I’m Orthodox myself. But I didn’t come here to argue with my catholic brethren. I love this guys channel. And I agree with 99% of everything I have heard him say.
@@clouds-rb9xt Speaking as an Orthodox convert of about 5 years, it depends on what Orthodox person you ask. The majority (though there ARE exceptions) acknowledge the Roman Catholic Church as having valid Apostolic Succession and as such the validly of all 7 sacraments. And for the most part accept that miracles occur in the RCC though some will debate some on a case by case basis but not THAT miracles occur. All that to say most acknowledge the RCC as brothers in Christ and that it is a Church rather than a “ecclesiastical community.” Also, Orthodox acknowledge the Bishop of Rome as the legitimate successor of St.Peter, and even his primacy among the Apostles. Of course this primacy is not seen the same way as RCC sees it. (But again as I said, I most certainly didn’t subscribe to argue over our few differences, but because of all that we share in common).
@@chrisnunn7888 Don’t know much about him really. All I know is that he is Orthodox and has a YT channel. I would probably agree with a some things he says (objectively and intellectually speaking) simply because he is Orthodox.) I subscribed to his channel but probably haven’t watched more than 15 min of his content. From the little I have seen I don’t like his style of debate, I think he needs more tact, and to be more charitable in his interactions with others. He also seems to come off as lacking in humility. That said, I see my own lack of charity and humility very clearly and am in no way suggesting I am in any way, shape, or form better than Mr. Dyer or anyone else in these areas, but can only pray, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.”
@athanasiusofalexandria4304 have you ever done any research on the papacy? If the papacy is true, and it is Biblically true, then the Orthodox are in schism.
I am a catholic, and this guy's channel is incredible. It truly describes the what, why, where, and how of Catholicism, in my opinion only, thank you very much.❤❤❤
There are documented Eucharistic miracles in our Church as well. I just mentioned this because you said they are only found in the Catholic Church. (Though you did acknowledge the valid sacraments of we Orthodox.) I found this channel a couple of days ago and have been binge watching. I love it. May God bless you, sir.
Thank you. Yes, Orthodox is valid, so Eucharistic miracles would be expected. When I said only in the Catholic Church I meant in the west, in relation to Protestants
I and many other Catholics will always recognize Orthodox as legitimate brothers and sisters of Christ. The official name of Orthodoxy afterall is, "Orthodox Catholic Church". We are not much different then people like to believe.
We do every Sunday when he is in the form of bread and wine. And other times, of course. But only Catholic and orthodox can bow before him when he is substantially present
I am a subscriber and I enjoy watching your videos. I am also Catholic and a member of the Knights of Columbus at my church. I have mentioned your channel to my family and friends. One of the reasons I watch your videos is because they are the facts and you back it up with scriptures. Can't get any more factual than that. It all makes perfect sense every time. I will continue to watch and spread the word about this channel. Please keep the videos coming. GOD BLESS
Your telling me that I'm actually in a 30% of something? God has granted my prayer of being in the elite in a way I never expected. I truly serve an awesome God who is powerful and loving.
I wonder what all the sedevacantists have to say about The amount of eucharistic miracles that happen in a church that supposedly has a bunch of Invalidly ordained bishops an priests…. +---------+---------+ 🌹“Pray the Rosary every day, in order to obtain Peace in the world..…” ~Our Lady’s Words at Fatima May 13th, 1917🌹 -As always, Repent & believe in the Gospel God Bless! +---------+---------+
@@athanasiusofalexandria4304 You’re asking me the same question that I was asking myself… Also the ISSUE they (Sede’s) propose is also mentioned in my comment so I don’t really understand why your asking me. I hope your not trying to stir the pot and start drama. +---------+---------+ 🌹“Pray the Rosary every day, in order to obtain Peace in the world..…” ~Our Lady’s Words at Fatima May 13th, 1917🌹 -As always, Repent & believe in the Gospel God Bless! +---------+---------+
@@Insightful_Inquiries Man, I don’t know what gave you that idea. Not at all trying to “stir the pot.” just noting that I too wonder about that…sort of saying, “Yeah, that’s a good question. I wonder what the answer is.”
"supposedly has a bunch of Invalidly ordained bishops an priests…" Valid, invalid, what does that matter to the little boys being raped in the back rooms by some pedophile in a dress.?.
I don’t understand why all are not Roman Catholic. We have the one true faith established by Christ Himself. Not one of the over 40,000 Protestant “churches” has the Eucharist . Also every one of them was founded by a man. None of them have a magisterium
@@paulcapaccio9905 dude learn about the church fool. There’s 24 rites in the Catholic Church. The 23 other rites are from the eastern churches. All in communion with the petrine see. That’s the problem with you protys. You don’t know much about the church.
This is a great video, as always. What makes me love our Lord and also makes me sad, is that, all these miracles show the blood and body of Christ when he was at the highest suffering on the cross. Does it mean that Jesus actually took this suffering with him, and is still suffering for us and for ever? I'm so sorry Lord. P.S. Some of these stock videos are so hilarious, especially these "scientists". Not a negative comment, just funny to watch them.. but we get the point.
I personally believe these miracles happen due to eucharistic abuses or lack of belief in the real presence. Our Lord is showing us that we are re crucifying him on the daily and we need to have more respect and reverance for the most holy thing which us his Body and Blood.
There are Eucharistic miracles in Orthodoxy, as well. Also, the Blessed Mother visited the Coptic Orthodox Church of Zeitoun, Egypt, over a period of 3 years, as witnessed by Copts, Muslims, Christians, Atheists, etc., and there were many, many miracles performed over the course of her apparitions atop the Orthodox Coptic Church there.🙂 One can find much on these events on RUclips. 🙂
I'm going to assume that the mass in which the Eucharists in which the miracles took place were consecrated in the Novus ordo. If so, would these Eucharist miracles give validity to that form of the mass?
In 21st century, the Eucharist miracles have been happening in the Novus Ordo Masses. So, to some do not chide the Novus Ordo Mass as it is not deprived of the validation. Yes, Liturgical abuses are arbitrary of the corrupt individual priest or bishop in the Novus Ordo Mass.
Amazing. I don’t understand how my Orthodox brethren can reject the Roman Catholic Church as being without grace or lacking sacramental validity. They’re dead wrong, as this video goes to show.
“The Novus Ordo does not foster a belief in the real presence.” This is just you projecting your preferences. No type of mass is designed to foster belief. They are liturgies that believers attend. Statements like this take the accountability away from people and place it on process. Do we think that if someone who doesn’t believe in the Real Presence goes to a Latin Mass, that they will suddenly believe? That’s the claim you’re making by implying that TLM fosters belief in the Real Presence. Is that what we observe?
how could he say that there were markers of trauma in the chest in a "blood sample"... from the EXAMPLE in Buenos Aires.???? And I am CATHOLIC, and believe in the EUCARIST.. ( is the blood and flesh of Jesus)but I can not accept this observation.
Buenos arires the host became flesh and blood, not just blood. No where on the Buenos Aires story do I say that only the blood was tested. In fact, I make it clear that both were tested: "Permission was given . in 1999, by Archbishop Bergoglio, who authorized Dr. Ricardo Castanon to have the flesh and blood analyzed" "Dr. Castanon found Dr. Fredereic Zugiba of Columbia University in New York, an expert in forensic medicine of the heart. Who received the sample without disclosure of the source." "Professor Zugibe identified the presence of intact white blood cells indicative of a living person. He confirmed that the sample was of the AB blood type that, like at Lanciano, was from the upper left ventricle of the myocardium. He also found markers indicative of trauma in the chest and that the patient could not breathe for lack of oxygen" I honestly dont know where you are getting " blood sample." With buenos aires? I never said that Both flesh and blood was analyzed
@@imisschristendom5293 Hello friend. If the catholic church is gods true church, why do you and every catholic keep trying to prove Christ founded it ? By saying it over and over again a zillion times, which catholics always do, doesnt make it true. Jesus said, ye shall know them by what they say about themselves. Oh, wait, i got that wrong. He said by their fruit. The fruit of the CC, from its inception till today is there for all to see. Just in Illinois in the last few weeks, the numbers of child abuse is staggering. We got 49 most states to go.
Ive heard of eucharistic miracles in the orthodox church and apparitions there as well but nothing from the oriental orthodox or assyrian church of the east. Make me wonder
friend, leave these wacked out religions alone. Jesus is standing at your door and knocking. Open and he will come in and sup with you and you with him. Its true, he does what he says.
@@peterzinya1 lol you think Catholics don't know Yeshua? The most intimate people with God were all catholic saints. Just look up padre Pio for a modern example. You think you can see but you're blind. The Lord founded one church and you're not in it
@@ChrisEAdlay I know about Pio. He bought a powdered acid which he used to make the sore spots on his hands and he used every opportunity to hold them up and show them to his idolatrous flock. Anyone born again will leave what ever religion they are in and gather with other born again folks. So only catholics are intimate with god. Only catholics this and that. Only catholics priests can call god down from heaven. The ONLY reason you believe all that is because the catholic church says so. Tell me friend, do you utilize the "kneelers" that the priest puts in front of the popular graven images so you can kneel befor it in comfort? Another thing only catholics do is bow befor the works of their hands. then they rise up and say all prots are going to hell.
@@peterzinya1your idea of Christianity is a modern concept but you obviously don't care enough to educate yourself on such things. Apparently you are your own authority and interpret the Bible for yourself like a demigod. The LORD rebuke you.
There's this miracle where a heretical priest gave his Eucharist to a priest and to test who was the heretic, there was a boiling pot of water. The heretic's Eucharist dissolved but the priest's Eucharist cooled the water.
a religious sister distributing Holy Communion in Mexico??????? is that right? I find no definite answer. In the Latin Mass, only the priest administers Communion and it does take a while; good, the the Mass is full with young families, teenagers at al The modern mass is a disaster..........don't see families
Catholicism is best described by Mother Mary, other denominations practice the eucharist. What they don't have is Mother Mary & forever virgin assumptions. How can you make a Christian doctrine with no biblical basis? Answer if it's not in the Bible it's not Christianity.
@@Ruudes1483 Trinity_For there are 3 that bear witness 1John 5-7 NKJV, Yes Jesus was fully man & fully God. Scripture alone 100%. If you don't believe in scripture 100%, you will end up believing Man over God. E. G Pope with homo blessing. Who do you believe, Man or God?
@@tknciliba4743 I believe God. I also believe He left us a Church to write, compile, and interpret Scripture and develop doctrine. Matthew 16:17-19. The Bible didn’t have a defined Canon until Councils of Hippo and Carthage in 393 and 397, respectively. The Early Christian writing from before that time are clearly Catholic. Maybe you should check out the writings of the Early Church Fathers like Saint Clement of Rome, who was consecrated by Saint Peter, Saint Ignatius of Antioch, who was a student of Saint John the Apostle, as were Saint Polycarp of Smyrna and Saint Papias of Hierapolis. How would you describe the nature of and relationship between the 3 persons of the Trinity? Also, why did you just break the commandment “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.“ Exodus 20:16
@@Ruudes1483 What Canon are you referring to. Firstly it was the laws of Moses which was the general rule that men can be judged by. Thereafter the New Testament. It must have been this time that your catholic early writers formed Mary & the Saints. Now in 2023 I am still arguing with Catholics on idol worship & praying to Saints. The Early writers did an injustice to Jesus of allowing & subscribing idol worship. Mat 16:17-19 you say develop doctrine. Please send me a verse that says Mary is our intercessor. Sound Doctrine is Biblical right. Did Jesus pray to Mary? I was reading Paul 1Corinthians yesterday & I got so irrate at how Paul lifts up Jesus, but Catholics lift up Mary. Jesus would never ask us to do what He didn't do! Even if you don't answer any thing please answer this for me. Do you, or have you ever prayed to Mary?
@@tknciliba4743 The 73 book Canon, 46 books of the Old Testament and 27 books of the New Testament, as defined by the previously mentioned Councils and reaffirmed at the Council of Trent. Not the castrated Protestant canon based on the anti-Christian Masoretic tradition. We don’t practice idol worship. That’s an old, consistently disproven, anti-Catholic claim that holds no water. In fact, idol worship has been explicitly condemned since the beginning. Can you prove to me, beyond the shadow of a doubt, that Catholics practice idolatry? Can you show me anywhere in official Catholic teachings (the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Magisterial documents, Canon Law, papal bulls, etc.) that allows for idol worship? Did you know that the word “idolatry” come from the words idol and latria? Do you know the difference between “latria” and “dulia”?
Miracles of any kind do NOT prove the Catholic Church is the true Church founded by Jesus. The Catholic Church is THE TRUE Church independent of a Eucharist miracle. Any miracle, especially one’s with Church approval, are for us weak in faith and does not substantiate the truth of the Real Presence Church. Thank you Jesus for the Eucharistic miracles!
Yes, the Catholic faith and the real presence are true. Even if there were no miracles to show it. However, i can't ignore the fact that God has seen fit to prove Catholicism with miracles
I’m Orthodox myself. But I didn’t come here to argue with my catholic brethren. I love this guys channel. And I agree with 99% of everything I have heard him say
orthodoxy's 4 eastern patriarchates are now mu slim cities. Istanbul, Cairo, Jerusalem, and Antioch. All fell within 4 centuries after 1054. Di vine just ice. Current Istanbul population: 15.46 million people. There are only 600 families that are greek orthodox out of that population of 15.46 million. A representation of 0.01%. Di vine just ice. There are 220 million eastern sch is matics worldwide and they're divided into 17 separate churches that h ate each other. The Russian church represents 50% of that total population of different orthodox churches worldwide. The russian church's leader ki rill is putin's b itch. 1.3 billion Catholics and growing. Di vine just ice. C ry h arder. Your s la vic t ears t ast e delicious.
I am unsubscribing from this channel until I learn who runs it. In today's world, preaching error can come from any quarter, however authentic it sounds. Please identify yourself!
Who changed The Ten Commandments in the Catholic Bible to suit your graven images, what about purgatory what a lie from the pit of hell,Jesus paid the price for our sins on the Cross ,Jesus said it is finished, The sinless sacrifice of Jesus was perfectly perfect,once for all. Go read your Bibles,and repent before God and not some sinful man or do you think mere men are sinless,For all have sinned and fall short of the Glory of God, that means all mankind were born in sin! 1Timothy 2v5 ,For there is one God and one mediator between God and men The Man Christ Jesus who gave Himself a ransom for all. What is a mediator! Jesus is our only mediator not Mary nor the dead,nor, the saints,nor the pope,nothing and nobody,only Jesus. Again Read your Bibles.Please note there are no Catholics,or Protestants, Baptists etc.in Heaven only those who are redeemed by His death and resurrection you where bought at a great price The Precious Blood of Jesus poured out for you on The Cross,it’s not about stupid religion it’s about a relationship with Jesus and His finished work,Do you know Him? Jesus was a Jew! Not a catholic etc. Time to wake up.
All of these arguments are generic. One read the catechism the church never changed the commandments. They also weren't numbered in the original Hebrew. Read Commandment 1 in the catechism section on the 10 Commandments. Also, read the OT the temples had icons and art. 2 Timothy 2:5 doesn't condemn intercession. Mediator is a salvific term, read the following verse. It has nothing to do with intercession. The saints aren't dead nor is Mary (Mark 12) if you are going to claim that only Christ interceded for us by committing an equivocation fallacy then be my guest. However, your one standard means 2 Timothy 2:1 is false and we can't ask others to pray for us. Prayer is simply defined as to ask of or request. These are offered to God by others not granted by them.( Revelation 5:8, 8) Study doctrine before commenting. The idea of it isn't about religion is a silly notion. Scripture titles us a religion in Paul's epistles. God Bless You.
So funny when Christians quote from John even though it was written like a hundred years after the cult began. It’s not a reliable source. John is just a rewrite of Luke. Luke is just a rewrite of Matthew. Matthew is just a rewrite of Mark. Mark is symbolic fiction about Jesus. The Eucharist was also practiced by the Osiris Mystery Cult a century before Christianity. Much Ado About Nothing.
Even the most liberal/atheistic scholars place the writing of John at about 80-90AD... which would be 50-60 years after the foundation of the Church, not 'like a hundred' 😅 Not sure I want to dignify the rest of your post with a meaningful response.
@@danceswithbears2521 The anonymous authors of John say their “source” was Lazarus-a fictional person Jesus spoke about in a parable, according to the author of Luke, who was probably making that up.
You Catholics STILL get it wrong even when you try to justify yourselves. Anything that proves anything is Gods. Miracles do NOT prove your religions nor your rituals nor ANYTHING to do with YOU. Its all HIM. Bow before Jesus.
Says those who have no documented miracles to prove thier theology What is God proving here? That the bread and wine become the flesh and blood of Christ in the Catholic church. Just like we say it does. We bow before Christ every Sunday when he is substantially present in the Eucharist. You can't do that unless your Catholic or Orthodox
Friend, only catholics believe all this miracle business. They take this craker, put it in a golden sun symbol, then worship it, their sun God from Babylon. Then they rise and get on their knees befor the mother child Semiramis graven image all the while saying protestants are going to hell for not bowing to their sun god.
@@imisschristendom5293 I realize this comment is 3 months old, but I couldn't not say something here after reading. I've been trying to figure out for the last year or so what's going on between Catholicism and Protestantism. And every time I read stuff like this, it gets harder for me. "Says those who have no documented miracles to prove their theology"? What kind of way to speak to a fellow believer is that? A couple more things. First, you shouldn't need a miracle from 2006 to prove your theology. Catholic beliefs were around for a long time before 2006. Second, who is to say what a particular miracle proves? The Catholic claim is that the bread and wine become Jesus's body and blood WITHOUT a visible change, so why would a supposed miracle where actual blood appears prove that? Third and most importantly, a Christian of ANY flavor has tons of very well documented miracles to provide evidence for their beliefs, as long as those beliefs are biblical. Healing the blind, turning water into wine, feeding the 5000, and most importantly the resurrection.
To Protestants and bad Catholics, they can deny the Real Presence of Jesus in Holy Eucharist, but can they expell Jesus from the Blessed Sacrament? If they can't, then they are believing in delusion.
I’m Orthodox myself. But I didn’t come here to argue with my catholic brethren. I love this guys channel. And I agree with 99% of everything I have heard him say.
Glad to have you
How do Orthodox view Catholic miracle claims (and vice versa, how do Catholics view Orthodox Miracle claims)
@@clouds-rb9xt Speaking as an Orthodox convert of about 5 years, it depends on what Orthodox person you ask. The majority (though there ARE exceptions) acknowledge the Roman Catholic Church as having valid Apostolic Succession and as such the validly of all 7 sacraments. And for the most part accept that miracles occur in the RCC though some will debate some on a case by case basis but not THAT miracles occur. All that to say most acknowledge the RCC as brothers in Christ and that it is a Church rather than a “ecclesiastical community.” Also, Orthodox acknowledge the Bishop of Rome as the legitimate successor of St.Peter, and even his primacy among the Apostles. Of course this primacy is not seen the same way as RCC sees it. (But again as I said, I most certainly didn’t subscribe to argue over our few differences, but because of all that we share in common).
@@chrisnunn7888 Don’t know much about him really. All I know is that he is Orthodox and has a YT channel. I would probably agree with a some things he says (objectively and intellectually speaking) simply because he is Orthodox.) I subscribed to his channel but probably haven’t watched more than 15 min of his content. From the little I have seen I don’t like his style of debate, I think he needs more tact, and to be more charitable in his interactions with others. He also seems to come off as lacking in humility. That said, I see my own lack of charity and humility very clearly and am in no way suggesting I am in any way, shape, or form better than Mr. Dyer or anyone else in these areas, but can only pray, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.”
@athanasiusofalexandria4304 have you ever done any research on the papacy? If the papacy is true, and it is Biblically true, then the Orthodox are in schism.
I'm a simple man. I see I Miss Christendom posts a new video and I click.
Good man!
in nomine patris et filii et spiritus sancti. Amen.
✝🇻🇦✝🇻🇦✝
How blessed we are to have this in our Church.
I am a catholic, and this guy's channel is incredible. It truly describes the what, why, where, and how of Catholicism, in my opinion only, thank you very much.❤❤❤
Every Mass has a Eucharistic Miracle performed during it. Each and every one.
There are documented Eucharistic miracles in our Church as well. I just mentioned this because you said they are only found in the Catholic Church. (Though you did acknowledge the valid sacraments of we Orthodox.) I found this channel a couple of days ago and have been binge watching. I love it. May God bless you, sir.
Thank you. Yes, Orthodox is valid, so Eucharistic miracles would be expected.
When I said only in the Catholic Church I meant in the west, in relation to Protestants
I and many other Catholics will always recognize Orthodox as legitimate brothers and sisters of Christ. The official name of Orthodoxy afterall is, "Orthodox Catholic Church". We are not much different then people like to believe.
Miracles do NOT prove any religion. Miracles belong to HIM. Miracles are GOD'S. Deal with it and bow before Jesus.
We do every Sunday when he is in the form of bread and wine. And other times, of course. But only Catholic and orthodox can bow before him when he is substantially present
Say the people who dont have documented miracles
Your my favorite Catholic RUclipsr. You bring glory to god. Keep up the good work.
If you deny the real presence of the Eucharist, then you deny Christ.
I am a subscriber and I enjoy watching your videos. I am also Catholic and a member of the Knights of Columbus at my church. I have mentioned your channel to my family and friends. One of the reasons I watch your videos is because they are the facts and you back it up with scriptures. Can't get any more factual than that. It all makes perfect sense every time. I will continue to watch and spread the word about this channel. Please keep the videos coming. GOD BLESS
Thank you very much
Great video. I am so glad you referenced Ricardo Castañón. For those who understand Spanish, I highly recommend his videos.
Interesting on those who doubted it, and walked with Him no more were
John 6:66
Great video, im always watching for a new one.
Your videos are really good. Surprised you don’t have more subscribers. God bless!
Great explanation may the lord bless us all🙏🏽
You're awesome bro. Keep it coming
Your telling me that I'm actually in a 30% of something? God has granted my prayer of being in the elite in a way I never expected. I truly serve an awesome God who is powerful and loving.
Gospodin Podmiliu!--from the Ukrainian Orthodox C
Great point regarding Novus Ordo!
I’m interested in people themselves experiencing miraculous actions from the communion , and less so about physical blood - what does it do thru us?
A very interesting presentation. Thank you.
I wonder what all the sedevacantists have to say about The amount of eucharistic miracles that happen in a church that supposedly has a bunch of Invalidly ordained bishops an priests….
+---------+---------+
🌹“Pray the Rosary every day, in order to obtain Peace in the world..…”
~Our Lady’s Words at Fatima
May 13th, 1917🌹
-As always,
Repent & believe in the Gospel
God Bless!
+---------+---------+
This is an interesting question…what DO they say?
@@athanasiusofalexandria4304 You’re asking me the same question that I was asking myself… Also the ISSUE they (Sede’s) propose is also mentioned in my comment so I don’t really understand why your asking me.
I hope your not trying to stir the pot and start drama.
+---------+---------+
🌹“Pray the Rosary every day, in order to obtain Peace in the world..…”
~Our Lady’s Words at Fatima
May 13th, 1917🌹
-As always,
Repent & believe in the Gospel
God Bless!
+---------+---------+
Ouch😂
@@Insightful_Inquiries Man, I don’t know what gave you that idea. Not at all trying to “stir the pot.” just noting that I too wonder about that…sort of saying, “Yeah, that’s a good question. I wonder what the answer is.”
"supposedly has a bunch of Invalidly ordained bishops an priests…"
Valid, invalid, what does that matter to the little boys being raped in the back rooms by some pedophile in a dress.?.
Jesus, Mary & Joseph, I love you. Save souls.
That footage of the host was so powerful I can't
Its the heart of our lord 😢
@@GodsDumbLamb Glorious.
The Shroud of Turin also proves Catholicism.
Jesus could return today and they still wouldn't believe in him or his miracles, humanity in general has not changed.
I don’t understand why all are not Roman Catholic. We have the one true faith established by Christ Himself. Not one of the over 40,000 Protestant “churches” has the Eucharist . Also every one of them was founded by a man. None of them have a magisterium
Please say "Catholic" that's the official name of the Catholic church.
Roman Catholic is an heretical protestant term for the one true faith.
@wolfthequarrelsome504 Roman is a rite one in 24 in communion with the Petrine see.
@@franciscoguzman1065 says who ????
@@paulcapaccio9905 dude learn about the church fool. There’s 24 rites in the Catholic Church. The 23 other rites are from the eastern churches. All in communion with the petrine see. That’s the problem with you protys. You don’t know much about the church.
Says the Catholic Church.
This is a great video, as always.
What makes me love our Lord and also makes me sad, is that, all these miracles show the blood and body of Christ when he was at the highest suffering on the cross. Does it mean that Jesus actually took this suffering with him, and is still suffering for us and for ever? I'm so sorry Lord.
P.S. Some of these stock videos are so hilarious, especially these "scientists". Not a negative comment, just funny to watch them.. but we get the point.
Any recommendations regarding a current book about this phenomenon? Thank you.
9:09 it looks like the sacred heart
Do the miracles of the Holy Eucharist happen mostly on novus ordo churches?
I love this video, but please work on your Polish pronunciation.
I personally believe these miracles happen due to eucharistic abuses or lack of belief in the real presence. Our Lord is showing us that we are re crucifying him on the daily and we need to have more respect and reverance for the most holy thing which us his Body and Blood.
You have those St Ignatius letters dated a little too early. More like 110 AD.
The problem is getting people to care
"Apathy is death. No, worse than death. Because at least a rotting corpse feeds the beasts and insects."
Yes. The lukewarm and indifferent.
No. The problem is your heart. Miracles do NOT prove ANY religion. They are GODs and GODS alone. Bow before Christ.
@@undignified2843 since Jesus did miracles I guess Christianity is a false religion.
There are Eucharistic miracles in Orthodoxy, as well. Also, the Blessed Mother visited the Coptic Orthodox Church of Zeitoun, Egypt, over a period of 3 years, as witnessed by Copts, Muslims, Christians, Atheists, etc., and there were many, many miracles performed over the course of her apparitions atop the Orthodox Coptic Church there.🙂 One can find much on these events on RUclips. 🙂
I dont doubt any of that. They have a valid priesthood, Eucharist, and other sacrements. And venerate our lady so, yeah
So is it ok that the blood is pre resurrection. ?
I'm going to assume that the mass in which the Eucharists in which the miracles took place were consecrated in the Novus ordo. If so, would these Eucharist miracles give validity to that form of the mass?
In 21st century, the Eucharist miracles have been happening in the Novus Ordo Masses. So, to some do not chide the Novus Ordo Mass as it is not deprived of the validation. Yes, Liturgical abuses are arbitrary of the corrupt individual priest or bishop in the Novus Ordo Mass.
Amazing. I don’t understand how my Orthodox brethren can reject the Roman Catholic Church as being without grace or lacking sacramental validity. They’re dead wrong, as this video goes to show.
“The Novus Ordo does not foster a belief in the real presence.”
This is just you projecting your preferences. No type of mass is designed to foster belief. They are liturgies that believers attend. Statements like this take the accountability away from people and place it on process.
Do we think that if someone who doesn’t believe in the Real Presence goes to a Latin Mass, that they will suddenly believe? That’s the claim you’re making by implying that TLM fosters belief in the Real Presence. Is that what we observe?
The Novus Ordo, if it's a good one, will place great emphasis on the Host, highlighting the truth of the real presence.
how could he say that there were markers of trauma in the chest in a "blood sample"... from the EXAMPLE in Buenos Aires.???? And I am CATHOLIC, and believe in the EUCARIST.. ( is the blood and flesh of Jesus)but I can not accept this observation.
Buenos arires the host became flesh and blood, not just blood.
No where on the Buenos Aires story do I say that only the blood was tested. In fact, I make it clear that both were tested:
"Permission was given . in 1999, by Archbishop Bergoglio, who authorized Dr. Ricardo Castanon to have the flesh and blood analyzed"
"Dr. Castanon found Dr. Fredereic Zugiba of Columbia University in New York, an expert in forensic medicine of the heart. Who received the sample without disclosure of the source."
"Professor Zugibe identified the presence of intact white blood cells indicative of a living person. He confirmed that the sample was of the AB blood type that, like at Lanciano, was from the upper left ventricle of the myocardium. He also found markers indicative of trauma in the chest and that the patient could not breathe for lack of oxygen"
I honestly dont know where you are getting
" blood sample."
With buenos aires?
I never said that
Both flesh and blood was analyzed
@@imisschristendom5293 Hello friend. If the catholic church is gods true church, why do you and every catholic keep trying to prove Christ founded it ? By saying it over and over again a zillion times, which catholics always do, doesnt make it true. Jesus said, ye shall know them by what they say about themselves. Oh, wait, i got that wrong. He said by their fruit. The fruit of the CC, from its inception till today is there for all to see. Just in Illinois in the last few weeks, the numbers of child abuse is staggering. We got 49 most states to go.
Ive heard of eucharistic miracles in the orthodox church and apparitions there as well but nothing from the oriental orthodox or assyrian church of the east. Make me wonder
friend, leave these wacked out religions alone. Jesus is standing at your door and knocking. Open and he will come in and sup with you and you with him. Its true, he does what he says.
@@peterzinya1 lol you think Catholics don't know Yeshua? The most intimate people with God were all catholic saints. Just look up padre Pio for a modern example. You think you can see but you're blind. The Lord founded one church and you're not in it
@@ChrisEAdlay I know about Pio. He bought a powdered acid which he used to make the sore spots on his hands and he used every opportunity to hold them up and show them to his idolatrous flock.
Anyone born again will leave what ever religion they are in and gather with other born again folks.
So only catholics are intimate with god. Only catholics this and that. Only catholics priests can call god down from heaven. The ONLY reason you believe all that is because the catholic church says so.
Tell me friend, do you utilize the "kneelers" that the priest puts in front of the popular graven images so you can kneel befor it in comfort? Another thing only catholics do is bow befor the works of their hands. then they rise up and say all prots are going to hell.
@@peterzinya1your idea of Christianity is a modern concept but you obviously don't care enough to educate yourself on such things. Apparently you are your own authority and interpret the Bible for yourself like a demigod. The LORD rebuke you.
There's this miracle where a heretical priest gave his Eucharist to a priest and to test who was the heretic, there was a boiling pot of water. The heretic's Eucharist dissolved but the priest's Eucharist cooled the water.
Why did he have a video camera in the church though? And what’s behind the WALL on which it was MOUNTED? it’s not free standing in a monstrance is it?
Do the Eucharistic miracles take place only in Latin mass? Or sometimes in Novus ordo mass?
Both. A Eucharistic miracle occurring after 1970 probably happened at a NO mass.
As I said in the video, all the modern miracles happened in the novus ordo
a religious sister distributing Holy Communion in Mexico???????
is that right? I find no definite answer.
In the Latin Mass, only the priest administers Communion and it does take a while;
good, the the Mass is full with young families, teenagers at al
The modern mass is a disaster..........don't see families
Those two polish scientists are a fishy bunch they never published any data and when i emailed them for picture i got no response
Real miracles, but the Novus Ordo is invalid!
Catholicism is best described by Mother Mary, other denominations practice the eucharist.
What they don't have is Mother Mary & forever virgin assumptions.
How can you make a Christian doctrine with no biblical basis?
Answer if it's not in the Bible it's not Christianity.
Does that mean the Trinity isn’t Christian? What about the Hypostatic Union? Sola Scriptura? Sola Fide?
@@Ruudes1483 Trinity_For there are 3 that bear witness 1John 5-7 NKJV, Yes Jesus was fully man & fully God. Scripture alone 100%.
If you don't believe in scripture 100%, you will end up believing Man over God. E. G Pope with homo blessing.
Who do you believe, Man or God?
@@tknciliba4743 I believe God. I also believe He left us a Church to write, compile, and interpret Scripture and develop doctrine. Matthew 16:17-19.
The Bible didn’t have a defined Canon until Councils of Hippo and Carthage in 393 and 397, respectively. The Early Christian writing from before that time are clearly Catholic. Maybe you should check out the writings of the Early Church Fathers like Saint Clement of Rome, who was consecrated by Saint Peter, Saint Ignatius of Antioch, who was a student of Saint John the Apostle, as were Saint Polycarp of Smyrna and Saint Papias of Hierapolis.
How would you describe the nature of and relationship between the 3 persons of the Trinity?
Also, why did you just break the commandment “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.“
Exodus 20:16
@@Ruudes1483 What Canon are you referring to. Firstly it was the laws of Moses which was the general rule that men can be judged by. Thereafter the New Testament.
It must have been this time that your catholic early writers formed Mary & the Saints.
Now in 2023 I am still arguing with Catholics on idol worship & praying to Saints.
The Early writers did an injustice to Jesus of allowing & subscribing idol worship.
Mat 16:17-19 you say develop doctrine.
Please send me a verse that says Mary is our intercessor.
Sound Doctrine is Biblical right.
Did Jesus pray to Mary?
I was reading Paul 1Corinthians yesterday & I got so irrate at how Paul lifts up Jesus, but Catholics lift up Mary.
Jesus would never ask us to do what He didn't do!
Even if you don't answer any thing please answer this for me.
Do you, or have you ever prayed to Mary?
@@tknciliba4743 The 73 book Canon, 46 books of the Old Testament and 27 books of the New Testament, as defined by the previously mentioned Councils and reaffirmed at the Council of Trent. Not the castrated Protestant canon based on the anti-Christian Masoretic tradition.
We don’t practice idol worship. That’s an old, consistently disproven, anti-Catholic claim that holds no water. In fact, idol worship has been explicitly condemned since the beginning. Can you prove to me, beyond the shadow of a doubt, that Catholics practice idolatry? Can you show me anywhere in official Catholic teachings (the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Magisterial documents, Canon Law, papal bulls, etc.) that allows for idol worship? Did you know that the word “idolatry” come from the words idol and latria? Do you know the difference between “latria” and “dulia”?
Miracles of any kind do NOT prove the Catholic Church is the true Church founded by Jesus. The Catholic Church is THE TRUE Church independent of a Eucharist miracle. Any miracle, especially one’s with Church approval, are for us weak in faith and does not substantiate the truth of the Real Presence Church. Thank you Jesus for the Eucharistic miracles!
Yes, the Catholic faith and the real presence are true. Even if there were no miracles to show it.
However, i can't ignore the fact that God has seen fit to prove Catholicism with miracles
First
Orthodox Church is the true church ☦️
I’m Orthodox myself. But I didn’t come here to argue with my catholic brethren. I love this guys channel. And I agree with 99% of everything I have heard him say
@@athanasiusofalexandria4304 I agree, this channel is quite good
orthodoxy's 4 eastern patriarchates are now mu slim cities. Istanbul, Cairo, Jerusalem, and Antioch. All fell within 4 centuries after 1054. Di vine just ice.
Current Istanbul population: 15.46 million people. There are only 600 families that are greek orthodox out of that population of 15.46 million. A representation of 0.01%. Di vine just ice.
There are 220 million eastern sch is matics worldwide and they're divided into 17 separate churches that h ate each other. The Russian church represents 50% of that total population of different orthodox churches worldwide. The russian church's leader ki rill is putin's b itch. 1.3 billion Catholics and growing. Di vine just ice.
C ry h arder. Your s la vic t ears t ast e delicious.
There have been miracles in the name of the Orthodox, Catholic, and Protestant...
@yoofij4724 plzzzz Protestants have no valid orders and most don’t believe in the presence alone.
I am unsubscribing from this channel until I learn who runs it. In today's world, preaching error can come from any quarter, however authentic it sounds. Please identify yourself!
I believe he has recently posted a video revealing his face, where he talks about going on vacation on a cruise.
Who changed The Ten Commandments in the Catholic Bible to suit your graven images, what about purgatory what a lie from the pit of hell,Jesus paid the price for our sins on the Cross ,Jesus said it is finished, The sinless sacrifice of Jesus was perfectly perfect,once for all. Go read your Bibles,and repent before God and not some sinful man or do you think mere men are sinless,For all have sinned and fall short of the Glory of God, that means all mankind were born in sin! 1Timothy 2v5 ,For there is one God and one mediator between God and men The Man Christ Jesus who gave Himself a ransom for all. What is a mediator! Jesus is our only mediator not Mary nor the dead,nor, the saints,nor the pope,nothing and nobody,only Jesus. Again Read your Bibles.Please note there are no Catholics,or Protestants, Baptists etc.in Heaven only those who are redeemed by His death and resurrection you where bought at a great price The Precious Blood of Jesus poured out for you on The Cross,it’s not about stupid religion it’s about a relationship with Jesus and His finished work,Do you know Him? Jesus was a Jew! Not a catholic etc. Time to wake up.
All of these arguments are generic. One read the catechism the church never changed the commandments. They also weren't numbered in the original Hebrew. Read Commandment 1 in the catechism section on the 10 Commandments. Also, read the OT the temples had icons and art. 2 Timothy 2:5 doesn't condemn intercession. Mediator is a salvific term, read the following verse. It has nothing to do with intercession. The saints aren't dead nor is Mary (Mark 12) if you are going to claim that only Christ interceded for us by committing an equivocation fallacy then be my guest. However, your one standard means 2 Timothy 2:1 is false and we can't ask others to pray for us. Prayer is simply defined as to ask of or request. These are offered to God by others not granted by them.( Revelation 5:8, 8) Study doctrine before commenting. The idea of it isn't about religion is a silly notion. Scripture titles us a religion in Paul's epistles. God Bless You.
So funny when Christians quote from John even though it was written like a hundred years after the cult began.
It’s not a reliable source.
John is just a rewrite of Luke.
Luke is just a rewrite of Matthew.
Matthew is just a rewrite of Mark.
Mark is symbolic fiction about Jesus.
The Eucharist was also practiced by the Osiris Mystery Cult a century before Christianity.
Much Ado About Nothing.
Even the most liberal/atheistic scholars place the writing of John at about 80-90AD... which would be 50-60 years after the foundation of the Church, not 'like a hundred' 😅
Not sure I want to dignify the rest of your post with a meaningful response.
Mathew is the first gospel, Clemens of Alexandria, nobody cares what you satanic blind fools think
@@skippy8696 This! I came here to say this. Now there is no need.
No, John is not a synoptic Gospel.
@@danceswithbears2521
The anonymous authors of John say their “source” was Lazarus-a fictional person Jesus spoke about in a parable, according to the author of Luke, who was probably making that up.
You Catholics STILL get it wrong even when you try to justify yourselves. Anything that proves anything is Gods. Miracles do NOT prove your religions nor your rituals nor ANYTHING to do with YOU. Its all HIM. Bow before Jesus.
We feel so sorry for you
Says those who have no documented miracles to prove thier theology
What is God proving here?
That the bread and wine become the flesh and blood of Christ in the Catholic church. Just like we say it does.
We bow before Christ every Sunday when he is substantially present in the Eucharist. You can't do that unless your Catholic or Orthodox
Friend, only catholics believe all this miracle business. They take this craker, put it in a golden sun symbol, then worship it, their sun God from Babylon. Then they rise and get on their knees befor the mother child Semiramis graven image all the while saying protestants are going to hell for not bowing to their sun god.
@@peterzinya1Enjoy your life here tic. He ll a waits.
@@imisschristendom5293 I realize this comment is 3 months old, but I couldn't not say something here after reading.
I've been trying to figure out for the last year or so what's going on between Catholicism and Protestantism. And every time I read stuff like this, it gets harder for me. "Says those who have no documented miracles to prove their theology"? What kind of way to speak to a fellow believer is that?
A couple more things. First, you shouldn't need a miracle from 2006 to prove your theology. Catholic beliefs were around for a long time before 2006. Second, who is to say what a particular miracle proves? The Catholic claim is that the bread and wine become Jesus's body and blood WITHOUT a visible change, so why would a supposed miracle where actual blood appears prove that? Third and most importantly, a Christian of ANY flavor has tons of very well documented miracles to provide evidence for their beliefs, as long as those beliefs are biblical. Healing the blind, turning water into wine, feeding the 5000, and most importantly the resurrection.
To Protestants and bad Catholics, they can deny the Real Presence of Jesus in Holy Eucharist, but can they expell Jesus from the Blessed Sacrament? If they can't, then they are believing in delusion.
These miracles pertain to the true Catholic Church,there are no such things attributed to the novus ordo church.