Bloc Party- Four ALBUM REVIEW

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 571

  • @dissonancecognitive1
    @dissonancecognitive1 10 лет назад +251

    nice touch with "Turn on the Bright Lights" in the background. Another band haunted by it's debut release.

    • @sisterraysson
      @sisterraysson 8 лет назад +30

      +discojack antics was good

    • @Emme-Kappa
      @Emme-Kappa 8 лет назад +19

      +Dick Dickingson so was our love to admire imho

    • @johnwhyte9088
      @johnwhyte9088 8 лет назад +6

      +Dick Dickingson loved antics very short concise affair

    • @dissonancecognitive1
      @dissonancecognitive1 8 лет назад +18

      indeed, antics was a good album, as was "a weekend in the city". Just noting that everything these bands put out is consistently compared to their initial breakout releases (Silent Alarms and Turn on the Bright Lights).

    • @sisterraysson
      @sisterraysson 8 лет назад

      tru tru

  • @gungrave515
    @gungrave515 10 лет назад +92

    i absolutely loved silent alarm, i was just getting into indie and heavy into british music and it defined me for like a year.
    their second album while it was considered meh at the time, looking back i actually really dig it. i see why it was criticized but its a solid second album.
    third album at first listen was so cool, back to fast hard and tight but with a weird electronic twist, and then i realized like 2 weeks later i wasnt listening to it anymore.
    i never gave 4 a chance, which is sad to me. i think bloc parties weird problem is like... they know theyre good and they see some weird alternate future where they could still be around and relevant 15 years later like radiohead or flaming lips or some shit. however, because they "know" their future they try to skip ahead and make the music the bloc party of 15 years from now is making instead of letting their current music get their on its own. and it sounds like once again this is their same problem. i guess ill give it a try.

  • @Emme-Kappa
    @Emme-Kappa 8 лет назад +161

    I actually like A weekend in the city very much... it's a very intimate album

    • @LUFC-yl2cd
      @LUFC-yl2cd 5 лет назад +16

      Emme It is extremely underrated

    • @syfo3-186
      @syfo3-186 5 лет назад

      nope it’s shit

    • @liamrobinson5303
      @liamrobinson5303 4 года назад +3

      wetissue 3 that’s your opinion bro

    • @michaelgraham9774
      @michaelgraham9774 4 года назад +5

      @@syfo3-186 You have the wrong opinion

    • @ryclemo4942
      @ryclemo4942 Год назад +1

      Does that mean Intimacy is a very Four album

  • @abbreviateddisc
    @abbreviateddisc 9 лет назад +80

    I thought V.A.L.I.S was a great track. Honestly Four was probably their best album since Silent Alarm, I wish they had stuck with the sound they had on this album because their new single is shit.

    • @TheStarfox187
      @TheStarfox187 8 лет назад +3

      Agreed

    • @spoonnoise8332
      @spoonnoise8332 4 года назад +7

      Matthew Forbes I’d rather have bands experiment and suck than sticking to a sound and be boring. The thing is that you don’t know if the band is gonna do well sticking to their sound, so might as well experiment. An example of this are The Fratellis and Catfish and the Bottlemen, people loathe them because their music sounds the same to their first releases and well you also have bands like AC/DC, Motörhead and Slayer that never changed their sound much which to me all their music unappealing

  • @artvjon
    @artvjon 12 лет назад +29

    Had this downloaded,hadn't listened yet. Now,I'm def gonna give it a listen right now

  • @MaxBrilhart
    @MaxBrilhart 11 лет назад +21

    Do I see "Turn On The Bright Lights" in the background? Such a great album! Roland is one of my favorite tracks ever and it is AMAZING live!

  • @angeljefferson1435
    @angeljefferson1435 9 лет назад +40

    Intimacy and Weekend in the City are life thooo

    • @TC-lk2ev
      @TC-lk2ev 4 года назад +2

      Intimacy is so damn good. It's a shame everyone hated it. I think it's basically what broke the band up.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +15

    it was difficult talking about this album for less than 10 minutes just because to explain it accurately is to describe the separate little nooks and crannies that exist within it.

  • @JMlynek99
    @JMlynek99 10 лет назад +26

    I was really surprised you didn't comment on the bonus tracks, two great songs!

  • @TheTarkAttack
    @TheTarkAttack 11 лет назад +19

    Great review. I think bloc party are absolutely amazing, ignoring any integrity. They have created some of the most personally adaptive music I've ever come across. I don't care where they take me I'm already a part of their journey and will never leave. No matter what happens ill always have silent alarm, it is eternal.

  • @butterfingersman
    @butterfingersman Год назад +3

    so true, bloc party forever! we should get a classic week sometime on silent alarm. i felt like id been living under a rock, i loved helicopter but never checked out the full album and its so damn good. literally was listening to bloc party's new album before ever hearing silent alarm lmfao

  • @imstillwaitin
    @imstillwaitin 11 лет назад +25

    My ranking goes:
    1. Silent Alarm
    2. Four
    3. Weekend in the City
    4. Intimacy

    • @clawn6ify
      @clawn6ify 7 лет назад +1

      Gregory Lyell nah I prefer intimacy over weekend in the city

    • @fordprefect1925
      @fordprefect1925 6 лет назад +1

      clawn6ify prefer intimacy over four

    • @thisisnotacompetition
      @thisisnotacompetition 4 года назад

      I prefer intimacy over all of it

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +1

    Thanks for being nice to that mean guy. It's always great to be nice in the face of nastiness. Anyway, not much of a Green Day fan these days, honestly. I don't think I'll be covering their new singles or album. It's just not something I feel is relevant to the channel. I know you may disagree, but I have to personally guide where I think things need to go, ya know? Make calls and all that.

  • @zacroper3577
    @zacroper3577 5 лет назад +3

    This has to be one of the best reviews from Melon. Really well structured and extremely clear.

  • @TNTIV
    @TNTIV 10 лет назад +43

    3X3 was kickass. lol.

    • @TheStarfox187
      @TheStarfox187 8 лет назад +1

      Surprised "he begins to lie" wasn't on this

    • @TheStarfox187
      @TheStarfox187 8 лет назад

      I mean like he didn't like that track

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +11

    i wake up at night in cold sweats with this very same fear.

  • @Guidonator181
    @Guidonator181 10 лет назад +16

    Am I the only one that thinks that Flux is easily their most radio-friendly song?

  • @xxInfectionx
    @xxInfectionx 12 лет назад +2

    I feel about this like every other bloc party album.
    It has some songs that really do nothing for me and then some songs that blow my mind and make me think how the hell did they come up with this this is genius.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +1

    never been huge on mndr, but i still have to try that one.

  • @crazygamer8
    @crazygamer8 12 лет назад +1

    I've only ever listened to Helicopter, which is one of my top played tracks on my ipod. I think its time I give these guys a listen, I more or less owe that to them.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +1

    he luvs u 2

  • @tylerjohnsmith
    @tylerjohnsmith 12 лет назад

    Thanks Anthony. Thanks Cal. What did I think? Honestly, what I thought as I selected and then returned the album to the shelf at Amoeba today was 'Let's see what theneedledrop has to say about it on that days-old video sitting in my inbox'. Also, enjoyed the wonky/glitchy screen over by Cal

  • @TokunboAdegbuyi
    @TokunboAdegbuyi 11 лет назад +5

    Am I the only one that really likes Coliseum hahaha

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    agreed.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    i agree...but also think other things are involved, too.

  • @Beatebaan
    @Beatebaan 12 лет назад +1

    If there's something really powerful about Bloc Party, its their first songs. Like Eating Glass, Song for Clay, Ares and here So He Begins to Lie are A-MA-ZING.

  • @dtanobo
    @dtanobo 12 лет назад +4

    After listening to four a LOT more times. It's actually really amazing. It takes a some getting used to but with tracks like Truth, Day Four, Octopus, V.A.L.I.S, Mean and Real Talk, it's awesome as hell. But there are some tracks that are a bit of a miss. Coliseum and We are not good people are not great. Still a great album. Not as good as Silent Alarm and A Weekend in the City but fucking brilliant

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    thanks for the comment. :-)

  • @Josabeech
    @Josabeech 12 лет назад +1

    I've been a huge BP fan for years - you've completely hit the nail on the head with the review mate, especially the first half about the history of the band, I think their journey is so unique. Only thing I'd disagree with is your bit about Coliseum, from what I can gather, it's sort of an anti-bloodsport song so they're trying to musically emulate the chaos of a fight (again, experimenting like you said). That's my thought anyway, your review is brilliant, definite like and subscribe :)

  • @jamesharcourt6025
    @jamesharcourt6025 11 лет назад +6

    Oh - and ... review the nextwave sessions please!

  • @petsch6787
    @petsch6787 2 года назад +2

    I love this album, hated Hymns after this, but Alpha Games just came out recently, and Fantano hates it but I actually think it's pretty decent.

  • @lookintothesun007
    @lookintothesun007 12 лет назад

    Hey,Anthony,huge fan,agree,strongly agree.Do you think this is Bloc Party's best Album since their Debut? Although it's been out there for awhile you could do a track review of "Runaways" from The Killers,new upcoming album,any predicitons for that band,who are also returning from a hiatus.Look forward to you reviewing that album,if you should choose to do so, when it drops next month.

  • @PortillaJ22
    @PortillaJ22 12 лет назад +1

    Not gonna lie, I've been a Bloc Party fanboy since like, 2007/2008-ish, so when I heard that "Four" had finally dropped, I pretty much pissed myself.
    I thought it was a great album; while it's not coherent as a whole, I never really thought of their albums as "whole beings" to begin with, which is why I sort of didn't care about it. I felt like they took the best ideas and concepts from their previous albums, and put it all together to make "Four", so I guess you can say I agree with this video.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    thinking about this one.

  • @thtdudewiththehair
    @thtdudewiththehair 12 лет назад +1

    I've liked all their albums pretty much equally. I haven't picked this one up yet though. I find that every album has about three or four real stand-out songs and then a lot of consistent decent songs.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    thanks for the comment and the kind words! :-)

  • @TheZatrahc
    @TheZatrahc 12 лет назад +2

    I saw them live a week or two before the LP came out. Honestly, it REALLY sold me on this thing. They played a lot of songs from it, and even opened up with two songs (3x3 and Kettling) from it. Seeing it live really does a lot for the album's integrity. You can tell they're really proud of this, even if they did decide that Colosseum is a good song. It's not, but hey. They tried.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад +2

    i think i'm just gonna wait for the album to come out, but i did like the track.

  • @G00N3R100
    @G00N3R100 6 лет назад +13

    1. Silent alarm
    2. Intimacy
    3. Weekend in the City
    4. Four
    5. Hymns

    • @Ptolomey
      @Ptolomey 5 лет назад +4

      1. Silent alarm
      2. Four
      3. Intimacy
      4. A weekend in the city
      5. Hymns

    • @raynebirkin6726
      @raynebirkin6726 4 года назад +1

      1.Four
      2.Silent Alarm
      Haven’t listen to the others yet 😅

    • @BLOCPARTY420
      @BLOCPARTY420 3 года назад +2

      1.Silent Alarm
      2. A Weekend In The City
      3.Intimacy
      4.Four
      5.Hymns
      Bruh it looks like if it’s in order but this is my ratings

    • @blocpartyfan97
      @blocpartyfan97 2 года назад

      1. Intimacy
      2. Silent Alarm
      3. A Weekend in the City
      4. Four
      5. Alpha Games
      6. Hymns

    • @blocpartyfan97
      @blocpartyfan97 2 года назад

      @@BLOCPARTY420 fav b side tracks??

  • @p0werfu11
    @p0werfu11 5 месяцев назад +1

    Miss the old Fantano. Miss the 2012.

  • @jamesharcourt6025
    @jamesharcourt6025 11 лет назад +2

    Great review. Personally I think they haven't made any perfect album and the high points of each are all as high as each other. Their best live highlights are Flux, This Modern Love, Song For Clay/Banquet and their best studio moments for me are Ratchet, Banquet, Helicopter, I Still Remember & Real Talk. French Exit is really cool as is 3x3, The Truth and - to be honest - loads of other tracks. They really are an amazing act but I don't agree that Silent Alarm tops the other albums - it was just first. If 'Four' had come first, it would have made just as much impact, if not more ...

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    comments?

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    thx.

  • @coisa985
    @coisa985 10 лет назад +6

    my reaction when i realized you have turn of the bright lights vinyl, man.......

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    yes, yes there is.

  • @Scarletatticus
    @Scarletatticus 12 лет назад +1

    Thank you for reviewing Four! The review did not at all disappoint as usual. Thank you also praising the group's constant desire for evolution. Too many reviewers are stuck in the Silent Alarm does.

  • @burnindownthehouse
    @burnindownthehouse 12 лет назад +2

    I remember Pearl Jam had that problem with the album Ten. Man, when that was released, it just took off and took on a life of its own. It was superb. And I remember at college in my freshman year everyone in my dorm saying, "There's no way they can top Ten. So I am not even going to buy the next album." Well, too bad for them they didn't because the next album (Vs.) kicked some major ass. So sometimes I think music fans can get in that mode where they just assume the debut album can't be topped.

  • @ExpensiveTibet
    @ExpensiveTibet 12 лет назад

    I had the exact same "I like this"-> "This is suspect" - > "Yeah...yeah!" Progression. I think it's 3x3 that got me back to equilibrium, great sense of urgency in Keles vocals. Octopus was a disappointmen; just underwhelmed by the nursery-rhyme quality of the melody.
    I've been sitting on MNDR for a week and the initial attraction is gone. Just playing 3 tracks and neglecting the rest. I would still be interested to see what you thought of that one.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    that's true.

  • @gogolplex74
    @gogolplex74 12 лет назад +4

    This album reminds me of Third by Portishead
    - the name is a number
    - its cover art is simple
    - it took forever to make

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    it's on the way this coming month.

  • @jaydivisi0n
    @jaydivisi0n 12 лет назад

    Since you're on the subject of London-based rock bands, would you mind turning an ear to the recent debut release from Spector? Enjoy It While It Lasts is getting quite a lot of hype at the moment in the UK, with Spector being seen as "the new Vaccines".
    I've just come back from seeing Spector at Reading festival and thought they were really good, but yet to buy their record.

  • @PabloZayas
    @PabloZayas 11 лет назад +1

    I agree so much with you! Silent Alarm might've set the bar too high. Four is not even close...

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    really nice of you to say. thank you! :-)

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    you do?

  • @RayasNegroOvejas
    @RayasNegroOvejas 12 лет назад

    I listen to every Bloc Party album and b-side in order right now and I have, kind of, fallen in love again. I'm at Four soon.

  • @LordSicard
    @LordSicard 12 лет назад

    very good review! i share your opinion for the most parts, except some riffs in "kettling" are just too much 90s for me. i am just thankful they went off the way intimacy seemed to lead.

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    sorry, i had gotten excited to just do the review and said some sentences fast. :-(

  • @fanboydee
    @fanboydee 12 лет назад

    Came here as soon as I got to Kettling. Had to hear your thoughts. That track took me by surprise, and yeah, the album doesn't feel crazy unified...but it's somehow working...

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    ok.

  • @j3fferson27
    @j3fferson27 12 лет назад +1

    silent alarm will always hold a special place in my heart. while i don't think four was equally good, it was great to hear something substantial from them. i thought it was a great album.

  • @ARMTOAST
    @ARMTOAST 12 лет назад

    I'll definitely check this out. I was hesitant before seeing this review, as I was left wanting a lot more from both Weekend In The City and Intimacy, but knowing that there's some rather enjoyable moments on here is comforting.

  • @m0cachin0
    @m0cachin0 12 лет назад +1

    Great review, really enjoyed it. Gave me a lot to think about. I really did enjoy the album. I mean as one of those desperate fans who just wanted them to pump out more music after the hiatus I was really impressed. It was new music but it felt like their older stuff at the same time? If you haven't you should really check the bonus songs "Mean" and "Leaf Skeleton". "Mean" had a similar feel to "Letter to my son" which I really enjoyed. All in all I think it was a 9/10 for me.

  • @ma2ko
    @ma2ko 12 лет назад +3

    TURN ON THE BRIGHT LIGHTS

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    ME2

  • @JeiBiRedbeard
    @JeiBiRedbeard 12 лет назад

    I know this is really out-dated but PLEASE when you do some classics again review Embrace's one and only album back from 1987!
    Thx a lot for the great videos!

  • @MrMattavocado
    @MrMattavocado 12 лет назад

    I'm sure it's not something you'd typically review, but please review the new Circa Survive album Violent Waves

  • @blackfox51
    @blackfox51 12 лет назад

    It's very rare that I find a good, thought out album review on any Bloc Party album, but this one was PERFECT. Bloc Party is definitely for the more invested fans, not some scenester that wants to hear more "Helicopter".
    I probably love Four more than Anthony did, but he nailed a lot of the details in this album. If "Coliseum" didn't have that intro, it would probably be the best song on this album. I really enjoyed a majority of the songs, though. I still need to give "The Healing" a chance.

  • @huntermauk9601
    @huntermauk9601 11 лет назад +6

    real talk was the best bloc party track on the CD it was the track I was waiting for by them.

  • @greenday48390
    @greenday48390 12 лет назад

    Glad to see you have a positive attitude. Have a nice day friend!

  • @bigsoso20
    @bigsoso20 12 лет назад

    is it just me or your reviews just get better and better, even when i strongly don't agree with you i'm just like damn this guy's good

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    STILL GOTTA LISTEN TO THAT 1

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    DOES NOT COMPUTE!

  • @Warstub
    @Warstub 12 лет назад +1

    Coliseum I actually like, especially the intro, but I'd rather hear that intro riff re-interpreted through the electric guitars rather than just be cast aside - would have worked really nice as a big fat stoner riff. Real Talk is a real nice off-kilter song as well, but neither takes off nor goes anywhere in any way that holds my interest.

  • @thecomplexindividual
    @thecomplexindividual 12 лет назад

    Only listened to it once so far, i liked the heavy tracks but found it weird when random slow tracks popped up. Will give it more listens as it could be a grower.

  • @patras458
    @patras458 12 лет назад

    You shold get deluxe version with Mean on it. It's one of the best Bloc Party's songs ever

  • @ilovecody7514
    @ilovecody7514 6 лет назад +3

    Man I wish they'd make another album like this.

    • @Languagestudy4
      @Languagestudy4 2 года назад +1

      What about now that Alpha games is out?

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    next.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2
    @MoonchildMindaugas2 12 лет назад

    I'm glad we're on the same wave this time, Anthony. And Real Talk is my biggest favorite.
    But my small problem is that heavy rock tracks are very-wel segued with indie pop/rock ones. Otherwise, solid release.

  • @tydavidian2506
    @tydavidian2506 11 лет назад +2

    Nice to see Turn On the BrIght Lights in the background, shit, imagine Bloc Party and Interpol in the same gig? SHIT MY LIFE WOULD BE COMPLETE lol

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    yes, you're all three!

  • @GizdaIin
    @GizdaIin 12 лет назад

    I like all of Bloc Party's albums and I don't see a problem that Four is "all over the place", must it not be? Cohesiveness is fine too but for me it doesn't aplly wheter I'll enjoy a LP more because of it. I somewhat expected the album to sound this way, but still hoped there will be a track or two that'll sound like one from Silent Alarm, which is my favourite,

  • @raiders545
    @raiders545 12 лет назад

    New Giles Corey EP. You should review it, you mean, mean, man.

  • @StokeCityFC44
    @StokeCityFC44 12 лет назад

    I'm glad about this review because after the string of bad reviews it received i decided it would be too painful to hear one of our (uk's) greatest bands of the past decade apparently lose it but you've inspired me to give it a try, loved the longer vid too btw ;)
    you should review matthew dear's album too, I've listened to it 3 times now and I'm beginning to love it!

  • @johncpole
    @johncpole 12 лет назад

    Turn on the bright lights in the background. A reference to bands still trying to step out of their debut albums shadow?

  • @mistersuremusic
    @mistersuremusic 12 лет назад

    Great review, you should do more of these retrospective looking-back-then-forwards type reviews.
    I literally CANNOT articulate anything anymore...I blame the internet.

  • @faust3530
    @faust3530 12 лет назад

    Fuck I'm starting to see this album everywhere after this review. I didn't even care about it before, but now i really feel like I need to listen to it

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    no, not at all.

  • @sammerro
    @sammerro 11 лет назад +1

    Oh, i didn't expect anything interesting from that band and now 7/10, i will look to them closer.

  • @rockonbass
    @rockonbass 11 лет назад +8

    intimacy is a fantastic album. None of the songs were "dance" tracks.

    • @bosyogurtlight
      @bosyogurtlight 3 года назад +1

      Aries, Mercury, Ion Square and Your Visits Are Getting Shorter

    • @rockonbass
      @rockonbass 3 года назад +4

      @@bosyogurtlight lol lord knows what I was saying 8 years ago, I don't think I even knew what dance tracks were haha

    • @spamsingles5948
      @spamsingles5948 Год назад

      ​@@rockonbassCharacter development

  • @GuestHostMike
    @GuestHostMike 12 лет назад

    Wow, I'm glad I listened to your whole review. The way its began I was expecting 10 minutes of hate. I've only listened to this album twice, but I really enjoy it so far, and think I'll keep getting more out of the songs with repeats. Def got a Foo Fighters vibe out of some of the songs, and a little bit of Elbow. Yeah, there isn't much to hang your hat on, as an album; but it feels like "Bloc Party is back" is the tagline here. (A year ago, I thought these guys were gone for good)

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    who needs more than one?

  • @theneedledrop
    @theneedledrop  12 лет назад

    i'll be doing that one this week.

  • @juliet8329
    @juliet8329 11 лет назад +1

    When I saw 'Turn on the bright Lights' behind you I immediately subscribed to your channel :D

  • @indiebein
    @indiebein 12 лет назад

    I LOVE octopus, day four, V.A.L.I.S, team a and real talk but i really hate 3X3. But i bought the delux edition and the two bonus song are really good two. Could you review Toko Police Clubs new album when it comes out next year?

  • @bigslick4115
    @bigslick4115 12 лет назад

    Great review! How about a review of circa survive's new album "violent waves"?

  • @cannibalwombat
    @cannibalwombat 12 лет назад

    Just listened to this today, glad to see a prompt review to follow up! Love the album.

  • @robjenkins494
    @robjenkins494 2 года назад +1

    I'm 100 years late to comment here. But The B-sides to A Weekend in the City were also amazing, frankly

    • @blocpartyfan97
      @blocpartyfan97 2 года назад +1

      True I love the b-side tracks like England, Emma Kate’s Accident, Atonement, etc.

  • @euodeiochuchu
    @euodeiochuchu 12 лет назад

    you should introduce Cal on the keyboard when you give the album being reviewed your rate, as you did on the previous video :)
    that cheesy tv moment was a good idea man, we want Cal, and we want him NOW!

  • @100sparrows
    @100sparrows 12 лет назад

    I'd love to see your thoughts/review of "Fear Fun" by Father John Misty.
    I kind of expected to see your opinion of J. Tillman's new solo project/album since leaving Fleet Foxes considering how much you enjoyed Helplessness Blues.