Hitchens: Why fight religion?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 2,8 тыс.

  • @sierragold
    @sierragold 5 лет назад +768

    Christopher Hitchens could slay with words... what a loss to the planet-- we need him now more than ever.

    • @Fernandez218
      @Fernandez218 5 лет назад +10

      he smoked more than a chimney and drank like there was no tomorrow. maybe if he had taken better care of himself we would have him a lot longer -- it's sad.

    • @sierragold
      @sierragold 5 лет назад +18

      @@Fernandez218 Well, no one can say that for sure. I mean, little kids die of cancer. IMO his smoking and drinking, while not exactly healthy, made him the Christopher Hitchens that we all know and love. I'm sure he wouldn't have changed a thing about his lifestyle-- he seemed to not have any regrets or remorse.

    • @Fernandez218
      @Fernandez218 5 лет назад +3

      ​@@sierragold supposedly Hitchens himself acknowledge the fact that the combination of those two habits were contributing to his decline. Kids do get cancer but how many get esophageal cancer?

    • @sierragold
      @sierragold 5 лет назад +8

      @@Fernandez218 yes, you're correct in that esophageal cancer doesnt typically strike children, and was likely a very crucial element to his death. BUT, I think it's a moot point to say, "If only he had taken care of himself better." He could have been in a fatal car accident or died in some kind of natural catastrophe... no one knows. If he wouldn't have smoked or drank, how much longer would he have lived? No one can answer that-- so for me, moot point. It's very sad, but lots of people die early, unexpected deaths. None of us know when our time is up. And yes, he did acknowedge his "bad" habits likely led to his cancer, but he was not remorseful. He had no regrets. He just stated it as a fact, in a typical Christopher Hitchens way.

    • @Fernandez218
      @Fernandez218 5 лет назад +2

      ​@@sierragold ​ Sonya Ziegler but he didn't die in a car accident. If he did I wouldn't have brought up smoking/drinking unless he was DUI 'cause it's totally irrelevant. He died from something that has a positive correlation with a habit he picked up -- and never stopped -- when he was a teenager. But no one does know how much longer he could've lived if he had stopped -- and it was his life to live. My whole point is his death was within the realm of his control. He could've stopped his habit eons ago and most likely would've added years to his life and he wouldn't have been a loss for the planet and would still be here fighting for his cause -- against religion. Anyone can die at any time in thousands of different ways. That doesn't mean you help death out by taking on a nasty habit that science has clearly found out shortens the length of your life.

  • @traceybanting3952
    @traceybanting3952 4 года назад +297

    As a woman in my 50s, I admire Hitch enormously! I was raised to believe that Jesus watched everything that I said and did. My sister was a stronger character than myself, so was regularly beaten. At 14, she was dragged to be confirmed by her hair. As an adult, letting go of that set of values has given me peace, freedom, and a burning desire to free others from the burden of guilt. Hitch, thank you! You helped me in my journey to mental freedom, which has enabled me to raise our sons without them being burdened by guilt, fear or hatred. I miss you, Sir! xx

    • @prophettoatheists8057
      @prophettoatheists8057 4 года назад

      Are you kidding? Your sons have no moral awareness?

    • @traceybanting3952
      @traceybanting3952 4 года назад +47

      prophetto atheists . Oh dear, do keep up. I said they weren’t burdened by guilt, fear or hatred. I at no point suggested they were without morals. Are you seriously suggesting that being raised by a violent bully is necessary for one to develop morals and conscience? I was referring to religious guilt, not suggesting that my sons are morally bankrupt. I suspect you’re trolling for entertainment purposes. If you have anything at all worth discussing, fine. If not I’m calling BS and will ignore you accordingly!

    • @LaplacianFourier
      @LaplacianFourier 2 года назад

      You are a remarkable woman. You've broken a cycle of stupidity, wickedness, and childhood indoctrination of toxic fairy tales. Don't mind these religious lunatics shouting insults at you. Their minds are so infected by this religion malware that it takes up about 80% of their brain power and can't discern blatant contradictions, of morality or otherwise, in their texts or their behaviors.

    • @AFMMD-q8
      @AFMMD-q8 2 года назад +20

      @ Tracey, I admire and congratulate you with utmost respect for getting out of the quick sands and chains of fantasies, delusions and hallucinations. You are one in a million Tracey, it is my sincere hope your children and grandchildren follow your footsteps one day with your example.

    • @traceybanting3952
      @traceybanting3952 2 года назад +11

      @@AFMMD-q8 wow, thank you so much for your kind words and understanding. I really do appreciate you taking the time to comment. I hope life’s kind to you 😘 x

  • @MrImIntoxicated
    @MrImIntoxicated 10 лет назад +1276

    I hate I'm finding out about him so late but I'm falling further in love with this guy with every speech and debate.

    • @lucerogal
      @lucerogal 10 лет назад +66

      Hitchens? I just discovered him about a year ago and I am saddened that I did't know about him before his death. I can't stop watching his debates or reading his books. I mentioned this before but at my work there is a picture of Christ and I want to bring in a photo of Hitch. Someone said why don't you bring in a photo of Satan and I said, "you really don't understand me at all do you?"

    • @TheBtak13
      @TheBtak13 10 лет назад +14

      You should try Bill Maher, Dawkings, and Bill Nye's debate on creationism vs evolution.

    • @RadioactiveSand
      @RadioactiveSand 9 лет назад +3

      Marvel Girl If you want more of that cake, search for Phil. Love gets even greater.
      You'll thank me later xD

    • @sololimpo553
      @sololimpo553 6 лет назад +11

      You should watch his documentary about mother teresa...

    • @sololimpo553
      @sololimpo553 6 лет назад +9

      You should hear the debate with his brother...

  • @newyorkwomen
    @newyorkwomen 10 лет назад +104

    Religion is not about freedom. Going to churches for over 25 years I was never once asked anything such as, "Do you like going to church?, Do you want to continue going to church?, Do you want to get married or not?, How do you want to live your own life?, What are your views?, etc." There was no dialogue, your own voice was silenced literally and you had no say when you are told to be quiet, and the priest preached in an authoritarian tone telling you what you must believe, told you what to do, said don't do this and that, said you "Have To" be married, said who to vote for, tried to control your own body saying what you sensually could not do with your own body, glorified sacrifice and pain as being better than pleasure and enjoyment in life, and would preach guilt trips if you were not there in church last week and how the church renovations cost hundreds of thousands of dollars and there are some who are not putting enough in the collection basket. Religions say they want more freedoms for themselves in other countries, yet religions tell people how they "Have To" live and this is NOT freedom, it is power over and control of people by the religions. Religion is not about freedom for the people.

    • @vasudevchakravarti4310
      @vasudevchakravarti4310 9 лет назад +3

      brandon hvac What?

    • @yojoeo9067
      @yojoeo9067 9 лет назад +1

      that's people, people are sinners, what about the bible and God Himself. Christianity is about God, not just Church.

    • @uscg1381
      @uscg1381 7 лет назад +9

      You're not listening. Like the OP said, religion is about control. It was invented for control and money.

    • @albertrogers2506
      @albertrogers2506 4 года назад +5

      @Jazzkeyboardist1 I was a bit slow about dropping God. In my case, I knew two or three downright decent ministers, one of whom preached an anti-war sermon on a Sunday that happened to be November 11. Also I mingled with decent Christians. I was shocked when I attended a church or two after coming to the USA and it seemed all they cared about was "being saved".

    • @SleepyPenguin-8og
      @SleepyPenguin-8og 6 месяцев назад

      Who when where how​@@vasudevchakravarti4310

  • @barristanselmy2758
    @barristanselmy2758 10 лет назад +438

    We lost some very heavy artillery when hitchens died. We still have harris , dawkins , dennet and many others. But hitchens was the main blood vessel pumping the truth into everyone he meets, this man hated lies and you could see it by the look on his face. R.I.P Christopher Hitchens. Sorely missed.

    • @edwardcurrent2874
      @edwardcurrent2874 5 лет назад +1

      Indeed! Too bad god struck him down☹

    • @lestweforgetsolvecoagula5867
      @lestweforgetsolvecoagula5867 5 лет назад +17

      @@edwardcurrent2874 I'd like you to remember what you said when you're suffering! Since you have no problem causing distress to someone mourning a true intellectual. Surely you'd have no problem.. oh wait you've got to jump back on God's side and say " he's in a better place now" or " he's with god now" like either one of these statements provide any source of real comfort other than just being lies "that comfort" your fucking ego. The more you educate yourself the more YOU KNOW when someones trying to swindle you..... Religions flourished when the greatest con men met the biggest fools.
      One god shall have enough evidence to prove to the entire world he is God to cease the suicide, murder, discrimination over sexual orientation of any kind, hunger, cancer I could go on and on. Point is, there are people with serious issues on Earth. What are you waiting for exactly ? Are you even real ? Is this a game and your point is to watch us graval below you? As if our lives are a television set and he never gives up the remote constantly channel surfing? OR they're all wrong.... leaders of these Religions are after one thing brothers and sisters.. (our brains) and they've created these monsters they call gods in order to achieve it...
      Save yourself
      Silly 🐇 tricks are for kids
      📖📖📖
      ⛪🕍🕌=🤑

    • @mjfraser04
      @mjfraser04 5 лет назад +5

      Matt Dillahunty has moved quickly up the ladder. While in my opinion, Dennet doesn't seem to be very relevant nowadays.

    • @vishwanathkadalagi2336
      @vishwanathkadalagi2336 5 лет назад +2

      Don't forget Krauss.

    • @rwatson2609
      @rwatson2609 5 лет назад +6

      I too just noticed Christopher, he is asking the real questions that we Christians should be sorting out. There really is no bigger mess than that which is made by the self righteous pew warmer who hates his neighbor.

  • @LightSaber12345
    @LightSaber12345 3 года назад +109

    He collects his thoughts so quickly and conveys them excellently.

    • @upturnedblousecollar5811
      @upturnedblousecollar5811 Год назад +4

      He had the best command of the English language of anyone I've ever heard.

    • @XYisnotXX
      @XYisnotXX Год назад

      "Man is not great" Peter Hitchens.

  • @supermiembro
    @supermiembro 5 лет назад +401

    A guy tried to belittle Hitch and receives a complete education along with a gigantic kick in the nuts for good measure, RIP Hitch!

    • @Fernandez218
      @Fernandez218 5 лет назад +19

      that's one way to see it. I think this audience member could've been seeking an answer to his own dilemma through Hitchens. Maybe he's seeking confidence through Hitchens' insight by asking a question that is often asked to him?! I saw a bit of malice in the man's eyes but that could also be a projection of my own experiences and emotion and not be factual at all.

    • @anthonyparkinson8547
      @anthonyparkinson8547 5 лет назад +17

      It didn't try to belittle Hitchens it was a perfectly reasonable question

    • @Fernandez218
      @Fernandez218 5 лет назад +15

      @@anthonyparkinson8547 i just rewatched some of the debate and the body language of the guy who asked the question, during some of Turek's points, doesn't support my original idea. haha.

    • @feonor26
      @feonor26 4 года назад +26

      It was a fair question and the guy sat and listened respectfully and did not speak out of turn. His question also gave us one of the best closing speeches of Christopher Hitchens ever. Whenever someone asks me why I hate religion and "what's the harm", I often refer them to this video.

    • @kw8757
      @kw8757 4 года назад +7

      The man who asked the question also applauded Hitchens, for a few seconds at least.

  • @JosephNordenbrockartistraction
    @JosephNordenbrockartistraction 11 лет назад +501

    Just look at that angry face of that guy who asked the question. Yes there is anger behind that mocking little smurk on his face. Still it's a VERY good question with a perfectly delivered answer.

    • @JosephNordenbrockartistraction
      @JosephNordenbrockartistraction 11 лет назад +10

      ***** I must at least commend the man for not walking out before the end.

    • @kurtknapp904
      @kurtknapp904 10 лет назад +3

      Joseph Nordenbrock and he clapped twice.

    • @Hirnlego999
      @Hirnlego999 10 лет назад +20

      No, it's not a good question. You would have to ignore news to ask that question. Anyone should know very well that the religious are not concerned only with the afterlife, they want to create their religious paradise here on earth and all should conform to these beliefs. Not true with all religious leaders, but to spread the good news is part of Christianity. Also, the questioner should know that Hitchens had not devoted his entire life to this cause. He could have done a bit research on Hitchens before asking such a question.

    • @JosephNordenbrockartistraction
      @JosephNordenbrockartistraction 10 лет назад +12

      Hirnlego999 Maybe it's not a thought out question, But it's a common one that makes people consider how to properly ask a better question later. It's also a way to gauge how much people just follow along with the status quo of sound bites, headlines and generalizations made by the uninformed population. This time the right kind of person answered this lame question and I'm glad it was done on youtube.

    • @manthasagittarius1
      @manthasagittarius1 9 лет назад +17

      Joseph Nordenbrock It's not a question at all, in the true sense, because it's purely rhetorical, expecting no answer and convinced that it is its own answer. Besides, it's rude.

  • @xxmotaxx93
    @xxmotaxx93 8 лет назад +298

    Damm.. I sincerely miss him. His absence is a loss for all of humanity.

    • @rcrbrewster7840
      @rcrbrewster7840 6 лет назад +3

      Azel G I agree.... I miss Alan Watts as well...

    • @johndowns3839
      @johndowns3839 5 лет назад +1

      Norman Finkelstein, Chomsky, and Ralph Nader have more to offer than Hitchens ever did, but you don't hear much from them because they never could bring themselves to suck-up to the neocons and weren't good at schmoozing at Vanity Fair soirees.

    • @Heycool08
      @Heycool08 5 лет назад +1

      @@johndowns3839 OK but which one had the biggest cock?
      Seriously, there's no need to nitpick your top 10 list of greatest people and dash the rest against the walls of the city. One man's success does not come at the cost of another's in the case of intellectual and moral teachings.

    • @Kitiwake
      @Kitiwake 4 года назад +1

      He s no loss.

    • @pkmkbdallahgallah2300
      @pkmkbdallahgallah2300 3 года назад +1

      Pat aherne
      Jesus bastard was no loss
      He was a slave master
      Stfu

  • @h.a.b.arguille1896
    @h.a.b.arguille1896 6 лет назад +51

    This is his most passionate defence of his ideas to be found online. He was an intellectual and moral giant, and he will be missed.

    • @NiklasKuhlmann
      @NiklasKuhlmann Год назад

      If this is his most passionate, I don't wanna know his other videos! You call him a "intellectual giant"? Yeah people call Jordan Peterson that at well because he says what they want to hear. Impressive...

  • @gauravsoni3265
    @gauravsoni3265 3 года назад +56

    It's remarkable to see Hitchen throwing an open Challenge in a crowd like this .... He made them applause with his intelligence and well articulated thoughts. What an absolute Beast he was. Looked invincible here.

    • @postplays
      @postplays Год назад

      Someone from the crowd asks a question then Hitchens proceeds with word salad for several minutes.
      This isn't how you have a debate with someone. Its a farce and illusion that he's being "open" with the audience when he's really not. If he were honest he'd have an actual dialogue with the person. This is hardly an open forum and the audience member could be a plant for all we know. Stop believing everything you see and hear.

    • @simonsis1321
      @simonsis1321 Год назад +5

      @@postplays The debate happened before this (I assume). This is not a debate, this is him responding to a question. The question was "If there is no god, why do you spend your whole life trying to convince people that there isn't?". This is asking for his opinion, not asking for a back and forth.

    • @vknl99
      @vknl99 Год назад +1

      @@postplayshe’s not debating that person in the audience though?? lol

    • @postplays
      @postplays 8 месяцев назад

      @@vknl99
      Oh I'm sorry. So, "Answers a question with no room for rebuttal" - That should satisfy you. Then the crowd claps.

  • @scienceforall8778
    @scienceforall8778 4 года назад +24

    I have yet to meet a human so comfortable in their own skin as this man.

  • @elgar104
    @elgar104 4 года назад +24

    If there's a better unrehearsed reply to a question out there. ..I want to hear it.
    The education and intellect needed to pull off this magnificent tour de force is unique.
    I so miss this guy.

  • @rtmordecai1
    @rtmordecai1 4 года назад +42

    I live in Virginia, and went to VCU only a couple years after this debate. I discovered Hitchens only a few months after this and there’s always a small pang when I realize how close I was to witnessing him in person. I’m always proud that he received that applause and even in the heart of this state he could be appreciated well.

  • @TheGlobuleReturns
    @TheGlobuleReturns Год назад +10

    Seeing the unjustified smugness of a man who has unwittingly asked a stupid question is that much more satisfying when you know Hitchens is the one to answer it.

  • @xerox1959
    @xerox1959 10 лет назад +144

    Christopher Hitchens: superior analyses - incredible!

  • @ziff_1
    @ziff_1 Год назад +7

    The answer to that question "why fight religion?" will never, ever be put better than this. Hitch was a linguistic genius. I've never seen anyone with a better command of the English language, and ability to recall and express ideas.

  • @Skindoggiedog
    @Skindoggiedog 15 лет назад +32

    "I have no doubt that his incisive arguments bounced off the head of the person asking his question, protected by his shield of Faith from ever having to consider what Mr. Hitchens said."
    You are 100% correct. The following morning that guy will wake up next to his wife and think back to where he was the previous night, turn to her and say "I don't know why guys like Hitchens don't just stay at home instead of going out trying to refute something they don't believe"
    It's simply incredible.

  • @54spatula
    @54spatula 5 лет назад +19

    That's the best answer to a question I've ever heard in my life.

  • @tranceformerfx
    @tranceformerfx Год назад +7

    "Why don't you just stay home?"
    is codeword for...
    *"I really don't like you criticizing my belief, it makes me look bad"*

  • @renupathak4442
    @renupathak4442 3 года назад +23

    What a courageously honest man I have discovered so late in my life. I savour ever word every thought pronounced by this man.

  • @VulpesMaximus
    @VulpesMaximus 5 лет назад +68

    Welp, that guy from the audience got his answer alright.

  • @torino390
    @torino390 5 лет назад +51

    One of my fave Hitch moments ever.

  • @stephenmayo9516
    @stephenmayo9516 2 года назад +12

    “We can’t think without this, we must be afraid, and we must be forced to love someone who we fear”… one of my favorite brilliant points from the Hitch himself

  • @rajaseelan6934
    @rajaseelan6934 9 лет назад +111

    Hitchens was brilliant and the honesty of his principle is clearly evident. The same question can also be asked about religion and it is highly unlikely anyone theist can come up with an impromptu answer anywhere near as eloquently as Hitchens did. This is a mind of a genius.

    • @brianslabbert8374
      @brianslabbert8374 6 лет назад

      raja seelan í8

    • @GidzPaul
      @GidzPaul 5 лет назад

      Ravi Zacharias.. He would be the man to talk to if you want such questions.

    • @GidzPaul
      @GidzPaul 5 лет назад

      ​@Alexander Duthie Facepalm!

    • @MoPar7055
      @MoPar7055 Год назад

      While I do think he was highly intelligent I think you're giving him way too much credit. First off, what makes you think it was impromptu? You don't think he's thought about this question before? Second off, don't forget he spent years studying this subject and question.

  • @angrylambie
    @angrylambie Год назад +4

    at the end, the audience member who asked that final question - "Why don't you stay home? (why don't you just shut-up!)" - does not applaud with the rest of the audience - that shows his was not asked in good faith, how unhappy he was that it blew up in his face and gave Hitchens the opportunity to show the audience what truth and integrity looks like! -

  • @Forkbot79
    @Forkbot79 Год назад +5

    The mike drop at the end is so resounding.

  • @paranuts7693
    @paranuts7693 3 года назад +22

    Wanted nothing more than to thank this man for articulating so elegantly the very ideas I have and could never convey myself. He is still to this day the only man I ever loved, respected and wished there were billions more like him.

    • @AFMMD-q8
      @AFMMD-q8 2 года назад +2

      @Paranuts 76 My sentiment exactly, agree with your statements 100% this will then be such a better world indeed, instead of the cesspool of filth, delusions, hallucinations, ignorance and corruption we have.

    • @johnfaichney9529
      @johnfaichney9529 Год назад

      When he does he will find out about God. Pity the does not believe in Jesus.

    • @croakhilleburg9155
      @croakhilleburg9155 Год назад

      ⁠​⁠@@johnfaichney9529😂Loads of people were born and died before that illiterate Jew even existed! Don’t forget that Christianity is plagiarized. Ever go to public school? Plagiarism is a big no-no.

    • @postplays
      @postplays Год назад

      The only man you should live is your father.

  • @cullenmott7614
    @cullenmott7614 2 года назад +7

    (overly) simplified answer: "Why fight religion? Because religion fights us. Religion started fighting us thousands of years ago and doesn't seem to be quitting any time soon."

  • @selsuru
    @selsuru 10 лет назад +324

    Monotheism is one of the most dangerous things ever invented.

    • @Hirnlego999
      @Hirnlego999 10 лет назад +35

      Yes. The evils of Stalin and nazism (for instance, there are other examples) at least have leaders who die and have to be replaced. The wickedness of God is for eternity, even continuing after death.

    • @WiseTube
      @WiseTube 10 лет назад +22

      Aside from Bagpipes.

    • @Simp44
      @Simp44 10 лет назад +16

      WiseTube
      Bagpipes are awesome (lifts kilt) :P

    • @rymdalkis
      @rymdalkis 6 лет назад +14

      Above all, polytheistic religions have no problem including another god into their pantheon. You can see it in most people when Christianity and Islam were introduced to them. The Abrahamic god was simply another god they could pray to. This opens up to a much more tolerant society. Just look at the Roman empire where people could pray to their respective gods however they liked

    • @bobhi2668
      @bobhi2668 6 лет назад +8

      yes, I would call it the worst invention for all inventions, as it makes use of all the other inventions to hurt invention itself.

  • @llynfach
    @llynfach 10 лет назад +48

    Breathtakingly brilliant Hitch.

  • @bgrice01
    @bgrice01 13 лет назад +10

    amazing, simply amazing. A brilliant mind of the 21st century. Hopefully you have changed the minds of believers to make this world a better place

  • @nealfager9178
    @nealfager9178 5 лет назад +22

    "The Thought of Eternal Punishment destroys interest in Life and makes Happiness Impossible"
    - Napoleon Hill: Think and Grow Rich, Six Ghosts of Fear; Fear of Death

    • @prophettoatheists8057
      @prophettoatheists8057 4 года назад +1

      Just nonsense! Does the Thought of punishment on this earth destroy interest in Life and make Happiness Impossible?
      Thankfully, we do have a justice systems now and hereafter! I'm happy!!!!!!!!!

    • @ShinsDomain
      @ShinsDomain 3 года назад +1

      Absolutely relatable

  • @mattball7074
    @mattball7074 5 лет назад +13

    Man, I couldn't write that with 30 days on my side and he vocalized it immediately, not even knowing what the question was going to be

  • @colonelkurtz2269
    @colonelkurtz2269 4 года назад +12

    One of my favorite quotes by Hitchens: religion isn't a buffet where you can pick and choose only what you like.
    It embodies nearly every believer today.

  • @Chadmay33
    @Chadmay33 7 лет назад +52

    Well... I think Christopher Hitchens just nailed that one. Next!

    • @Omerta_1964
      @Omerta_1964 5 лет назад +1

      Yes no doubt HItchens dropped the mic Literally and figuratively! lol

    • @andyng5321
      @andyng5321 3 года назад

      just like how Jesus was nailed to the cross :)

  • @wanderlustsick1538
    @wanderlustsick1538 4 года назад +3

    Am from lebanon. And yea u did help me alot. U freed my mind. Nothing would be said to u enough as a thanks. RIP. The biggest loss of humanity i ever know.

  • @Mr._Nobadi_M._Portent
    @Mr._Nobadi_M._Portent 4 года назад +114

    Hitch: "Is there anyone who'd like to challenge me?"
    **Translation**
    Hitch: "Who wants to die today?"

    • @albertrogers2506
      @albertrogers2506 4 года назад +1

      Actually he warned us about the number of people who expect to die, the sooner the better!

    • @FlexBeanbag
      @FlexBeanbag 4 года назад

      @@albertrogers2506 ruclips.net/video/Bmc9NFfhx74/видео.html

    • @prophettoatheists8057
      @prophettoatheists8057 4 года назад

      I will challenge his ideas as it is a little late to have a discussion with him.
      Do you believe that Hitchens was/is your greatest teacher?

    • @dortmundgrabenstein9193
      @dortmundgrabenstein9193 3 года назад +1

      Hey Joniah,
      I suppose it was meant to be a joke, if not thats rubbish. No one dies if he|she gets challenged on his|her opinion. The thing with religion is even if Hitchens won the argument by rational standards, the religious person will not see it bc religion makes some ppl "immune" to reason.

  • @wymanspace4173
    @wymanspace4173 5 лет назад +17

    Each and every time when I hit the wall, I return here to seek courage and strength from the Hitch.
    Tomorrow I’ll fight again.

    • @karenkaren3189
      @karenkaren3189 4 года назад +2

      Wyman Space As a lifelong nurse, I have seen so much suffering. I never try to talk my patients out of their faith. If I sense that their belief in God is a source of strength to them, that’s fine. I have even prayed with them, because to me the words are somewhat meaningless, but the feeling behind them is sincere, and that’s good enough for me.
      However if someone tries to tell me that prayer saves people’s lives, I have to demur. I have seen prayer in that context fail over and over again. Perhaps their prayers helped, maybe they didn’t. Again, if it gives folks strength and consolation, good for them. But don’t tell an old Oncology nurse that you can pray cancer away.
      👵🏻😔👵🏻

    • @prophettoatheists8057
      @prophettoatheists8057 4 года назад +1

      So when you "hit the wall" are you having doubts about atheism?

  • @toi_techno
    @toi_techno Год назад +8

    It's amusing to see the face of an American Christian realising he is exactly equivalent to a muslim extremist.

  • @bigjohnson9561
    @bigjohnson9561 5 лет назад +46

    Purely amazing!!!! He makes a lot of sense about what religion does to human society. It would have been great to meet him before he passed but fortunately there are videos of him.

    • @karenkaren3189
      @karenkaren3189 4 года назад +3

      Big Johnson YT’s greatest value to my life are videos like this ( also cooking and ballet videos 😉)

    • @positivesecret
      @positivesecret 3 года назад

      I wonder how many hot meals hes served to homeless people on Sunday morning

    • @iqbalindaryono8984
      @iqbalindaryono8984 Год назад

      ​@@positivesecretI wonder what percentage of Christians have done that themselves.

    • @positivesecret
      @positivesecret Год назад

      @@iqbalindaryono8984 I know of quite a few churches that help the homeless. It fact Christians help more than any other organization. Thans not opinion.

  • @WayOfAges
    @WayOfAges Год назад +7

    Because religion will drag down society the moment the resistance to it collapses.

  • @PNGPJS
    @PNGPJS 5 лет назад +15

    such a great loss to the world . he will be sorely missed . A man who thinks beyond the square we live in . RIP Christopher .

    • @andredeketeleastutecomplex
      @andredeketeleastutecomplex Год назад

      A loss to the anglo world, you can keep the rest of us out of it.

    • @upturnedblousecollar5811
      @upturnedblousecollar5811 Год назад

      @@andredeketeleastutecomplex You may want to put forward reasoning behind your statement, otherwise it's just timewasting.

  • @TyphoidBryan
    @TyphoidBryan 9 лет назад +61

    That flustered guy could have accomplished the same effect by asking, "If you hate violent crime so much, why not board yourself up at home?"
    If there is something worth fighting, then you do it if you of are that particular mindset. You don't sit on your hands and just wish problems away. You don't rest on one's platitudes and recite familiar parables to gloss over the realities of the world.
    Consider the folks who respond to traumatic situations or social disarray with "it is in God's hands" or something similar in fashion. When you have no options, look to the heavens for a solution. You can do that once and you will have a nice laugh in the process. Do it twice and you are tempting habit. Keep your eyes always lifted in time of trouble, you are likely going to never solve a single thing in your lifetime. A bedrock of daily belief assumes you are of no action and all faith...just the way they want you.

    • @nealmac187
      @nealmac187 5 лет назад +3

      Very well-put. I think The Hitch himself would applaud.

    • @anthonyparkinson8547
      @anthonyparkinson8547 5 лет назад

      He showed courage in questioning Hitchens in a room full of Hitchen's acolytes

  • @Søutħsidë
    @Søutħsidë 4 года назад +15

    That unfortunate man at the beginning 1:05 and at the end sitting alone in the crowd 6:02 who received one of the best Hitchslap’s ever delivered. 👏🏻

    • @Søutħsidë
      @Søutħsidë 3 года назад +1

      @bãßßêt continue.

    • @Søutħsidë
      @Søutħsidë 3 года назад +1

      @bãßßêt He is only pointing to some Muslims and Jews and I don't think he is saying that entire Muslims and Jews are bad. You can also says that those idiots whi claims to kill people based on religion wouldn't have dared to commit such an utter stupidity if it wasn't for their religion. Religion makes good people do bad things. Thats all he is saying. Also about charity or good morals I am clearing this upfront because I know that u will ask me this next that but most people who r religious are good, they do charity.... etc. Yes atheists also does that. Atheists also does charity and have good morals. So its not about one's inclination to any Gods. Its innate in us. But religion makes good people do bad things.

    • @Søutħsidë
      @Søutħsidë 3 года назад

      @bãßßêt Atheism is not a belief system. Its actually the opposite of that. Atheism is the pure lack of any beliefs unsupported by logic and reasoning. I dont know how u can call the lack of belief, a belief?
      To answer your first point, Hitler was not an atheist. He may have used Darwinism to justify his atrocious hatred towards Jews, but he was definitely not an atheist and he basically was a self proclaimed God by himself. We can understand it by his open allegiance with Catholic priests and the belt buckles of the Nazis expressed their substantial love for Christianity.
      And may I know any atheist based ideologoes that u r talking about. I didn't knew atheists had any ideologies.

    • @Søutħsidë
      @Søutħsidë 3 года назад

      @bãßßêt What are these atheist ideologies that you r talking about? In a sense you are right that people with or without religion can do brutal practices. But the question here is does religion have any value in this current society and age. It may well have tested times and survived centuries, but it only represents the gullible nature of their followers. Does it truly have any place in this 21st century? I dont think so. Bad people do bad things, good people do good things, but if you want a good person to do bad things you need religion. It is cancerous and devoid of any value to the society as a whole. We may be good off without it. A simple example would be the practice of circumcision. I mean who even would think to remove the foreskin of their own child if it wasnt for their God and religion? Show me some barbaric practices like these happening in an atheist society?

    • @Søutħsidë
      @Søutħsidë 3 года назад

      @bãßßêt You keep saying that atheists created more bloodbath than religious people and saying I must admit that too. Speaking of education, how illiterate of you to think that I must accept that idiotic belief of yours. When I say religion, it also include religions like Hitler, Stalin etc. too and you are saying that they are atheists. You must learn to see religion in a much broader perspective even to comprehend what I am saying. Since you r not going to change your mind and I am neither, lets just agree to disgree.

  • @williamthegirl
    @williamthegirl 14 лет назад +19

    Wow, that last part gave me goosebumps... the sooner humanity shakes off these ridiculous, barbaric, superstitious notions, the more likely we are to avoid untold destruction.

    • @DimGiant
      @DimGiant Год назад +1

      This is not true. Tell me which great wars of the previous century were waged over religion? Hitler, Stalin and Mao warred over resources, glory and gross misinterpretations of political and philosophical thought.

  • @mikepolk4126
    @mikepolk4126 11 лет назад +29

    Miss ya Christopher.

  • @Chardonbois
    @Chardonbois Год назад +4

    Now that is what you call the ultimate reply to a question!

  • @chrissilver7719
    @chrissilver7719 2 года назад +4

    He is brutal, direct and correct. Why don't atheist's stay at home because religious zealots keep knocking on people's doors.

  • @LynnetteJJW
    @LynnetteJJW Год назад +5

    Why go around and try to turn people away from religion?
    A: Why do you go around and try to turn people TO religion?

  • @scottymocap
    @scottymocap 10 лет назад +25

    I love it, Hitch had Turek applauding at the end!

    • @lawofthewest1983
      @lawofthewest1983 3 года назад +1

      I was just thinking - why did Mr. Turek applauded? I think out of respect to the debate adversary and for the clear presentation of his views, however I do not believe that he agreed with the views oh Mr. Hitchens.

    • @AFMMD-q8
      @AFMMD-q8 2 года назад

      Frank Turek may be a closeted atheist, church exempt him from paying taxes, Christianity and the church are both a big racquet, and a detriment to the progress of humans.

  • @yukiyavalentine5867
    @yukiyavalentine5867 Год назад +4

    If only more people could hear this

  • @thomasneal9291
    @thomasneal9291 8 лет назад +55

    While Hitchens is of course correct in what he says about religion, I would like to point out the the reason religiotards ask the question you heard, "If God doesn't exist, why do you try to disprove him?" was NOT because they are unaware.
    they view it differently... for example, someone in the comments below compared it to:
    "That flustered guy could have accomplished the same effect by asking,
    "If you hate violent crime so much, why not board yourself up at home?" "
    the people asking those questions would tell you that what they are trying to get Hitchens to admit, is that he is indeed fighting against "violent crime". meaning, they think it's a "gotchya" moment in forcing him to admit there IS violent crime, IOW, framed in the original questions wording: god.
    see, they all think atheists really secretly believe in god, they just hate him.
    these are the people that ask questions like that.
    their minds work on an entirely different wavelength.
    if you used the analogy above to address their question... they would just look at you funny and claim you did not answer it.
    shorter:
    know your enemy.

    • @oldflute
      @oldflute 5 лет назад +4

      I don't believe Mr. Hitchens was trying to disprove anything. The burden is on those who hypothesize that a god and an afterlife exist to show US the evidence. Real evidence, not just some ancient writings or statements made by other believers.
      So far no one has proposed a way to test those hypotheses.

    • @oldflute
      @oldflute 5 лет назад +8

      @Jazzkeyboardist1 I hope you can get some help to improve your emotional well being. May I kindly point out that it is bizarre that you would gloat about another person's terminal depressive illness. Good luck in your search.

    • @mikewahnsinn567
      @mikewahnsinn567 5 лет назад +3

      @Jazzkeyboardist1why don't you go back to whatever hole you crawled from, you fucking moron.

    • @tralfamadore5719
      @tralfamadore5719 5 лет назад +2

      @Jazzkeyboardist1 all you keep proving is your a piece of garbage

    • @kalsulivani5791
      @kalsulivani5791 4 года назад +2

      @Jazzkeyboardist1 how is Iraq war or any wars have any relevancy with science apart from the weapons they use in warfare made from scientific achievements.

  • @wayneburton8168
    @wayneburton8168 3 года назад +5

    This is one of my favorite Hitchens speeches. The greatest wordsmith of the atheist movement.

  • @elfedowen6452
    @elfedowen6452 6 лет назад +26

    The chap in the blue shirt was the only one that didn't clap.... probably reeling from the hitchslap.....

    • @reason5591
      @reason5591 5 лет назад +1

      It left him stung and bewildered im sure 😂

  • @timewilltell7
    @timewilltell7 13 лет назад +8

    I LOVE THIS MAN FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART

  • @notimmortal9738
    @notimmortal9738 4 года назад +3

    Just so people know (I doubt anyone will find this comment by now) the gentleman asking the question is obviously an atheist. Throughout the debate he continuously nodded along with signifying agreement with Hitch’s points. Because he is an atheist I find it extremely commendable that he would choose to pose such a challenging and personal question to Hitch, he really answered Hitch’s call to be challenged and should be commended for it.

  • @Hirnlego999
    @Hirnlego999 11 лет назад +7

    Why should we leave harmful ideas alone? Half the human race is imprisoned in the middle-east thanks to religion. This alone is a worthy cause to speak against religion...because religion does not leave people alone, it asks, no demands us to live our lives on our knees.

  • @jabba0975
    @jabba0975 6 лет назад +147

    Duh. The answer is in the question: If there is no god, why try to convince people? Because of the incredible amount of suffering people's false beliefs cause, both to themselves and others. Silly question from a silly man.

    • @oldflute
      @oldflute 5 лет назад +3

      It's almost as if the silly question was a plant to justify a fuller explanation. Likely was not a plant, but it served the same purpose.

    • @supermal112233
      @supermal112233 5 лет назад +4

      Or it was just a question.

    • @fredworthmn
      @fredworthmn 5 лет назад +3

      There are those who believe that THEIR religion is not like any of the others. Why are you attacking my religion when I / we are so good and loving? But when it comes right down to it, those people still believe that anyone who disagrees with them is going to hell.

    • @jimmy5634
      @jimmy5634 5 лет назад +1

      jabba0975 jj what suffering? Belief in the Word of God brings peace knowing that there is something beyond this miserable existence.
      Besides it’s really none of your business what people choose to believe in. We all have a free will and a mind.
      I see a lot of Godless people suffering every day. What good does their lack of belief do for them?

    • @jimmy5634
      @jimmy5634 5 лет назад +1

      fredworthmn no they believe that anyone who rejects Gods Holy Spirit will not spend eternity with God.
      Obviously, you don’t. Good for you.

  • @Ribbo
    @Ribbo Год назад +3

    I love how the guy who asked the question could not bring himself to applaud when his fragile house of cards fell over before his eyes.
    When your opinion is destroyed through facts and logic, at least have the decency to acknowledge it...

  • @luisbranko.
    @luisbranko. 5 лет назад +16

    There’s only one adjective to express his command of the English language... divine.

    • @Jeff-tj4tx
      @Jeff-tj4tx 4 года назад +1

      Let's not forget "sublime"

  • @gusjackson3658
    @gusjackson3658 6 лет назад +19

    Love exists without God. It is a release to truly know that.

  • @danialhowe9814
    @danialhowe9814 Год назад +2

    i love the fact that Hitch simply puts his thoughts out there and never elevates his voice to speak over others to drive his point home

  • @legioneer2
    @legioneer2 11 лет назад +12

    5:59 Even the guy who asked the question had to clap a little

  • @giorodrigues8589
    @giorodrigues8589 3 года назад +22

    An ordinary person :" Would anyone like to ask me a question ''?
    Hitch: "Is there anyone who'd like to challenge me?"

    • @postplays
      @postplays Год назад

      Fake audience questions don't count. If you think that wasn't a plant then youre delusional.
      Goofballs like Hitchens aren't out to have a discussion. The guy in the audience asked his questions then Hitchen yammered on for several minutes. The guy didn't get a chance to retort or follow up.

  • @stud8569
    @stud8569 4 года назад +3

    This is one of his most eloquent and articulate responses on the subject

  • @Blunttalker
    @Blunttalker 2 года назад +3

    Hitchens is loved by many in Nigeria (secretly)

  • @MCsCreations
    @MCsCreations Год назад +2

    The guy who asked didn't clap in the end. Did you guys see it?
    Either way, enjoy life. The most you can, without throwing it in the trash can. It's your only one. 🖖😊

  • @scratchfg212
    @scratchfg212 5 лет назад +16

    Haha even frank turek is clapping. Damn that was good

    • @MOGGS1942
      @MOGGS1942 3 года назад +3

      Yes he was, and it seemed genuine. Fair play to him for that. Even the man who asked the question joined in the applause.

  • @gooddaysahead1
    @gooddaysahead1 9 месяцев назад +5

    Why fight religion? Because it's the most perniciously divisive set of conflicting and unjustifiable ideas humanity has ever concocted.

  • @MrMrh1958
    @MrMrh1958 5 лет назад +11

    So articulate!

  • @pswright2285
    @pswright2285 3 года назад +6

    Perfect summary of the severe threat which religion bestows upon mankind.

  • @eenie1234
    @eenie1234 3 года назад +2

    The best thing we can do is direct others to his debates and hopefully put thought in their minds.

  • @WindChimes-id5nf
    @WindChimes-id5nf 15 дней назад +1

    Still my top fave video clip of Christopher Hitchens. 💙💚💛💜

  • @joshuaphilip9935
    @joshuaphilip9935 5 лет назад +18

    It is okay to believe in Santa Claus if you’re eight . But if you’re thirty four and still believe in such a ridiculous entity without a shred of evidence it is a bit embarrassing socially .

    • @postplays
      @postplays Год назад

      I don't "believe" in God. He just is.

    • @Cenot4ph
      @Cenot4ph Год назад

      ​@postplays where's the evidence?

    • @CeruleanSword
      @CeruleanSword Год назад

      @@postplays
      When you were 8, you thought Santa just ‘was’. You didn’t believe in him per say, you thought he was an accepted part of existence.
      You moved on from Santa, why haven’t you moved on from God.
      What is the difference.

  • @adabsurdum3314
    @adabsurdum3314 5 лет назад +4

    A true intellectual, with a good dose of wisdom.

  • @JustWasted3HoursHere
    @JustWasted3HoursHere Год назад +4

    With all the good that you accept in your religion, you have to accept the bad too. And there's a lot of it. If you think not, then you have not read your holy book in its entirety.

  • @ThelemicMovement
    @ThelemicMovement Год назад +1

    I see Nietzsche in the first line applauding the sharp intellect of the great Hitch!

  • @tomellis4750
    @tomellis4750 3 года назад +2

    The questioner wasn't clapping at the end, although. as Hitch pointed out, he was cheering for the end.

  • @launabanauna8958
    @launabanauna8958 5 лет назад +8

    Omg, talk about giving someone the “stink eye!” Chill dude!
    You just got “Hitchslapped!”

  • @baritony8763
    @baritony8763 5 лет назад +10

    Well, I guess he told you.A good-hearted & brilliant answer to a stupid question.

  • @3niknicholson
    @3niknicholson 5 лет назад +6

    He hits the awful Nail of Religion absolutely smack-bang on its evil head

  • @CaptainInsano20
    @CaptainInsano20 3 года назад +2

    Look how everyone claps at the end... EXCEPT FOR THE GUY THAT ASKED THE QUESTION!

  • @gorrillion1
    @gorrillion1 5 лет назад +1

    Great answer , great guy , CH is a legend .. part of the reason he is able to win in these situations is that he has truth on his side , combine this truth with his eloquent and witty delivery and you have an unbeatable force

  • @crapmunky99
    @crapmunky99 12 лет назад +6

    "Is there anyone who would like to challenge me?"
    They can try, but they'll never succeed.

  • @elamplough1
    @elamplough1 5 лет назад +4

    One of the best speeches Hitchens ever made.

  • @jimdeighan7078
    @jimdeighan7078 5 лет назад +4

    Amazing, just an absolute pure warrior.

  • @CosmicValkyrie
    @CosmicValkyrie 2 года назад +2

    I like that he asked this question, so i can hear this magnificent answer.

  • @petyrkowalski9887
    @petyrkowalski9887 2 года назад +2

    Bet that smug guy asking the question wasnt expecting such a thorough and cutting answer.

  • @timothyjohn8877
    @timothyjohn8877 3 года назад +6

    I absolutely love Christopher Hitchens.

  • @angrylambie
    @angrylambie Год назад +3

    Just stunning.... i dare any christian to come up with a response that equals it in eloquence or power -

  • @alexbaradoy
    @alexbaradoy Год назад +3

    I can only hope someone near as brilliant will take on the role of champion for reason and fight against the disease of religion.

  • @bentrider
    @bentrider 2 месяца назад +1

    I do not know and I do not care. This has become my mantra of late. Having lived for 70 years on this planet and having been interested and integral in my role as a human, I finally arrived at this place. I was involved and excited about two things early in life. Those two things were politics and religion. Around my forties I dropped out of both. I could see no reason for continuing in them.. After this, I had an epiphany that had been ruminating for decades in my mind. My conclusion was that since no one consulted anyone before being thrown into this thing called life, we could all be considered either prisoners or slaves or both. Therefore, I am not a citizen of any place and I do not care what happens to the human race. I am simply passing the time until the day when I am no more. Some have told me that my outlook is depressing and dismal. On the contrary, I have found it quite liberating. I do not have to wrestle with nor fear anything in this existence. I perceive it all as one would perceive going to the movies. It is simply entertainment.😀

  • @stevechurchouse4670
    @stevechurchouse4670 3 года назад +1

    Of all the clips of this great man this is my favourite. Sums religion up perfectly.

    • @nad1ax2
      @nad1ax2 2 года назад

      My favourite is this video called _’Hitchens on what Theists MUST believe’,_ in it he masterfully dismantles all notions of monotheism with humour and self-evident logic

  • @jerrygarciaisgod4409
    @jerrygarciaisgod4409 2 года назад +5

    If there is no God, why not just stay at home? Because religion interjects itself at every opportunity in life. As long as there are religions civil society needs atheists. If for nothing else, to counteract the evils of theism.

  • @ITYFIGHTERI
    @ITYFIGHTERI 11 лет назад +2

    How did the entire room not give him a standing ovation?? RIP Hitchens.

  • @WarEnsembleIndia
    @WarEnsembleIndia 7 лет назад +3

    i love this guy so much and sadly i only heard of him 1st when i read the news of his death :(

  • @MM-yi9zn
    @MM-yi9zn 2 года назад +1

    There’ll never ever be another Hitchens. His intellect is awesome & not truly understood by most people especially those needing the protection of religion.

  • @kimhansen8615
    @kimhansen8615 3 года назад

    Wow - The ultimate wrap up for the evening. Man, he was truly something special...

  • @crapmunky99
    @crapmunky99 12 лет назад +4

    LOL.
    And then I just imagine him throwing his mic into the audience and yelling "ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED!?"