kyrgzstan should invite them back to kyrgzstan
Bro we tried to do it, but as Kyrgyzstan not rich country it’s difficult for the moment in 2016 there were programs by government to relocate them but this is going with difficulties and now Afghanistan new power in head seems would be more problematic to support them in future
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏
And I would like to listen their kyrgyz language more ,but unfortunately they speak Farsi mostly in this vireo.
درود به همه ی فارسی زبانان💚💚
این ها مردومی فارسی زبان نیست. ای ها مردومی قیرگیز است وه مردای شی فارسی گب میزنه از خاتیری که ده افقانستان زندگی میکونه فقد زن هایشی قیرگیزی گب میزنه.
How blessed am i to be a woman in a western country, worth a hundred sheep then likely to die in childbirth. I am so blessed.
blessed my ass the west doesnt even know the definition of a woman let alone the value of one
Conditions... Until 1 or 2 centuries ago, ur thoughts and choices as a woman were nothing in the West. Women in many western countries gained the right to vote in the ''last century''.
I was blessed to be born Māori in New Zealand and as a woman in Māori culture my female ancestors were equal to the men. Western culture brought the concept of woman being secondary...
@@bernadinemarr8432 If western culture brought the concept of women being secondary, then why do u feel blessed to be a woman in a western country? The Kyrgyz people mentioned in the video are a Turkic people. In Turkic culture and Tengrism the religion of our ancestors, women and men were equal. Our history is full of female heroes, warriors, soldiers, commanders and rulers. Hundreds of years ago, in a world where women weren't even considered human beings, Turkic women could be doctors, judges and shamans. However, some conditions and the influence of other religions or cultures can ruin this.
The government should be dropping boxes of food, and other goods for them. They have billions, and are cruel.) Prayer for the kids.
What government? It’s Afghanistan. They don’t care.
not in globalization
Choose to be out
The plain and simple reason for the high mortality rates during births is due to their poor diet of wheat bread and tea. If they would eat more of the sheep instead of trading them for wives then their women would survive in higher numbers.
Perhaps the sheep are also hard to raise.
Nope, anywhere without proper modern medical care during childbirth, mother/baby mortality is high. No matter of diet.
Obviously you’re a physician, so okay you must be correct lol.
no, you find the same amount of death everywhere around the world , it's just how humanity is , childbirth for women is the most dangerous in the whole animal kigdom. That's why you should be thankfull for what you have, epidurals, doctors tending to you, Er's, germ theory etc... childbearing is brutal and is the reason why women have accepted male domination everywhere on earth.
You should surely go there and bring them what they need, won't you?
Ничего нет,а опиум где то находят 😮
They speak Farsi(dari) persian which I understand and the reason that life get harder for them is they get converted by force to a faith did not do them good! With my deep respect 👍🙏
what are you yapping about
Which is ? I thought they are still Shamanic .
The Kyrgyz are Muslims, as are all Afghans
WTF are you talking about they have been muslims centuries even before migrating to this place. Women seemed to be speaking Kyrgyz, men were speaking Dari or Wakhi (probably switching between the two) for the benefit of their visitors
@@அவானிஉயர்ந்தது Muslims have been for centuries
They should migrate to Kyrgyzstan
Can they apply for refugees status in Kyrgyzstan
Tajikistan is in the way, but I do not see why they wouldn't be allowed to relocate to Kyrgyzstan
ı hope that turkish government will welcome them to Türkiye.
These men are well spoken and sounded educated. They are aware of the world even if they can't reach it.
Poor girls
У них не киргизский язык, это действительно киргизы, а где они живут?
Я сам понял половину это смешанный диалект южных и северных племен некоторые говорят на чистом северном диалекте который я понимал без проблем а в основном уже смешка языка с персидскими языками микс с тюркскими тяжело нужно изучать
life of this people become more bad whean Afghanistan and chaina make highway betwean Afghanistan and chaina because they are better away from tgis world life of them heard but beautiful life in nowadays technology more bad than any other time
We will bring these people to their own independent country in 10 year! I am sure for this
What do you mean stranded?????That's their home, and it's been their home for hundreds of years.
Watch the video. Their nomadic habitat was much larger than this, much of Central Asia, before the land was divided up between several countries.
nah bro these kyrgyz need to stop smoking and stuff if they want a better health
Mate you see in the documentary he condemned their addiction I am not protecting them but as any society can destroy their lives and future, they need to be brave to totally change their perspective but without responsibility it’s impossible and they feel that their life not going to change till they decide it
Kyrgyzistan should take them in their country
It’s possible and government do have programs for them but situation in Afghanistan and weak economy of Kyrgyzstan do not allowed it in near future only hope that they will stabilised their living by receiving medical care and education institutions
Правительство переселили таких людей в Кыргызстан дали им скот построили дома ,но многие не захотели переселятся ,хотя здесь их дети ходят в школы и все условия
Кыргызстан хочет переселить их на родину но не может так как афганцы не выпускают их .. Не знаю почему..Мы обращались в ООН чтобы помогли их переселить в Кыргызстан но всё заглохло после прихода Талибов..
It’s very informative to know about what’s going in different parts of the world through your channel but it doesn’t mean you don’t keep privacy of that poor woman. It would be better if the feeding section was blurred.
no worries! they won't see this documentary!
Why should we blurr it? It is natural and human nature. also she did it in front of the camera man, so she didn't mind it and perhaps they don't see tits as sexual objects, only assets to feed babies. 🤷🏻♀️
I'm sure she's not ashamed to be seen doing the most natural thing in the world. Why would she be? I wasn't ashamed when I fed my babies.
it wasn't feeding. it was smoking.@@notashroom
@@jonam7589 so that is why the comment I replied to said "It would be better if the FEEDING section was blurred"? Even if it was meant, through some linguistic code, to refer to the smoking, we do not know what she smoked, how much she smoked, how often she has smoked it (or that she ever did it off camera, before or after), how her family or community would react, or that she didn't give informed consent to being in the documentary.
Any assumptions we make are based on our lives and cultural contexts, not hers, so I choose to assume that she is a competent adult able to make decisions for herself.
Kyrgyz who fled from the Soviet Communists
Even though life is not going well for them this is the pure example of heritage of Kyrgyz ethnic genome 🧬 couldn’t live under oppression nor party nor khan
Sad, sad, sad. Where , who is the government?
There's no government in Afghanistan 😅
@@themoon1886yes, we have an Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan government.
@@phoenixrising8640 then where's this Islamic government who doesn't care about women and other ethnics.
There is no central government unless you count the Taliban Government and most of their Villages are the same which is why rural Pashtuns support them because the Western Puppet central government only enriches itself. Taliban with all their vices are still trying to change the country but Western Nations have sanctioned Afghanistan and USA has frozen their assets and confiscated half of them. They are more worried about education of some elite girls which is low on the list of priorities for Taliban government right now, than saving Millions dying from Hunger right now, which is their top priority and priority of any logical Human being in their place.
@@phoenixrising8640 the dumpster fire of morons that has to keep their engineers hostage because no one wants to live in that hell hole? Sure, If it's so great can you please tell the hundreds of thousands of Afghans that keep crawling to western countries that the Taliban is a great government, and they should go back that would be great. Now that the big mean Americans are gone, they can go live with the Taliban.
Pamir kırgız türkleri
"aziz" means "penis" in Navajo. 😂
Aziz is muslim name
I thought you indians were extinct.
wouldn't be wrong in his case
They are not stranded they chose to be there a beautiful land
Pay attention. Changing borders have limited their movement.
@@fredflinstone6601 I have they have been there for more than 600-800 years